ArticlePublisher preview available
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

Objective. The study of motor unit behavior has been classically performed by selective recording systems of muscle electrical activity (EMG signals) and decomposition algorithms able to discriminate between individual motor unit action potentials from multi-unit signals. In this study, we provide a general framework for the decomposition of multi-channel intramuscular and surface EMG signals and we extensively validate this approach with experimental recordings. Approach. First, we describe the conditions under which the assumptions of the convolutive blind separation model are satisfied. Second, we propose an approach of convolutive sphering of the observations followed by an iterative extraction of the sources. This approach is then validated using intramuscular signals recorded by novel multi-channel thin-film electrodes on the Abductor Digiti Minimi of the hand and Tibilias Anterior muscles, as well as on high-density surface EMG signals recorded by electrode grids on the First Dorsal Interosseous muscle. The validation was based on the comparison with the gold standard of manual decomposition (for intramuscular recordings) and on the two-source method (for comparison of intramuscular and surface EMG recordings) for the three human muscles and contraction forces of up to 90% MVC. Main results. The average number of common sources identified for the validation was 14 ± 7 (averaged across all trials and subjects and all comparisons), with a rate of agreement in their discharge timings of 92.8 ± 3.2%. The average Decomposability Index, calculated on the automatic decomposed signals, was 16.0 ± 2.2 (7.3–44.1). For comparison, the same index calculated on the manual decomposed signals was 15.0 ± 3.0 (6.3–76.6). Significance. These results show that the method provides a solid framework for the decomposition of multi-channel invasive and non-invasive EMG signals that allows the study of the behavior of a large number of concurrently active motor units.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Multi-channel intramuscular and surface
EMG decomposition by convolutive blind
source separation
Francesco Negro
1
, Silvia Muceli
1
, Anna Margherita Castronovo
1
,
Ales Holobar
2
and Dario Farina
1
1
Institute of Neurorehabilitation Systems, Bernstein Focus Neurotechnology Göttingen, Bernstein Center
for Computational Neuroscience, University Medical Center Göttingen, Georg-August University of
Göttingen, Göttingen, Germany
2
Faculty of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, University of Maribor, Maribor, Slovenia
E-mail: dario.farina@bccn.uni-goettingen.de
Received 24 July 2015, revised 1 December 2015
Accepted for publication 27 January 2016
Published 29 February 2016
Abstract
Objective. The study of motor unit behavior has been classically performed by selective
recording systems of muscle electrical activity (EMG signals)and decomposition algorithms
able to discriminate between individual motor unit action potentials from multi-unit signals. In
this study, we provide a general framework for the decomposition of multi-channel
intramuscular and surface EMG signals and we extensively validate this approach with
experimental recordings. Approach. First, we describe the conditions under which the
assumptions of the convolutive blind separation model are satised. Second, we propose an
approach of convolutive sphering of the observations followed by an iterative extraction of the
sources. This approach is then validated using intramuscular signals recorded by novel multi-
channel thin-lm electrodes on the Abductor Digiti Minimi of the hand and Tibilias Anterior
muscles, as well as on high-density surface EMG signals recorded by electrode grids on the First
Dorsal Interosseous muscle. The validation was based on the comparison with the gold standard
of manual decomposition (for intramuscular recordings)and on the two-source method (for
comparison of intramuscular and surface EMG recordings)for the three human muscles and
contraction forces of up to 90% MVC. Main results. The average number of common sources
identied for the validation was 14±7(averaged across all trials and subjects and all
comparisons), with a rate of agreement in their discharge timings of 92.8±3.2%. The average
Decomposability Index, calculated on the automatic decomposed signals, was 16.0±2.2
(7.344.1). For comparison, the same index calculated on the manual decomposed signals was
15.0±3.0 (6.376.6).Signicance. These results show that the method provides a solid
framework for the decomposition of multi-channel invasive and non-invasive EMG signals that
allows the study of the behavior of a large number of concurrently active motor units.
Keywords: EMG, motor unit, motor neuron, decomposition, blind source separation
(Some gures may appear in colour only in the online journal)
Introduction
Since the pioneering work of Adrian and Bronk (Adrian and
Bronk 1929), the recording of the discharge timings of motor
units during voluntary contractions has provided a
fundamental knowledge to our understanding of human
movement (Heckman and Enoka 2004,2012). The access to
motor units can occur via recording of the muscle ber action
potentials since the neuro-muscular junction is a highly reli-
able synaptic connection (Enoka 2008). Each discharge of a
Journal of Neural Engineering
J. Neural Eng. 13 (2016)026027 (17pp)doi:10.1088/1741-2560/13/2/026027
1741-2560/16/026027+17$33.00 © 2016 IOP Publishing Ltd Printed in the UK1
... HD-sEMG signals recorded during the experimental tasks were offline decomposed to identify the activity of individual MUs using a convolutive blind source separation algorithm (Negro et al., 2016). To ensure high-quality data, spike trains with a silhouette value (SIL) below 0.9 were automatically discarded (Holobar et al., 2014;Negro et al., 2016). ...
... HD-sEMG signals recorded during the experimental tasks were offline decomposed to identify the activity of individual MUs using a convolutive blind source separation algorithm (Negro et al., 2016). To ensure high-quality data, spike trains with a silhouette value (SIL) below 0.9 were automatically discarded (Holobar et al., 2014;Negro et al., 2016). The decomposed spike trains were then manually reviewed to identify and correct errors. ...
... Following these procedures, additional quality control criteria were applied. MUs were excluded if their SIL was below 0.9, their firing duration was less than 50% of the task time, or their instantaneous firing rate had a standard deviation exceeding 20 Hz (Del Vecchio et al., 2020;Negro et al., 2016). Decomposition and manual editing were conducted using the MUedit MATLAB application (Avrillon et al., 2024a). ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Cortical beta band oscillations (13 - 30 Hz) are associated with sensorimotor control, but their precise role remains unclear. Evidence suggests that for low-threshold motor neurons, these oscillations are conveyed to muscles via the fastest corticospinal fibers. However, their transmission to motor neurons of different sizes may vary due to differences in the relative strength of corticospinal and reticulospinal projections across the motor neuron pool. Consequently, it remains uncertain whether corticospinal beta transmission follows similar pathways and maintains consistent strength across the entire motor neuron pool. To investigate this, we examined beta activity in motor neurons innervating the tibialis anterior muscle across the full range of recruitment thresholds in a study involving 12 participants of both sexes. We characterized beta activity at both the cortical and motor unit levels while participants performed contractions from mild to submaximal levels. Corticomuscular coherence remained unchanged across contraction forces after normalizing for the net motor unit spike rate, suggesting that beta oscillations are transmitted with uniform strength to motor neurons, regardless of size. To further explore beta transmission, we estimated corticospinal delays using the cumulant density function, identifying peak correlations between cortical and muscular activity. Once compensated for variable peripheral axonal propagation delay across motor neurons, the corticospinal delay remained stable, and its value (approximately 14 ms) indicated projections through the fastest corticospinal fibers for all motor neurons. These findings demonstrate that corticospinal beta band transmission is determined by the fastest pathway connecting in the corticospinal tract, projecting uniformly across the entire motor neuron pool.
... Specific details regarding analysis and statistical methodologies can be found below. Briefly, HDsEMG was decomposed into individual MU spike trains using convolutive blind source separation and successive sparse J Physiol 0.0 deflation improvements (Martinez-Valdes et al., 2017;Negro et al., 2016) and fit with support vector regression (Beauchamp, Khurram et al., 2022). MU discharge profiles were analysed as detailed below. ...
... Following collection, each channel of surface EMG was visually inspected to remove channels with substantial artifacts, noise or saturation of the A/D board. The remaining EMG channels were decomposed into individual MU spike trains using convolutive blind source separation and successive sparse deflation improvements (Martinez-Valdes et al., 2017;Negro et al., 2016). The silhouette threshold for decomposition was set to 0.87. ...
Article
Full-text available
Motoneurons are the final common pathway for all motor commands and possess intrinsic electrical properties that must be tuned to control muscle across the full range of motor behaviours. Neuromodulatory input from the brainstem is probably essential for adapting motoneuron properties to match this diversity of motor tasks. A primary mechanism of this adaptation, control of dendritic persistent inward currents (PICs) in motoneurons by brainstem monoaminergic systems, generates both amplification and prolongation of synaptic inputs. While essential, there is an inherent tension between this amplification and prolongation. Although amplification by PICs allows for quick recruitment and acceleration of motoneuron discharge, PICs must be deactivated to derecruit motoneurons upon movement cessation. In contrast, during stabilizing or postural tasks, PIC‐induced prolongation of synaptic inputs is critical for sustained motoneuron discharge. Here, we designed two motor tasks that challenged the inhibitory control of PICs, generating unduly PIC prolongation that increases variability in human torque control. This included a paradigm combining a discrete motor task with a stabilizing task and another involving muscle length‐induced changes to the balance of excitatory and inhibitory inputs available for controlling PICs. We show that prolongation from PICs introduces difficulties in ankle torque control and that these difficulties are further degraded at shorter muscle lengths when PIC prolongation is greatest. These results highlight the necessity for inhibitory control of PICs and showcase issues introduced when inhibitory control is constrained. Our findings suggest that, like sensory systems, errors are inherent in motor systems. These errors are not due to problems in the perception of movement‐related sensory input but are embedded in the final stage of motor output. This has many implications relevant to clinical conditions (e.g. chronic stroke) where pathological shifts in monoamines may further amplify these errors. image Key points All motor commands are processed via spinal motoneurons, whose intrinsic electrical properties are adapted by brainstem neuromodulatory input. The effects of these neuromodulatory inputs (i.e. persistent inward currents; PICs) must be tightly regulated by inhibitory inputs to allow for the large repertoire of human motor behaviours. We designed two motor tasks to restrict the ability of inhibitory synaptic inputs to control PICs and show that this generates substantial errors that reduce the precision of motor output in humans. Our findings suggest that errors are inherent in motor systems and embedded in the final stage of motor output. This has many implications relevant to clinical conditions (e.g. chronic stroke) and may, speculatively, shed light on contributing factors to muscle cramps.
Article
Skeletal muscles are essential parts of the human motor system and are mainly regulated by motor units (MUs) through the nervous system. As a widely used noninvasive measurement of MUs, surface EMG cannot obtain in-depth spatial information on MUs. Ultrafast ultrasound (UUS) can measure the mechanical response of MUs from muscle morphology with image sequences. This research proposed a blind source separation method with enhanced interpretability for decoding ultrasound image sequences to obtain the mechanical response of MUs. In particular, the spatiotemporal data were decomposed using non-negative matrix factorization (NMF). Then, the spatial components’ multiple probability density functions were obtained using a parametric self-fitting function. The proposed algorithm, called NMF-stICA, was validated on ten groups of computational simulation datasets. The accuracies of the obtained spatial and temporal components were 87.26% ± 2.18% and 85.13% ± 1.83%, respectively. Further, a dynamic ultrasound phantom experiment was performed, and all the potential spatial components were correctly decoded. Additionally, isometric contraction human experiments were conducted on the biceps muscle of eight subjects with simultaneous acquisition of UUS and intramuscular electromyography (iEMG). The results showed that the rate of agreement was 58.71%, comparing the decoded components with the firing pattern of iEMG. The proposed decoding method can get precise spatial position and the firing pattern of the MUs in the skeletal muscle. This might help to study the neuromechanical properties of MUs and localize disease in specific muscle regions.
Article
Objective: The identification of individual neuronal activity from multielectrode arrays poses significant challenges, including handling data from numerous electrodes, resolving overlapping action potentials and tracking activity across long recordings. This study introduces NeuroNella, an automated algorithm developed to address these challenges. Approach: NeuroNella employs blind source separation to leverage the sparsity of action potentials in multichannel recordings. It was validated using three datasets, including two publicly available ones: (1) in vitro recordings (252 channels) of retinal ganglion cells from mice with simultaneous ground-truth loose patch data to assess accuracy; (2) a Neuropixel recording from an awake mouse, comprising 374 channels spanning different brain areas, to demonstrate scalability with dense multielectrode configurations in in vivo recordings; and (3) data (32 channels) recorded from the medullary reticular formation in a terminally anaesthetised macaque, to showcase decomposition over long periods of time. Main Results: The algorithm exhibited an error rate of less than 1% compared to ground-truth data. It reliably identified individual neurons, detected neuronal activity across a wide amplitude range, and tolerated minor probe shifts, maintaining robustness in prolonged experimental sessions. Significance: NeuroNella provides an automated and efficient method for neuronal activity identification. Its adaptability to diverse dataset, species, and recording configurations underscores its potential to advance studies of neuronal dynamics and facilitate real-time neuronal decoding systems.
Article
Sex-related differences have been documented for intrinsic motoneuron excitability and firing rates in young adults, with females exhibiting higher excitability than males; however, it is unknown if these parameters are affected by sex earlier in development. We compared the sex-related differences in firing behaviour of single tibialis anterior (TA) motor units decomposed from high-density surface EMG in young (7-17 years) and older (18-28 years) developmental males and females during triangular dorsiflexion contractions at 10%, 20%, and 30% of their maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) torque. The amount of motoneuron self-sustained firing at estimated synaptic inputs below that needed for recruitment was measured (i.e., ΔF), along with start, maximal, and end firing rates and the interspike interval variability across the entire contraction. When taking the recruitment threshold of the motor units into account, both young and older development females had larger ΔF values compared to males, which functionally allows more sustained firing of TA motoneurons in females. Young development females also had faster firing rates compared to males and equivalent firing variability, an effect that disappeared in the older development group, where males exhibited higher start rates and less firing variability. Overall, while female motor unit firing rates became similar to males as they matured, they were more variable, slower at recruitment, and continued to exhibit evidence of greater persistent inward currents that sustained firing (ΔF), the latter indicating that sex-related differences in intrinsic motoneuron excitability are established early during development.
Preprint
Full-text available
Studying human motoneuron activity through electromyography (EMG) can yield insights into the operation of fundamental spinal cord microcircuits. Traditional surface and needle electromyography (EMG) methodologies have limited capacity to shed light on the diversity of motor unit (MU) control strategies that may be unique to each individual. Here, we employed high-density surface EMG (HDsEMG) to sample multiple MUs per subject to investigate the dynamics of inhibitory spinal microcircuits in both upper and lower limb control. We characterised the net inhibition as a function of individual MU firing rates, revealing subject-specific relationships. In silico modelling replicated these experimental characteristics and suggested that properties of the inhibitory currents rather than motoneuron size are responsible for net functional inhibition. Our results show that HDsEMG can highlight distinct control strategies across circuits and motor pools, revealing subject-specific properties of inhibitory spinal microcircuits. TEASER High-density surface EMG electrodes can reveal the functional properties of inhibitory spinal circuits
Article
Full-text available
to the editor: We are compelled to clarify some points made by Farina et al. ([1][1]). In a previous exchange of letters Farina et al. sought that we “decompose a set of synthetic surface EMG signals that we [Farina et al.] generate with a model” to provide a convincing validation of our sEMG
Article
Full-text available
to the editor: The Letter by De Luca et al. ([2][1]) reiterates the arguments presented by them in a previous exchange ([1][2], [3][3]). The issue concerns how to validate a generic algorithm that purports to decompose a surface EMG signal into its constituent motor unit action potentials. De Luca
Article
Full-text available
The developed muscle activity imaging approach (MAI) was validated with surface EMG and intramuscular EMG signals simultaneously acquired from the biceps of a healthy male subject. 128 unipolar channels were employed for surface EMG measurement and one bipolar channel was employed for simultaneous intramuscular EMG measurement for the validation purpose. Ultrasound scans were also specifically performed to localize the location of the wire electrode inserted into the biceps. The surface EMG measurements, after noise filtering and signal decomposition, were used to reconstruct the internal muscle activities for the biceps by using the MAI approach. The locations of the reconstructed muscle activities were compared against the location of the wire electrode in the biceps identified from ultrasound images. Results demonstrate the feasibility and validity of the MAI approach in imaging internal muscle activities from multi-channel surface EMG recordings.
Article
Full-text available
A new approach has been developed by combining the K-mean clustering (KMC) method and a modified convolution kernel compensation (CKC) method for multi-channel surface electromyogram (EMG) decomposition. The KMC method was first utilized to cluster vectors of observations at different time instants and then estimate the initial innervation pulse train (IPT). The CKC method, modified with a novel multi-step iterative process, was conducted to update the estimated IPT. The performance of the proposed K-means clustering - Modified CKC (KmCKC) approach was evaluated by reconstructing IPTs from both simulated and experimental surface EMG signals. The KmCKC approach successfully reconstructed all 10 IPTs from the simulated surface EMG signals with true positive rates (TPR) of over 90% with a low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of -10dB. Over 10 motor units were also successfully extracted from the 64-channel experimental surface EMG signals of the first dorsal interosseous (FDI) muscles when a contraction force was held at 8 N by using the KmCKC approach. A 'two-source' test was further conducted with 64-channel surface EMG signals. The high percentage of common MUs and common pulses (over 92% at all force levels) between the IPTs reconstructed from the two independent groups of surface EMG signals demonstrates the reliability and capability of the proposed KmCKC approach in multi-channel surface EMG decomposition. Results from both simulated and experimental data are consistent and confirm that the proposed KmCKC approach can successfully reconstruct IPTs with high accuracy at different levels of contraction.
Article
We describe the design, fabrication and testing of a novel multi-channel thin-film electrode for detection of the output of motoneurones in vivo and in humans, through muscle signals. The structure includes a linear array of 16 detection sites that can sample intramuscular electromyographic (EMG) activity from the entire muscle cross-section. The structure was tested in two superficial muscles (the abductor digiti minimi (ADM) and the tibialis anterior (TA)) and a deep muscle (the genioglossus (GG)) during contractions at various forces. Moreover, surface EMG signals were concurrently detected from the TA muscle with a grid of 64 electrodes. Surface and intramuscular signals were decomposed into the constituent motor unit (MU) action potential trains. With the intramuscular electrode, up to 31 MUs were identified from the ADM muscle during an isometric contraction at 15% of the maximal force (MVC) and 50 MUs were identified for a 30% MVC contraction of TA. The new electrode detects different sources than a surface EMG system, as only one MU spike train was found to be common in the decomposition of the intramuscular and surface signals acquired from the TA. The system also allowed access to the GG muscle, which cannot be analysed with surface EMG, with successful identification of MU activity. With respect to classic detection systems, the presented thin-film structure enables recording from large populations of active MUs of deep and superficial muscles and thus can provide a faithful representation of the neural drive sent to a muscle. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
Article
This study presents a progressive FastICA peel-off (PFP) framework for high density surface electromyogram (EMG) decomposition. The novel framework is based on a shift-invariant model for describing surface EMG. The decomposition process can be viewed as progressively expanding the set of motor unit spike trains, which is primarily based on FastICA. To overcome the local convergence of FastICA, a "peel off" strategy (i.e. removal of the estimated motor unit action potential (MUAP) trains from the previous step) is used to mitigate the effects of the already identified motor units, so more motor units can be extracted. Moreover, a constrained FastICA is applied to assess the extracted spike trains and correct possible erroneous or missed spikes. These procedures work together to improve the decomposition performance. The proposed framework was validated using simulated surface EMG signals with different motor unit numbers (30, 70, 91) and signal to noise ratios (SNRs) (20, 10, 0 dB). The results demonstrated relatively large numbers of extracted motor units and high accuracies (high F1-scores). The framework was also tested with 111 trials of 64-channel electrode array experimental surface EMG signals during the first dorsal interosseous (FDI) muscle contraction at different intensities. On average 14.1 ± 5.0 motor units were identified from each trial of experimental surface EMG signals.
Article
Human-machine interfacing (HMI) uses biological signals, such as brain signals,and translates them into control commands for external devices. An exciting application of HMI is the active control of robotic limbs that substitute lost body parts (bionic reconstruction).Despite recent progresses in brain-computer interfacing [1], muscle electrical potentials are still the most important input for clinical HMI. The ensemble electrical activity of a muscle, the electromyogram (EMG), is generated by the neural activation of the motor neurons innervating the muscle and thus contains information on the neural control of movement. Muscle recordings can be performed noninvasively (surface EMG) by electrodes located on the skin to record the electrical activity of the underlying muscle fibers. This recording modality has advantages compared to other HMI modalities, such as those based on implanted electrodes, in terms of long-term stability, biocompatibility, reduced risks of infections, and ethical constraints.
Conference Paper
The present contribution deals with the statistical tool of Independent Component Analysis (ICA). The focus is on Fas-tICA, arguably the most popular algorithm in the domain of ICA. Despite its success, it is observed that FastICA occasionally yields outcomes that do not correspond to any solutions of ICA. These outcomes are called spurious solutions. In this work, we give a thorough and rigorous investigation of the spurious solutions of FastICA. We characterize various sets of interest and show that the kurtosis-based FastICA is theoretically free of spurious solutions. Examples are given, showing that in certain scenarios, popular nonlinearities such as “Gauss” or “tanh” systematically yield spurious solutions, whereas only “kurtosis” may give reliable results.
Article
In considering the role of common synaptic input to motor neurons in force control, we hypothesize that the effective neural drive to muscle replicates the common input and is thus the main determinant of force production. Such a perspective argues against a significant role for motor unit synchronization in force control.
Article
Decomposition of the EMG signal into constituent action potentials and identifying individual firing instances of each motor unit in the presence of ambient noise is an inherently probabilistic process -whether performed manually or with automated algorithms. Consequently it is subject to errors. We set out to classify and reduce these errors by analyzing 1,061 motor unit action potential trains obtained by decomposing surface EMG signals recorded during human voluntary contractions. Decomposition errors were classified into two general categories: location errors representing variability in the temporal localization of each motor unit firing instance; and identification errors consisting of falsely detected or missed firing instances. To mitigate these errors, we developed an error reduction algorithm that combines multiple decomposition estimates to determine a more probable estimate of motor unit firing instances with fewer errors. The performance of the algorithm is governed by a trade-off between the yield of motor unit action potential trains obtained above a given accuracy level and the time required to perform the decomposition. When applied to a set of surface EMG signals synthesized from real motor unit action potential trains, the identification error was reduced by an average of 1.78%, improving the accuracy to 97.0%, and the location error was reduced by an average of 1.66 ms to 3.44 ms. The error reduction algorithm in this study is not limited to any specific decomposition strategy. Rather, we propose it be used for other decomposition methods, especially when analyzing precise motor unit firing instances, as occurs when measuring synchronization.