ArticlePDF Available

School‐Based Programs to Reduce Bullying and Victimization

Wiley
Campbell Systematic Reviews
Authors:

Abstract

Bullying is becoming an ever more pressing issue for schools, daycare centers, politicians and the public. Everyone agrees that bullying is a serious problem and initiatives are urgently called for to stamp it out. This Campbell Systematic Review studied the effects of anti‐bullying programs in schools. The conclusion is that programs generally work and bullying is reduced on average by around 20%. A total of 89 reports were of sufficient quality to be included in the systematic review. The 89 reports describe 53 different studies. However, nine studies did not provide enough data to allow the calculation of an effect size and were, therefore, not included in the final meta‐analysis. The overall analysis is therefore based on a total of 44 studies. The 44 different studies were carried out between 1983 and mid‐2009 and came from 16 different countries. The included studies were either randomized controlled trials, quasi‐randomized trials, age‐cohort studies or other controlled studies. Furthermore, the systematic review clearly states that future evaluations should measure the children's situation before and after an anti‐bullying program. This should apply to the experimental group as well as the control group to get the most accurate results possible. Executive Summary/Abstract BACKGROUND School bullying has serious short‐term and long‐term effects on children's physical and mental health. Various anti‐bullying programs have been implemented world wide and, more rarely, evaluated. Previous narrative reviews, summarizing the work done on bullying prevention, as well as previous meta‐analyses of anti‐bullying programs, are limited. The definition of school bullying includes several key elements: physical, verbal, or psychological attack or intimidation that is intended to cause fear, distress, or harm to the victim; an imbalance of power (psychological or physical), with a more powerful child (or children) oppressing less powerful ones; and repeated incidents between the same children over a prolonged period. School bullying can occur in school or on the way to or from school. It is not bullying when two persons of the same strength (physical, psychological, or verbal) victimize each other. OBJECTIVES This report presents a systematic review and meta‐analysis of the effectiveness of programs designed to reduce school bullying perpetration and victimization (i.e. being bullied). The authors indicate the pitfalls of previous reviews and explain in detail how the present systematic review and meta‐analysis addresses the gaps in the existing literature on bullying prevention. SEARCH STRATEGY In the present report, we go beyond previous reviews by: doing much more extensive searches for evaluations such as hand‐searching all volumes of 35 journals from 1983 up to the end of May 2009; searching for international evaluations in 18 electronic databases and in languages other than English; and focusing only on programs that are specifically designed to reduce bullying and not aggressive behavior (i.e. the outcome variables specifically measure bullying). Leading researchers in the area of school bullying were also contacted via e‐mail. SELECTION CRITERIA Studies were included in this review if they evaluated the effects of an anti‐bullying program by comparing an experimental group who received the intervention with a control group who did not. The word ‘experimental’ here refers to students who received the program and does not necessarily imply randomization. Four types of research design were included: a) randomized experiments, b) experimental‐control comparisons with before and after measures of bullying, c) other experimental‐control comparisons and d) quasi‐experimental age‐cohort designs, where students of age X after the intervention were compared with students of the same age X in the same school before the intervention. Both published and unpublished (e.g. PhD theses) reports were included. Reports concerning an evaluation of a program had to clearly indicate that bullying or victimization were included as outcome measures. Bullying and victimization could be measured using self‐report questionnaires, peer ratings, teacher ratings, or observational data. RESULTS We found a total of 622 reports that were concerned with bullying prevention. The number of reports on anti‐bullying programs and on the necessity of tackling bullying has increased considerably over time. Only 89 of these reports (describing 53 different program evaluations) could be included in our review. Of the 53 different program evaluations, only 44 provided data that permitted the calculation of an effect size for bullying or victimization. Our meta‐analysis of these 44 evaluations showed that, overall, school‐based anti‐bullying programs are effective in reducing bullying and victimization (being bullied). On average, bullying decreased by 20% – 23% and victimization decreased by 17% – 20%. The effects were generally highest in the age‐cohort designs and lowest in the randomized experiments. It was not clear, however, that the randomized experiments were methodologically superior in all cases, because sometimes a very small number of schools (between three and seven) were randomly assigned to conditions, and because of other methodological problems such as differential attrition. Various program elements and intervention components were associated with a decrease in both bullying and victimization. Work with peers was associated with an increase in victimization. We received feedback from researchers about our coding of 40 out of 44 programs. Analyses of publication bias show that the observed effect sizes (for both bullying and victimization) were based on an unbiased set of studies. AUTHORS’ CONCLUSIONS Results obtained so far in evaluations of anti‐bullying programs are encouraging. The time is ripe to mount a new long‐term research strategy on the effectiveness of these programs, based on our findings. The main policy implication of our review is that new anti‐bullying programs should be designed and tested based on the key program elements and evaluation components that we have found to be most effective. We recommend that a system of accrediting anti‐bullying programs should be developed, supervised by an international body such as the International Observatory on Violence in Schools.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... The next subgroup analysis assessed non-externalizing behaviors that are often associated with externalizing and other aggressive behaviors. There is evidence that victimization is associated with but distinct from bullying and other aggressive behaviors (Card & Little, 2006;Cook et al., 2010;Farrington & Ttofi, 2009;Jiménez-Barbero et al., 2016). Likewise, interventions often show small effectiveness in increasing prosocial behavior while decreasing aggressive behaviors (Malti & Krettenauer, 2013;Mesurado et al., 2019). ...
Thesis
Full-text available
eHealth treatments vary widely from automated treatment protocols to professional-led treatment tools that are integrated into treatment protocols with therapists. This dissertation organized, coded, and submitted 33 eHealth treatment trials to meta-analytic study to assess eHealth treatment study effectiveness overall and for each type of eHealth treatment type. Systematic review and descriptive analyses revealed that eHealth treatments that target externalizing behaviors varied widely in study, sample, and design characteristics. eHealth treatments most frequently targeted externalizing behaviors in adolescent samples (n = 22), adapted cognitive behavior therapy (CBT) to digital platforms (n = 11), and integrated digital tools into traditional treatment protocols (n = 11). eHealth treatments were effective in treating externalizing behaviors overall (d = -.52); a series of 19 meta-analyses split by study characteristics revealed that the strongest effect sizes were observed for eHealth treatments that targeted adolescent externalizing behaviors (d = -.76), used CBT or parent-focused orientations (d = -.11 and d = -1.47), and used included technology-enhanced or professional-led eHealth tools (d = -1.07, d = -.11).
... This includes establishing a supportive and inclusive school ethos and environment, strengthening curriculum delivery and teaching practice, and creating connections with parents, communities, and other stakeholders to improve social and emotional well-being at school. The rationale is that change is more likely to occur when the whole school community has a shared vision and commitment for inclusive environments (Jimerson and Huai 2010;Farrington and Ttofi 2009;Plog et al. 2010). A whole school approach recognizes that bullying, violence, and discrimination are multifaceted problems that require multifaceted solutions. ...
Technical Report
Full-text available
Thailand is widely considered progressive among developing and middle-income countries regarding the inclusion of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, or intersex (LGBTI) people. Yet, a growing body of research shows they still experience discrimination, limited job and housing opportunities, and barriers to accessing many common services. This study was led by the World Bank, in partnership with Thammasat University, Love Frankie, and the Nordic Trust Fund, and includes the first endeavor to gather and analyze quantitative data on economic and financial outcomes for a large, statistically significant sample of LGBTI people in Thailand. Qualitative data from in-depth “live story” interviews with 19 SOGI-diverse participants from across each of Thailand’s main regions complement the online survey data and provide further insights into the lives of LGBTI respondents. For the first time in Thailand, the study also presents information on non-LGBTI people and their attitudes toward LGBTI groups, based on survey responses from a statistically representative non-LGBTI reference group. The study focuses on how LGBTI people fare in Thai society economically and financially: their opportunities and inclusion, or discrimination and exclusion. It highlights outcomes for the LGBTI and non-LGBTI population in the labor, housing, and financial markets, along with LGBTI people’s challenges in their access to education, health, and government services. This study is also available on the World Bank's website: https://documents.worldbank.org/en/publication/documents-reports/documentdetail/269041521819512465/main-report
... A series of workshops and intensive training sessions were designed to improve teachers' competencies in teaching anti-bullying materials and handling bullying cases in schools. (Farrington & Ttofi, 2009). The evaluation results showed that teachers who received adequate training showed significant improvements in confidence and teaching effectiveness, as confirmed by (Mack, Sandhu, & Filipe, 2016) Study on the importance of continuous professional development for educators. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study examines the reconstruction of the Islamic Religious Education (PAI) curriculum as a strategy to prevent bullying in SMA Primaganda. The problem of bullying in schools is a serious issue that requires special attention. The hypothesis is that the integration of anti-bullying values in the PAI curriculum will be effective in reducing bullying incidents in schools. This study uses a case study method with a qualitative approach, involving in-depth interviews with PAI teachers, students, and education experts, participant observation, and analysis of curriculum documents. The results of the study indicate that the reconstruction of the PAI curriculum that integrates anti-bullying values has succeeded in reducing bullying incidents in schools. This success was achieved through systematic implementation that included the development of learning modules, teacher training, and collaborative activities. A holistic approach involving the dimensions of moral knowledge, moral feelings, and moral actions has proven effective in increasing students' awareness and understanding of the negative impacts of bullying. The continuous evaluation system confirms the creation of positive changes in school culture, marked by increased empathy and cooperation among students. The findings of the study indicate that the integration of anti-bullying values in the PAI curriculum is not only effective in preventing bullying but also contributes to the formation of positive student character and the creation of a safe and inclusive learning environment. This curriculum reconstruction model can be a reference for other educational institutions in developing effective bullying prevention programs.
... School-based prevention programmes effectively decreased bullying by about 20-23% (Farrington & Ttofi, 2009). The Olweus Bullying Prevention Program (OBPP) is one of the most widely implemented programmes (Gaffney et al., 2021;Olweus, 1991;Smith, 2017) which enhanced knowledge and efficacy in preventing different types of bullying (Olweus, 1991). ...
Article
Full-text available
Bullying is a global issue affecting students, with significant consequences. This study examined the impact of a school-based bullying education programme on student knowledge of bullying, bullying behaviour, and self-esteem among Jordanian school students. Using an uncontrolled pre-post design, 210 students from grades 7 and 8 in two Jordanian public schools participated in a four-week intervention programme. Results showed significant improvements in students’ knowledge about bullying and self-esteem and decreased victimization rates. The programme’s effectiveness varied based on factors like GPA and grade level. While overall bullying behaviours did not significantly change, there was a notable interaction effect with students’ medical status. These findings highlight the potential of such interventions in Jordanian schools and emphasize the need for tailored approaches considering various student characteristics.
... Clinically referred children who were more likely to be involved in bullying experiences included individuals living in lower-income households, those experiencing parental and home life challenges, and children with mental health and behavioural concerns. Public health implications for these children include increased bullying screening in schools or community centers, increased supervision, and recreational opportunities for children at risk, and implementing school-based programming [1,70] to teach children emotion regulation skills, empathy, and conflict management. Our finding that bullying rates were lower during the pandemic and when schools were closed to in-person learning suggests the important role of schools in bullying prevention. ...
Article
Full-text available
Amongst school-aged children and youth, bullying is a significant problem warranting further investigation. The current study sought to investigate the influence of the COVID-19 pandemic waves and school closures on the bullying experiences of 22,012 children aged 4–18-years-old who were referred and assessed at mental health agencies in Ontario, Canada. Individual, familial, and mental health variables related to bullying experiences were also investigated. Data were collected from January 2017 to February 2022. The pre-pandemic period of study included January to June 2017, September 2018/2019 to June 2019/2020. The pandemic period was divided into categories of remote learning (17 March 2020 to 30 June 2020, 8 January 2021 to 16 February 2021, 12 April 2021 to 30 June 2021) and in-person learning (remaining pandemic dates). The summer holidays pre-pandemic were in July–August 2017, 2018, 2019 and during the pandemic they were in July–August 2020 and 2021. Logistic regressions were conducted to analyze data. Findings related to COVID-19 showed bullying rates to be lower during the pandemic when compared to pre-pandemic levels (bullied others during pandemic in school: OR = 0.44, CI = 0.34–0.57; victim of bullying during pandemic in school: OR = 0.41, CI = 0.33–0.5). Furthermore, bullying rates were lower during the pandemic periods when schools were closed for in-person learning (bullied others during pandemic remote: OR = 0.62, CI = 0.45–0.85; victim of bullying during pandemic remote: OR = 0.24, CI = 0.17–0.34). Children who lived in lower income areas, experienced home life challenges, exhibited mental health difficulties, or had behavioural concerns were more likely to be involved in bullying experiences. Finally, classroom type and school program impacted the child’s likelihood of bullying others or being bullied. These findings further our understanding of the impact of school closures on children’s mental health and behaviour during the pandemic. Public health and policy implications such as bullying prevention, supervision, and conflict management are discussed.
Article
Full-text available
The general objective of this research was to understand the scientific evidence on the use of electronic receipts in customer service of water and sewerage service companies. A qualitative approach and a literature review were used, covering national and international studies. The instruments applied included content analysis of scientific publications. The main results indicate that the implementation of electronic receipts significantly improves operational efficiency and customer satisfaction. In Belgium and the United States, digitalization has reduced costs and improved resource management; in Peru, companies such as Sedapal have shown progress in reducing environmental impact and improving customer service through digital billing. However, challenges such as resistance to change and the need for adequate technological infrastructure are identified. The main conclusion was that electronic receipts in water and sewerage companies represent an effective tool to modernize management, increase customer satisfaction and promote sustainable practices.
Article
The aim of the paper is to research the frequency of experiencing, committing and witnessing individual forms of peer violence, as well as certain consequences of peer violence to secondary school students in Croatia. Gender differences with regard to the aforementioned experiences were researched, as well as the differences regarding the locality, grade (age) and the type of school. The research participants were 10,138 students of all grades from various secondary school programs from five Croatian towns: Zagreb, Pula, Split, Osijek and Varaždin. Quota sampling was used with the sample of young men of 47.4% (n = 4595), while 4.5% of participants did not report their gender. The average age of participants is M = 16.2 (SD = 1.16). Regarding the established aims of the paper, the Survey on socio-demographic data and a scale related to peer abuse and violence CTC (Communities That Care) – Questionnaire for children and young people (Mihić, Novak & Bašić, 2010.). The results show that 38.9% of students witnessed peer abuse at least once in the last month, while 18.2% were exposed to it at least once. Additionally, 11.8% of secondary school students had at least one experience of cyberbullying in the last month. The research also determined certain differences in the frequency of experiencing, committing and witnessing certain forms of peer abuse, as well as the consequences of peer violence with regard to gender, locality, age (grade) and type of school program. The obtained results indicate the need for timely, comprehensive and continuous investments in evidence-based preventive strategies and programs, as well as psycho-social support approaches aimed at children and young people. Key words: peer violence, peer abuse, secondary schools students, adolescents.
Article
Full-text available
Impetus for the intervention study, early stages of planning, and funding In 1994 the Institute for Families in Society at the University of South Carolina received a grant from the Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention (within the US Department of Justice) to undertake a 3-year project to conduct research related to violence among rural youth. A critical component of this grant was the implementation and evaluation of the Olweus Bullying Prevention Programme in rural schools in South Carolina. Faculty at the Institute for Families in Society were familiar with the success of the programme in Norwegian schools, from reading published summaries of the programme (Olweus, 1991; 1993) and from discussions with Professor Olweus. Recognising that no other violence-prevention programme to date had produced such impressive results, faculty were anxious to test the programme in an American setting. Early planning and preparation for the implementation of the programme involved the hiring of staff, extensive consultation with Professor Olweus, and the selection and preparation of participating schools. With the receipt of the Justice Department grant, the Institute hired a project director and part-time faculty, staff, and graduate students to support the implementation of the project. The principal university project team consisted of the principal investigator (Melton), a three-quarter time project director (Limber), three part-time PhD-level faculty at the Institute and at the Medical University of South Carolina who were responsible for providing ongoing technical assistance to schools, a part-time consultant for the project’s evaluation, and several graduate research assistants to collect, input, and collate data from participating schools.
Article
Systematic reviews use rigorous methods for locating, appraising, and synthesizing evidence from prior evaluation studies. They have explicit objectives, explicit criteria for including or excluding studies, and a structured and detailed report. The Campbell Collaboration Crime and Justice Group aims to prepare and maintain systematic reviews of criminological interventions and to make them accessible electronically to scholars, practitioners, policy makers, and the general public. The major challenges include setting methodological criteria for including studies in reviews, securing continued funding, academics needing publications in scholarly journals, and coping with the volume of work needed to maintain high standards, including refereeing proposals and final reviews and dealing with correspondence and unsolicited proposals. The aim of making the best knowledge about the effectiveness of criminological interventions immediately available to everyone is ambitious and very important.
Chapter
This volume focuses on methods of data treatment, emphasising the importance of careful matching of methodology to the substantive problem under consideration. It deals particularly with concepts of stability and change which are central to personality and developmental research. Contributions to this volume explore the methodology and scope of life span studies in a varity of contexts, including intellectual and cognitive development, transitions such as that from childhood to early adult life, social mobility, behavioural genetics, and psychological disorder, particularly depression. A valuable reference for a wide range of interests in developmental psychology, social and behavioural science, psychiatry, epidemiology and statistics.
Chapter
Impetus for the intervention study, early stages of planning, and funding Within the last decade several epidemiological studies on school bullying have been carried out nationally as well as internationally (Olweus, 1991; Smith, Morita, Junger-Tas, Olweus, Catalano, and Slee, 1999). In Germany a number of cross-section studies were published (Holtappels, 1987; Tillmann, 1994; Todt and Busch, 1994). However, in contrast to the wide number of descriptive correlational studies on bullying and aggression, there are relatively few longitudinal studies that allow us to assess possible changes in bullying. This chapter presents the conception, implementation, and evaluation of an intervention study to prevent bullying and aggression in German schools. In 1993 a survey was commissioned by the Ministry of Education of the Land Schleswig-Holstein to assess the extent of bullying and victimisation in schools in Schleswig-Holstein. From the results of the survey, recommendations for school-based violence prevention were derived (Niebel, Hanewinkel, and Ferstl, 1993). The Ministry of Education formed the networking group ‘violence prevention in schools’ which consisted of school staff, parents, as well as experts from different working areas. The working group decided to adapt and implement an antibullying programme in schools in Schleswig-Holstein which is based on the concepts and ideas of Dan Olweus (1993). Selection of schools In April 1994, the information brochure ‘Prevention of Violence and Aggression in Schools’ was distributed to all schools in Schleswig-Holstein (N = 1,055), introducing the idea of, as well as offering participation in, the programme.
Article
Bullying in Schools is the first comparative account of the major intervention projects against school bullying that have been carried out by educationalists and researchers since the 1980s, across Europe, North America and Australasia. Working on the principle that we can learn from success as well as failure, this book examines the processes as well as the outcomes, and critically assesses the likely reasons for success or failure. With contributions from leading researchers in the field, it is an important addition to the current debate on tackling this distressing problem.
Article
Impetus for the intervention, early stages of planning, and funding The Expect Respect projectwas developed by SafePlace, the sole provider of comprehensive sexual and domestic violence prevention and intervention services in Austin, Texas. Since 1989, SafePlace has been providing school-based counselling and support groups for students who have experienced dating, sexual, or domestic violence, and educational programmes in schools for students, parents, and school staff. These services began in response to requests from school counsellors who were aware of young women in physically abusive dating relationships. SafePlace counsellors initiated weekly support groups at several local high schools and middle schools to help abused girls to increase their personal safety, social support, and skills for healthy relationships. Over the years, additional counselling and support-group services were added to respond to the needs of boys and girls in grades K-12 who had experienced dating, sexual, or domestic violence. In an effort to reduce the incidence of dating violence SafePlace began in 1995 to investigate strategies for promoting safe and respectful relationships among younger children, with the intent of raising their expectations and skills for respectful behaviour in future dating relationships. Discussions with elementary school teachers and counsellors revealed that children as young as 11 years were already engaging in dating behaviours, and that frequently these relationships involved behaviours that could be described as bullying and sexual harassment, including hitting, pushing, unwanted touching, name-calling, and put-downs.
Article
Impetus for the intervention, early stages of planning, and funding The development and evaluation of the Flemish anti-bullying intervention programme was based on the results of a prevalence study among primary and secondary school students on the extent of bullying and victimisation at school, as well as on previous research on bully/victim problems. Especially, the work done by Olweus (1994) and the information drawn from the DFE Sheffield anti-bullying project (Smith and Sharp, 1994) were a trigger for programme development and further evaluation. Two successive projects were carried out. Funding was obtained from the Department of Social Affairs and from Ghent University, respectively. The first project developed an anti-bullying intervention programme adapted to the Flemish educational context. The second project aimed at implementing and evaluating the programme outcomes of the Flemish anti-bullying intervention. Following a description of these projects, we will give an overview of some critical issues related to the programme outcomes observed. The first project: Programme development The development of the Flemish anti-bullying intervention programme was founded on the principles of health education research (Green and Kreuter, 1991; Damoiseaux et al., 1993; Bartholomew et al., 1998) and included four successive steps for programme development. The first step consisted of a prevalence study to analyse the seriousness and characteristics of bully/victim problems in Flemish schools. The second step aimed at identifying the behavioural determinants of bully/victim problems.
Article
Impetus for the intervention study, early stages of planning, and funding Over the past decade, Canadians have become increasingly aware of the extent and consequences of bullying problems. Recently, there have been several high-profile cases of Canadian children who have suffered from prolonged victimisation, with severe consequences of suicide, revenge attacks, or death at the hands of peers. These cases have highlighted the need for empirically based prevention and intervention programmes. We will describe a school-based intervention programme developed prior to the recent surge in interest in the problem of bullying in Canada. This anti-bullying initiative emerged from a survey conducted in the early 1990s by the Toronto Board of Education in collaboration with researchers from York University. The questionnaire used for the survey was modelled after the Olweus self-report questionnaire (Olweus, 1989), with some adaptations for the Canadian context. The survey indicated that bullying and victimisation were pervasive problems. During the past two months, 24% of the grade 3-8 students reported that they had bullied other students at least once or twice, and 15% more than once or twice. Half of the students (49%) indicated that they had been victims of bullying at least once, 20% more than once or twice, and 8% reported being victimised weekly or more often during the past two months (Charach, Pepler, and Ziegler, 1995).
Article
Impetus for the Friendly Schools intervention study In Australia, approximately 1 in 6 school students reports being bullied at least once a week, and 1 in 20 reports bullying others in the past 6 months (Rigby, 1997; Zubrick et al., 1997). Slee and Rigby (1993; Slee, 1995) found that while most of these episodes of bullying last for a day or two, 17% last for 6 months or more. Australian primary-school children of both genders report being bullied more often than secondary-school students, with more boys than girls bullying others and being bullied (Rigby and Slee, 1991; Rigby, 1997; Rigby and Slee, 1998). Despite Australian schools’ increasing need systematically to address bullying, prior to 1999 no system-level, evidence-based recommendations or state curriculum materials to help to reduce bullying were available. Many school staff reported that they were unsure of the effectiveness of the strategies they utilised, and often did not know what actions could be taken at a whole-school level to reduce, or prevent, the harm from student bullying. In response to this situation, in 1999, the Curtin University, Western Australian Centre for Health Promotion Research, applied for and received funding extensively to review and synthesise international published empirical and theoretical evidence of successful school-based strategies to reduce the harm experienced by children from being bullied or bullying others. This systematic review provided a set of ‘successful’ practice principles and exemplar case studies to develop a whole-school approach to reduce bullying.