ArticlePDF Available

Fishes of the Mekong- how many species are there?

Authors:
4Catch and Culture Volume 15, No. 2 August 2009
Taxonomy
Recent records suggest that about
850 ‘freshwater’ fish species occur in
the basin, but many more marine and
coastal fishes may at times enter the
waters of the Mekong delta
Introduction
Loss of biodiversity is a major concern for biologists,
who warn that we are now well into ‘the century of
extinctions’ during which conservation biology is likely
to become an increasingly important discipline (Dubois
2003). While there is increasing understanding of the
need to manage habitat to maintain biodiversity, there
is much less awareness that rational management of
ecosystems faces a major ‘taxonomic impediment’,
the incompleteness and inaccuracy of inventories
of biodiversity, which are the starting point for any
conservation program .
Tropical rivers are generally among the most diverse
ecosystems and their biodiversity is particularly
threatened by habitat changes and introduction
of exotic species (Coates et al. 2003, Dudgeon et
al. 2006). The Mekong system is thought to be an
international ‘hotspot’ of unusually high biodiversity,
so there is an urgent need for an up-to-date inventory
of the system’s biodiversity, both in an absolute sense
and relative to other larger tropical rivers, as well as
accurate information on individual species’ distribution
and migration patterns.
One element of biodiversity is species richness,
thenumberofspeciespresentinadenedarea,
an easily understood notion and one that is useful
incomparisonsbetweensystems.Theshspecies
richness of the Mekong system is a topic of particular
Fishes of the Mekong–howmany
speciesare there?
interest,giventheimportanceofsheriestoMekong
peoples and the claim by many authors that the
system has unusually high biodiversity.
It should also be noted that apart from species
richness (the subject of this article), other features of
biodiversity ensure that the Mekong deserves the title
of a biodiversity hotspot and should be given a high
priority in conservation. These include the apparently
largenumberofshfamilies(Kottelat,2001),a
signicantproportionofendemicspecies(about
24%)whichincludeseverallargeorgiantshes,
thepersistenceofthenaturaloodpulse,andan
extraordinarydependenceonsheriesbyexpanding
rural populations (Hortle 2009).
Whatisaspecies?
The biological species concept (BSC) has been
generally accepted by zoologists as the most useful
andpracticaldenitionofaspeciesas‘actuallyor
potentially reproductively isolated’ population(s)
of organisms (de Queiroz 2005)1.The BSC can be
seen as a special case of the broader ‘evolutionary
species concept’, which covers asexually reproducing
organismsandfossils,andwhichdeneseach
species as a separately evolving lineage (Wiley 1978).
Although there is a lively and ongoing debate about
thenatureanddenitionof‘species’(deQueiroz2005;
Hey 2006), in practical terms testing for reproductive
isolation is usually not feasible, and genetic studies to
reveal phylogeny (evolutionary relatedness) are too
expensive to be applied to the many wild populations
whichrequireclassication.Todeducerelationships
and to diagnose ‘species’ taxonomists continue to
relyonmorphology―variationinfeatures,suchas
number of gill rakers, number of scales, counts of
1An alternative ‘phylogenetic’ system based only upon degree of genetic relationship has been developed recently and is being increasingly used in
cladistics (Rieppel 2006).
2Thebasisforthecurrentsystemofscienticclassication(taxonomy)ofanimalswassetoutover200yearsagobyLinnaeusinhisSystema
Naturae, with rules now formalised in the Code set by the International Commission on Zoological Nomenclature (www.iczn.org).
By Kent G. Hortle *
5
August 2009 Catch and Culture Volume 15, No. 2
Taxonomy
nraysorevenshapeandcoloration2. Taxonomists
generallyadjustclassicationswhenevidenceis
found of intermediates between what were thought to
be reproductively isolated populations, or if genetic
studies indicate the presence of sympatric but
reproductively isolated populations of morphologically
similarshes.Theverylimitedresourcesavailable
to study in the Earth’s biodiversity in detail, and
differences in opinion between taxonomists, ensure
thatrevisionstoclassicationofspeciesthathave
been described on morphological grounds are likely to
continue for the foreseeable future.
Theneedtoadjustfortaxonomiceffort
The number of species recorded from any particular
system tends to increase as species are collected
andrecordedforthersttime(newrecords)andas
new species are found and described, with the rate
of addition of species tending to decrease over time
to an asymptote. Figure 1 suggests that there are
stilllikelytobemanymoreshspeciesdescribed
from the Mekong catchment, as is also evident from
listings of un-described species in recent literature
(see below). However, this is not an unusual situation
for tropical river systems, indeed it seems likely that
the Mekong has by now received comparable or more
attention than many other large tropical river systems
which are less accessible or subject to security risks.
It is also highly likely that in many other tropical river
systemsowandhabitatalterationsandtheimpactof
species introductions may have caused the extinction
ofmanyshspeciesbeforetheycouldbedescribed.
This inference can be reasonably drawn based on the
situation in well-studied regions: for example in North
America61taxaofinlandsharethoughttohave
becomeextinctandaboutonethirdofallinlandsh
species are considered imperilled (Jelks et al. 2008).
Someotherfactorsthataffectspeciesrichness
As well as possible artefacts introduced by differences
in taxonomic effort, comparisons between systems
should take account of other factors which are
well-knowntobecorrelatedwithspeciesrichness;
for example, the ecoregion in which the system is
situated (Abell 2008), the fact that tropical systems are
generally richer in species than temperate systems,
and the ‘species-area effect’: more species are found
in larger areas, other factors being equal. Welcomme
(1985 Fig 5.1) used data from 47 major rivers to show
thatshspeciesrichnessiswellcorrelatedwiththe
size of the river catchment, one indicator of available
habitat area. Lévêque et al. (2008) provide updated
graphs of the relationship between the size of some
major river systems and their species richness, and
de Silva et al. (2007 Fig 1.) show that land area alone
accounts for over 70% of the variance in published
‘nsh’speciesestimatesbetweencountriesineast
and southeast Asia. It is to be expected therefore
that the Mekong will support more species than other
smaller tropical river systems in the Oriental region
because of the large extent of available aquatic habitat
within its catchment of about 800,000 km2.
ThelimitsoftheMekong
Deningariversystem’sboundariesbyitscatchment
isstraightforward,butdeningitsseawardextentis
moreproblematic.MRCpublicationsgenerallydene
the boundary geographically as a line across the
mouth, but a more useful ecological boundary would
be based on salinity. In the dry season, saline water
extends at least 60 km inland, whereas in the wet
season a surface layer of fresh water extends several
kilometres offshore in the river’s plume. Although not
well-documented for the Mekong, it can be assumed
that the downstream limit of distribution of strictly
freshwater species, as well as the penetration of
marine species into the estuary changes with season.
Estuaryshestendtopreferwaterofaparticular
salinity so they are also likely to move seasonally.
Any reference to species counts of the system should
thereforerefertowhetherthegureincludesshes
normally found in brackish or marine waters that
may only be present in the ‘Mekong’ seasonally or
occasionally.
Publishedspeciesestimates
Published estimates of the number of species in the
Mekong system appear to have increased rapidly in
the last few years, as can be seen from the following
brief chronology:
• Taki(1978)reviewedinformationuptotheearly
1970s and estimated that there were about 300
species known from the lower Mekong basin.
• Welcomme(1985Fig5.1)estimatedthatthere
were about 600 species in the Mekong, and
ranked the system third in terms of its species
richness after the Amazon and the Zaire, both of
which are larger rivers.
6Catch and Culture Volume 15, No. 2 August 2009
Taxonomy
• Rainboth(1996)recorded475speciesfrom
Cambodia and estimated that the Mekong “has
about1200speciesofsh”(p.14)andreiterated
this estimate in an interview (Jensen 1996). This
estimate however was clearly his expectation
of the total that might be eventually found after
more collection and taxonomic work.
• Kottelat(2001p19)statedthattherewere
documented records of about 700 species from
the Mekong basin, and because there were
nodatatosupportclaimsofhighergureshe
suggested that they should not be quoted.
Several authors provided similarly high but
unsubstantiatedgures,perhapsbasedonRainboth’s
estimate,butmisusedhisgureasifitwereacount
of species actually recorded or a minimum estimate.
In some cases, authors implied that the species count
was for the river, when many species are found only
in upland tributaries or in the estuary or in specialised
habitats such as lakes or caves. Some of these recent
species estimates include the following.
• ‘Thereare1200recordedshspecies’
(Sverdrup-Jensen 2002).
• ‘It(theMekong)isahotspotforbiodiversitywith
between 1200 and 1600 described species of
sh’(Campbell2002).
• ‘Thereareatleast1200andpossiblyasmany
as1700(speciesofsh)livingintheMekong
Basin’ (Coates et al. 2003).
• ‘Therearemorethan1200speciesintheriver’
(sic) (MRC 2003).
TheMRCFisheriesProgrammepublishedtherst
compendium of species of the Mekong, the Mekong
Fish Database (MFD), in 2003 and widely distributed it
asaCDtosheriesscientistsintheregion.TheMFD
containedinformationon898indigenousshesaswell
as 24 introduced species that were recorded from or
thought likely to be present in the lower Mekong basin
andinYunnan.Theshescanbegroupedaccording
to their known occurrence in water of different
salinities, using information which has been obtained
from FishBase (Froese and Pauly 2009).
Freshwater only : 539 species
Freshwater-brackish: 79 species
Fresh- brackish marine: 113 species
Brackish only: 4 species
Brackish and marine: 115 species
Marine: 48 species
The marine species and many of the brackish/marine
species have only been recorded from the sea off the
mouth of the Mekong or from nearby marine waters,
and records for several of the freshwater species are
questionable, so the MFD supports an estimate of
about 750 species likely to be found at times within
freshwaters of the system, which can be loosely
denedas‘freshwater’species3.Thisgureisquite
consistent with Kottelat’s estimate, nevertheless higher
unsubstantiated estimates continued to be published,
for example:
• ‘Thenumberofshspeciesisatleast1200’
(Mattson 2004)
• ‘Thenumberofshspeciesthathasbeen
found in the (Mekong basin) exceeds 2000’ (van
Zalinge et al. 2004).
The citation of species numbers seems to represent
acaseof‘escalationbias’,whereagureisquoted
that supports a commonly-held belief (the Mekong has
‘high’ biodiversity) while ignoring the actual counts of
species from the system published by Kottelat in 2001
and in the MFD in 2003. The variability between recent
published estimates of species richness certainly
creates a credibility issue for those seeking to promote
conservation of the system’s biodiversity, as well as
highlightingthepracticalproblemsofclassicationand
nomenclaturefacingthoseengagedineldstudiesor
managementofhabitatforsheries.
3Itshouldbenotedthat‘freshwater’specieshavebeendenedbysomeauthorsasonlythosewithinprimaryfreshwaterfamilies,i.e.familieswhich
have a long history of evolution in freshwaters, and if this approach were used the total for the Mekong system would fall to about 530 species
becausemanyMekongshesarewithinperipheraldivisionfamilies,thosewithrecentmarineancestors.See:BerraTM(2001)FreshwaterFish
Distribution. Academic Press: San Diego, USA.
7
August 2009 Catch and Culture Volume 15, No. 2
Taxonomy
Figure 1: TheSundashelf
Showing the maximum extent of sea level regression over the last 250,000 years, the -120 m
contour. Based on (Voris 2000)
Figure 2: SpeciesdescribedfromtheMekongRiversystem
Cumulativecountdoesnotincludespeciesrecordedthatwererstdescribedfromelsewhere
8Catch and Culture Volume 15, No. 2 August 2009
Taxonomy
Sisterspecies Reviseddistributionsummary
Amblyrhynchichthys truncatus (Bleeker, 1851) Malay Peninsula and Borneo
Amblyrhynchichthys micracanthus Ng&Kottelat,2004 LowerandMiddleMekongtoVientiane,ChaoPhraya,MaeKhlong,Tapi
River
Bagrichthys macracanthus (Bleeker, 1854) Sumatra, Peninsular Malaysia, northern Borneo (Sarawak)
Bagrichthys majusculus Ng,2002 LowerandmiddleMekongRiversystem
Balantiocheilos melanopterus (Bleeker, 1851) Kalimantan, Malay Peninsula, Sumatra
Balantiocheilos ambusticauda Ng&Kottelat,2007 LowerandmiddleMekongupstreamtoNamNgum,ChaoPhraya
Hemiarius stormii (Bleeker, 1858) Eastern Malay Peninsula and west Borneo
Hemiarius verrucosus (Ng,2003) LowerMekongtoKhoneFallsandpossiblyBangPakongR.,Southeast
Thailand
Kryptopterus cryptopterus (Bleeker, 1851) Borneo, Java, Sumatra and Malay Peninsula
Kryptopterus geminusNg, 2003 LowerandmiddleMekong,MaeKhlong,BangPakongR.,ChaoPhraya
Kryptopterus schilbeides (Bleeker, 1858) Eastern Sumatra and western and southern Borneo
Kryptopterus paraschilbeidesNg,2003 LowerandmiddleMekongupstreamtoVientiane
Ompok hypophthalmus (Fang & Chaux, 1949) Java and southern Borneo (Barito River drainage)
Ompok urbaini Ng,2003 Mekong,ChaoPhrayaandPasakRiverdrainages
Ompok rhadinurus Ng, 2003 Sumatra, the Malay Peninsula and Borneo
Ompok eugeneiatus (Vaillant, 1893) Peninsular Malaysia, central Sumatra and western Borneo
Ompok pinnatusNg,2003 LowerMekongRiverandChaoPhrayadrainages
Pangasius kunyit Pouyaud Teugels & Legendre, 1999 Sumatra and Kalimantan (southern Borneo)
Pangasius mekongensis Gustiano, Teugels&Pouyaud,2003 LowerMekongRiversystem
Pangasius sabahensis Gustiano, Teugels & Pouyaud, 2003 Sabah, northern Borneo
Pangasius polyuranodon Bleeker, 1852 Sumatra and Borneo
Pangasius elongatus Pouyaud,Gustiano&Teugels,2002 ChaoPhraya,MekongandBangPakongbasins
Pangasius mahakamensis Pouyaud, Gustiano & Teugels, 2002 Mahakam River, East Kalimantan, Borneo
Polynemus dubius Bleeker, 1853 Malay Peninsula, Sumatra, Kalimantan
Polynemus aquilonaris* Motomura,2003 ChaoPhrayaandMekongRiverbasins
Wallago leerii Bleeker, 1851 Southern Thailand, Malay Peninsula and western Indonesia
Wallago micropogon Ng,2004 LowerandmiddleMekongtoLuangPhabang,andmiddleChaoPhraya
* alsoincludesmaterialformerlyidentiedas Polynemus longipectoralis
Table1.Species‘split’sincematerialwascompiledforpublicationoftheMFDin2003
The newly described Mekong species is shown in bold after the species which was formerly considered to occupy a large range on both sides of the
Sunda shelf, including the Mekong system
9
August 2009 Catch and Culture Volume 15, No. 2
Taxonomy
Anupdatedspeciescount
Since the MFD was published there has been
considerable taxonomic work which has resulted in
manychangestoclassicationofMekongsystem
shes,whichincludethefollowing.
• ‘Splitting’ofspecies:inatleast12casesa
species that was considered widespread in
rivers that formerly ran across the Sunda shelf
has been ‘split’ into ‘sister’ species, a mainland
Indochinese (including Mekong) species and
one or more ‘Sundaic’ species, found in river
systems to the south (Figure 2, Table 1). Such
splitting does not change the species count
for the Mekong, only the name applied to the
Mekong species. But it can cause confusion
and double-counting when distribution records
for the Sundaic species are not updated,
which is a problem for example in the current
version of FishBase. Examples of split species
are shown in Table 1 with updated distribution
information.
• Descriptionofnewspecies:newspeciesare
still being described, either from new collections
or when taxonomists re-examine existing
collections which may have been stored in
museums for many years. At least 16 new inland
species have been described from the Mekong
River system since the MFD was published in
2003 (Table2), adding to the species count for
the system.
• ‘Lumping’:twoormorespeciesformerlythought
to be distinct are synonymised when additional
examination shows that there is overlap in
the range of variation of diagnostic characters
between populations that have been named
as separate species, or when it is found that
a species has been named more than once.
Since 2003 ‘lumping’ of species has reduced
the count for the Mekong system by about 20
species, more than compensating for the effect
of description of new species.
• Revisionsofgroups:severalgroups(genera
or families) have been revised since the MFD
was published, with many new generic names
createdtobetterdenerelationshipsbetween
species. For example, the widespread genus
Botia, which includes several common Mekong
species, was split into seven genera by Kottelat
(2004), with Mekong species now falling within
three genera. Thus the red-tailed botia, formerly
Botia modesta is now known as Yasuhikotakia
modesta.ArevisionofthecatshfamilyAriidae
Species Distributionsummary
Scizothorax nudiventris YangChen&Yang,2009 UpperMekong,Yunnan
Bangana brevirostris Liu & Zhou, 2009 UpperMekong,Yunnan
Mekongina lancangensis Yang,Chen&Yang,2008 UpperMekong,Yunnan
Minyclupeoides dentibranchialus Roberts, 2008 Lower Mekong, Cambodia
Oreoglanis jingdongensis Kong,Chen&Yang,2007 UpperMekong,Yunnan
Pareuchiloglanis abbreviatus Li,Zhou,Thomson,Zhang&Yang,2007 UpperMekong,Yunnan
Pareuchiloglanis prolixdorsalis Li,Zhou,Thomson,Zhang&Yang,2007 UpperMekong,Yunnan
Tonlesapia tsukawakii Motomura & Mukai, 2006 Great Lake, Tonlé Sap drainage in Cambodia.
Polynemus bidentatus Motomura & Tsuwaki, 2006 Mekong delta, Viet Nam
Pseudobagarius lifer (Ng & Rainboth, 2005) Tonlé Sap drainage near Phnom Penh, Cambodia
Pseudobagarius nitidus (Ng & Rainboth, 2005) Mekong River downstream of Khone Falls near Cambodia-Lao border
Akysis fuliginatus Ng & Rainboth, 2005 Lower Mekong River in northern Cambodia
Betta stiktos Tan & Ng, 2005 Mekong Drainage, Cambodia
Schistura bannaensis Chen,Yang&Qi,2005 UpperMekong,Yunnan
Oreoglanis macronemus Ng, 2004 Xieng Khouang, Lao PDR
Hemimyzon ecdyonuroides Freyhof & Herder, 2002 Headwaters of Se San River, Viet Nam
Table2.NewspeciesdescribedfromtheMekongRiversystem
SincematerialwascompiledforpublicationoftheMekongFishDatabasein2003
10 Catch and Culture Volume 15, No. 2 August 2009
Taxonomy
has also led to many new names for genera
(Marceniuk and Menezes 2007). Such name
changes are relatively easy to follow by updating
species lists using FishBase and do not affect
the species count for the system.
• Additionaldistributionrecords:speciesthat
are already described from elsewhere are
recordedforthersttimeincollectionsfrom
the Mekong system. Such information has not
been updated in any systematic way since
the MFD was published. Summary distribution
records are often woefully inadequate for
assessing whether it is likely that a species
is present in the area of interest, in some
cases simply reading “Asia”, while original
locality data on museum specimens are often
incompleteorerroneous.Thelistsofshes
published in ecological surveys typically include
incompletelyidentiedspecies(usuallynoted
as ‘sp1’, ‘sp2’ etc.) or may contain errors (for
example non-Mekong species), hardly surprising
wheretherearemanysimilarspeciesofshes
thataredifcultfornon-specialiststoidentify
correctly. Ideally, distribution data for inland
species in FishBase would accurately identify
the major river basins in which each species
hasbeendenitelyrecorded,butitisamajor
task to check and carefully summarize and
update such information. A review and cross-
checking of Mekong system species listed in
Baird et al. (1999), Kang et al. (2009), Kottelat
(2001), Rainboth (1996) and Vidthayanon
(2008) suggests that there are about 100
additional species that have been recorded
from freshwaters of the Mekong basin, although
most of these are not formally described or are
of uncertain taxonomic status. Therefore it is
reasonable to estimate that there are about 850
‘freshwater’ species known from the system.
Thecountofallshspeciesfrom‘theriversystem’is
likelytobeheavilyinuencedbythecoastalspecies
which enter fresh water for short periods, or marine
species which may cross the geographical boundary (a
line across the mouth) during dry periods. Systematic
collectionandaccurateidenticationofshesfromthe
delta region would do much to remove the uncertainty
in species counts and resolve the discrepancies in
published estimates. If marine and coastal ‘visitors’ are
included, there are about 1100 species recorded from
or thought likely to occur in the system at times based
on their occurrence in the Mekong’s plume. More
species will continue to be found, but at present there
are no grounds for quoting higher estimates.
Conclusion
The available data indicate that there are about 850
freshwatershspeciesrecordedfromtheMekong
(a total that includes some undescribed species of
uncertain status) , with a total estimate of about 1100
if the possible coastal or marine visitors are included.
As mentioned above, comparison with other river
systems should take into account the biogeographic
province or ecoregion, the area of each system, the
relative taxonomic effort that has been applied, and the
extent to which biodiversity may have been lost before
it could be documented. If it is evident that the Mekong
does indeed have more species than expected for a
river of its size and location, it would be of interest to
explore the possible causes, which might include its
recent geological history and the geography of the
system.
Unless great care is taken, comparisons with other
river systems may lead to erroneous conclusions.
For example, according to FishBase there are 405
species recorded from the Zaire (Congo) and 1212
species recorded from the Amazon, but these are
clearly under-estimates, both because existing records
have not been systematically compiled and because
many species remain to be described. Roberts
(1975)recorded650shesfromtheZairebasinand
Tedescoetal.(2005)quotedagureof686species,
but Lévêque et al. (2008) cautioned that existing
information for this basin needs to be synthesised
and that many new discoveries are anticipated. For
the Amazon, Tedesco et al. (2005) used an estimate
of 1761 species and Lévêque et al. (2008) recorded
2416 species, but Kottelat (2001) cited an opinion
that the number of species in South America could
more than double with new collections and taxonomic
effort. The Amazon’s catchment is about seven times
andtheZairevetimesthesizeoftheMekong’s,soit
islikelythattheysupportmoreshes,butatpresent
it is impossible to know whether any of these large
river system’s species richness is above or below
the average that would be predicted for large tropical
rivers of their size.
11
August 2009 Catch and Culture Volume 15, No. 2
Taxonomy
Acknowledgments
The Water Studies Centre of Monash University kindly
providedofcespaceandlibraryfacilitiestoassistin
the preparation of this paper. I thank Eamonn Hortle
for assisting with compilation of species information
from FishBase and Chris Burridge and Chris Barlow
for helpful comments on a draft manuscript.
*Mr Hortle was a technical ofcer at the MRC Fisheries Programme
from 2001 to 2005 and currently works as a consultant on sheries
and environment
References
Abell (2008) Freshwater ecoregions of the world: a new map
of biogeographic units for freshwater biodiversity conservation.
BioScience 58, 403-414.
Baird IG, Inthaphaisy V, Kisouvannalath P, Phylavanh B,
Mounsouphom B (1999) The Fishes of southern Lao. Ministry of
Agriculture and Forestry, Vientiane, Laos. 161 pages. (In Lao).
Berra TM (2001) Freshwater Fish Distribution. Academic Press: San
Diego, USA. 604 pages.
CampbellIC(2002)TheMekongRiver-water,peopleandsheries
in a politically complex river basin. Paper presented in ‘Enviro Flows
2002 4th Ecohydraulics Conference, 4th February 2002, Capetown,
South Africa.’ 15 pages.
Coates D, Ouch P, Suntornratana U, Nguyen TT, Viravong S (2003)
BiodiversityandsheriesintheMekongRiverBasin.Mekong
Development Series 2: 1-30.
de Queiroz K (2005) Ernst Mayr and the modern concept of species.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 102: 6600-6607.
de Silva SS, Abery NW, Nguyen TTT (2007) Endemic freshwater
nshofAsia:distributionandconservationstatus.Diversity and
Distributions 13: 172-184.
de Queiroz K (2005) Ernst Mayr and the modern concept of species.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 102, 6600-6607.
Dubois A (2003) The relationships between taxonomy and
conservation biology in the century of extinctions. Comptes Rendus
Biologies 326, Supplement 1: 9-21.
Dudgeon D, Arthington AH, Gessner MO, Kawabata Z-I, Knowler
DJ, Lévêque C, Naiman RJ, Anne-Hélène, Prieur-Richard, Soto
D, Stiassny MLJ, Sullivan CA (2006) Freshwater biodiversity:
importance, threats, status and conservation challenges. Biological
Reviews 81: 163-182.
Froese R, Pauly D (2009) (Eds) FishBase. World Wide Web
ElectronicPublication.www.shbase.org,version(03/2009).
Hey J (2006) On the failure of modern species concepts. Trends in
Ecology and Evolution 21, 447-450.
Hortle KG (in press) Fisheries of the Mekong River basin. Ch 9 in:
The Mekong: Biophysical Environment of an International River
Basin. (Ed. IC Campbell). Elsevier Publishers Amsterdam, the
Netherlands.
Jelks HL, Walsh SJ, Burkhead NM, Contreras-Balderas S, Diaz-
Pardo E, Hendrickson DA, Lyons J, Mandrak NE, McCormick F,
Nelson JS, Platania SP, Porter BA, Renaud CB, Schmitter-Soto JJ,
Taylor EB, Warren ML (2008) Conservation status of imperiled North
Americanfreshwateranddiadromousshes.Fisheries 33: 372-386.
JensenJG(1996)1,200differentshspeciesintheMekongbasin.
Catch and Culture 2: 4-5.
KangB,HeD,PerrettL,WangH,HuW,DengW,WuY(2009)Fish
andsheriesintheUpperMekong:currentassessmentofthesh
community, threats and conservation. Reviews in Fish Biology and
Fisheries.
Kottelat M (2001) Fishes of Laos WHT Publications Pty Ltd:
Colombo, Sri Lanka. 198 pages.
Kottelat M (2004) Botia kubotai, a new species of loach (Teleostei:
Cobitidae) from the Ataran River basin (Myanmar), with comments
on botiine nomenclature and diagnosis of a new genus. Zootaxa
401: 1-18.
Lévêque C, Oberdorff T, Paugy D, Stiassny MLJ, Tedesco PA (2008)
Globaldiversityofsh(Pisces)infreshwater.Hydrobiologia 595:
545–567.
Marceniuk AP, Menezes NA (2007) Systematics of the family Ariidae
(Ostariophysi,Siluriformes),witharedenitionofthegenera.
Zootaxa 1416: 1-126.
MattsonNS(2004)Conservationandenhancementofsheries-the
case of the lower Mekong basin. Paper presented in ‘INTECOL, 7th
International Wetlands Conference, 23-30 July 2004’. Utrecht, the
Netherlands 16 pages.
MRC (2003) State of the Basin Report 2003. Mekong River
12 Catch and Culture Volume 15, No. 2 August 2009
Commission: Phnom Penh, Cambodia. 300 pages.
Rainboth WJ (1996) Fishes of the Cambodian Mekong. FAO: Rome,
Italy. 265 pages + plates pages.
Rieppel O (2006) The PhyloCode: a critical discussion of its
theoretical foundation. Cladistics 22: 186-197.
Roberts TR (1975) Geographical distribution of African freshwater
shes.Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 57, 249-319.
Sverdrup-Jensen S (2002) Fisheries in the lower Mekong Basin:
status and perspectives. MRC Technical Paper 6: 1-95.
TakiY(1978)AnanalyticalstudyoftheshfaunaoftheMekong
Basin as a biological production system in nature. Research Institute
of Evolutionary Biology Special Publications 1: 1-77.
Tedesco PA, Oberdorff T, Lasso CA, Zapata M, Hugueny B (2005)
Evidence of history in explaining diversity patterns in tropical riverine
sh.JournalofBiogeography321899-1907.
van Zalinge NP, Degen P, Pongsri C, Nuov S, Jensen JG, Nguyen
VH, Choulamany X (2004) The Mekong River system. RAP
Publication 2004: 335-357.
Voris HK (2000) Maps of Pleistocene sea levels in Southeast
Asia: shorelines, river systems and time durations. Journal of
Biogeography 27: 1153–1167.
Vidthayanon C (2008) Field Guide to Fishes of the Mekong Delta.
(Mekong River Commission: Vientiane, Lao PDR).
WelcommeRL(1985)Riversheries.FAO Fisheries Technical
Paper 262: 1-358.
Wiley EO (1978) The evolutionary species concept reconsidered.
Systematic Zoology 27, 17-26.
Taxonomy
... El enriquecimiento excesivo de nutrientes es un factor que contribuye a la degradación de los ecosistemas costeros (Páez-Osuna et al., 2003;Rojo et al., 2021;Duque et al., 2022). Los impactos negativos en los esteros se magnifican debido a los niveles altos de contaminación en los ambientes de agua dulce (Hortle, 2009;Cooke et al., 2012;Darwall y Freyhof, 2015;Palmer y Montagna, 2015) y, aunque estos ecosistemas son áreas altamente productivas, las presiones antropogénicas han provocado cambios progresivos en la biodiversidad (Araujo et al., 2017;Osorto et al., 2017), cambios que han sido poco estudiados en el neotrópico. En ese sentido, los ecosistemas costeros de las zonas templadas han sido estudiados con mayor profundidad. ...
... Nutrient over-enrichment is a factor that contributes to the deterioration of coastal ecosystems (Páez-Osuna et al., 2003;Rojo et al., 2021;Duque et al., 2022). The negative impacts on estuaries are magnified due to high levels of pollution in freshwater environments (Hortle, 2009;Cooke et al., 2012;Darwall and Freyhof, 2015;Palmer and Montagna, 2015), and, even though these ecosystems are highly productive areas, anthropogenic pressures have caused progressive changes in biodiversity (Araujo et al., 2017;Osorto et al., 2017), which have been little studied in the Neotropics. In this sense, coastal ecosystems in temperate zones have been studied in more depth. ...
Article
Full-text available
Se recopilaron datos de calidad de agua de ocho sitios de monitoreo que incluyo 7 parámetros entre 2000-2015. Para el análisis de datos se utilizaron estadísticas descriptivas, análisis de componentes principales (ACP) y de conglomerados. El ACP resulto en 3 componentes que explicaron el 72,6% de la varianza total. El primer componente incluyo Nitrógeno total, Fosforo total, Demanda Bioquímica de Oxígeno (DBO5) y alcalinidad representando mala calidad de agua. El segundo componente incluyo salinidad y pH representando calidad de agua moderada. El tercer componente representa la contaminación por solidos sedimentables. Como resultado del análisis de conglomerados, se clasificaron tres grupos estadísticamente significativos, el grupo I esteros Purgatorio y Barrancones con calidad de agua buena, grupo II esteros Garcero, San Bernardo, Pedregal, Perejil y Berbería calidad de agua mala, y grupo III estero Jagua calidad de agua moderada. Los análisis indicaron que los esteros con mala calidad de agua fueron los sitios que han aumentado las actividades antropogénicas directamente por aguas residuales de acuicultura. Es necesario tomar medidas preventivas que propicien el desarrollo de la vida acuática a través de la orientación de una regulación y servicio costero efectivo en la que se apoyen los esfuerzos de gestión en el futuro.
... According to Winemiller et al. (2016), the river is home to 599 species, 213 of them endemic. Hortle (2009a) gives a species number of 1100, 850 of which are freshwater fish. He further notes that some of the variations in estimates may well be due to taxonomic shifts, with species being split or lumped on the basis of new analyses, as well as the discovery of new species in the system. ...
... 279 new species were found in the Mekong. However, Hortle (2009a) also notes what he calls "escalation bias", "where a figure is quoted that supports a commonly-held belief (the Mekong has 'high' biodiversity) while ignoring the actual counts of species from the system", which in turn "creates a credibility issue for those seeking to promote conservation of the system's biodiversity, as well as highlighting the practical problems of classification and nomenclature facing those engaged in field studies or management of habitat for fisheries" (p.6). ...
Thesis
Full-text available
This thesis provides insights into the hydrological processes in the Cambodian Mekong delta, as well as their relationship to ecosystem services from which the local population benefits. In particular, the role of the Prek channels is examined. First constructed during the period of the French protectorate in the early20th century, these channels diverge perpendicularly from the Mekong and its deltaic distributary, the Bassac, and provide a connection between the river mainstream and its low-lying floodplains by breaching the elevated river banks. The aim of this thesis is to assess how large-scale changes in the Mekong basin,such as climate and land use change, as well as hydropower development, are reflected at a local scale in its delta. It also aims to elucidate how local infrastructure such as Preks catalyzes these processes and could help mitigate negative effects of future scenarios.To address all of these research questions, a multi-method approach was chosen. First, a thorough literature review of the complex challenges facing the Mekong basin and its delta was carried out. Subsequently, an analysis of long-term trends in water levels, precipitation patterns, and inundation extents and dynamics at the scale of the Cambodian Mekong delta is provided. Water level time series at four hydrological stations maintained by the Mekong River Commission (MRC) are subjected to a trend and break point analysis. Furthermore, precipitation data from three in-situ stations, as well as remotely sensed CHIRPS data are compared. Inundation extents are assessed on the basis of a new model developed in the course of this thesis: WAFL - Water Level Flood Link. WAFL uses in-situ water level time series and inundation maps derived from Sentinel-1 and -2 images taken between 2017 and 2020, and establishes a correlative link between them, accounting for flood propagation delays and attenuation. It can then be used to reconstruct past inundation extents based on water levels, overcoming spatial data sparsity. It is able to reconstruct earlier events (floods in the 1990’s and 2000s) with good accuracy, in comparison to historical Landsat-derived maps. This indicates that long-term changes of flood patterns are mostly due to shifts in boundary inflow, rather than in the local configuration of the link between the riverand its floodplains. Overall, average inundation durations have declined by 19 days and the incidence of inundations in the early wet season (July and August) has decreased by an average of to 21 Furthermore, fieldwork was carried out in a case study area on the banks of the Bassac river, which encompasses ten Preks. Local stakeholders, such as farmers and village chiefs, were interviewed to gain a better understanding of the ecosystem services linked to local hydrological processes, and the capacity in which the Preks catalyze these processes. The interviews also served as a basis to characterize typical cropping patterns and practices, from irrigation to average and maximum yield. To further enhance the understanding of the role of the Preks for local communities and agricultural practices archival research was undertaken. In addition, local land use and its variations depending on the spatial configuration of hydrological processes and Preks was analyzed using a land use - land cover (LULC) classification based on Sentinel imagery and a supervised Gradient Tree Boosting machine learning approach.Finally, to formalize the understanding of the role of Preks for local hydrological processes and ecosystem services in the Cambodian Mekong delta, and to simulate future scenarios, a numerical model was constructed in Python. It uses the data generated through interviews, literature research, and remote sensing analyses as input and simulates four future scenarios with respect to local climate variables, the configuration of Prek channels and river water levels, the latter depending on basin-wide climate change and hydropower development. Flood-related and non-flood related ecosystem services were simulated separately, to central role of annual monsoon inundations. The results show that under likely future precipitation, temperature, and water level patterns, agricultural production is set to decrease, but that this decrease could be compensated by Prek rehabilitation.
... After the Amazon and Congo river basins, it is one of the world's most productive and biodiverse ecosystems [93,95,96], and one of the world's major freshwater aquatic ecosystems providing significant seafood resources to Vietnam and surrounding countries [97,98]. There are approximately 800-850 freshwater fishes in this region [99,100]. When marine and estuarine migratory fish are added to this, the LMB supports an incredible diversity of 1,148 fish species [101]. ...
... After the Amazon and Congo river basins, it is one of the world's most productive and biodiverse ecosystems [93,95,96], and one of the world's major freshwater aquatic ecosystems providing significant seafood resources to Vietnam and surrounding countries [97,98]. There are approximately 800-850 freshwater fishes in this region [99,100]. When marine and estuarine migratory fish are added to this, the LMB supports an incredible diversity of 1,148 fish species [101]. ...
Chapter
Full-text available
The Lower Mekong Basin (LMB) supports one of the largest, most rapidly expanding and economically dynamic human populations across the globe. It is also one of the world’s most productive and diverse ecosystems. Over 80% of the sixty million people living in this region are significantly impacted by changes to fish availability because of pollution, climate change, degradation of wetland ecosystem services, upstream development activities and population growth. Fish is the main source of dietary protein in both national and international trade. The Mekong Delta is a hotspot of aquaculture and fish biodiversity and a center of agricultural production in Vietnam. This report summaries the environmental history and major decisions by government that led to changes in land use, aquaculture development and wild capture fisheries. The changes to productivity of wild fisheries and the influence of major pollutants in the Mekong Delta are explored.
... In terms of economic value, the fisheries sector contributes about 12% to Gross Domestic Product (GDP) among the LMB countries, and provides most people there with vital sources of animal protein, calcium and vitamin A (MRC, 2004). Recent estimates by Hortle (2009) found there are around 850 fish species in the LMB; most of which support the rural dwellers' way of life, emphasizing their reliance on fish and the habitats that support them (Halwart, 2008). In 2002, the Mekong River Commission (MRC) estimated that the annual fish catch in the MRB as a whole is around 1.5 million tonnes, with 0.5 million tonnes also caught in reservoirs and through other forms of aquaculture (MRC, 2003). ...
... In addition, Southeast Asia's largest lake-the Tonle Sap-lies in western Cambodia. As a tropical watershed with a recurring wet season and associated fl ooding of expansive wetlands, the lake supports a productive and diverse community of over 1,000 fi sh species (Hortle, 2009a;Rainboth et al., 2012). The seasonal fl ood pulse drives fi sh abundance in the basin, as species are adapted to utilize seasonally available, highly productive habitats (Poulsen et al., 2002). ...
... The Mekong basin is one of the richest sites of biodiversity in the world after the Amazon River basin which has the higher level of biodiversity [2]. Mekong is home to approximately 20,000 plant species, 430 mammals, 1,200 birds, 800 reptiles and amphibians [3], and around 850 freshwater fish species including the world largest freshwater fish [4]. Around 80% of the nearly 65 million people living in the Lower Mekong River Basin depend their lives on the river's natural resources [5]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The assessment of flood dynamics is essential in supporting the nation and all stakeholders for the better flood management and adaptation. Climate change and hydropower dam operation pose threat to water resources in the Lower Mekong Delta. Cambodia is vulnerable to the flood impact due to its low adaptive capacity. Historically, flood has big impact on Cambodian society, economics and environment. This research was conducted by using the 2D HEC-RAS Modeling Application to study the flood dynamics under the influence of climate change, hydropower operation and irrigation expansion. The analysis is based on the observed flow and water level of 5 years from 2015 to 2019 and digital elevation model (6 m x6 m). The indices indicated satisfactory performance for the simulation model with the value of NSE between 0.78 and 0.97 and R2 between 0.80 and 0.96. The impact of climate change, hydropower operation and irrigation expansion, on the Cambodian Mekong floodplain area in forms of the flood inundation characteristics using the above well-configured hydraulic model framework. The results show that the flood extent increases around 74% in dry season and decrease around 20% in rainy season. Comparing to the baseline, the results of the scenario study suggest that the study area is likely to experience larger floodplain area in dry season (October to April), and flood extent in rainy season is lesser (May to October). The simulated results will provide important hydraulic information to respond to the future change of flood extent. The increase of water level in the dry season will provide water availability in the water supply sector and agriculture.
Article
The spotted spiny eel, Macrognathus siamensis is an economically important freshwater fish in the Mekong River basin, which is undergoing dramatic biodiversity changes due to anthropogenic impacts. The species is non-migratory, with a moderate larval duration that facilitates downstream genetic connectivity. Restriction site-associated DNA sequence datasets that includes 3736 and 1244 single nucleotide polymorphisms representing putatively neutral loci, from all geographic sites and without the Tachileik site, indicate strong population structure in this sedentary fish, with a significant isolation-by-distance signature. This structure reflects isolation of tributary populations and downstream dispersal of these distinct populations to mix in the Mekong mainstem and contributes to increased genetic diversity in the lower reaches of the Mekong basin. Genetic data indicates that the dispersal of eggs and larvae downstream is not impeded by Khone Falls and that the falls prevent upstream dispersal of eggs and larvae. Despite this downstream connectivity, there is a strong population structure among above- and below-Khone Falls groups. An analysis of outlier loci putatively under selection provides evidence that the difference between connected metapopulations above and below the falls is due to the fundamental differences in environmental regimes. We hypothesize that instead of a physical barrier, the falls simply represents a demarcation between previously recognized upstream limited-floodplain environments and downstream extensive-floodplain environments. These findings emphasize the need to monitor genetic diversity of key sedentary fishery species to assess whether proposed dams along the river could affect genetic diversity downstream. This genetic diversity is particularly important for the resilience of downstream populations because of the many environmental impacts caused by dams, land use, and climate change. Early detection of reduced downstream genetic diversity could trigger remediation programs to ensure resilience and continued fisheries productivity of important non-migratory fish resources.
Article
Full-text available
The Lower Mekong Basin (LMB), covering parts of Cambodia, Lao PDR, Thailand and Vietnam, is a biodiversity hotspot for many types of organisms, including some 1,200 fish species. The river supports one of the largest and most diverse inland fisheries in the world, with an estimated annual yield of three million tonnes. The LMB environment is still considered healthy, but the human population and the economy of the LMB countries are growing rapidly, causing an increasing rate of natural resource use. There are already signs of stress in the fishery, with increasing catches of small bodied fish and dwindling numbers of the larger species. Ongoing fisheries development activities in the LMB are described, including co-management and support to fisheries enhancement, for example stocking and aquaculture development. However, serious threats to biodiversity and fisheries arise from activities like dam construction, improvement of navigation and conversion of floodplains for agriculture. Therefore, in the LMB the primary concern for fisheries agencies may not be enhancement of the already highly productive fisheries but how to sustain acceptable yields. This will require a holistic view of the natural resources, and implies that fisheries agencies must assume a greater role in relevant policy formulation. A major impediment to integrated natural resource management is the lack of a common, cross-scale and cross-sector knowledge base. Improving the way management and policy information is generated and communicated will improve the prospects for just and rational development of fisheries and other sectors in the LMB.
Article
Full-text available
The taxonomic status of all the nominal genera of the Ariidae are reviewed and ariid genera are diagnosed by exclusive characters as well as by a combination of internal and external morphological features. The results are based on a phylogenetic analysis undertaken by the senior author (Marceniuk, 2003). The species so far recognized are taxonomically reevaluated and considered as valid, inquirendae or synonyms under each diagnosed genus based on direct examination of specimens or use of diagnostic characters available in the literature. A key to identification of genera is provided based on morphological characters that can be easily recognized. In the new classification proposed, Ariidae comprises the following twenty six valid genera: Amissidens, Arius, Aspistor, Bagre, Batrachocephalus, Brustiarius, Cathorops, Cephalocassis, Cinetodus, Cochlefelis, Cryptarius, Doiichthys, Galeichthys, Genidens, Hemiarius, Ketengus, Nedystoma, Nemapteryx, Neoarius, Netuma, Notarius, Osteogeneiosus, Pachyula, Plicofollis, Potamarius and Sciades. Three new genera are erected. The nominal genera Bagre Oken, 1817, Glanis, Stearopterus, Breviceps non Merrem, 1820, Felichthys, Ailurichthys, Mystus non Scopoli, 1777 and Anemanotus are considered junior synonyms of Bagre Cloquet, 1816. Hexanematichthys, Sciadeichthys, Selenaspis, Ariopsis and Leptarius are synonyms of Sciades. The nominal genus Pseudarius is an objective synonym, and Ariodes a subjective synonym, of Arius. Sciadeops is synonymous with Notarius. Catastoma and Sarcogenys are synonyms of Netuma. Tetranesodon is preliminary considered junior synonym of Pachyula. Hemipimelodus is a synonym of Cephalocassis. Septobranchus is a junior synonym of Cinetodus, and Guiritinga is a new synonym of Genidens.
Article
Full-text available
The Mekong is the longest river in southeast Asia. From its source on the Tibetan plateau it runs for 4,800 km through China, Myanmar, Lao PDR, Thailand, Cambodia and Viet Nam to the South China Sea, where it discharges on average 475,000 million m3 per year. The total Mekong Basin (MB) catchment area covers 795,000 km2 and has 73 million inhabitants. The Lower Mekong Basin (LMB) comprises the four countries, - Cambodia, Lao PDR, Thailand and Viet Nam - that signed the 1995 river development agreement and covers 77% of the total basin with 55 million people. The degree of inundation of the 70,000 km2 floodplains depends on the strength of the monsoon, as 85 -90 % of the discharge is generated during the wet season from May to October. Although far from pristine, the river still is in a relative good condition. Only 2 mainstream dams (in China) have been built, but many more on the tributaries. The number of fish species that has been found in the MB exceeds 2000. Many migrate across international borders, thus constituting trans-boundary resources. The largest fisheries are found in the extensive floodplains in central Cambodia and the delta. A huge variety of fishing gear is used, from the most simple traps to kilometers -long fence systems. Catch levels of the capture fisheries in the LMB are estimated to top 2.6 million tons annually with a value exceeding US$ 1.7 billion. In Cambodia fisheries contribute 16% to the GDP. Strong increases in human population are matched by equal increases in fishing effort resulting in catch levels that are probably higher than ever. Major declines in stock sizes of the larger later-in-life spawning species have been witnessed. Catches are now dominated by smaller rapidly reproducing species. Aquaculture is wide spread in the Thai and Viet Namese parts of the LMB; production is estimated at 260,000 t. In addition, 240,000 t are captured in reservoirs.
Article
Full-text available
This is the third compilation of imperiled (i.e., endangered, threatened, vulnerable) plus extinct freshwater and diadromous fishes of North America prepared by the American Fisheries Society's Endangered Species Committee. Since the last revision in 1989, imperilment of inland fishes has increased substantially. This list includes 700 extant taxa representing 133 genera and 36 families, a 92% increase over the 364 listed in 1989. The increase reflects the addition of distinct populations, previously non-imperiled fishes, and recently described or discovered taxa. Approximately 39% of described fish species of the continent are imperiled. There are 230 vulnerable, 190 threatened, and 280 endangered extant taxa, and 61 taxa presumed extinct or extirpated from nature. Of those that were imperiled in 1989, most (89%) are the same or worse in conservation status; only 6% have improved in status, and 5% were delisted for various reasons. Habitat degradation and nonindigenous species are the main threats to at-risk fishes, many of which are restricted to small ranges. Documenting the diversity and status of rare fishes is a critical step in identifying and implementing appropriate actions necessary for their protection and management.
Article
The modern age of species concepts began in 1942, when Ernst Mayr gave concept names to several different approaches to species identification. A long list of species concepts then followed, as well as a complex literature on their merits, motivations and uses. Some of these complexities arose as a consequence of the semantic shift that Mayr introduced, in which procedures for identifying species were elevated to concepts. Much of the debate in recent decades over concepts, and over pluralism versus monism, can be seen as an unnecessary consequence of treating species identification criteria as if they were more fundamental concepts. Recently, biologists have begun to recognize both the shortcomings of a lexicon of multiple species concepts and a common evolutionary idea that underlies them.
Article
Geographical distribution of African freshwater fishes is discussed with emphasis on the effects of major continental features, hydrographic history, and Pleistocene climatic fluctuations. Differences in the modes of dispersal and biological interactions among various categories of fishes, ecological as well as phyletic, have also had marked effects on distribution. The African continent can be divided into ten ichthyofaunal provinces. The geography of these provinces and composition of their fish faunas is briefly described. The paper concludes with a consideration of the faunistic relationships of African lakes with endemic fishes.
Article
Botia kubotai, new species, is distinguished from all other species of the genus by its unique body colour pattern. In juveniles, three black stripes and five black bars leave four pairs of elongate yellow blotches; with increasing age, the bars and stripes widen, the yellow blotches become more slender and rows of small yellow spots are added in the stripes and in the bars. The nomenclature of Botiinae and the systematics of the South and Southeast Asian taxa are discussed. A new genus is named: Chromobotia ( type species: Cobitis macracanthus). Hymenphysa is a synonym of Botia and species usually placed in Hymenphysa should be called Syncrossus.
Article
Wiley, E. O. (Division of Fishes, Museum of Natural History, University of Kansas, Lawrence, KS 66045). 1978. Syst. Zool. 27:17-26.-The concept of species (as taxa) adopted by an investigator will influence his perception of the processes by which species originate. The concept adopted should have as universal applicability as current knowledge permits. Simpson’s definition of a species is modified to state: A species is a lineage of ancestral descendant populations which maintains its identity from other such lineages and which has its own evolutionary tendencies and historical fate. This definition is defended as that which has widest applicability given current knowledge of evolutionary processes. Four corollaries are deduced and discussed relative to other species concepts: (1) all organisms, past and present, belong to some evolutionary species; (2) reproductive isolation must be effective enough to permit maintenance of identity from other contemporary lineages; (3) morphological distinctiveness is not necessary; and (4) no presumed (hypothesized) single lineage may be subdivided into a series of ancestral-descendant “species.” The application of the evolutionary species concept to allopatric demes and to asexual species is discussed and it is concluded that the lack of evolutionary divergence forms the basis for grouping such populations into single species. It is suggested that some ecological species definitions lead to under-estimations of the rate of extinction due to interspecific competition because their logical framework excludes unsuccessful species from being species. Finally, the implications of accepting an evolutionary species concept to the field of phylogeny reconstruction are discussed. [Species concepts; evolution; phylogeny reconstruction.].