Star Trek's mirror universe episodes and US military culture through the eyes of the other

If you want to read the PDF, try requesting it from the authors.


Across the vast Star Trek franchise, a small number of television episodes have used the device of the alternative universe, or "mirror universe," to comment specifically on war and the military. In contrast to the general political stance of the franchise, these episodes provide an embedded dystopian counter-narrative, legitimized by playful diametric reversal, which replaces the benign vision of peaceful exploration and co-existence with one of ruthless imperialist aggression. Conscious of their transgressive impact, these episodes encourage readings against the grain, yet contain such readings by re-absorbing them into the larger discursive paradigm of American military power.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.

... A broad perspective on diplomacy has been applied to Star Trek as 'America in space' (Buzan, 2010) before -including studies of the frontier myth in Star Trek (Kapell, 2016), the show's liberalist underpinnings (Weldes, 1999), and its implicit colonialism (Inayatullah, 2003), interventionism (Lagon, 2011), and militarism (Hantke, 2014). Most explicitly, however, Neumann has analyzed diplomacy in Star Trek -drawing on, explicitly and implicitly, Der Derian's understanding of diplomacy (Neumann, 2001(Neumann, , 2003 According to Neumann, Star Trek reproduces two major U.S. representations of diplomacy that, combined, shape U.S. foreign policy. ...
This chapter will discuss how Discovery either reproduces, criticizes, or subverts established U.S. representations of diplomacy. The results will provide some leads on whether Discovery lives up to Star Trek ’s progressive worldview. Revisiting Iver B. Neumann’s argument, this chapter argues that Discovery ’s pilot episode can be viewed as a critical reflection on how the difference between idealist (“We come in peace”) and realist (a “Vulcan Hello”) approaches to diplomacy become blurred from the inverted perspective of the (Klingon) Other. However, over the further course of the season, Discovery loses its reflexive perspective on the ambiguity of diplomacy and settles for demonstrative idealism. The chapter discusses whether Discovery in its adaptation of a demonstrative ‘idealism’ subverts U.S. representations of diplomacy in the light of paradigmatic shifts after 9/11, or whether it reproduces the ambiguity of ‘realist’/’idealist’ representations, ultimately legitimizing the use of force for supposed higher ends.
Popular Culture is of increasing interest for the discipline of Political Science/International Relations. This article traces how the science fiction series Star Trek reviews contemporary US zeitgeist and US foreign policy through a utopian lense in the last 50 years. While the franchise reboot of 2009 has been heavily criticised by the loyal Star Trek fandom for neglecting its utopian heritage, the reboot movie INTO DARKNESS remedies this judgement. It criticis-es US foreign policy associated with the Global War on Terrorism (GWoT). Furthermore, INTO DARKNESS provides a fictional example of the perils and pitfalls of a society going into war against terrorism itself and how this jeopardises its liberal foundation and utopian ideal.
Currently, there is no structured data standard for representing elements commonly found in transmedia fictional worlds. Although there are websites dedicated to individual universes, the information found on these sites separate out the various formats, concentrate on only the bibliographic aspects of the material, and are only searchable with full text. We have created an ontological model that will allow various user groups interested in transmedia to search for and retrieve the information contained in these worlds based upon their structure. We conducted a domain analysis and user studies based on the contents of Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings, the Marvel Universe, and Star Wars in order to build a new model using Ontology Web Language (OWL) and an artificial intelligence-reasoning engine. This model can infer connections between transmedia properties such as characters, elements of power, items, places, events, and so on. This model will facilitate better search and retrieval of the information contained within these vast story universes for all users interested in them. The result of this project is an OWL ontology reflecting real user needs based upon user research, which is intuitive for users and can be used by artificial intelligence systems.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.