Under the uncertain scenario of water availability for irrigation, plants are often exposed to drought periods, which can negatively impact their vegetative growth and yield potential. To address this issue, various soil amendments including inorganic, organic, and biological treatments, have been investigated as solutions for mitigating water stress. However, comparative studies of different amendments are lacking. The aim of this study was to assess the efficacy of various soil amendments for alleviating drought stress in avocado trees over two seasons. The study was conducted in a young avocado orchard with sandy loam soil. Different soil amendments, such as zeolite, absorbent biopolymers, mycorrhizae, Ascophyllum nodosum extract, humic acids, and diazotrophic bacteria, were applied either at planting or through fertigation. These treatments were compared to controls with and without water restriction. The water supply was interrupted throughout the growing seasons, and the accumulated water stress during the drought was evaluated. Two and three water restriction were imposed during the first and second season, respectively, on critical phenological stages. Additionally, physical soil properties, vegetative growth, and yield components were assessed. The treatments with the greatest alleviation of water stress were those in which A. nodosum seaweed extract was incorporated, followed by those with humic acid and mycorrhizae. These treatments enhanced soil water retention and stimulated root growth and/or mycorrhization, resulting in a greater volume of soil exploration. Conversely, biopolymer treatment increased water retention but did not increase water availability at the required tension levels for plant extraction, resulting in increased stress. Similarly, although zeolite improved certain soil properties, it did not increase water availability for plants, not alleviating the water stress levels. Moreover, the application of diazotrophic bacteria did not yield beneficial effects on soil or plant health and was ineffective at mitigating water stress in avocado trees. In conclusion, soil amendments that effectively maintain or reduce bulk density, improved soil stability and water availability demonstrated good crop performance even under drought conditions. However, the mitigation of water stress is a complex process influenced by various factors, including root growth, mycorrhization, and other physiological responses.