This study examines the relative predictive power of ARIMA, VAR and ECM models in forecasting inflation in Nigeria. In doing this, a domestic Consumer Price Index(CPI) was lumped into headline(All Item). This is because decomposing Consumer Price Index will generate difficult task for monetary authority, since different factors determine inflation(CPI) under different types of CPI. Annual data that spanned from 1970-2010 were used. Comparatively, the study examines the performance of the forecasting ability of the models, and how well the simulated series track the actual data. In doing this, historical simulation of the models were carried out. Thus, it was observed that, different models performed well in different periods. While ARIMA is good as a benchmark model, VAR for short term forecasting and ECM is suitable for long run forecasting. The study shows that significant relationship exist between domestic CPI and exchange rate, US-CPI(foreign price) and government expenditure in predicting inflation movements in Nigeria. Hence, in transiting into inflation targeting framework by CBN, these variables must be critically monitored, examined and put into consideration before resorting to any policy option.