No full-text available
To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.
Crystal dehydration technique
Abstract
X-ray crystallography is the most common technique used to understand the structure-function relationship of macromolecules. Although, with the enormous advancement of technology, this technique has proven to be very successful at elucidating macromolecular structures, obtaining a well diffracting crystal remains still a major hurdle. In particular, crystals with high solvent content tend to diffract poorly. Crystal dehydration is one of the most frequently used treatments to improve diffraction quality. In addition to improving the diffraction quality of a crystal, dehydration can yield functional insights where dehydration causes conformational changes in the protein structure. Crystals can be dehydrated in a controlled manner either by changing the relative humidity or by assisted dehydration by adding dehydrating agents. Here we provide a description of a dehydration method, examples of its application in general and its specific application to improving the diffraction quality of Saccharomyces cerevisiae ribonucleotide reductase crystals.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
The first neutron fibre diffraction studies of an amyloid system are presented. The techniques used to prepare the large samples needed are described, as well as the procedures used to isotopically replace H2O in the sample by D2O. The results demonstrate the feasibility of this type of approach for the pursuit of novel structural analyses that will strongly complement X-ray fibre diffraction studies and probe aspects of amyloid structure that to date have remained obscure. The approach is demonstrated using an amyloid form of the peptide NSGAITIG, but is equally applicable for the study of other systems such as Alzheimer's Aβ peptide.
Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb), a dreaded pathogen, has a unique cell envelope composed of high fatty acid content that plays a crucial role in its pathogenesis. Acetyl Coenzyme A Carboxylase (ACC), an important enzyme that catalyzes the first reaction of fatty acid biosynthesis, is biotinylated by biotin acetyl-CoA carboxylase ligase (BirA). The ligand-binding loops in all known apo BirAs to date are disordered and attain an ordered structure only after undergoing a conformational change upon ligand-binding. Here, we report that dehydration of Mtb-BirA crystals traps both the apo and active conformations in its asymmetric unit, and for the first time provides structural evidence of such transformation. Recombinant Mtb-BirA was crystallized at room temperature, and diffraction data was collected at 295 K as well as at 120 K. Transfer of crystals to paraffin and paratone-N oil (cryoprotectants) prior to flash-freezing induced lattice shrinkage and enhancement in the resolution of the X-ray diffraction data. Intriguingly, the crystal lattice rearrangement due to shrinkage in the dehydrated Mtb-BirA crystals ensued structural order of otherwise flexible ligand-binding loops L4 and L8 in apo BirA. In addition, crystal dehydration resulted in a shift of approximately 3.5 A in the flexible loop L6, a proline-rich loop unique to Mtb complex as well as around the L11 region. The shift in loop L11 in the C-terminal domain on dehydration emulates the action responsible for the complex formation with its protein ligand biotin carboxyl carrier protein (BCCP) domain of ACCA3. This is contrary to the involvement of loop L14 observed in Pyrococcus horikoshii BirA-BCCP complex. Another interesting feature that emerges from this dehydrated structure is that the two subunits A and B, though related by a noncrystallographic twofold symmetry, assemble into an asymmetric dimer representing the ligand-bound and ligand-free states of the protein, respectively. In-depth analyses of the sequence and the structure also provide answers to the reported lower affinities of Mtb-BirA toward ATP and biotin substrates. This dehydrated crystal structure not only provides key leads to the understanding of the structure/function relationships in the protein in the absence of any ligand-bound structure, but also demonstrates the merit of dehydration of crystals as an inimitable technique to have a glance at proteins in action.
Intercellular signalling is an essential characteristic of multicellular organisms. Gap junctions, which consist of arrays of intercellular channels, permit the exchange of ions and small molecules between adjacent cells. Here, the structural determination of a gap junction channel composed of connexin 26 (Cx26) at 3.5 Å resolution is described. During each step of the purification process, the protein was examined using electron microscopy and/or dynamic light scattering. Dehydration of the crystals improved the resolution limits. Phase refinement using multi-crystal averaging in conjunction with noncrystallographic symmetry averaging based on strictly determined noncrystallographic symmetry operators resulted in an electron-density map for model building. The amino-acid sequence of a protomer structure consisting of the amino-terminal helix, four transmembrane helices and two extracellular loops was assigned to the electron-density map. The amino-acid assignment was confirmed using six selenomethionine (SeMet) sites in the difference Fourier map of the SeMet derivative and three intramolecular disulfide bonds in the anomalous difference Fourier map of the native crystal.
A significant improvement in the X-ray resolution of crystals of Escherichia coli inorganic pyrophosphatase at cryotemperature was obtained as a result of studying the relationship between the crystal order and cryosolution component concentrations. To perform the experiments, the ability to reverse the flash-cooling process and to return a crystal to ambient temperature was used. In each cycle, the crystal was transferred from a cold nitrogen-gas stream to a cryosolution with modified concentrations of the components. The crystal was then flash-cooled again and the diffraction quality checked. Such a technique allows the screening of a wide concentration range rather quickly without using a large number of crystals and allows the determination of optimal cryosolution component concentrations. The resolution limit for crystals of pyrophosphatase increased by almost 0.7 Å, from 1.8 to 1.15 Å.
High-salt crystals of human oxy- and deoxyhaemoglobin have been studied at different levels of environmental humidity and solvent content. The structure of the oxy form remains relatively unchanged at all levels. The deoxy form, however, undergoes a water-mediated transformation when the relative humidity around the crystals is reduced below 93%. The space group is maintained during the transformation, but the unit-cell volume nearly doubles, with two tetrameric molecules in the asymmetric unit of the low-humidity form compared with one in the native crystals. Interestingly, the haem geometry in the low-humidity form is closer to that in the oxy form than to that in the native deoxy form. The quaternary structure of one of the tetramers moves slightly towards that in the oxy form, while that in the other is more different from the oxy form than that in the high-salt native deoxy form. Thus, it would appear that, as in the case of the liganded form, the deoxy form of haemoglobin can also access an ensemble of related T states.
Succeeding in getting a protein to crystallize is not always the final hurdle in the determination of its three-dimensional structure. A relatively frequent and particularly vexing situation is the production of macroscopically well formed crystals that exhibit no suitable diffraction pattern. In this paper, three independent cases (i.e. proteins and crystallization conditions) are reported of spectacular diffraction-pattern improvement through a simple crystal-handling procedure that was discovered serendipitously. The procedure basically consists of removing a non-diffracting frozen crystal from the X-ray beam, plunging it into a soaking solution made of the original crystallization solution supplemented with a traditional cryoprotectant and then letting it dry in the evaporating sitting drop for some time (15 min to several hours). The treated crystals are then remounted and exhibit a huge improvement in their diffraction intensity and resolution. In all three cases presented here, the crystal quality shifted from unusable to perfectly suitable for structure determination. In addition to being a ‘last resort’ procedure for experimentalists struggling with non-diffracting crystals, this puzzling effect constitutes one more challenging problem for theoretical protein crystallographers.
The crystal structures of 88 and 79% relative humidity forms of ribonuclease A, resulting from water-mediated transformations, have been refined employing the restrained least-squares method using X-ray data collected on an area detector to R = 0.173 for 15 326 observed reflections in the 10-1.5 A resolution shell and R = 0.176 for 8534 observed reflections in the 10-1.8 A shell, respectively. The comparison of these structures with those of the native, the phosphate-bound and the sulfate-bound forms demonstrates that the mobility of the ribonuclease A molecule involves hinge-bending movement of the two domains and local flexibility within them, particularly at the termini of regular secondary structures and in loops. The comparison also leads to the identification of 31 invariant water molecules in the hydration shell of the enzyme, many of which are involved in holding different parts of the molecule together and in stabilizing local structure. The conformational changes that accompany the partial removal of the surrounding water, particularly those observed in the 79% form, could be similar to those that occur during enzyme action.
Orthorhombic crystals of bovine F1-ATPase have been subjected to controlled dehydration. A decrease in the relative humidity surrounding the crystals to 90% reproducibly reduced their unit-cell volume by 22% (950 000 ų) and improved the diffraction limit and mosaic spread of the crystals significantly. These dehydrated crystals diffracted X-rays to 1.8 Å resolution at a synchrotron source, the best diffraction limit yet attained with these crystals, although radiation damage limited the resolution of a complete data set to 1.95 Å.
The crystal structure of high-salt horse methaemoglobin has been determined at environmental relative humidities (r.h.) of 88, 79, 75 and 66%. The molecule is in the R state in the native and the r.h. 88% crystals. At r.h. 79%, the water content of the crystal is reduced and the molecule appears to move towards the R2 state. The crystals undergo a water-mediated transformation involving a doubling of one of the unit-cell parameters and an increase in water content when the environmental humidity is further reduced to r.h. 75%. The water content is now similar to that in the native crystals and the molecules are in the R state. The crystal structure at r.h. 66% is similar, but not identical, to that at r.h. 75%, but the solvent content is substantially reduced and the molecules have a quaternary structure that is in between those corresponding to the R and R2 states. Thus, variation in hydration leads to variation in the quaternary structure. Furthermore, partial dehydration appears to shift the structure from the R state to the R2 state. This observation is in agreement with the earlier conclusion that the changes in protein structure that accompany partial dehydration are similar to those that occur during protein action.
There has been considerable interest in the variability of the structure of the liganded haemoglobin after characterization of the R2 state in addition to the original relaxed R state. The structures of three crystallographically independent relaxed haemoglobin molecules have been determined through the X-ray structure analysis of the crystals of human methaemoglobin. The three molecules have quaternary structures intermediate between those of the R and R2 structures. The same is true about the disposition of residues in the 'switch' region. Thus it would appear that haemoglobin can access different relaxed states with varying degrees of similarity among them.
Macromolecular crystals commonly suffer rapid radiation damage during room temperature X-ray data collection. Therefore, data are now routinely collected with the sample held at around 100K, significantly reducing secondary radiation damage, and usually resulting in higher resolution and better quality data. At synchrotron sources, the frequent observation of radiation damage even at cryotemperatures has prompted the development of exciting new experiments aimed at characterising and reducing this damage, and using it for structure determination and enzymatic studies. Current research into cryotechniques seeks to understand the basic physical and chemical processes involved in flash-cooling and radiation damage, which should eventually enable the rational optimisation of cryoprotocols.
The binding sites in hen egg-white lysozyme for neutral bromophenol red (BPR) and ionized bromophenol blue (BPB) have been
characterized at 2 Å resolution. In either case, the dye-bound enzyme is active against the polysaccharide, but not against
the cell wall. Both binding sites are outside, but close to, the hexasaccharide binding cleft in the enzyme. The binding site
of BPR made up of Arg5, Lys33, Phe34, Asn37, Phe38, Ala122, Trp123 and possibly Arg125, is dose to subsite F while that of
BPB made up of Tyr20, Arg21, Asn93, Lys96, Lys97 and Ser100, is close to subsites A and B. The binding sites of the neutral
dye and the ionized dye are thus spatially far apart. The peptide component of the bacterial cell wall probably interacts
with these cells during enzyme action. Such interactions are perhaps necessary for appropriately positioning the enzyme molecule
on the bacterial cell wall.
Earlier studies involving water-mediated transformations in lysozyme and ribonuclease A have shown that the overall movements in the protein molecule consequent to the reduction in the amount of surrounding water are similar to those that occur during enzyme action, thus highlighting the relationship among hydration, plasticity, and action of these enzymes. Monoclinic lysozyme retains its crystallinity even when the level of hydration is reduced further below that necessary for activity (about 0.2 gram of water per gram of protein). In order to gain insights into the role of water in the stability and the plasticity of the protein molecule and the geometrical basis for the loss of activity that accompanies dehydration, the crystal structures of monoclinic lysozyme with solvent contents of 17.6%, 16.9%, and 9.4% were determined and refined. A detailed comparison of these forms with the normally hydrated forms show that the C-terminal segment (residues 88-129) of domain I and the main loop (residues 65-73) in domain II exhibit large deviations in atomic positions when the solvent content is reduced, although the three-dimensional structure is essentially preserved. Many crucial water bridges between different regions of the molecule are conserved in spite of differences in detail, even when the level of hydration is reduced well below that required for activity. The loss of activity that accompany dehydration appears to be caused by the removal of functionally important water molecules from the active-site region and the reduction in the size of the substrate binding cleft.
A flash-annealing method has been developed that increases the diffraction limits, and simultaneously decreases the mosaicity of glycerol kinase crystals. This technique utilizes brief thawing and rapid freezing cycles of the crystal in the cold nitrogen stream. The effective resolution limits increased almost by 0.8 A, from 3.6 to 2.8 A, and mosaicity values halved.
The structures of orthorhombic lysozyme grown at basic pH and its low-humidity variant have been solved and refined at 1.9 and 2.0 A resolution, respectively. A comparison of the native structure with those of crystals grown at acidic pH does not show any systematic pH-dependent difference in the molecular geometry. The conformations, mutual orientation and interactions of the catalytic residues Glu35 and Asp52 also remain unchanged. However, comparison between the native and low-humidity forms in the orthorhombic form show that the changes in molecular geometry which accompany the water-mediated transformation to the low-humidity form are more pronounced in the C-terminal residues than in the other regions of the molecule. During the transformation from the native to the low-humidity form, the locations of only about half the water molecules in the hydration shell remain unchanged, but the hydration shell as a whole moves along with the protein molecule.
Reduction of NDPs by murine ribonucleotide reductase (mRR) requires catalytic (mR1) and free radical-containing (mR2) subunits and is regulated by nucleoside triphosphate allosteric effectors. Here we present a new, comprehensive, and quantitative model for allosteric control of mRR enzymatic activity based on molecular mass, ligand binding, and enzyme activity studies. In this model, nucleotide binding to the specificity site (s-site) drives formation of an active R1(2)R2(2) dimer, ATP or dATP binding to the adenine-specific site (a-site) results in formation of an inactive tetramer, and ATP binding to the newly described hexamerization site (h-site) drives formation of active R1(6)R2(6) hexamer. In contrast, an earlier phenomenological model [Thelander, L., and Reichard, P. (1979) Annu. Rev. Biochem. 67, 71-98] (the "RT" model) ignores aggregation state changes and mistakenly rationalizes ATP activation versus dATP inhibition as reflecting different functional consequences of ATP versus dATP binding to the a-site. Our results suggest that the R1(6)R2(6) heterohexamer is the major active form of the enzyme in mammalian cells, and that the ATP concentration is the primary modulator of enzyme activity, coupling the rate of DNA biosynthesis with the energetic state of the cell. Using the crystal structure of the Escherichia coliR1 hexamer as a model for the mR1 hexamer, a scheme is presented that rationalizes the slow isomerization of the tetramer form and suggests an explanation for the low enzymatic activity of tetramers complexed with R2. The similar specific activities of R1(2)R2(2) and R1(6)R2(6) are inconsistent with a proposed model for R2(2) docking with R1(2) [Uhlin, U., and Eklund, H. (1994) Nature 370, 533-539], and an alternative is suggested.
Diffraction quality crystals are essential for crystallographic studies of protein structure, and the production of poorly diffracting crystals is often regarded as a dead end in the process. Here we show a dramatic improvement of poorly diffracting DsbG crystals allowing high-resolution diffraction data measurement. Before dehydration, the crystals are fragile and the diffraction pattern is streaky, extending to 10 A resolution. After dehydration, there is a spectacular improvement, with the diffraction pattern extending to 2 A resolution. This and other recent results show that dehydration is a simple, rapid, and inexpensive approach to convert poor quality crystals into diffraction quality crystals.
It is notoriously difficult to produce crystals of membrane proteins that diffract to sufficient resolution for structural studies by X-ray crystallography. Crystals of a prokaryotic CLC chloride channel that were initially unacceptable for structural analysis improved in both quality and diffraction limit by a process of dehydration. The loss of water decreased the dimensions of the unit cell axes by up to 25 A, improved the diffraction limit from 8.0 to 4.0 A, and decreased the mosaicity to values of approximately 1 degrees. Dehydration of integral membrane protein crystals should be one of the procedures included in the initial screening for appropriate crystals and as a method of improving the diffraction limits of existing crystals.
The diffraction resolution of crystals of the guanine nucleotide-exchange factor complex, EF-Tu-Ts, has been extended from 5.0 to 2.5 A by lowering the solvent content in the crystals as well as the temperature of data collection. The common form of EF-Tu-Ts crystal belongs to space group P2(1)2(1)2(1) with a = 81.1, b = 109.9, c = 207.5 A and has a solvent content of 61%. The crystals diffract to a resolution of 5.0 A at 293 K and 4.0 A at 273 K. When cryoprotective agents are slowly diffused into the crystals, the cell constants shrink to a = 74.4, b = 109.9, c = 198.7 A and the solvent content falls to 55%. After the cryoprotective agent has been added, the crystals diffract to 2.7 A resolution at 293 or 273 K and 2.5 A at 250 K. X-ray diffraction data, collected before and after the transformation of individual EF-Tu-Ts crystals, demonstrate that a large percentage of the improvement in diffraction resolution is due solely to the addition of cryoprotective agents. The transfer procedures for the successful introduction of cryoprotective agents into EF-Tu-Ts crystals as well as the general applicability to other crystal systems will be discussed.
The atomic models of native monoclinic lysozyme obtained by refinement at Bangalore and elsewhere [Young, Dewan, Nave & Tilton (1993). J. Appl. Cryst. 26, 309-319] differed significantly in the flexible regions of the protein molecule. The two models were reconciled starting from regions where they were in reasonable agreement to produce an improved model which yielded an R value of 0.169 for 12 816 observed reflections in the 10-2 A resolution range. The reconciled model was compared with the structure of the 88% relative humidity form obtained through a water-mediated transformation [Madhusudan, Kodandapani & Vijayan (1993). Acta Cryst. D49, 234-245]. Parts of the flexible regions of the molecule register significant movements during the transformation. The changes resulting from the transformation from the native to the low-humidity forms are pronounced in many of the side chains in the active-site region, thus indicating the relationship between hydration, mobility and enzyme action. The fact that the overall changes in molecular geometry resulting from water-mediated transformation are similar to those which occur during enzyme action, further emphasizes this relationship.
Mycobacterium smegmatis RecA and its nucleotide complexes crystallize in three different, but closely related, forms characterized by specific ranges of unit cell dimensions. The six crystals reported here and five reported earlier, all grown under the same or very similar conditions, belong to these three forms, all in space group P6(1). They include one obtained by reducing relative humidity around the crystal. In all crystals, RecA monomers form filaments around a 6(1) screw axis. Thus, the c-dimension of the crystal corresponds to the pitch of the RecA filament. As reported for Escherichia coli RecA, the variation in the pitch among the three forms correlates well with the motion of the C-terminal domain of the RecA monomers with respect to the main domain. The domain motion is compatible with formation of inactive as well as active RecA filaments involving monomers with a fully ordered C domain. It does not appear to influence the movement upon nucleotide-binding of the switch residue, which is believed to provide the trigger for transmitting the effect of nucleotide binding to the DNA-binding region. Interestingly, partial dehydration of the crystal results in the movement of the residue similar to that caused by nucleotide binding. The ordering of the DNA-binding loops, which present ensembles of conformations, is also unaffected by domain motion. The conformation of loop L2 appears to depend upon nucleotide binding, presumably on account of the movement of the switch residue that forms part of the loop. The conformations of loops L1 and L2 are correlated and have implications for intermolecular communications within the RecA filament. The structures resulting from different orientations of the C domain and different conformations of the DNA-binding loops appear to represent snapshots of the RecA at different phases of activity, and provide insights into the mechanism of action of RecA.
Dimeric lactoglobulin molecules exist in the open conformation at basic pH, whereas they exist in the closed conformation at acidic pH, after undergoing the Tanford transition around neutral pH. Orthorhombic crystals consisting of molecules in the open conformation, grown close to neutral pH, undergo a water-mediated transformation when the relative humidity around the crystals is reduced. The two subunits in the dimer are related by a crystallographic twofold axis in the native crystals while the dimer is asymmetric in the low humidity form. Interestingly, one of the subunits in the dimer in the low humidity form is in an open conformation while the other is in a closed conformation. This is the first observation of such an asymmetric dimer. A hydrogen bond between the side chains of Gln35 and Tyr42 exists and the side chain of Glu89 is substantially buried in the closed subunit of the asymmetric unit, as in other structures with molecules in the closed conformation. However, the closure of the EF loop is not complete; its conformation can be described as half-closed. A comparison of different crystal structures of beta-lactoglobulin indicates that the conformation of the loops in the molecule is substantially influenced by other factors such as crystal packing, the pH, and the composition of the medium, while the change in the conformation of the EF loop follows the Tanford transition. The mutual disposition of the two subunits in the low humidity form is halfway between those in the open and closed structures. The present work further demonstrates that structural changes that occur during partial dehydration could mimic those that occur during the action of proteins.