Content uploaded by Florentina (Radoi) Matei
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Florentina (Radoi) Matei on May 03, 2016
Content may be subject to copyright.
Romanian Biotechnological Letters Vol. 19, No. 5,2014
Copyright © 2014 University of Bucharest Printed in Romania. All rights reserved
ORIGINAL PAPER
Romanian Biotechnological Letters, Vol. 19, No. 5, 2014 9699
Studies on antimicrobial activity of Inula helenium L Romanian cultivar
Received for publication, July 21, 2014
Accepted, September 22, 2014
DIGUȚĂ,C.1,2, CORNEA C.P.2, IONIȚĂ L.3, BRÎNDUȘE, E.4, FARCAȘ, N.5,
BOBIT D.6, MATEI F.1,2*
1 CBM BIOTEHGEN, 59 Mărăști Bld., Bucharest 011464, Romania
2 UASMV Bucharest, Faculty of Biotechnologies, 59, Mărăști Bld., 011464,
Bucharest 1, Romania
3 UASMV Bucharest, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, 105, Splaiul Independenței
050097, Bucharest 5, Romania
4 ICDVV Valea Călugărească, Prahova, Romania
5 UASMV Bucharest, Faculty of Agriculture, 59, Mărăști Bld., 011464, Bucharest 1,
Romania
6 SC DACIA PLANT SRL, Hărmanului fn, Brasov, Romania
*corresponding author: florentina.matei@biotehnologii.usamv.ro
Abstract
This study was carried out to evaluate the in vitro antimicrobial activities of dried roots of a
Romanian indigenous population of Inula helenium L. The powdered dried root of the plant was
extracted in ethanol (using 30%, 50% and 70% v/v). The antimicrobial activity has been tested on
five potential pathogenic bacterial species (Bacillus subtilis, Bacillus cereus, Enterococcus faecalis,
Escherichia coli, Staphylococcus aureus) and four fungal species (Candida albicans, C.
parapsilosis, C. lipolytica and Aspergillus niger), all of veterinary interest. Antimicrobial activity
was investigated by the drop-diffusion test method, measuring the inhibition zones. The preliminary
results of our study indicated that ethanolic extracts (50% and 70%) from the roots of a Romanian
cultivar of I. helenium L. showed significant antimicrobial activity against all tested
microorganisms, except the pathogenic philamentous fungi A. niger. On the dermatophytic species
(Candida sp.) the inhibitory effects of 50% and 70% extracts are very similar. Further investigation
will be done to determine the minimal inhibitory concentrations for each susceptible
microorganism. As final goal is the design of a new veterinary product with antimicrobial effects.
Keywords: in vitro, Inula helenium, ethanolic extracts, antibacterial, antifungal
1. Introduction
Since the beginning of the twentieth century, the discovery and development of antibiotics
revolutionized human and veterinary medicine. However, due to excessive use of antibiotics
to treat the infectious diseases, many microorganisms developed several mechanisms to resist
conventional antibiotics, creating serious problems worldwide. For this reason, many research
have been directed towards finding alternatives such as new antimicrobial compounds from
natural sources in order to achieve the effective treatment. Since ancient times, medicinal and
aromatic plants, or spices have been used as food and feed additives, food supplements and
medicinal value. More recently, much attention has been paid to investigate weed plants as
sources of new bioactive compounds. The presence of antimicrobial and other biological
activities have been already demonstrated in extracts of Eupatorium spp. (L.-L. JI & al. [1];
N. ARVIND and S. AMIT [2]), Helleborus spp. (S. PUGLISI & al. [3]), Inula spp. (T.
KONISHI & al. [4]; A. STOJAKOWSKA & al. [5, 6, 7]; P.D. LOKHANDE & al. [8]; A.
DERIU & al. [9]; Z. STOJANOVIĆ-RADIĆ & al. [10]; H. YAN & al. [11]).
DIGUȚĂ,C., CORNEA C.P., IONIȚĂ L., BRÎNDUȘE, E., FARCAȘ, N., BOBIT D., MATEI F.
9700 Romanian Biotechnological Letters, Vol. 19, No. 5, 2014
The genus Inula (Asteraceae; tribe Inuleae) consists of approximately 100 species mainly
distributed in Europe, Africa and Asia. Recently, several species (Inula britannica L., I.
ensifolia I. helenium L, I. racemosa L., and I. viscosa L.) have been investigated for their
pharmacological benefit including antioxidant and anti-inflammatory activities,
hepatoprotective characteristics, cytotoxicity, and antimicrobial properties (Y.M. ZHAO &
al. [12]; W. H. TALIB & al. [13]; S. AMIN & al. [14]).
Among these species, Inula helenium L. also known as elecampane is a perennial herbaceous
plant, with tuberous, thick roots. Chemical analysis of the rhizome and roots showed that I.
helenium contains many bioactive compounds including polysaccharide inulin (up to 44%),
essential oil with eudesmane –type (up to 5%), sesquiterpene lactones (mainly alantolactone
and isoalantolactone), thymol derivatives, terpenes, and sterols (T. KONISHI & al. [4]; A.
STOJAKOWSKA & al. [5, 6]; A. DERIU & al. [9]; Z. STOJANOVIĆ-RADIĆ & al. [10]; H.
YAN & al. [11]; J. WANG & al. [15]). It is known that a number of these compounds are
responsible for its anti-inflammatory, anti-microbial and anti-helminthic properties.
Sesquiterpene lactones (Z. STOJANOVIĆ-RADIĆ & al. [10]) and thymol derivatives (A.
STOJAKOWSKA & al. [5, 6]) from elecampane have been demonstrated to be main
antimicrobial agents in the roots.
There are few reports concerning the antimicrobial activity of others members of the Inula
spp. against several microorganisms, including bacteria and fungi. P.D. LOKHANDE & al.
[8] reported that alantolactone isolated from root of the plant I. racemosa have been shown
maximum antibacterial activity as compared to other constituents and ethyl acetate extract of
the roots. Y.M. ZHAO & al. [12] isolated and identified five thymol derivatives from the
roots of I. hupehensis. One of these compounds was the most active, not only displaying
moderate antibacterial activities against S.aureus, Methicillin-resistant S. aureus and E. coli,
but also exhibiting inhibitory activities against three plant pathogenic fungi: Rhizoctonia
solani, Phytophthora melonis and P. litchi, and its content accounted for 0.033% of the roots
of I. hupehensis (Y.M. ZHAO & al. [12]). W. H. TALIB & al. [13] investigated the
antiproliferative and antimicrobial effects of thirteen compounds isolated from Inula viscosa
L. and demonstrated that two flavonoids (3-O-methylquercetin and 3,3′-di-O-
methylquercetin) inhibit Salmonella typhimurium (at MIC of 125 μg/mL) and Bacillus cereus
(at MIC of 125 μg/mL and 62.5 μg/mL, respectively).
In the present study, we have proceeded to a qualitative screening regarding the antimicrobial
activity of a Romanian cultivar of Inula helenium L root alcoholic extracts, in order to future
use of this plant as a source of new antimicrobial products for veterinary use. In Romania,
Inula helenium grows on plane and hills area, very close to the villages and it has been used as
old medicinal plant. As a general remark, it has been noticed that Romanian indigenous Inula
plants are shorter than the other Southern European cultivars
2. Materials and methods
Collection of plant material
Dried roots from a Romanian cultivar of Inula heleniumL. have been harvested from the
experimental field of Dacia Plant S.A., Bod, Romania. The plants have been cultivated under
certified ecological conditions. The cultivar has been introduced in the collection from a local
Inula population growing in South-Eastern side of Romania (Brăila) in a plane area.
Herbarium specimen was preserved at the manufacturer.
Preparation of plant extracts
Roots of Inula heleniumL. have been dried and chopped in small pieces of 0.2-1 cm and
extracted in ethanol with different concentrations: 30%v/v (I30o), 50% v/v (I50o) and 70%v/v
Studies on antimicrobial activity of Inula helenium L Romanian cultivar
Romanian Biotechnological Letters, Vol. 19, No. 5, 2014 9701
(I70
o
). After preliminary tests (data not shown) the optimal extraction time in hydro-alcoholic
solutions has been established at 6 hours at room temperature.
Test microorganisms
The Inula extracts have been tested on six potential pathogen bacterial strains and four fungal
strains which can affect the animals (Table 1).
Table 1 - Microorganisms tested for their susceptibility to Inula helenium alcoholic extracts
No. Strain Characteristics Origin
1. Bacillus subtilis ICCF 276 Gram-positive, catalase-positive Collection ICCF, Bucharest,
Romania
2. Bacillus cereus CP1 Gram-positive, beta hemolytic
bacterium
Collection of Faculty of
Biotechnologies, Bucharest,
Romania
3. Escherichia coli MI 57 Gram-negative, non-toxinogenic
serotype
Collection of Faculty of
Biotechnologies, Bucharest,
Romania
4. Escherichia coli CP2 Gram-negative, toxinogenic
serotype
Collection of Faculty of
Biotechnologies, Bucharest,
Romania
5. Staphylococcus aureus CP 3 Gram-positive, catalase-positive Collection of Faculty of
Biotechnologies, Bucharest,
Romania
6. Enterococcus faecalis CP 4 Gram-positive, sensible to β-
lactam-based antibiotics
Collection of Faculty of
Biotechnologies, Bucharest,
Romania
7. Candida albicans
ATCC10231
Serotype A, sensible to nystatin Collection of Microbial Genetics
and Biotechnology, Faculty of
Biology, Bucharest, Romania
8. Candida parapsilosis
CBS604
Sensible to amphotericin B,
nystatine, essential oils of
Coriander sativum
Collection of Microbial Genetics
and Biotechnology, Faculty of
Biology, Bucharest, Romania
9. Candida lypolytica MI 2 non-conventional yeast, lipase
production
Collection of Faculty of
Biotechnologies, Bucharest,
Romania
10. Aspergillus niger F2T Responsible for pulmonary
infections in dogs
Collection CBM Biotehgen
Bucharest, Romania
The bacterial strains were maintained and tested on nutrient agar (0.5% peptone; 0.3% yeast
extract; 1.5% agar; 0.5% NaCl) at 37
o
C, using 24 hours old inoculums. Yeasts and fungal
strains were maintained and tested on Yeast Extract Glucose Agar (1% yeast extract; 2%
peptone; 2% glucose; 2% agar) at 30
o
C, using 24 hours old inoculums for yeasts or mycelium
block (5 mm) for filamentous fungi.
Antimicrobial Analysis
In vitro, the antimicrobial activity was assessed by the "drop agar
diffusion" method (fig.1). The microorganisms were spread using
100μl of suspension containing 10
8
CFU/ml on nutrient agar or on
Yeast Extract Glucose Agar respectively.
Fig.1 - Aspects from the "drop agar diffusion" screening method
Concerning A. niger F2T, the mycelium block (5 mm) was placed in
DIGUȚĂ,C., CORNEA C.P., IONIȚĂ L., BRÎNDUȘE, E., FARCAȘ, N., BOBIT D., MATEI F.
9702 Romanian Biotechnological Letters, Vol. 19, No. 5, 2014
the centre of the medium in Petri dishes. After 1 hour, 10 μL of each sterile extract have been
added in the agar plates pre- inoculated with the tested microorganisms. Non diluted
ampicillin (for bacteria) and fluconazole (for fungi) have been used as positive control and the
Inula extracts solvent (hydro ethanolic solutions of 30%, 50% and 70%) have been used in the
master plates. All plates were incubated according to the itemed test microorganisms. The
diameter of growth inhibition zones (halos) was measured in millimetres on two axes and the
mean value reported. The results are the mean of two separate experiments with three
repetitions for each sample.
3. Results and discussion
On international levels main reports on antimicrobial activity of Inula sp. are linked to
extracts made of other species that Inula hellenium, like Inula racemosa (P.D. LOKHANDE
& al. [8]), Inula hupehensis (J. ZHAO & al [16]) or Inula viscosa (W. H. TALIB & al. [13]).
The present study was conducted on ethanol extracts (30%, 50%, 70%) from dried roots of a
Romanian cultivar of Inula helenium L. Antimicrobial activity was determined by drop agar
diffusion method, measuring the diameter of zone of inhibition. All the measurements have
been done in triplicate. As control, solutions of ethanol of same concentrations as the plant
extracts have been used. As general remark, the results indicated that the antimicrobial
activity increases while increasing the solvent concentration from 30% to 50%, while from
50% to 70% concentration no significant activity increase has been noticed (tables 2 and 3)
comparing to the control.
Fig.2 - Inula’ s extract
antimicrobial activity on
non-toxinogenic serotype
Escherichia coli MI 57 (a-
I30, b- I50, c- I70).
Against the bacterial strains, the ethanol extracts (I50˚ and I70˚) exhibited moderate to high
inhibitory activity, while the ethanol extract I30˚ proved not significant inhibitory activity
only on non-toxinogenic serotype Escherichia coli MI 57 (fig. 2, table 2), close to the control.
Table 2- Antibacterial activity of dried root extracts from I. helenium L.
Legend:
-: non inhibitory halo
+: low inhibitory activity
++: moderate inhibitory
activity
+++: high inhibitory activity
The susceptibility of the fungal strains inhibition is shown in Table 3. Ethanol extract (I50˚)
showed moderate antifungal activity against Candida albicans and good activity against
C.parapsilosis and C. lipolytica. No antifungal activity was found against A. niger (table 3). It
has been noticed that on the testes yeast (Candida spp.) the inhibitory effects of I50˚ and I70˚
are very similar.
Test bacteria
Inhibitory effect
Extract I30˚ Extract I50˚ Extract I70˚
Escherichia coli MI 57 + + + + + +
Escherichia coli CP2 - + + +
Bacillus spp. ICFF 276 - + + + +
Bacillus cereus CP1 - + + + +
Staphylococcus aureus CP3 - + + +
Enterococcus faecalis CP4 - + + + +
Studies on antimicrobial activity of Inula helenium L Romanian cultivar
Romanian Biotechnological Letters, Vol. 19, No. 5, 2014 9703
Table 3- Antifungal activity of dried root extracts from I. helenium L.
Legend:
-: no inhibitory halo
+: low inhibitory
activity
++: moderate
inhibitory activity
+++: high inhibitory
activity
These results are in agreement with the data reported by A. DERIU & al. [9], assaying root
essential oil of I. helenium against some Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria and
Candida species.
Regarding the Inula effects on the filamentous fungi, few reports have been issued. Some
recent data (TE ZHAO & [17]) reported the inhibitory effect of Inula britannica extracts on
most important plant pathogenic fungi (Fusarium, Phytophthora, Colletotrichum, etc) and the
potential to produce botanical fungicide to protect crops. In our study, the Inula helenium
ethanolic extracts did not show any inhibitory effect on animal pathogenic Aspergillus niger
which is the main responsible for pulmonary infections in dogs, while other authors (M.A.
NAN & [18]) reported some inhibitory activity on 50 mg/l (MIC).
4. Conclusions
The preliminary results of our study, evaluated by the diameter of the inhibition zone of
microbial growth, indicated that both ethanol extracts (I50˚ and I70˚) from the roots of a
Romanian cultivar of I. helenium L. have significant activity against the pathogenic bacteria
and dermatophytic fungi, while on filamentous fungi A. niger there is no inhibitory activity.
On Candida sp. the inhibitory effects of I50˚ and I70˚ are very similar. In order to develop a
veterinary product with anti-aspergillosis effect some other plant extract (Helleborus,
Eupatorium) should be taken into account.
Further research is required to identify and analyze the bioactive compounds present in the
extracts and to establish the minimal inhibitory concentration for each type of pathogenic
microorganisms. Considering the bioactive potential of roots extracts from indigenous
population of I. helenium could be of great interest for the development of new
pharmaceuticals for veterinary uses.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the Executive Agency for Higher Education, Research,
Development and Innovation Funding in the frame of Partnerships in S&T priority domains
Program, Project no. 134/2012, acronym PHYTOIMMUVET.
References
1. L.-L. JI, M.-Y. LUO, GUI-LONG YAN. Studies on the antimicrobial activities of extracts from
Eupatorium lindleyanum DC against food spoilage and food-borne pathogens. Food Control, 19, 995,
1001 (2008).
2. N. ARVIND, S. AMIT. Antimicrobial Potential of Eupatorium adenophorum Spreng. Phcog. J., 2(18),
61, 64 (2011).
3. S. PUGLISI, A. SPECIALE, R. ACQUAVIVA, G. FERLITO, S. RAGUSA, R. DE PASQUALE, L.
IAUK Antibacterial activity of Helleborus bocconei Ten. subsp. siculus root extracts -
Ethnopharmacological communication. J. Ethnopharmacol., 125, 175, 177 (2009).
4. T. KONISHI, Y. SHIMADA, T. NAGAO, H. OKABE, T. KONOSHIMA. Antiproliferative
sesquiterpene lactones from the roots of Inula helenium. Biol Pharm Bull., 25(10), 1370, 1372 (2002).
Test microorganism Inhibitory effect
Extract I30˚ Extract I50˚ Extract I70˚
Candida albicans ATCC10231 - + + +
C. parapsilosis CBS604 - + + + +
C. lipolytica MI2 - + + + +
Aspergillus niger F2T - --
DIGUȚĂ,C., CORNEA C.P., IONIȚĂ L., BRÎNDUȘE, E., FARCAȘ, N., BOBIT D., MATEI F.
9704 Romanian Biotechnological Letters, Vol. 19, No. 5, 2014
5. A. STOJAKOWSKA, J. MALARZ, W. KISIEL. Thymol derivatives from a root culture of Inula
helenium. Z Naturforsch C., 59, 606, 608 (2004).
6. A. STOJAKOWSKA, B. KEDZIA, W. KISIEL. Antimicrobial activity of 10- isobutyryloxy-8, 9-
epoxythymol isobutyrate. Fitoterapia, 76, 687, 690 (2005).
7. A. STOJAKOWSKA, J. MALARZ, S. ZUBEK, K. TURNAU, W. KISIEL. Terpenoids and phenolics
from Inula ensifolia. Biochem. Syst. Ecol., 38, 232, 235 (2010).
8. P.D. LOKHANDE, K.R. GAWAI, K.M. KODAM, B.S. KUCHEKAR, A.R. CHABUKSWAR, S.C.
JAGDALE. Antibacterial activity of isolated constituents and extract of roots of Inula racemosa. J.
Med. Plants Res., 1(1), 7, 12 (2007).
9. A. DERIU, S. ZANETTI, L.A. SECHI, B. MARONGIU, A. PIRAS, S. PORCEDDA, E. TUVERI.
Antimicrobial activity of Inula helenium L. essential oil against Gram-positive and Gram-negative
bacteria and Candida spp. International Journal of Antimicrobial Agents, 31, 581, 592 (2008).
10. Z. STOJANOVIĆ-RADIĆ, LJ. ČOMIĆ, N. RADULOVIĆ, P. BLAGOJEVIĆ, M. DENIĆ, A.
MILTOJEVIĆ, J. RAJKOVIĆ, T. MIHAJILOV-KRSTEV. Antistaphylococcal activity of Inula
helenium L. root essential oil: eudesmane sesquiterpene lactones induce cell membrane damage. Eur. J.
Clin. Microbiol. Infect. Dis., 31(6), 1015, 1025 (2012).
11. H. YAN, S. HAIMING, G. CHENG, L. XIAOBO. Chemical constituents of the roots of Inula
helenium. Chem. Nat. Compd., 48(3), 522, 524 (2012).
12. Y.M. ZHAO, M.L. ZHANG, Q.W. SHI, H. KIYOTA. Chemical constituents of plants from the genus
Inula (Review). Chemistry & Biodiversity, 3(4), 371, 384 (2006).
13. W. H. TALIB, M. H. A. ZARGA, A. M. MAHASNEH. Antiproliferative, antimicrobial and apoptosis
inducing effects of compounds isolated from Inula viscosa. Molecules, 17, 3291, 3303 (2012).
14. S. AMIN, Z. A. KALOO, S. SINGH, T. ALTAF. Medicinal importance of genus Inula-A
Review. IJCRR, 5(2), 20, 26 (2013).
15. J. WANG, Y.M. ZHAO, C.Y. GUO, S.M. ZHANG, C.L. LIU, D.S. ZHANG, X.M. BAI. Ultrasound-
assisted extraction of total flavonoids from Inula helenium. Pharmacognosy Magazine, 8, 166, 170
(2012).
16. J. ZHAO, Y. LI, Q. LIU, K. GAO. Antimicrobial activities of some thymol derivatives from the roots of
Inula hupehensis. Food Chem., 120, 512, 516 (2010).
17. TE ZHAO, F. GAO, L. ZHOU, T. SONG. Essential oil from inula britannica extraction with SF-CO2
and its antifungal activity. Journal of Integrative Agriculture 12 (10), 1791, 1798 (2013).
18. M.A. NAN. Doctoral thesis, Pharmacobotanical study of Inula helenium L. (Asteraceae) species
regarding its use in phytotherapy, UMF Iuliu Hațieganu, Cluj-Napoca (2011).