Content uploaded by Damon Coppola
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Damon Coppola on Dec 11, 2015
Content may be subject to copyright.
Federal Emergency Management Agency
Emergency Management Institute
Investigation of the
Political Implications of Disasters
Requiring International Assistance
Damon Coppola, MEM Crisis, Disaster and Risk Management
Abstract:
Introduction
!
"
#
$%"
&
'
(
) *+ & ,
- -
()
(
( (
. . ) *
(
/
"#&/)*#0"*#1
2a humanitarian crisis in a country, region, or society where there is a total or considerable breakdown of
authority resulting from the internal and/or external conflict and which requires an international response that goes
beyond the mandate or capacity of any single agency”0)%334+)5
#6" * ) & " # / 788
858+845#6"+1
9 #&/ 01
: * *
+
( ‘why are you involved in helping those impacted by this
emergency, but not helping in that emergency?’
6&*
*;
) *
) *
-<provider
-)*
Bilateral Humanitarian Assistance is Foreign Policy
<
=>
<
"
6
)*"
?@3333
(2 )* +A4
How Governments Provide Disaster Assistance
6
8
6
"
(
!)*06*
1 ) * " 6 0)*"61 B . 6
" 0B.6"1 ' ?@3333
<&
7$1C%1
C41")*+
)
D7
)
# " 9 0#"91@ "
' B' "* " )
. '
(
Monetary Assistance
!"
#$%&&'#&%&()&#*+*,
-#(("%%."/0#1(2%31%13(1
# # 2 0 # %( 11!1"(
%%4%5 (30## #)%# 11)(( #"
4 %0 13 (3( 3 (1)# )%4#1
260(1(%($%%3(
017)0#1(##"(#)%4
8###1(()9(
8##1#0((##1(
8#)#(
" (("%% ."/ 4((1 %%( ) 0
5:141%1!""##1:4(###"3
; 1:#%%(%<0#!"%#")
%%( ) # ! %1 3(##())#);#
,=4#(#1#")44(%%3))
1.%%3,16(6,>1?@
-A/
#
<(
<
6
'
&
)
)0)B
# & " 0)B#&"1 ) 6
90)6911
5 '
6 '
0.1<
0.1
Equipment / Supplies
"
(
( /7
E .
E !
E 5
E F
E 9
E #
E &8
E 9
E
E # 888
E .
E
-
E *
#(
6(
'(
/(
7
E *(0 1
E G(01
E 58(0 1
E +
E :
E )(
E .8
E !(
E !
Technical Expertise
/
!
'
.(
(
*'
( $% %D
B<7
E 5
E 9
E
E /
+
E 5
E #
E )
E *01
E 6
E 5
Types of National Government Agencies Involved in Bilateral Assistance Offers
"
5
'
7
Overseas Diplomatic Missions (Embassies and Consulates)
B <
(
/
<
/ '
'
International Development Agencies
5"
<
'
6
<
6 '
7
E 9
'
<
B
E .
E
E 9 (
'
<
<6
)*"6<0)*"6<1B
.6"0B.6"1
< )
'
National Disaster Management Agencies
+
"
<
'
0 1
Military Resources
5
(
(
&
'
"
C
(
(
<5
'
The Political Implications of Bilateral Humanitarian Assistance
Maintenance of Effective Command and Control
/
*
'0)B
# & "1 (
& <
!+B
.
7 $1 C %1
C 41
CD1(
:
0
1
*
)
0%3$31 ( & ) *
5G<BH
&><
. 2)*A I
+ &
+#>):(3(0(#:314#%(1
#%4#1
B 3D() US Accused of Annexing Airport as Squabbling Hinders Aid Eort in Hai # ;(
E)B#$%&&000(&0(&&<&B&F(F(F7F#
A
(
B
( .
)*
#*0#*1 5 *
05*1 (
:
:
& ,
+*#
) *
)*
) * +
)*5
Image of ‘Weakness’ Among the Public, or by the International Community
F any
+
2A
(
+#
* %33@
" =
$JJ@,(
: %333 ,
:
"
:5":<
(0$$K
1K )
:9F9
Maintenance of Forceful Population Control
:
=$JJ@ * (
+:=
%33K#+
$@
'
8
)$4@333 J6
D3
<
/'(
0
1
+B
)
$3
Protection of State Sovereignty
9
C # / %333 , 67 6 6 " %D # !
788 8%888KJDH4K
J / 9 6 6 & : ! 2:
L '
'M0".9%3$35"
&#:".9"%J7888888"G(5@64.)!NB@*'+/"I"
65G%33K##7=."G9(=$
788(88(8
8C # + %33K 85" 7 '" :"
: $H$ B %3 7888O88.8888
$H$NNNNNNNNNNN
.
%33IK3( 9
&(
$$.%3$$J3( =
)**'
=
$% *%3$3*+!#
B',5 :, )B
#&"5)05)1
)
&
P
Ideological Compatibility of Donor and Recipient
*
<
# ) *
01*
F'
)*/$4
&
266$DA
%33K " # G 5' : # : #
57888/88'%3$$N$8$3$4
+ : %3$$ . : 6 = "# 5 %4
78888QR$4$%HJ3DSRIH
!#2(#74#%42G(0#1)H)
4#"11%=#204 (#%4 1)% "141
0## 4 0 411 4# ( .# + #2 7
?%=#I;(>)#$%&&000(&0(&+&1)&&2
6 I1 ./ 0 # J, ,%1) !0 , "7 ( 9K # #
#)141((%1)J/6##F1FF#(40(1#FF(F
(3 ( 0)31% (%1),F( 9(%1
(%#1 3 %FL0 %4# (%1)30#L1%
%33@*"( G
9 < '
, $@
"
#=%3$$
J3 ( ( 6
H $H # =
0
1$I *
%33D 6 9
*G $K
Assignment of Liability, and the Risk of Accident-Related Implications
9
"
:
3( 3 M / # F1FF1 4)FFF(
4# 15 1% (%1) # (F( ?L1% (#%
#3 (3 4 # # 9 #( %( %F()
#1(%(3%4##9((%1(((M(
/,F( 11 # #%% 1 #) L9 ((
(%1)K
-"1#73# (F9) 204#%#13(F
(0(04#4F904#3"<-6(3
I#1 ,% ,% ?#: ,%1) D4 8 A
#$%&&40&(&CA
+6%143E%;(%((#5##(#
(%(,)6(30###10##()E%.;1,)
6(,;1%1C#$%&&%1&(&FA&-BC#1/
BI3EG"(3#(D13>)3(%%E%>#
#$%&&1&FF&0(&#(%**#F:F#F#:F
(1F:#N*O>8 DG,
C#14F()("."6"/(%J,,%1)
G 0 # 1 ,K #3 J# () 4 # 11) 0
5(#(31(L%#4141%0>)(
4#0(((1%)3GL%4()(
4#1#L4(1"G((41>
1>4(341 (@( ;@#313)
54121 )##( ); I5
"K
.
(
'
' *
( 0 1
!
.
&5%3$3( &
'"
<'
&!
($J
Corruption
#<
.
017
C
#
C
+ ''
C
+
C
A "( ! D ?7 4 ( 2 2( @" E)
#$%&&011&%F&F%LN%F(1(OBBA
.
0
(1
.
'
9
%3 6 (
C
"
<
+B
B
#
9/Mapping the Risks
of Corruption in Humanitarian Action
7
#C
C
C
C
C
"C
C
C
&:
#&"
0 1 !
.7
6D6"6, G6P#%,D%!10("))
#$%&&0000&D%%LND%6(OCBAB
?033!)3I3("LE+>%%#D4%!1
"#$%&&000(&&(0(&+B%(4
-
#7
2 A
!
29 6* A
G67!
0
1#'
G7!(
''
B
'
57
/ 57
*
0
(1
Conclusion
!
( " (
(
)*
!
+
) * + (
Author Biography
,1%% 1)11 )1 0# ((4 % ( F
( L% > %% # %(( ) ( # L% 1) 113
%3(%)%<4#%3%53(%4?>"3#
(3# 8( @3# (3 # , %( 3
( 4 ( 13 1 # > %% # (%( ( F
(%(14?>"(,!((4##?>"&?>6!#?(1
(4#,!(?( ,3(#+F# Naonal Incident Management
Systems3#CF# Comparave Emergency Management, #CF# Hazards Risk Management3#CF#
Natural Disaster Preparedness for Security Professionals3(#>%%)(<
4)11#G1G()#4!##?1)>1(%13
0##(%( # 140 (( Economic, Legal, and Policy
Issues in Disasters( Principles of Emergency Management3#40###>%%
##((F#((1(%41)11L#)
C ( .( Introducon to Internaonal Disaster Management3
Introducon to Emergency Management, Introducon to Homeland Security, Communicang Emergency
Preparedness: Strategies for Creang a Disaster Resistant Public, (Managing Children in Disasters./ >%%
#(>4?>1.>?>/3?1)3(D>141#;
8#)
B