ArticlePDF Available

Islamic banking – the case of Malaysia

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

In the last few decades the increasing significance of Islamic finance has been observed. Among all the Islamic financial institutions, banks have been playing a dominant role in Islamic financial industry. A distinctive feature of Islamic banks is the obligation to conduct operations in accordance with principles of shariah, which is the religious law of Muslims. The purpose of this paper is to analyse the Islamic banking market in Malaysia. The reason why Malaysia has been chosen is the fact that it is one of the most developed Islamic banking markets in the world, and many other Muslim countries introduce the same regulations and banking practices, that has been functioning with success in this country. The methodology used in the paper is based on the analysis of the literature, as well as statistical data, provided mainly by Bank Negara Malaysia.
Content may be subject to copyright.
PRACE NAUKOWE UNIWERSYTETU EKONOMICZNEGO WE WROCŁAWIU
RESEARCH PAPERS OF WROCŁAW UNIVERSITY OF ECONOMICS nr 370 2014
Redenition of the Role of Asia-Pacic Region in the Global Economy ISSN
1899-3192
Iwona Sobol
University of Gdansk
e-mail: isobol@ek.univ.gda.pl
ISLAMIC BANKING – THE CASE OF MALAYSIA
Abstract: In the last few decades the increasing significance of Islamic finance has been ob-
served. Among all the Islamic financial institutions, banks have been playing a dominant role
in Islamic financial industry. A distinctive feature of Islamic banks is the obligation to conduct
operations in accordance with principles of shariah, which is the religious law of Muslims.
The purpose of this paper is to analyse the Islamic banking market in Malaysia. The reason
why Malaysia has been chosen is the fact that it is one of the most developed Islamic banking
markets in the world, and many other Muslim countries introduce the same regulations and
banking practices, that has been functioning with success in this country. The methodology
used in the paper is based on the analysis of the literature, as well as statistical data, provided
mainly by Bank Negara Malaysia.
Keywords: Islamic banking, shariah, Malaysia.
DOI: 10.15611/pn.2014.370.19
1. Introduction
In the last few decades the increasing significance of Islamic finance has been
observed. Among all the Islamic financial institutions, banks have been playing
a dominant role in Islamic financial industry. According to estimates of Kuwait
Finance House Research Department, assets of Islamic financial institutions
amounted to $1.8 trillion in 2013.1 About 80% of those assets belong to Islamic
banks. Islamic banks operate in over 75 countries, not only Muslim ones, but also
those, where Muslim minority live, such as the UK, the USA or France. The reasons
why such institutions were established across the world are connected with the neo-
-revivalist movements among Muslim societies on the one hand and the raising wealth
of some Middle East countries on the other. One of the most influential movements
was the Muslim Brotherhood, established in Al-Ismailijja (Egypt) in 1928 by Hasan
1 The numbers are given according to a short scale system, used in most English and Arabic speak-
ing countries.
Islamic banking – the case of Malaysia 241
al-Banna. The Muslim Brotherhood criticized interest-based financial system in
Egypt and other parts of the Muslim world and argued that since Islam provides
its followers with a comprehensive ideological framework for all aspects of life,
economic affairs should be also included within that framework.2 The opinions of
Muslim Brotherhood and other Muslim movements found followers in academic
world as well as among market practitioners. But if it were not the wealth of the Gulf
states, which was the result of oil crisis and the enormous increases in the oil prices,
the development of Islamic finance probably would have been much slower. Almost
all the Islamic banks that were established in the 1970s were partly or even totally
funded by oil-linked wealth.
In Malaysia the first full-fledged Islamic bank was founded in 1983, when the
Islamic Banking Act came into force. Since the very beginning Islamic banking
sector of the country was supported by the government and as a result Malaysia has
become world’s leading Islamic financial centre.
2. Operations of Islamic banks
A distinctive feature of Islamic banks is the obligation to conduct operations in
accordance with principles of shariah which is the religious law of Muslims. The basic
principle applied by Islamic financial institutions is the prohibition of usury (arab.
riba). It also constitutes the main difference between Islamic banks and conventional
financial institutions which base all their operations on interest rate. The prohibition
of riba has its origins in the holy book of the Muslims – the Koran. The hadiths,
which describe the life and actions of Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah, also
state that riba is condemned. However, neither the Koran nor the hadiths define what
riba is. According to most Islamic economists, usury is any sort of increase over
the principal amount.3 So it has a different meaning than in contemporary Western
world, where usury is defined as the practice of charging excessive, unreasonably
high interests on loans.
Apart from the prohibition of riba, Islamic financial institutions must operate in
accordance with other principles. They must avoid contracts that involve excessive
risk (gharar), that is transactions where a significant element of uncertainty exists.
That is one of the reasons why Islamic banks should not trade in derivatives.
It should be also mentioned that all economic transactions of Muslims should
support those practices or products which are not considered haram, or unlawful, to
Islam. Thus investments in areas such as alcohol, casinos, cigarettes are prohibited.
2 A. Saeed, Islamic Banking and Interest. A Study of Prohibition of Riba and Its Contemporary
Interpretation, E.J. Brill, Leiden 1996.
3 S.M. Hasanuz Zaman, Conceptual foundations of riba in Qur’an, Hadith and Fiqh, Journal of
Islamic Banking and Finance 2001, vol. 18, no. 3-4, pp. 17–25.
242 Iwona Sobol
Since riba is prohibited in Islamic finance, instruments typical for conventional
banking are not allowed either. They must be replaced by other types of products.
Financial tools of Islamic banks can be divided into two groups: profit and loss
sharing (PLS) instruments and cost-plus instruments.
The basic principle of PLS instruments is that instead of lending money at
interest, the bank forms a partnership with the borrower, sharing in a venture’s profits
and losses. Hence unlike an interest-based product, in the case of PLS modes of
finance there is no guaranteed rate of return on the investment, since income depends
on the profit earned by the partnership company and may possibly result in losses.
Mudaraba and musharaka are the most common PLS contracts. In the mudaraba
contract one party of the agreement, called rabb-ul-maal or sahib-al-maal provides
capital finance for a specific venture indicated by the other party, called mudarib.
Mudarib’s contribution to the venture is professional and technical expertise. It is
also responsible for the management of the business. If the venture brings profits,
they are shared according to a pre-agreed ratio between rabb-ul-maal and mudarib.
Losses however are entirely borne by the rabb-ul-maal. Musharaka on the other
hand is a form of joint venture, where two or more parties combine their capital and
labour together to share the profits, enjoying similar rights and liabilities. The profits
resulted from such a venture are shared according to a pre-agreed ratio between the
parties of musharaka, while losses are borne in proportion to contributed capital.4
The second group of instruments includes such modes of finance as murabaha,
salam, istisna and ijara. Murabaha (a cost-plus, mark-up contract) is a trade contract
stipulating that one party purchases a good for its own account and sells it to the
other party with a mark-up.5 The payment usually takes place sometime afterwards
or in instalments. There are many controversies connected with this tool of finance.
Some Islamic scholars even consider murabaha not shariah-compliant, since the
mark-up is often based on the interest rate. However, since it is a very useful mode
of finance, appreciated by both the banks and their clients, it is widely used. The
practice of heavy usage of murabaha has even earned its own name – “murabaha
syndrome”.6
In a salam contract one party of the contract agrees to provide specific goods at
a future date while the other party agrees to pay its price in full at the conclusion of
the contract. Just like salam, an istisna contract is a purchase agreement for future
delivery of an asset. Unlike the salam contract, however, in the istisna contract,
the payment to the producer or contractor of the asset does not have to be in full in
advance. Payment usually is done in instalments in line with the progress made on
4 I. Sobol, Concept of profit and loss sharing in Islamic finance, [in:] S. Hittmar (ed.), Regional
Management. Theory, Practice and Development, Faculty of Management Science and Informatics,
University of Zilina, Zilina 2012.
5 H. Vissner, Islamic Finance: Principle and Practice, Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham 2013.
6 T.M. Yousef, The murabaha syndrome in Islamic finance: Laws, institutions and politics, [in:]
C. Henry, R. Wilson (eds.), The Politics of Islamic Finance, Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh 2004.
Islamic banking – the case of Malaysia 243
the development of the asset. Therefore this tool of finance is especially suited to
project finance and construction.7
An ijara contract is the Islamic equivalent of a leasing transaction. The difference
between two instruments is that in ijara the proprietorship of the object of the lease
stays with the lessor. The asset stays on its balance sheet until the end of the period
of the lease. What is transferred is its usufruct.8
Naturally, Islamic banks, just like their conventional counterparts, offer their
customers the possibility of depositing their money. Islamic deposits may be based
on the profit and loss sharing principle. In that case the return the customer receives
depends on the profits of venture in which the bank has invested the money of the
depositor. Since in this case the depositor’s profits are uncertain, Islamic banks often
use other constructions for deposit accounts, where they present their customers
with a gift, called hibah, which is an equivalent of interests, typical for conventional
banking. The value of hibah cannot be stipulated in the contract and can be paid in
any moment, agreed by the bank and its client.
3. Overview of Islamic banking in Malaysia
Malaysia is a multicultural country in Southeast Asia, inhabited by about 30 million
people. The two largest ethnic groups of Malaysia are Malay (over 50% of population)
and Chinese (over 22%). Over 60% of the population of the country are Muslims.
Most of them are Sunni and represent Shafi’i school of shariah law.9
For generations Malaysian economy had been controlled by minority
communities, mainly Chinese, but also in a lesser extent Indians. When Malaysia
gained independence in 1957, it was agreed that Indians and Chinese would receive
citizenship in exchange for the political power for Malays. As a result, Malay became
the official language and Islam the state religion. It should be noted, however, that
the system of government remained secular and all the religions have a guarantee of
freedom of worship.
Although religion has been present in the political and economic life of the
country, it should be emphasised that in Malaysia Islam was never an obstacle for
modernisation, but quite opposite. It can be argued that it contributed to the growth
of financial services, which made Kuala Lumpur a leading regional financial centre.
The Malaysian brand of Islam is considered to be pragmatic and tolerant,10 which
probably influenced the popularity of Islamic finance in Malaysia, also among non-
Muslims.
7 N. Schoon, Islamic Banking and Finance, Spiramus Press, London 2010.
8 A. Boumediene, Is credit risk really higher in Islamic banks?, The Journal of Credit Risk 2011,
vol. 7, no. 3, pp. 97–129.
9 There are four main Sunni schools of law: Hanafi school, Maliki school, Shafi’i school and
Hanbali school.
10 I. Warde, Islamic Finance in the Global Economy, Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh 2000.
244 Iwona Sobol
Islamic finance origins in Malaysia can be traced back to 1963, when Malaysia
Muslim Pilgrims Savings Corporation was established, which was a saving fund for
Muslims planning to perform the religious duty of pilgrimage (hajj). Within 20 years
the fund (known as Tabung Hajj), received a wide recognition as a successful Islamic
investment company in Malaysia. Its success encouraged the Malaysian government
to establish in 1983 the first full-fledged Islamic commercial bank, the Bank Islam
Malaysia Berhad (BIMB).11 The creation of the bank was possible owing to the
introduction of the Islamic Banking Act (IBA) of 1983, which provided Malaysian
central bank with powers to regulate and supervise Islamic banks, in similar way
to other banks, operating in Malaysia. The move was considered to be a part of the
government’s strategy to support Muslim Malays, who were perceived to be not
competitive enough in comparison with more commercially minded Chinese.12 In
a very short time BIMB gained success, proving that Islamic banking services were
needed in the country.
The 1993 was another important year for Islamic banking industry in Malaysia.
In this year Ministry of Finance introduced legislation regulating an “Interest
Free Banking Scheme”, which was actually a step liberalising Islamic services in
the country. As a result those services started to be offered by about 50 financial
institutions, such as commercial banks, finance companies, merchant banks,
cooperative banks and discount houses. Also in 1993 Malaysian central bank, Bank
Negara Malaysia (BNM) undertook an initiative that further boosted growth of
Islamic finance in the country. It was a creation of Islamic interbank money market,
which was essential for managing liquidity of Islamic banks.13
Another important factor, contributing to the development of Islamic banking
in Malaysia, was establishment of the National Shariah Advisory Council (NSAC)
in 1997 as the highest shariah authority on Islamic banking and takaful (Islamic
insurance) in Malaysia. The main objectives of the NSAC include: acting as the
sole authoritative body to advise the central bank on Islamic banking and takaful
operations, coordination of shariah issues with respect to Islamic banking and
finance, analysing and evaluation of shariah aspects of new products and schemes
submitted by the banking and takaful institutions.14
It should also be added that in recent years, Islamic banking in Malaysia has been
promoted through special fiscal incentives, such as:15
11 W.S. Hegazy, Contemporary Islamic finance: From socioeconomic idealism to pure legalism,
Chicago Journal of International Law 2007, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 581–601.
12 A.M. Venardos, Islamic Banking in South East-Asia: Its Development & Future, World Scientific
Publishing, Singapore 2005.
13 S. Haron, N. Ahmad, The Islamic banking system in Malaysia, [in:] Islamic Finance: The Task
Ahead. Proceedings of the Fourth Harvard University Forum on Islamic Finance, Center for Middle
Eastern Studies, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, 2000, pp. 155–163.
14 A.M. Venardos, op.cit.
15 http://www.mifc.com (retrieved: 10.06.2014).
Islamic banking – the case of Malaysia 245
10-year tax holidays on income earned from the Islamic banking operations
conducted in foreign currencies by international banks from years of assessment
2007 until 2016,
10-year stamp duty exemption on instruments executed pertaining to Islamic
banking operations in foreign currencies undertaken by international Islamic
banks from years of assessment 2007 until 2016,
tax exemption on any profits paid out by Islamic banks to non-residents for
deposits placed at those banks,
20% stamp duty remission on Islamic finance instruments as approved by Bank
Negara Malaysia from 2 September 2006 until 31 December 2015,
tax exemption for five consecutive years given to Islamic banks from payment
of income tax in relation to sources of income derived from its overseas branch
or investee company.
The Malaysian regulations also guarantee some personal tax incentives. These
are:
tax exemption on any profits paid out by an Islamic bank to individual residents
and non-resident depositors,
withholding tax exemption on income received by non-resident experts in
Islamic finance.
It should also be added that banks, operating in Malaysia, have full flexibility
to employ expatriates with expertise to contribute to the development of Islamic
financial system in the country.
Taking into account all the factors mentioned above, it is not surprising, that
Islamic banking has been developing very well in Malaysia. Today, Malaysia is
considered to have one of the leading Islamic financial systems in the world, which
includes banking. As for 2014 the following Islamic banks operated in Malaysia:
Affin Islamic Bank Berhad, Al Rajhi Banking & Investment Corporation (Malaysia)
Berhad, Alliance Islamic Bank Berhad, AmIslamic Bank Berhad, Asian Finance
Bank Berhad, Bank Islam Malaysia Berhad, Bank Muamalat Malaysia Berhad,
CIMB Islamic Bank Berhad, HSBC Amanah Malaysia Berhad, Hong Leong Islamic
Bank Berhad, Kuwait Finance House (Malaysia) Berhad, Maybank Islamic Berhad,
OCBC Al-Amin Bank Berhad, Public Islamic Bank Berhad, RHB Islamic Bank
Berhad, Standard Chartered Saadiq Berhad. Apart from those institutions, Islamic
services are also offered by the branches of the following international banks:
Al Rajhi Banking & Investment Corporation, Alkhair International Islamic Bank
Bhd, Deutsche Bank Aktiengesellschaft, Elaf Bank B.S.C., PT. Bank Syariah
Muamalat Indonesia, Tbk.16
Malaysian Islamic banks offer their clients products that satisfy the same needs as
the products offered by conventional institutions. Additionally they give their clients
the feeling of involvement in the operations which are ethical. Because, it should be
16 http://www.bnm.gov.my (retrieved: 5.06.2014).
246 Iwona Sobol
stressed, there is more to Islamic banking than only elimination of riba. All Islamic
financial products should be also free from any form of deceit or exploitation. This
can be one of the reasons why not only Muslims are attracted to Islamic banking in
Malaysia, but also people of other religions. The other reasons are the tax incentives
mentioned above and the fact that some Chinese banks have been actively promoting
Islamic products to their customers.
The popularity of Islamic banking in Malaysia is reflected in the numbers. In
2012, assets of Islamic banks operating in Malaysia, accounted for 13% of total
global Islamic banking assets.17 Only banks in Iran and Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
had larger shares, 37 and 18%, respectively (Figure 1).
Figure 1. Domicile of Islamic banking assets
Source: http://www.mifc.com (retrieved: 10.06.2014).
Figure 2. Islamic Banking Assets in Malaysia (in RM billion)
Source: http://www.bnm.gov.my (retrieved: 5.06.2014).
17 http://www.mifc.com (retrieved: 10.06.2014).
Islamic banking – the case of Malaysia 247
The assets of Islamic banking in Malaysia amounted to 381.5 billion RM in
2012, which accounted for almost 20% of total assets in the banking system of the
country. In 2008, that share was about 14%, so it increased over the last few years
(Figure 2). Also the share of Islamic financing and Islamic deposits increased. In
2012 the share of Islamic financing was 21%, while in 2008 it was less than 15%.
Similarly, in 2012, the Islamic deposits represented almost 22% of all the deposits in
the Malaysian banking sector in comparison with 16% in 2008.18
It should be pointed out, however, that although Malaysia is considered to be
the country, where Islamic finance, including banking, has gained a big success,
the country’s system meets also some criticism. Especially there are doubts with
regard to lawfulness of some instruments and procedures with shariah. For instance,
one of the most popular ways of managing liquidity by Malaysian Islamic banks
is by means of commodity murabaha, which a deferred sale or instalment credit
sale which uses commodity as an underlying asset for the transaction. Commodities
chosen as underlying assets should be non-perishable, freely available and can be
uniquely identified. Most of commodity murabaha transactions use metals, traded
on London Stock Exchange (LME) as an asset since they meet all above mentioned
criteria required from a commodity.19 In Malaysia a special trading platform, the
Burssa Suq Al-Sila’, was established for commodity murabaha transactions. On this
exchange crude oil palm (COP) is used as the underlying asset.20 The intention of
commodity murabaha is to replicate conventional interbank deposit transactions.
Thus this instrument may serve as both: a deposit placement facility and instrument
which helps to increase liquidity. It should be also added that commodity murabaha
can be conducted between a bank and a central bank. Bank Negara Malaysia is the
example of a central bank which is engaged in such transactions. In the case of
commodity murabaha, the mark-up, the delivery date and repayment date are agreed
up front. It should be added that the banks engaged in commodity murabaha usually
do not possess the underlying commodity. The commodities are purchased and sold
solely to manage liquidity in accordance with shariah principles.21 This is one of
the reasons why commodity murabaha provokes disputes among scholars about
its permissibility.22 According to shariah, uncertainty (gharar) should be avoided
in financial contracts. And selling of the product which the seller does not own is
considered gharar.
18 http://www.bnm.gov.my (retrieved: 5.06.2014).
19 N. Schoon, op.cit.
20 A.W. Dusuki (ed.), Islamic Financial System. Principles & Operations, International Shari’ah
Research, Academy of Islamic Finance, Kuala Lumpur 2001.
21 N. Schoon, op.cit.
22 A. Rais, A. Majid, Development of Liquidity Management Instruments: Challenges and Oppor-
tunities, International Conference on Islamic Banking: Risk Management, Regulation and Supervision,
Jakarta 2003.
248 Iwona Sobol
Malaysian Islamic banking system is also criticised for the limited usage of PLS
modes of finance. Both mudaraba and musharaka are considered to be the ideal
Islamic transactions. And according to Islamic scholars, especially conservative
ones, all financial institutions should base their operations on them. But in practice,
PLS transactions are not often conducted by Islamic banks. The reason for that lies
in the fact that there are many problems associated with those modes of finance.
Most of the problems result from the information asymmetry, which may lead to
moral hazard behaviour of the borrowers.23 As a consequence of problems associated
with PLS transactions, other methods of finance, especially murabaha, are much
more often used by Islamic banks. According to the data provided by Bank Negara
Malaysia, in 2013 PLS instruments accounted for only 6% of all the modes of finance
in Islamic banking sector. It should be noted, however, that this problem does not
concern only Malaysia, but all the countries, where Islamic banks operate. Even in
Sudan, where the whole financial system is Islamised, PLS modes of finance are not
frequently used.
4. Conclusions
Islamic banking sector in Malaysia has always had a strong support from
the government on legislative and regulatory aspects. Also good promotion,
accompanied by the revival of the religion among the society, heavily influenced the
quick development of Islamic banking in this country.
The future of this sector seems also to be bright. Malaysian policy makers and
bankers even believe that Islamic banking will take over the conventional banking
by 2020. There are a few factors that should contribute to this. Firstly, in the next
few years still tax incentives favouring Islamic sector will be in force. Secondly,
the further opportunities for Islamic lie also in the inclusion in the banking system
of those members of the society who have not used any banking services so far, but
who will be attracted to the system by the ethical values, represented by Islamic
banks. It should also be added that Islamic banks in Malaysia are also engaged in
microfinance schemes, in much greater scale than their conventional counterparts.
And in the future their engagement is going to be even higher.
It should be stressed, however, that although the Islamic banking in Malaysia is
considered to be very progressive, and as it has already been written, it is believed
that it would develop in the next years, there are still problems that have to be solved.
First of all, Islamic banks still sometimes are perceived as imitators of conventional
institutions. And the philosophy and goals of Islamic banks should be different from
those of conventional banks. It is impossible to require from Islamic banks not to
concentrate on achieving profits, but the profit motive must be accompanied by the
motives of ethics and morality. It is also important for Islamic banks to concentrate on
23 I. Sobol, Concept of profit…
Islamic banking – the case of Malaysia 249
offering the products that cannot be considered as conventional products in disguise,
which is now a frequent case. The first step in this direction was made in 2013,
when Islamic Financial Services Act was enacted in Malaysia. In this regulation it is
stipulated that an Islamic institution shall at all times ensure that its aims, operations,
business, are in compliance with shariah.
It should also be noted that Islamic banking is only one element of Islamic
financial system. Islamic bonds (sukuk) or Islamic insurance (takaful) markets
were not discussed in this paper, but they have also been developing very well in
Malaysia.24 When it comes to sukuk issuance, Malaysia is the absolute world leader.
And it should be also noticed that development of Islamic banking is related to the
development of other Islamic financial sectors. For instance, sukuk are used by
Islamic banks in Malaysia for liquidity management purposes.25
Finally, it should also be added that the development of Islamic banking in
Malaysia is impossible without the cooperation with foreign institutions. And this is
possible only if there is uniformity between products and procedures used by Islamic
banks in different countries. It means the necessity of the development of globally
accepted shariah compliant products and practices. It is not an easy task taking into
account different shariah schools, but it is a challenge that Islamic banks, also those
from Malaysia, have to face.
References
Boumediene A., Is credit risk really higher in Islamic banks?, The Journal of Credit Risk 2011, vol. 7,
no. 3, pp. 97–129.
Dusuki A.W. (ed.), Islamic Financial System. Principles & Operations, International Shari’ah Rese-
arch, Academy of Islamic Finance, Kuala Lumpur 2001.
Haron S., Ahmad N., The Islamic banking system in Malaysia, [in:] Islamic Finance: The Task Ahe-
ad. Proceedings of the Fourth Harvard University Forum on Islamic Finance, Center for Middle
Eastern Studies, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, 2000, pp. 155–163.
Hasanuz Zaman S.M., Conceptual foundations of riba in Qur’an, Hadith and Fiqh, Journal of Islamic
Banking and Finance 2001, vol. 18, no. 3-4, pp. 17–25.
Hegazy W.S., Contemporary Islamic finance: From socioeconomic idealism to pure legalism, Chicago
Journal of International Law 2007, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 581–601.
Rais A., Majid A., Development of Liquidity Management Instruments: Challenges and Opportunities,
International Conference on Islamic Banking: Risk Management, Regulation and Supervision,
Jakarta 2003.
Saeed A., Islamic Banking and Interest. A Study of Prohibition of Riba and Its Contemporary Interpre-
tation, E.J. Brill, Leiden 1996.
Schoon N., Islamic Banking and Finance, Spiramus Press, London 2010.
24 G. Sivalingam, The Islamic bond market in Malaysia, [in:] M.J. Montesano, L. Poh Onn (eds.),
Regional Outlook: Southeast Asia, Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, Singapore 2012.
25 I. Sobol, Liquidity management practices in Islamic banking, Journal of Management and Fi-
nance 2013, vol. 11, no. 2, part 1, pp. 566–576.
250 Iwona Sobol
Sivalingam G., The Islamic bond market in Malaysia, [in:] M.J. Montesano, L. Poh Onn (eds.), Regio-
nal Outlook: Southeast Asia, Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, Singapore 2012.
Sobol I., Concept of profit and loss sharing in Islamic finance, [in:] S. Hittmar (ed.), Regional Ma-
nagement. Theory, Practice and Development, Faculty of Management Science and Informatics,
University of Zilina, Zilina 2012.
Sobol I., Liquidity management practices in Islamic banking, Journal of Management and Finance
2013, vol. 11, no. 2, part 1, pp. 566–576.
Venardos A.M., Islamic Banking in South East-Asia: Its Development & Future, World Scientific Pu-
blishing, Singapore 2005.
Vissner H., Islamic Finance: Principle and Practice, Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham 2013.
Warde I., Islamic Finance in the Global Economy, Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh 2000.
Yousef T.M., The murabaha syndrome in Islamic finance: Laws, institutions and politics, [in:] C. Henry,
R. Wilson (eds.), The Politics of Islamic Finance, Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh 2004.
Websites
http://www.bnm.gov.my (retrieved: 5.06.2014).
http://www.mifc.com (retrieved: 10.06.2014).
BANKOWOŚĆ ISLAMSKA – PRZYKŁAD MALEZJI
Streszczenie: W ciągu ostatnich kilku dekad wzrosło istotnie znaczenie finansów islamskich,
w szczególności zaś bankowości islamskiej. Charakterystyczną cechą banków islamskich jest
konieczność przeprowadzania operacji finansowych zgodnie z religijnym prawem muzułma-
nów – szariatem. Celem niniejszego artykułu jest analiza rynku bankowości islamskiej w Ma-
lezji, ze szczególnym naciskiem na czynniki, które przyczynily się do rozwoju tego rynku.
Słowa kluczowe: bankowość islamska, szariat, Malezja.
... In 1983, The Bank Islam Malaysia Berhad was established; the bank carried out interest-free activities for 10 years. Under the IF legislation, the Central Bank of Malaysia is authorized to apply the rules applicable to the CF banks to the IF institutions as well (Sobol 2014). ...
Chapter
The performances of the commanding height sectors including agriculture, manufacturing, construction, tourism and mining are crucially important for growth. To improve the productivity and competitiveness of these sectors, it is imperative to offer financial options and opportunities. Despite that Malaysia gained its independence recently, the country experienced a fairly satisfactory level of development. The contribution of the financial sector greatly influenced the success of the policies that offered solutions to the structural problems of Malaysia’s economy. For this reason, the Malaysian government has taken steps to improve the CF and IF. The stability of both sectors enables scholars to run a comparative analysis. This study seeks to provide a comparative analysis of growth based on empirical measurements of the impact of loans offered by conventional and Islamic finance.
... In 1983, The Bank Islam Malaysia Berhad was established; the bank carried out interest-free activities for 10 years. Under the IF legislation, the Central Bank of Malaysia is authorized to apply the rules applicable to the CF banks to the IF institutions as well ( Sobol 2014). In 1993, the government introduced legislation required for the CF institutions to offer interest-free financial services; in 1999, the Ministry of Finance raised discussion on Interest-Free Banking Scheme. ...
Chapter
Major religions in the world have introduced an interest ban for different reasons. Those other than Islam have, however, made lenient changes to this ban over the centuries, ultimately completely eliminating it. As a result, the modern financial system has evolved onto the interest-based banking model which played a huge role in the development of the Western world. On the other hand, most Muslims have distanced themselves to this model for religious reasons in predominantly Muslim countries, leaving most financial sources idle. As a cure to this problem, an alternative model based on PLS principle has been offered, briefly called Islamic Finance (IF). A dual banking system has subsequently emerged with the involvement of both conventional and Islamic finance models in the system in some countries in the world.
... In 1983, The Bank Islam Malaysia Berhad was established; the bank carried out interest-free activities for 10 years. Under the IF legislation, the Central Bank of Malaysia is authorized to apply the rules applicable to the CF banks to the IF institutions as well (Sobol 2014). ...
Chapter
The appearance of the cities in the Gulf has been for a while marked by luxury cars, glorious shopping malls and magnificent buildings. However, these cities are no longer as vibrant as they used to be because of the sharp decline in the prices of the hydrocarbon products. The slowdown in growth has led to some structural issues in the Gulf nations. The governments in these countries have for the first time introduced the idea of taxes. The administrators, now aware of the structural problems, made efforts to ensure that the economy would not depend on hydrocarbon products alone. This part of the study is focused on the impact of financial sector loans in Qatar upon growth rate.
... In 1983, The Bank Islam Malaysia Berhad was established; the bank carried out interest-free activities for 10 years. Under the IF legislation, the Central Bank of Malaysia is authorized to apply the rules applicable to the CF banks to the IF institutions as well (Sobol 2014). ...
Chapter
Economists who considered the growth performance in the past estimated that Indonesia would preserve its high growth rate performance in the long term. However, the national economy can be currently considered as a developing nation. In addition to public sources, domestic and foreign resources are also needed in the financing of high growth rate. Dual banking offers alternative financial capital opportunities for the developing Islamic countries. It could be argued that the IF serves as an alternative in Indonesia to finance investments. To better measure the probable impacts of the loans they offer upon the GDP, seemingly unrelated regression model has been utilized. A review of the both correlation matrix reveals that there is a strong positive relationship between the loans offered for the sectors and the GDP.
... In 1983, The Bank Islam Malaysia Berhad was established; the bank carried out interest-free activities for 10 years. Under the IF legislation, the Central Bank of Malaysia is authorized to apply the rules applicable to the CF banks to the IF institutions as well (Sobol 2014). ...
Book
Full-text available
This Palgrave Pivot empirically analyzes the role of conventional and interest-free Islamic banking in the growth process of developing Islamic nations. After explaining the theoretical background of this dual banking system structure, the book then empirically analyzes growth in a variety of sectors - such as agriculture, manufacturing, and tourism - in the predominantly Muslim countries of Turkey, Malaysia, Indonesia, and Qatar. Finally, the book concludes with a detailed comparison of policy efficiency surrounding the dual bank structure, providing advice from more successful countries that can be applied to those still struggling to find a balance.
... Below are some of the answers given by the respondents in reference to government support in supporting Islamic and conventional home financing: This view regarding government support for financial institutions is supported by Sobol (2014). Ever since full-fledged Islamic banks were developed in Malaysia in 1983, the Islamic banking sector has received well attention and support from the Government of Malaysia to make Malaysia the hub for IBF. ...
Article
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to explore the development of Islamic home financing and some of its practical issues. In addition, the study also intends to draw attention to some recommendations to the issues highlighted from the viewpoint of industrial experts. Design/methodology/approach The methodology for this study follows the qualitative research approach which aims to capture the thoughts and extensive knowledge of a few related experts in the field. Eight respondents who are mainly scholars and bankers in Islamic banking were selected for the interview purpose. A semi-structured interview was adopted to investigate a series of themes concerning the Islamic home financing in Malaysia. Findings In terms of development, the findings showed that a majority of the participants agreed that the Islamic banking and finance (IBF) is developing in line with its counterpart – the conventional banks. This is due to its innovation in products as well as offering a variety of financial products including home financing. Some of the practical issues highlighted by the respondents include pricing, adherence to conventional framework and interest rate movement. Islamic home financing is argued to be much more expensive and faces difficulty in working within a conventional framework. The issue of interest rate movement is also becoming a major hurdle in Islamic banking due to the absence of a proper benchmark for IBF. At present, IBF still follows the benchmark set by its conventional counterpart. Furthermore, the respondents also believed that the product of home financing, together with other financial products, are not in line with the teaching of Shariah principles and guideline. In addressing those issues, the respondents provided some suggestions to counter those problems, which include promoting Islamic home financing, particularly in terms of Musharakah Mutanaqisah (MM), ensuring the transparency of products, strengthening due diligence, legal aspect and others. Research limitations/implications This study is limited in terms of the relatively small number of respondents used to generate its findings. Time constraint is another limiting factor of the research. Additionally, potential respondents in a higher position were unable to take part in the study. Due to these factors, the generalisation of the study’s findings will be visibly restricted. Practical implications This paper is expected to generate several practical implications. Firstly, the study’s exploration of the issues surrounding home financing will likely provide a general overview of the recent development in Islamic banking and the challenges it faces. Consequently, this will indirectly help policymakers and bankers alike to design a better policy when dealing with Islamic home financing issues. In the review of various literatures in the field, a majority of research studies were observed to mainly focus on a quantitative approach. Hence, in terms of methodological innovation, the study’s use of qualitative inquiry based on an interview method may provide a deeper understanding of the matter. The resolutions proposed by the various experts are hoped to contribute to shaping a better framework and system in Islamic and conventional home financing in Malaysia. Originality/value Despite having many literatures revealing mixed results concerning Islamic home financing, especially the Bai Bithaman Ajil and MM, addressing the issues of Islamic home financing, particularly from an expert perspective, has been lacking. The majority of research studies claim those issues from a theoretical viewpoint rather than a practical one. With this gap and lack of initiative, the current study is motivated to undertake an in-depth analysis on the issues of Islamic home financing and how to address those arising issues from an industrial expert’s point of view via a qualitative approach.
... In 1983, The Bank Islam Malaysia Berhad was established; the bank carried out interest-free activities for 10 years. Under the IF legislation, the Central Bank of Malaysia is authorized to apply the rules applicable to the CF banks to the IF institutions as well (Sobol 2014). ...
Chapter
This study evaluates the capacity of Islamic finance to address the current financial problems and its ability to offer an alternative model and solutions. Specifically, one primary goal of this study is to offer a rational answer to whether Islamic finance could play a role in the global economy and serve as a valuable alternative to the conventional financial and banking systems in emerging markets like Turkey and Malaysia. This study analyzes the evolution of participation banks, also referred to as Islamic banks, in Turkey and the rationality of the political goals set by the government. The literature on the linkage between financial development and economic growth will also be evaluated. The study will finally discuss the contribution of Islamic finance in Turkey and Malaysia to economic growth.
Chapter
Full-text available
Giriş Küreselleşen, değişen ve yenilenen dünyada, giderek gelişen ve karmaşıklaşan finansal sistem içerisinde finansal alternatiflere duyulan ihtiyaç her geçen gün daha fazla hissedilmektedir. Bu noktada, finansal sistem içerisinde bir alternatif olarak yer bulan, “Faizsiz (İslami) Finans” giderek önemli bir konu haline gelmiştir. 2008 küresel finansal kriz sürecinde sergilediği performans sonrası dikkatleri üzerine çekmeyi başarabilen ve her geçen gün artan bir potansiyele sahip olan faizsiz finans ve bankacılık uygulamalarının başlangıç yılları ve gelişim düzeyleri ülkeden ülkeye farklılık göstermektedir. Bu çalışmanın amacı, dünyada faizsiz finans ve bankacılığın tarihsel gelişimini ve mevcut durumunu ele alarak Türkiye ve Malezya özelinde değerlendirme yapmaktır. Türkiye ve Malezya’da faizsiz finans ve bankacılığın gelişim seyri incelendiğinde, her iki ülkede de faizsiz finansın en belirgin yansıması olan faizsiz bankacılığın temellerinin 1983 yılında atıldığı fakat gelişim performanslarının farklılık gösterdiği görülmektedir. İncelenmesi önem arz eden bu durum çalışmanın motivasyonunu oluşturmakta ve Türkiye - Malezya özelinde değerlendirme yapılmasının nedenini açıklamaktadır. Konuya ilişkin geniş ve güncel bir perspektifle anlatım sunulması çalışmanın literatüre katkısını ortaya koymaktadır. Çalışma planı üç bölümden oluşmaktadır. Öncelikle dünyada faizsiz finans ve bankacılığın gelişim seyri ele alınmaktadır. Devam eden bölümde Malezya’da faizsiz finans ve bankacılığın tarihsel gelişimi ve mevcut durumuna ilişkin değerlendirme sunulmaktadır. Ardından Türkiye özelinde faizsiz finans ve bankacılığın tarihsel gelişimi ve mevcut durumu değerlendirilmektedir. Sonuç ve değerlendirmeler ile birlikte çalışma tamamlanmaktadır.
Chapter
Full-text available
Küreselleşen, değişen ve yenilenen dünyada, giderek gelişen ve karmaşıklaşan finansal sistem içerisinde finansal alternatiflere duyulan ihtiyaç her geçen gün daha fazla hissedilmektedir. Bu noktada, finansal sistem içerisinde bir alternatif olarak yer bulan, “Faizsiz (İslami) Finans” giderek önemli bir konu haline gelmiştir. 2008 küresel finansal kriz sürecinde sergilediği performans sonrası dikkatleri üzerine çekmeyi başarabilen ve her geçen gün artan bir potansiyele sahip olan faizsiz finans ve bankacılık uygulamalarının başlangıç yılları ve gelişim düzeyleri ülkeden ülkeye farklılık göstermektedir. Bu çalışmanın amacı, dünyada faizsiz finans ve bankacılığın tarihsel gelişimini ve mevcut durumunu ele alarak Türkiye ve Malezya özelinde değerlendirme yapmaktır. Türkiye ve Malezya’da faizsiz finans ve bankacılığın gelişim seyri incelendiğinde, her iki ülkede de faizsiz finansın en belirgin yansıması olan faizsiz bankacılığın temellerinin 1983 yılında atıldığı fakat gelişim performanslarının farklılık gösterdiği görülmektedir. İncelenmesi önem arz eden bu durum çalışmanın motivasyonunu oluşturmakta ve Türkiye - Malezya özelinde değerlendirme yapılmasının nedenini açıklamaktadır. Konuya ilişkin geniş ve güncel bir perspektifle anlatım sunulması çalışmanın literatüre katkısını ortaya koymaktadır. Çalışma planı üç bölümden oluşmaktadır. Öncelikle dünyada faizsiz finans ve bankacılığın gelişim seyri ele alınmaktadır. Devam eden bölümde Malezya’da faizsiz finans ve bankacılığın tarihsel gelişimi ve mevcut durumuna ilişkin değerlendirme sunulmaktadır. Ardından Türkiye özelinde faizsiz finans ve bankacılığın tarihsel gelişimi ve mevcut durumu değerlendirilmektedir. Sonuç ve değerlendirmeler ile birlikte çalışma tamamlanmaktadır.
Book
To truly understand the current interest in the development of Islamic banking and finance in South-East Asia, and how it is different from the conventional banking system, the author believes one must firstly understand the religious relationship originating from the Qur'an, and then trace the historical geographic and political developments of Islam over recent centuries. Only on this basis can the reader, without prejudice or cynicism, begin to appreciate the subject matter of Shari'ah Law and Islamic Jurisprudence that confronts the title of this book. With this platform established in the first part of the book, readers will begin to learn of the financial products and services offered, appreciate the challenges in their development, and ultimately recognize the significant opportunities that Islamic banking and finance can provide both Muslims and non-Muslims. © 2005 by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. All rights reserved.
Article
In the three eras identified in the previous chapters, the evolution of Islamic finance was paradoxical. The creation of the first Islamic banks could be seen, especially in the context of oil crisis and the calls for a New International Economic Order, as a challenge to the existing political-economic order. In reality, the first Islamic banks were firmly rooted within the existing Western financial system. By the same token, the age of globalisation allowed a financial system rooted in the Middle Ages to survive and to thrive. What is more striking is that even amid the Islamaphobia spurred by the September 11 events and the ‘Global War on Terror’, Islamic finance experienced its most dramatic growth in the first years of the twenty-first century. These paradoxes can be understood only in connection with the evolution of the global political economy during those three periods. The first section of this chapter discusses the political and economic context of the birth of modern Islamic finance, as well as the emergence of pan-Islamism, petrodollar windfall and relations with the West. The second section discusses Islamic finance and the global economy, as well as the transformation of banking and the rise of Islamism.
Article
Islamic intellectuals observed that the Muslim societies' banking and finance, which should be pegged on religious tenets, have undergone a rapid transformation in the past decades. According to the prevailing interpretations of Islamic law, financial instruments should be based on the principle of profit-and-loss sharing (equity contracts) and should avoid predetermined or fixed returns (debt contracts). However, evidence on the current practice by Islamic banks suggests that the majority of their financial operations are not based on equity, but rather on the use of the murabaha contract – an instrument which is akin to the standard debt contract in conventional banking systems. This departure from the theory and religious doctrine has spurred debates among scholars, and economics and finance specialists. The predominance of the murabaha represents a challenge to the very notion that Islamic finance would provide an alternative to interest-based conventional financial systems. And while there has been a tendency on the part of critics of Islamic finance to overplay the murabaha syndrome, defenders have been equally guilty of dismissing its significance for evaluating the contribution of modern Islamic capitalists. This chapter aims to provide a comparative framework for explaining the murabaha syndrome in Islamic finance. The observation that the financial structure in Islamic sub-systems is no different from those in conventional banking systems establishes the necessity of a systemic examination of financial structure. Starting from the paradigm of corporate governance, the chapter incorporates the insights of recent work on the systemic determinants of financial structure, including the role of law, institutions and politics. This analysis places the murabaha syndrome into a broad national and international context, and elucidates the constraints faced by Islamic capitalists in adhering to the goals of the equity-based model of Islamic finance. The implications for the future of Islamic finance are included also in this chapter.
Article
This article explores empirically the assertion that Islamic Banks have higher credit risk than Conventional Banks. A definition, identification and the way to manage credit risk are given to each Islamic financial tool. This risk is, then, measured on nine Islamic and nine Conventional Banks, using Contingent Claims Analysis (CCA). Merton’s model (1974), based on Black & Scholes’ (1973) option pricing formula, allowed the measure of the Distance-to-Default (DD) and Default probability (DP) from 2005 to 2009. Islamic Banks have a mean DD of 204 significantly higher than conventional Banks (DD = 15). Mean DP equals 0.03 and 0.05 respectively. Afterward, cumulative logistic probability distribution has been used to derive DP from DD. Results are more satisfying; the distribution of DP has larger tails which respond to the critic against the use of a normal distribution.
Contemporary Islamic finance: From socioeconomic idealism to pure legalism
  • W S Hegazy
Hegazy W.S., Contemporary Islamic finance: From socioeconomic idealism to pure legalism, Chicago Journal of International Law 2007, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 581-601.
Islamic Financial System. Principles & Operations, International Shari'ah Research, Academy of Islamic Finance
A.W. Dusuki (ed.), Islamic Financial System. Principles & Operations, International Shari'ah Research, Academy of Islamic Finance, Kuala Lumpur 2001. 21 N. Schoon, op.cit.