Context
In the last 3 decades, herpes simplex virus type 2 (HSV-2) infection
seroprevalence and neonatal herpes have increased substantially. An effective
vaccine for the prevention of genital herpes could help control this epidemic.Objective
To evaluate the efficacy of a vaccine for prevention of HSV-2 infection.Design
Two randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled multicenter trials
of a recombinant subunit vaccine containing 30 µg each of 2 major HSV-2
surface glycoproteins (gB2 and gD2) against which neutralizing
antibodies are directed, administered at months 0, 1, and 6. Control subjects
were given a citrate buffer vehicle. Participants were followed up for 1 year
after the third immunization.Setting and Participants
We enrolled 2393 persons from December 10, 1993, to April 4, 1995, who
were HSV-2 and human immunodeficiency virus seronegative. One trial with 18
centers enrolled 531 HSV-2–seronegative partners of HSV-2–infected
persons; the other, with 22 centers, enrolled 1862 persons attending sexually
transmitted disease clinics. A total of 2268 (94.8%) met inclusion criteria
and were included in the analysis with 1135 randomized to placebo and 2012
to vaccine.Main Outcome Measure
Time to acquisition of HSV-2 infection, defined by seroconversion or
isolation of HSV-2 in culture during the study period by randomization group.Results
Time-to-event curves indicated a 50% lower acquisition rate among vaccine
vs placebo recipients during the initial 5 months of the trial; however, overall
vaccine efficacy was 9% (95% confidence interval,−29% to 36%). Acquisition
rates of HSV-2 were 4.6 and 4.2 per 100 patient-years in the placebo and vaccine
recipients, respectively (P=.58). Follow-up of vaccine
recipients acquiring HSV-2 infection showed vaccination had no significant
influence on duration of clinical first genital HSV-2 episodes (vaccine, median
of 7.1 days; placebo, 6.5 days; P>.10) or subsequent
frequency of reactivation (median monthly recurrence rate with vaccine, 0.2;
with placebo, 0.3; P>.10). The vaccine induced high
levels of HSV-2–specific neutralizing antibodies in vaccinated persons
who did and did not develop genital herpes.Conclusions
Efficient and sustained protection from sexual acquisition of HSV-2
infection will require more than high titers of specific neutralizing antibodies.
Protection against sexually transmitted viruses involving exposure over a
prolonged period will require a higher degree of vaccine efficacy than that
achieved in this study.
Figures in this Article
Herpes simplex virus type 2 (HSV-2) seroprevalence has increased by
32% in the last decade.1 Overall, HSV-2 seroprevalence
is 22% in the general US adult population, and in some populations, such as
sexually transmitted disease (STD) clinic attendees, seroprevalence varies
between 30% and 50%.1- 5
Concomitant with this increase in genital herpes has been an increase in reported
cases of neonatal herpes.6 Also, risk of neonatal
HSV infection is greater in the setting of new maternal infection during the
third trimester of pregnancy than in the setting of established maternal infection.7 Thus, an effective method for control of genital HSV
is of major public health importance. A reduction in HSV-2 prevalence would
also reduce the influence of HSV-2 infection in human immunodeficiency virus
(HIV) 1 acquisition and transmission.8- 10
Several experimental and epidemiological factors indicate that development
of an effective vaccine against HSV-2 should be possible. First, HSV-2–specific
antibodies are associated with reduction of maternal-fetal transmission of
HSV-2.6,11- 13
Also, new infection with the same HSV-2 subtype is rare,14- 15
and prior HSV-1 infection appears to ameliorate frequency and severity of
subsequent HSV-2 disease.16- 18
In experimental models, both humoral and cellular immune responses have been
effective in preventing HSV in experimental challenge.19
Passive immunization has been achieved with type-specific neutralizing antibodies,
and monoclonal antibodies directed at major neutralizing epitopes of HSV-2
glycoproteins B2 (gB2) and D2 (gD2)
protected against experimental challenge in mice.20- 21
Immunization with gD2 and gB2 proteins is similarly
effective in a guinea pig model.22- 23
Phase 1 and 2 clinical trials with these recombinant proteins have shown that
humans develop postimmunization neutralizing antibodies to HSV-2 that are
similar to those that arise following natural infection.24
Based on these preclinical and phase 1 and 2 studies, we conducted 2
large, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trials with 27 participating
study sites to evaluate the efficacy of a recombinant glycoprotein subunit
vaccine for the prevention of genital HSV-2 infection. The vaccine contained
30 µg each of gD2 and gB2 in combination with
the adjuvant MF59, a 5% squalene oil-in-water emulsion.