ArticlePDF Available


Interacting with children is one of the most popular activities among volunteer tourists, yet volunteer tourism research rarely is informed by insights from childhood studies. This paper shows how a greater understanding of the socially constructed nature of many assumptions about children and childhood, as well as a more accurate understanding of child development processes, can deepen understanding of the phenomenon widely referred to as orphanage tourism. Issues to be addressed include the definition and delineation of orphanage tourism, motivations for and consequences of orphanage tourism, and the anti-orphanage tourism campaign. Main points will be illustrated with excerpts from a content analysis of volunteers' testimonials, blogs and other online sources.
Childhood studies and orphanage tourism in
Kathie Carpenter
University of Oregon, Department of International Studies, University of Oregon, Eugene, OR 97403, USA
article info
Article history:
Received 23 October 2014
Revised 29 June 2015
Accepted 18 August 2015
Coordinating Editor: S. Wearing
Volunteer tourism
Childhood studies
Interacting with children is one of the most popular activities
among volunteer tourists, yet volunteer tourism research rarely is
informed by insights from childhood studies. This paper shows
how a greater understanding of the socially constructed nature of
many assumptions about children and childhood, as well as a more
accurate understanding of child development processes, can deepen
understanding of the phenomenon widely referred to as orphanage
tourism. Issues to be addressed include the definition and delin-
eation of orphanage tourism, motivations for and consequences of
orphanage tourism, and the anti-orphanage tourism campaign.
Main points will be illustrated with excerpts from a content analysis
of volunteers’ testimonials, blogs and other online sources.
Ó2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
The nexus of childhood studies and tourism studies remains underexplored, under-theorized and
under-utilized despite the light it can shed on dimensions of tourism that are growing in importance
and complexity. The purpose of this paper is to use the lens provided by childhood studies to clarify
some of the underlying issues pertaining to orphanage tourism
and in so doing to illustrate how
childhood studies can illuminate the study of tourism more generally, using orphanage tourism and
the anti-orphanage tourism campaign in Cambodia as a case study. Wearing and McGehee (2013, p.
0160-7383/Ó2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Tel.: +1 (541) 346 3898; fax: +1 (541) 346 5041.
E-mail address:
Despite the inherently value-laden nature of the term and the vagueness of its reference, the term ‘orphanage tourism’ will be
used in this paper even as it is critiqued, because it has become established as a conventional term in the literature.
Annals of Tourism Research 55 (2015) 15–27
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Annals of Tourism Research
journal homepage:
122) have called for ‘‘a broadening and setting of the research parameters” in the study of volunteer tour-
ism, and while, as pointed out by McGehee (2014, p. 849) ‘‘a broad spectrum of theoretical perspectives
have been applied to volunteer tourism,” so far the perspectives of childhood studies have yet to be
explored. This omission is somewhat puzzling, given that interacting with children is one of the most
popular volunteer tourism activities, as well as one of the most controversial (Conran, 2011).
Specific issues to be examined are: (1) the definition and delineation of orphanage tourism; (2)
motivations for orphanage voluntourism; (3) consequences of orphanage voluntourism; (4) the
anti-orphanage tourism campaign. These areas have been chosen because they all have generated sub-
stantial research interest yet remain incompletely understood because while they all pivot around
children empirically, the lens of childhood studies has yet to be added to the body of research inves-
tigating them.
Literature review
The term ‘childhood studies’ encompasses two distinct approaches which together provide an
understanding of childhood as both socially constructed and biologically informed. Child development
focuses on maturational processes, highlighting children as ‘‘developing beings who are vulnerable
and in need of protection” (Bluebond-Langner & Korbin, 2007, p. 243). In addition, the term ‘childhood
studies’ has also been more narrowly used since the 1980s to refer to a new social studies of childhood
which emphasizes culturally constructed dimensions of childhood and a view of children as ‘‘in pos-
session of agency, capable and able to make interpretations of their worlds and act on them
(Bluebond-Langner & Korbin, 2007).” In this view, childhood can be viewed as a metaphorical space
as well as a biological stage, and so an overarching goal of childhood studies is to ‘‘resist universal def-
initions of children and childhood,” and to be skeptical of the ‘‘bright line” dividing childhood from
adulthood solely on the basis of years lived (Bluebond-Langner & Korbin, 2007, p. 242). While they
are in principle complementary, tension can arise between the two approaches and their proponents.
The social studies of childhood problematizes perceptions of childhood as a state of becoming rather
than a legitimate state of being in its own right, and maintains that viewing childhood as a temporary
state of preparation for adult life focuses attention on the outcomes of childhood experiences rather
than the lived experience of children. The view of childhood as primarily important insofar as it pre-
pares children for adulthood provides one explanation for the marginalization of children’s perspec-
tives throughout the social sciences. In contrast, focusing on childhood as a state of being in its
own right brings an added salience to children’s rights, both as an object of inquiry and as an ethical
guide to conducting research with children; methodological concerns are therefore another reason
that research concerning children is often scanty (Einarsdottir, 2007). Principles such as the best inter-
ests of the child are often elusive because they are guided by values and culturally informed assump-
tions about the ideal childhood and the ideal way to structure adult–child responsibilities and
interactions, issues that inevitably are contested in volunteer tourism, which frequently includes
encounters of foreign adults with the children of another society.
That the child is largely absent from the tourism literature has been noted (Poria & Timothy, 2014;
Small, 2008) although calls for increased attention have thus far failed to gather significant momen-
tum. The majority of references to children in tourism studies analyze the child as a consumer, most
frequently as a family member in research on family tourism, rather than on children per se (Kidron,
2013; Obrador, 2012). A small body of research focuses on children as members of the host commu-
nity, most notably Crick (1989) and Gamradt (1995). Rarest of all is research addressing the ways that
children themselves are perceived as tourist attractions (Guiney, 2012). The best articulated area of
research focused on this dimension of children and tourism addresses child sex tourism, although it
too remains undeveloped, perhaps due to the very uncomfortable nature of the topic; as
Montgomery (2008, p. 914) has written ‘‘it is hard to look at it objectively.”
While volunteer tourism has been lauded as a new kind of tourism (Wearing, 2001; Godfrey &
Wearing, 2012), often linked to 9/11 and the Asian tsunami (Wearing & McGehee, 2013), and as a
‘‘simply ...logical conclusion” of applying ethical concerns to the interest in traveling (Butcher &
Smith, 2010, p. 30), orphanage tourism can also be situated within the history of children’s institutions
and domestic volunteering, not just the history of tourism. In fact, as Guttentag (2009, p. 538) points
16 K. Carpenter / Annals of Tourism Research 55 (2015) 15–27
out ‘‘the most significant growth in the volunteer tourism sector has occurred since 1990,” corre-
sponding closely with an increase in U.S. domestic volunteering spurred by the 1988 ‘‘thousand points
of light” speech by then-President Bush. However, orphanage volunteering was well established even
before that; from the mid-19th through mid-20th centuries, when orphan asylums were widespread
in the U.S., they relied heavily on volunteers (Pousson, n.d.). In the 1980s, many foreigners volunteered
in orphanages that had been set up inside the Cambodian refugee camps along the Thai border, cre-
ating a historical and conceptual foundation for volunteering in orphanages located inside Cambodia
after repatriation (Duchateau-Arminjon, 2013).
One of the first discussions of orphanage tourism in the scholarly literature is Richter and Norman
(2010, p. 217) who report coining the term ‘‘orphan tourism” to mean ‘‘travel to residential care facil-
ities, volunteering for generally short periods of time as caregivers.” However, the term has been used
in Cambodia at least since the 2007 Phnom Penh Post headline ‘‘Orphanage tourism: a questionable
industry” (Shelton & Rith, 2007), to refer to a range of experiences, including being a spectator at chil-
dren’s dance performances, bringing donations, playing with children, giving formal or informal Eng-
lish classes, or just viewing the premises. In the scholarly literature, the requirement that the
experience be short-term is criterial. Reas (2013) stipulates that it refers to experiences lasting fewer
than six months, and Guiney & Mostafanezhad (2014, p. 2) define it as ‘‘the donation of money and
goods, attending performances or volunteering on a short-term basis at orphanages as part of one’s
holiday.” While the referential meaning of the term therefore varies, uses are linked by negative con-
notations, and most discussions in the scholarly literature are cautionary in nature (Verstraete, 2014).
While Richter and Norman (2010) emphasize the risk of attachment disorders for children who inter-
act with an ever-changing stream of transient volunteers, Reas (2013, p. 126) focuses her critique on
the commodification of Cambodian orphans even as orphanage tourism fails to address the ‘‘funda-
mental inequalities between the needy and the benevolent.” Wilson (2015) stresses the inadequate
child protection policies and practices of many organizations that rely on volunteers, highlighting par-
ticularly the vulnerabilities that can be exacerbated by residential care, causing excessive potential for
child abuse and exploitation. Focusing primarily on sex abuse, she points out that not only are most
volunteers unfamiliar with appropriate ways to interact with children who are survivors of or at risk of
abuse, but volunteers themselves can be abusers. Guiney & Mostafanezhad (2014) show how an anti-
orphanage tourism campaign that has arisen in Cambodia can insightfully be analyzed as arising in
response to neoliberal forces commodifying children in a situation of double movement as proposed
by Polanyi (2001 [1944]). Taking all these analyses as a point of departure, this paper will address
questions they leave unresolved, such as why the anti-orphanage tourism campaign has taken the
form it has, and why orphanages continue to proliferate despite the success of the campaign, by exam-
ining how implicit unquestioned assumptions about childhood have shaped both sides of the double
This research is primarily theoretical and exploratory, intercalating the lenses of childhood studies
with more established approaches to orphanage tourism. However, in order to ground it empirically
and to provide illustrations for purposes of clarity, a qualitative conventional content analysis (Hsieh,
2005) was conducted, using an inductive approach to identify themes that emerged as relevant to the
intersection of childhood and tourism studies. Using the search strings ‘volunteer orphanage Cambo-
dia,’ ‘orphanage Cambodia’ and ‘orphanage tourism Cambodia,’ a snowball approach was used to col-
lect texts from personal blogs, travel forums and orphanage, volunteer agency and NGO websites.
Although Cambodia is a popular destination for Asian tourists and, increasingly, volunteers, in this
research only the anglophone media has been examined. Collection of texts was begun in 2011 and
has continued through 2015. Since Google’s search algorithm precludes any assumption of random-
ness in the sample of texts, a large number were targeted for analysis, under the assumption that this
would ensure representativeness, if not randomness. In all, a total of 100 texts, 50 testimonials of
returned volunteers and 50 criticisms of volunteering, were first read in order to identify relevant
themes. In order to be added to the corpus, both criticisms and testimonials were required to be spon-
taneous, unprompted, and unrenumerated. In other words, volunteer testimonials were not added to
K. Carpenter / Annals of Tourism Research 55 (2015) 15–27 17
the collection if they were prompted with specific questions, as is common on some user reviews, and
reports from formal media, such as online newspapers, were not part of the collection. Some keyword
searches were conducted to quantify how many texts contained particular themes and will be pro-
vided where relevant, but they are meant only as an indication of the salience of particular themes,
and are not intended to imply statistical significance; excerpts are meant to serve primarily as illus-
trations. The analysis of primary data from online sources, known as digital ethnography (Underberg &
Zorn, 2013) or netnography (Mkono & Markwell, 2014), has the virtues of comprehensiveness, authen-
ticity and verbatim accuracy. Online communities’ ‘‘candor and richness” (Mkono & Markwell, 2014, p.
290) reveal what posters choose to disclose, reflecting subjective importance, rather than what a
researcher might think to ask them. It has been convincingly argued that ‘‘weblogs do not represent
a radical departure from more established media of communication” (Haas, 2005), but the relationship
between how people express themselves on blogs and how they communicate in more established
modes of communication remain a topic for further research. Although all excerpts used for illustra-
tion are part of the public record, names and sources have been removed for purposes of
This purposive sampling of online texts was originally inspired by the author’s previous research
project pertaining to the lived experience of children in Siem Reap orphanages, done through
participant-observation in four separate visits over three years. In the course of conducting that study,
it became clear that tourists and volunteers were important factors in the children’s lives because they
interacted regularly with the children and because the resources they provided were essential for the
operating costs of several orphanages. While the results of that study are not directly relevant to the
current investigation, they provided an initial point of entry as well as motivation for pursuing this
research in the first place.
Definition and delineation of orphanage tourism
The definitional boundary between ‘volunteering’ and ‘orphanage tourism’ is complicated by
socially constructed norms concerning appropriate adult interaction with children (Lancy, 2010),
including a privileging of particularistic models of how children learn and the prevalent Western belief
that childhood is a state of preparation, rather than a legitimate state of being in its own right
(Uprichard, 2008). As discussed above, whereas the scholarly literature focuses on short duration as
criterial in distinguishing between orphanage tourism and volunteering, even very short-term visitors
do not refer to themselves as orphanage tourists. In popular discourse, the activities performed, rather
than the length of time, are criterial. In particular, visitors who spend their time playing with the chil-
dren consider themselves to be legitimate volunteers and speak proudly of the time they spend play-
ing. The theme of play was very salient in volunteers’ testimonials, with 26 out of the 50 using the
word ‘play’ when describing their experiences, as illustrated in the following excerpts:
‘‘I know it’s important,” [name of volunteer] said. ‘‘They don’t have family, so I like to just play with
them. I took every opportunity I could before we had to leave.”
‘‘In fact the greatest highlights were simply being with children and the friendships I made. I hope
though, that by being with them, reading stories, playing games, talking and generally caring for
and taking an interest in them, that they can enjoy being children a bit longer.”
‘‘My favourite moment was playing with the kids outside in the afternoons and seeing them
‘‘We spent around 3 or 4 hours playing with them, we were absolutely sweating in 30+ heat run-
ning around with kids on our shoulders! We all had so much fun together. It’s a lovely feeling
knowing we enriched their lives as they enriched ours.”
At the same time, a belief in childhood as primarily a time of preparation, rather than a way of
being in the world in its own right, leads to the evaluation of children’s activities in terms of how well
they position children for adulthood rather than whether or not children find playing with the visitors
fun, leading to critics’ perception that volunteers who play with children are motivated by self-
18 K. Carpenter / Annals of Tourism Research 55 (2015) 15–27
indulgence and are not performing legitimate volunteer activities, as illustrated in the excerpt below,
which explicitly criticizes the fact that volunteers spend their time playing with the children rather
than performing more putatively valuable activities with them:
‘‘If you know anything about the voluntourism trend, you know that 99.999% of the tourists have
absolutely no credentials whatsoever. And if you work with children then you should also know
that having tourists pop in to play with the kids for a week or two does absolutely nothing for
the children and is simply done to give the tourist the warm fuzzies.”
The critique of volunteers who just play represents an ongoing contestation concerning the chang-
ing social construction of childhood. As children have been disconnected from the workplace during
the 19th and 20th centuries, children’s play has been reinterpreted to have critical functions beyond
amusement, crystalized into the widely repeated dictum ‘‘play is children’s work” (Rivera, 2009, p. 17).
Adult play with children has become highly valorised as a legitimate form of care provision, elevating
it ‘‘to the level of an exportable social good” (Lancy, 2007, p. 273). Foreign visitors to orphanages often
note negatively that staff rarely play with children (Wang, 2010), and providers and parents are
advised that ‘‘Children often need adult help play” so adults should not just observe, but should
‘‘participate” and ‘‘model” ideal forms of play (Extension, 2014). Thus, it can be seen that even the
choice to use the term ‘orphanage tourist’ rather than ‘volunteer’, reveals as much about the implicit
assumptions about childhood borne by the speaker as it does about objective circumstances.
Motivations for orphanage tourism
Motivation has been called the social sciences’ ‘‘most vexed question” (Dann, 2005; quoting Weber,
1968), and this question is especially vexed in the case of Cambodian orphanage tourism. As the num-
ber of children without living parents has decreased, orphanage tourism has increased. Why is it gath-
ering momentum just as the need for orphanages in Cambodia appears to be dwindling? Like
volunteer tourism in general, orphanage tourism is richly overdetermined, because, in addition to fac-
tors driving volunteer tourism more generally such as altruism, the search for a transformative expe-
rience, self-healing and intimacy (Alomari, 2002; McGehee, 2014; Wearing & McGehee, 2013),
orphanage tourism is also motivated by perceptions of childhood, with a historical trajectory separate
from, but overlapping with, the history of tourism.
The quest for a transformative experience is often considered a primary motivation for volun-
tourism (Knollenberg, McGehee, Bynum Boley, & Clemmons, 2014) and this is amplified when the vol-
unteering involves orphans, who are themselves one of the most potent symbols of transformation in
Western literature. Although typically characterized as materially and socially vulnerable, orphans are
paradoxically powerful in their ability to effect a transformation, because by helping orphans, adults
become better people, morally and emotionally (Avery, 1994; Kimball, 1999). Many volunteer testi-
monials conform very closely to the schema of the adult who is transformed into a better human being
through helping orphans, and the expectation of this transformation probably motivates many volun-
teers. The following excerpts illustrate how explicit the theme of transformation is in volunteers’ tes-
timonials, which was found in 36% of them:
‘‘We taught English at an orphanage and the School for Orphans. Although we were there to teach
the children, we found that the values we learnt from them are ones that we will carry with us for
the rest of our lives.”
‘‘I taught English there for a time, but it seems that the children taught me a few things also, they
taught me the true meaning of life & love, & what it is to be human. I will remember those kids &
their lessons for the rest of my life.”
‘‘...the children truly touched my heart and altered my direction in life.”
Adults’ use of orphans as instruments of transformation is an example of the kind of affective con-
tribution that has increasingly come to replace the economic contributions that children once made.
As Zelizer has famously pointed out, the modern child has become at once economically ‘‘useless”, but
K. Carpenter / Annals of Tourism Research 55 (2015) 15–27 19
emotionally ‘‘priceless” (Zelizer, 1994). Consequently, children’s economic contributions to household
finances, once considered routine, are now considered exploitative while the affective contributions
expected from children have become more important. Since the 19th century, the trope of childhood
innocence has become dominant, but this automatic association of childhood, and especially orphan-
hood, with innocence is by no means globally ubiquitous (Lancy, 2008). The centrality of innocence to
minority world
constructions of childhood helps foreigners to reconcile the dissonance they experience
when their internalized ideology of individual accountability is confronted with majority world poverty
for the first time. Raised to hold individuals rather than historical and structural factors as primary deter-
minants of success or failure, at the same time young travelers cannot help but be moved by poverty, a
response that is capitalized on explicitly in imagery used to market volunteer opportunities by agencies
(Zeddies, 2013). They are invited to help children, who because they are innocent, cannot be held
accountable for their own poverty. Calkin (2014, p. 34) speaks of the ‘‘deep ambivalence volunteers feel
toward poverty” as a ‘‘marker of authenticity and otherness”; volunteering with orphans is a way to rec-
oncile some of the tensions inherent in that ambivalence.
Motivations can become conventionalized over time so that reasons that were meaningful to pre-
vious visitors are sometimes unexamined by later ones, particularly when they bolster cultural scripts
that are already well-developed, such as the largely unquestioned expectation that one should volun-
teer, which is particularly well developed in the current cohort of teenagers and twenty-somethings.
And, while Calkin (2014) proposes that volunteer tourism ‘‘assigns a homogeneous otherness to all
destination countries” (p. 37), patterns can be destination-specific as well. For example, while tourism
and voluntourism have both been critiqued for involving an element of voyeurism (Scheyvens, 2010),
Hughes (2008) argues that visitors to Cambodia in the late 1990s were provoked by the paucity of
interpretive materials into interpreting their own experience as an act of bearing witness rather than
one of entertainment, stimulating an orientation toward Cambodia distinct from consumption in the
conventional sense. Hughes’ interviewees spoke of a ‘‘moral imperative” to visit unpleasant sites,
framing their relationship to Cambodia in terms of ‘‘duty,” often as a prelude to ‘‘the shuttling from
a tourist subjectivity to that of a humanitarian actor” (p. 327). This reorientation encouraged many
visitors to genocide memorials to seek volunteer opportunities in sites such as orphanages. However,
many of the insights experienced firsthand by Hughes’ interviewees are today fossilized as a conven-
tional perception of Cambodia which has led to a proliferation of, and intense competition among,
development organizations and aid workers, in addition to volunteers. A striking aspect of prospective
volunteers’ inquiries online is how often no motivation or justification for volunteering in an orphan-
age is provided – out of the 50 testimonials analyzed, only three gave any kind of explanation or moti-
vation. Just as conventionalized Western narratives of Cambodia construct the ‘‘tourist gaze” (Urry,
1990) as an act of bearing witness and construct Cambodia as a site for humanitarian intervention,
so do conventionalized Western perceptions of orphans construct them as sites for adult intervention;
the confluence of the two narratives leads to an unquestioned perception of volunteering in a Cambo-
dian orphanage as simply what one does. The following examples of inquiries from prospective vol-
unteers on travel forums reflect how volunteering has become a normalized expectation among
young people (Friedland & Morimoto, 2005, p. 16) who ‘‘simply assume that these activities are what
they should do, and need to do” (Friedland & Morimoto, 2005, p. 11):
‘‘Has anyone had any experience with this? I was looking at going back to Cambodia in July and
thought I might as well volunteer rather than just travel.”
‘‘I will have a free month in Cambodia or Thailand and I was thinking to do some volunteering work
during this time.”
For many young travelers the overseas volunteer experience is a logical sequel to volunteering they
have been doing at home, with rates as high as 70% among U.S. high school seniors (Bound, Hershbein,
& Long, 2009). In other words, volunteering while traveling internationally shares continuities with a
In much of the childhood studies literature, it is customary to use the term ‘minority world’ for countries that are also referred
to as high HDI, wealthy, Western, Global North and/or developed. Countries referred to as low HDI, less wealthy, non-Western,
Global South and/or developing are referred to as ‘majority world’.
20 K. Carpenter / Annals of Tourism Research 55 (2015) 15–27
popular domestic pastime, consonant with a recent recognition of the importance of ‘‘ordinary expe-
riences” that has gained more attention in studies of tourism (Blichfeldt & Mikkelsen, 2014), in con-
trast to a tradition of research which is focused on the allure of difference for travelers (McCabe,
2002). Critics of orphanage tourism often use prompts such as ‘‘If you want to work with children
in Cambodia, first, ask yourself if you are qualified to work with children at home?” (Goldberg,
2013) to elicit a voluntary decision to cancel volunteering plans, but their point is lost on many young
travelers who already have internalized volunteering with children as the unmarked case.
Consequences of orphanage tourism
The potential consequences of orphanage tourism are particularly concerning to its critics. It is gen-
erally accepted that visitors’ eagerness to volunteer and make donations encourages the proliferation
of new orphanages as an entrepreneurial niche (Tuovinen, 2014), undermining Cambodian families by
pulling children into residential care unnecessarily (Clark, 2014). The Cambodian government reports
that three-fourths of children residing in orphanages have at least one living parent (NGOCRC, 2013;
UNICEF, 2009), a figure generally interpreted as evidence of widespread deception. However, just as
childhood is a social construction as much as it is a biological reality, the word ‘orphan’ is also cultur-
ally informed and does not map perfectly from one language into another. In Khmer, kamprea, usually
translated as ‘orphan’, is closer in meaning to ‘waif’ or ‘foundling’, that is, a child who lacks parental
care for whatever reason, not necessarily because both parents are dead. This discrepancy in usage
accounts for a mismatch in expectations that underlies some of the controversy over the pull factors
created by orphanage tourism. Cambodians can use it in good faith to refer to children with one or two
living parents, even as foreigners feel that deception or corruption is involved.
In addition to concerns about the undermining of families, there is also the concern that orphanage
tourism, especially visitors’ donations, may be creating dependency and may be unsustainable
(McGehee, 2012), especially in the context of Cambodia’s already heavy dependence on foreign aid
(Ear, 2012). These concerns inform perceptions of the popular volunteer activity of teaching English
to children in orphanages. Criticisms revolve around both the volunteers’ lack of professionalism
and their preference for teaching children rather than adult English teachers (Holmberg, 2014;
Lancy, 2010; Tuovinen, 2014), as shown in the criticisms below:
Do think hard about what skills you have that will make a difference to the children; teaching them
to sing nursery rhymes in English is not going to do much for their future.
Even teaching English to kids (a popular short-term stint) has been proven conclusively to be at
best mildly entertaining, and at worst a waste of everybody’s time.
However, these criticisms do not reflect current scholarship on how language is best learned. Most
interactions among volunteers and resident children are marked by the characteristics of immersion
learning, namely language which ‘‘is used for real communication in meaningful, contextually-rich
settings” (Cummins & Swain, 2014, p. 57). Immersion language learning can be very effective for chil-
dren, especially in a setting that is marked with fun and playful interactions with slightly older com-
panions, such as the youth who are the majority of volunteer English teachers at orphanages. Although
volunteers are often advised that for their efforts to be truly sustainable, they should teach English to
adult Cambodian teachers rather than to children (ConCERT, n.d.), an important practical considera-
tion is that children usually learn a new language more effectively than adults (Gursoy & Akin, 2013).
Volunteer testimonials consistently report that English proficiency is on average higher among
children in orphanages than it is among children who have only studied in the public school system,
and the following observations, while anecdotal, suggest that progress is being made in the children’s
acquisition of English even though many of the teachers are inexperienced and turnover is high:
‘‘The children speak better English than some of the staff.”
‘‘We had such an amazing time, singing songs, playing games and, at the same time, learning
K. Carpenter / Annals of Tourism Research 55 (2015) 15–27 21
‘‘Most of the work was dictation which, as a future teacher, seemed quite boring a lot of the time. I
would usually mix it up by adding in a few word games, drawing games, etc, which the kids loved!”
‘‘Thus, our structured time with the orphans focused on development of English skills. (Name) and I
did not speak a lick of Khmer, so even our free time spent with them pushed along this agenda.”
‘‘Unfortunately, the kids here may have a better chance of succeeding than kids who come from
solid family backgrounds.”
Despite the certainty with which critics dismiss the value of volunteer efforts to engage children
using English, the arguments are based on implicit values and assumptions about child development,
rather than objective evidence. No formal research has compared English skills of resident and non-
resident Cambodian children, although there is evidence from the domain of reading tutoring that
minimally trained college students, enlisted in many cases simply because they needed the income
rather than any altruistic motivation, can significantly improve the reading outcomes of at-risk chil-
dren (Fitzgerald, 2001).
An additional contribution that can be made by applying a more thorough knowledge of child
development to the study of orphanage tourism pertains to the risk of attachment disorders due to
high turnover and short duration of most visits. This concern has been repeated relatively uncritically
in anti-orphanage tourism literature (Richter & Norman, 2010; Walker & Hartley, 2013) but the usage
reflects some misunderstanding. Attachment disorder refers to permanent deficits due to care depri-
vation or instability in the first three years of life, and its causes, symptoms and prevalence are in fact
quite controversial (Quinn & Mageo, 2013). However, the attachment literature is very clear that it is
children under the age of three who are at risk, and attachment disorder should be diagnosable by age
five (Zeanah & Gleason, 2010). It is not a risk for children who are placed in institutions after age five,
as is usually the case in Cambodia because that is when the lack of educational opportunities in rural
areas becomes an issue. Children may become very fond of volunteers, and they may be sad when they
leave, but it is not accurate to refer to this sadness as attachment disorder, nor to assume that it is
inevitably harmful.
Cambodia’s anti-orphanage tourism campaign
Since much debate concerning volunteer tourism surrounds its potential to contribute to host soci-
eties’ wellbeing weighted against the ways it may be inherently commodifying and even destructive
(Butcher & Smith, 2010; Godfrey & Wearing, 2012), the need for research into evaluation and regula-
tion of volunteer tourism is widely recognized (Taplin, Dredge, & Scherrer, 2014), consonant with
McGehee’s (2014, p. 849) call for ‘‘criteria to strive for in order to curb the example of irresponsible
and unethical volunteer tourism.” Although common approaches to monitoring emphasize the role
of formal regulation (Fee & Mdee, 2010, chap. 15), an anti-orphanage tourism campaign that has
arisen in Cambodia provides an alternative model of self-regulation among orphanages, volunteer
agencies and visitors themselves. The campaign has been analyzed by Guiney & Mostafanezhad
(2014) as an example of double movement, based on Polanyi’s prediction that resistance will sponta-
neously arise in response to the dislocations caused by unregulated economic interests encroaching
into the personal and affective sphere. This analysis explains how effective regulation can originate
outside of formal state policies. However, it raises the more basic question of how any regulation
can appropriately determine best practices across different cultural settings, particularly in a domain
as contested and affectively charged as childhood. To illustrate, I will first give a brief history of the
anti-orphanage tourism campaign, then show how it is based on a universalization and naturalization
of particularistic social constructions of childhood.
In 2005 Friends-International, a respected NGO serving children living and/or working on the
streets of Phnom Penh, began an initiative called ChildSafe, which offered training to drivers, hotel
staff and others employed in tourism so they could respond to child exploitation and endangerment
(Friends-International, 2007a). Orphanages were not the original focus, but were included as places
where it was particularly easy for predators to gain access to children. Volunteers and tourists were
enlisted as allies in efforts to prevent exploitation, and were educated to patronize only individuals
22 K. Carpenter / Annals of Tourism Research 55 (2015) 15–27
and establishments that had made the ChildSafe commitment. While volunteer tourists still tend to
see themselves as central to the solution, many resident aid workers have come to see them as central
to the problem instead, and as the campaign has gathered momentum, the focus has shifted from con-
cerns about the potential for sexual exploitation in orphanages to concerns about orphanages per se. In
2011, Friends-International launched the ‘‘Children are not tourist attractions” campaign, specifically
targeting orphanage tourism and drawing on a children’s rights-based framework, with a particular
focus on the child’s right to privacy and dignity.
As a model for self-regulation in the absence of effective government enforcement of minimum
standards, the campaign has been quite successful, but it is vital to recognize how fundamentally
the campaign relies on imported minority world ideas about childhood. Rather than arising as a spon-
taneous social movement as predicted by Polanyi, it was intentionally designed by expatriate aid
workers in Western NGOs (Guiney & Mostafanezhad (2014)), and it remains thinly grafted onto Cam-
bodian society. Cambodian voices are largely missing from the campaign, as expatriate aid workers
use their own constructions of childhood, children’s rights, and the best interests of the child to inform
its goals and strategies. For example, research conducted by UNICEF and the Cambodian government
found that 92% of Cambodian family members agreed that a poor family should send a child to an
orphanage for education (UNICEF, 2011), suggesting that out-of-home residence is viewed somewhat
differently in Cambodia from how it is in the West (Carpenter, 2013, 2014). While poverty is widely
regarded as the driving force behind orphanage placements of children with living parents, the same
study indicates that fewer than half are placed solely because of poverty. In Cambodia, the primary
reason families place their children in orphanages is that they believe that children’s educational
opportunities will be greater there, and, as several research projects have documented, they often
are (Emond, 2009; Whetten et al., 2009).
The anti-orphanage tourism campaign is largely inspired by a rights-based approach as formalized
in the Convention on the Rights of the Child, especially the guiding principle of best interests of the
child, which is subject to a great deal of individual and cultural interpretation. In particular, although
all rights are intended to be inalienable with none privileged with respect to any other, in complex
situations they necessarily come into conflict, and the choice of which to prioritize in cases of conflict
inevitably is based on culture-specific values. For example, the anti-orphanage tourism campaign sin-
gles out the right to privacy as paramount, and violations of children’s dignity are seen as especially
egregious (Friends-International, 2007b). However, in situations of educational deprivation, the right
to privacy may not be as important to stakeholders as the right to education is, and dignity can be
accrued in many different ways. The right to dignity is interpreted in anti-orphanage tourism narra-
tives as primarily a right not to ‘‘be exposed to strangers in their own home” (ChildSafe Traveler Tips,
n.d.), rather than, say, a right to the dignity that comes from working as a contributing member of a
family and community (Alcala et al., 2014), such as performing as dancers in orphanage fundraisers. In
the idealized minority world childhood, responsibility flows in only one direction, from the parent to
the child, thus pathologizing children’s own contributions, but this is far from universal. In many parts
of the world, it is believed that contributing to household resources may be not only necessary, but
even that ‘‘working is good for children” (Sinervo, 2011, p. 170). Children’s work is not universally
viewed as exploitation, and children can derive satisfaction and dignity from being able to contribute
to their own and others’ wellbeing.
Similarly, the campaign’s interpretation of the child’s right to family care privileges certain ideals of
family configuration over others. The view of family as a mother, a father and their minor dependent
children residing under one roof precludes the possibility of a longer-term view allowing for the fam-
ily to be strengthened rather than undermined if children leave home in order to enhance their abil-
ities to make contributions later on. Article 47 of the Cambodian constitution frames children’s rights
in a reciprocal, lifelong manner: ‘‘Parents shall have the duty to take care of and educate their children
to become good citizens. Children shall have the duty to take good care of their elderly parents accord-
ing to Khmer customs.” For many families, prioritizing the child’s right to education, along with the
reciprocal nature of responsibility to the family unit, logically leads to residential care as a desirable
choice, and the many young foreigners who enthusiastically practice English with their children are
seen as a tremendous boon.
K. Carpenter / Annals of Tourism Research 55 (2015) 15–27 23
The Cambodian anti-orphanage tourism campaign has come to dominate the global discourse on
orphanages. However, as it has spread through the global media, some themes have been selectively
amplified, while others have become less salient. The original Friends-International campaign focused
on the inherent exploitativeness of strangers’ access to children’s place of residence, and to the prob-
lem of families being misled into believing that their children’s material and educational circum-
stances will be improved. However, secondary reports, especially in the media, tend to focus on the
way that the volunteers are being duped because resident children are often revealed to have at least
one living parent, framing naive volunteers as the victims, rather than the children. Headlines such as
‘‘Scambodia ‘fake’ orphans” (Cambodia Forum, 2011), ‘‘Cambodia’s orphanages target the wallets of
well-meaning tourists” (Carmichael, 2011) and ‘‘In Cambodia, fake orphanages soak up donations
by duping tourists” (Hruby, 2014) all appear to cast the volunteers as the ones who are being exploited
because the resident children are not real orphans. Why does the fact that many resident children
have at least one living parent disturb foreigners so much, particularly since, as previously discussed,
the Khmer word that translates as ‘orphan’ contains no requirement that both of the child’s parents be
deceased? The answer has to do with the orphan trope and its value to volunteers. Seeking a transfor-
mative experience, visitors feel duped because fake orphans are not transformative. Foreigners posi-
tion themselves as the true victims in the scenario, because they were duped into feeling sorry for
children who are not real orphans, and who therefore cannot provide the kind of transformative expe-
rience that they are expecting.
This paper has shown several ways in which childhood studies can contribute to a deeper under-
standing of important issues in volunteer tourism. In particular, it has shown how naturalizing and
universalizing socially constructed values and beliefs about childhood contribute to both the wide-
spread desire to volunteer with children, and to the strong reaction against widespread volunteering
with children. Understanding all stakeholders’, especially prospective volunteers’, cultural schemata
of childhood can also shed light on complex issues that have been recognized throughout the volun-
teer tourism literature as needing further elucidation, such as motivations. Prospective volunteers in
Cambodian orphanages are motivated by belief in orphans’ transformative power, and by the ability of
childhood innocence to reconcile conflicting perceptions of poverty and individual accountability.
Similarly, critics of orphanage tourism often assume idealized family compositions and roles and
responsibilities based on minority world constructions of childhood and children’s rights. In addition,
understanding and not overgeneralizing constructs from child development, such as attachment the-
ory and language acquisition, can lead to a more accurate understanding of the consequences of
orphanage tourism.
This paper has necessarily opted for breadth over depth, thus paving the way for future research
investigating all of these areas in greater depth and detail. For example, while in this paper it has been
proposed that common metaphorical and literary uses of childhood influence both the decision to vol-
unteer and the meaning with which that experience is afterwards imbued, conducting interviews to
complement the online sources would provide greater insight into the extent to which this is signif-
icant. Anecdotal reports concerning the relative effectiveness of playful immersion with volunteers
compared with more didactic approaches to teaching English need to be verified with research to
resolve whether or not untrained volunteers are really wasting children’s time, or whether they are
really enhancing children’s English language proficiency. In addition, while volunteer tourism has
been widely analyzed as a historical outgrowth from tourism more generally, the extent to which it
shares historical continuities with other phenomena, such as domestic volunteering and local models
of children’s services provision, could provide new ways of thinking about volunteer tourism more
To question implicit and deeply held assumptions about the nature of childhood does not entail a
lack of concern for the vulnerabilities of children, nor a lack of compassion for the lived experience of
the many children in Cambodia who grapple with the challenges caused by poverty and other social
problems that arise in post-conflict societies. However, implicit assumptions need to be recognized
24 K. Carpenter / Annals of Tourism Research 55 (2015) 15–27
and interrogated dispassionately precisely because discussions of children generate so much emotion.
Certainly, there is much that is concerning about the rise of unregulated orphanage tourism and the
potential for harm that accompanies it. But critiques are more credible when they are anchored firmly
in accurate understandings of phenomena and their actual consequences, and concerns about chil-
dren’s wellbeing are best served when one is as informed as possible about childhood and child
The author wishes to thank the Center for Khmer Studies for the Senior Faculty Research Fellow-
ship that made this research possible, as well as the many children, staff and community members
in Cambodia who remain anonymous to preserve their privacy, but whose generous sharing of time
and insights provides the foundation for this study.
Alcala, L., Rogoff, B., Mejia-Arauz, R., Coppens, A., & Dexter, A. (2014). Children’s initiative in contributions to family work in
indigenous-heritage and cosmopolitan communities in Mexico. Human Development, 57, 96–115.
Alomari, T. (2002). Motivation and socio-cultural sustainability of voluntourism (MA thesis). University of Lethbridge. <http://> (Accessed 2/
Avery, G. (1994). Behold the child: American children and their books, 1621–1922. London: The Bodley Head.
Blichfeldt, B. S. & Mikkelsen, M. (2014). The extraordinariness of ordinariness in tourism research. In: Proceedings of 3rd
Interdisciplinary Tourism Research Conference, Istanbul, Turkey (pp. 83–88).
Bluebond-Langner, M., & Korbin, J. E. (2007). Challenges and opportunities in the anthropology of childhoods: An introduction
to ‘‘Children, Childhoods and Childhood Studies”. American Anthropologist, 109(2), 241–246.
Bound, J., Hershbein, B., & Long, B. T. (2009). Playing the admissions game: Student reactions to increasing college competition.
Journal of Economic Perspectives, 23(4), 119–146.
Butcher, J., & Smith, P. (2010). ‘Making a difference’: Volunteer tourism and development. Tourism Recreation Research, 35(1),
Calkin, S. (2014). Mind the ‘gap year’: A critical discourse analysis of volunteer tourism promotional material. Global Discourse:
An Interdisciplinary Journal of Current Affairs and Applied Contemporary Thought, 4(1), 30–43.
Cambodia Forum. (2011). Scambodia ‘fake’ orphans.<>
(Accessed 2/2/2015).
Carmicheal, R. (2011). Cambodia’s orphanages target the wallets of well-meaning tourists. The Independent 3/25/2011.
Carpenter, K. (2013). Continuity, complexity and reciprocity in a Cambodian orphanage. Children & Society, 29(2), 85–94.
Carpenter, K. (2014). Using orphanage spaces to combat envy and stigma. Children, Youth and Environments, 24(1), 124–137.
ChildSafe Traveler Tips (n.d.) <> (Accessed
Clark, F. (2014). If We reintegrate six babies, someone else will institutionalize eight (MA thesis). Lund University. <
se/luur/download?func=downloadFile&recordOId=4438756&fileOId=4496722> (Accessed 2/25/2015).
ConCERT. (n.d.). Responsible volunteering.<> (Accessed 2/25/2015).
Conran, Mary. (2011). They really love me! Intimacy in volunteer tourism. Annals of Tourism Research, 38, 1454–1473.
Crick, Malcolm. (1989). The hippy in Sri Lanka: A symbolic analysis of the imagery of school children in Kandy. Chai: Criticism
Heresy and Interpretation, 3, 37–54.
Cummins, J., & Swain, M. (2014). Bilingualism in education: Aspects of theory, research and practice. New York: Routledge.
Dann, G. M. S. (2005). The theoretical state of the art in the sociology and anthropology of tourism. Tourism Analysis, 10, 3–15.
Duchateau-Arminjon, B. (2013). Healing Cambodia one child at a time. Singapore: Editions Didier Millet.
Ear, S. (2012). Aid dependence in Cambodia: How foreign assistance undermines democracy. New York: Columbia University Press.
Einarsdottir, J. (2007). Research with children: Methodological and ethical challenges. European Early Childhood Education
Research Journal, 15(2), 197–211.
Emond, R. (2009). I am all about the future world: Cambodian children’s views on their status as orphans. Children & Society, 23
(6), 407–417.
Extension. (2014). <>
(Accessed 2/2/2015).
Fee, L., & Mdee, A. (2010). How does it make a difference? Towards ‘accreditation’ of the development impact of volunteer
tourism. In A. M. Benson (Ed.), Volunteer tourism. London: Routledge. Available at: <
Fitzgerald, Jill. (2001). Can minimally trained college student volunteers help young at-risk children to read better? Reading
Research Quarterly, 36(1), 28–47.
Friedland, L. A. & Morimoto, S. (2005). The changing lifeworlds of young people: Risk, resume-padding and civic engagement. Circle
Working Paper 40 (September 2005). The Center for Information and Research on Civic Learning and Engagement.
Friends-International. (2007a). ChildSafe International.<> (Accessed 2/5/2015).
Friends-International. (2007b). Annual Technical Report. Available online at: <
resources.asp?mm=au&sm=rs> (Accessed 9/9/14).
K. Carpenter / Annals of Tourism Research 55 (2015) 15–27 25
Gamradt, J. (1995). Jamaican children’s representations of tourism. Annals of Tourism Research, 22(4), 735–762. MA: Imaginary
Godfrey, J., & Wearing, S. (2012). Can volunteer tourism be more than just the successful commodification of altruism? In
CAUTHE 2012: The new golden age of tourism and hospitality: Book 2: Proceedings of the 22nd annual conference (pp. 188–192).
Melbourne, Vic: La Trobe University.
Goldberg, L. (2013). Move to Cambodia: A guide to living and working in the kingdom of wonder. North Adams, MA: Imaginary
Guiney, T. (2012). ’Orphanage tourism’ in Cambodia: When residential care becomes tourist attractions. Pacific News, 38, 9–14.
Guiney, T., & Mostafanezhad, M. (2014). The political economy of orphanage tourism in Cambodia. Tourist Studies,
1468797614563387, 1–24.
Gursoy, E., & Akin, F. (2013). Is younger really better? Anxiety about learning a foreign language in Turkish children. Social
Behavior and Personality, 41(5), 827–842.
Guttentag, D. A. (2009). The possible negative impacts of volunteer tourism. International Journal of Tourism Research, 11,
Haas, T. (2005). From ‘‘public journalism” to the ‘‘public’s journalism”? Rhetoric and reality in the discourse on weblogs.
Journalism Studies, 6(3), 387–396.
Holmberg, B. (2014). The orphan and the saviour – A relationship of love, gratitude and commodities (MA thesis). Stockholm
Hruby, D. (2014). In Cambodia, fake orphanages soak up donations by duping tourists. Los Angeles Daily News. 7/21/2014.
Hsieh, H. F., & Shannon, S. E. (2005). Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qualitative Health Research, 15(9),
Hughes, R. (2008). Dutiful tourism: Encountering the Cambodian genocide. Asia Pacific Viewpoint, 49(3), 318–330.
Kidron, C. A. (2013). Being there together: Dark family tourism and the emotive experience of co-presence in the holocaust past.
Annals of Tourism Research, 41, 175–194.
Kimball, M. A. (1999). From folktales to fiction: Orphan characters in children’s literature. Library Trends, 47(3), 558–578.
Knollenberg, W., McGehee, N. G., Bynum Boley, B., & Clemmons, D. (2014). Motivation-based transformative learning and
potential volunteer tourists: Facilitating more sustainable outcomes. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 22(6), 922–941.
Lancy, D. F. (2007). Accounting for variability in mother–child play. American Anthropologist, 109(2), 273–284.
Lancy, D. F. (2008). The anthropology of childhood: Cherubs, chattel, changelings. Cambridge University Press.
Lancy, D. F. (2010). Learning ‘from nobody’: The limited role of teaching in folk models of children’s development. Childhood in
the Past, 3, 79–106.
McCabe, S. (2002). The tourist experience and everyday life. In G. M. Dann (Ed.), The tourist as a metaphor of the social world
(pp. 61–75). Wallingford, UK: CABI Publishing.
McGehee, N. G. (2012). Oppression, emancipation and volunteer tourism. Annals of Tourism Research, 39(1), 84–107.
McGehee, N. G. (2014). Volunteer tourism: Evolution, issues and futures. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 22(6), 847–854.
Mkono, M., & Markwell, K. (2014). The application of netnography in tourism studies. Annals of Tourism Research, 48, 289–291.
Montgomery, H. (2008). Buying innocence: Child-sex tourists in Thailand. Third World Quarterly, 29(5), 903–917.
NGO Coalition on the Rights of the Child (NGOCRC) UPR Submission on Cambodia Child Rights. (2009–2013). <http://ngocrc.
UPRpercent20submissionpercent20onpercent20Childpercent20Rightspercent20inpercent20Cambodia.pdf> (Accessed 9/
Obrador, P. (2012). The place of the family in tourism research: Domesticity and thick sociality by the pool. Annals of Tourism
Research, 39(1), 401–420.
Polanyi, K. (2001). The great transformation. Boston: Beacon.
Poria, Y., & Timothy, D. J. (2014). Where are the children in tourism research? Annals of Tourism Research, 47, 93–95.
Pousson, E. (n.d.) Hebrew Orphan Asylum.<>
(Accessed 2/9/2015).
Quinn, N., & Mageo, J. M. (2013). Attachment reconsidered: Cultural perspectives on a western theory. Culture, Mind and Society
Series. Palgrave Macmillan.
Reas, P. J. (2013). ‘Boy, have we got a vacation for you’: Orphanage tourism in Cambodia and the commodification and
objectification of the orphanaged child. Thammasat Review, 16, 121–140.
Richter, L. M., & Norman, A. (2010). AIDS orphan tourism: A threat to young children in residential care. Vulnerable Children and
Youth Studies, 5, 217–229.
Rivera, M. (2009). The power of play. The hispanic outlook in higher education, 19(13), 17.
Scheyvens, R. (2010). Tourism and poverty. New York: Routledge.
Shelton, T., & Rith, S. (2007). Orphanage tourism: A questionable industry. The Phnom Penh Post. 9 March, 2007.
Sinervo, A. (2011). Appeals of childhood: Child vendors, volunteer tourists, and visions of aid in Cusco, Peru (Doctoral dissertation).
University of California, Santa Cruz.
Small, J. (2008). The absence of childhood in tourism studies. Annals of Tourism Research, 35(3), 772–789.
Taplin, J., Dredge, D., & Scherrer, P. (2014). Monitoring and evaluating volunteer tourism: A review and analytical framework.
Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 22(6), 874–897.
Tuovinen, H. (2014). Shadows of voluntourism and the connection to orphanage business in Asia and Cambodia (BA thesis). Haaga-
Helia University of Applied Sciences.
Underberg, N. M., & Zorn, E. (2013). Digital ethnography: Anthropology, narrative and new media. Austin, TX: University of Texas
UNICEF. (2009). Fact sheet, residential care in Cambodia. <
Cambodia.pdf> (Accessed 9/12/14).
UNICEF. (2011). With the best intentions: A study of attitudes towards residential care in Cambodia.<
Study_Attitudes_towards_RC.pdf> (Accessed 9/19/14).
Uprichard, E. (2008). Children as beings and becomings’: Children, childhood and temporality. Children & Society, 22, 303–313.
26 K. Carpenter / Annals of Tourism Research 55 (2015) 15–27
Urry, J. (1990). The tourist gaze-leisure and travel in contemporary societies. London: Sage.
Verstraete, J. (2014). The impact of orphanage tourism on residential care centres in Cambodia: A qualitative research (Masters
thesis). Leeds Metropolitan University <52513_Scriptie_vrijwilligerwerk_Cambodja_joni-verstraete.pdf>.
Walker, C., & Hartley, M. (2013). Cambodia’s orphan-industrial complex. The Atlantic. 6/3/2013.
Wang, L. K. (2010). Importing Western childhoods into a Chinese state-run orphanage. Qualitative Sociology, 33, 137–159.
Wearing, S. (2001). Volunteer tourism: Experiences that make a difference. UK: CABI Publishing, CAB International.
Wearing, S., & McGehee, N. G. (2013). Volunteer tourism: A review. Tourism Management, 38, 120–130.
Weber (1968). The theory of social and economic organization (A. Henderson & T. Parsons, Trans.). New York: Free Press.
Whetten, K., Ostermann, J., Whetten, R., Pence, B., O’Donnell, K., Messer, L., & Thielman, N. (2009). A comparison of the wellbeing
of orphans and abandoned children ages 6–12 in institutional and community-based care settings in 5 less wealthy nations.
PLoS One, 4. Article e8169.
Wilson, L. (2015). Finding the win–win: Providing supportive and enriching volunteer tourism experiences while promoting
sustainable social change. Worldwide Hospitality and Tourism Themes, 7(2), 201–207.
Zeanah, C. & Gleason, M. M. (2010). Reactive attachment disorder: A review for DSM-V. Report submitted to the American
Psychiatric Association.
Zeddies, M. (2013). A more united planet representations of children in voluntourism. VolunTourist Newsletter, 9(2). <http://> (Accessed 8/19/14).
Zelizer, V. (1994). Pricing the priceless child: The changing social value of children. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
K. Carpenter / Annals of Tourism Research 55 (2015) 15–27 27
... Recognizing the adverse effects of institutionalization on children's development and well-being (Petrowski et al., 2017), countries have strived to minimize the number of children in residential care (Dozier et al., 2014). In contrast to such efforts, orphanage tourism, a form of volunteer tourism that is 'characterized by travel to [residential care] facilities for children to engage in everyday caregiving' (Richter & Norman, 2010, p. 222), is believed to unnecessary retain and increase the number of children in residential care facilities (Carpenter 2015;Guiney 2017;Ursin & Skålevik 2018;van Doore 2016;Westerlaken, 2021). ...
... It poses concern in two aspects: sustaining unnecessary residential care facilities and lowering the quality of care for children. First, in several countries, orphanage tourism results in placing children in residential care facilities for profit even though they have living family members (Carpenter, 2015;Guiney, 2018;Ursin & Skålevik, 2018;van Doore, 2020). Guiney (2018) documented cases in Cambodia where orphanage directors actively recruited children from their families or paid the other institutions to buy their 'child overflow'. ...
... Past studies on orphanage tourism have focused on the motivations and perceived outcomes of the stakeholders directly involved in orphanage tourism, such as volunteers, orphanage staff, and intermediary agencies, using qualitative methods (e.g. Bargeman et al., 2018;Carpenter, 2014Carpenter, , 2015Freidus & Caro, 2021;Guiney, 2017;Proyrungroj, 2017). Using measures like in-depth interviews and ethnographic observations, previous studies conducted on-site research in developing Southeast Asian and African countries, such as Cambodia, Ghana, Malawi, Thailand, and Rwanda. ...
This study examined 106,979 tweets posted by 34,370 unique users from 2010 to 2019 to understand the sentiment of those indirectly involved in orphanage tourism and its change over time. The result from this study indicated that despite recent critiques of orphanage tourism, the conversations on orphanage volunteering were still largely positive. The persistence of positive sentiment toward orphanage tourism was due to fleeting critiques, the low rate of new critics joining the discourse, and the limited engagement of the existing users. The findings implied that there is a need for further anti-orphanage tourism campaigns and active recruitment of orphanage tourism critiques. The current study contributed to the limited literature on orphanage tourism by utilizing social media to extract valuable information about the perceptions of not only the directly involved stakeholders but also those indirectly involved.
... This chapter highlights a group of teaching certificates available "on the market" and several pandemic issues linked to the increasingly commoditized volunteer tourism and language learning/teaching industry. While pre-service training may not be feasible nor necessary for volunteers in all circumstances (see Carpenter, 2015), becoming TEFL certified has currency. Private companies have exploited this cachet, exacerbating problems linked to volunteer preparation and the ELT industry more broadly. ...
Full-text available
This chapter examines the management, curricula, and potential learning outcomes of a group of teaching English as a foreign language (TEFL) certificates offered through Groupon’s global e-commerce marketplace. The emergence of private companies marketing online certificates to volunteer tourists reflects the trend of packaged/tailored “experiences” found in mass tourism and can be understood as a response to the academic/public critique of unskilled volunteers and their contribution to communities in need. Using TESOL International Association’s standards as a lens to analyze the claims made by various Groupon TEFL certificate providers, data analysis suggests that these certificate programs serve to (1) commodify language education in the context of volunteer tourism and (2) perpetuate unequal power dynamics between volunteers and the people whom volunteers purportedly help. I argue that volunteer tourism helps to create a market for online, ultimately ineffective and profit-driven TEFL certificates, and consequently deprofessionalizes the English language teaching profession. This chapter thus highlights the limitations of online certification programs as a way to improve volunteer tourists’ service while contributing to the broader discussion of what professionalization, certification, and commodification mean in relation to TEFL volunteer tourism.
... Yet, there are also cases where some organisations superficially treat transformation more as a form of profit than in a way of helping individuals on different journeys. In such cases, if the intention is not there, consumers will not be able to transform [181], tourists ending up only with marketing proclaims that do not match the reality [55], rehearsing the same old adage of an unrealistically optimistic side of the transformative story. In order to achieve a proper marketing strategy and to match with what was promised [182], both service providers and the community should be aware and informed about the transformative phenomenon, how it happens and what it entails alongside with taking the personalised needs of consumers into account. ...
Full-text available
Transformative tourism (TT) has been gaining a lot of attention over the past few years due to its power to transform both the individual and the world we live in, in a positive way. Although presently consisting of a plethora of studies, transformative tourism lacks the lens of a bibliometric approach to track its growth in a more objective and quantitative manner. In this article, a total of 250 publications were analysed using several bibliometric performance metrics, science mapping techniques, such as citation analysis, co-occurrence, and co-authorship, as well as enrichment procedures. By combining these methods, the study identifies the most prolific journals, reference studies in the field, key authors, collaboration patterns, geographic distribution, preferred methods, major research topics, as well as an overall research timeline in this area of study. Findings suggest that transformative tourism could become the heart of tourism in the upcoming years as it begins to take deeper roots through new junctions and discoveries, appealing to more researchers and practitioners, with the literature on TT thus gaining momentum. This paper contributes to fill a research gap and capture the evolution of the fast-growing concept of transformative tourism using bibliometric analysis. The article provides useful insights as well as further research directions for both researchers and tourism practitioners interested in this field of study.
... She challenges the rights-based approach on which humanitarian interventions and the anti-orphanage movement are built, arguing this approach is often in stark contrast with local practices and religious beliefs. The remaining Carpenter article was a content analysis of volunteers' testimonials, blogs and other online sources pertaining to orphanage tourism (Carpenter, 2015b). Both articles by Carpenter employ a childhood studies framework built on the understanding that children and childhood are socially constructed. ...
This article maps and critically discusses the intersection of childhood, human rights and tourism in scholarly research. Findings reveal this area of scholarship has received little attention beyond “adultist” and “protectionist” approaches, which construct children as too vulnerable to participate in tourism research, policy and practice. Through a systematic scoping review of relevant peer-reviewed scholarly articles, we argue for more child-centred, rights-based, and participatory approaches to engaging children in research about their lives in an area where their voices are often neglected. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (uncrc) was an important milestone in realising children’s rights, and while much has been achieved during this time, children’s rights research and scholarship must address certain fundamental issues to move into the future. This paper aims to respond to the recent call for more interdisciplinary efforts focused on children’s rights in the context of global development and tourism.
... One of the most popular activities in volunteer tourism studies is interaction with the children (Carpenter, 2015). The interactions between health care providers and persons who lives in residential care are really important (Clark 1996 (Blau & Holladay, 2006). ...
While host-children are vulnerable to tourism impacts, the tourism literature has neglected how these impacts affect host-children’s quality of life (QOL). The concept of QOL is ambiguous, and the influence of a host-guest relationship on residents’ QOL has been overlooked. This paper addresses these gaps by exploring how host-children in a developing country perceive tourism impacts on their QOL, focusing on power dynamics in a host-guest relationship. Data were collected from 94 Cambodian host-children using qualitative methods, including drawings and group interviews. The findings revealed Cambodian host-children’s perceptions of tourism impacts over five life domains—material, learning opportunity, cultural pride, emotion, and child sex tourism/trafficking. Despite their perception of negative impacts, all host-children believed that tourism had improved their QOL. The paradox of QOL is explained through Bottom-up Spillover Theory incorporated with Social Exchange Theory. Practical implications for post-COVID and directions for future research are suggested.
The incursion of tourism into schools is an increasing phenomenon, whether through volunteer tourism, developmentourism or philanthropic tourism. Tourism studies have largely ignored children as stakeholders in tourism destinations. In Zimbabwe, economic turbulence has led to a broken education system that relies on external donors to finance schools. As part of this financing, some schools welcome tourists in exchange for funds, sponsorship or infrastructure. Tourists in these settings usually visit schools as part of a mass tour for between 2 and 3 h, with the expectation that children will receive financial benefits or improve their English speaking skills. This paper uses art-based methods to centre children in the research process and reporting. Using children’s drawings and extracts from the interviews and observations, the findings of this study indicate that children in the school experience the school tour in a repetitive manner. In contrast, interviews with adults suggest that school tours are positioned as enjoyable and valuable due to the exposure to English. The data generated by this study contribute to our understanding of children at host destinations and the use of art-based methods.
Issues related to problems with institutional models of care for at-risk children in India have long been addressed by conversations around de-institutionalization. Researchers, however, believe that despite the benefits of family-based alternative care, there are multiple practical constraints in the stated transition. Fostering resilience among institutionalized children has been considered a worthier goal for intervention. The purpose of this study was to understand the pattern of resilience among adolescents with experience of family disruption due to parental loss and resultant relocation to an institutional set-up. Study 1 utilized semi-structured interviews with eight institutional caretakers in the age range of 28–50 years, and study 2 involved focus groups with 19 resilient adolescents in the age range of 14–19 years. Data from the both studies was thematically analyzed. Findings showed that against the backdrop of pre-admission adversities, resilience was conceptualized as a realization about the need to achieve in life and acquisition of a set of culturally sanctioned behavioral attributes. Resources within the institutional context itself were found to have fostered these resilient outcomes. Our findings suggest that by offering resident children needed resources, institutional care holds the potential to provide a permanent and stable living arrangement when other options are unfeasible.
In Cambodia, orphan dance shows were once popular as a way to preserve endangered art forms and to cultivate children's dignity and well-being. But they came to be seen as exploitative instead, and today are nearly nonexistent. This article examines the confluence of changes that caused this reversal of opinion. The reversal is due to both covert factors such as changes in constructions of childhood, and overt factors such as changes in audience composition. The rise and fall of Cambodian orphan dance shows took place largely within foreign communities, with little local input.
Full-text available
Cambridge Core - Anthropological Theory - The Anthropology of Childhood - by David F. Lancy
Full-text available
Some 12,000 children are living in nearly 300 orphanages in Cambodia today. While stigma is a problem for children in these centers, there is also a surprising amount of envy directed towards the children because of the opportunities and resources they receive. This report presents some of the strategies orphanages use to counter stigma and envy. Among these are site location, use of signage, attractive facilities, exclusive educational opportunities, access to internationalization, physical openness, new kinds of non-placed-based community, traditional architecture, intentional simplicity, and sharing of resources with the surrounding community.
Full-text available
Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to consider critical improvements that need to be made to the volunteer tourism industry with regard to risks to both service users and volunteers. Following an exploration of why these issues are so hard to resolve, recommendations are made for next steps forward. Design/methodology/approach – The paper uses a case example of the project from which the author is a Director: Supporting Kids In Peru and draws on her additional practice experience as a child protection social worker. Findings – The paper provides a summary of observations to encourage and support practice improvements within the volunteer tourism industry to better safeguard both volunteers and vulnerable people they may be working with. Practical implications – A number of clear recommendations are made, including sharing information, improving communication and setting minimum standards, to improve the overall professionalism of the industry. Originality/value – The paper provides an insightful practitioner perspective to an aspect of the tourism industry that bridges directly into social services, something which it has had little time to prepare for and has seen dramatic growth in the past few years.
Full-text available
A recent Aljazeera report on ‘Cambodia’s Orphan Business’ explains ‘how “voluntourism” could be fuelling the exploitation of Cambodian children’. Anti-orphanage tourism movements have emerged to resist the growth of Cambodia’s contested orphanage tourism industry, which is blamed for widespread corruption and the exploitation of children for profit. Taking a Polanyian political economy approach, this article illustrates how the emergence of and response to the orphanage tourism industry represent, in Karl Polanyi’s words, a ‘double movement’ between the neoliberalization of orphanages and the corollary protective countermovement by anti-orphanage tourism campaigns that challenge the industry’s morality and legitimacy. It argues that while resistance to the commodification of orphanages under the newly neoliberalized Cambodian economy reflects Polanyi’s double movement thesis, the limits of this resistance are also indicative of how countermovements are challenged by the broader political economy in which they operate.
This is a remarkably interesting and useful book…it makes a significant contribution to our knowledge and understanding of both bilingualism and education.' Journal of Education Policy.
This book includes 15 papers selected from the presentations that were delivered at the 15th World Congress of the International Sociological Association. These papers were prepared for that organization's research committee on international tourism, which took as its overall theme 'the tourist as a metaphor of the social world'. Following the introductory chapter, two contributions (chapters 2 and 3) raise serious fundamental questions about how academics should research (and hence theorize) about tourists. The next two contributions (chapters 4 and 5) provide a critique of conventional tourism wisdom. Chapter 6 suggests that tourism is an intricate and evolving social network with varying degrees of trust that are based on the correlative processes of self-presentation and interpretation. Chapter 7 conceptualizes the tourist and the social world within a paradigm of social facts so that the former becomes a sign of the latter. Chapter 8 sees the tourist as never entirely alone on an uncharted journey, because there are always those who have undertaken it before. Chapter 9 asks the question as to whether or not tourists experience reality. Chapter 10 provides an analogy between tourism and love in all its many phases. Chapter 11 emphasizes that it is necessary to go beyond traditional analyses that focus solely on the 'tourist gaze'. The next two essays (chapters 12 and 13) highlight the fact that not all tourists are identical and hence, by implication, that the tourist as a metaphor of the social world must be understood as a multiple persona figurative of complex reality. The final three contributions (chapters 14-16) present postmodern and futuristic perspectives on tourists. The book has a subject index.
This paper reviews the 30-year evolution of volunteer tourism as phenomenon, industry, and research area, charting changes in the size, breadth, definition, and the perceived positive and negative contributions of the volunteer tourism industry. Discussion then moves on to how research in volunteer tourism has reflected those changes. Studies have focused on the transition from decommodified to commodified volunteer tourism; participant motivation, including the altruism versus self-development discussion; and the paucity of a unified and cohesive theoretical foundation in volunteer tourism. Fresh debates are now emerging that center upon the potential interface of technology and volunteer tourism, including crowd-sourcing for funding, smart phone apps, and GIS; the importance of monitoring and maintaining quality volunteer tourism experiences through certification and/or other indicators; and the role of religion and spirituality in volunteer tourism. These issues, and others, including the role of transformative learning, are addressed in the papers chosen for this special issue on volunteer tourism which are reviewed here. The paper's conclusions include specific recommendations for greater cooperation between researchers and industry to create a more sustainable industry, minimizing its negative impacts while maximizing its potential influence for positive social change, and perhaps becoming the ultimate sustainable form of tourism.