ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

Automatic joinery has become a common technique for the jointing of beams in timber framing and roofing. It has revived traditional, integral joints such as mortise and tenon connections. Similarly, but only recently, the automatic fabrication of traditional cabinetmaking joints has been introduced for the assembly of timber panel shell structures. First prototypes have used such integrated joints for the alignment and assembly of components, while additional adhesive bonding was used for the load-bearing connection. However, glued joints cannot be assembled on site, which results in several design constraints. In this paper, we propose the use of dovetail joints without adhesive bonding, on the case study of a timber folded plate structure. Through their single-degree-of-freedom (1DOF) geometry, these joints block the relative movement of two parts in all but one direction. This presents the opportunity for an interlocking connection of plates, as well as a challenge for the assembly of folded plate shells, where multiple non-parallel edges per plate must be jointed simultaneously.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Interlocking Folded Plate - Integral Mechanical Attachment for
Structural Wood Panels
Christopher Robeller 1and Yves Weinand 1
1Timber Construction Laboratory IBOIS, EPFL
June 20, 2015
Abstract
Automatic joinery has become a common technique for the jointing of beams in timber framing and
roofing. It has revived traditional, integral joints such as mortise and tenon connections. Similarly,
but only recently, the automatic fabrication of traditional cabinetmaking joints has been introduced
for the assembly of timber panel shell structures. First prototypes have used such integrated joints
for the alignment and assembly of components, while additional adhesive bonding was used for the
load-bearing connection. However, glued joints cannot be assembled on site, which results in several
design constraints.
In this paper, we propose the use of dovetail joints without adhesive bonding, on the case study
of a timber folded plate structure. Through their single-degree-of-freedom (1DOF) geometry, these
joints block the relative movement of two parts in all but one direction. This presents the opportunity
for an interlocking connection of plates, as well as a challenge for the assembly of folded plate shells,
where multiple non-parallel edges per plate must be jointed simultaneously.
1 Introduction
Architectural designs have often been inspired by
folded shapes such as Origami, however the fold-
ing principle can rarely be applied to building
structures directly. Instead, many folded plates
have been cast as concrete thin-shells in the 1960s.
These constructions were labour-intensive and re-
quired elaborate formwork for the in-situ casting.
Prefabricated constructions with discrete ele-
ments made from fiber-reinforced plastics have
been researched in the 1960s. [1]
Folded plates built from laminated timber pan-
els have been presented by C. Schineis [19] (Glu-
lam) and H. Buri [2] (Cross-laminated Timber).
These designs combine the elegant and efficient
shape of folded plate shells with the advantages of
structural timber panels, such as CO2 storage and
a favorable weight-to-strength ratio. However, a
major challenge in the design of a timber folded
plate is presented by the joints: Since timber pan-
els cannot be folded, a large amount of edgewise
joints has to provide two main functions. One
of these functions is the load-bearing behaviour,
where connector features of the joints must pro-
vide a sufficient stiffness and rigidity. The second
main function of the joints is the assembly of the
parts, where locator features of the joints are es-
sential for a precise and fast positioning and align-
ment of the parts.
B. Hahn [5] examined the structural behaviour
of a first timber folded plate shell which was built
from plywood and assembled with screwed miter
joints, concluding that the load-bearing perfor-
mance could be improved significantly with more
resistant connections.
Inspiration for such improvements may be found
in integral mechanical attachment techniques, the
oldest known technique for the jointing of parts,
where the geometry of the parts themselves blocks
their relative movements [13]. Such integrated
joints have recently been re-discovered by the tim-
ber construction industry. Beginning in 1985,
mortise-and tenon joints have been repatriated in
timberframe and roof constructions [7]. Only very
recently, integrated joints have also been proposed
for the edgewise jointing of timber panels. In
the ICD/ITKE Reserach Pavilions 2011 [12] and
1
2013 [11], fingerjoints have been applied to ply-
wood panels and an application of dovetail joints
for cross-laminated timber panels (CLT) was pre-
sented in the IBOIS Curved Folded Wood Pavil-
ion 2013 [18]. In these prototype structures, the
integrated joints have played an important role
for the assembly of the components. They have
also participated in the load-bearing connection
of the parts, but additional adhesive bonding was
needed. With few exceptions [6], such glued joints
cannot be assembled on site, because they require
a curing period with a specific constant tempera-
ture and humidity [15]. Therefore, their applica-
tion is limited to off-site assembly of larger compo-
nents, which complicates both transport and han-
dling while still requiring additional connectors for
the final assembly.
In this paper, we propose the use of dovetail
joints without additional adhesive bonding, on the
case study of a timber folded plate shell. (Figure
1).
Through their single-degree-of-freedom (1DOF)
geometry, these joints block the relative movement
of two parts in all but one direction. This presents
the opportunity for an interlocking connection of
plates, as well as a challenge for the assembly
of folded plate shells, where multiple non-parallel
edges per plate must be jointed simultaneously.
1.1 Dovetail joint geometry and me-
chanical performance
Using polygon mesh processing, we describe an
edgewise joint based on its edge E. From the
mesh connectivity, we obtain the edge vertices p
and qand the adjacent faces F0and F1with their
face normals n0, n1. We use the polygon mesh
to represent the mid-layer of timber panels with
a thickness tand offset F1and F2at ±t
2to ob-
tain the lines L(Figure 2a). From a division of
E, we obtain the points Xjfor a set of refer-
ence frames {u1, u2, u3}, where u1k~pq and u2kn0
(Figure 2b). A finger joint geometry is obtained
from an intersection of planes located at Xj, nor-
mal to u1, with the four lines L.
Without additional connectors, finger joints are
a kinematic pair with three degrees of freedom
(3DOF), also called planar joints. They can re-
sist shear forces parallel to the edge and in-plane
compressive forces. However depending on the
plate geometry, thickness and most of all rota-
tional stiffness of the connection detail, bending
moments are also transferred between the plates.
Also, due to the rotation of the plate edge caused
Figure 3: FEM analysis (top view) of a 3x3m,
21mm Kerto-Q folded plate thin shell assuming
fully stiff joints. Distribution of traction (red)
and compression (blue) stresses in the y direction.
Top: gravity load case. Bottom: asymmetric snow
load.
by bending, in-plane traction forces perpendicu-
lar to the edge line appear and their magnitude
increases under asymmetrical loads. Such forces,
which occur as a result of out-of-plane loading,
cannot be supported only by shear and in-plane
compression resistant joints.
On a dovetail joint (Figure 2d,e), the intersec-
tion planes on the points Xjare normal to a ro-
tated vector w1. It is obtained from a rotation
of the reference frame {u1, u2, u3}about u3at an
alternating angle ±θ3. The resulting rotated side
faces reduce the dovetail joints degrees of freedom
to one translation ~w3(1DOF). Simek and Sebera
[20] have suggested θ3= 15for spruce plywood
panels. Such prismatic joints can only be assem-
bled or disassembled along one assembly direction
~v =~w3. In addition to the finger joints resistance
to shear and compressive forces, dovetail joints
can, without adhesive bonding, also resist bend-
ing moments and traction forces which are not
2
Figure 1: Folded thin shell prototype built from 21mm LVL panels, assembled with single-degree-of-
freedom dovetail joints without adhesive bonding. Components interlock with one another
p
q
p
q
p
q
n0n1
w3
F0
F0
F+
F0
F-F1
F1
F+
F1
F-
a. b. c. d. e.
u2u3
u1
Ei
L1
L
L3
LL2
L
L0
L
Xj
j+1
j+2
j+3
j+1
j+2
j+3
j+1
j+2
j+3
v
w1
w2
Figure 2: Joint geometry. a: Basic parameters, b: Intersection planes (grey) normal to ~pq, c: 3DOF
joint, d: Rotated intersection planes (grey) normal to ~wj, e: 1DOF joint
parallel to ~v. Due to the inclination of the side
faces of the joint, resistance to these forces can be
improved significantly. In that way the inclined
faces take over the role that the glue would have
in a finger joint. (Figure4)
1.2 Fabrication Constraints
One of the main reasons for the resurgence of fin-
ger and dovetail joints is the possibility of auto-
matic fabrication. However, the mechanical per-
formance of the joints depends on fabrication pre-
cision. At the same time, fast machine feed rates
are important for a time-efficient production. We
have fabricated such joints with a robot router and
a gantry router, achieving higher precision with
the gantry machine, which is more stiff and pro-
vides a higher repeat accuracy.
The variability of the machine-fabricated joints
is enabled by the 5-axis capability of modern
routers: Although traditional edgewise joints in
cabinetmaking were used for orthogonal assem-
blies, both the finger and dovetail joint can also
be applied for non-orthogonal fold angles, which
was essential for the reference projects mentioned
before. However, there are certain fabrication-
related constraints for machine-fabricated dovetail
joints. In order to integrate the joint fabrication
directly with the panel formatting, we use a side-
cutting technique [8], which is limited to a tool
inclination βmax. We obtain this limit from the
specific geometry of the tool, tool-holder and spin-
dle used for the joint fabrication. (Figure 5)
The parts can be assembled in two ways, as
shown in figure 5, which allows to address a larger
range of dihedral angles ϕ. From this we ob-
tain the fabrication-constrained most acute fold
ϕmin = 90βmax and most obtuse fold ϕmax =
90+βmax. With standard cutting tools, this tech-
nique allows for the jointing of acute folds up to
3
Figure 4: FEM simulation of bending on a dovetail joint connecting two Kerto-Q 21mm LVL panels.
The bending moment applied is transformed into compression, normal and shear forces parallel to the
inclined contact faces.
βmax
φmax
φmin
βmax
βmax
TCP
TCP
TCP
TCP
TCP
TCP
TCP
TCP
TCP
TCP
TCP
TCP
Figure 5: Fabrication Constraints. Side-cutting technique used for the automated fabrication of 1DOF
edgewise joints with common 5-axis CNC routers. The maximum tool inclination βmax results from
the tool and the tool holder geometry. From this we obtain the range of possible dihedral angles ±ϕ
between panels.
ϕ= 50, which is ideal for folded plate structures.
Very obtuse fold angles ϕ140, which might be
required for smooth segmented plate shells, can-
not be fabricated with this method.
1.3 Simultaneous Assembly of Multiple
Edges
The assembly of doubly-corrugated folded plates
requires the simultaneous joining of multiple edges
per component (Figure 1), which has implications
on both the shell and the joint geometry.
For multiple 1DOF-jointed edges, simultaneous
assembly is only possible if the individual assem-
bly directions ~v are parallel. With a normal dove-
tail joint geometry (Figure 7a), this is not the case:
A simultaneous assembly is only possible for par-
allel edges, which allows only for rectangular as-
semblies, such as drawers or a cabinets.
In order to simultaneously join non-parallel
edges, we must rotate the assembly direction vof
the joints to make them parallel. This possibility
is known from Japanese cabinetmaking [9], where
certain joints, like the Nejiri Arigata Joint (Figure
7b), are assembled diagonally, along a vector that
does not lie on either one of the two planes. While
European dovetail form a prism with a single tab,
e1
e2
e1
e0
e2e1
e0
x3
x2
Figure 6: The assembly of a folded plate from dis-
crete elements (left side) requires the simultaneous
assembly of non-parallel edges. (right side) We
rotate the insertion direction of our 1DOF joints,
to make the insertion vectors of simultaneously
jointed edges parallel. We chose a hexagon re-
verse fold pattern which requires only moderate
rotations.
4
vv
a. b.
faces across
edge only faces
across edge
faces along
edge +
Figure 7: a. Dovetail Joint, b. Nejiri Arigata Joint
using faces both acrioss and along the edge, the
Nejiri Arigata joints form a prism using multiple,
differently shaped tabs.
We extend this Japanese technique to a vector
subset of possible assembly directions. Figure 8
shows that the rotation about the edge line is con-
strained to 180ϕi. The vector subset is large for
acute and small for obtuse fold angles. This is par-
ticularly important when joining multiple edges
simultaneously, because an intersection must be
found between multiple vector subsets (Fig. 9).
If there is an intersection, the parts can be joined
simultaneously along any direction within the in-
tersection of the subsets.
Finally we extend this concept to a 3-
dimensional rotation (Fig. 10). This is possible
through a second rotation θ2, which is constrained
to a maximum value of ±θ2,max. The limitation
results from multiple other corelated parameters,
such as θ1and βmax. We call the resulting 3D
vector subset rotation window.
With this method, we can search for a joining
solution for the prototype in figure 6. We compute
rotation windows S1,S2,S3for the edges E1,E2,
E3and overlay them at their center point. Fig-
ure 11 shows that there is a common vector sub-
set S1TS2TS3between these three edges, we can
choose our assembly direction within it.
As a result of these limited rotations, the an-
gle between neighbouring, simultaneously joined
edges cannot be very acute. Folded plate pat-
terns like the Herringbone, the Diamond, or the
Hexagon pattern, which we chose for our proto-
types, (Figure 6) work well for our joining tech-
90° 130°50°
"
#
!
!
E34 68344
a.
Figure 8: 2D vector subset
3"3$
3"
3$
E1E2
E1
E2
b.
Figure 9: 2D simultaneous assembly
2, max
1
Figure 10: 3D vector subset
5
S3
S1
E1
E2
S2
v
S1ŀS2ŀS3
E3
3x
Figure 11: 3D simultaneous assembly
nique. Another essential feature provided by these
reverse-folds are the acute fold angles, which eas-
ily satisfies the fabrication-constrained range of
ϕmin = 50to ϕmax = 140.
2 Interlocking Arch Prototype
In an assembly of multiple components (Figure
12), a step-by-step sequence must be planned for
the assembly of the parts. The completed struc-
ture can only be disassembled piecewise in the re-
verse order of assembly. In this way, the elements
interlock with one another like a Burr Puzzle [22].
Each joint consists of two parts, which must be
parallel during assembly. We therefore chose a
folded plate geometry with relatively short edges.
The manual assembly of long edges may be more
difficult but can be simplified with a modified joint
geometry. It is important to know the approxi-
mate direction of insertion for each part, as this is
not easily visible through the joint geometry. De-
formations of the arch during the assembly should
be minimised. We have assembled this first pro-
totype lying on the side. However larger assembly
may require temporary punctual supports. Al-
though the in-plane dimensional stability of the
Kerto-Q panels is very high, panels may be slightly
warped and some force may be necessary during
assembly. While we have simply used a rubber
hammer, more advanced techniques could be ap-
plied.
To understand the mechanical behaviour of the
built prototype, we have applied a vertical load at
mid-span of the arch and measured the vertical de-
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
0
200
400
600
800
1000
Load cycle #1
Load cycle #2
Force [N]
Displacement [mm]
Figure 13: Series of 3-point flexural tests on the
small scale interlocking arch prototype built from
Metsawood 12mm birch plywood panels.
flection at the same point. The total load of 821N
was applied in two identical load cycles consist-
ing of four loading/unloading sub-cycles. First, a
vertical load of 117N was applied in seven steps,
after which the load of the last four steps was re-
moved. The loading and unloading of the last four
steps was repeated three more times, after which
the complete load was removed and the residual
deflection was measured. (Figure 13)
Under a vertical load equal to the archs dead
weight of 9.8kg (98N), the deflection measured at
mid-span was 2mm. From this we obtain a span-
to-deflection-ratio of L/750 and the arch’s struc-
tural efficiency which reaches 8.6 when loaded
with 821N (ratio of the maximal load over the
dead weight of the arch).
3 Interlocking Shell Prototype
3.1 Automatic Geometry Processing
Using the RhinoPython application programming
interface, we have developed a computational tool
which lets us instantly generate both the geom-
etry of the individual components and the ma-
chine G-Code required for fabrication. The tool
processes arbitrary polygon meshes, and gener-
ates 1DOF joints for all non-naked edges where
the fold angle ϕis larger than ϕmin and smaller
than ϕmax shown in figure 5(non-smooth meshes).
It also requires an input of edge identifier tuples
identifying those edges which must be jointed si-
multaneously, as well as the thickness of the LVL
panels. Exploiting this geometrical freedom, we
have tested our computational tool on the design
of a folded plate shell prototype with an alter-
6
Figure 12: Folded-plate arch prototype built from 12mm birch plywood (9-layer, I-I-I-I-I). Assembled
without adhesive bonding or metal fasteners. Span 1.65m, self-weight 9.8kg.
nating convex-concave transversal curvature. The
shell spans over 3m at a thickness of 21mm, us-
ing Kerto-Q structural grade LVL panels (7-layer,
I-III-I). (Figure 14)
Comparing this doubly-curved folded plate with
a straight extrusion (as tested by H. Buri [2]), it
can be concluded that the slight double-curvature
proves to be very beneficial when it comes to
global deflections, for example those caused by
wind loads. Deflections for the doubly-curved
shell geometry in the vertical direction are up to
39% smaller and up to 13% smaller in the lateral
direction than the ones for the straight extrusion
one.
3.2 Assembly
Due to the different assembly directions of its 239
joints, the 107 components components in our pro-
totype interlock with one another, similar to a
Burr Puzzle [22]. Figure 15 shows a part of a
so called non-directional blocking graph (NDBG),
which was inroduced by Wilson and Latombe [21].
In such a graph, single arrows indicate that
parts can be removed from the assembly. Two
opposite arrows between parts indicate that the
connection is blocked. In order to remove blocked
parts, the blocking parts must be removed first.
Our graph illustrates a left-to-right assembly. On
the right side, part number 86 is being inserted. It
connects to three other plates and blocks all other
parts in the graph. In such a configuration, the
final part remains removable, it is called the key.
Figure 16 shows the parts from figure 15 in 3D,
demonstrating how the component based on mesh
face F86 is being inserted. Its three edgewise joints
E41,E68 and E89 must be assembled simultane-
ously. The three assembly vectors of the edges
~v41,~v68 and ~v89 have been rotated to be parallel.
The same applies for the adjacent edges on the
left side of the faces F67,F69 ,F88,F103 and F105
(see figure 15). Within the rotation window of the
edge, we can freely rotate ~v for these edges (the
greater the angle between ~v and the main direction
of traction e1, the better).
3.3 Completed Shell Prototype and
Load Test
Figure 17 shows the completed folded plate pro-
totype, with a span of 3m and a shell thickness
of 21mm. Boundary conditions that restrain dis-
placements of the supports in every direction, but
allow rotations, were applied on both sides. A lon-
gitudinal line load was introduced along the top of
the shell and vertical displacement was measured
at center point. (Figure 18)
The prototype structure was also modelled in
7
8889
6869
71
107
87
104
86
70 Blocked
Free
65
98
35
68
89
41
105
106 7
107
90
44
100 91
59
66
36
99
18
Figure 15: Partial connectivity, assembly and blocking graph of the folded plate shell prototype.
(Left-to-right assembly) Large numbers represent mesh faces, small numbers represent mesh edges.
Pi+1
Pi+2
Pi+3 Pi+4
Pi+5
Pi+6
Pi
ni+1
ni+2
ni+3 ni+4
ni+5
CV
1
CC1
CV
2
CV3
CC2
CC3
CC: Concave
CV: Convex
A
B
A
A
B
B
B
A: min length
B: max length
Figure 14: Doubly-curved folded-plate: The ra-
dius (R= 17m) of the transversal curvature is
determined by the folded plates maximum ampli-
tude h[2], which is inversely proportional to the
number of segments mof the cross-section poly-
line (grey). We obtain this polyline from a circular
arc divided into segments of equal length. The in-
terior angle γ= ((m2)180)mof this polyline
is proportional to all fold angles ϕ. The geometry
of our prototype was fabrication-constrained to a
maximum component length B2.5m
FE analysis software (Abaqus) and loaded in the
same way. The plates were modelled using shell el-
ements, where the mid-surface is used to represent
the 3D plate and transverse shearing strains are
neglected. Connections between the plates were
considered as completely rigid in order to obtain
minimal displacements of the structure. By com-
paring the displacements of the structure with in-
finitely stiff joints with the ones measured on the
prototype, we obtained information about the ac-
tual semi-rigidity of the joints. The results ob-
tained from the testing of the large scale prototype
showed that the load of 25kN, that corresponds
to the proportional limit of the load-displacement
curve, causes a vertical displacement of 23mm. In
the FE model, the load applied in the same man-
ner caused a vertical displacement of 2.6mm.
Figure 18: Load-displacement curve of the shell
prototype. A longitudinal line load was intro-
duced along the top of the shell. Vertical displace-
ment was measured at the center point.
8
e3
v41 = v68 = v89
v35 = v65 = v98
v7 = v36
v13 = v42
e2
e1
v7v13
v59
v44
v18 v35 v36
v41 v42
v70
v43
v68
v66
v65
v84
v89
v90
v100
v99 v98
v107
v94
e1
e2
F86
F86
Figure 16: Left-to-right assembly of the Interlocking folded plate shell prototype. Built from Kerto-Q
structural grade LVL panels (7-layer, I-III-I))
9
Figure 17: Folded-plate shell prototype, built from 21mm LVL panels. With a self-weight of 192kg,
the prototype with a span of 3m was tested with a line-load up to 45kN.
4 Conclusion
A timber folded plate shell combines the struc-
tural advantages of timber panels with the effi-
ciency of folded plates. However, in such discrete
element assemblies, a large amount of semi-rigid
joints must provide sufficient support for the ad-
jacent plates in oder to ensure an efficient load-
bearing system. This remains a challenge with
much potential for improvements [5].
Integrated edgewise joints present an interest-
ing addition and an alternative to state-of-the-art
connectors: Compared to adhesive bonding, such
joints can be assembled rapidly on site. Also, com-
pared to costly metal plates and fasteners, which
are typically required in large quantities [14], the
fabrication of integrated joints is not more ex-
pensive. The replacement or reduction of metal
fasteners with an integrated mono-material con-
nection includes advantages such as improved aes-
thetics, ease-of recycling or a homogenous thermal
conductivity of the parts, which can reduce con-
densation and decay. [4] Another particular ad-
vantage is the possibility to join thin panels: The
current technical approval for the Kerto-Q panels
does not permit screwed joints on panels with a
thickness of less than 60mm. [3]
Recent experimental projects, which we intro-
duced in chapter 1, have already demonstrated
first applications of integrated edgewise joints for
timber panels. This paper followed up on these
projects, examining the particular advantages, po-
tential and challenges of 1DOF joints for timber
folded plate shells. We have demonstrated how
this joint geometry helps resisting the forces which
occur in such structures. In addition to the load-
bearing connector features, the joints provide lo-
cator features, which allow for precise positioning
and alignment of the parts through the joint ge-
ometry. This improves both accuracy and ease of
assembly. Furthermore, we have presented a so-
lution for the simultaneous assembly of multiple
edges per panel, which is essential for the applica-
tion of 1DOF joints in a folded plate shell struc-
ture. The per edge ”rotation window” introduced
in section 1.3 integrates the joint constraints re-
lated to assembly and fabrication. It can be pro-
cessed algorithmically and gives instant feedback
on whether or not a set of non-parallel edges can
be jointed simultaneously. This provides a tool for
the exploration of a variety of alternative folded
plate shell geometries.
10
The prototypes presented in this paper already
suggest possible patterns and demonstrate the re-
ciprocal relationship between the geometry of the
plates and the joints. Two built structures allowed
us to test and verify the proposed methods for fab-
rication and assembly while providing valuable in-
formation about the load-bearing capacity of the
integrated joints.
For the application in a large-scale building
structure, further research is required to deter-
mine if the integrated joints can replace additional
connectors entirely or reduce their amount. A pos-
sible combination of integrated joints with addi-
tional metal fasteners has been demonstrated re-
cently in the LaGa Exhibition Hall [10]. Another
possibility would be a combination of the 1DOF
joints with integrated elastic interlocks. [17]
Acknowledgments
We would like to thank Andrea Stitic and Paul
Mayencourt for their support with the finite ele-
ment models and load testing of the prototypes,
as well as Gabriel Tschanz and Francois Perrin
for assisting with the fabrication and assembly of
prototypes. We also thank Jouni Hakkarainen and
the Metsa Group for the supply of information and
materials.
References
[1] B.S. Benjamin and Z.S. Makowski. The
analysis of folded-plate structures in plastics.
In Proceedings of a conference held in Lon-
don, pages 149–163. Pergamon Press, Lon-
don, 1965.
[2] Hani Buri and Yves Weinand. BSP Visionen -
Faltwerkkonstruktionen aus BSP-Elementen.
In Grazer Holzbau-Fachtage, 2006.
[3] DIBt. Allgemeine bauaufsichtliche Zulassung
Kerto-Q Z-9.1-100, Paragraph 4.2 and At-
tachment No 7, Table 5. Deutsches Institut
ur Bautechnik, 2011.
[4] Wolfram Graubner. Holzverbindungen,
Gegen¨uberstellung von Holzverbindungen
Holz in Holz und mit Metallteilen. Deutsche
Verlags-Anstalt Stuttgart, 1986.
[5] Benjamin Hahn. Analyse und beschreibung
eines r¨aumlichen tragwerks aus massivholz-
platten. Master’s thesis, EPFL, Lausanne,
2009. Master Thesis.
[6] HESS. Hess limitless, 2014.
http://www.hess-timber.com/de/produkte/.
[7] Hundegger. Hans Hundegger Maschinen-
bau GmbH, Hawangen, Germany, 2014.
http://www.hundegger.de/en/machine-
building/company/our-history.html.
[8] Peter Koch. Wood Machining Processes.
Wood Processing. Carl Hanser Verlag GmbH
& Co. KG, 1964.
[9] Tetsuya K¯ondo. Dento kanehozo kumitsugi :
Sekkei to seisaku no jissai. LLP Gijutsushi
Shuppankai, Tokyo : Seiunsha, 2007.
[10] Oliver Krieg, Tobias Schwinn, Achim
Menges, Jian-Min Li, Jan Knippers, Annette
Schmitt, and Volker Schwieger. Compu-
tational integration of robotic fabrication,
architectural geometry and structural de-
sign for biomimetic lightweight timber
plate shells. In Advances in Architectural
Geometry 2014. Springer Verlag, 2014.
[11] Oliver David Krieg, Zachary Christian, David
Correa, Achim Menges, Steffen Reichert,
Katja Rinderspacher, and Tobias Schwinn.
Hygroskin: Meteorosensitive pavilion. In
Fabricate 2014 Conference Zurich, pages
272–279, 2014.
[12] Riccardo la Magna et al. From nature to fab-
rication: Biomimetic design principles for the
production of complex spatial structures. In-
ternational Journal of Spatial Structures, Vol.
28 No. 1:27–39, 2013.
[13] Robert W. Messler. Integral Mechanical At-
tachment: A Resurgence of the Oldest Method
of Joining. Butterworth Heinemann, 2006.
[14] Helmuth Neuhaus. DIN EN 1995 (Eu-
rocode 5) - Design of timber structures. DIN
Deutsches Institut fur Normung e. V., 2004.
[15] Purbond. National Technical Approval Z-9.1-
711 / Single-component polyurethane adhe-
sive for the manufacture of engineered wood
products. Deutsches Institut f¨ur Bautechnik,
2011.
[16] Christopher Robeller. Integral Mechanical
Attachment for Timber Folded Plate Struc-
tures. PhD thesis, ENAC, Lausanne, 2015.
11
[17] Christopher Robeller, Paul Mayencourt, and
Yves Weinand. Snap-fit joints: Integrated
mechanical attachment of structural timber
panels. In Proceedings of the 34th Inter-
national Conference of the Association of
Computer-aided Design in Architecture ACA-
DIA, Los Angeles, USA. Riverside Architec-
tural Press, 2014.
[18] Christopher Robeller, SeyedSina Nabaei, and
Yves Weinand. Design and fabrication of
robot-manufactured joints for a curved-folded
thin-shell structure made from clt. In Wes
McGee and Monica Ponce de Leon, editors,
Robotic Fabrication in Architecture, Art and
Design 2014, pages 67–81. Springer Interna-
tional Publishing, 2014.
[19] Regina Schineis. Gefalteter Klangko-
erper Musikprobensaal Thannhausen /
Thannhausen Rehearsal Room. In 10.
Internationales Holzbau Forum (IHF),
Garmisch-Partenkirchen, 2004.
[20] Vaclav Sebera and Milan Simek. Finite el-
ement analysis of dovetail joint made with
the use of cnc technology. Acta Universitatis
Agriculturae Et Silviculturae Mendelianae
Brunensis, Volume LVIII:321–328, 2010.
[21] Randall H. Wilson and Jean-Claude
Latombe. Geometric reasoning about
mechanical assembly. Artificial Intelligence,
71(2):371 – 396, 1994.
[22] Edwin Wyatt. Puzzles in Wood. Bruce Pub-
lishing Co., 1928.
12
... In the context of the presented research, recent advances in CAD interfaces and multi-axis fabrication technologies paved the way for the construction of geometrically complex segmented shell structures from planar timber elements. Such shells are, among others, ICD/ITKE Research Pavilion 2011 [9], folded-plate arch prototype [10], Landesgartenschau Exhibition Hall [11], and BUGA pavilion [12]. This paper adds to the existing research context by introducing a new innovative approach, which uses a chemical connector instead of the mechanical one, to the design and construction of large-span wood-only shell structures. ...
Conference Paper
This research is an extension of the work from our previous study on using digital technology to construct lightweight wood-only shell structures from Cross-Laminated Timber (CLT) production waste. In a previous paper, we developed an algorithm that turns CLT offcuts into efficient timber plates and uses them for the construction of a medium-scale compression-only shell demonstrator. Although the FEM analysis and experimental load tests proved the structural efficiency of wooden connectors, we found that realization of a significantly larger span requires a joint system with a higher tension resistance capacity. As a solution, this paper presents a custom adhesive joint system for reaching a higher load-bearing capacity of CLT plates for withstanding both compression and tension forces, enabling the construction of a larger shell structure completely without metal connectors. The joint system consists of an innovative gluing method without any additional bonding agent and wood grain direction optimization that increases the adhesive strength of butt joints where CLT plates are fastened together. The paper discusses the possible applications and limitations of the construction system while presenting the structural analyses for a load-bearing shell demonstrator with a column-free span of 35 meters. To validate the structural performance of the construction system, FEM analysis and MATLAB post-processing of the FEM results are presented.
... In the paper entitled 'Interlocking Folded Plate -Integral Mechanical Attachment for Structural Wood Panels', Robeller and Weinand (2015) built folded thin shell prototype consisting of timber panels by utilizing automatic fabrication of cabinetmaking joints, i.e., dovetail joints without adhesive ( Figure 6). This interlocking arch prototype was constructed from 21mm LVL panels and 12mm plywood with a self-weight of 192 kg and a span of 3 meters to provide input on the load-carrying capacity of integrated joints. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Due to easy connection technique, airtightness, and high rigidity, engineered wood products (EWPs) e.g., Cross-laminated timber (CLT) can compete, especially in multi-story timber buildings. In EWPs, adhesives play an important role, particularly by helping to protect the wood, making the structure light and strong, and relieving expansion and contraction due to natural moisture. However, the use of adhesives raises some concerns about EWPs' sustainability, recyclability, and wider environmental impact. There is still room for a solution of solid and pure wood based on one of the oldest traditionally used joining methods, providing dovetailed massive wood board elements (DMWBE) that offer as healthy indoor air as possible without adhesives and metal binders. Numerous studies have been done in the literature on the technological, ecological, social, and economic aspects of EWPs in construction with different building solutions, but no attempt has been made to evaluate the technical performance of DMWBE in multi-story buildings. This research aims to create higher value-added circular economy opportunities to increase the competitiveness of Finnish large-scale industrial timber structures at the local level and to support European climate policy as part of bio-economy and sustainable development.
... Therefore, there is still room for a solution consisting of solid and completely pure wood, dovetail wood board elements (DWBEs) [23]. Numerous studies have been conducted in the literature on the technological, ecological, and economic aspects of EWPs in construction with different building solutions [24] such as [25][26][27][28][29][30], and there is limited understating of DWBEs, which mostly includes structural analysis of connection details (e.g., [31][32][33][34][35][36][37][38][39]). Here, the dovetail wood board elements (DWBEs) can be defined as solid/massive and pure wood structural elements such as floor 4 slabs that use plug-in dovetail form in the joint detail and do not use adhesives and metal connections. ...
Chapter
Full-text available
Adhesives and metal fasteners have an important place in the content of engineered wood products (EWPs). However, adhesives may cause toxic gas emissions due to their petroleum-based nature, while metal fasteners may adversely affect the reusability of these products. These issues also raise important questions about the sustainability and environmental friendliness of EWPs. Thus, there is still room for a solution that is solid and completely pure wood, adhesive-and metal-connectors-free dovetail wood board elements (DWBEs). There are many studies on the technological, ecological, and economic aspects of these products in the literature, but no studies have been conducted to assess the technical performance of DWBEs. This chapter focuses on DWBEs by proposing various geometric configurations for horizontal structural members in multistory building construction through architectural modeling programs. In this architectural design phase, which is one of the first but most important stages, the proposed configurations are based on a theoretical approach, considering contemporary construction practices rather than structural analysis or mechanical simulation. Further research, including technical performance tests, will be undertaken after this critical phase. It is believed that this chapter will contribute to the dissemination of DWBEs for innovative architectural and structural applications, especially in multistory wooden structures construction.
... Besides the studies mentioned above, other similar research [40,42,[49][50][51][52][53][54][55][56][57] focused more on the structural analysis and model testing of various connection details in different geometric configurations, rather than evaluating the performance of a structural component, a floor slab, or the entire structure. ...
Article
Full-text available
Adhesives and metal fasteners play important roles in the composition and connections of engineered wood products (EWPs) such as cross-laminated timber and glue-laminated timber in the building construction industry. However, due to their petroleum-based nature, adhesives can cause toxic gas emissions, while metal fasteners compromise the end-of-life disposal and reusability of EWPs. These issues adversely affect the sustainable material properties of EWPs. Numerous studies have been conducted in the literature on the technological, ecological, social, and economic aspects of EWPs in construction with different construction solutions, but no studies have been conducted to evaluate the technical performance of dovetail wood board elements (DWBE) in multi-story or tall building construction. This study focuses on adhesive- and metal fastener-free DWBE as sustainable material alternatives for ecologically sensitive engineering solutions. Various preliminary design proposals are presented for DWBE using architectural modeling programs as an environmentally friendly approach intended for use in the timber construction industry. The research findings are based on a theoretical approach that has not yet been practically tested but is proposed considering existing construction practices that need further investigation, including technical performance tests. It is believed that this paper will contribute to the promotion and diffusion of DWBE for more diverse and innovative architectural and structural applications, particularly in multi-story timber building construction, as one of the key tools in tackling climate change challenges.
... In the paper entitled 'Interlocking Folded Plate -Integral Mechanical Attachment for Structural Wood Panels' , Robeller and Weinand built folded thin shell prototype consisting of timber panels by utilizing automatic fabrication of cabinetmaking joints, i.e. dovetail joints without adhesive (Figure 9) [46]. This interlocking arch prototype was constructed from 21 mm LVL panels and 12 mm plywood with a self-weight of 192 kg and a span of 3 meters to provide input on the load-carrying capacity of integrated joints. ...
Chapter
Full-text available
Engineered wood products (EWPs) have been progressively more being utilized in the construction industry as structural materials since the 1990s. In the content of EWPs, adhesives play an important role. However, because of their petroleum-based nature, adhesives contribute to toxic gas emissions such as formaldehyde and Volatile Organic Compounds, which are detrimental to the environment. Moreover, the frequent use of adhesives can cause other critical issues in terms of sustainability, recyclability, reusability, and further machining. In addition to this, metal connectors employed in EWPs harm their end-of-life disposal, reusability, and additional processing. This chapter is concentrating on dovetail massive wood elements (DMWE) as adhesive-and metal connector-free sustainable alternatives to commonly used EWPs e.g., CLT, LVL, MHM, Glulam. The dovetail technique has been a method of joinery mostly used in wood carpentry, including furniture, cabinets, log buildings, and traditional timber-framed buildings throughout its rich history. It is believed that this chapter will contribute to the uptake of DMWE for more diverse and innovative structural applications, thus the reduction in carbon footprint by increasing the awareness and uses of DMWE in construction.
Article
Timber folded-plate structures built with cross-laminated timber (CLT) panels can be applied to gymnasiums and conference halls. The design of the joints is crucial to facilitate the development of timber folded-plate structures. Considering that the compressive performance of CLT panels should be fully utilized and the failure of the joints was induced by the self-tapping screws, 45° miter-connected (MCJR) and mortise-tenon (MTJR) joints reinforced with self-tapping screws were designed. Eight CLT specimen groups with varying connection type, loading direction, and self-tapping screw spacing and diameter were designed and subjected to tests. Typical characteristics of the failure modes and moment–rotation curves were evaluated, and the corresponding rotational stiffness, yield rotation, yield moment, ultimate rotation, and ultimate moment of the specimens were calculated. The results showed that the failure mode of the MCJR and MTJR in push was the pull-out of self-tapping screws, and those in pull included the shear-off and pull-out of self-tapping screws. The loading direction significantly influenced the rotational stiffness and ultimate moment of both types of joints. The mechanical behavior of the MTJR in pull was better than that of the MCJR in pull; however, the rotational stiffness and ultimate moment of the MTJR in push were relatively lower than those of the MCJR in push. Moreover, increased self-tapping screw diameter and decreased self-tapping screw spacing significantly improved the mechanical behavior of MCJR. Finally, an analytical model was established to determine the rotational stiffness of the MCJR and MTJR in different loading directions. A comparison of the analytical and experimental results demonstrates that the proposed analytical method can conservatively estimate the rotational stiffness of the MCJR and MTJR.
Article
This paper aims to characterise the mechanical behaviour of folded timber sandwich structures developed using integral rotational press-fit (RPF) joints. Six folded arches are tested to failure, under three load cases designed to induce different sagging and hogging conditions at internal joints. Experimental testing showed failures occurring at joint locations with maximum hogging moment, with two failure types observed as FRP tensile fracture and core compressive rupture. A nonlinear static analysis and simplified 2D frame model is proposed to predict moment distribution and failure load for FRP fracture modes. This model characterises the RPF joint as a nonlinear semi-rigid hinge, with assigned bilinear moment–curvature relation obtained from analysis of joint strain data collected during arch testing. Core compressive failures are shown to occur as an inelastic core buckling behaviour when there is misalignment between assembled core segments.
Article
This paper presents an integrated design tool for structures composed of engineered timber panels that are connected by traditional wood joints. Recent advances in computational architecture have permitted to automate the fabrication and assembly of such structures using Computer Numerical Control (CNC) machines and industrial robotic arms. While several large-scale demonstrators have been realized, most developed algorithms are closed-source or project-oriented. The lack of a general framework makes it difficult for architects, engineers and designers to effectively manipulate this innovative construction system. Therefore, this research aims at developing a holistic design tool targeting a wide range of architectural applications. Main achievements include: (1) a new data structure to deal with modular assemblies, (2) an analytical parametrization of the geometry of five timber joints, (3) a method to generate CNC toolpath while integrating fabrication constraints, and (4) a method to automatically compute robot trajectories for a given stack of timber plates.
Article
Full-text available
Interlocking Particle Structures (IPS) are geometrically stable assemblies, usually fabricated from plate type elements that are interconnected by slotted joints. IPS are demountable and their components have the potential to be used and reused in different structures and configurations. This paper explores the applicability of birch plywood panels, which are characterized by a high surface hardness, for this type of structural system. Experimental tests were conducted to determine the mechanical properties of birch plywood plates. Moreover, IPS connections with different geometrical properties were investigated for two different load exposures: bending and rotation. The characteristics under bending exposure are influenced by the orientation of the face-veneers. For the rotational load exposure, very small strength and stiffness properties have been identified. A linear elastic finite element model is presented that shows a wide agreement with the test results. The study serves as an initial probe into the performance of IPS structures at the component level. Various aspects that are relevant for the design of IPS, such as the assembly, the accuracy and challenges regarding digital fabrication, the durability, and the structural performance are discussed.
Chapter
Full-text available
The prototype presented in this chapter utilizes the technique of curved folding for the design of a thin-shell structure built from curved cross-laminated timber panels (CLT). The curved-folded geometry allows for a span of 13.5 m, at a shell thickness of only 77 mm. The construction requires curved line CLT joints, which are difficult to address with state-of-the-art jointing techniques for CLT. Inspired by traditional woodworking joinery, we have designed connections for the integrated attachment of curved CLT panels, utilizing digital geometry processing tools to combine the advantages of traditional joinery techniques with those of modern automation technology.
Thesis
Full-text available
Timber folded plate Structures combine the advantages of timber as a construction material, such as its carbon-dioxide storage, low energy production and favorable weight-to-strength ratio, with the structural efficiency and elegance of folded surface structures. The construction of such surface-active structure systems with timber is a relatively new development, driven by an increasing awareness for sustainable building constructions, and enabled by new engineered wood products. However, these constructions require a large amount of edgewise joints between the thin timber plates, which are difficult to address with state-of-the-art connection techniques. Instead of using mass-produced mechanical fasteners for these connections, this thesis investigates the use of customized Integral Mechanical Attachment techniques, which use geometrical features of the parts to establish connections, rather than additional fasteners. Integral joints were common in traditional woodworking, but their manual crafting became infeasible during the industrialization. However, new computer-controlled fabrication technology, which is already available in the timber prefabrication industry, allows for an efficient, automatic production of integral joints. The advantages of such joints have already been demonstrated in framing constructions, where timber beams are used as the primary structural components. The proliferation of automatic joinery machines has repatriated customizable single-degree-of-freedom (1DOF) joints, which allow for the fast and precise assembly of prefabricated components. The objective of this thesis is to transfer these advantages to the construction of timber folded plate structures. Inspiration is taken from traditional cabinetmaking joints from Europe and Asia, as well as other industry sectors, where mass-produced integral joints are commonly used. The thesis will demonstrate several adaptations which have been made for the application of the joints on cross-laminated wood panels, for their automatic fabrication and for the customized purposes in the jointing timber folded plate structures. The geometry, fabrication and assembly of these new joints is being implemented and tested through the development of algorithmic tools. This is followed up by a verification of the proposed methods through large- and small scale physical prototypes. In its three peer-reviewed core chapters, the thesis presents investigations ranging from an initial hybrid approach, where integral joints are combined with adhesive bonding, towards a completely integral mechanical attachment solution. After a first application of the joints on a surface which is folded in one direction, the integral attachment of bidirectionally folded surfaces will be demonstrated. This is achieved through a new technique, which allows for the simultaneous jointing of multiple non-parallel edges, with single-degree-of-freedom joints. Algorithms will be presented, which allow for the automatic processing and the automatic fabrication of the joints. The automation of these processes will then be used for the construction of a doubly-curved, bidirectionally-folded surface, which obtains its structurally beneficial double-curvature through incremental changes in the geometry of the plates. [...]
Chapter
Full-text available
The HygroSkin project explores a novel mode of climate responsive architecture based on the combination and interrelationships of material inherent behaviour, computational morphogenesis and robotic manufacturing. The dimensional instability of wood in relation to moisture content is employed to develop a meteorosensitive architectural skin that opens and closes in response to climate changes with no need for any technical equipment or a supply of external energy. Embedded within robotically fabricated, lightweight structural components made of elastically bent plywood panels, the responsive wood-composite apertures adjust the envelope’s porosity in direct feedback to changes in ambient relative humidity. The HygroSkin Pavilion was commissioned by the Fonds Régional d’Art Contemporain du Centre and now forms part of the permanent collection of the FRAC Centre in Orleans.
Chapter
Full-text available
The research presented in this paper pursues the development and construction of a robotically fabricated, lightweight timber plate system through a biologically informed, integrative computational design method. In the first part of the paper, the authors give an overview of their approach starting with the description of the biological role model and its technical abstraction, moving on to discuss the computational modelling approach that integrates relevant aspects of biomimetics, robotic fabrication and structural design. As part of the validation of the research, a full-scale, fully enclosed, insulated and waterproof building prototype has been developed and realized: The first building featuring a robotically fabricated primary structure made of beech plywood. Subsequently, the methods and results of a geodetic evaluation of the fabrication process are presented. Finally, as the close collaboration between architects, structural and geodetic engineers, and timber fabricators is integral to the process, the architectural and structural potentials of such integrative design processes are discussed. 1 Introduction New developments in computational design and digital fabrication currently lead to a rethinking of architectural design and delivery processes. In contrast to traditional, hierarchical, and form-driven design approaches, integrative strategies can activate discipline-specific knowledge in early design stages. In the case of the research presented in this paper, this includes the activation of reciprocal dependencies between architectural geometry, biomimetic engineering, structural design, robotic fabrication and geodetic evaluation (engineering geodesy being the
Article
Full-text available
The objective of the paper is the parametrization and the finite element analysis of mechanical properties of a through dovetail joint made with the use of a specific procedure by a 3-axis CNC machine. This corner joint was used for the simulation of the bending load of the joint in the angle plane - by compression, i.e. by pressing the joint together. The deformation fields, the stress distribution, the stiffness and the bending moment of the joints were evaluated. The finite element system ANSYS was used to create two parametric numerical models of the joint. The first one represents an ideally stiff joint - both joint parts have been glued together. The second model includes the contact between the joined parts. This numerical model was used to monitor the response of the joint stiffness to the change of the static friction coefficient. The results of both models were compared both with each other and with similar analyses conducted within the research into ready-to-assemble furniture joints. The results can be employed in the designing of more complex furniture products with higher demands concerning stiffness characteristics, such as furniture for sitting. However, this assumption depends on the correction of the created parametric models by experimental testing.
Article
Full-text available
In the current paper the authors present a biomimetic design methodology based on the analysis of the Echinoids (sea urchin and sand dollar) and the transfer of its structural morphology into a built full-scale prototype. In the first part, an efficient wood jointing technique for planar sheets of wood through novel robotically fabricated finger-joints is introduced together with an investigation of the biological principles of plate structures and their mechanical features. Subsequently, the identified structural principles are translated and verified with the aid of a Finite Element Model, as well as a generative design system incorporating the rules and constraints of fabrication. The paper concludes with the presentation of a full-scale biomimetic prototype which integrates these morphological and mechanical principles to achieve an efficient and high-performing lightweight structure.
Article
Full-text available
p. 1019-1031 The two main folding plate principles of pointed folding plates forming an facet texture and longitudinal folding plates forming the typical fold texture imply different fields of application in architecture and structural engineering. This Paper presents a method of developing the folding plate principles on spatial structures also with irregular and freeform geometries. Hereby algorithms of triangulation, originally applied in finite elements analysis, are used for discretisation and form-finding of the textures of folded plate shells
Conference Paper
The research presented in this paper pursues the development and construction of a robotically fabricated, lightweight timber plate system through a biologically informed, integrative computational design method. In the first part of the paper, the authors give an overview of their approach starting with the description of the biological role model and its technical abstraction, moving on to discuss the computational modelling approach that integrates relevant aspects of biomimetics, robotic fabrication and structural design. As part of the validation of the research, a full-scale, fully enclosed, insulated and waterproof building prototype has been developed and realized: The first building featuring a robotically fabricated primary structure made of beech plywood. Subsequently, the methods and results of a geodetic evaluation of the fabrication process are presented. Finally, as the close collaboration between architects, structural and geodetic engineers, and timber fabricators is integral to the process, the architectural and structural potentials of such integrative design processes are discussed.
Article
Integral Mechanical Attachment, highlights on one of the world's oldest technologies and makes it new again. Think of buttons and toggles updated to innovative snaps, hooks, and interlocking industrial parts. Mechanical fasteners have been around as long as mankind, but manufacturers of late have been re-discovering their quick, efficient and fail proof advantages when using them as interlocking individual components as compared with such traditional means of joining materials like welding, soldering, gluing and using nuts bolts, rivets and other similar devices. For many years, it has been virtually impossible to find a single-source reference that provides an overview of the various categories of fastening systems and their various applications. Design engineers should find this book to be an invaluable source of detailed, illustrated information on how such fasteners work, and how they can save time and money. Students, too, will find this book to be extremely useful for courses in mechanical design, machine design, product development and other related areas where fastening and joining subjects are taught. This will be the first reference book to come along in many years that will fully illustrate the major classes of integral mechanical fasteners, replete with examples of typical assembly and ideas and suggestions for further research. * Covers all major techniques for integral mechanical attachment within the context of other types of joining including chemical (adhesive) bonding, melting and solidification (welding, soldering, brazing), and mechanical joining (fasteners and part features) * Includes specific chapters for particular attachment considerations by materials type, including metals, plastics, ceramics, glass, wood, and masonry * Provides unique coverage of mechanical/electrical connections for reliable contact and use.
Article
In which order can a product be assembled or disassembled? How many hands are required? How many degrees of freedom? What parts should be withdrawn to allow the removal of a specified subassembly? To answer such questions automatically, important theoretical issues in geometric reasoning must be addressed. This paper investigates the planning of assembly algorithms specifying (dis) assembly operations on the components of a product and the ordering of these operations. It also presents measures to evaluate the complexity of these algorithms and techniques to estimate the inherent complexity of a product. The central concept underlying these planning and complexity evaluation techniques is that of a “non-directional blocking graph”, a qualitative representation of the internal structure of an assembly product. This representation describes the combinatorial set of parts interactions in polynomial space. It is obtained by identifying physical criticalities where geometric interferences among parts change. It is generated from an input geometric description of the product. The main application considered in the paper is the creation of smart environments to help designers create products that are easier to manufacture and service. Other possible applications include planning for rapid prototyping and autonomous robots.