ArticlePDF Available

Application of different external tagging methods to "Octopus vulgaris" Cuvier, 1797, with special reference to T-bar anchor tags and Petersen disks

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

This paper presents a study on the persistence and effects caused by a wide variety of types of tag (loops, rabbit tags, girths, flexible plastic bands, small darts, Petersen disks, T-bar anchor tags, circular plastic tags, rectangular plastic flags, jewellery pins, commercial badges, and burning with liquid nitrogen) applied to the cephalopod Octopus vulgaris Cuvier, 1797, under culture conditions. Preliminary analysis of the results obtained with the different tagging systems indicates that Petersen disks and T-bar anchor tags are the most suitable types. Both provide adequate retention after 1 month (90 % and 80 %, respectively), a maximum persistence of three months, a similar cost, and they are easily recognised externally. However, Petersen disks can produce serious injuries, and require a more laborious insertion process. Therefore, in the final analysis, the insertion of T-bar anchor tags in left arm III can be considered the most appropriate system.
Content may be subject to copyright.
3
Bol. Inst. Esp. Oceanogr. 22 (1-4). 2006: 3-11 BOLETÍN. INSTITUTO ESPAÑOL DE OCEANOGRAFÍA
ISSN: 0074-0195
© Instituto Español de Oceanografía, 2006
Application of different external tagging methods
to Octopus vulgaris Cuvier, 1797, with special
reference to T-bar anchor tags and Petersen disks
L. Fuentes, J. J. Otero, C. Moxica, F. J. Sánchez and J. Iglesias
Centro Oceanográfico de Vigo, Instituto Español de Oceanografía, Apdo. 1552, E-36200 Vigo, Pontevedra, Spain.
E-mails: lidia.fuentes@vi.ieo.es; jjose.otero@vi.ieo.es; covimoxica@inicia.es; javier.sanchez@vi.ieo.es; jose.iglesias@vi.ieo.es
Received November 2003. Accepted May 2005.
ABSTRACT
This paper presents a study on the persistence and effects caused by a wide variety of types of
tag (loops, rabbit tags, girths, flexible plastic bands, small darts, Petersen disks, T-bar anchor tags,
circular plastic tags, rectangular plastic flags, jewellery pins, commercial badges, and burning
with liquid nitrogen) applied to the cephalopod Octopus vulgaris Cuvier, 1797, under culture
conditions. Preliminary analysis of the results obtained with the different tagging systems indi-
cates that Petersen disks and T-bar anchor tags are the most suitable types. Both provide adequate
retention after 1 month (90 % and 80 %, respectively), a maximum persistence of three months,
a similar cost, and they are easily recognised externally. However, Petersen disks can produce se-
rious injuries, and require a more laborious insertion process. Therefore, in the final analysis, the
insertion of T-bar anchor tags in left arm III can be considered the most appropriate system.
Keywords: Octopus vulgaris, tagging, T-bar anchor tags, Petersen disks.
RESUMEN
Aplicación de diferentes métodos de marcado externo a Octopus vulgaris Cuvier, 1797 con referencia
especial a las marcas de tipo T y a los discos de Petersen
En este trabajo se presentan datos de persistencia y efectos provocados por una gran variedad de estilos de
marcas (loops, marcas de conejos, cinchas, cintas plásticas flexibles, lancetas, discos de Petersen, marcas de
tipo T, marcas plásticas circulares, banderillas plásticas rectangulares, soportes de bisutería, pines comerciales
y quemaduras con nitrógeno líquido) aplicadas al cefalópodo Octopus vulgaris Cuvier, 1797 sometido a
condiciones de cultivo. Tras una primera revisión de los resultados obtenidos con los diferentes sistemas de
marcado se concluye que los discos de Petersen y las marcas de tipo T son los más aconsejables. Ambos mues-
tran una retención adecuada después de un mes (90 y 80 % respectivamente), una persistencia máxima de
tres meses, un coste similar y ambos son detectados externamente con facilidad. Sin embargo, los discos de
Petersen producen heridas considerables y requieren un proceso de inserción más laborioso, por lo que, final-
mente, el sistema considerado más adecuado fue la inserción de marcas de tipo T en el brazo III izquierdo.
Palabras clave: Octopus vulgaris, marcado, marcas de tipo T, discos de Petersen.
INTRODUCTION
The experiments described in this article took
place within the research project titled ‘Tagging
and release of Octopus vulgaris Cuvier, 1797, paralar-
vae and juveniles’ (CYTMAR 97-0323) and were de-
veloped at the Instituto Español de Oceanografía
(IEO) in Vigo (northwest Spain). The main goal of
this project was to determine the most efficient tag-
ging systems for O. vulgaris paralarvae and juveniles.
The first phase, on efficient internal tagging for par-
alarvae, has been described by the authors in a pre-
vious article (Fuentes, Iglesias and Moxica, 2000),
where a chemical tagging method for statoliths with
alizarin complexone was used. The present paper
focuses on experiments performed using external
tagging in octopus sub-adults, in order to deter-
mine the most efficient tagging technique.
There is considerable literature on finfish tagging
(e.g., Nielsen, 1992; Sánchez-Lamadrid, 2001), but
there are far less publications related to
cephalopods, and more specifically, to the common
octopus O. vulgaris. Especially noteworthy is the
compilation made by Nagasawa, Takayagani and
Takami (1993), presenting data published in Japan
between 1927 and 1990 on 14 cephalopod species.
Cephalopod tagging has also been indirectly ad-
dressed in other publications, such as Sakurai et al.
(1993) and Gonçalves et al. (1995), who worked with
Todarodes pacificus (Steenstrup, 1880) and Loligo
forbesi (Steenstrup, 1856) respectively. Taki (1941),
Inoue, Hamaguchi and Li (1953), Katayama and
Morita (1960) showed the difficulties inherent in
tagging O. vulgaris since, despite having used metal
plaques, heat burning, wires and different colorants
(methylene blue, neutral red, trypan blue, erythro-
sine, saffranine) on the skin or injected in the mus-
cle, they failed to obtain satisfactory results.
Domain, Jouffre and Caverivière (2000) compared
O. vulgaris growth in tanks with marked wild indi-
viduals in Senegalese waters using Petersen disks.
In this article, a detailed description is given of
the steps followed to select the most efficient tag-
ging method, as well as the most suitable body area
to tag on O. vulgaris.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Capture and acclimatisation of juveniles
Octopus specimens weighing between 0.5 and 1
kg were caught in the Ría de Vigo between 1998
and 2001 by small local fishing boats. They were
transferred to IEO facilities in 200 l tanks with prop-
erly oxygenated seawater. Before beginning the tag-
ging experiments, the specimens were acclimatised
to captivity for one week, following the recommen-
dations on water circuit, type of tank, characteristics
of den, etc., given by Iglesias et al. (1999). The food
given consisted basically of frozen crabs Carcinus
maenas L., 1758 although sporadically the diet was
complemented with fish, mainly Micromesistius
poutassou (Risso, 1826) and mussels Mytilus sp.
Types of external tag and their placement
During the first two years (1998 and 1999) a
wide range of tags were tested: injected acrylic
paint and cold burning with liquid nitrogen, plastic
tags (loops, girths, small darts, flexible plastic
bands, badges, earrings or jewellery pins, rabbit
tags and Petersen disks) and those inserted with a
gun (T-type anchor tags or Corplus®circular and
rectangular ones). Following is a brief description
of each one (some of them are showed in figure 1).
Loops (Hallprint®, ‘Self-locking loop tags’ se-
ries SLA). The ends of this 5" (118.5 mm) plas-
tic cord join in a mechanism which prevents
tag loss. These were manually placed in the
mantle and arm.
Metal rabbit tags (Hauptner®). A rectangular
numbered plaque (10 mm by 5 mm) with
pointed prongs on the base which pierce the
structure to be tagged –in our case, the man-
tle– and once inside are bent into place.
• Small commercial plastic girths, length 100
mm which were fixed round the arms and in
the external end of the mantle.
Flexible plastic bands (Hallprint®‘Polyethylene
streamer tags’, series PST), especially designed
for crustaceans (shrimps, crabs, small lobster,
etc.). The band pierces the structure to be
tagged (mantle) drawn by a needle, which is
later withdrawn. The two ends of the bands
are free whilst the middle part goes through
the structure to be tagged.
• Darts (Hallprint®, ‘Small plastic tipped dart
tags’ series PD). They have a hook-like point
and are inserted by being placed into a thin
tube with a sharp end, which is introduced in-
to the area to be tagged (arms) and then slow-
L. Fuentes et al. External tagging of Octopus vulgaris
Bol. Inst. Esp. Oceanogr. 22 (1-4). 2006: 3-11
4
is inserted into the animal’s body and the
longer bar (35 mm) bears an inscription,
which includes the tag number, address and
telephone. This tag is inserted using a tagging
gun designed by the same company.
Circular plastic tags (Insvet Corplus®). A sys-
tem similar to Petersen disks; that is, two
plaques of approximately 20 mm diameter,
joined by an element which pierces the body
structure (mantle), but in this case, the pin is
replaced by a larger diameter element. These
tags are inserted with a specific applicator.
Rectangular plastic tags (Corplus®), a tagging
system similar to the previous one, but with
L. Fuentes et al. External tagging of Octopus vulgaris
Bol. Inst. Esp. Oceanogr. 22 (1-4). 2006: 3-11 5
Figure 1. Different kinds of tags used in the
present study
Loops Metal rabbit tags
Flexible plastic bands Darts
Petersen disks T-bar anchor tags
Circular plastic tags Rectangular plastic tags
ly withdrawn, making sure that the point of
the dart is anchored.
• Petersen disks (Floy Tag & MGF. CO., INC.).
The 9/16" (13.3 mm) diameter disks with a cen-
tral hole are made of vinyl protected against UV;
the nickel pins measure 3" (11.1 mm). The sys-
tem consists of two disks joined by a pin which
can pierce any part of the body. The inscription
on this type of tag is on the surface of one of the
disks and their insertion, unlike the T-bar an-
chor tags is, completely manual.
• T-bar anchor tags (Hallprint®‘T-bar anchor
tags’, series TBF-2 fine) are pieces of flexible T-
shaped plastic. The short bar of the T (8 mm)
the difference that the plaques are rectangu-
lar (approx. 30 mm 10 mm). Their inser-
tion also requires an applicator from the same
firm.
Nitrogen burns were produced by pressing the
animal’s skin with rods previously submerged
in liquid nitrogen. The numbers on the end of
the rods are then tattooed on the octopus
mantle.
Others. Other systems were tested such as, ear-
ring bases, commercial badges on the edge of
the mantle, and even subcutaneous injection
with acrylic paint in the arms and mantle.
Most of these (loops, rabbit tags, flexible plastic
girths, darts, Petersen disks and T-bar anchor tags)
carry an inscription which makes individual track-
ing possible.
To select the most appropriate tagging place, in-
sertions were made in the mantle and the arms. An
experiment was also carried out to determine
which arm was the most suitable for use with this
type of tags, so tests were made in triplicate on left
arms I, II, III and IV.
Preliminary experiments
Throughout 1998 and 1999, numerous tests
were carried out, which made it possible to evalu-
ate the degree of retention rate in a wide range of
external tags on the species O. vulgaris. All these ex-
periments took place in 1 m3tanks in an open wa-
ter circuit using 10 specimens per test, and had a
duration of 1 month. The tags were those cited in
the previous methodology section. In each experi-
ment, calculations were made regarding degree of
retention, injuries produced, and maximum persis-
tence, so that at the end of this process, it was pos-
sible to select the most suitable tag.
Comparison between T-bar anchor tags
and Petersen disks
From the preliminary experiments, the conclu-
sion reached was that the most persistent tags were
the T-bar anchor tag and the Petersen disks.
Consequently, in 2000-2001, more exhaustive tests
were carried out, with the aim of determining the
efficiency of each one and finding out which was
the most effective placement.
Before comparing Petersen disks and T-bar an-
chor tags, another experiment had been designed
to select the most suitable arm for tagging, in
which 12 octopi were tagged, three replicates each
for the I, II, III and IV left arms with Petersen disks
in individual 100 l tanks. Right arms were not test-
ed so as not to interfere so as to not interfere with
the male reproductive function (as is known, the
third right arm, or hectocotylus, is used by males to
copulate). This experiment lasted 1 month, and
the number of injuries and lost tags were moni-
tored weekly.
To compare Petersen disks and T-bar, the follow-
ing methodology was used.
To avoid the octopi becoming hyperactive dur-
ing the tagging process, they were anaesthetised by
immersion for 5 minutes in cold seawater (4-5 ºC),
to which a few drops of ethyl alcohol had been
added.
The tests were carried out with 2 replicates for
each type of mark, both in the mantle and in left
arm III. The experiments had a duration of 1
month and were kept in 2 000 l capacity tanks with
10 specimens in each, so a total of 80 specimens
were tagged. Weekly, for the period of 1 month, a
control was carried out, recording the weight of
specimens in each experiment, the number of lost
tags and any other kind of observation related to
tag evolution (correct fixing, appearance of rele-
vant injuries, etc.). Finally the possible effect of the
marking procedure on growth was analysed in both
types of tags.
RESULTS
Preliminary experiments
Concerning the different types of marks utilised,
it was observed from the first-year results that most
of the marks were lost in the first two weeks of the
experiments, confirming the difficulty of tagging
cephalopods. A brief summary of these results ob-
tained for each system are presented in figure 2.
None of the loops lasted more than 9 days. The cir-
cular plastic tags (Insvet Corplus®) lasted between
4 and 14 days; only one of them reached 27 days.
Only one of the metal rabbit tags remained 6 days
joined to the octopus. The octopi freed themselves
from the girths very easily, and when this was not
L. Fuentes et al. External tagging of Octopus vulgaris
Bol. Inst. Esp. Oceanogr. 22 (1-4). 2006: 3-11
6
the case, they caused considerable injuries where
they had been placed. The majority of the badges
became unpinned on the same day that they were
inserted; one lasted 10 days. The jewellery bases
did not survive long, except in one specific case,
which lasted 42 days. The paint disappeared almost
immediately, leaving no trace. After a month, only
37 % liquid nitrogen burns were visible, but their
numbers were unreadable; the lack of firmness and
scant consistency of octopus muscle, coupled with
its capacity for regeneration, make tag retention
difficult.
On the other hand, the results of those experi-
ments carried out with T-bar (anchor) tags were
most satisfactory, recording a retention rate of 77%
after a month (figure 2), and a maximum persis-
tence time of 89 days (data recorded after the 1-
month experiment). In the case of the Petersen
disks, a similar retention rate (62 %) was obtained
after a month, compared with the T-bar tags, but
wounds soon appeared in the insertion area when
Petersen disks were used.
From these results, it was concluded that among
all the different types of tags used, the most suit-
able were Petersen disks and T-bar anchor tags.
The study was therefore oriented towards a more
detailed comparison between these two types.
Comparative study between Petersen
disks and T-bar anchor tags
Evaluation of the most suitable arm
From the 12 individuals marked in left arms I, II,
III and IV, only one specimen, specifically one
tagged on left arm II, lost its tag before a month
had elapsed (figure 3). As the results showed no
preference among treatments and retention per-
centages were similar, left arm III was chosen for fu-
ture experiments.
Marking effect on growth
Figure 4 shows the mean wet weight observed in
the 1-month period of growth for the individuals
marked with T-bar and Petersen disk tags. Initial
mean weights were 846.5 g for T-bar and 843.6 g for
the Petersen disk, reaching final weights of 1 157.9
g and 1 000.3 g, respectively. Growth in weight was
adjusted to the following exponential equations:
T-bar: y 865.49 e0.0384x; R20.8897
Petersen disk: y 849.35 e0.0773x; R20.9867
No significant difference in growth was found
between the two groups (
0.05), indicating that
L. Fuentes et al. External tagging of Octopus vulgaris
Bol. Inst. Esp. Oceanogr. 22 (1-4). 2006: 3-11 7
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
0 7 14 21 28
P e rsist e nce (day s)
Re te ntio n r a te ( % )
Lo o p s
Nitr o g en
T- b a r
C i rcu l ar In s v et
Re c t a ngul a r C.
Rab b it/Gir th s/Ear r i n g /
Pa i n t
Ba dg e s
Pe t e r s e n di s k
Figure 2. Retention rate (%) for each type of mark from preliminary experiments (1 month long)
DISCUSSION
In this work the great difficulty in tagging
cephalopods when compared with fish tagging has
been confirmed. Considerable differences exist be-
tween the viability of same tagging technique being
used with fish and cephalopods. O. vulgaris muscle is
less firm than that of fish, and therefore tag anchor-
ing is less safe and reliable; nor do cephalopods have
no hard structures, such as a backbone, on which to
thread the tags. At the same time, the great agility in-
herent to octopi, along with the whole range of
movements they can make with their arms, play a de-
cisive part against any tagging system, since these
characteristics enable them to remove their own tags
or those of others. All of these factors have compli-
cated considerably the choice of a suitable tag for
these animals.
The retention rate and effects on the tagged
specimen with regard to survival, injuries and
growth, along with difficulties related to applica-
tion processes and tag detection, are fundamental
L. Fuentes et al. External tagging of Octopus vulgaris
Bol. Inst. Esp. Oceanogr. 22 (1-4). 2006: 3-11
8
0
1
2
3
4
0 da y s 7 da y s 14 da y s 21 da y s 28 da y s
T i m e afte r tag g i n g (d ays)
Oc t opus wi t h di s k s
Ar m I
Ar m I I
A r m III
Ar m I V
Figure 3. Persistence (days) of the tags
placed in different arms (right arms I, II, III
and IV)
there was no negative effect of the marking proce-
dure on growth.
Persistence obtained in both types of tags
In figure 5, it can be seen that inserting the tag
in the arm was more effective than in the mantle,
both with Petersen disks and T-bar anchor tags. Of
those markers inserted in the mantle, only one of
the 10 disks reached day 28 of the experiment, and
all the T-tags were lost during the first week.
Regarding the comparison between the disks
and the T-tags using left arm III as a site, average
values of 80 % T-tags and 90% disks remained in
place for the 4 weeks of the test (figure 5). Both
marks presented a maximum persistence of more
than 3 months (data recorded after the 1-month
experiment). However, it is necessary to point out
that disks caused cuts and other injuries in the in-
sertion area after the first week of the experi-
ment.
Petersen disk:
y = 865.49 e0.0384x
R
2
= 0.8897
T-bar:
y = 849.35 e0.0773x
R
2
= 0.9867
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
012345
Time after marking (weeks)
W e g i e w t h t g ( )
Average Disk-Arm A-B
Average T-Arm A-B
Figure 4. Growth in mean wet weight (g)
from individuals marked with Petersen
disks and T-bar anchor tags during
1 month
Petersen discs on left arm III
0
2
4
6
8
10
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Petersen disks on mantle
0
2
4
6
8
10
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
T-bar anchor tags on left arm III
0
2
4
6
8
10
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
T-bar anchor tags on mantle
0
2
4
6
8
10
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
o n : Y i f o . n d i d i v u a s l h t i w ag t
X: time after tagging (days)
issues to consider when a tagging system is to be
chosen for enhancement programmes (Collins,
Smith and Heyward, 1994). Each of these aspects
was analysed for the tags used in this experiment.
Regarding retention rate from preliminary experi-
ments, we had to reject such systems as acrylic paint
injections, plastic girths, metal rabbit tags, com-
mercial badges, liquid nitrogen burns, and loops.
The maximum persistence for earring bases, circu-
lar plastic tags (Insvet) and rectangular flags
(Corplus®) was approximately 30 days, but only a
very low percentage of these actually lasted that
long. In addition, the last two types of tags men-
tioned caused considerable injuries. Subsequently,
only the Petersen disks and the T-bar anchor tags
passed this first screening.
Several authors have already dealt with the sub-
ject of tagging O. vulgaris. Most of these works are
by Japanese authors and almost none are recent.
Taki (1941) compared the permanence of several
types of tags and marks to identify O. vulgaris indi-
L. Fuentes et al. External tagging of Octopus vulgaris
Bol. Inst. Esp. Oceanogr. 22 (1-4). 2006: 3-11 9
viduals kept in aquariums. The tags evaluated were
pieces of sewn material, metal plaques, removal of a
sucker, and dyeing techniques using trypan blue on
the dorsal part of the mantle. He observed that the
first two systems were easily removed by the animals;
the excision of a sucker was only valid during the
two months of regeneration, and that trypan blue
produced stains which were visible up to six months
after application. Inoue, Hamaguchi and Li (1953)
maintained that burning is effective for O. vulgaris,
and attained a 90-day persistence. Regarding this
particular tagging system, Katayama and Morita
(1960) suggested that the best place for its applica-
tion is the posterior end of the mantle, because
there it is easily and does not change its shape.
However, we observed poor retention rates for cold
burning. Itami (1964) also showed that 35.7% of
the animals tagged in this way died from the effects,
but these were particularly small specimens.
Takeda et al. (1981) again used trypan blue and
detected marks a month after tagging. These same
Figure 5. Persistence obtained in a comparative study between Petersen disks and T-bar anchor tags. Replica 1: ; repli-
ca 2:
authors showed that wires used to pierce the man-
tle or the umbrella were pulled out by the octopi,
in most cases in less than 20 days. This fact is agree-
ment with the results of this paper, which clearly
stated that better retention rates were obtained
when octopi were marked in the arm rather than in
the mantle.
Studies carried out more recently by Tsuchiya,
Ikeda and Shimizu (1986) examined the effective-
ness of a wide range of tags (anchor tag, dart tag,
Petersen disks, fingerling tag, metal ring and nylon
thread) and dyes (methylene blue, neutral red, ery-
throsine and saffranine T). They showed that in
general, tags (external marks) were not effective,
some of them being removed by the arms and oth-
ers becoming loosened by the injuries caused by
the tagging process. On the other hand, the meth-
ylene blue and neutral red intramuscular injec-
tions under skin of the mantle to form 1-2 cm di-
ameter stains, were successful insofar as persistence
was concerned, and hardly affected the tagged ani-
mals. This method of individual recognition using
dyes could be viable at an experimental level, but it
does not permit individual identification of tagged
specimens when the intention is to use a tag recog-
nisable to fisherman in an enhancement pro-
gramme.
In this work, Petersen disks and T-bar anchor tag
were the only methods that passed the first screen-
ing and provided adequate retention after 1 month
(90 % and 80 %, respectively). Both had a maxi-
mum persistence of three months and a similar
cost; moreover, they are easily recognised external-
ly. Domain, Jouffre and Caverivière (2000) also
used Petersen disks in growth studies, and they ob-
tained promising persistence values (up to 177
days). It must be remembered, however, that the
disks require a laborious manual insertion process,
and that the cuts and other injuries produced can
be very serious and increase mortality.
Consequently, we recommended the use of a T-
bar anchor tag inserted in left arm III to carry out
short-term studies (1-3 months) on the biology and
distribution of O. vulgaris juveniles in their natural
environment.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This work has been carried out with a grant from
the Inter-ministerial Commission for Science and
Technology and the Instituto Español de
Oceanografía, as part of the CYTMAR 97-0323 pro-
ject.
REFERENCES
Collins, M. R., T. I. J. Smith and L. D. Heyward. 1994.
Effectiveness of six methods for marking juvenile short-
nose sturgeons. Progressive Fish-Culturist 56 (4): 250-254.
Domain, F., D. Jouffre and A. Caverivière. 2000. Growth of
Octopus vulgaris from tagging in Senegalese waters.
Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United
Kingdom 80 (4): 699-705.
Fuentes, L., J. Iglesias and C. Moxica. 2000. Marking octo-
pus (Octopus vulgaris) paralarvae statoliths with alizarin
complexone. Journal of the Marine Biological Association of
the United Kingdom 80: 553-554.
Gonçalves, J. M., F. M. Porteiro, F. Cardigos and H. R.
Martins. 1995. The Azorean adult squid Loligo forbesi in
captivity: transport, handling, maintenance, tagging and
survival. International Council for the Exploitation of the Sea.
Mariculture Committee C.M. 1995/F:14 Ref. K: 1-15.
Iglesias, J., F. J. Sánchez, J. J. Otero and C. Moxica. 1999.
Culture of octopus (Octopus vulgaris Cuvier): Present
knowledge, problems and perspectives. In: Recent ad-
vances in Mediterranean aquaculture finfish species diversifi-
cation. Cahiers Options Méditerranéennes 47: 313-321.
Inoue, K., A. Hamaguchi and A. Li. 1953. Preliminary mark-
and-release experiment of common octopus. Annual
Report. Hyogo Prefectural Fisheries Experimental Station.1952:
p. 123. (In Japanese.)
Itami, K. 1964. Marks for common octopus and results of
marking experiments. Suisanzoshoku 12: 119-125. (In
Japanese.)
Katayama, K. and S. Morita. 1960. Preliminary survey of
common octopus. Annual Report. Okayama Prefectural
Fisheries Experimental Station.1959: p. 32. (In Japanese.)
Nagasawa, K., S. Takayagani and T. Takami. 1993.
Cephalopod tagging and marking in Japan: a review. In:
Recent Advances in Fisheries Biology. T. Okutani, R. K.
O’Dor and T. Kubodera (eds.): 313-319. Tokai University
Press. Tokyo.
Nielsen, L. A. 1992. Methods of marking fish and shellfish.
American Fisheries Society. Special Publication 23: 208 pp.
Sakurai, Y., Y. Ikeda, M. Shimizu and K. Shimazaki. 1993.
Feeding and growth of captive adult Japanese common
squid, Todarodes pacificus, measuring initial body size by
cold anesthesia. In: Recent Advances in Fisheries Biology. T.
Okutani, R. K. O’Dor and T. Kubodera (eds.): 467-476.
Tokai University Press. Tokyo.
Sánchez-Lamadrid, A. 2001. Effectiveness of four methods for
tagging juveniles of farm-reared gilthead sea bream, Sparus
aurata, L. Fisheries Management and Ecology 8: 271-278.
Takeda, R., S. Karata, K. Nakamoto, T. Nakano, T. Sakai, K.
Itami, Y. Sano, S. Nose, N. Mitsuo, T. Yahashi, K.
Nakamura, N. Sakai, N. Hamano, T. Doi and T.
Kawakami. 1981. Survey of large-scale propagation area
in 1980 (Meitan area: common octopus). Annual Report.
L. Fuentes et al. External tagging of Octopus vulgaris
Bol. Inst. Esp. Oceanogr. 22 (1-4). 2006: 3-11
10
Hyogo Prefectural Fisheries Experimental Station. 1980: 359-
369. (In Japanese.)
Taki, I. 1941. On keeping octopods in an aquarium for
physiological experiments, with remarks on some opera-
tive techniques. Venus 10: 140-156.
Tsuchiya, H., F. Ikeda and T. Shimizu. 1986. The study on
octopus (Octopus vulgaris Cuvier) resource in Tokyo Bay-
III. Experiment of marking methods for octopus.
Bulletin. Kanagawa Prefectural Fisheries Experimental Station
7: 45-53. (In Japanese.)
L. Fuentes et al. External tagging of Octopus vulgaris
Bol. Inst. Esp. Oceanogr. 22 (1-4). 2006: 3-11 11
... Within the national park, small-scale shellfish and artisanal fishing activities are permitted, while recreational fisheries are banned [18]. Individual O. vulgaris were tracked within the boundaries of an acoustic telemetry array composed of 26 omni-directional receiver stations (Thelma Biotel TBR700L) and four reference transmitters (Thelma Biotel [n = 2 D-2LP13; n = 2 D-2LP9L] [26,27]. The fixed telemetry array covered ~ 1.09 km 2 based on an intermediate established detection radius of 250 m from receivers (maximum detection range of 400 m on hard substrates and 200 m on soft substrates for 9 mm transmitters, we thus suggest ~ 250 m to account for 6 mm transmitters) [25], with receivers located at depths ranging from 3.3 to 13.1 m. ...
... These specimens were each observed over a ~ 1 month period, totalling to a 4 month pilot study, to determine unusual behaviours caused by the tagging procedure, assess tag retention and monitor potential injuries. Furthermore, the retention of T-bar plastic tags (Floy© Tag) was also evaluated with the two octopuses tagged in the third arm [27]. T-bar tags enable the recording of re-sightings or recaptures, and prevent double tagging. ...
... Our acoustic transmitter retention study revealed that the third left arm, (but not the mantle), is a suitable area of attachment for this species, at least at the time scale at which we evaluated retention. This is in accordance with the previous observation of successful retention of Peterson discs attached also to the third arm for at least a month in common octopus [27]. In addition, Barry et al. (2011) speculated that tagging in the third arm may extend the time until tissue expels tags compared to tagging in the mantle, as the muscle here is the thickest in the octopus body. ...
Article
Full-text available
Octopuses are amongst the most fascinating animals in our oceans; however, while their intricate behaviours are often studied in laboratory settings, basic aspects of their movement ecology remain unstudied in the wild. Focusing on the socio-economically important common octopus (Octopus vulgaris), this study employs, for the first time, acoustic tracking techniques to address knowledge gaps regarding the species spatial ecology within a marine protected area. A total of 24 wild O. vulgaris (13 males, 11 females) were tagged in 2022 in the National Park Maritime-Terrestrial of the Atlantic Islands of Galicia, Spain. Acoustic transmitters were externally attached to the third arm, after testing other body parts (mantle cavity). Males were on average detected on 10 times more occasions than females (49 days in males and five in females). The average activity space in the study area was large in comparison to that determined in similar studies, with 0.16 km². Activity space between males and females as well as day and night were comparable. Tagged octopuses displayed a crepuscular activity pattern. The location of dens could be established for 15 out of 24 individuals, from which octopuses were observed to undertake regular daytime excursions. Several individuals were also found to occupy more than one den and/or switch their main dens throughout the study duration. First implications and benefits of this approach are discussed.
... Numerous tests in tanks, conducted to identify the appropriate tag for O. vulgaris, have shown that only Petersen discs and T-bar anchor tags, inserted at the base of the third left arm, can ensure satisfactory results (Taki, 1941;Inoue et al., 1953;Katayama & Morita, 1960;Domain et al., 2000;Fuentes et al., 2006). ...
... In a preliminary phase from May to November 2008, 268 animals were tagged after having been anaesthetized according to Fuentes et al. (2006) by immersion for 5 min in cold seawater (4 -58C), with the addition of a few drops of ethyl alcohol. ...
... Petersen discs and T-bars were both applied at the base of the third left arm, in agreement with Domain et al. (2000) and Fuentes et al. (2006). After the tagging, dorsal mantle length (ML, to the nearest mm), total weight (TW, to the nearest 1 g) and sex were recorded. ...
Article
Full-text available
T-bar anchor tags and Petersen discs were used during a preliminary mark-recapture experiment in the wild on 268 Octopus vulgaris. Discs, despite causing some injuries, were characterized by a quicker healing (within 5 days) and a higher retention rate than T-bar tags (about 97% versus 22%, respectively), therefore they were considered the best technique for tagging the animals in the subsequent growth studies. From 2010 to 2013, a total of 1604 O. vulgaris (74.4% with a total weight <300 g) were tagged with discs and released in an area of the central western Sardinian Sea (western Mediterranean Sea). Ninety-one specimens were recaptured after 4-63 days of freedom, 59 of which (31 males and 28 females) showed positive growth increments after a minimum time of 8 days at liberty. In general, a high individual variability (0.96-9.09 g day1) and higher mean daily growth rates in females (3.07-3.65 g day1) than in males (2.08-2.98 g day1) were recorded, but this difference was not statistically significant. Using tag-recapture data, the first exponential growth curves for both sexes of Octopus vulgaris of small-medium size from the Mediterranean Sea were obtained, and compared with those available in the literature for the species.
... On previous researches carried out at the Spanish Institute of Oceanography (IEO) in Vigo, Fuentes et al. (2000, 2006 analyzed the most adequate type of tag for adults and newly-hatched paralarvae of O. vulgaris (Cuvier, 1797), respectively. After having analyzed a wide range of tag types, they concluded that T-bar anchor tag and Petersen discs were the most appropriate for subadults tagging. ...
... Tags were placed perpendicularly to the dorsal side and close to the base of the third left arm, avoiding harming suckers (Fuentes et al. 2006). Each octopus was later introduced in a rectangular mesh bag, which allows an appropriate handling during transportation, since it prevents from escaping, and also reduces attacking each other. ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper describes the release experiments carried out with 465 octopus (Octopus vulgaris Cuvier, 1797) with an average weight ranging from 703 to 986 g in three different areas in the Ría of Vigo, Galicia, NW Spain. Thirty-seven, individuals were recaptured by fishermen, representing a total recapture rate of 7.9 %. Among these, 80.5 % remained within 5 km of the release point, showing a sedentary behavior. The specific growth rate (SGR) in weight was 0.00902 ± 0.00468; there was not a significant difference between males and females. The exponential growth curve is the best fitting theoretical model. Life expectancy in Ría de Vigo waters was estimated at 18 months for males, and 1.6 months for females. Throughout the recapture process, males were predominant over females, giving a sex ratio of 1.83:1. Data reported in this paper on recapture rate, sedentary behavior and instantaneous growth rate can be used as reference for future stocking programs in Galicia.
... Several methods of marking ⁄ identification tags have been tested in different species [O. vulgaris (Fuentes et al. 2006; Estefanell et al. 2011), Octopus tetricus and O. maorum (Anderson & Babcock 1999), S. officinalis (Ezzeddine-Najai 1997)], but most of ...
... Reviews in Aquaculture (2012) 4, 142–162 ª 2012 Wiley Publishing Asia Pty Ltd them with limited success (Fuentes et al. 2006). A review on tagging in cephalopods was recently published by Semmens et al. (2007). ...
Article
This review intends to provide a reflection regarding Directive 2010 ⁄ 63 ⁄ EU, on animal welfare, and its application concerning cephalopod breeding and experimentation in aquaculture research. To do so, we gathered different perspectives of our group members, involving two cephalopod aquaculture researchers, an aquaculture fish production technician and a veterinary professional, the latter with no background on cephalopod research. The inclusion of this class in the animal welfare legislation; the definition of live cephalopods, stress, pain and suffering are revised according to the latest scientific knowledge. Considering the 15 year background that the Centre of Marine Sciences holds on the cultivation of the European cuttlefish, an evaluation of existing production protocols, aquaculture technology related research, ethics and cephalopod welfare are discussed. The application of anaesthesia, analgesia and euthanasia is discussed, bearing in mind the different procedures applied on a daily basis in aquaculture breeding and experimentation and the requirements of the new Directive. Finally, an overview of the above and progress on 3Rs (replacement of animals, reduction in number of animals and refinement of procedures) application to cephalopod welfare is presented.
... The effort to increase the canon of field data will be aided by the pace of technological development and decreasing costs of data acquisition tools. Various types of tagging have been utilized successfully in recent years to answer questions about geographic range, migration and diving habits (Fuentes et al., 2006;Gilly et al., 2006;Replinger and Wood, 2007;Bazzino et al., 2010;Barry et al., 2011;Sims et al., 2011;Wearmouth et al., 2013;Sykes et al., 2017b). Remote monitoring through videography and photography is another increasingly accessible option thanks to the profusion of low-cost cameras that have come on the market in recent years. ...
Article
Full-text available
Here, three researchers who have recently embarked on careers in cephalopod biology discuss the current state of the field and offer their hopes for the future. Seven major topics are explored: genetics, aquaculture, climate change, welfare, behavior, cognition, and neurobiology. Recent developments in each of these fields are reviewed and the potential of emerging technologies to address specific gaps in knowledge about cephalopods are discussed. Throughout, the authors highlight specific challenges that merit particular focus in the near-term. This review and prospectus is also intended to suggest some concrete near-term goals to cephalopod researchers and inspire those working outside the field to consider the revelatory potential of these remarkable creatures.
... It is known that O. vulgaris can remove their own tags, or those of other, with their arms confounding recapture rates and affecting the success of capture-recapture studies (e.g. Domain et al., 2000;Fuentes et al., 2006;Mereu et al., 2010). High retention rates of subcutaneous passive integrated transponders (PIT tags) implanted in the upper arm without causing any harm on the animal has been previously reported on O. vulgaris (Estefanell et al., 2011). ...
Article
A spatially explicit capture-recapture (SCR) model was applied to estimate simultaneously population parameters and individual activity (i.e. home range size) of O. vulgaris, based on experimental mark-recapture data in a human-altered Mediterranean coastal area. Seventy-two octopuses were captured, tagged with subcutaneous PIT-tags and released. Nineteen tagged individuals were recaptured (recapture rate: 26.4%) in the same area over the study period, which spanned over 6 months. Population sizes and densities decreased over the study period, from 337 octopuses (8 ind. ha−1) in September-October to 105 octopuses (2.5 ind. ha−1) in February-March. The highest recruitment probability was estimated to occur at the beginning of the study but it clearly decreased over time, while mortality probability during a fishing period slightly increased. Mean specific growth rate was 0.82 ± 0.11 day−1. Individual home range or activity area ranged from 2.8 ha to 7.3 ha (median home range radius: 121.8 m). Overall, these results suggest that human-altered coastal habitats, which are characterized by abundant shelters, abundant food and absence of predators, can act as settlement and growth areas for juveniles and adults of O. vulgaris. Furthermore, the methodologies applied in this study are recommended as innovative tools to improve management actions of coastal resources.
... Methods used with success, but which require anaesthesia for their application -and hence scientific justification and approval from the National Competent Authority -have included implanted fluorescent elastomer tags in squid and octopus, 124,125 subcutaneous dye injection into the arm of octopus, 123,126 and external tagging of cuttlefish, octopus and other species. [127][128][129][130][131][132] Careful consideration of harms, benefits and justification is therefore needed for invasive tagging, and development of minimally invasive individual marking methods for cephalopods is an important goal. 31,133 ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper is the result of an international initiative and is a first attempt to develop guidelines for the care and welfare of cephalopods (i.e. nautilus, cuttlefish, squid and octopus) following the inclusion of this Class of ∼700 known living invertebrate species in Directive 2010/63/EU. It aims to provide information for investigators, animal care committees, facility managers and animal care staff which will assist in improving both the care given to cephalopods, and the manner in which experimental procedures are carried out. Topics covered include: implications of the Directive for cephalopod research; project application requirements and the authorisation process; the application of the 3Rs principles; the need for harm-benefit assessment and severity classification. Guidelines and species-specific requirements are provided on: i. supply, capture and transport; ii. environmental characteristics and design of facilities (e.g. water quality control, lighting requirements, vibration/noise sensitivity); iii. accommodation and care (including tank design), animal handling, feeding and environmental enrichment; iv. assessment of health and welfare (e.g. monitoring biomarkers, physical and behavioural signs); v. approaches to severity assessment; vi. disease (causes, prevention and treatment); vii. scientific procedures, general anaesthesia and analgesia, methods of humane killing and confirmation of death. Sections covering risk assessment for operators and education and training requirements for carers, researchers and veterinarians are also included. Detailed aspects of care and welfare requirements for the main laboratory species currently used are summarised in Appendices. Knowledge gaps are highlighted to prompt research to enhance the evidence base for future revision of these guidelines.
... On board the vessels, dorsal mantle length (ML, to the nearest mm), total weight (TW, to the nearest 5 g) and sex were recorded for each specimen caught; according to Fuentes et al. (2006) they were anaesthetised before being tagged with Petersen discs. The tag was placed on the 3rd left arm, after the animal was maintained for about 1 h in a tank (with running seawater and an oxygenator). ...
Article
The movements of Octopus vulgaris were investigated by a mark–recapture study (1604 specimens tagged), carried out during a commercial octopus traps fishery, at a depth of 20–50 m, over a rocky substrate area of the Sardinian Sea (central western Mediterranean Sea). Overall 87 specimens (56 males and 31 females) were recaptured after 4 and 63 days from the tagging. The difference between the depth at release and recapture varied up to 5.0 m but in 100% of males and in 80% of females the variation was less than 3.0 m. Theoretical straight distances travelled by recaptures ranged from 9 to 5800 m in males and from 9 to 1700 m in females, regardless of the days of freedom.
Article
Full-text available
In this work, the effects of visible implant elastomer (VIE) tags on survival and body growth rate on juvenile red octopus Octopus maya from the Yucatan Peninsula were tested under controlled conditions. Juveniles with an average weight of 1.14 g were not affected by VIE within 30 days, so this methodology is suggested as a useful tool to study the life cycle aspects of this important fishery species.
Article
Most of the research on marking of aquatic organisms has been done using large organisms since they tend to have better retention rates, their swimming behaviour is less affected by the size of the tag, they have less trauma due to injectable tags or from the injector itself and they are easier to handle and able to withstand the stress of tagging and recapture. The development of small tags has grown from a necessity to study smaller fish species, earlier life stages of fish and to study other small aquatic organisms. As an endangered species, delta smelt (Hypomesus transpacificus) are being intensively studied in the upper San Francisco Estuary (CA, USA). A crucial part of many of these studies is tracking delta smelt, which requires a distinctive mark on each individual or group of fish. Unfortunately, many of the experimental fish suffer inadvertent mortality, as delta smelt are very sensitive to environmental and handling stress. The purpose of this review was to synthesize the different tagging and marking studies on small fish and aquatic organisms and to evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of each method for applications on sensitive species such as delta smelt. This review suggests the most effective methods for tracking delta smelt are visible implant alphanumeric (VIA) tagging and adipose fin clips for subadult to adult fish and calcein marks for young life stages. Among these methods, only VIA tagging currently provides individual organism identification.
Article
Full-text available
The growth of Octopus vulgaris (Mollusca: Cephalopoda) in tanks and the sea was modelled and calculated following tagging studies in Senegal. Octopus exhibits a large individual variability in growth and the exponential growth curve is the best fitting theoretical model among other usual models tested. Globally, the growth rates were comparable in the sea and in tanks. Growth rates for the hot season were lower than those for the cold season. Applied to in situ data, the statistical tests showed that females grow more quickly than males. Life expectancy was estimated at between 12 and 14 months. These results question the previous growth curves for the region, all of which were obtained from modal analysis using size or weight–frequencies and were used during stock assessments of this important resource off the north-west African coast.
Article
It is possible to mark octopus (Octopus vulgaris) paralarvae on a massive scale (up to 3500 paralarvae l(-1)) with 100% marking reliability using alizarin complexone (ALC). The whole statolith is marked and the best results obtained were with concentrations of 60-300 mg l(-1) and bath duration of 3 24 h. Taking into account the quality of marking, mortality and ALC costs suggest using from 60 to 200 mg l(-1) for 3-6 h. The only treatments causing significant mortalities were 300 mg l(-1) over 6 and 24 h.
Article
The shortnose sturgeon (Acipenser brevirostrum), an endangered species, was the subject of a stock enhancement trial. Some standard methods of marking individuals for later identification as cultured fish appeared to be ineffective. Therefore, six marking techniques were tested on several groups of cultured juvenile shortnose sturgeons (mean total lengths, 115–500 mm) during 1989–1990. The methods evaluated were: (1) coded wire tags implanted in the snout cartilage, (2) dorsally implanted T-bar tags, (3) dorsally implanted dart tags, (4) abdominally implanted T-anchor tags, (5) abdominally implanted disk anchor tags, and (6) barbel clipping. After 2 years, 100% of the clipped barbels were partially or completely regenerated. Retention of coded wire tags was highly variable (70–100%) in trials of 62–410 d. Retention was greater for the T-anchor tag (92%) than for any of the other tag types. However, in most cases, tag incisions and wounds persisted for the duration of the experiment.
Article
This study tested different tags for each size of farm-reared gilthead sea bream, Sparus aurata L. juveniles, used in enhancement programmes. The following tags were tested: dye mark, fingerling tag, opercular tag, anchor tag A (filament diameter of 1.20 mm) and anchor tag B (0.85 mm). Tag/mark retention, wounds produced by the tag, ease of application, ease of detection and cost were examined. Epidermal dye marks had poor retention and detection rates. Of the tags tested, retention was greater for the anchor tag A (80–100%) after 7 months; anchor tag B showed a retention rate of only 20% after 3 months. The fingerling tag had a retention rate of 27.5% after 12 months. The opercular tag had a retention rate of 44% after 20 days but fractured the opercular bone in many cases. Tag incisions and wounds persisted in some fish for the duration of the experiment.
1-4) 2006: 3-11 10 rHyogo Prefectural Fisheries Experimental Station On keeping octopods in an aquarium for physiological experiments, with remarks on some opera-tive techniques The study on octopus (Octopus vulgaris Cuvier) resource in Tokyo Bay-III. Experiment of marking methods for octopus
  • L Fuentes
L. Fuentes et al.External tagging of Octopus vulgaris Bol. Inst. Esp. Oceanogr. 22 (1-4). 2006: 3-11 10 rHyogo Prefectural Fisheries Experimental Station. 1980: 359- 369. (In Japanese.) Taki, I. 1941. On keeping octopods in an aquarium for physiological experiments, with remarks on some opera-tive techniques. Venus 10: 140-156. Tsuchiya, H., F. Ikeda and T. Shimizu. 1986. The study on octopus (Octopus vulgaris Cuvier) resource in Tokyo Bay-III. Experiment of marking methods for octopus. Bulletin. Kanagawa Prefectural Fisheries Experimental Station 7: 45-53. (In Japanese.) L. Fuentes et al.External tagging of Octopus vulgaris Bol. Inst. Esp. Oceanogr. 22 (1-4). 2006: 3-11 11
The Azorean adult squid Loligo forbesi in captivity: transport, handling, maintenance, tagging and survival. International Council for the Exploitation of the Sea
  • J M Gonçalves
  • F M Porteiro
  • F Cardigos
  • H R Martins
Gonçalves, J. M., F. M. Porteiro, F. Cardigos and H. R. Martins. 1995. The Azorean adult squid Loligo forbesi in captivity: transport, handling, maintenance, tagging and survival. International Council for the Exploitation of the Sea. Mariculture Committee C.M. 1995/F:14 Ref. K: 1-15
Survey of large-scale propagation area in 1980 (Meitan area: common octopus) Annual Report
  • Kawakami
Kawakami. 1981. Survey of large-scale propagation area in 1980 (Meitan area: common octopus). Annual Report.
Methods of marking fish and shellfish
  • L A Nielsen
Nielsen, L. A. 1992. Methods of marking fish and shellfish. American Fisheries Society. Special Publication 23: 208 pp.