Article

Errores de interpretación de los métodos estadísticos: importancia y recomendaciones

Psicothema, ISSN 0214-9915, Vol. 18, Nº. 4, 2006, pags. 848-856 01/2006;
Source: OAI

ABSTRACT

Trabajos empíricos previos han identificado las opiniones de los investigadores respecto de las pruebas de significación y de otros recursos estadísticos, algunas de estas opiniones resultan totalmente inaceptables. En esta investigación comprobamos el grado en que estos errores aparecen en una muestra española de profesores e investigadores de universidad mediante la aplicación de un cuestionario. Los datos obtenidos son importantes para: a) la prevención de interpretaciones inadecuadas; b) la corrección de usos incorrectos; c) el análisis de alternativas posibles; y d) proponer cambios editoriales en los criterios de publicación.

Download full-text

Full-text

Available from: Dolores frías-navarro
  • Source
    • "This is confirmed by Task Force on Statistical Inference (TSFI) regarding the sampling, design, measurement, instruments, procedures, data analysis, results and reports preparation (Wilkinson and TSFI, 1999). Nonetheless, such recommendations are controversial (Fidler, 2002) and the effectiveness of guidelines has been poor up to now (Borges and Sanchez- Bruno, 2004; Monterde, Pascual and Frias, 2006). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The aim of this study is to compare partially disaggregated structural models, using item parcels as indicators of latent variables, and path analysis models, assuming totally aggregated items make up measurements without errors of the constructs. Data come from two empirical studies: one focused on education and another one focused on health, in such a way we can prove the constructs evaluated do not interfere with methodological results showed. The results in both studies are consistent. On one hand, the use of items parcels as indicators of the constructs rather than path models increase the value of the parameters in absolute value, and residual variance is reduced. This is reflected in an increase of the explained variance by the models. Parcel construction method does not seem to be a relevant factor. On the other hand, goodness-of-fit indexes of path models show a better fit. Summarizing, latent variable models would be better fitted to reality, improving the percentage of explained variance, but losing fit due to the higher number of parameters to be estimated.
    Full-text · Article · Jan 2009
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The penalty point system is an internationally spread strategy aimed to reduce the number of road traffic accidents and its dramatic consequences. This paper summarizes some of the main research projects on the effectiveness of the penalty point system and indicates some issues for further research. The evidence analyzed here suggests that the introduction of the system is an effective way to reduce the number of traffic offences and to improve both road safety and health-related indicators. However, some rigorous studies would still be necessary to clearly separate the effects of the penalty point system from other road safety-relevant factors (such as previous tendencies in accident statistics) and to clarify the issue of the middle-term and long-term duration of its effects. El permiso por puntos, considerado como una estrategia válida para lograr una reducción significativa de los accidentes de tráfico, ha experimentado una notable expansión internacional en los últimos años. En el presente artículo se realiza una síntesis de las principales iniciativas de investigación que han evaluado la eficacia del sistema y se sugieren algunas recomendaciones para futuros estudios. A partir de la evidencia científica analizada, se puede concluir que el permiso por puntos es una medida eficaz para modificar el comportamiento del conductor y para mejorar la seguridad vial. Sin embargo, todavía resultaría necesario desarrollar estudios que permitan separar de una forma rigurosa la incidencia de otros factores relevantes (como, por ejemplo, las tendencias previas en la siniestralidad) y que ayuden a aclarar la cuestión de la duración a medio/largo plazo de los efectos del permiso por puntos.
    Full-text · Article · Sep 2008 · Securitas Vialis
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The present article deals with the controversy about null hypothesis significance testing (NHST) that currently exists in psychological research. The main criticisms and counter-criticisms posed by its detractors and supporters are presented. Alternatives have been proposed to replace or complement the NHST, as recommended by the Task Force on Statistical Inference of the APA, and these are explained. Furthermore, the procedure for calculating these alternatives using SPSS statistical software in a two-way between-factor design is demonstrated. Thus, an attempt is made to provide the applied researcher with resources that make it possible to analyse and interpret the results of any research study using a group of indicators that lends a high level of validity to the statistical inference performed.
    Full-text · Article · Mar 2009 · Psicothema
Show more