Article

Environmental Modesty

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

Despite this virtue's history as an instrument of women's oppression, modesty, at its most basic, means voluntary restraint of one's power, undertaken for the sake of others. It is a mechanism that modifies unequal power relationships and encourages greater compassion and fairness. I use a Christian perspective with influences from Jewish and Muslim sources to examine modesty. The modest person, I argue, must be in relationship with others, must be honestly aware of her impacts on others, must be sensitive to those impacts, compassionate toward others, and willing to hold back for others' sakes. Moreover, modesty is not only a virtue that pertains to sexuality and clothing, but it also can promote virtuous environmental behavior, particularly as it leads to awareness of, and sensitivity to, the effects of everyday behaviors on vulnerable others.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.

... Kagan, 2018) and, on the other, of intense preoccupation with the social self as coming forth during development (Asendorpf, 1990;Cheek & Briggs, 1990;Cheek & Buss, 1981;Cheek & Melchior, 1990;Gruenewald et al., 2007;McDougall, 1963;Schmidt & Poole, 2019). Furthermore, we posit that these emotional reactions-as nested within the concept of social inhibition-differ in terms of their intensity and durability (whether the emotional response goes beyond the situation that triggers the inhibited reaction) in relation to individuals' self-regulatory capacity (Asendorpf, 2010;Han, 2011;Hartman, 2015;Rothbart, 1989;Xu et al., 2007Xu et al., , 2009. In this way socially inhibited individuals may either experience rather temporary exposure embarrassment and abashment (Goetz & Keltner, 2007;Lewis, 2016;Miller, 1995) or shame and evaluative embarrassment which are much more prolonged over time and which possess the potential for a drop in one's social self-esteem (Crozier, 1999(Crozier, , 2010Henderson & Zimbardo, 1998;Litwinsky, 1950;Lewis, 2016;Miller, 1995;Mosher & White, 1981). ...
... Therefore, during highly-evaluative social interactions, socially inhibited individuals might either stop the actual behaviour when in the company of others or simply withdraw from such social situations (and, as a result, avoid such situations in the future; Denollet & Duijndam, 2019;Kagan et al., 1984;Kagan et al., 1987;cf. Kagan, 2018) or rather act in an unassuming, socially desirable (or even prosocial) manner according to socio-cultural norms Kwiatkowska to avoid being at the centre of others' attention (Asendorpf, 2010;Gough & Thorne, 1986;Han, 2011;Hartman, 2015;Xu et al., 2007Xu et al., , 2009Wiggins, 1995). ...
... Zheng et al., 2017)-as this is the basis for maintaining harmonious relationships and thinking about oneself as a member of the group (Xu et al., 2007(Xu et al., , 2009. Through their attitude focused on good relations with others, modest individuals ensure self-protection because they regulate their behaviour, emotions, and thoughts so as not to pose any threat to others (Han, 2011;Hartman, 2015;Wood, 1989;cf. Sedikides et al., 2007), and unwittingly contribute to strengthening the self-esteem of others by providing them with a beneficial comparison (Vonk, 2002;cf. ...
Article
Full-text available
The purpose of this paper is to present a new model of social inhibition conceptualised as a dual structured construct including shyness and modesty. The complexity and diversity of these two social inhibition forms are shown across various domains of psychosocial functioning (i.e., self-image, cognitive, emotional, and behavioural). Locating shyness and modesty within the space of the Circumplex of Personality Metatraits enabled us to identify conceptually adjacent constructs to social inhibition (i.e., humiliation and humility) and put the latter into a broad personality context. Through supplementary meta-analyses of the relationships of shyness and modesty with the Big Five personality traits, we confront our theoretical proposition with existing empirical findings. Our paper indicates that social inhibition can be treated as a psychoso-cial disposition with two related and sharing core elements, but distinct and differentially targeted forms-more neurotic and dysfunctional shyness and more agreeable and adaptive modesty.
... En raison de cette hétérogénéité, les champs d'application de la permaculture, loin de se restreindre à l'agriculture ou au jardinage alternatif, peuvent concerner des domaines très variables. On trouve dans la littérature internationale une plus grande diversité de ces exemples d'application dans des domaines comme la santé (Centemeri, 2017 ;Corazon et al., 2012), le féminisme (Harland, 2017), l'engagement associatif à Détroit (Hoffman et al., 2016;Ferguson et Lovell, 2015), l'apprentissage dans les entreprises de ventes (Ingram et al., 2014) ou l'apprentissage de la science et du développement durable (Lebo et Eames, 2015), le droit à l'alimentation au Salvador (Millner, 2016), la conception architecturale (Parvin, 2013), la stratégie d'entreprise (Akhtar et al., 2015), la « sociocratie » (méthode de gouvernance de groupes) (Rios, 2011), le changement climatique (Henfrey, 2017), les éco-villages (Birnbaum et Fox, 2014), la gestion des ressources naturelles (Akhtar et al., 2016), l'art et l'activisme (Kwakkenbos, 2011), l'agriculture en climat tempéré (Wolz et al., 2018), la relation natureculture (Bellacasa, 2010, Lacroix, 2012, la religion (Hartman, 2015), l'urbanisme (Pezrès, op. cit). ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Mémoire pour l'obtention du Master de Environmental Policy, Paris School of International Affairs. Sous la direction de Sophie Dubuisson-Quellier
... Low-dominance feeling was characterised by the combination of 10 characteristics as "shyness, timidity, embarrassability, [lack of] self-confidence, self- 11 conscientiousness, inhibition, conventionality, modesty, fearfulness, poise, inferiority 12 feelings, [lack of] social ease" (Maslow, 1939, p. 3). 13 Further research echoed Maslow's clinical findings: we can find traces of shyness in 14 descriptions of modesty (Gregg et al., 2008;Hartman, 2015) and vice versa (Asendorpf, 2010; 15 Liu, Bowker, Coplan, & Chen, 2018; Xu, Farver, Yu, & Zhang, 2009); however, none of the 16 previous studies explicitly examined the relationship between modesty and shyness nor 17 investigated their common qualities. Furthermore there are some perspectives that are not 18 entirely consistent with the notion of linking these two constructs. ...
Article
Full-text available
Shyness and modesty are similar constructs, but to date no study has investigated their relationship empirically, hence the goal of this study was to examine this relationship and how shyness and modesty are related to the Big Five model of personality. We administered a set of self-report measures of shyness, modesty and Big Five personality traits to 727 adults in Poland. The results conformed our expectations, revealing that shyness and modesty are positively correlated traits. Moreover, in regard to Big Five personality traits, both of them were negatively related to extraversion and positively to neuroticism, but only modesty was positively related to agreeableness. Our findings are discussed in light of previous research and theory.
... Low-dominance feeling was characterised by the combination of 10 characteristics as "shyness, timidity, embarrassability, [lack of] self-confidence, self- 11 conscientiousness, inhibition, conventionality, modesty, fearfulness, poise, inferiority 12 feelings, [lack of] social ease" (Maslow, 1939, p. 3). 13 Further research echoed Maslow's clinical findings: we can find traces of shyness in 14 descriptions of modesty (Gregg et al., 2008;Hartman, 2015) and vice versa (Asendorpf, 2010; 15 Liu, Bowker, Coplan, & Chen, 2018; Xu, Farver, Yu, & Zhang, 2009); however, none of the 16 previous studies explicitly examined the relationship between modesty and shyness nor 17 investigated their common qualities. Furthermore there are some perspectives that are not 18 entirely consistent with the notion of linking these two constructs. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Shyness and modesty are similar constructs, but to date no study has investigated their relationship empirically, hence the goal of this study was to examine this relationship and how shyness and modesty are related to the Big Five model of personality. We administered a set of self-report measures of shyness, modesty and Big Five personality traits to 727 adults in Poland. The results conformed our expectations, revealing that shyness and modesty are positively correlated traits. Moreover, in regard to Big Five personality traits, both of them were negatively related to extraversion and positively to neuroticism, but only modesty was positively related to agreeableness. Our findings are discussed in light of previous research and theory.
Chapter
As a result of the projected growth of the global fashion industry, and the fact that the majority of the world’s population is affiliated with a religious faith, the present study aimed to assess the state of the art on the intersections of fashion, religion and consumer behaviour. This study is done in order to help guide the strategies of marketers and theorists on this subject, which despite its significance is still relatively new in scientific literature, therefore including limited research. This literature review touches on the difference between religion and religiosity, and how it can be a moderating factor in consumer behaviour, focusing on the influence of Christian religiosity in apparel shopping behaviour and the purchase intentions of fashion products by Muslim consumers. This study also investigates the impact of religiosity on pro-environmental and sustainable fashion attitudes and how different faiths see this relationship. Similarly, it was also concluded that while most faiths give great emphasis to modesty and, therefore, its incompatibility with status consumption, religiosity has very little influence on the consumption of luxury fashion, as consumers did not see a connection between consuming luxury goods and their faith.
Article
Climate engineering is subject to the “playing God” critique, which charges that humans should not undertake to control nature in ways that seem to overstep the proper scope of human agency. This argument is easily discredited, and in fact the opposite—that we should “play God”—may be equally valid in some circumstances. To revive the playing God critique, I argue that it functions not on a logical but on a symbolic and emotional level to highlight nostalgia for functional dualisms in the face of the bewildering problem of climate change. It also raises significant questions about the virtue of those who might engineer the climate. These two concerns point to questions about the proper role of human agency. I use the scholarship of Aldo Leopold and H. Richard Niebuhr to argue for a model of human agency based on contextual awareness and responsive, communal responsibility. I conclude with some implications of this view for decision-makers engaging the topic of climate engineering.
Book
Full-text available
Earth is imperiled. Human activities are adversely affecting the land, water, air, and myriad forms of biological life that comprise the ecosystems of our planet. Indicators of global warming and holes in the ozone layer inhibit functions vital to the biosphere. Environmental damage to the planet becomes damaging to human health and well-being now and into the future-and too often that damage affects those who are least able to protect themselves. Can religion make a positive contribution to preventing further destruction of biological diversity and ecosystems and threats to our earth? Jame Schaefer thinks that it can, and she examines the thought of Christian Church fathers and medieval theologians to reveal and retrieve insights that may speak to our current plight. By reconstructing the teachings of Augustine, Thomas Aquinas, and other classic thinkers to reflect our current scientific understanding of the world, Schaefer shows how to green the Catholic faith: to value the goodness of creation, to appreciate the beauty of creation, to respect creation's praise for God, to acknowledge the kinship of all creatures, to use creation with gratitude and restraint, and to live virtuously within the earth community.
Article
Lisa Tessman's Burdened Virtues: Virtue Ethics for Liberatory Struggles- engages questions central to feminist theory and practice, from the perspective of Aristotelian ethics. Focused primarily on selves who endure and resist oppression, the book addresses the ways in which the devastating conditions confronted by these selves both limit and burden their moral goodness, and affect their possibilities for flourishing. The book describes two different forms of "moral trouble" prevalent under oppression. The first is that the oppressed self may be morally damaged, prevented from developing or exercising some of the virtues; the second is that the very conditions of oppression require the oppressed to develop a set of virtues that carry a moral cost to those who practice them, and that are referred to as "burdened virtues." These virtues have the unusual feature of being disjoined from their bearer's own well being. It is suggested that eudaimonistic theories should be able to account for virtues of this sort.
Book
Politics of Piety is a groundbreaking analysis of Islamist cultural politics through the ethnography of a thriving, grassroots women's piety movement in the mosques of Cairo, Egypt. Unlike those organized Islamist activities that seek to seize or transform the state, this is a moral reform movement whose orthodox practices are commonly viewed as inconsequential to Egypt's political landscape. Saba Mahmood's compelling exposition of these practices challenges this assumption by showing how the ethical and the political are indelibly linked within the context of such movements. Not only is this book a sensitive ethnography of a critical but largely ignored dimension of the Islamic revival, it is also an unflinching critique of the secular-liberal assumptions by which some people hold such movements to account. The book addresses three central questions: How do movements of moral reform help us rethink the normative liberal account of politics? How does the adherence of women to the patriarchal norms at the core of such movements parochialize key assumptions within feminist theory about freedom, agency, authority, and the human subject? How does a consideration of debates about embodied religious rituals among Islamists and their secular critics help us understand the conceptual relationship between bodily form and political imaginaries? Politics of Piety is essential reading for anyone interested in issues at the nexus of ethics and politics, embodiment and gender, and liberalism and postcolonialism. In a substantial new preface, Mahmood addresses the controversy sparked by the original publication of her book and the scholarly discussions that have ensued.
Article
In recent years, concern for “modesty” has become more prominent in American religious circles. Recent advocates of modest clothing for women voice important concerns, but also perpetuate problematic attitudes toward women, especially poor women and women of color. Thomas Aquinas' description of modesty corrects this error, because it includes modesty of the mind. Contemporary developments in moral theology then enable us to relate both mental and physical modesty to the cardinal virtue of justice, where modesty decenters the self and makes room for other people to flourish. Findings from social psychologists illuminate the dynamics of social power, and clarify specific ways that mental and physical modesty work under the rubric of justice. These findings suggest that men and women may face different challenges in the practice of modesty, and so Christians must attend to all types of modesty in order to adequately address the question of appropriate clothing.
Article
Reviewing The Ethics of Gender, Feminism and Christian Ethics, and The Cambridge Companion to Feminist Theology, the author suggests that Susan Parsons responds to questions postmodernism has posed to both feminism and Christian ethics by using insights gained from various accounts of the moral subject found in feminist philosophy, ethics, and theology. Hesitant to embrace postmodernism's critique of the possibility of ethics, Parsons redefines ethics by establishing a moral point of view within discursive communities. Yet in her brief treatment of Emmanuel Levinas, Parsons does not explore the postmodern option he offers feminists: an understanding of moral responsibility that can be critical of ethics. Parsons also ignores some feminist perspectives in the physical and natural sciences, thereby missing valuable insights of feminists who insist upon the materiality of the body.
Article
ABSTRACTA Great Plains land ethic is shaped by an intimate knowledge of and appreciation for the evolution, ecology, and aesthetics of the plains landscape. The landscape evokes a sense of wonder and mystery suggested by the word “sacrament.” The biblical concept of “covenant” points to God as a community-forming power, a creative process that has evolved into the earth community to which we humans belong. In contrast to an anthropocentric ethic which emphasizes human dominion over nature, a Theo-centric land ethic seeks a balance, reflected in Genesis 1–3, between humans who are members of the earth community and moral agents accountable to God for the earth. A land ethic identifies concrete practices of metanoia and healing: agricultural practices to address the loss and degradation of soil; conservation and protection of water sources; utilization of wind and solar energy; and prescribed burning to restore processes vital to the prairie ecosystem. The concept of subsidiarity suggests that practices of metanoia and healing are a combination of wise public policy balanced by personal, family, church, business, and community responsibility.
Book
Be it fair trade coffee or foreign oil, our choices as consumers affect the well-being of humans around the globe, not to mention the natural world and of course ourselves. Consumption is a serious ethical issue, and Christian writers throughout history have weighed in, discussing topics such as affluence and poverty, greed and gluttony, and proper stewardship of resources. These voices are often at odds, however. In this book, Laura M. Hartman formulates a coherent Christian ethic of consumption, imposing order on the debate by dividing it into four imperatives: Christians are to consume in ways that avoid sin, embrace creation, love one's neighbor, and envision the future. An adequate ethics of consumption, she argues, must include all four considerations as tools for discernment, even when they seem to contradict one another. The book includes discussions of Christian practices such as fasting, gratitude, solidarity, gift-giving, Sabbath-keeping, and the Eucharist. Using exemplars from the Christian tradition and practical examples from everyday life, The Christian Consumer offers a thoughtful guide to ethical consumption.
Stoic Naturalism, Rationalism, and Deep Ecology
  • Stevens
Beneath the Veil: Muslim Girls and Islamic Headscarves in Secular France
  • Jones Nicky