Several mammalian lineages, most notably cetaceans, sirenians, and pinnipeds, have independently reverted to the marine environment of their long-ago, pre-mammalian ancestors. Other mammals have also adapted to coastal, estuarine, or freshwater habitats. These include various members of the Carnivora and Rodentia, along with some other living and extinct mammals. Because water is dense, heavy, viscous, and incompressible, feeding in water poses challenges, especially for animals whose ancestors evolved in terrestrial settings. Many secondarily aquatic mammals separately adopted similar functional and structural solutions to acquire, ingest, and process food, particularly suction feeding, filter feeding, raptorial (“seizing”) grasping of prey, or adaptations to remove prey from benthic sediments. This led to striking examples of convergence with other mammals or with other aquatic animals, including sharks, bony fishes, marine reptiles, and birds. Most instances of convergence involve close similarities in jaws, dentition, and musculature, overall shape of the head and mouth, methods for separating food from water, and neural and behavioral adaptations to locate and capture prey. Following discussion of basic principles underlying aquatic mammalian feeding, we outline numerous examples of convergence in extant and extinct taxa.