ChapterPDF Available

A Randomized Control Trial of Teen STAR

  • Universidad Bernardo O Higgins
  • Executive DirectorNatural Family Planning Center of Washington, D.C. Inc.
      
      
e Teen STAR (Sexuality Teaching in the context of Adult Re-
sponsibility) program avoids the two extremes of sexuality edu-
cation—abstinence-only or “comprehensive”—as it balances the
facts of fertility with the emotional, cognitive, social, and spiritual
aspects of human sexuality.
A primary and secondary program was initiated to prevent sexual
activity among Chilean teens aged 12–18 years old. Among the
females who participated in the program, only 3.4% transitioned
from virginity to intercourse, compared with 12.4% of control
females who did not participate in the program. Among the males
who participated in the program, only 8.8% transitioned from
virginity to intercourse, compared with 17.6% of control males
who did not participate in the program. Twenty-one percent of
sexually active program subjects discontinued intercourse, com-
pared with 9% controls. Of those program subjects who discon-
tinued intercourse, none resumed activity at the end of one year,
whereas 11.7% of control subjects did resume sexual activity.
Pregnancy rates were studied among female students who partici-
pated in Teen STAR versus female students who did not partici-
pate in the program (i.e., the control group). Average pregnancy
rates per year were 0.87% in the program group and 4.87% in the
control group during the follow-up period.
During the last twenty-five years, there have been extensive
efforts to reduce the consequences of risky adolescent sex-
ual behaviors by programs classified either as abstinence-
only or as comprehensive sexuality (also known as abstinence-based
education, safer-sex, secular, or abstinence-plus programs) education
programs (omas 2000, Silva 2002). e first kind of program—
170 Human Fertility: Where Faith & Science Meet
abstinence-only sex education programs, which the United States
government defined under Section 510 of the 1996 Social Security
Act—can be perceived as inherently coercive in the sense that they
do not promote free choice on the part of the teen participant. ey
can also be seen as authoritarian in approach. e second kind of
program—comprehensive sexuality education—also promotes ab-
stinence as the first and best choice for preventing pregnancy and
sexually transmitted diseases (STDs), including Human Immunode-
ficiency Virus (HIV), but it also provides education and sometimes
services regarding all contraceptive methods. ese comprehensive
sexuality education programs are designed to assist students in be-
coming well-informed decision makers (Pittman 2006), but these
programs sometimes view the consequences of sexual behaviors
mechanistically, or isolated from social and individual values.
Although controlled randomized evaluation has been scant for
both approaches (Silva 2002), the available evidence suggests that
adolescent sexual behavior is a complex phenomenon and that ad-
dressing it requires an integrated, sophisticated approach that is not
unduly bound by ideological simplicity (Kirby 2001).
e Teen STAR (Sexuality Teaching in the context of Adult Re-
sponsibility; see: and
program began twenty-seven years ago in an attempt to offer a pro-
gram of education in human sexuality that encompasses the whole
person. In so doing, the program has avoided the two extremes of
abstinence-only and comprehensive sexuality education programs.
Teen STAR is an interactive, holistic education program in hu-
man sexuality leading to the acceptance of one’s own sexuality and
fertility. It involves feelings as well as intellect, requires that fertility
patterns be learned through observation, and demands both parental
participation and teacher-student confidentiality. Learning through
observation challenges teens to integrate their biological capacity to
be fathers or mothers into all aspects of their lives, i.e., social, emo-
tional, intellectual, spiritual, and physical aspects of their sexuality
(Vigil 2004a; de Malherbe 2005). Adolescence can produce a tem-
porary “deafness” to the teachings that adults would like to transmit
to young people (Hall et al. 2004). Teens need to make decisions
about their own behavior, make their own discoveries, and reach
Vigil, Cortés, Klaus  Randomized Control Trial of Teen STAR 171
their own conclusions. Adolescents are immersed in the task of es-
tablishing their own ego identity. is requires at least a theoretical
distancing from the “parental ego”. Knowledge of their fertility helps
them understand their sexuality (Vigil et al. 2006a, 2006b), as well as
their capacity to procreate. Experiencing their body’s messages about
fertility and its potential for procreation is a source of intellectual
learning for teens. Additionally, it allows teens to choose to express
this potential with total freedom and to save it for a committed re-
lationship: marriage (Vigil et al. 2002a). At the same time, parental
involvement is still an important component of the Teen STAR pro-
gram. Other studies have also shown that parental participation in
interventions appears to be associated with a higher tendency toward
abstinence (Silva 2002).
To reach these goals, Teen STAR develops the following areas:
1. Improving self-identity and self-esteem. Adolescents need to
know who they are, so they are encouraged to become aware of
themselves as free, if limited, persons.
2. Valuing their freedom and decision-making ability. Teens are
informed about free and responsible choices. Self-control is a
prized fruit that feeds on self-knowledge.
3. Building a feeling of respect for the gift of life. Human life is a
gift, received to be given. Only those teens who value their own
life will be able to present it as a gift to others. If youngsters de-
spise themselves, they will despise life and will not consider their
possible surrender as a precious gift.
   
e objective of the present review is to analyze the results obtained
with the Teen STAR program in two randomized, controlled tri-
als: (1) a study conducted to evaluate the effect of Teen STAR on
sexual behaviour among Chilean female and male adolescents (Vigil
et al. 2005a) and (2) a study conducted to evaluate the effect of Teen
STAR on teenage pregnancy rates in Chilean adolescent girls (Ca-
bezón et al. 2005).
172 Human Fertility: Where Faith & Science Meet
   
Teachers from different schools voluntarily participating in the study
were trained in a five-day seminar-workshop at the Pontifical Catho-
lic University of Chile (PUC), Santiago. ey were prepared to de-
velop all units of the Teen STAR program with the students and hold
effective meetings with parents. Teen STAR has different develop-
mental curricula, differentiated on the basis of age, sex, and school
class. Each curriculum has 14 units (Cabezón et al. 2005):
1. Initial session and introduction to the program
2. Differences between genders
3. Identification of prejudices on female and male’s features
4. Anatomy and physiology of human reproductive system
5. Puberty, fertility in women, and fertility in men
6. Fertility awareness, registration of fertility records (classes dis-
tributed along the course)
7. Knowing emotions and controlling behaviors
8. e manipulation of sexuality in media
9. Self-assurance and maintaining decisions
10. Marriage, family, and parenthood
11. Beginning of life, value of human life
12. Family planning methods, contraception
13. Pregnancy, delivery, breastfeeding
14. Final session and feedback
e units are delivered in one or more 45–90 minute sessions. Pro-
gression depends on satisfactory completion of each unit by the stu-
dents before passing to the next unit.
Teachers were trained to maintain fluent communication with par-
ents, while at the same time respecting the confidentiality of com-
Vigil, Cortés, Klaus  Randomized Control Trial of Teen STAR 173
munications with students. Personal interviews with the students are
an integral aspect of the program, so teachers were also trained in
counseling skills. Each teacher received a Teen STAR manual includ-
ing the curricula and supplementary articles and audiovisual materi-
als, such as posters, videotapes, and CDs.
    
  
e study on Teen STAR’s effect on adolescent sexual behavior (Vigil
et al. 2005a; 2005b) included 740 Chilean white teens (12–18 years
old) attending 10 basic schools or high schools (Figure 1). e study
and control groups consisted of students in the same grade in classes
Figure 1: Flow of Participants through Each Stage of the Study of the
Effect of Teen STAR on Adolescent Sexual Behavior
174 Human Fertility: Where Faith & Science Meet
of 30 to 40 students. ey were randomly divided into program and
control groups by drawing the letter of the class from a black bag.
e program group (n = 147 females, 251 males) consisted of those
teens who participated in the Teen STAR program with parental con-
sent. A trained Teen STAR teacher who was part of the school’s staff
and had voluntarily agreed to participate in the training workshop
worked with the program group over eight months. e program’s
curricula, differentiated on the basis of age, sex, and school class,
were offered twice a week during school hours. In addition, at least
one personal interview was conducted with each student as part of
the program. e intervention with parents consisted of three meet-
ings along the school year, which described the characteristics of the
program and physical and psychological development of teens and
requested parents’ feedback. Program impact was assessed by means
of anonymous pre- and post-program questionnaires administered
to study and control subjects (Vigil et al. 2005a).
e control group (n = 147 females, 195 males) comprised stu-
dents with similar characteristics (same age, sex, and socioeconomic
and educational levels) from parallel classes at each school who did
not participate in the Teen STAR program and received the regular
school education. ese students also completed the pre- and post-
program questionnaires. Questionnaires were given at the same time
to control and program students. e questionnaires for both groups
were identified by a name chosen by each student and known only to
him or her. e completed questionnaires were placed into a special
box, which was sealed in front of the students. e box was then sub-
mitted to a statistician. e pre- and post-program responses of the
control group and the program group were compared. e surveys
contained 135 questions about diverse topics. eir analysis allowed
evaluation of the impact of the Teen STAR program on the teens’
sexual activity via rates for (1) primary abstinence, (2) discontinua-
tion of intercourse, (3) resumption of sexual activity, and (4) influ-
ence of the curriculum on abstinence (Vigil et al. 2005a).
e study was approved by the directing councils of all participat-
ing educational establishments, as well as by the Ethics Committee
of the Faculty of Biological Sciences of the Pontifical Catholic Uni-
versity of Chile, Santiago.
Vigil, Cortés, Klaus  Randomized Control Trial of Teen STAR 175
e study included all those teenagers willing to take part who had
their parents’ consent. Before the initiation of the study, all adoles-
cents younger than 12 and older than 18 years of age (both ends of
the normal distribution curve) were excluded. Also excluded from
the outcome analysis were all those students whose pre- and post-
tests either were missing identifiers (e.g., missing date of birth) or
had internal inconsistencies or unreliable data, (e.g., noncorrelated
questionnaires in terms of date of birth and ID code, omitted ques-
tions, or noncorrelated answers to paired questions in the question-
naire). For certain variables, exclusion criteria were lack of answer or
dissenting replies (e.g., saying he/she had intercourse in pre-program
questionnaire and saying he had not in post-program questionnaire)
to a specific question (Vigil et al. 2005a).
e statistical study employed a student’s t-test and analysis for
sample homogeneity for dropouts in both groups.
       
 
A randomized, controlled study to evaluate the efficacy of the pro-
gram in preventing adolescent pregnancy (Cabezón et al. 2005) was
conducted that compared intervention with the Teen STAR program
with no intervention in a public girls school in San Bernardo, a pe-
ripheral community of Santiago, Chile. e trial included a total of
1,259 Chilean white girls, 15 to 16 years old at the time they joined
the study, who were divided into three cohorts depending on what
year they started high school: the 1996 cohort of 425 students, in
which no one received intervention; the 1997 cohort, in which 210
students received Teen STAR and 213 (control group) did not; and
the 1998 cohort, in which 328 students received Teen STAR and 83
(control group) did not (Cabezón et al. 2005; Rev. Pan. 2005) (Fig-
ure 2 [next page]). As in the previous study, participants were ran-
domly divided into program and control groups by drawing the let-
ter of the class from a black bag. e classes each had 30 to 35 girls.
e 1998 cohort included more girls in the program group. is
was because initial results obtained with the 1997 cohort showed a
decrease in pregnancy rates, so we were asked to expand the program
group. Eight teachers were available, so the program group included
eight classes (328 girls) for the 1998 cohort. All cohorts were fol-
176 Human Fertility: Where Faith & Science Meet
lowed for four years; pregnancy rates were recorded for program and
control groups. Pregnancy rates were measured, and risk ratio (RR)
with 95% confidence interval (CI) was calculated for program and
control groups in each cohort. e homogeneity test consisted of the
application of the chi-square (χ2) test (Cabezón et al. 2005).
    
In the program group, 8.8% of virgin males and 3.4% of virgin fe-
males transitioned to sexual activity, versus 17.6% of virgin males
and 12.4% of virgin females in the control group (p = 0.004) (Vigil
et al. 2005a; 2005b) (see Figure 3 [next page]). e delay observed in
the initiation of sexual activity within the program group was simi-
lar for females and males (V-square = 0.32; p = 0.571; V-square is a
corrected χ2 value obtained from a 2 x 2 table) (Cortés et al. 2006).
Within the group of sexually active students, 20.5% of program
students discontinued sexual activity (i.e., had no act of intercourse
within the final three months), compared with 9% of students in the
Figure 2: Flow of Participants rough Each Stage of the Study of the
Effect of Teen STAR on Teenage Pregnancy Prevention
Vigil, Cortés, Klaus  Randomized Control Trial of Teen STAR 177
control group who discontinued sexual activity (p ≤ 0.03). Among
students who had initiated sexual activity before the intervention,
but who were sexually inactive at the time the study began, 11.7%
of the control group resumed intercourse during the period of the
study, while none of the students in the program group did (Vigil
et al. 2005a). Adolescents participating in the program exhibited
an increase in the number of reasons for not having intercourse, or
“maintaining abstinence,” from one reason at the beginning of the
program to three reasons at the end of it (Vigil et al. 2005a).
   
Over the four-year follow-up, 6 pregnancies occurred in the program
group and 35 in the control group. Average pregnancy rates per year
were 0.87% for the program and 4.87% for the control group dur-
ing the follow-up period. For the 1996 cohort (no intervention), the
pregnancy rate was 14.7%. For the 1997 cohort, the pregnancy rates
were 3.3% and 18.91% for program and control groups, respec-
virgin to non-virgin transition (%)
Control males Program males Control females Program females
Figure 3: Transition Rates of Sexual Activity in Program and
Control Students for Males and Females
178 Human Fertility: Where Faith & Science Meet
tively (RR: 0.17619, CI: 0.0759–0.4086). For the 1998 cohort, the
pregnancy rates were 4.43% and 22.66% for program and control
groups, respectively (RR: 0.19574, CI: 0.0995–0.3848) (Cabezón
et al. 2005; Rev. Pan. 2005) (see Figure 4). Program adolescents also
exhibited a significant change in their reasons for abstinence, partic-
ularly “I can’t seem to find the right person” and “I don’t feel ready,
suggesting an internalization of their locus of control. ey pointed
out that they felt less prepared to have sexual intercourse. A reverse
trend was found in the control group adolescents for the second of
the above reasons (being one year older, they felt better qualified to
initiate sexual activity), while choices for the first reason remained
unchanged (Cabezón et al. 2005).
Although many sex education programs have been conducted and
lavish amounts of money have been spent, it is well known that
teenage pregnancies continue to be a significant problem. In Chile,
Pregnancy (%)
1997 1998
Figure 4: Overall Cumulative Pregnancy Rates over 4-Year Follow-Up
for the 1997 and 1998 Cohorts
Vigil, Cortés, Klaus  Randomized Control Trial of Teen STAR 179
15.6% of all live births in the 1996–1998 period involved moth-
ers younger than 20 years. erefore, in Chile, about 40,000 teens
become mothers every year (Vigil et al. 2005a), and this does not
consider illegal abortions or pregnancies starting at 19 and ending at
20 years (Álvarez et al. 1990; Delpiano and Aguilera Reyes. 2001).
In countries such as the United States, teenage pregnancies have
decreased during the last 15 years, but still about 800,000 adoles-
cents give birth each year. It should be noted that the decrease in
teenage pregnancy rates is different according to ethnic groups. Cur-
rently, the highest pregnancy rates are within the Hispanic groups
(Brindis 2006).
Adolescents are at high risk of contracting STDs: nearly one half
of new reported cases occur among 15 to 24 year old people (Brindis
2006). Teens’ perceptions of invulnerability (Hall et al. 2004), teen
pregnancies, and the increasingly earlier initiation of sexual activity
signal an urgent need to provide effective sex education programs to
this age group.
DiCenso’s meta-analysis (DiCenso et al. 2002) of primary pre-
vention strategies found that provision of contraception, even while
acknowledging that abstinence is preferable, did not delay the ini-
tiation of sexual intercourse or improve use of birth control among
young men and women. Nor was there a reduction in pregnancies
among young women, while the interventions increased pregnancies
in partners of male participants.
Other studies, in addition to ours, have demonstrated that sexual
education programs can have an impact in the delay of initiation of
sexual activity and teen pregnancies (Olsen et al. 1991; Darroch et
al. 2000; Sather and Zinn 2002; Rev. Pan. 2005). ese programs
promote a person’s sense of worth, together with free and informed
decision making, and appear to have greater impact on teens. A pro-
gram that embraces all aspects of the human person leads to satisfac-
tory outcomes. Teen STAR is such a program. It has resulted in (a)
increased tendency toward abstinence, (b) discontinuation of sexual
activity, and (c) taking personal responsibility for decisions about
when to give oneself to another. An additional factor to be consid-
ered is parental involvement. Our program included three meetings
with parents. A positive correlation between parental involvement
180 Human Fertility: Where Faith & Science Meet
and delay in initiating of sexual activity has been shown (Klaus et
al. 1987). For this reason, we believe that including and integrating
parents is a key factor in the success of the program.
Attitudes precede behavior change; hence, changes in attitude to-
ward primary (decides to abstain from intercourse without having
had it previously) or secondary abstinence (decides to abstain from
intercourse having had it previously) are significant. When these
changes settle in, a holistic perception and transformation of life can
be expected. Understanding the following factors helps Teen STAR
foster changes in attitude:
1. e psychological underpinnings of the increased tendency
toward abstinence. Teen STAR’s anthropological rationale en-
courages the free decisions not only by adolescents (our first and
foremost goal) but also by anyone who says yes to the program.
e above data show that the values people get in touch with work
both through their innate appeal and through group interaction
(i.e., increased awareness of one’s own dignity and the value of
2. Causes for discontinuation of sexual activity. e participants’
post-test responses appear to show that they stopped activity as a
result of a changed perception of themselves, rather than out of
boredom or peer pressure.
3. Strong personal decisions, reached through internalized un-
derstanding of one’s procreative capacity. e focus on personal
decisions shows the value of the Teen STAR program as a proposal
with a future—with firm roots. e program is based on convic-
tions and adherence to values.
is study showed a decrease in initiation of sexual activity, along
with an increase in discontinuation of sexual activity. Analysis of the
long-term effects of this type of intervention is important and has
not been done sufficiently. Preliminary studies indicate that contin-
ued observation and attention to the girls’ fertility patterns reinforces
their decision to remain, or return to, abstinence. e reduction in
pregnancies was sustained in the groups of girls who participated
in the program. However, the goal of long-term follow-up of these
students to assess behavior after high school still needs to be met.
We believe that the effectiveness of the Teen STAR program is
mainly based on certain characteristics that make it substantially dif-
Vigil, Cortés, Klaus  Randomized Control Trial of Teen STAR 181
ferent from both abstinence-only and comprehensive sexuality edu-
cation programs. Fertility awareness, coupled with placing a high
value on possessing fertility, in terms of both future procreation and
present understanding of their bodily processes, makes the program
a whole-person experience whose impact may well last for the rest of
participants’ lives. Generally, self-esteem and self-confidence result
from integrating what one understands of oneself into making one’s
own decisions about all behaviors.
For teens, recognizing their fertility not only leads to better knowl-
edge of themselves but also can become a tool for them to recognize
various endocrine-metabolic pathologies. Specifically, among girls,
certain gynecological problems can be discovered through the chart-
ing of their fertile period by the observation of the different pat-
terns of cervical mucus, as well as the regularity of their menstrual
cycles (Vigil et al. 2006a, 2006b). Some disorders, such as polycystic
ovarian syndrome, can be suspected in patients who have noticed
abnormal cervical mucus patterns, as well as an abnormal distribu-
tion of adipose tissue in the body. Symptoms of other pathologies,
such as ovarian and adrenal tumors, problems in the hypothalamo-
hypophyseal-gonadal axis, and autoimmune diseases, could also be
identified from the cervical mucus patterns, a tool that every woman
should be familiar with (Vigil 2004b). In the case of males, appro-
priate learning of their anatomy and physiology could help them to
discover emerging problems at their juvenile stages, such as obesity,
hypo- and hyperandrogenism, abnormal development of their geni-
tals, growth dysfunctions, and STDs such as Chlamydia trachomatis,
an infection that can impair the fertility of men as well as women
(Vigil et al. 2002b; Gonzales et al. 2004; Vigil and Cortés 2006).
Prompt recognition of abnormalities would hasten medical diagnosis
and treatment.
Today’s challenge for educators is to help young people to perceive
sexuality as a whole, including all dimensions of one’s human ex-
perience. Reason, freedom, and emotions should be integrated into
sex education programs. Programs should overcome the tendency to
separate affections and emotions from bodily requirements, as well.
Personal actions such as precocious sexual activity not only can cause
undesirable consequences, e.g., unintended teen pregnancies and the
182 Human Fertility: Where Faith & Science Meet
contraction of STDs, but also have an impact on the adolescent’s
psyche and emotions.
e Teen STAR program delayed sexual initiation among virgins and
facilitated discontinuation of sexual activity among sexually active
students: program students found more reasons to maintain sexu-
al abstinence than control students (Vigil et al. 2002a; Vigil et al.
2005a). e program was also effective in preventing unintended ad-
olescent pregnancies (Cabezón et al. 2005; Rev. Pan. 2005). Properly
trained high school teachers proved to be efficient in delivering the
program. Teen STAR has shown an impact on pregnancy prevention
that extends for at least the four years of high school when begun
during the first year of high school (Cabezón et al. 2005).
We thank Paulina del Río and Professor María Angélica Kaulen
(from the Faculty of Letters, PUC), for their help with the prepara-
tion of the English version of this manuscript. Also, we thank Ana
R. Godoy, BSc (Biochem), for her technical help with the preparation
of the figures.
 
Álvarez, M. L., A. Mauricci, and S. Muzzo. 1990. Información sexual de los
adolescentes según sexo. Revista Chilena de Pediatría 61(2): 102-108.
Brindis, C. D. 2006. A public health success: Understanding policy changes
related to teen sexual activity and pregnancy. Annual Review of Public
Health 27: 277-295.
Cabezón, C., P. Vigil, I. Rojas, M. E. Leiva, R. Riquelme, W. Aranda,
and C. García. 2005. Adolescent pregnancy prevention: An abstinence-
centered randomized controlled intervention in a Chilean public high
school. Journal of Adolescent Health 36(1): 64-69.
Cortés, M. E., M. J. del Río, and P. Vigil. 2006. El efecto de Teen STAR
sobre el comportamiento sexual en jóvenes. Panel 8: Catholic physicians,
globalisation and poverty. XXII Congress of the World Federation of the
Catholic Medical Associations. Barcelona, Catalonia, Spain. http://www. (accessed July 28, 2006).
Darroch, J. E., D. J. Landry, and S. Singh. 2000. Changing emphases in
sexuality education in U.S. public secondary schools, 1998–1999. Family
Planning Perspectives 32(5): 204-211, 265.
Vigil, Cortés, Klaus  Randomized Control Trial of Teen STAR 183
de Malherbe, A. 2005. Dignity and respect for oneself and others: a practi-
cal initiative with adolescents. In: by J. Donnelly, A. Kovacova, H. Os-
ofsky, C. Paskell, J. Salem-Pickartz, (eds.), Developing strategies to deal
with trauma in children. A means of ensuring conflict prevention, security
and social stability: case study 12–15-year-olds in Serbia. Amsterdam, IOS
Press: 107-109.
Delpiano, A., and M. Aguilera Reyes. 2001. Mujeres chilenas: estadísticas
para el nuevo siglo. Servicio Nacional de la Mujer & Instituto Nacional
de Estadísticas. Santiago of Chile: Empresa Periodística «La Nación»: 25-
DiCenso, A., G. Guyatt, A. Willan, and L. Griffith. 2002. Interventions to
reduce unintended pregnancies among adolescents: Systematic review of
randomised controlled trials. British Medical Journal 324(7351): 1426-
Gonzales, G. F., G. Muñoz, R. Sánchez, R. Henkel, G. Gallegos-Ávila, O.
Díaz-Gutiérrez, P. Vigil, F. Vásquez, G. Kortebani, A. Mazzolli, and E.
Bustos-Obregón. 2004. Update on the impact of Chlamydia trachomatis
infection on male fertility. Andrologia 36(1): 1-23.
Hall, P. A., M. Holmqvist, and S. B. Sherry. 2004. Risky adolescent sexual
behavior: A psychological perspective for primary care clinicians. Topics
in Advanced Practice Nursing eJournal 4(1).
viewarticle/467059 (accessed July 28, 2006).
Kirby, D. 2001. Emerging Answers: Research Findings on Programs to Reduce
Teen Pregnancy. Washington, D.C.: National Campaign to Prevent Teen
Klaus, H., L. Bryan, M. Bryant, M. Fagan, M. Harrigan, and F. Kearns.
1987. Fertility awareness/natural family planning for adolescents and
their families: Report of multisite pilot project. International Journal of
Adolescent Medicine & Health 3(2): 101-119.
Olsen, J. A., S. E. Weed, G. M. Ritz, and L. C. Jensen. 1991. e effects
of three abstinence sex education programs on student attitudes toward
sexual activity. Adolescent 26(13): 631-641.
Pittman, V. 2006. Comprehensive sexuality education or abstinence-only
education: Which is more effective? Journal of Research for Educational
Leaders 3(2): 60-91.
Rev. Panam. 2005. Prevención del embarazo de adolescentes en una escuela
secundaria de Chile. Revista Panamericana de Salud Pública 17(4): 281.
Santelli, J., M. A. Ott, M. Lyon, J. Rogers, D. Summers, and R. Schleifer.
2006. Abstinence and abstinence-only education: A review of U.S. poli-
cies and programs. Journal of Adolescent Health 38(1): 72-81.
Sather, L., and K. Zinn. 2002. Effects of abstinence-only education on
adolescent attitudes and value concerning premarital sexual intercourse.
Family and Community Health 25(2): 1-15.
184 Human Fertility: Where Faith & Science Meet
Silva, M. 2002. e effectiveness of school-based sex education programs in
the promotion of abstinent behavior: A meta-analysis. Health Education
Research 17(4): 471-481.
Social Security Act, Title V, of 42 United States Codes 710, Section 510.
omas, M. H. 2000. Abstinence-based programs for prevention of adoles-
cent pregnancies. Journal of Adolescent Health 26(1): 5-17.
Vigil, P. 2004a. Uniendo ciencia básica y educación sexual. Bioplanet
10(July): 38-40.
bio_2004_julago_genetica03.htm (accessed June 30, 2007).
Vigil, P. 2004b. Every woman should know fertility awareness so that their
reproductive health can be monitored. Bulletin of the Ovulation Method
Research and Reference Centre of Australia 31(4): 8-9.
Vigil, P., F. Ceric, M. E. Cortés, and H. Klaus. 2006a. Usefulness of moni-
toring fertility from menarche. Journal of Pediatric and Adolescent Gyne-
cology 19(3): 173-179.
Vigil, P., F. Ceric, M. E. Cortés, and H. Klaus. 2006b. Usefulness of moni-
toring fertility from menarche. Bulletin of the Ovulation Method Research
and Reference Centre of Australia 33(2): 21-30.
Vigil, P., and M. E. Cortés. 2006. Infertilidad y Chlamydia trachomatis.
International Journal of Morphology 24(1): 115-116.
Vigil, P., R. Riquelme, and A. Peirone. 2002a. Teen STAR: Opting for
maturity and freedom. In: J. D. Vial Correa, E. Sgreccia, eds. Natura e
dignità della persona umana a fondamento del diritto alla vita. Le sfide del
contesto culturale contemporaneo. Atti della VIII Assemblea della Pontifi-
cia Accademia per la Vita. Città del Vaticano, Libreria Editrice Vaticana:
Vigil, P., R. Riquelme, R. Rivadeneira, and W. Aranda. 2005a. Teen STAR:
una opción de madurez y libertad. Programa de educación integral de
la sexualidad orientado a adolescentes. Revista Médica de Chile 133(10):
Vigil, P., R. Riquelme, R. Rivadeneira, and H. Klaus. 2005b. Effect of Teen
STAR®, an abstinence-only sexual education program on adolescent sexu-
al behavior. Journal of Pediatric and Adolescent Gynecology 18(1): 212.
Vigil, P., A. Tapia, S. Zacharias, R. Riquelme, A. M. Salgado, and J. Varleta.
2002b. First-trimester pregnancy loss and active Chlamydia trachomatis
infection: Correlation and ultrastructural evidence. Andrologia 34(6):
View publication statsView publication stats
... Power as it relates to fertility is often referred to in the biological sense as the ability to conceive a child. 1,2,4,8,26 It also can be the power over fertility or the suppression of fertility. 4,6,25,27 Power over fertility is manifested in family planning methods such as contraception, induced abortion, fertility-awareness based methods, and most importantly, reproductive behaviors. ...
... Sexual decision making is dependent upon many factors including self-perception, 18 perception of physical risk such as sexually transmitted infections (STIs), 34 and fertility goals related to pregnancy 35 as well as emotional considerations. 26 Sexual decision making is an antecedent of fertility because biologically, women are fertile beings, but fertility cannot be potentiated or realized until the woman engages in sexual intercourse during the fertile window of her menstrual cycle. 3 However, sexual decision making does not always precede fertility, as in the case of women who undergo assistive reproduction. ...
... 36,37 Women with cancer who undergo chemotherapy and radiation also may experience uncertainty of fertility. 30,32,38 On the other hand, fertility has positive consequences such as increased understanding of self, which leads to selfconfidence as a sexual person, integrity, 26 and the ability to discern and make sexual decisions based on social and psychological readiness for fertility, versus biological readiness. 4 Clinicians can aid in decisions involving female fertility by explaining the possible positive and negative, physical and emotional consequences. ...
Introduction: Female fertility is commonly described as the biological nature of women, yet different meanings emerge when one takes a holistic approach to fertility while considering varying contexts and perspectives. An improved understanding of female fertility will enhance health care professionals' understanding of female fertility and improve communication with women and other health care professionals. This article presents a conceptual and dimensional analysis of female fertility. Methods: A search of the literature included the databases CINAHL, PsycINFO, Philosopher's Index, and Web of Science. Concept and dimensional analyses were performed using the Rogers' methodology and the Caron and Bowers' framework to define female fertility and explore the concept. Articles were examined to identify definitions, dimensions, perspectives, antecedents, and consequences of female fertility. Results: Biological self, psychosexual self, power, and paradox are the attributes of female fertility. The contexts of menarche, menstruation, menopause, infertility, fertility goals, society and culture, and health care were explored. Perspectives included those of women across many different fertility stages as well as perspectives of various clinicians. Necessary antecedents were sexual decision making and influences of culture and society. Consequences were realized fertility, stress, and an understanding of self. A definition of fertility was proposed: Female fertility is a paradoxical phenomenon of power between the biological and psychosexual self. Discussion: Antecedents, attributes, and consequences derived from the fertility literature can be used by health care providers for patient education and therapeutic interventions. This concept analysis may assist in facilitation of a greater understanding of biological and psychosexual self, as they relate to fertility across the lifespan.
... El enseñar el reconocimiento de la fertilidad a las mujeres jóvenes involucra un esfuerzo que puede resultarles de utilidad durante toda su vida (Vigil, 2004b). Además se ha demostrado que (Vigil, 2007c) estos conocimientos cuando son aprendidos durante la adolescencia junto a una formación personal que considere todos los aspectos de la persona, constituyen una herramienta importante para fortalecer la identidad y prevenir el embarazo en adolescentes. ...
Full-text available
I. Introducción. La fertilidad es un estado biológico transitorio que depende del potencial de fertilidad de la pareja (Vigil et al., 2006). Durante el ciclo de vida de la mujer, el ovario pasa por distintos estados en relación a su capacidad ovulatoria y de secreción hormonal. El concepto de ciclo ovárico como un continuo-conocido este como el «continuo ovárico»-considera que todos los tipos de actividad que se observan durante la vida reproductiva de la mujer constituyen respuestas a diferentes condiciones ambientales, con el propósito de asegurar la salud de la madre y la del niño, en el caso de ocurrir una concepción. El continuo ovárico comienza en el instante de la fecundación, cuando el cigoto empieza su desarrollo (Vigil et al., 2006). Aproximadamente dos meses después de ocurrida la fecundación, las futuras ovogonias, llamadas células germinales primordiales (CGP o gonocitos) en este período, dejan el embrión y migran hacia el saco vitelino, hecho que les permite evadir el proceso de diferenciación celular embrionario. Alrededor de cuatro semanas más tarde, las CGP migran a la cresta gonadal, región del futuro ovario, se establecen ahí, se rodean de células somáticas y comienzan su proceso de diferenciación, formando millones de folículos primordiales. En este período se forman cerca de 7 millones de folículos primordiales, la mayoría de los cuales sufrirá atresia-proceso de degeneración-que reduce el número de folículos.
Full-text available
Fertility awareness constitutes fundamental knowledge for every woman and is an important tool for health professionals. The objective of this review is to show how fertility awareness can be useful in the assessment of a woman's health. The main techniques for detecting ovulation are explained, and then the events that characterize a normal menstrual cycle are discussed. The relevance of cervical mucus from the perspective of female fertility is highlighted. Finally, the usefulness of fertility awareness 1) to identify fertile and infertile periods, 2) to help to detect several pathologies, and 3) in regards to how it exerts an important role in the success of programs in education for affectivity and sexuality are discussed. © 2012 by the Catholic Medical Association. All rights reserved.
Full-text available
La infección por Chlamydia trachomatis (Ct), bacteria Gramnegativa patógena, constituye una de las enfermedades de transmisión sexual más frecuentes, con aproximadamente 90 millones de casos al año. Aunque el rol de Ct en la infertilidad masculina es controversial, y hemos demostrado que la infección por Ct en el varón no afecta la función espermática evaluada mediante reacción acrosómica, unión a la zona pelúcida y test de fusión gamética heteróloga, en Chile se ha encontrado una incidencia de 38,6% entre los varones de parejas infértiles (n = 284), versus 13 % en varones sin problemas de fertilidad, lo cual indicaría un probable efecto en la disminución del potencial reproductivo. Otros estudios sugieren que muchas infecciones del tracto genital superior masculino, incluyendo la epididimitis, son atribuibles a Ct. Las clamidias actuarían como un impedimento físico para el movimiento del espermatozoide, causarían un daño epitelial que alteraría la espermatogénesis, e inducirían respuestas inmunológicas generadoras de anticuerpos antiespermáticos. La clamidiosis también causa problemas en la mujer y aunque aproximadamente 2/3 de quienes la sufren son asintomáticas, la infección se manifiesta inicialmente con uretritis o cervicitis. Si la infección avanza, puede ocasionar enfermedad inflamatoria pélvica, embarazos ectópicos e infertilidad. Nuestros estudios han demostrado que en mujeres que sufrieron aborto espontáneo durante el primer trimestre de embarazo la incidencia de Ct es 21% (14 de 66), lo que es superior a la incidencia de infección por Ct en la población general. La patogenia de la infección por Ct estaría dada principalmente por un factor inmunológico e inflamatorio crónico. Sin embargo, son necesarios estudios posteriores para determinar el principal mecanismo de acción de Ct en la génesis de aborto espontáneo e infertilidad.
Full-text available
Se estudia la informacion sexual de los adolecentes segun sexo, la cominicacion con los padres respectos a esta materia y la pratica religiosa, a fin de explicar indirectamente el aumento de los embarazos precoces. La muestra es representativa de escolares de Gran Santiago (n = 1.782), proveniente de distintos estratos socioeconomicos. Los resultados indican que las ninas son mas informadas por su madre que los varones (p
Full-text available
in the frequency of pregnancies and sexually transmitted diseases among teenagers. A means of facing this problem is promoting sexual abstinence among youngsters. There are studies that confirm the efficacy of this approach. Aim: To show the results of the application of a holistic sexuality program (TeenSTAR) among Chilean teenagers. Subjects and Methods: Students attending basic or high school were divided into a control or study group. The control group (342 students) received the usual education on sexuality given by their schools and the study group (398 students) participated in twelve TeenSTAR sessions lasting 1.5 hours each, given by a trained professor. Assessment of achievements was made using an anonymous questionnaire answered at the start and end of the program. Results: The rates of sexual initiation among control and study groups were 15 and 6.5%, respectively. Among sexually active students, 20% of those in the study group and 9% of those in the control group discontinued sexual activity. Conclusions: A higher proportion of students in the TeenSTAR program retarded their sexual initiation or discontinued sexual activity and found more reasons to maintain sexual abstinence than control students (Rev Méd Chile 2005; 133: 1173-82). (Key Words: Adolescent; Sexual abstinence; Sexual behavior)
Full-text available
The purpose of this study was to examine the difference in effectiveness between comprehensive sexuality abstinence-based education and abstinence-only education. A survey was developed and distributed to over 140 individuals via a variety of sources such as a) the researcher's e-mail lists, b) a group of City Core/City Year volunteers, c) a nightclub frequented by young adults, d) patients enrolled at Test Positive Awareness Network (TPAN), an agency that provides HIV/AIDS counseling, testing and referral services to a north shore community in Chicago Illinois, and e) co-workers' adult children. One hundred-four participants met at least three to four of the criteria which included: a) age range between 18 and 30 years, b) be at least a high school graduate, c) have participated in either an abstinence-only or comprehensive sexuality education program, and d) have an active e-mail address. Comprehensive sexuality education appeared to be more effective than abstinence-only sexuality education. It was recommended that this study be conducted on a larger scale using a larger sample. In addition, it may be worthwhile to examine program effectiveness through those who have participated in both abstinence-only sexuality education and comprehensive sexuality education for a better comparison.
The majority of older adolescents in North America are sexually active, yet many do not take appropriate precautions to prevent pregnancy or the spread of sexually transmitted infections. This article discusses several ways to conceptualize, assess, and manage risky sexual behavior in adolescents from a psychological perspective. Adolescents, like adults, may be prone to engaging in risky sexual behavior due to perceptions of personal invulnerability and their tendency to focus on the immediate, rather than long-term, consequences of their behavior. Mentally ill adolescents may be particularly at risk and warrant special consideration. Specific clinical recommendations for assessing and managing risky sexual behavior are discussed. These include maintaining an empathic stance toward the adolescent, supporting the autonomy of the adolescent, identifying and owning one's own values, familiarizing oneself with available resources, and referring to mental health practitioners when appropriate.
This report summarizes three bodies of research on teenage pregnancy and programs to reduce the risk of teenage pregnancy. Studies included in this report were completed in 1980 or later, conducted in the United States or Canada, targeted adolescents, employed an experimental or quasi-experimental design, had a sample size of at least 100 in the combined treatment and control group, and measured the impact on sexual or contraceptive behavior, pregnancy, or childbearing. Six chapters focus on: (1) "Making the Case for Prevention Efforts: Adolescent Risk-Taking Behavior and Its Consequences"; (2) "Looking for Reasons Why: The Antecedents of Adolescent Sexual Behavior"; (3) "Assessing the Evidence: Factors Affecting the Strength of Research Results"; (4) "Emerging Answers: The Behavioral Impact of Programs To Reduce Adolescent Sexual Risk-Taking"; (5) "Looking Forward: Conclusions about the State of Research and the Effectiveness of Programs"; and (6) "Bringing It Home: Applying These Research Results in Communities." (Chapters contain references.) (SM)
The effects of three abstinence sex education programs on student attitudes toward sexual activity were studied. The programs were administered to 7th- and 10th-grade students in three school districts in the State of Utah. All students were administered a pre- and posttest survey to determine attitude change. The independent variables were program, grade level, gender, and pre/posttest. The dependent variable was the combined and averaged response to 12 questions taken from the survey. There was a four-way interaction between the independent variables. The Sex Respect program produced the most positive attitude change.
PIP This article assesses the abstinence-based programs developed by family life educators and the factors associated with positive results through a review of abstinence promotion programs of the federal government. In 1996, Section 510 was added to Title V of the Social Security Act allocating US$50 million annually from 1998-2000 to fund abstinence education programs, while in 1997, a National Strategy to Prevent Teen Pregnancy was launched by the Office of Adolescent Pregnancy Prevention to provide teen pregnancy programs to at least 25% of the communities. Presented in this paper is a discussion of the Abstinence Only programs, which focus on the prevention of pregnancy and sexually transmitted disease among adolescents, and the Abstinence Plus programs, which emphasize other prevention methods as well as abstinence. Evaluation of Abstinence Only programs include Success Express, Project Taking Charge, Sex Respect, Teen Aid, Values and Choices and Facts and Feelings. Moreover, programs such as Reducing the Risk, Postponing Sexual Involvement, Project Education Now, and Babies Later were evaluated under the Abstinence Plus programs. Several programs evaluated have shown to have a positive effect on attitudes among adolescents, but are not proven to have a significant effect on sexual behavior. In conclusion, this article encourages exploration of new approaches to address teen pregnancy and the increasing incidence of sexually transmitted diseases among adolescents, while the federal government must utilize the implementation of existing programs with positive effects.
Since the late 1980s, both the political context surrounding sexuality education and actual teaching approaches have changed considerably. However, little current national information has been available on the content of sexuality education to allow in-depth understanding of the breadth of these changes and their impact on current teaching. In 1999, a nationally representative survey collected data from 3,754 teachers in grades 7-12 in the five specialties most often responsible for sexuality education. Results from those teachers and from the subset of 1,767 who actually taught sexuality education are compared with the findings from a comparable national survey conducted in 1988. In 1999, 93% of all respondents reported that sexuality education was taught in their school at some point in grades 7-12; sexuality education covered a broad number of topics, including sexually transmitted diseases (STDs), abstinence, birth control, abortion and sexual orientation. Some topics--how HIV is transmitted, STDs, abstinence, how to resist peer pressure to have intercourse and the correct way to use a condom--were taught at lowergrades in 1999 than in 1988. In 1999, 23% of secondary school sexuality education teachers taught abstinence as the only way of preventing pregnancy and STDs, compared with 2% who did so in 1988. Teachers surveyed in 1999 were more likely than those in 1988 to cite abstinence as the most important message they wished to convey (41% vs. 25%). In addition, steep declines occurred between 1988 and 1999, overall and across grade levels, in the percentage of teachers who supported teaching about birth control, abortion and sexual orientation, as well as in the percentage actually covering those topics. However, 39% of 1999 respondents who presented abstinence as the only option also told students that both birth control and the condom can be effective. Sexuality education in secondary public schools is increasingly focused on abstinence and is less likely to present students with comprehensive teaching that includes necessary information on topics such as birth control, abortion and sexual orientation. Because of this, and in spite of some abstinence instruction that also covers birth control and condoms as effective methods of prevention, many students are not receiving accurate information on topics their teachers feel they need.
This article compares the values and attitudes of two groups of 7th and 8th grade adolescents toward premarital sexual activity. One group received state-funded, abstinence-only education; the other group did not receive that education. Abstinence-only education did not significantly change adolescents' values and attitudes about premarital sexual activity, nor their intentions to engage in premarital sexual activity. The majority of both the treatment and control group subjects expressed disagreement with the statement: "It is okay for people my age to have sexual intercourse," and they did not intend to have sexual intercourse while an unmarried teenager.