ResearchPDF Available

Abstract

See also: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/383028418_Products_-_Tourism. CITATION: Koutoulas, D. (2004). Understanding the Tourism Product. In Proceedings of the international scientific symposium “Understanding Tourism – Theoretical Advances”. https://doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.1.2250.4806. ABSTRACT: The aim of this paper is to propose a marketing-oriented definition of the tourist product as well as a classification system of its components based on an extensive review and analysis of tourism marketing literature. Tourist products satisfy the tourist needs and are the objects of the transactions between tourists and businesses. Determining the tourist products is most helpful for social scientists interested in understanding the aforementioned transactions and the benefits derived by consuming these products. This proves to be a challenging task, though, due to the lack of a common understanding among the authors who have explored this issue as well as due to the different levels of tourist products and their complex nature. For instance, tourist products can be determined on two distinct levels: ➢ The total tourist product comprises a combination of all the elements, which a tourist consumes during his/her trip. ➢ The specific products are components of the total tourist product and can be sold as individual offerings such as accommodation, transport, attractions and other facilities for tourists. This paper focuses on the total tourist products, that can be understood as bundles of tangible and intangible components, based on an activity at a destination. It is the consumption of such a bundle that allows engaging in specific activities at the destination(s) and that creates the travel experience of each individual. Thus, the tourist product can be equated with the total travel experience. Tourist products are characterised by their complex nature. They consist of numerous components ― most of which constitute products themselves ― with each one playing a distinct functional role in this “amalgam of tangible and intangible elements”. These components complement each other, i.e. they are functionally interdependent as each one provides only a part of the total sum of benefits sought by tourists.
Interim symposium of the Research Committee on International Tourism (RC 50)
of the International Sociological Association (ISA) on the topic:
“UNDERSTANDING TOURISM - THEORETICAL ADVANCES”
14-16 May 2004, University of the Aegean, Mytilini, Greece
UNDERSTANDING THE TOURIST PRODUCT
Paper Presented By Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas
Business Consultant and Lecturer at the Department of Business Administration,
University of Macedonia, Thessaloniki, Greece
E-Mail: d.koutoulas@gmail.com
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
2
Abstract
The aim of this paper is to propose a marketing-oriented definition of the tourist product as
well as a classification system of its components based on an extensive review and analysis of
tourism marketing literature. Tourist products satisfy the tourist needs and are the objects of the
transactions between tourists and businesses.
Determining the tourist products is most helpful for social scientists interested in
understanding the aforementioned transactions and the benefits derived by consuming these
products. This proves to be a challenging task, though, due to the lack of a common
understanding among the authors who have explored this issue as well as due to the different
levels of tourist products and their complex nature.
For instance, tourist products can be determined on two distinct levels:
The total tourist product comprises a combination of all the elements, which a
tourist consumes during his/her trip.
The specific products are components of the total tourist product and can be sold
as individual offerings such as accommodation, transport, attractions and other
facilities for tourists.
This paper focuses on the total tourist products, that can be understood as bundles of
tangible and intangible components, based on an activity at a destination. It is the consumption of
such a bundle that allows engaging in specific activities at the destination(s) and that creates the
travel experience of each individual. Thus, the tourist product can be equated with the total travel
experience.
Tourist products are characterised by their complex nature. They consist of numerous
components most of which constitute products themselves with each one playing a distinct
functional role in this “amalgam of tangible and intangible elements”. These components
complement each other, i.e. they are functionally interdependent as each one provides only a part
of the total sum of benefits sought by tourists.
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
3
Introduction
What do tourists consume during their trips? Marketing literature has focused on this issue
since the early 1970s as part of the discussion regarding tourist products. These products satisfy
the primary and secondary tourist needs (Paul, 1977:18) and are the objects of the transactions
between tourists and businesses (Koutoulas, 2001:473).
Determining the tourist product is most helpful for social scientists interested in
understanding the aforementioned transactions and the benefits derived by consuming this
product. This proves to be a challenging task, though, due to the lack of a common understanding
among the authors who have explored this issue as well as due to the different levels of tourist
products and their complex nature.
The target of this paper is to propose a marketing-oriented definition of the tourist product
as well as a classification system of its distinct components. The methodology applied for that
purpose comprises (1) the critical and comparative analysis of literature (mostly tourism
marketing literature in German, English and Greek), (2) the codification of the scientific
discussion regarding the tourist product and (3) the formulation of analytical theoretical
principles for the definition of the tourist products and its components. These three steps have
been preceded by a systematic and extensive review of the tourism marketing literature spanning
several decades.
The need to formulate definitions and other theoretical principles derives from the absence
of an established and commonly accepted tourism marketing theory, a situation that can be
characterised as the theoretical deficit of tourism marketing (Freyer, 1999:35). The disagreement
among authors has been established for practically every meaning crucial to the discussion about
the tourist products (Koutoulas, 2001), e.g.:
tourism
tourism marketing
tourist product
components of the tourist product
The limited space of this paper does not allow to present the whole range of approaches
found in the literature. Instead, the paper includes the key findings of the aforementioned analysis
as well as the proposed theoretical principles.
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
4
Products as Need Satisfiers
Marketing theory views products as fulfilling two distinct tasks (Burkheiser, 1969:106;
Scheuch, 1993:315):
Primarily, each product satisfies a need of its consumer through the benefit(s) it
incorporates. Or, to put it in the words of Theodore Levitt, “It is the benefits that
are the product” (Levitt, 1969:9).
Secondarily, the products are the means to achieve the targets of the marketing
organisation through their sale. Although the primary objective of an enterprise is
to make a profit, this is the derived result of selling products that satisfy consumer
needs.
Tourist products are the means to satisfy tourist needs (Paul, 1977:18). According to
Jovicic (1988:2-3), tourist needs are those that are “satisfied when movement is performed (travel
and sojourn) outside the place of residence.” Therefore, “a need is a tourist need only if it
requires a departure from one’s place of residence.”
These needs can be grouped into two distinct categories (Paul, 1977:18):
i. Primary tourist needs are those that urge a person to make a tourist trip in
order to satisfy them.
ii. Secondary or derived tourist needs are those arising from the decision to
make a tourist trip.
For instance, our need to find accommodation in Mytilini is a secondary one, as it has been
derived from our decision to take part in this conference.
Tourist products are the means to satisfy these primary and secondary needs, thanks to the
benefits offered by their consumption (Koutoulas, 2001:253). Both the needs and the products are
objects of the transaction between tourists and businesses (Koutoulas, 2001:473). This
transaction is depicted in Figure 1.
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
5
Total Vs. Specific Tourist Products
Before defining tourist products, a basic distinction should be made considering that they
can be determined on two distinct levels (Freyer, 1993:129; Middleton, 1989:573; Tietz,
1980:10):
The total tourist product comprises the combination of all the elements, which a
tourist consumes during his/her trip.
The specific products are components of the total tourist product and can be sold
as individual offerings such as accommodation, transport, attractions and other
facilities for tourists. In other words, specific products are the offerings of the
individual tourist enterprises.
This paper focuses on the total tourist products that can be understood as bundles of
tangible and intangible components based on an activity at a destination (Middleton, 1988:79). It
is the consumption of such a bundle that allows engaging in specific activities at the
destination(s) and that creates the travel experience of each individual. Thus, the tourist product
can be equated with the total travel experience (Medlik and Middleton, 1973:138).
The marketing approach adopted in this paper makes it imperative to embrace the total view
of the tourist product, which is how the consumer sees the product. According to Medlik and
Middleton (1973:132), “all tourists buy, either separately, or as an inclusive tour, the various
components of the tourist product. Either way, the end result of all these purchases is a ‘package.’
This view of the tourist product holds good whether a business trip, a holiday or, indeed, any
other form of tourism, international or domestic, is under consideration. Airline seats or hotel
beds may be individual products in the eyes of their producers, but they are merely elements or
components of a total tourist product, which is a composite product.”
From now on, the term “tourist product” refers in this paper to the total tourist product as
determined above.
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
6
Defining Tourist Products
The critical and comparative analysis of the literature as well as the codification of dozens
of definitions and other approaches to the meaning of the tourist product have resulted in the
following theoretical principles (Koutoulas, 2001:258):
i. The tourist product should not be seen from the point of view of the individual
producer (such as the hotelier or the transportation company) but from the
point of view of the consumer, thus equating the tourist product with his/her
total travel experience. The tourist product should be perceived as including all
the elements that are part of a trip.
ii. These elements can be found at the destination(s) of the trip, the transit routes
and the places of residence (Leiper, 1990:81). In addition, the consumption of
these elements takes place before, during and after the trip. For instance,
tourists spend part of their travel budget both at their home town (e.g. for
buying a map before the trip and developing films after the trip) and en route to
their destination (e.g. for buying food or gasoline).
iii. A tourist product can only be determined in relation to a specific destination,
a fact that makes each product unique. For instance, the geological tour of the
petrified forest in Sigri is a product unique to Lesbos; this particular experience
and combination of elements cannot be found anywhere else.
iv. The tourist product should be distinguished from the destination. The
destination is not the product. On the contrary, a destination usually offers
several products to its visitors, with each distinct travel experience constituting
a tourist product (Jeffries, 1971:4). For instance, the island of Lesbos allows for
a cosmopolitan beach vacation in Molyvos; a serene beach vacation in a
secluded village; a geological tour; a tour of the historic sights; small or
medium-sized conferences; culinary experiences related to the local ouzo drink,
sardines, olives and olive oil; and the list goes on.
v. The tourist product should be distinguished from the inclusive tours or package
tours. An inclusive tour is not a total tourist product but a specific tourist
product as discussed above, even though it is a composite one. An inclusive
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
7
tour is essentially a selected combination of individual elements of the total
tourist product, marketed under a particular product or brand label, and sold at
an inclusive price (Middleton, 1988:271).
vi. The tourist product is a composite product consisting of several components
(Burkart and Medlik, 1981:195). It is also labelled as a “package” (Jeffries,
1971:4), an “amalgam” (Medlik and Middleton, 1973:132) or a “bundle”
(Middleton, 1988:79) of tangible and intangible components. These
components complement each other, i.e. they are functionally interdependent as
each one provides only a part of the total sum of benefits sought by tourists
(Mrnjavac, 1992:122).
vii. It is not the production but the consumption of the tourist product that
explains its composite nature. Each component is produced independently by
the respective enterprise and it provides only a limited benefit or no benefit at
all to its consumer if it is not combined with the other components of the tourist
product. It is only the whole bundle of components that fully satisfies the
primary and secondary needs of a tourist. In other words, it is the demand side
and not the supply side that makes it necessary to consume bundles of
elements (Menges, 1973:46).
viii. From the consumer’s point of view, the tourist product amounts to his/her
travel experience, including everything experienced and consumed as part of
the trip. According to Heath and Wall (1992:4), the product is an experience
that is achieved through the combination of a diverse array of products and
service. Furthermore, the tourist product has the characteristics of a type A’
service (Koutoulas, 2001:252), due to the fact that the tourist becomes the
external factor of the production process and participates in the provision of
services by tourist businesses (Tietz, 1980:8).
ix. The purpose of a tourist trip is to engage in certain activities that satisfy the
primary tourist needs. For instance, the primary need to relax can be satisfied
by bathing in the sea and basking in the sun. The tourist product provides all
the means needed to engage in the desired activity (Koutoulas, 2001:260),
i.e. a safe beach, warm seawater and sunshine. Actually, the concept of the
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
8
tourist product cannot be fully understood without determining the particular
activities that a tourist wants to engage in.
x. The tourist product is a carrier of benefits, as is the case with every product
form. It constitutes the means to satisfy both primary and secondary tourist
needs as discussed above. Tourist products consist, on the one hand, of the
attractions that allow tourists to engage in the desired activities and, on the
other hand, of the elements facilitating the tourist’s transition to the destination
and the social reproduction during his/her stay (Koutoulas, 2001:260).
xi. Normally, it is the producers of goods and services who decide which benefits
to incorporate in their products. In the case of the tourist product, this holds true
only for some of its elements. The benefits of several components are not the
result of a management decision, but of natural, cultural and historic
processes. A good example for this is the climate and the beaches of Lesbos.
xii. It is important to stress that consumers perceive tourist products in a
subjective way. The perception depends on each tourist’s socio-economic and
psycho-demographic variables as well as on his/her previous travel experiences,
motivation, conceptions and expectations etc. (Mrnjavac, 1992:121).
xiii. It is very unlikely that two tourists will have exactly the same travel experience.
On the one hand is the subjective perception of each trip as mentioned above.
One the other hand, there is a huge number of goods, services and facilities,
from which each tourist makes his/her own combination (Taylor, 1980:56-57).
Even when some important items are sold together in packages determined by
the tourism producers or intermediaries, each individual trip will still largely
consist of a consumer selection of products, which will be necessarily unique
(Ashworth and Voogd, 1990:8). Thus, each tourist experiences his/her own
unique tourist product. According to Cullen (1989:447), “the experiences of
each traveller differ from those of every other traveller in some way. These
differences are part of the intangible benefits, the sensations of well-being,
acquired by each traveller. The extent of the benefits and their value can be
even harder to measure, since they vary with the personality and disposition of
the recipients.” In short, from an individual tourist’s point of view, each tourist
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
9
engages in a personalised mix of activities, consumes a personalised set of
goods, services and facilities and experiences the trip in a subjective manner
(Koutoulas, 2001:261). It is impossible to determine each individual’s tourist
product in advance; the exact combination of experiences and consumed
elements can only be established after the trip.
xiv. The tourist product, i.e. the travel experience and the various elements
goods, services and facilities used and consumed by a tourist as part of
his/her trip, has a total price. This price is not settled in one payment; on the
contrary, it takes several transactions to obtain all elements of the product,
even in the case of an all-inclusive package tour (Koutoulas, 2001:262).
xv. Some of the tourist product’s components are not produced specifically for the
tourist market, with the respective businesses serving other markets, as well. It
is the consumption phase and not the production phase that makes
some elements part of the tourist product. For instance, most of the
restaurants of Mytilini have tourists among their customers, but their clientele is
predominantly the local population. The same holds true for the grocery shops,
the pharmacies, the bus lines and many other local businesses. The very same
good, service or facility can be a tourist one or not depending not on the way it
is produced or provided but on who will consume or use it (Walterspiel,
1956:8).
These principles constitute the specifications of the definition adopted in this paper. In line
with the above findings, the following definition is proposed (Koutoulas, 2001:474):
The tourist product is defined as the total bundle of functionally interdependent
tangible and intangible elements that enables the tourist on the one hand to engage in
a specific activity at one or at several consecutive destinations and on the other hand
to facilitate the transition to the destination(s) and the social reproduction during the
trip. As a carrier of benefits, the tourist product satisfies both the primary and
secondary tourist needs. Some of these benefits pre-existed in components of the
product, while other benefits were consciously incorporated in the components by the
respective producers. The tourist product’s components that include all
aforementioned tangible and intangible elements are found in different
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
10
geographical location (the place of residence, the destination(s) and the transit routes)
and in different time periods (before, during and after the trip). The tourist product
constitutes a type A’ service. From the tourist’s point of view it is equated with
his/her total travel experience that is perceived in a subjective manner; for this
experience he/she pays the total travel expenses. The consumption of the tourist
product primarily allows for the satisfaction of tourist needs (through the benefits
offered) and secondarily promotes the achievement of the organisational targets set
by individual tourist enterprises and collective tourism organisations (through the
obtained income).
The Components of Tourist Products
Tourist products consist of numerous components due to their complex nature. The analysis
of the tourism literature has revealed several approaches to the components, with the respective
authors not agreeing (1) on what constitutes a component of the tourist product and (2) on how
the components are classified.
These components come in various forms (Koutoulas, 2001:394):
Integral products that can be sold independently on the market (such as hotel
accommodation, air transport, admission to visitor attractions etc.)
“Free” or “public” goods, such as the climate and the scenery, that can be used
or consumed by tourists free of charge (Scheuch, 1982:87; Leiper, 1990:147)
Complementary services that cannot be sold independently on the market, such
as the services provided by a tourist information office or by a tour leader.
In this paper, the following definition is adopted:
Components of the tourist product are those integral products, “free and public
goods” and complementary services that perform a specific functional role in the
framework of the total product and that are part of the product because of their
functional characteristics. Components are, therefore, a prerequisite for the total
product, so that the latter can provide the expected benefits to the consumers. The
functional characteristics have been incorporated into the components either by their
respective producers following a conscious managerial decision (in the case of
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
11
integral products and complementary services), or by the nature and culture of the
destination (in the case of the “free and public goods”). More specifically, it is final
products and not intermediate products or inputs of a production process that are
considered integral products. In addition, integral products should be produced and/or
sold by tourist enterprises that fulfil two characteristics in order to be considered as
components of the tourist product: (1) the products good and services provided
by these enterprises directly satisfy the needs of tourists; (2) these enterprises come in
direct contact with tourists when trading their products. Components complement
each other, i.e. they are functionally interdependent as each one provides only a part
of the total sum of benefits sought by tourists (Krippendorf, 1971:18 & 34; Zolles et
al., 1981:34; Mrnjavac, 1992:122; Koutoulas, 2001:395).
This definition does not accept certain elements as components of the tourist product, such
as the inputs used by tourist enterprises in their production process and the infrastructure
(consisting of the material, institutional and personnel-related infrastructure that is usually
provided by the government and is a prerequisite for economic development Spatt, 1975:76),
because neither constitutes a final product. The definition also excludes those elements that
influence a tourist’s travel experience but that do not have a functional role in satisfying
consumer needs (see Figure 2). For instance, the climate of the Greek islands is a major draw for
tourists from northern Europe and, therefore, can be considered a component of the tourist
product. On the other hand, visitors of London also experience the weather, but most don’t gain
any satisfaction from the rain and cold typical for this city. Therefore, the climate of London
cannot be considered a component of the tourist product.
The literature review and analysis has revealed six different approaches to the classification
of the tourist product’s components. Different criteria are used to group the numerous
components into separate categories:
i. Purpose of creation: Components created for a purpose not related to tourism
are classified as primary tourist supply (such as natural attractions and
historic sites); components created especially for satisfying tourist needs are
classified as secondary tourist supply (such as hotels and theme parks
Krippendorf, 1971:19; Kaspar, 1991:64; Mrnjavac, 1992:117).
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
12
ii. Origin: Man-made elements vs. natural elements (Jaenecke, 1955:2;
Hanrieder, 1992:399; Mill and Morrison 1992:375).
iii. Tangibility: Tangible elements such as hotels and restaurant vs. intangible
elements such as the history and the climate of the destination (Zolles et al.,
1981:44).
iv. Variability: Invariable elements such as the climate and the scenery of the
destination vs. variable elements such as the infrastructure and the transport
services of the destination (Paul, 1977:16).
v. Time of consumption: Components are classified according to the phase of the
trip during which they are consumed: (1) planning or anticipation, (2) travel to
the destination, (3) destination activities, (4) travel back home, (5) recollection
(Taylor, 1980:57).
vi. Functional role: Components attracting tourists to the destination are classified
as primary tourist supply or as attractions (the “primary causal elements”);
components facilitating the travel and stay at the destination are classified as
secondary tourist supply or as amenities or as facilitators (among others
Medlik and Middleton, 1973:132; Coltman, 1989:80; Gunn, 1993:769).
The comparative analysis of these approaches has revealed several methodological
problems in their application and has indicated that the most suitable classification criterion from
a marketing point of view is the functional role of the components (Koutoulas, 2001:396). This
criterion can be used (1) to understand why an element is a component of the tourist product and
(2) to classify components in distinct categories.
Some of the reviewed authors split the two basic categories attractions and amenities
in several subcategories. The classification adopted in this paper is the most extensive of the ones
found in the literature with a total of seven subcategories, as it assigns each function of the tourist
product with the corresponding component category (Koutoulas, 2001:397). More specifically,
the tourist product performs six distinct functions (Koutoulas, 2001:475):
It enables the tourist to engage in the main activity of his/her trip.
It allows the tourist to engage in this activity and to live the total travel experience
the way he/she wants.
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
13
It facilitates the transport to and from the destination as well as within the
destination.
It facilitates the tourist’s social reproduction during the trip.
It facilitates the preparation and execution of the travel arrangements.
It allows the tourist to remember and relive the trip and to share his/her travel
experience with other people.
The social reproduction of tourists during their trip means satisfying their daily biological
and social needs according to their usual standard of living at their place of residence (Koutoulas,
2001:253). According to Leiper (1990:96), “tourists, as temporary visitors in a region for at least
one overnight stay, require life support systems: shelter from the environment, somewhere to
sleep, food and drink and, in most cases, require some sort of comfortable amenities
corresponding to their individual preferences while at leisure.”
In accordance with the above functions, the following component categories are defined
(Koutoulas, 2001:476; see also Figure 3):
a. The Primary Tourist Supply includes all the attractions that draw the tourists
to a destination. The benefits offered by the attractions satisfy the primary
tourist needs, i.e. those needs that urge a person to make a tourist trip in order
to satisfy them.
a.1. Means and conditions for engaging in the main activity of the trip at the
destination or inside the mode of transportation (as in the case of cruise
ships and luxury overnight trains): natural conditions, natural and cultural
heritage, people, socio-economic conditions of the destination, artistic
creation, events, facilities, equipment, goods and service related to the
main activity.
a.2. Qualitative aspects defining HOW the tourist wants to engage in the main
activity and to live the total travel experience: e.g. familiar or exotic
destination; short or long distance between the place of residence and the
destination; luxurious or traditional ambience, the particular character of
the destination; hospitable attitude of the local population; good weather;
protected natural environment, secure environment etc.
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
14
b. The Secondary Tourist Supply includes all the amenities needed by a tourist
to visit a destination and to consume its attractions (Geigant, 1962:114). It also
includes souvenirs and gifts of all kind. The benefits offered by the amenities
satisfy the secondary or derived tourist needs, i.e. those needs arising from the
decision to make a tourist trip.
b.1. Modes of transportation and other components of the transportation
systems: transition from the place of residence to the destination and back
as well as within the destination.
b.2. Means for the tourist’s social reproduction during the trip: elements
performing household functions as well as allowing the tourist to engage
in leisure activities, to communicate with other places, to socialise and to
stay informed. This category includes accommodation, food and beverage
outlets and/or shops selling food, public restrooms (outside the
accommodation), cleaners, hairdressers, telecommunication services,
postal services, sports and other leisure facilities, cultural events, retail
outlets (for recreational shopping) etc.
b.3. Several aspects regarding the preparation and execution of the travel
arrangements in regard to making the trip easier, safer and more
affordable, to prevent or to heal injuries and sickness, to enter a foreign
country, to finance the travel expenses, to make prior payments etc. This
category includes all means of tourist information (travel guidebooks,
maps, national tourist organisations, travel-related websites, local tourist
offices etc.); telecommunications; services provided by tour operators,
travel agencies, escorts, translators, certified travel guides and porters;
vaccines, sun protection, medicine and healthcare services; passports and
visas; travel insurance; credit cards and other financial services; as well as
numerous goods such as suitcases, clothes, photo cameras and films etc.
b.4. Practical aspects of engaging in the main activity of the trip. These
aspects do not constitute attractions but merely support the tourist in
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
15
engaging in the activity (e.g. sale or rental of sports equipment, lessons by
sports instructors, sports apparel etc.).
b.5. Souvenirs and gifts, usually bearing sentimental and symbolic values for
the tourists. They allow tourists to remember and relive their experiences,
thus prolonging the pleasure of the trip. They are also used for sharing the
travel experience and for strengthening the ties with other people (both at
the place of origin and at the destination). Souvenirs and gifts include a
vast range of goods such as typical products of the destination or the
place of origin as well as items found or made by the tourist or
received as a gift.
It should be noted that the same component may have two or even more functional roles.
For instance, a famous hotel may be an attraction in itself and not just a substitute for the tourist’s
household. In addition, the very same component can have a different functional role for different
people as shown in the following example: Theatre buffs may come to Greece just for attending a
performance of ancient drama, whereas people visiting Greece for another purpose let’s say
for attending a conference may see this performance just as a way to spend the evening.
Epilogue
Understanding the tourist product is a prerequisite for effectively marketing a destination or
a tourist business. It is also a useful tool for every social scientist analysing the phenomenon of
tourism.
Unfortunately, the discussion carried out during the last decades has not resulted in a
broader agreement among scientists in regard to the meaning of the tourist product and its
components. There are many incompatible approaches that cover only some of the aspects related
to the product. With this in mind, the definitions and principles formulated in this paper after an
extensive review and analysis of tourism literature attempt to bridge the theoretical deficit of
tourism marketing (Freyer, 1999:35) on this particular issue.
The proposed definition of the tourist product represents a benefit-oriented approach as
required by marketing theory. It is based on the distinction of the primary from the secondary
tourist needs that also explains the complex nature of the product. The definition also stresses the
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
16
experiential nature of the tourist product and highlights some peculiarities relevant to tourism,
such as the temporal and spatial dimension of the product.
The approach to this complex product form would not be complete without determining its
components. Therefore, a classification system is proposed that allows to characterise an item as
a component of the product and to assign it to the appropriate category according to its functional
role.
The classification covers everything a tourist spends money for. It also includes those
elements that do not result in any expenditure for the tourist such as beaches and freely
accessible heritage sites as well as tourist information services but that may create costs for
authorities at the destination.
Literature
Ashworth, Gregory and Henk Voogd (1990), “Can places be sold for tourism?”, in Ashworth,
Gregory and Brian Goodall (eds.), Marketing tourism places, Routledge, London
Burkart, A.J. and Slavoj Medlik (1981), “Tourism: Past, Present and Future,” 2nd ed.,
Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford
Burkheiser, Uwe (1969), “Das Produkt als Bestimmungsfaktor der Absatzpolitik: Ein Versuch
zur Weiterentwicklung der Absatztheorie,” Dissertation, Verlag Harri Deutsch, Frankfurt/M. &
Zürich
Coltman, Michael M. (1989), “Tourism Marketing,” Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York
Cullen, Peter (1989), “Tangibility of the intangible travel product,” in Witt, Stephen F. and Luiz
Moutinho (eds.), Tourism Marketing and Management Handbook, Prentice Hall, Hemel
Hempstead
Freyer, Walter (1993), “Tourismus: Einführung in die Fremdenverkehrsökonomie,” 4. Auflage,
R. Oldenbourg Verlag, München & Wien
Freyer, Walter (1999), “Tourismus-Marketing: Marktorientiertes Management im Mikro- und
Makrobereich der Tourismuswirtschaft,” 2. Auflage, R. Oldenbourg Verlag, München & Wien
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
17
Geigant, Friedrich (1962), “Die Standorte des Fremdenverkehrs: Eine sozialökonomische Studie
über die Bedingungen und Formen der räumlichen Entfaltung des Fremdenverkehrs,” Deutsches
Wirtschaftswissenschaftliches Institut für Fremdenverkehr (DWIF) an der Universität München,
München
Gunn, Clare A. (1993), “Tourism Infrastructure and Development,” in Khan, Mahmood A.,
Michael D. Olsen and Turgut Var (eds.), VNR’s Encyclopedia of Hospitality and Tourism, Van
Nostrand Reinhold, New York
Hanrieder, Manfred (1992), “Checkliste zur Situations-Analyse im Touristik-Marketing,” in
Roth, Peter und Axel Schrand (Hrsg.), Touristik-Marketing: Das Marketing der Tourismus-
Organisationen, Verkehrsträger, Reiseveranstalter und Reisebüros,Verlag Franz Vahlen,
München
Heath, Ernie and Geoffrey Wall (1992), “Marketing Tourism Destinations: A Strategic Planning
Approach,” John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York
Jaenecke, Klaus (1955), “Die Saisonabhängigkeit des Fremdenverkehrs in den Seebädern,”
Institut für Fremdenverkehrswirtschaft an der Johann Wolfgang Goethe-Universität Frankfurt a.
M., Frankfurt
Jeffries, David J. (1971), “Defining the Tourist Product - and its Importance in Tourism
Marketing,” Revue de Tourisme, No. 1, pp. 2-5
Jovicic, Zivodin (1988), “A Plea for Tourismological Theory and Methodology,” Revue de
Tourisme, No. 3, pp. 2-5
Kaspar, Claude (1991), “Die Tourismuslehre im Grundriß,” 4. Auflage, Verlag Paul Haupt, Bern
& Stuttgart
Koutoulas, Dimitris (2001), “The Theoretical Determination of the Tourist Product as a
Presupposition for Tourism Marketing”, doctoral dissertation, University of the Aegean, Chios
[in Greek]
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
18
Krippendorf, Jost (1971), “Marketing im Fremdenverkehr,” Herbert Lang & Cie AG, Bern &
Frankfurt
Leiper, Neil (1990), “Tourism Systems: An Interdisciplinary Approach,” Occasional Paper No. 2,
Massey University-Business Studies Faculty, Palmerston North, New Zealand
Levitt, Theodore (1969), “Improving Sales Through Product Augmentation,” European Business,
No. 21, pp. 5-12
Medlik, Slavoj and Victor T.C. Middleton (1973), “The Tourist Product and its Marketing
Implications,” International Tourism Quarterly, No. 3. Reprinted in Burkart, A.J. and Slavoj
Medlik (eds.) (1975), “The Management of Tourism,” Heinemann, London
Menges, Günter (1973), “Tourism Marketing Decisions,” in AIEST, Tourisme et Marketing:
Rapports présentés au 23e Congrès de l’AIEST, Editions Gurten, Berne
Middleton, Victor T.C. (1988), “Marketing in Travel and Tourism,” Heinemann Professional
Publishing, Oxford
Middleton, Victor T.C. (1989), “Tourist product,” in Witt, Stephen F. and Luiz Moutinho (eds.),
Tourism Marketing and Management Handbook, Prentice Hall, Hemel Hempstead
Mill, Robert Christie and Alastair M. Morrison (1992), “The Tourism System: An Introductory
Text,” 2nd ed., Prentice-Hall International, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
Mrnjavac, Zeljko (1992), “Defining Tourist Product,” Acta Turistica, Vol. 4, No. 2, pp. 114-124
Paul, Hermann (1977), “Marketing für Fremdenverkehr: Leitlinien für die Dienstleistungs- und
Absatzpolitik im Herstellerbereich der Fremdenverkehrswirtschaft,” RKW Rationalisierungs-
Kuratorium der Deutschen Wirtschaft, Frankfurt
Scheuch, Fritz (1982), “Dienstleistungsmarketing,” Verlag Franz Vahlen, München
Scheuch, Fritz (1993), “Marketing,” 4. Auflage, Verlag Franz Vahlen, München
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
19
Spatt, Ernst (1975), “Allgemeine Fremdenverkehrslehre: Grundlagen und wirtschaftliche
Aufgaben,” Inn-Verlag, Innsbruck
Taylor, Gordon D. (1980), “How to match plant with demand: a matrix for marketing,”
International Journal of Tourism Management, Vol. 1, No. 1, pp. 56-60
Tietz, Bruno (1980), “Handbuch der Tourismuswirtschaft,” Verlag Moderne Industrie, München
Walterspiel, Georg (1956), “Grundlagen der Betriebswirtschaftslehre des Fremdenverkehrs: Teil
I”, in Rößle, Karl und Bernhard Pfister (Hrsg.), Jahrbuch für Fremdenverkehr, 4. Jahrgang, Heft
2, Deutsches Wirtschaftswissenschaftliches Institut für Fremdenverkehr (DWIF) an der
Universität München, München
Zolles, Helmut, Fritz-Karl Ferner und Robert Müller (1981), “Marketingpraxis für den
Fremdenverkehr,” 2. Auflage, Orac Pietsch, Wien
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
20
Figure 1: Relations between the Subjects and the Objects of Tourism Marketing (simplified
depiction)
Source: Koutoulas, Dimitris (2001), “The Theoretical Determination of the Tourist Product as a
Presupposition for Tourism Marketing”, doctoral dissertation, University of the Aegean, Chios, p.
474 [in Greek]
Tourists
Collective Organisations
Representing Businesses
and/or Destinations
Tourist Businesses
Products
(Need Sa-
tisfiers)
Money
Needs
Objects of Tourism Marketing
Demand
Supply
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
21
Figure 2: External Factors Influencing A Tourist’s Travel Experience
Source: Koutoulas, Dimitris (2001), “The Theoretical Determination of the Tourist Product as a
Presupposition for Tourism Marketing”, doctoral dissertation, University of the Aegean, Chios, p.
479 [in Greek]
Infrastructure Used by Tourist Enterprises and Tourists
Components of the Tourist Product
TRAVEL
EXPERIENCE
OF A TOURIST
Environmental Factors of the Destination and the Transit
Areas:
Natural factors (e.g. geographical position, climate,
condition of the natural environment, threat by natural
forces such as typhoons and earthquakes)
People:
Personnel of tourist businesses
Other consumers or users (tourists, locals)
Local population
Man-made factors (e.g. architectural features of the
destination)
Social characteristics of the destination (e.g. political
stability, economic development, public health and security)
Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product
22
Figure 3: Components of the Tourist Product Classified According to their Functional Role
Source: Koutoulas, Dimitris (2001), “The Theoretical Determination of the Tourist Product as a
Presupposition for Tourism Marketing”, doctoral dissertation, University of the Aegean, Chios, p.
429 [in Greek]
Components of the Tourist Product
(classified according to their functional role)
a. Primary Tourist Supply
(Attractions)
b. Secondary Tourist Supply
(Amenities)
a.1. Means and conditions
for engaging in the main
activity of the trip at the
destination or inside the
mode of transportation
a.2. Qualitative aspects
defining HOW the tourist
wants to engage in the main
activity and to live the total
travel experience
b.1. Modes of
transportation and other
components of the
transportation systems
b.2. Means for the tourist’s
social reproduction during
the trip
b.3. Several aspects
regarding the preparation
and execution of the travel
arrangements
b.4. Practical aspects of
engaging in the main
activity of the trip
b.5. Souvenirs and gifts
... All tourists opt for a "package" purchased either separately or as an inclusive tour (Medlik and Middleton 1975). Figure 1 outlines the interrelationship between tourists' needs and elements or components of a composite total tourism product (based on Jovicic 1988;Koutoulas 2004). ...
... The numerous components of tourism products can also be classified in different ways (Koutoulas 2004). According to their functional role, components corresponding to the primary tourist supply represent a destination's attractions. ...
Chapter
Full-text available
CITATION: Koutoulas, D. (2024). Products. In: Jafari, J., Xiao, H. (eds) Encyclopedia of Tourism. Springer, Cham. 824-826. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-74923-1_293. ABSTRACT: This encyclopaedia entry includes a definition of the tourism product in relation to the primary and secondary needs of tourists. With the tourism product being a composite product comprising numerous components, the text proposes a functional classification, which directly connects product components with the needs they satisfy. Primary needs can be considered as “push factors” explaining a person’s desire to leave their place of residence. These are fulfilled by the attractions of a destination which represent the “pull factors” and explain destination choice. On the other hand, tourists’ secondary needs, which arise during travel, can be satisfied through the destination’s amenities.
... All tourists opt for a "package" purchased either separately or as an inclusive tour (Medlik and Middleton 1975). Figure 1 outlines the interrelationship between tourists' needs and elements or components of a composite total tourism product (based on Jovicic 1988;Koutoulas 2004). ...
... The numerous components of tourism products can also be classified in different ways (Koutoulas 2004). According to their functional role, components corresponding to the primary tourist supply represent a destination's attractions. ...
Chapter
Full-text available
Citation: Koutoulas, D. (2024). Products – Tourism. In: Jafari, J., Xiao, H. (eds) Encyclopedia of Tourism. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-01669-6_293-2. ABSTRACT: This encyclopaedia entry includes a definition of the tourism product in relation to the primary and secondary needs of tourists. With the tourism product being a composite product comprising numerous components, the text proposes a functional classification, which directly connects product components with the needs they satisfy. Primary needs can be considered as “push factors” explaining a person’s desire to leave their place of residence. These are fulfilled by the attractions of a destination which represent the “pull factors” and explain destination choice. On the other hand, tourists’ secondary needs, which arise during travel, can be satisfied through the destination’s amenities.
... (Sofronov, 2018). Tourist products can be synonymous to the total travel experience including the tangible and intangible components of the trip (Koutoulas, 2015). ...
Article
Full-text available
The main purpose of the study is to analyze the gap of tourists’ expectations and satisfaction on a Farm Tourism in Bulacan using the five dimensions of SERVQUAL. The 219 respondents were tourists of the farm and they were conveniently selected. Data were further subjected to ANOVA and T – test analysis via SPSS. Findings revealed that the majority of the respondents belong to the Gen Z individuals. With a gap of 0.15, it was determined that the farm tourism site provides the appropriate level of quality service in terms of tangibility, responsiveness, reliability, assurance, and empathy. The result shows that farm tourism manages to exceed the set expectation level of the tourist in their service quality based on gap from their satisfaction level. Moreover, the tourist gap was significantly equal for both male and female respondents. The total satisfaction is significantly higher compared to their total expectation with a mean difference of 0.16 in favor of the satisfaction level. The null hypothesis was rejected and concluded the gap between tourist’ expectation and satisfaction on the farm tourism service quality when they are grouped according to profile are significantly equal
... Populasi yang diambil dalam penelitian ini adalah karyawan UMKM sektor pariwisata Provinsi Bali. Dalam penelitian ini metode sampling yang dipakai adalah purposive sampling yang didasar oleh teori Koutoulas (2015) yang mengkalisifikasikan produk pariwisata menjadi 6 tipe yaitu: Convenience tourism product, Shopping tourism product, Specialty tourism product, Unsought tourism product, Industrial tourism product, Capital item. Terdapat 2 kelompok responden utama dalam penelitian ini yaitu karyawan Pasar Seni Merta Nadi Legian dan anggota HIPMI Kota Denpasar dengan total responden sebanyak 52 orang. ...
Article
Full-text available
The objective of this research is to identify the effects of job stress and leadership on the performance of micro, small, and medium-sized tourism enterprise’s employees in Bali Province. This quantitative explanatory study focuses on explaining the relationship between job stress (X1), leadership (X2), and employee performance (Y). Using purposive sampling technique, 52 employees of tourism-sector businesses were selected as the respondents, to whom questionnaires were distributed to harvest the required data. The research instruments were assessed using validity and reliability tests. Here the classical assumption test and the multiple linear regression were performed in SPSS version 20. This study finds that job stress negatively and significantly influences employee performance and that leadership positively and significantly affects employee performance. These facts indicate that an increase in job stress can reduce employee performance and that upgrades in leadership enhance employee performance in the context of tourism enterprises in Bali Province.
... These multiple meanings of erratic boulders are used in geotourism, i.e., nature tourism aimed at promoting geosciences and, in parallel, the conservation of geoheritage (e.g., [55][56][57][58]. As a branch of cognitive tourism, geotourism makes use of the results of basic geology research for practical purposes, such as the creation of a new tourism product [59][60][61][62]. It also recognises historical sites that show a close relationship with geology. ...
Article
Full-text available
In north-western Poland, cultural and historical structures were erected using erratic boulders of Scandinavian origin. These structures have yet to be subjected to detailed analysis with the aim of determining their origin, type of erratic boulders and rock abundance of a given petrographic type. This topic has not been addressed by art historians in previous studies of similar structures. The objective of this paper is to present five illustrative examples of stone structures that are closely related to cultural heritage in north-western Poland. A comprehensive inventory of the stone material is presented, categorised according to petrographic types. This is accompanied by a guide to the erratics. Furthermore, this article addresses the principles of geoethics and the concept of sense of place, with the objective of fostering a sense of pride in cultural heritage among residents and viewers. The objective was to identify the current and potential future geosystem services that erratic boulders can provide at the aforementioned locations. The survey methods were non-intrusive and included a comprehensive analysis of the stone material at eye level. Furthermore, in addition to graphic and photographic archiving, the petrographic type of rock and the type of indicative erratics were identified in carefully designed test fields. The results were subjected to basic statistical calculations. The results obtained represent a new corpus of knowledge that can be employed in the sustainable development of the five regions through the utilisation of a tool such as geotourism. It is anticipated that the implementation of innovative initiatives aimed at fostering geoenvironmental awareness and providing educational benefits, such as disseminating knowledge about the petrography and history of the sites (including the evolution of stone workshops and techniques), the role of historic buildings in strengthening attachment to roots, and their promotion in the media and on the internet, will result in the attraction of a more diverse group of tourists with interests beyond the current tourist and recreational offerings.
... The criteria set for digital benchmarking and the respective website features of the tourism and the information about related activities covers 7 topics with 38 attributive criteria (Table 3); this reflects, first, the availability and, second, the detail of presentation of the necessary information. The marketing conceptualization of a tourist product and its components [42][43][44], refracted through the features of natural heritage-based tourism, has theoretically influenced the construction of this subsystem. The seven thematic areas, adopted in the present study, prove to be the most common and adequately represent the basic global trends and practices in this area. ...
Article
Full-text available
The need for a closer and enhanced connection with nature, as the basis for human wellbeing, reinforces the importance of natural heritage governance, including wider and much improved access to information about nature-based tourism and recreation. This research seeks to reveal how Internet content can support the digital identification of nature sites and their branding as tourist destinations. To this end, it analyzes 20 exemplary websites, each known around the world, and highlights important current trends in the structuring and attractiveness of the information provided. Based on the devised benchmarking criteria, the study develops a benchmarking approach that improves digital “packaging” and marketing of natural heritage for the purposes of tourism, recreation, leisure, and sports, and then tests it in Bulgaria. The procedure includes the selection of 57 natural heritage sites and rating the content of their official websites. The results show an unsatisfactory level of representation of the heritage value of the Bulgarian NH and a severe depreciation of the provision of the necessary tourism and recreation information, in comparison to the selected global benchmark. Besides the outline of the most frequent gaps and shortcomings, the results provide managers with suggestions about the development of a “natural heritage” brand for tourism and recreation, which features amplification of site identity and messaging, plus enhancement of its visibility. The conclusions are applicable to a wide variety of geographical contexts and audiences in nature-based destination governance.
Article
Full-text available
The study examined Rwanda's innovative marketing strategies and its influence on tourism development. The study used a sample size of 123 respondents mainly from Rwanda Development Board (RDB), tour operators, tourists, park officials and transport officers who were conveniently and purposively selected in accordance to their availability and willingness to participate in the study. The major findings revealed that Rwanda has existing traditional marketing strategies. However, given their performance, they are not as effective as they are supposed to be. In a bit to attract more tourists, RDB introduced new innovative marketing designs which can capture the attention and the mind of the visitor. This is in agreement with Morgan and Pitchard (2000) who stated and argued that the battle for customers in the tourism industry will be fought not over price but over the hearts and minds, thus, RDB introduced Kwita Izina ceremony, diplomats country tour, partnerships with European football clubs, product innovation, MICE tourism, doubling gorilla price, improving service standards, and biodiversity conservation. This has increased visitor arrivals hence, tourism growth in terms of sales revenue, private sector investment, increased FDI in tourism sector among others. The study recommends more allocation of funds for the effective global marketing, particularly with a mix of both private and public efforts.
Article
Full-text available
The study employs a pragmatic approach to comprehend the constructed environment as a means for propelling tourism industries. Various relevant works of literature are taken into account in analyzing the impact of the constructed environment and its significance to tourism. The objectives of the study are twofold. First, it reviews the constructed environment in detail considering it in three subsets. These are the frame; sustenance; and nature. Second, it analyzes the global status of the constructed environment concerning tourism development. The study highlights the research lacuna to draw convincing conclusions about why the constructed environment signifies the growth of the sector. The key takeaway point from the study is the earnest need for a developed constructed environment for development of the industries. The study concludes with suggestive notes to various stakeholders to be conscious enough in understanding tourist psychology, policymaking, and resource management; which will result in economic vitality.
Chapter
Full-text available
Capital structure can put pressure on firms to change their level of competitive intensity in an industry. The availability of debt and equity finance may have a significant effect on competitive strategies of the firm such as differentiation and cost leadership. This study contends that financial policies can create bargaining pressure on firms to either dampen competitive rivalry or increase the threat of new entrants. This study is the first to investigate the role of capital structure on firms’ competitive strategies in Bangladesh. The study examines the role of capital structure on the link between competitive strategies and financial performance of firms in the tourism destination of Bangladesh. It further examines the nexus between differentiation strategy and capital structure, and the relationship between cost leadership strategy and capital structure. The study employs a panel regression estimation technique to analyze the sample data of 85 listed firms in Bangladesh for the period 2007-2018. Findings reveal that capital structure favors cost leadership strategy over differentiation strategy. The moderating effects of capital structure show the relationship between cost leadership and financial performance is stronger when firms use long-term debt and short-term debt while the link between differentiation strategy and financial performance is stronger when firms use total debt and equity finance. This study provides a new model for sustaining competitive strategy through capital structure theoretically and for tourism policymakers. Keywords: competitive strategy, capital structure, tourism, Bangladesh
Article
Some will perhaps continue to dispute tourismology as a science but there is no doubt that it will find its full assertion in the near future.
Article
Who are those principally engaged in marketing any commodity? They are the specialists in market research, in publicity, in public relations, in sales and in physical distribution and they have this in common: that they communicate with the consumer. Their role is two-fold, before and after production.
Article
Despite the intangibility of its final product, tourism can usefully be analysed in terms of plant and output. The author describes the five phases of any trip and introduces the supply - demand matrix. In, say, the marketing and planning of new tours the matrix aids the optimum use of existing assets, the identification of market segments and, ultimately, leads to an increase in final output, ie costumer satisfaction.
Article
4., überarb. und erg. Aufl Bibliogr. na konci kapitol
Marketing tourism places, Das Dissertation Tourism Marketing Tangibility of the intangible travel product Tourismus: Einführung in die Fremdenverkehrsökonomie
  • Gregory Ashworth
  • Henk Voogd Routledge
  • London Burkart
  • Slavoj Medlik
Ashworth, Gregory and Henk Voogd (1990), " Can places be sold for tourism? ", in Ashworth, Gregory and Brian Goodall (eds.), Marketing tourism places, Routledge, London Burkart, A.J. and Slavoj Medlik (1981), " Tourism: Past, Present and Future, " 2nd ed., Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford Burkheiser, Uwe (1969), " Das Produkt als Bestimmungsfaktor der Absatzpolitik: Ein Versuch zur Weiterentwicklung der Absatztheorie, " Dissertation, Verlag Harri Deutsch, Frankfurt/M. & Zürich Coltman, Michael M. (1989), " Tourism Marketing, " Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York Cullen, Peter (1989), " Tangibility of the intangible travel product, " in Witt, Stephen F. and Luiz Moutinho (eds.), Tourism Marketing and Management Handbook, Prentice Hall, Hemel Hempstead Freyer, Walter (1993), " Tourismus: Einführung in die Fremdenverkehrsökonomie, " 4. Auflage, R. Oldenbourg Verlag, München & Wien Freyer, Walter (1999), " Tourismus-Marketing: Marktorientiertes Management im Mikro-und Makrobereich der Tourismuswirtschaft, " 2. Auflage, R. Oldenbourg Verlag, München & Wien Dr. Dimitris Koutoulas Understanding the Tourist Product 17
Die Standorte des Fremdenverkehrs: Eine sozialökonomische Studie über die Bedingungen und Formen der räumlichen Entfaltung des Fremdenverkehrs
  • Friedrich Geigant
Geigant, Friedrich (1962), "Die Standorte des Fremdenverkehrs: Eine sozialökonomische Studie über die Bedingungen und Formen der räumlichen Entfaltung des Fremdenverkehrs," Deutsches Wirtschaftswissenschaftliches Institut für Fremdenverkehr (DWIF) an der Universität München, München
Checkliste zur Situations-Analyse im Touristik-Marketing
  • Manfred Hanrieder
Hanrieder, Manfred (1992), "Checkliste zur Situations-Analyse im Touristik-Marketing," in
Die Saisonabhängigkeit des Fremdenverkehrs in den Seebädern
  • Klaus Jaenecke
Jaenecke, Klaus (1955), " Die Saisonabhängigkeit des Fremdenverkehrs in den Seebädern, "