ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

Ophioplocus januarii is a common brittle star on soft and hard substrates along the Argentinian and Brazilian coasts. Based on stomach contents, tooth microstructure and field observations we identified its food. Opposed to previous suggestions, O. januarii appears to be a microphagous species feeding on macroalgal fragments (found in 60.0 % of the analyzed stomachs with content), plant debris (28.0 %), animal cuticle structures (13.0 %), and unidentifiable material (30.7 %). Less frequent items found were foraminiferans, ostracods, an amphipod, a juvenile bivalve, and other crustaceans. Electronic microscope revealed digested material, diatoms and small crustacean appendices. Thus, O. januarii is an omnivorous species, feeding mainly on algae, complemented opportunistically with other items. Suspension feeding was observed in the field. It has an fenestrated arrangement intermediate between the previously described uniform and compound teeth. Rev. Biol. Trop. 63 (Suppl. 2): 353-360. Epub 2015 June 01.
Content may be subject to copyright.
353
Rev. Biol. Trop. (Int. J. Trop. Biol. ISSN-0034-7744) Vol. 63 (Suppl. 2): 353-360, June 2015
Tooth microstructure and feeding biology of the brittle star
Ophioplocus januarii (Echinodermata: Ophiuroidea)
from northern Patagonia, Argentina
Martín I. Brogger1,2, Mariano I. Martinez2, María Pilar Cadierno3 & Pablo E. Penchaszadeh2
1. Laboratorio de Reproducción y Biología Integrativa de Invertebrados Marinos, CENPAT-CONICET, Blvd. Brown
2915, Puerto Madryn, Argentina; brogger@cenpat-conicet.gob.ar, mbrogger@bg.fcen.uba.ar
2. Laboratorio de Ecosistemas Costeros, MACN-CONICET, Av. Ángel Gallardo 470, Buenos Aires, Argentina; mmarti-
nez@macn.gov.ar, pablopench@gmail.com
3. Instituto de Investigaciones Bioquímicas de La Plata, UNLP-CONICET, Avenida 60 y 120, La Plata, Argentina; mpi-
larcadierno@yahoo.com.ar
Received 28-VII-2014. Corrected 10-X-2014. Accepted 20-XI-2014.
Abstract: Ophioplocus januarii is a common brittle star on soft and hard substrates along the Argentinian and
Brazilian coasts. Based on stomach contents, tooth microstructure and field observations we identified its food.
Opposed to previous suggestions, O. januarii appears to be a microphagous species feeding on macroalgal frag-
ments (found in 60.0 % of the analyzed stomachs with content), plant debris (28.0 %), animal cuticle structures
(13.0 %), and unidentifiable material (30.7 %). Less frequent items found were foraminiferans, ostracods, an
amphipod, a juvenile bivalve, and other crustaceans. Electronic microscope revealed digested material, diatoms
and small crustacean appendices. Thus, O. januarii is an omnivorous species, feeding mainly on algae, comple-
mented opportunistically with other items. Suspension feeding was observed in the field. It has an fenestrated
arrangement intermediate between the previously described uniform and compound teeth. Rev. Biol. Trop. 63
(Suppl. 2): 353-360. Epub 2015 June 01.
Key words: brittle star, stereom microstructure, stomach contents, Ophiolepididae, teeth.
Ophiuroids display diverse feeding strate-
gies, often combined, and ranging from preda-
tion and scavenging to deposit- and suspension
feeding (Warner, 1982; Harris et al., 2009).
Based on the size of the ingested particles,
Warner (1982) proposed the division between
macrophagous and microphagous species, with
the former acquiring large particles through
predation and scavenging while the latter
include suspension feeding and the acquisi-
tion of small particles from the substratum.
Some species exhibit high degrees of flex-
ibility in their feeding mechanisms and their
prey spectra (Fontaine, 1965; Warner, 1982),
and it has been proposed that for both, shal-
low water and deep-sea species, differences in
diets between species also reflect differences in
lifestyles. Hereby they may act as non-special-
ized opportunists with respect to diet (Pearson
& Gage, 1984).
Information available on the diet of brittle
stars has been established through field obser-
vations estimating the feeding preferences by
the observed feeding behavior (Warner, 1982),
or by stomach content analyses (Harris et al.,
2009). Depending on their behavior it is pos-
sible to identify active predators or suspension-
feeding species (Davoult & Gounin, 1995),
while is difficult to directly observe those
species that feed on deposited material from
the sediment surface or beneath it (Gielazyn et
al., 1999). Prey items that are found in stomach
content studies allow for the identification of
an ophiuroid being microphagous, but also
354
Rev. Biol. Trop. (Int. J. Trop. Biol. ISSN-0034-7744) Vol. 63 (Suppl. 2): 353-360, June 2015
for the general source of the respective food
particles: planktonic prey items suggest a filter
feeding mode on water-borne items, whereas
considerable amounts of sediment may indicate
a surface- or subsurface deposit feeding mode
(Ferrari & Dearborn, 1989; Dahm, 1999). A
third approximation of brittle star feeding pref-
erences is relatively poorly developed and is
based on the analysis of the stereom microstruc-
ture of the teeth (i.e. how calcite is arranged or
disposed in the teeth). Medeiros-Bergen (1996)
analyzed the stereom microstructure of teeth
from several ophiuroid species using light and
scanning electron microscopy. She defined
two tooth types: a uniform teeth, in which the
tooth stereom is completely fenestrated, and
compound teeth, where the base of the tooth is
fenestrated, while the distal edge is composed
of imperforated calcite. With a few exceptions,
macrophagous feeders possess uniform teeth,
while microphagous species reveal compound
teeth (Medeiros-Bergen, 1996).
The brittle star Ophioplocus januarii (Lüt-
ken, 1856) (Ophiolepididae) is distributed
along the Western Atlantic coast from Golfo
Nuevo, Argentina, to northern Brazil, with a
doubtful record from Barbados (Thomas, 1975;
Bernasconi & D’Agostino, 1977). It is found
from the tidal zones down to 74 meters depth,
both on hard substrates and on soft sediments
rich in detritus (Bartsch, 1982). To date very
little is known about the feeding biology of O.
januarii (Brogger et al., 2013). Bartsch (1982)
analyzed stomach contents of some individuals
finding only sediment grains. Medeiros-Bergen
(1996) observed the microstructure of the teeth
of O. januarii under a light microscope and
described it as completely fenestrated, similar
to those teeth she observed in Ophioplocus
esmarki Lyman, 1874 with the scanning elec-
tron microscope.
Here we report on the diet of O. janu-
arii and discuss its feeding biology based
on stomach content analysis, feeding mecha-
nisms observed in the field, and tooth stereom
microstructure analysis using scanning electron
microscopy. For comparison, we also describe
and discuss the microstructure of the teeth of
other brittle stars species and their relations to
the respective feeding habits.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Ophioplocus januarii were collected
monthly from Playa Villarino (42º 24’ S - 64º
17’ W), Golfo San José (northern Patagonia),
from April 2005 to April 2007 comprising a
total of 25 consecutively taken samples. Dur-
ing each sampling event, the specimens were
captured from the same location by SCUBA
diving at depths between 2 and 7 m (depending
on the tides) and collected in plastic bags. At
the laboratory, they were fixed in Bouin’s solu-
tion for 24 h and then preserved in 70 % etha-
nol. When individual remaining particles were
found in the collection bags they were also
preserved in 70% ethanol for later observation.
While sampling, brittle stars were observed and
photographed in situ in order to identify and
determine feeding activities. All sampling and
observations were conducted during daylight.
Stomach contents: The discs were cut
off along with the stomach lining, and the
contents picked out. Stomach contents of 10
brittle stars from each month (total N = 250)
were examined under the light microscope,
and all content items were separated. When at
least one item from a stomach was identified,
the respective brittle star was considered ‘with
stomach content’, including unidentifiable and/
or digested remains. Only those ophiuroids
without any stomach content were considered
‘empty’. Some portions of the unidentifiable or
digested remains were examined with the light
and scanning electronic microscope (SEM).
Tooth microstructure analysis: The jaws
of O. januarii were dissected and placed for
a few minutes in a diluted solution of com-
mercial house bleach in order to remove the
epidermal layer. Longer maceration allowed
for the dissociation of individual teeth from the
dental plates. In order to observe the internal
calcite microstructure, one tooth was fractured.
For comparative purposes, the jaws and teeth
355
Rev. Biol. Trop. (Int. J. Trop. Biol. ISSN-0034-7744) Vol. 63 (Suppl. 2): 353-360, June 2015
of five other brittle star species were examined
as well. These included Ophiomyxa vivipara,
Amphipholis squamata, Ophiactis asperula,
Ophiacantha vivipara and Ophiocten amiti-
num. All jaws and teeth were prepared for
SEM observations. At least 7 adult individuals
of each species were dissected during the tooth
microstructure analysis.
RESULTS
The remaining particles from the indi-
vidual collection bags resulted to be small shell
fragments mixed with algal fragments originat-
ing from the sediment. These particles were
similar to objects that are sometimes retained
or hooked by the ophiuroid’s arm spines and
other body parts. In no case there were signs of
these particles being egested stomach contents
from prior to the animals’ fixation.
Typical passive suspension-feeding activi-
ties were observed in the field. While feeding,
the individuals raised two or three arms into the
passing currents. Small particles were trapped
by the tube feet and collected into a bolus that
was passed down along the arm to the mouth.
Stomach contents: Of the 250 individuals
examined, 31.2 % had stomachs with contents.
Of these, 64.1 % presented only one food item,
and far lower percentages referred to stomachs
containing two to five different items (Table 1).
The most frequent item found corresponded to
macroalgal fragments, mainly from filamen-
tous algae. Food particle sizes were up to 0.5
mm with the exception of two larger structures:
a macroalgal fragment of 6.0 mm, and a cuticu-
lar structure of 7.5 mm. The average number of
food items was 1.64 per individual.
Macroalgal fragments were present in 60
% of the stomachs with contents, and in 64 %
of the studied months. Other frequent items
found were unidentifiable material (31%) and
small terrestrial plant debris (28 %). Less fre-
quent items were cuticular animal structures
(13%), unidentifiable laminar structures (8
%), spicules (4 %), three foraminiferans, three
ostracods, one amphipod, other crustaceans,
one juvenile bivalve and one hydrozoarian col-
ony. No sediment particles were found inside
the stomachs.
Tooth microstructure analysis: All teeth
in O. januarii revealed a fenestrated stereom
microstructure (Fig. 1). However, it was pos-
sible to clearly identify two distinct regions:
the basal parts of the teeth which are in contact
with the dental plate, are more loosely perfo-
rated than the distal parts. There the calcite
is much more compacted, presenting a clear
different arrangement (Fig. 1 A, B, C, D). This
superficial distinction is visible also internally
in the calcite microstructure as can be seen in a
fractured tooth (Fig. 1 F, G). The basal surface
presents little serrated edges, but at the distal
portion these edges are less prominent because
of the tightly packed calcite (Fig. 1 E).
Under light microscope, the teeth of Ophi-
omyxa vivipara presented translucent crys-
talline edges with small spines protruding
from the distal edges; they are semicircle in
shape and are perforated apart from the dis-
tally protruding spines (Fig. 2 A). The teeth of
Ophiacantha vivipara and Ophiocten amitinum
presented spine like shapes with uniform fenes-
trated surfaces and sharply serrated edges (Fig.
2 D, E). Amphipholis squamata carried teeth
with a fenestrated base, but distally the calcite
was imperforate (Fig. 2 B). The tooth stereom
microstructure of Ophiactis asperula is similar
to that described here for O. januarii, and con-
sisted of two regions with differentiated calcite
compactions (Fig. 2 C). The tooth types of the
TABLE 1
Total number of stomachs with content and percentage of
stomachs with distinguishable amounts of food item
Number Percentage
Stomachs analyzed 250
With contents 78 31.2
With one food item 50 64.1
With two food items 13 16.6
With three food items 9 11.5
With four food items 5 6.4
With five food items 1 1.3
356
Rev. Biol. Trop. (Int. J. Trop. Biol. ISSN-0034-7744) Vol. 63 (Suppl. 2): 353-360, June 2015
six species analyzed presently are summarized
in the Table 2.
DISCUSSION
In the present study, Ophioplocus januarii
from Playa Villarino fed ingesting small-sus-
pended particles through suspension feeding
from the water-sediment interface. Contrari-
ly to previously made assumptions (Warner,
1982; Medeiros-Bergen, 1996), O. januarii is a
microphagous species. It fed opportunistically,
mainly ingesting fragments of macroalgae,
but also small plant and animal structures,
and other suspended material. When analyzing
stomach contents from a 60 meters depth O.
januarii population collected in a nearby loca-
tion on the continental shelf (42° S - 62° W),
Bartsch (1982) observed stomachs lacking food
but filled partly with sediment grains. In the
present study, no sediments were found, sug-
gesting differences in feeding preferences to be
Fig. 1. Scanning electron microscopy images of teeth in Ophioplocus januarii. A) Dorsalmost tooth. B) Mid-positioned
tooth. C) Proximal view of dorsal teeth. D) Proximal view of ventral teeth. E) Detail of B, showing the different calcite
compaction. F) Fractured tooth. G) Detail of F, showing the internal differentiation in microstructure. I and II indicate
regions of more compaction (I) and more porosity (II) of the calcite, respectively. Scale bars: A, B, C, D = 200 μm; E, G
= 50 μm.
357
Rev. Biol. Trop. (Int. J. Trop. Biol. ISSN-0034-7744) Vol. 63 (Suppl. 2): 353-360, June 2015
dependent of habitat diversity. This was also
observed for different populations of Ophiura
ophiura (Blegvad, 1914 in Warner, 1982) and
of Ophionotus victoriae (Dearborn, 1977). The
main distinction between feeding types in
brittle stars used to be drawn between car-
nivory and microphagy (Warner, 1982). Those
species that capture large particles –typically of
animal origin– and, thus, feed as microphagous
feeders, are generally described as carnivorous,
while microphagous species feed on a mixture
of minute animal and vegetal material. The diet
presently observed for O. januarii indicates
that this species is an unselective omnivorous
species. Others also feeding mainly on vegetal
origin material are mostly associated with sedi-
ments. Ophionereis reticulata, for example,
has been indicated as exclusively herbivorous
TABLE 2
Tooth stereom microstructure for six analyzed ophiuroid species: uniform (completely fenestrated), compound
(fenestrated base and imperforate calcite tip) and intermediate (fenestrated with two distinct regions) tooth types
Species Family Source Tooth type
Ophioplocus januarii (Lütken, 1856) Ophiolepididae 42º 24’ S; 64º 17’ W (2 - 7 m) intermediate
Amphipholis squamata (Delle Chiaje, 1828) Amphiuridae 44º 53 ’S; 65 º40’ W (0 m) compound
Ophiacantha vivipara Ljungman, 1870 Ophiacanthidae 38º 51’ S; 55º 39’ W (115 m) uniform
Ophiactis asperula (Philippi, 1858) Ophiactidae 38º 51’ S; 55º 35’ W (145 m) intermediate
Ophiocten amitinum Lyman, 1878 Ophiuridae 38º 51’ S; 55º 35’ W (145 m) uniform
Ophiomyxa vivipara Studer, 1876 Ophiomyxidae 43º 36’ S; 60º 05’ W (96 m) uniform
Fig. 2. Scanning electron microscopy images of tooth stereom microstructure in different ophiuroid species (mid-positioned
teeth). A) Ophiomyxa vivipara. B) Amphipholis squamata. C) Ophiactis asperula. D) Ophiacantha vivipara. E) Ophiocten
amitinum. Scale bars: A, C, D = 200 μm; B, E = 100 μm.
358
Rev. Biol. Trop. (Int. J. Trop. Biol. ISSN-0034-7744) Vol. 63 (Suppl. 2): 353-360, June 2015
(May, 1925 in Warner, 1982) and more recently
as an omnivore with algal feeding preference
(Yokoyama & Amaral, 2008). Algal and cal-
careous fragments are the most frequent items
in the diets of Ophiocoma wenditii, O. echinata
and O. pumila (Sides & Woodley, 1985).
In stomach contents analyses conducted
with different species, the percentages of empty
stomachs found were highly variable between
the species. For example, Harris et al. (2009)
observed 66 % of empty stomachs in Ophiura
sarsii, Yokoyama and Amaral (2008) 23 % in
Ophionereis reticulata, Hendler (1982) found
variations from 100 to 5% with a dependence
of the months under study, and Hendler and
Miller (1984) observed differences in percent-
age for Asteroporpa annulata according to
whether the individuals were captured during
day or nighttime. In the present study, the per-
centage of empty stomachs in O. januarii was
close to 70 % and included only samples that
were collected during the daylight. The fact that
brittle stars may egest their stomach contents in
response to collecting procedure or handling
(Pearson & Gage, 1984; Hendler, pers. comm.),
could explain the high proportions of empty
stomach found in some deep-sea investigations
(Warner, 1982). This, however, does not seem
to be the case in the presently investigated O.
januarii because no egested material was found
when analyzing the collection bags.
The tooth stereom microstructure in O.
januarii is distinctly different from that in teeth
of macrophagous as well as microphagous spe-
cies (Fig. 1; Table 2). The presently found inter-
mediate fenestrated arrangement of the stereom
was also here observed for Ophiactis asperula,
and confirmed as such when analyzing the
teeth with the scanning electron microscope
(SEM). The fact that SEM reveals structures
which might remain disguised under the light
microscope could explain that Medeiros-Ber-
gen (1996) did not recognize differences in
the tooth microstructure between Ophioplocus
esmarki and O. januarii. Therefore, it is pos-
sible that other species previously described as
carrying uniform teeth (macrophagous) could,
in fact, possess intermediate tooth types. In
the present study we identified the intermedi-
ate tooth type, and the previously described
uniform and compound types. However, it
would be interesting to analyze additional
species in order to recognize other possible
variations in the tooth stereom microstructure
previously overlooked.
The present results observed for the diet
of O. januarii represent, to our knowledge,
the first trustworthy report of microphagy in
the family Ophiolepididae. Dietary studies
on Ophiolepis elegans suggested this spe-
cies to be a macrophagous species (Warner,
1982), while Medeiros-Bergen (1996), based
on tooth microstructure, estimated three Ophi-
oplocus species and Ophiolepis impressa to be
microphagous as well. Two other species from
the same family (Ophioplocus incipiens and
Ophiomusium lymani) are reported to conduct
suspension-feeding activities (Warner, 1982),
and little information about their diets is avail-
able. Pearson and Gage (1984) suggested O.
lymani to have an omnivorous diet. Because
there are no records of passive suspension feed-
ing in macrophagous species, it is likely that
both O. incipiens and O. lymani being repre-
sentatives of the Ophiolepididae, are micropha-
gous as well.
Much progress on the knowledge of the
diet of ophiuroids has been made since War-
ner’s summary in 1982. Yet, much is still
obscure. For example, the role that brittle stars
play in trophic transfers of nutrients with-
in benthic communities and between benthic
and pelagic communities still remains highly
unknown (Gielazyn et al., 1999). The utility of
analyzing teeth microstructure may surpass not
only knowledge on feeding habits and diet in
ophiuroids, but may also provide a helpful tool
for phylogenetic issues, most likely in combi-
nation with tooth macrostructure analyzes as
proposed by Stöhr (2005), and with studies on
jaw morphology already used by Murakami
(1963), Smith et al. (1995) and Stöhr and
Muths (2010).
359
Rev. Biol. Trop. (Int. J. Trop. Biol. ISSN-0034-7744) Vol. 63 (Suppl. 2): 353-360, June 2015
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Thanks to the people from the Laboratorio
de Ecosistemas Costeros (MACN) and the
LARBIM (CENPAT) for their assistance dur-
ing collection and processing at the laboratory.
This work was funded by grants from the Con-
sejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas
y Técnicas (CONICET PIP-0253) and from
the Agencia Nacional de Promoción Cientí-
fica y Tecnológica (PICT 2012-0561 and PICT
2013-2504). We also thank three referees for
valuable suggestions, particularly to Karin
Boos for her helpful commentaries and recom-
mendations that improved considerably the
final manuscript.
RESUMEN
Microestructura dental y biología alimentaria del
Ophioplocus januarii (Echinodermata: Ophiuroidea) del
norte de Patagonia, Argentina. El ofiuroideo Ophioplo-
cus januarii se distribuye a lo largo de las costas de Argen-
tina y Brasil, encontrándose tanto en substratos duros como
blandos. En base al análisis de contenidos estomacales y
la microestructura de los dientes, junto a observaciones
de campo, se describe el comportamiento alimentario de
esta especie. Opuesto a suposiciones previas, O. januarii
es una especie micrófaga que se alimenta de fragmentos
de macroalgas (encontrados en el 60.0 % de los estómagos
analizados que presentaban contenido), detritos vegetales
(28.0 %), estructuras cuticulares animales (13.0 %) y mate-
rial inidentificable (30.7 %). Menos frecuente, se encon-
traron foraminíferos, ostrácodos, un anfípodo, un bivalvo
juvenil y otros crustáceos. Pequeñas porciones del material
inidentificable fueron analizadas en el microscopio electró-
nico de barrido, resultando ser material digerido, diatomeas
y pequeños apéndices de crustáceos. Así, O. januarii es una
especie omnívora, que se alimenta principalmente de algas,
complementando su dieta de manera oportunista con otros
ítems. Las observaciones de campo revelaron alimentación
suspensívora. El análisis de la microestructura del este-
reoma del diente resultó en un arreglo del tipo fenestrado
intermedio, que se encuentra entre los dos tipos de arreglos
descriptos hasta ahora, los dientes de tipo uniforme y los
compuestos. De estos últimos, el primero ha sido encon-
trado en especies macrófagas mientras que el segundo se
corresponde a ofiuroideos micrófagos. En el presente tra-
bajo, se propone la existencia de un nuevo tipo de arreglo
intermedio en la matriz dental de los ofiuroideos.
Palabras claves: Estrellas quebradizas, microestructura
estereoma, contenido estomacal, Ophiolepididae, diente.
REFERENCES
Bartsch, I. (1982). Ophiuroidea (Echinodermata) from the
Patagonian shelf. Mitteilungen aus dem Hamburgis-
chen Zoologischen Museum und Institut, 79, 211-250.
Bernasconi, I., & D’Agostino M. M. (1977). Ofiuroideos
del mar epicontinental Argentino. Revista del Museo
Argentino de Ciencias Naturales, Hidrobiología, 5,
65-114.
Brogger, M. I., Gil, D. G., Rubilar, T., Martinez, M. I.,
Díaz de Vivar, M. E., Escolar, M., … Tablado, A.
(2013). Echinoderms from Argentina: Biodiversity,
distribution and current state of knowledge. In J. J.
Alvarado, & F. A. Solís-Marín (Eds.), Echinoderm
Research and Diversity in Latin America (pp. 359-
402). Berlin: Springer.
Dahm, C. (1999). Ophiuroids (Echinodermata) of southern
Chile and the Antarctic: Taxonomy, biomass, diet
and growth of dominant species. Scientia Marina,
63, 427-432.
Davoult, D., & Gounin, F. (1995). Suspension-feeding
activity of a dense Ophiothrix fragilis (Abildgaard)
population at the water-sediment interface: Time
coupling of food availability and feeding behavior
of the species. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science,
41, 567-577.
Dearborn, J. H. (1977). Foods and feeding characteristics
of Antarctic asteroids and ophiuroids. In G. Llano
(Ed.), Adaptations within Antarctic ecosystems: Pro-
ceedings 3rd SCAR Symposium of Antarctic Biolo-
gy (pp. 293-326). Washington D.C.: Smithsonian
Institution.
Ferrari, F. D., & Dearborn, J. H. (1989). A second exa-
mination of predation on pelagic copepods by the
brittle star Astrotoma agassizii. Journal of Plankton
Research, 11, 1315-1320.
Fontaine, A. R. (1965). The feeding mechanisms of the
ophiuroid Ophiocomina nigra. Journal of the Marine
Biological Association of the UK, 44, 145-162.
Gielazyn, M. L., Stancyk, S. E., & Piegorsch, W. W.
(1999). Experimental evidence of subsurface feeding
by the burrowing ophiuroid Amphipholis gracillima
(Echinodermata). Marine Ecology Progress Series,
184, 129-138.
Harris, J. L., MacIsaac, K., Gilinson, K. D., & Kenching-
ton, E. L. (2009). Feeding biology of Ophiura sarsii
Lütken, 1855 on Banquereau bank and the effects of
fishing. Marine Biology, 156, 1891-1902.
Hendler, G. (1982). The feeding biology of Ophioderma
brevispinum (Ophiuroidea: Echinodermata). In J. M.
Lawrence (Ed.), Echinoderms: Proceedings of the
International Echinoderm Conference (pp. 21-27).
Rotterdam: Balkema.
360
Rev. Biol. Trop. (Int. J. Trop. Biol. ISSN-0034-7744) Vol. 63 (Suppl. 2): 353-360, June 2015
Hendler, G., & Miller, J. E. (1984). Feeding behavior of
Asteroporpa annulata, a gorgonocephalid brittlestar
with unbranched arms. Bulletin of Marine Science,
34, 449-460.
Medeiros-Bergen, D. E. (1996). On the stereom micros-
tructure of ophiuroid teeth. Ophelia, 45, 211-222.
Murakami, S. (1963). The dental and oral plates of Ophiu-
roidea. Transactions of the Royal Society of New
Zealand, 4, 1-48.
Pearson, M., & Gage, J. D. (1984). Diets of some deep-sea
brittle stars in the Rockall Trough. Marine Biology,
82, 247-258.
Sides, E. M., & Woodley, J. D. (1985). Niche separation in
three species of Ophiocoma (Echinodermata: Ophiu-
roidea) in Jamaica, West Indies. Bulletin of Marine
Sciences, 36, 701-715.
Smith, A. B., Paterson, G. L. J., & Lafay, B. (1995). Ophiu-
roid phylogeny and higher taxonomy: morphological,
molecular and palaeontological perspectives. Zoolo-
gical Journal of the Linnean Society, 114, 213-243.
Stöhr, S. (2005). Who’s who among baby brittle stars
(Echinodermata: Ophiuroidea): postmetamorphic
development of some North Atlantic forms. Zoolo-
gical Journal of the Linnean Society, 143, 543-576.
Stöhr, S., & Muths, D. (2010). Morphological diagnosis of
the two genetic lineages of Acronida brachiata (Echi-
nodermata: Ophiuroidea), with description of a new
species. Journal of the Marine Biology Association of
the UK, 90, 831-843.
Thomas, L. P. (1975). The systematic relationships of
Ophioplocus, Ophioceramis, and Ophioceres (Echi-
nodermata, Ophiuroidea). Bulletin of Marine Science,
25, 232-247.
Warner, G. (1982). Food and feeding mechanisms: Ophiu-
roidea. In M. Jangoux & J. M. Lawrence (Eds.),
Echinoderm Nutrition (pp. 161-181). Rotterdam:
Balkema.
Yokoyama, L. Q., & Amaral, A. C. Z. (2008). The diet of
Ophionereis reticulata (Echinodermata: Ophiuroi-
dea) in southeastern Brazil. Revista Brasileira de
Zoologia, 25, 576-578.
... The numbers in parentheses refer to the following comments: (1) The microstructure of type A and B tooth types has been described and illustrated with scanning electron micrographs by Medeiros-Bergen [36][37][38]. Most examined type B teeth have a cap consisting of imperforate stereom (Fig 1Cc), which has been described variously in the literature as "enamelled", "hyaline" or "glassy"; a cap consisting of more densely fenestrated stereom has been observed in Ophiopholis aculeata (Ophiopholidae), Ophiactis asperula (Ophiactidae), ophiolepidids have type A dental plates, one species has an "imperfect" perforation and another has distinctly type B perforations. ...
... https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0202046.g010 Acrocnida brachiata, Amphiura chiajei (both Amphiuridae) and Ophioplocus januarii (Hemieuryalidae) ( [37,39]; Wilkie pers. obs.) (Fig 1Dc). ...
... There are no comparable data on any type B IF. It is, however, intriguing that, even taking into account the trophic versatility demonstrated by many ophiuroids [67][68][69][70], suspension feeding features prominently and consistently in all clades with type B IFs (as shown in Fig 10), but sporadically, or not at all, in those with type A IFs (see inter alia [37,63,68,69,[71][72][73]). It has also been suggested that the capped teeth of type B IFs are an adaptation for the efficient comminution of material obtained by suspension or deposit feeding [36,64]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The peristomial plates are skeletal components of the interbrachial frame (or mouth frame), which is located below the true mouth of ophiuroids. Whilst the peristomial plates were extensively described and used as diagnostic characters by some early workers, for the past 100 years they have been largely neglected as a taxonomic resource. In this investigation the peristomial plates of 48 species representing 21 families were examined directly, and information on a further 61 species, including representatives of another eight families, was obtained from the published literature. Observations were made with regard to fragmentation state, relative size and orientation of the peristomial plates. Although fragmentation state showed little consistency at any taxonomic level, relative size and orientation segregated a group of families comprising species with relatively small, inclined peristomial plates, viz. Ophiotrichidae, Ophiopholidae, Ophiactidae, Amphiuridae and Ophiocomidae, together with a single hemieuryalid species–Ophioplocus januarii. The distribution of peristomial plate traits was strongly correlated with that of several other character states pertaining to the interbrachial frame. This supported the proposition that two major types of interbrachial frame are present in ophiuroids (designated ‘A’ and ‘B’). Current phylogenies inferred from both morphological and molecular data imply that type B is derived and has evolved independently at least twice in the orders Amphilepidida and Ophiacanthida. This represents a remarkable example of evolutionary convergence. An analysis of the distribution of all interbrachial frame character states suggested that within the Amphilepidida paedomorphosis was probably responsible for the complete reversion of the interbrachial frame to the ancestral type A condition in two families (Ophiothamnidae and Amphilepididae) of suborder Gnathophiurina and possibly responsible for varying degrees of trait reversal in the four families of suborder Ophionereidina. Such paedomorphic events may have been associated with a secondary return to the deep-sea from shallow-sea environments.
... be more specialized than deep-sea counterparts. For example, Ophioplocus januarii found in shallow northern Patagonia appears to be microphagous and omnivorous (Brogger et al., 2015). In intertidal areas of Madagascar, O. venosa feeds on Sargassum densifolium and on organic matter, whereas O. scolopendrina feeds on neuston (Fourgon et al., 2006). ...
... In intertidal areas of Madagascar, O. venosa feeds on Sargassum densifolium and on organic matter, whereas O. scolopendrina feeds on neuston (Fourgon et al., 2006). Many species have been reported to ingest live prey such as molluscs, annelids, crustaceans, or even other ophiuroids (Brogger et al., 2015;Pearson & Gage, 1984;Stöhr et al., 2012;Warner, 1982;Yokoyama & Amaral, 2008). Deep-dwelling ophiuroids display opportunistic and generalist behaviors with a feeding strategy centered on predation or suspension feeding (Gage & Tyler, 1991;Pearson & Gage, 1984). ...
Article
Ophiopholis aculeata is a ubiquitous brittle star (Echinodermata: Ophiuroidea) known to occur from the upper subtidal to the bathyal zone. Individuals from shallow inshore habitats (rhodolith beds and rock fields) and deeper offshore locations in eastern Canada were studied to assess the population structure, habitat selection, diet, and feeding strategies of this species through use of stable isotope analyses, gut contents, and laboratory experiments. Potential drivers of habitat selection such as depth, light conditions, body size, sex, intraspecific competition, and presence of predators were examined. This study highlighted variable population size structures and abundances as well as diversified food sources and feeding strategies (i.e., suspension and deposit feeding, scavenging, predation on live organisms, and even cannibalism) as a function of native depth and habitat. It also revealed that studies on the feeding biology of brittle stars must carefully consider sex and life stage as driving factors.
... Although a relatively extensive amount of literature may be found on this topic (e.g. Deschuyteneer and Jangoux 1978;Chartock 1983;Emson 1990;Emson et al. 1991;Dearborn et al. 1996;Allen 1998;Boos 2012;Brogger et al. 2015), few studies have been conducted in the tropical Atlantic (Davis 1966;Reimer and Reimer 1975;Hendler 1982;Hendler and Miller 1984a;Yokoyama and Amaral 2008). In general, all papers analysing feeding biology in ophiuroids in detail, in both cold and warm waters, recorded a large variety of food items in the diet of these animals. ...
... In general, all papers analysing feeding biology in ophiuroids in detail, in both cold and warm waters, recorded a large variety of food items in the diet of these animals. The most common items are algae, crustaceans, echinoderms, gastropods and polychaetes (Feder 1981;Fratt and Dearborn 1984;Pearson and Gage 1984;Dearborn et al. 1996;Yokoyama and Amaral 2008;Harris et al. 2009;Brogger et al. 2015). ...
Article
Ophioderma appressum is a common and abundant ophiuroid species in tropical reef communities. Nevertheless, few studies analyse and describe its biology. In this paper, we evaluate and describe the diet of this species collected at Seixas reefs, João Pessoa, Brazil. Monthly diurnal samples were obtained between September 2018 and July 2019. In total, 143 individuals were analysed. The recorded diet was variable and consisted of 24 taxa and two additional items. Most material represented unidentifiable and/or digested remains, foraminiferans, crustacean fragments, and sediment particles, indicating omnivory. The number of individuals with stomach contents varied along the year (from two to 13 specimens per month). There was also significant temporal variation in the composition of the stomach contents. The months September 2018, May 2019 and June 2019 had the highest variety of items during the study. Our results suggest generalist and opportunistic feeding behaviour and highlight the role of O. appressum as an active predator on prey of diverse taxa and body size.
... This may indicate the broad food spectrum, unselective feeding behaviour and dependence of Ophiothrix spp. feeding preference to its habitat diversity (Brogger et al. 2015). Feeding preferences of brittle star is approximated by Brogger et al. (2015) as relatively poorly developed both on hard substrates and on soft sediments rich in detritus. ...
... feeding preference to its habitat diversity (Brogger et al. 2015). Feeding preferences of brittle star is approximated by Brogger et al. (2015) as relatively poorly developed both on hard substrates and on soft sediments rich in detritus. As a deposit feeder, Ophiothrix spp. ...
... This is consistent with the hypothesis claiming that madreporites are ecologically informative (Ezhova et al. 2016). The differences among species in the type of teeth are relevant if we consider that teeth types have been used as an indicator of feeding preferences (uniform teeth for macrophagous feeders and compound for microphagous) (Medeiros-Bergen 1996;Brogger et al. 2015). Five ophionereidids have been reported to possess only compound teeth (Medeiros-Bergen 1996), while O. commutabilis shows both compound and uniform teeth, which could represent an adaptation, increasing the importance of omnivorous feeding in this cave system (as suggested by Bribiesca-Contreras et al. (2019) for other food sources). ...
Article
Full-text available
Due to their peculiar and sometimes bizarre morphology, cave fauna (across invertebrates and vertebrates from both aquatic and terrestrial cave habitats) have fascinated researchers throughout history. Despite their success in colonizing most marine ecosystems, the adaptations of cave brittle stars (Ophiuroidea) to a stygobiotic lifestyle have been scarcely examined. Employing comparative methods on a data set of two species belonging to the genus Ophionereis , this study addresses whether a cave-dwelling species from Cozumel exhibited similar troglomorphic traits as those of other taxa inhabiting caves. Our work demonstrated that some characters representing potential morphological cave adaptations in O. commutabilis were: bigger sizes, elongation of arms and tube feet and the presence of traits potentially paedomorphic. In addition, an element of ophiuroid’s photoreceptor system, as well as pigmentation, was observed to be peculiar in this stygobiotic species, plausibly as a result of inhabiting a low light-energy environment. Finally, we add evidence to the statement that O. commutabilis is a cave endemic species, already supported by demography, distribution and origin of this species, and now by a typical array of troglomorphisms.
... Likewise, a previous study conducted in the North Atlantic Ocean also found the longest fiber uptake by brittle stars (Courtene-Jones et al., 2017). The brittle star prefers to live in or on the sea floor and can utilize a variety of feeding methods (Feder, 1981;Brogger et al., 2016). A previous study has observed that the maximum length of food items ingested by brittle star could range up to 17.5 or 30.0 mm depended on the prey types (Feder, 1981). ...
Article
The seafloor is recognized as one of the major sinks for microplastics (MPs). However, to date there have been no studies reported the MP contamination in benthic organisms from the Arctic and sub-Arctic regions. Therefore, this study provided the first data on the abundances and characteristics of MPs in a total of 413 dominant benthic organisms representing 11 different species inhabiting in the shelf of Bering and Chukchi Seas. The mean abundances of MP uptake by the benthos from all sites ranged from 0.02 to 0.46 items g-1 wet weight (ww) or 0.04-1.67 items individual-1, which were lower values than those found in other regions worldwide. The highest value appeared at the northernmost site, implying that the sea ice and the cold current represent possible transport mediums. Interestingly, the predator A. rubens ingested the maximum quantities of MPs, suggesting that the trophic transfer of MPs through benthic food webs may play a critical role. Fibers constituted the major type (87%) in each species, followed by film (13%). The colors of fibers were classified as red (46%) and transparent (41%), and the film was all gray. The predominant composition was polyamide (PA) (46%), followed by polyethylene (PE) (23%), polyester (PET) (18%) and cellophane (CP) (13%). The most common sizes of MPs concentrated in the interval from 0.10 to 1.50 mm, and the mean size was 1.45 ± 0.13 mm. Further studies about the temporal trends and detrimental effects of MPs remain to be carried out in benthic organisms from the Arctic and sub-Arctic regions.
Article
Full-text available
Increasing habitat modification and species loss demand consistent efforts to describe and understand biodiversity patterns. The BIOTA/FAPESP Program was created in this context and it has been a successful initiative to promote studies on biodiversity and conservation in Brazil. The BIOTA/Araçá is an interdisciplinary project that provided a detailed evaluation of the biodiversity of Araçá Bay, a coastal seascape located on the North coast of the state of São Paulo, Southeast Brazil. The bay encompasses multiple habitats, such as beaches, mangroves, rocky shores, and a tidal flat, and provides important ecosystem services. Unfortunately, the bay is the subject of complex social-environmental conflicts that oppose economic, social, and environmental demands (i.e., the expansion of neighboring harbor activities vs. small-scale artisanal fisheries and protection of biodiversity). The present study presents a survey of the benthic species occurring in the different habitats of Araçá Bay, including data obtained during the BIOTA/Araçá project and previous assessments of the area. The benthic species play an important role in marine environments and studying the diversity of these organisms that live associated with the bottom is indispensable for comprehending the environment’s functioning. The macrofauna, meiofauna, and microorganisms associated with soft and hard bottom were listed, and additional information, such as the habitat and geographical distribution, were provided for each species. The checklist includes 826 species, almost 70% recorded during the BIOTA/Araçá project. The most speciose taxa were the annelids (225 spp.), mollusks (194 spp.), and crustaceans (177 spp.). Seven benthic species are endemic to Araçá Bay, 14 are considered threatened, and seven are economically exploited. Furthermore, the bay is the type locality of many taxa, and 11 new benthic species were described based on specimens sampled during the project. This project shows the importance of Araçá Bay as a unique biologically rich environment and highlights the need for conservation efforts in light of the current threats.
Thesis
Full-text available
Les algues brunes du genre Cystoseira sensu lato forment les écosystèmes marins, comptant parmi les plus productifs de Méditerranée, mais aussi parmi les plus menacés par les facteurs anthropiques et phénomènes globaux ; elles comptent aujourd’hui 45 espèces reconnues taxonomiquement, avec un nombre soumis à évolution, en raison des confusions taxonomiques récurrentes et de l’apport de la biologie moléculaire. Cette dernière a permis grâce aux récents travaux de distinguer trois genres : Cystoseira, Carpodesmia et Treptacantha. Notre étude qui a concerné un total de 29 Stations de la région centre, s’étendant du littoral de Chlef à l’Ouest au Littoral de Bejaia à l’est, ainsi que 3 stations additives à l’extrême est et ouest, a permis de recenser un total de 12 espèces, parmi les 16 citées dans la littérature. Le Treptacantha barbata, classé taxa excludenda, et signalé par de rares auteurs n’a été observé ni par Sellam (2018), ni par nous-mêmes, nous suggérons une confusion taxonomique avec le Cystoseira compressa subsp. Compressa ou le Cystoseira humilis. Un intérêt particulier a par ailleurs été dévolu à l’espèce endémique stricte Cystoseira sedoides, car très peu étudiée, elle a été recensée à 14 stations, où elle forme des faciès monospécifiques et 2 autres où elle est rare. L’analyse historique de son observation a révélé une tendance à la diminution, voire à la disparition dans les stations les plus urbanisées. Les résultats des mesures de densité et de matière sèche moyennes ont corroboré la nécessité de reconsidérer son statut écologique, d’espèce fondatrice, au même titre que le Cystoseira amentacea var. stricta et le Carpodesmia crinita. L’étude de la faune et de la flore associées a concerné les 4 formations clés du littoral algérien, l’association en mode battu à Cystoseira amentacea var. stricta, moyennement battu à Cystoseira sedoides et l’association à Carpodesmia crinita et à Cystoseira humilis, en mode calme. L’examen de la diversité floristique a permis d’énumérer un total de 94 espèces et de décrire les strates caractéristiques de chaque association. Un total de 160 espèces fauniques a été recensé, l’analyse comparative des indices de biodiversité calculés par la méthode d’interpolation et d’extrapolation, qui standardise la taille des échantillons, a révélé des différences non significatives entre les associations étudiées, hormis entre celles du Cystoseira amentacea var. stricta et du C. sedoides. L’approche comparative de la composition des peuplements a permis de mettre en évidence que le facteur hydrodynamique contribue significativement à la structure de la macrofaune associée, principalement fonctionnelle, liée au mode trophique des espèces, qui semble être un meilleur outil de caractérisation des peuplements fauniques associés.
Article
The detailed study of arm ossicles, particularly the lateral arm plates, is providing valuable information in the elucidation of ophiuroid taxonomy. The present study describes in detail 16 species of brittle stars from Araçá Bay, Brazil. This information is used to construct the first interactive electronic key, providing a valuable resource for a broad range of researchers. Brittle stars families were divided into three groups based on their spatial distribution: i) infaunal species of intertidal and shallow subtidal belonging to Amphiuridae and Ophiactidae, ii) epizoic species belonging to Amphiuridae, Ophiactidae, and Ophiotrichidae and, iii) epifaunal species of the subtidal belonging to Ophiodermatidae and Hemieuryalidae. In the global context of recent revisions of ophiuroid taxonomy, the present work provides additional characters for use in future phylogenetic studies.
Article
Full-text available
Knowledge of the feeding habits of infaunal deposit-feeders is essential to understand their role in the movement of sediment-bound material and nutrients and in trophic transfer. Deposit-feeding ophiuroids are abundant in the world's oceans but many details of their intricate feeding behaviors are unknown. We used fluorescent polystyrene microspheres in a subsurface food layer to demonstrate that Amphipholis gracillima, an infaunal ophiuroid known to feed on surface particles, is also capable of consuming subsurface particles in the laboratory. Although physical conditions varied only slightly during experiments there was a significant effect of temperature on the number of microspheres consumed. Additional experiments using layers of microspheres with and without food demonstrated that food layers significantly influenced the disc depth of A. gracillima, whereas layers without food did not. Utilizing subsurface sources of food might give burrowing organisms access to more sources of nutrients, decrease sublethal predation and lead to more stable populations over time.
Article
Full-text available
The ophiuroid Ophionereis reticulata (Say, 1825) occurs in the sediment-rocky shore interface, under small stones. Its diet is analyzed in this short communication. Specimens were collected at the Praia Grande beach, located on the northern coast of the state of São Paulo, Brazil, in July, 2002 and January, 2003. The animals were fixed in 70% ethanol and dissected to obtain their stomach contents. Of the total (35), 77.1% (27) had ingested some kind of food and, among those, 81.4% (22) had more than one item. The mean number of food items per stomach was 1.9. Ophionereis reticulata is an omnivorous species, consuming sediment, green and red algae, and polychaetes.
Article
Full-text available
Euchaeta antarctica and Calanoides acutus, common pelagic copepods of the Southern Ocean, dominate stomach contents of the brittle star Astrotoma agassizii from the South Georgia shelf in November–December. This finding does not support our earlier hypothesis of restricted feeding by Astrotoma in austral fall on these copepods during their seasonal migration.
Article
This study aims on a first comparison of the shallow water (<550 m) ophiuroid fauna of the Magellan region and the high-Antarctic Weddell Sea. Five species are common to both the Magellan region (22 species) and the Weddell Sea (42 species). The most abundant Magellan species is Ophiuroglypha lymani, contributing 33% to total ophiuroid abundance and 44% to total ophiuroid biomass. The diets of O. lymani and of three closely related (same sub-family Ophiurinae) also dominant. Antarctic species are similar, indicate however slightly different feeding strategies. The Magellan species tends more towards microphageous grazing, whereas the Weddell Sea species act more like scavengers. Within the sub-family Ophiurinae growth performance of O. lymani is higher than in Antarctic species and in the range of boreal species.
Article
Ophiuroids are selective feeders and are either basically carnivorous or microphagous.-from Author
Article
The tooth stereom microstructure of 43 species of ophiuroids, from 9 families, was examined using light and scanning electron microscopy. Two basic types of teeth, uniform and compound, are present in ophiuroids. From a mechanical standpoint, compound teeth may provide a tougher grinding surface for ingestion of prey. Tooth types seem to be conserved at the family level, with only two exceptions, and are considered in light of known feeding strategies. Macrophagous feeders generally possess uniform teeth whereas microphagous feeders possess compound teeth. Ophiocomina nigra and Ophiopteris papillosa (Ophiocomidae) possess tooth types that are not in accord with other species in this family. Perhaps genera within this family are in need of reclassification.
Article
The nominal species of the ophiurid genera Ophioplocus, Ophioceramis and Ophioceres are discussed and their respective type-species are considered so closely related as to require the two latter names to be treated as junior synonyms of Ophioplocus. The heterogenous nature of Ophioceramis is demonstrated and two species are placed in genera in other families.
Article
The brittle-stars Ophiocoma wendtii, O. echinata and O. pumila occur under rubble and in crevices in coral heads shoreward of the reef crest. To determine if the three species differed in use of resources, the sizes of crevice openings used were measured, feeding methods and behavior were observed, and stomach contents examined. The three species were found to use crevices of different sizes, which in part may be a function of their difference in size: but size alone is unlikely to be the reason for the use of such large crevices by O. wendtii. All three species were observed to suspension- and deposit-feed, but differed in the degree to which they exposed themselves, and in the feeding areas used in relation to their crevices. The analysis of stomach contents revealed a broad overlap in diet and particle size, but those of O. wendtii had the highest amount of very fine flocculent material, and O. pumila, the smallest species, contained the largest particles. Thus these three closely related species, which appear to co-exist, when studied in detail show striking and subtle differences in several aspects of their life habits. The availability of suitable sized crevices is likely to be a major determinant of the distribution of the species.