A preview of the PDF is not available
Hillslope Degradation by Trees in Central Kentucky
Abstract and Figures
I am at the age & stage of career where I have to choose my battles, and this is one I don't really have time for. This paper was submitted to Catena in February, 2015, and received two reviews recommending minor revision. A revised version was submitted June 1, 2015, but a third reviewer was strongly critical and Catena’s editor decided to reject it. Some of the referee’s objections & suggestions are reasonable, but for various reasons I am not able or willing to accommodate them. Some are demonstrably off-base—for example, he/she complains some things are missing from the paper that are unquestionably there. Some—well, you can be the judge if you decide to read this, as the reviewer complains that the paper is “quite poorly written, hard to follow,” and “simply a mishmash of various statements.” I don’t think it’s THAT bad, but consider yourself fairly warned. I have cleaned up a typo or two in formatting the paper for posting, but what you see is pretty much what the 3rd referee didn’t like.
Figures - uploaded by Jonathan Phillips
All figure content in this area was uploaded by Jonathan Phillips
Content may be subject to copyright.