ArticlePDF AvailableLiterature Review

Gender Identification by Cloacoscopy and Cystoscopy in Juvenile Chelonians

Authors:
  • CRARC (Catalonian Reptiles and Amphibians Rescue Center). Masquefa. Barcelona. Spain
  • Zoològic Veterinaris, Badalona

Abstract and Figures

Cloacoscopy and cystoscopy are simple, noninvasive to minimally invasive techniques that provide excellent visualization, and result in fast recovery. General or intrathecal anesthesia is sufficient. They can be performed in free-ranging turtles under field conditions. Cloacoscopic gender identification of external genitalia is not reliable because of the high degree of misinterpretation between phallus and clitoris, especially in juveniles. However, saline-infusion or air insufflation cystoscopy through the urinary bladder (or accessory vesicles/bladders) is often effective for the visualization of gonads and to identify the sex. Visualization of gonads is feasible through the urinary bladder or accessory vesicle wall in many species. Copyright © 2015 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Gender Identification by
Cloacoscopy and
Cystoscopy in Juvenile Chelonians
Albert Martínez-Silvestre, DVM, MSc, PhD, Acred AVEPA (Exotic Animals), Dipl ECZM (Herpetology)
a,
*,
Ferran Bargalló, DVM
b
, Jordi Grífols, DVM, MSc
b
Videos of endoscopic evaluation and cystoscopy evaluation accompany this
article at http://www.vetexotic.theclinics.com/
INTRODUCTION
In recent years, breeding of chelonians has become more common because of the
popularity of tortoises and turtles as pets as well as their inclusion in recovery plans
of endangered species.
1
Because of these circumstances, there is not only special in-
terest in knowing the sex of subadults but also of newborn animals.
Disclosure: The authors have nothing to disclose.
a
CRARC (Catalonian Reptile and Amphibian Rescue Center), C/Santa Clara, s/n Masquefa
08783, Spain;
b
Zoologic Badalona Veterinary Clinics, C/Conquista, 74, Badalona 08912, Spain
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: albertmarsil@outlook.com
KEYWORDS
Cloacoscopy Cystoscopy Gender identification Chelonian Tortoise Turtle
Reproductive
KEY POINTS
Sexual dimorphism is apparent in most adult chelonians, but appears at, and not before,
maturation.
The primary method of classifying sex in hatchlings and juvenile chelonians is the direct
observation of gonads through celioscopy.
Cloacoscopic gender identification of external genitalia is not reliable because of the high
degree of misinterpretation between phallus and clitoris, especially in juveniles.
Cystoscopy is an alternative noninvasive technique (performed through natural openings)
for gender identification and is often effective for the visualization of gonads.
Further studies are necessary to verify safety and efficacy of cystoscopic gender identifi-
cation in different species of chelonians.
Vet Clin Exot Anim -(2015) --
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cvex.2015.04.009 vetexotic.theclinics.com
1094-9194/15/$ – see front matter Ó2015 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Sexual dimorphism is apparent in most adult chelonians. As a general guideline,
males have longer tails with distal cloaca openings, plastron concavity, differences
in size and weight, and distinctive behaviors. In some species, males have different
toenail lengths; bones or scales; eye, skin, or nose color; submandibular glands;
and even an ability to vocalize. However, all these items are secondary sexual charac-
teristics that appear at, and not before, maturation.
2
The sex of hatchlings can be identified by numerous methods. In several studies
with wild tortoises or sea turtles, some investigators have used indirect estimates
of nest sex ratios. However, because of gender differences associated with variable
thermal conditions, these indirect methods are considered imprecise.
3,4
The radioim-
munoassay of testosterone and/or estrogen is another indirect method for sex classi-
fication, but it must be validated for each species to which it is applied. To date, this
method has been successfully used for sex identification of the Arrau River turtle
(Podocnemis expansa), loggerhead sea turtle (Caretta caretta), and green sea turtle
(Chelonia mydas).
5,6
Therefore, the primary method of classifying sex remains the direct observation of
gonads in hatchlings and juveniles. Immature ovarian follicles and nonactive testes
are visible inside the coelomic cavity of even young turtles.
7
Endoscopy has been shown to be one of the main techniques for gender identifica-
tion by direct visualization of gonads.
7
Celioscopy is a minimally invasive technique
performed through the prefemoral fossa, requiring an adequate anesthetic plane.
7
In addition to gender identification, some surgical operations, such as orchiectomy
or ovarian biopsies, can be performed using this system.
7
Cystoscopy is an alternative
noninvasive technique (performed through natural openings) for gender identification
that can provide excellent visualization, without surgery, and results in a rapid recov-
ery time.
INDICATION AND CONTRAINDICATIONS FOR GENDER IDENTIFICATION BY
CLOACOSCOPY AND CYSTOSCOPY IN JUVENILE CHELONIANS
The indications and contraindications for gender identification by cloacoscopy and
cystoscopy in juvenile chelonians are presented in Table 1.
APPROACH
The technique of cloacoscopy/cystoscopy is the same for all species. Each species,
genus, or family can have particular anatomy that must be appreciated.
8
Gender iden-
tification by cloacoscopy/cystoscopy consists of indirect observation of the gonads
via a natural anatomic opening, the cloaca, and through the bladder wall.
9
For these
procedures clinicians take advantage of the transparency of membranes forming
Table 1
The most common indications and contraindications for gender identification by cloacoscopy
and cystoscopy in juvenile chelonians
Indications Contraindications
Gender identification by indirect gonad
visualization in juveniles weighing >150 g
Presence of yolk sac (it might hinder indirect
gonad visualization in hatchlings)
Risk of mucosa damage, bladder (including
accessory bladders) and cloaca rupture
Some species have no accessory vesicles
Martı
´nez-Silvestre et al
2
both urinary bladder and accessory vesicles (also known as cloacal bursae or acces-
sory bladders) (Fig. 1).
8,10
Only some species of turtles have accessory vesicles. As a
general rule, many aquatic turtles have accessory vesicles, whereas they are not
present in terrestrial species.
8
Some details on the differences between species are
provided in Table 2.
Thus, in species without cloacal bursae, observation of gonads must be done by
entering the bladder. The main disadvantage of cystoscopy is the presence of uric
acid crystals and sediments that can hinder visualization.
Accessory vesicles are always close to the proctodeum and, in many species, they
are highly vascularized. Their basic functions are to provide buoyancy control and
store water that is used on land for softening the ground for nest excavation. They
are also used in stress situations (to create repulsion from predators).
8,10
They usually
consist of a transparent membrane in which no urine is stored. Accessory vesicles can
be filled and emptied quickly through the cloaca, and may therefore be used to effect
short-term changes in lung volume and, hence, buoyancy.
10
In some species the
accessory vesicular membrane lacks papillae. In the big-headed turtle (Platisternon
megacephala), although the membrane is transparent, the density of highly vascular-
ized papillae hinders the vision of gonads (Fig. 2A). In the Hilaire’s side-necked turtle
(Phrynops hilarii) accessory vesicles have a thin membrane covered with vascularized
folds (plicae) (see Fig. 2B). Other species such as the Central America wood turtle
(Rhinoclemmys pulcherrima) have a dark pigmented mucosa around the proctodeum
that makes visualization difficult or impossible.
TECHNIQUE/PROCEDURE
Preparation/Patient Positioning
Turtles are placed in ventral recumbency, and the cloaca is flushed using warmed sa-
line. This procedure allows filling of the accessory vesicles, and removes urates and
fecal material.
Cloacal lavage can be performed in conscious animals because stress urination can
be helpful for emptying the urinary bladder and accessory vesicles. In box turtles
Fig. 1. Cloacoscopic view of the entrance to the accessory vesicles using insufflation of air in
a male European pond turtle (Emys orbicularis). The transparent membrane cannot be
appreciated on this picture.
Cloacoscopy and Cystoscopy in Juvenile Chelonians 3
Table 2
Special features of the main families of continental tortoises and turtles at the time of the cloacoscopy, as well as some internal peculiarities specific to
certain species
Family Accessory Vesicles Present Accessory Vesicles Absent Common Name Details of Interest
Carettochelyidae Carettochelis insculpta Pig-nosed turtle Multilobulated clitoris
Chelydridae Chelydra serpentina Snapping turtle
Macrochelys temminckii Alligator turtle
Emydidae Emys orbicularis/Emys trinacris European pond turtle Two big accessory vesicles
Graptemys pseudogeographica Common map turtle
Trachemys scripta Red-eared slider
Trachemys emolli Nicaraguan slider
Pseudemys floridana Coastal plain cooter
Chrysemys picta Painted turtle
Mauremys leprosa Mediterranean turtle Two big accessory vesicles
Mauremys mutica Asian yellow pond turtle
Mauremys sinensis Chinese stripe-necked turtle
Mauremys anamensis Annam pond turtle
Malaclemys terrapin Diamondback terrapin
Cuora amboinensis Malayan box turtle One small accessory vesicle
Cuora flavomarginata Yellow-margined box turtle One small accessory vesicle
Cyclemys dentata Asian leaf turtle
Terrapene carolina Common box turtle
Rhinoclemmys pulcherrima Central America wood turtle Dark pigmented mucosa
Kinosternidae — Sternotherus odoratus Musk turtle
Kinosternon scorpioides Scorpion mud turtle
Platysternidae Platysternon megacephalum Big-headed turtle Papillae sieved accessory vesicles
Martı
´nez-Silvestre et al
4
Testudinidae — Testudo hermanni Herman’s tortoise
Testudo graeca Moorish tortoise
Testudo marginata Greek tortoise
Testudo kleinmanni Egyptian tortoise
Gopherus berlandieri Texas tortoise
Geochelone elegans Indian star tortoise
Chelonoidis carbonaria Red footed tortoise Large clitoris
Chelonoidis denticulata Yellow footed tortoise Large clitoris
Stigmochelys pardalis Leopard tortoise
Centrochelys sulcata African spur thigh tortoise
Astrochelys radiata Radiated tortoise
Aldabrachelys gigantea Aldabra giant tortoise
Geochelone chilensis Chaco tortoise
Manouria emys Asian giant tortoise
Trionychidae Apalone ferox Florida softshell turtle
Pelodiscus sinensis Chinese softshell turtle
Chelidae Phrynops hilarii Hilaire’s side-necked turtle Accessory vesicle with plicae
Pelomedusidae Pelusios subniger East African mud turtle Two small accessory vesicles
Pelomedusa subrufa African helmeted turtle One small accessory vesicle
Emydura subglobosa Red-bellied short-necked turtle
Podocnemididae Podocnemis unifilis Yellow-spotted Amazon river
turtle
One small accessory vesicle
Cloacoscopy and Cystoscopy in Juvenile Chelonians 5
(Terrapene or Cuora), a Farabeuf abdominal retractor can be used to prevent closure
of the carapace during examination (Fig. 3).
Surgical anesthesia using inhalants is rarely required, but analgesia and tranquiliza-
tion are beneficial.
11
Anesthesia time rarely, if ever, exceeds 20 minutes. Drugs recom-
mended for this purpose are propofol, alfaxalone, or a combination of (dex)
medetomidine, ketamine, and an opiate (eg, morphine or hydromorphone).
9,11–13
Nor-
mally, both loss of consciousness and recovery from anesthesia are rapid and
uneventful.
13
In hatchlings, intravenous administration of anesthesia is impractical,
so the intramuscular route is used. Intrathecal anesthesia using lidocaine can also
be useful
14
and facilitates relaxation of hind limbs, tail, and cloaca, thereby facilitating
cloacoscopy, especially in larger species. Postoperative analgesics, like meloxicam or
tramadol, should also be considered.
12,13,15
Basic Equipment
Rigid telescope: 2.7 mm, 30, 18 cm with a 3.5-mm protective sheath
Xenon light source with light cable
Endovideo camera
Monitor
Fluid set for lactated Ringer solution infusion (1 drop every 3–4 seconds)
Special Equipment
Portable battery endoscope
Direct light source
Different diameter endoscopes can be used for this technique depending on the
size of the turtle and the cloaca opening. However, diameters of 1.9 mm to 4 mm
are generally preferred for most animals. In turtles weighing more than 200 g, the
diameter of the cloacal sphincter and the diameter of the bladder or accessory vesicle
entrance usually do not represent a physical limitation for this procedure. In very small
chelonians (eg, <20 g), the use of a small telescope (eg, 1.9-mm, rigid 30-viewing
endoscope) should be used to avoid possible size-related trauma. The endoscopic
Fig. 2. (A) Cloacoscopic view showing the high density of vascularized papillae in the proc-
todeum of a big-headed turtle (P megacephala). (B) Cloacoscopic view of vascularized folds
or plicae on the proctodeum in a side-necked turtle of the genus Phrinops.
Martı
´nez-Silvestre et al
6
equipment can be cleaned and disinfected by immersion in 2.4% glutaraldehyde
solution for 15 minutes and rinsed with sterile distilled or deionized water between
each procedure.
TECHNIQUE/PROCEDURE
Cloacoscopy
The patient is placed in ventral recumbency. The endoscope is inserted through the
cloaca, progressing cranially. One finger and thumb are placed around the vent to
act as a valve in order to control the fluid infusion and avoid the outflow of lactated
Ringer solution. With the animal in ventral recumbency, 4 structures can be seen
within the proctodeum: genitalia (ventral), urodeal folds, coprodeal entrance, and
entrances to accessory vesicles (see Figs. 1 and 5A). If cloacoscopic accessory vesic-
ular examination is performed, the endoscope easily enters the wide, natural
openings.
Sometimes air insufflation into the proctodeum allows easy access to the accessory
vesicles (Video 1) without the use of lactated Ringer solution. When air is used for the
expansion of the vesicles, urate or digestive remnants do not remain floating in front of
the endoscope, which can improve the overall image.
Access to the accessory vesicles is simple and decreases the possibility of forcing
or damaging the urethral opening. In species in which these structures exist, exam-
ining them before resorting to examination from within the urinary bladder is advisable.
Fig. 3. Positioning of an Amboina box turtle (Cuora amboinensis) for cloacoscopy using the
Farabeuf abdominal retractor. The instrument is used to prevent natural closure of the
caudal plastron hinge.
Cloacoscopy and Cystoscopy in Juvenile Chelonians 7
PHALLUS/CLITORIS IDENTIFICATION
The first image that is seen when the endoscope enters in the cloaca is the phallus or
clitoris. In females, the clitoris consists of a small structure similar in shape to a phallus
(Fig. 4A, see Video 1). In adult males, the phallus is bent anteriorly, has a differentiated
longitudinal groove (see Fig. 4B), glans (see Fig. 4C), and its color is normally bright
pink to black. In the Sicilian pond turtle (Emys trinacris) young tortoises can have a
gray phallus, more similar to a female clitoris.
16
Unlike squamates (phallic erection
by eversion), chelonian erection is caused by tumescence of 2 spongy bodies: the
corpus spongiosum/cavernosum and corpus fibrosum.
17,18
Therefore, differentiation
of phallus and clitoris can be difficult when the organ is flaccid within the cloaca,
and is almost impossible to identify in young or subadult individuals (see Fig. 4D).
17
In one study that attempted to identify gender in red-eared sliders (Trachemys
scripta elegans) by the presence of the phallus/clitoris, males were misdiagnosed as
females (100%) and females as males (38%). This rate clearly shows the degree of er-
ror associated with this technique.
19
In the author’s experience, in some species, the
clitoris is almost nonexistent, as in the big-headed turtle (P megacephala). In other
Fig. 4. (A) Cloacoscopic view of the clitoris of a mature Moorish tortoise (Testudo graeca).
Note the small structure similar to a phallus. (B) Cloacoscopic view of the longitudinal
groove (arrow) of the phallus in a male immature Moorish tortoise (T graeca). (C) Close
endoscopic view of a glans in an immature male Moorish tortoise (T graeca). (D) Cloaco-
scopic view of the phallus in a subadult male marginated tortoise (Testudo marginata).
Note the similarity with the clitoris in Fig. 4A.
Martı
´nez-Silvestre et al
8
species, such as the red footed tortoise (Chelonoidis carbonaria), the clitoris is highly
variable in size and degree of differentiation. Endocrine disruption can result in females
with a pseudophallus (with groove, glans, and corpus cavernosum), increasing the
possibilities of inaccurate assignment of gender.
20
CYSTOSCOPY
Insufflation of air can be performed in accessory vesicles but not in the urinary bladder,
for which warm (30C) lactated Ringer solution is preferred. If the urinary bladder is not
naturally distended with transparent urine, the operator needs to expand and distend
the bladder with fluid.
For access to the urinary bladder, the endoscope is directed toward the urethral
opening, which is located ventral to the entrance of the colon (see Fig. 4B). In a few
cases, the urethral opening is not clearly identified and the colon can be used as an
anatomic landmark (Video 2). The urethral opening is usually seen in a horizontal plane
in land tortoises (Fig. 5B), whereas it is seen in a vertical plane in terrapins and aquatic
turtles (see Fig. 5A). Once the endoscope is in the proximity of the colonic orifice, a
gentle caudal retraction of the endoscope allows visualization of the urethral opening.
9
Lactated Ringer solution (1 drop every 3 to 4 seconds) permits distension of the ure-
thral opening and aids entry into the bladder. Once access to the urinary bladder is
gained, the endoscope is guided dorsolaterally until the gonads can be seen. The uri-
nary bladder is a greatly distensible organ that can contain large quantities of fluid.
GONAD IDENTIFICATION
Chelonian gonads are located in the dorsocaudal coelom, lying cranioventrally to the
retrocoelomic kidneys. They are usually found in close association with the caudal
lungs and colon.
9
In juvenile turtles the immature testis is elongated to round/oval,
smooth, yellowish, with a smooth surface with superficial blood vessels, and attached
dorsally by a short mesorchium (Fig. 6). The epididymis is cream in color, convoluted,
and continues caudally as the ductus deferens.
Fig. 5. (A) Cloacoscopic view of the entrance to the accessory vesicles after sterile fluid infu-
sion in a male European pond turtle (E orbicularis). A, Urodeal folds; B, distal colon sphincter
(or entrance); C, accessory vesicles. (B) Cloacoscopic view of proctodeum and urodeum in a
Herman’s tortoise (Testudo hermanni) using sterile fluid infusion. A, Urodeum; B, distal
colon sphincter. Note the absence of accessory vesicles.
Cloacoscopy and Cystoscopy in Juvenile Chelonians 9
The immature oviduct is a straight, flat, transparent to white band located immedi-
ately dorsal and parallel to the ovary. The immature ovaries are long, irregular, semi-
transparent organs. Round and white to yellow follicles can be seen developing
throughout the organ. Previtellogenic follicles are separated from each other and do
not completely fill the parenchyma of the organ (Fig. 7).
19
In general, the identification of the gonad by indirect visualization through cystos-
copy is reliable, but sometimes is difficult and not safe (discussed later). This tech-
nique is easier in young terrestrial or giant tortoises (>150 g weight) than in young
Fig. 6. Close endoscopic view of the testis of a European pond turtle (E orbicularis) through
the transparent accessory vesicle membrane. Note the yellowish organ with small blood ves-
sels. The bigger blood vessels belong to the vesicle membrane.
Fig. 7. Cloacoscopic view of the ovary of a subadult European pond turtle (E orbicularis)
through the transparent accessory vesicle membrane. Note the white to yellow follicles
within the ovary.
Martı
´nez-Silvestre et al
10
turtles weighing less than 100 g. In hatchling land tortoises (Testudo hermanni) gender
identification by cystoscopy was accurate compared with gonadal histology.
9
COMPLICATIONS AND MANAGEMENT
In the author’s experience, there are several factors that can affect the reliability of
gender identification by cloacoscopy/cystoscopy:
1. Obesity. Fat tissue may cover and hide the gonads.
2. In offspring less than 6 months old, the presence of the internalized yolk sac greatly
complicates the identification of other coelomic structures, which makes this tech-
nique less helpful.
3. The presence of distended intestinal loops can hinder the identification of the
gonads. Thus, 3 days of starving can be helpful.
4. Infectious diseases that cause inflammation and loss of transparency of bladder
membranes can negatively affect visualization.
5. Emesis has been reported as an adverse reaction in 16% of anesthetized hatchling
Herman’s tortoises (T hermanni) undergoing cystoscopy.
9
POSTOPERATIVE CARE
Postoperative care is simple and usually does not require the use medication, with few
exceptions (eg, use of antiinflammatories because of mucosa damage). Usually, tor-
toises are eating and behaving normally after 24 hours.
CURRENT CONTROVERSIES/FUTURE CONSIDERATIONS
The order Testudines contains more than 300 species. This article shows that cysto-
scopic gender identification can be performed in the turtle families shown in Table 2.
However, a recent study performed in 30 clinically healthy immature (36–90 g) Tra-
chemys scripta shows that only 10% (3 of 30) of the animals had their gender accu-
rately identified by cystoscopy and 7 of 30 animals experienced bladder or cloacal
rupture.
21
Therefore, more studies are necessary to verify safety and efficacy of cysto-
scopic gender identification in different species. In addition, the gonads of chelonians
may vary in size and aspect seasonally, and this may complicate their identification,
especially in turtles that hibernate.
22,23
Further studies focusing on seasonal fluctua-
tions of gonadal morphology in chelonians are needed.
SUMMARY
Identifying sex in young chelonians by cloacoscopy or cystoscopy is an alternative
noninvasive technique (performed through natural openings) that is often effective
for the visualization of gonads. Moreover, some important anatomic differences exist
between different chelonians and further studies are necessary to verify safety and
efficacy of the procedures.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
To the veterinary technicians at the Zoologic Badalona Veterinaria, especially Simon
Lopez, as well as the technicians in the CRARC center, especially Isabel Verdaguer,
Silvia Merchan, Juan Miguel Cano, and Joaquim Soler.
Cloacoscopy and Cystoscopy in Juvenile Chelonians 11
SUPPLEMENTARY DATA
Supplementary data related to this article can be found online at http://dx.doi.org/10.
1016/j.cvex.2015.04.009.
REFERENCES
1. Ballasina D, Vandepitte V, Mochi E, et al. The necessity of reintroductions of
captive bred Geochelone sulcata. Strategies for management and set up of
captive breeding groups. International Congress on Chelonian Conservation, II.
Dakar, Senegal; 2003. 12.
2. Blanvillain G, Owens D, Kuchling G. Hormones and reproductive cycles in turtles.
In: Norris D, Lopez KH, editors. Hormones and reproduction in reptiles. London:
Academic Press; 2011. p. 277–303.
3. Hulin V, Girondot M, Godfrey MH, et al. Mixed and uniform brood sex ratio strat-
egy in turtles. In: Wyneken J, Godfrey MH, Bels V, editors. The facts, the theory
and their consequences (biology of turtles). Boca Raton (FL): CRC Press;
2008. p. 279–90.
4. Lance VA, Valenzuela N. A hormonal method to determine the sex of hatchling
giant river turtles, Podocnemis expansa. Application to endangered species
research. Am Zool 1992;32:16.
5. Gross TS, Crain DA, Bjomdal KA, et al. Identification of sex in hatchling logger-
head turtles (Caretta caretta) by analysis of steroid concentrations in chorioallan-
toic/amniotic fluid. Gen Comp Endocrinol 1995;99:204–10.
6. Xia ZR, Li PP, Gu HX, et al. Evaluating non invasive methods of sex identification
in Green sea turtle (Chelonia mydas) hatchlings. Chelonian Conservation and
Biology 2011;10:117–23.
7. Hernandez-Divers SJ, Stahl SJ, Farrell R. An endoscopic method for identifying
sex of hatchling Chinese box turtles and comparison of general versus local
anesthesia for coelioscopy. J Am Vet Med Assoc 2009;234:800–3.
8. Pickel FW. The accessory bladders of the testudinata. Zoological Bulletin 1899;
2(6):291–302.
9. Selleri P, Di Girolamo N, Melidone R. Cytoscopic sex identification of posthatch-
ling chelonians. J Am Vet Med Assoc 2013;242:1744–50.
10. Peterson CC, Gomez D. Buoyancy regulation in two species of freshwater turtle.
Herpetologica 2008;64:141–8.
11. Divers SJ, Innis CJ, Stah SJ, et al. Coelioscopic orchidectomy in red-eared terra-
pins (Trachemys scripta elegans): a model for chelonian endosurgery. ICARE
2013;1:125–6.
12. Innis CJ. Endoscopy and endosurgery of the chelonian reproductive tract. Vet
Clin North Am Exot Anim Pract 2010;13:243–54.
13. Divers SJ. Reptile diagnostic endoscopy and endosurgery. Vet Clin North Am
Exot Anim Pract 2010;13:217–42.
14. Mans C, Lahner LL, Steagall P, et al. Feasibility, efficacy and inter-operator vari-
ability of spinal anaesthesia in female red-eared slider turtles (Trachemys scripta
elegans). ICARE 2013;1:162–3.
15. Greenace CB, Paul-Murphy J, Sladky KK, et al. Reptile and amphibian analgesia.
J Herp Med Surg 2005;15:24–9.
16. Spadola F, Insaccoi G. Endoscopy of cloaca in 51 Emys trinacris (Frist et al,
2005): morphological and diagnostic study. Acta Herpetologica 2009;4:73–81.
17. Larkins CE, Cohn MJ. Phallus development in the turtle Trachemys scripta. Sex
Develop 2014;1–9. http://dx.doi.org/10.1159/000363631.
Martı
´nez-Silvestre et al
12
18. DeSolla SR, Portelli MJ, Spiro H, et al. Penis displays of snapping turtles (Chely-
dra serpentina) in response to handling: defensive or displacement behavior?
Chelonian Conservation and Biology 2001;4:187–9.
19. Perpin
˜an D, Costa T, Bargallo, et al. Correlation between gonad histology and
endoscopic sex determination in juvenile red-eared turtles (Trachemys scripta
elegans). ICARE 2013;1:126–7.
20. Guix JC, Fedullo DL, Molina FB. Masculinization of captive females of Chelonoidis
carbonaria (Testudinidae). Rev Esp Herpetol 2001;15:67–77.
21. Proenc¸a L. Comparison between coelioscopy versus cloacoscopy for gender
identification in immature turtles (Trachemys scripta). ICARE, II, Paris, France.
142–43.
22. Carvalho D, Cesar dos Santos A, Fernandes L, et al. Body and testicular biomet-
ric parameters of the scorpion mud turtle (Kinosternon scorpioides). Acta Scien-
tiarium 2014;36:477–81.
23. Casares M, Ru
¨bel A, Honegger RE. Observations on the female reproductive
cycle of captive giant tortoises (Geochelone spp.) using ultrasound scanning.
J Zoo Wildl Med 1997;28(3):267–73.
Cloacoscopy and Cystoscopy in Juvenile Chelonians 13
... The technique is based on the identification of four papillae in the urodeum of females: two cranial papillae corresponding to the openings of the oviducts and two caudal papillae corresponding to the openings of the ureters (ureteral papillae). In mature males, only the two ureteral papillae are present [49,[55][56][57] (Figure 11). ...
... The technique is based on the identification of four papillae in the urodeum of females: two cranial papillae corresponding to the openings of the oviducts and two caudal papillae corresponding to the openings of the ureters (ureteral papillae). In mature males, only the two ureteral papillae are present [49,[55][56][57] (Figure 11). Cloacoscopy for early sex identification was used in one-year-old Varanus cumingi and Varanus macraei. ...
... In this study, sex was accurately determined by observing the urodeum (which is blind-ended in males) and two ostia (oviduct outlets) in females [56]. Via cloacoscopic examination in sexually mature chelonians, it is possible to identify the phallus located on the floor of the urodeum in males and the clitoris in females [57]. However, in some cases, hormonal imbalances can cause females to develop a pseudophallus with features resembling those of a true phallus, such as a groove, glans, and corpus cavernosum. ...
Article
Full-text available
Reptile biodiversity is rapidly declining, with over 11,733 recognized species across 1226 genera being documented, many of which are endangered. Captive breeding programs play a crucial role in conservation; however, effective management requires accurate sex determination, especially due to the fact that many reptile species exhibit minimal or no sexual dimorphism. When present, sexual dimorphism manifests as differences such as size, coloration, and morphological features influenced by evolutionary pressures and hormones. Various sex determination techniques are employed due to the lack of external sexual characteristics in many species. These methods include probing, hydrostatic eversion, popping, ultrasound, CT, radiography, contrast radiography, endoscopy, and genotypic sex determination. Accurate sex determination is crucial for the success of captive breeding programs and the conservation of reptile species. Advanced imaging and molecular methods offer promising non-invasive alternatives but may not be universally accessible or effective. An understanding of the unique reproductive anatomy and the use of appropriate sexing techniques are fundamental to establishing breeding groups, preventing aggressive behaviours among groups, and ensuring the long-term survival of endangered reptile populations.
... These include cloacoscopy, cystoscopy, anti-Mü llerian hormone (AMH) detection, and coelioscopy. 16,31 Cloacoscopy and cystoscopy have been successfully used to visualize gonads for sex identification in numerous species, and these techniques may be less invasive as they do not require an incision. 16 However, cloacoscopy is not a reliable method to differentiate the phallus and clitoris to determine sex because both structures appear almost identical in sexually immature chelonians. ...
... 16,31 Cloacoscopy and cystoscopy have been successfully used to visualize gonads for sex identification in numerous species, and these techniques may be less invasive as they do not require an incision. 16 However, cloacoscopy is not a reliable method to differentiate the phallus and clitoris to determine sex because both structures appear almost identical in sexually immature chelonians. 16 Discomfort may be associated with cystoscopy and bladder insufflation, but a lighter plane of anesthesia or the use of sedation with local anesthetics could be used for this procedure, which may facilitate rapid recoveries in the field. ...
... 16 However, cloacoscopy is not a reliable method to differentiate the phallus and clitoris to determine sex because both structures appear almost identical in sexually immature chelonians. 16 Discomfort may be associated with cystoscopy and bladder insufflation, but a lighter plane of anesthesia or the use of sedation with local anesthetics could be used for this procedure, which may facilitate rapid recoveries in the field. Anesthesia times are reported to be up to approximately 20 min, usually shorter, when using cystoscopy in a hospital setting. ...
Article
Evaluation of sex ratios is a critical component of chelonian captive breeding programs and may become increasingly useful to assess the demographics of free-living populations. In many reptile species, the sex of immature animals cannot be determined based on external features. Endoscopic sex identification is an accurate and safe method to identify the sex of immature individuals of some chelonian species. A number of studies describe this technique in controlled, hospital settings and report significant interspecies variations in gonad morphology; however, there are few reports describing this technique in field conditions. In the current study, the gonadal morphology of 40 immature Western Santa Cruz tortoises (Chelonoidis porteri) on Santa Cruz Island in Galapagos, Ecuador, was assessed. A previously described endoscopic protocol was used to perform sex identification under field conditions. Tortoises were anesthetized using an intramuscular injection of ketamine (10 mg/kg) and medetomidine (0.1 mg/kg), which provided an adequate plane of anesthesia. The medetomidine was reversed with atipamezole (0.5 mg/kg). Field conditions presented challenges such as limited control over lighting, suboptimal patient positioning, and restricted power supply for endoscopy equipment. The immature testicle in Western Santa Cruz tortoises was oval, reddish pink, and tightly adhered to the coelomic membrane ventral to the kidney. The surface of the gonads resembled other species with the notable exception that the ovaries lacked a significant number of primordial follicles. These gonadal characteristics were consistent, with only one individual identified as undetermined sex of the 40 samples. This field-based endoscopic gonadal evaluation was a safe and sensitive technique for determining the sex of free-living immature Western Santa Cruz Galapagos tortoises.
... However, gonadal ultrasound is only useful when applied to adult, sexually mature lizards (Reed et al., 2012;Stetter, 2006). Cloacoscopy has proved a feasible method of sex determination in many reptile species (Schildger et al., 1989;1999;Kuchling, 2006;Spadola et al., 2009;Divers, 2010;Innis, 2010;Selleri et al., 2013;Martínez-Silvestre et al., 2015;Perpinan et al., 2016;Spadola et al., 2021). However, to date no information on cloacoscopy of tegus has been published. ...
... Cloacoscopy is an important tool in the study of cloacal anatomy. Cloacoscopy and cystoscopy have also been proposed as useful methods of sex determination in young chelonians by indirect visualisation of gonads through the urinary bladder wall (Selleri et al., 2013;Martínez-Silvestre et al., 2015); recently cloacoscopy has been used for sex determination in lizards (Morici et al., 2017), and to aid artificial insemination in snakes (Oliveri et al., 2017;. There is great variability in cloacal morphology between reptile species (Morici et al., 2017;Oliveri et al., 2016;Spadola et al., 2009;2015;, and the physician should achieve a detailed knowledge of these differences before attempting sex determination through cloacoscopy. ...
... E ndoscopy can be used for direct observati on of anatomy of the cloaca (Martí nez- Silvestre et al., 2015;Oliveri et al., 2016;Spadola et al., 2009). The fi rst report of endoscopy applied to repti les was published in 1983 (Wood et al., 1983) but it is only in the last few years that endoscopy has become common in routi ne clinical practi ce. ...
Article
Full-text available
A rigid endoscope was used to examine the cloacae of an adult pair of Tiliqua gigas gigas, and single specimens of Tiliqua gigas evanescens and Tiliqua sp. (Irian Jaya form). Throughout the procedure the animals showed no signs of stress. Clear anatomical differences were observed between the sexes. Females presented the typical two pairs of papillae (ureteral and genital) and males a single pair of urogenital papillae. The observed differences were confirmed when both pairs bred successfully in the following year.
... However, SD studies of Chelonoidis have not progressed because sexually dimorphic characteristics typically take many years to develop and it is unacceptable to conduct risky procedures on individuals so valuable to conservation. Therefore, the development of quick, easy, and harmless ways to identify the sex of hatchlings (e.g., Burke et al. 1994;Mrosovsky et al. 1999;Valenzuela et al. 2004;Martínez-Silvestre et al. 2015) are potentially very valuable. ...
Article
Full-text available
Sex determination (SD) mode is documented in only 26% of turtle species; temperature dependent sex determination (TSD) is common but not ubiquitous. SD mode is documented for only five tortoise species; all of these have TSD with the Ia pattern. Temperature dependent sex determination was reported in Galápagos tortoises (Chelonoidis nigra complex) in 1991 based solely on a personal communication. Here we report TSD pattern, incubation duration, and hatchling sexual dimorphism in the Española Giant Tortoise (Chelonoidis hoodensis) of the Galápagos Islands based on experiments conducted in 1986-87. We found strong evidence for Type Ia TSD, a pivotal incubation temperature of 28.3 °C, and a range for transition temperatures of 25.2-31.4 °C. We also found longer incubation durations for male than for female hatchlings, and describe a new method for sex identification for hatchling tortoises. These results have important implications for incubation of eggs for head-starting captive breeding, especially for conservation purposes, and for interpretation of data from natural nests. We caution against the assumption that all C. nigra complex species have similar pivotal or transitional temperature ranges, and encourage evaluation of more species in this group. Resumen.-El modo de determinación sexual (DS) solamente se ha documentado para el 26% de las especies de tortugas; la determinación del sexo por la temperatura (DST) en las tortugas es común pero no es generalizada. Se conoce el modo SD solamente para cinco especies de tortugas; todas ellas tienen el modo de DST. Se reportó en 1991 la determinación TSD para las tortugas de Galápagos (complejo Chelonoidis nigra), sobre la base de una comunicación personal. En este trabajo reportamos el patrón de DST, la duración de la incubación y el dimorfismo sexual a la eclosión en Chelonoidis hoodensis (la Tortuga Gigante de Española de las Islas Galápagos), sobre la base de experimentos realizados entre 1986-87. Nosotros encontramos firme evidencia para el DST tipo Ia, una temperatura pivotal de incubación de 28.3 °C y un rango de temperaturas transicionales de 25.2-31.4 °C. También detectamos que los períodos de incubación hasta la eclosión de tortugas machos fueron más prolongados en comparación con las hembras. Estos resultados tienen implicaciones ventajosas e importantes para la incubación de los huevos y para la interpretación de datos tomados de nidos naturales. Sugerimos evitar el inferir que todas las especies del complejo C. nigra tengan rangos de temperaturas transicionales similares y sugerimos la evaluación de más especies dentro de este grupo.
Article
Objective: To compare the effect of two anaesthetic protocols on heart rate (HR), time to muscle relaxation and tracheal intubation and time to surgical plane of anaesthesia, in Trachemys scripta spp. undergoing oophorectomy. Study design: Prospective randomized clinical study. Animals: A total of 43 healthy female turtles. Methods: Morphine (1.5 mg kg-1) was injected subcutaneously 2 hours before anaesthesia induction. The turtles were randomly administered either medetomidine (0.2 mg kg-1) and ketamine (10 mg kg-1) (group MK; n = 23) or alfaxalone (20 mg kg-1) (group A; n = 20) intramuscularly followed by bupivacaine (2 mg kg-1) administered subcutaneously along the incision site. Anaesthesia was maintained with isoflurane delivered in oxygen (100%). HR and the anaesthetic depth score (ADS) were recorded every 5 minutes from induction to recovery. A Friedman test followed by Wilcoxon tests with Bonferroni adjustment were used to compare these non-parametric data (HR and ADS) between groups and over time. Time to muscle relaxation of neck and limbs (TMR), tracheal tube insertion (TTTI) and stage of surgical anaesthesia (TADS≤3) were recorded and compared between groups using a Welch's t test after logarithmic transformation. Results: Median values of TMR, TTTI and TADS≤3 were 4, 9.5 and 25 minutes in group A, respectively, and 14, 20 and 35 minutes in group MK (TMR, TTTIp ≤ 0.0001; TADS≤3p = 0.001). Plane of anaesthesia was significantly deeper in group A than in group MK for the first 20 minutes (p < 0.01). HR at 10 and 15 minutes post injection was significantly lower in group MK (28 beats minute-1) than in group A (36 and 34 beats minute-1) (p < 0.02). Conclusions and clinical relevance: After intramuscular injection in Trachemys scripta spp., tracheal intubation, muscle relaxation and a surgical plane of anaesthesia developed faster with alfaxalone than medetomidine-ketamine.
Article
We studied the determination of sex for intermediate size classes and adult sexual dimorphism in a Georgia population of Macrochelys temminckii (Alligator Snapping Turtle). We sexed turtles when possible based on size and morphometrics. We took blood samples from captured individuals and measured plasma testosterone using enzyme-linked immunoassay. We examined females and individuals for which sex was unknown using ultrasound to determine sex and reproductive status. We used testosterone concentration to confirm individual sex assignments. For all biometric measurements, adult males were larger than females. Testosterone concentrations were higher in adult and subadult males than in females. Head width did not differ between the sexes when adjusted for body size. Plastron-to-vent length (cm) and testosterone concentrations were significantly greater in adult and subadult male turtles compared to females and were valuable in determining sex of smaller adults >25 cm straight-midline carapace length.
Article
A wild, adult, female Florida cooter (Pseudemys floridana floridana) was evaluated for injuries sustained after vehicular trauma. On presentation the turtle had a minimally displaced caudal carapacial fracture, marked hyphema in the right eye, epistaxis, and frank hemorrhage from the cloaca. Immediately following initial triage, the turtle laid eight eggs and produced seven more over 72 h. After approximately 3 wk of hospitalization and treatment, the turtle received access to an outdoor water enclosure. Positive buoyancy was observed and a large, gas-filled, Y-shaped structure was identified in the caudal coelom via computed tomography. Cloacoscopy confirmed right-sided accessory cystitis, secondary to a focal necrotic wound with a mixed bacterial infection. After wound debridement and 3 wk of antibiotic therapy, the patient successfully submerged, there was no gas present in the accessory bladders, and the previous necrotic wound showed excellent healing on recheck cloacoscopy. This is the first report of accessory cystitis in the literature and it should be considered a differential for positive buoyancy in chelonian species that possess accessory bladders.
Article
Objective: To compare a ventral and a left lateral endoscopic approach to coelioscopy in bearded dragons (Pogona vitticeps). Animals: 18 adult bearded dragons. Procedures: In a randomized crossover design involving 2 surgical approaches, anesthetized bearded dragons first underwent coelioscopy with a ventral approach (left lateral of midline next to the umbilicus; animal positioned in dorsal recumbency) or left lateral approach (intercostal; animal positioned in right lateral recumbency) and then with the alternate approach. A 2.7-mm × 18-cm, 30° oblique telescope with a 4.8-mm operating sheath and CO2 insufflation at 2 to 5 mm Hg were used. Ease of entry into the coelom and ease of visual examination of visceral structures were scored. Results: Both approaches were straightforward, with the left lateral approach requiring significantly more time than the ventral approach. Scores for ease of visual examination for the heart, lungs, liver, stomach, intestines, pancreas, gallbladder, left kidney, gonads, and fat body were good to excellent. Visual examination of the spleen and adrenal glands was difficult in most animals via either approach. The left kidney, testis, and vas deferens were easier to see with the left lateral approach, whereas the pancreas in females and gallbladder in both sexes were easier to see with the ventral approach. All bearded dragons recovered without complications from the procedures, except for one with nephritis, renal gout, and hepatic necrosis. Conclusions and clinical relevance: Both coelioscopy approaches could be safely and effectively used in bearded dragons. Choice of approach should be based on the coelomic structures requiring evaluation.
Chapter
Full-text available
Reproductive cycles of cryptodire turtles and species from the northern hemisphere have been investigated extensively compared to those of pleurodire species from the southern hemisphere. Radiography, laparoscopy, and ultrasonography have been used on a few species of turtle to describe a diversity of ovarian and testicular cycles. Radioimmunoassays (RIAs), on the other hand, have provided evidence of the dynamic cycling of peptides and steroid hormones within a reproductive season. All turtles are cyclic breeders and show a range of annual and multiannual reproductive patternsdregulated by nutritional status and environmental conditionsdwhich are most often described as prenuptial or postnuptial. These cycles may be seasonally coordinated by an active pineal gland in the brain via melatonin secretion affecting the hypothalamus. Moreover, the steroid hormone cycles can be rapid and dynamic, and steroid hormones stimulate a carefully orchestrated mating receptivity period: a series of rapid ovulations in the case of multiclutched turtles, egg production, and oviposition events.
Article
Full-text available
The reptile Kinosternon scorpioides is a freshwater chelonian, popularly known as jurará, and is found in the Baixada Maranhense, Maranhão State, Brazil. Due to the lack of scientific information on the reproductive biology of the species, current paper describes the body and testicular biometry and the gonad-somatic index (GSI) in adult specimens collected from the natural environment. Twenty male adults were collected in the rainy (n = 10) and dry (n = 10) seasons. Data were derived from the body, testis size and GSI and tests of correlation between these measures were performed. The body biometrics of free-living Kinosternon scorpioides is similar to those found in other studies for adult animals bred in captivity. The body weight was higher in animals collected in the rainy season than that in animals collected in the dry season. The testis size presents variations among animals captured during the rainy and dry season, but the gonadossomatic index did not vary between different groups of animals. Further studies were suggested related to the levels of sexual steroid hormones and behavioral studies to understand the factors related to the species´s reproductive cycle. © 2014, Eduem - Editora da Universidade Estadual de Maringa. All rights reserved.
Article
Full-text available
Development of a phallus occurs in almost all amniotes; however, considerable variation in phallus morphology among different amniote lineages has contributed to the debate about their structural homology. Mammals are the only amniotes that form a closed urethral tube within the penis. In contrast, the phallus of reptiles and birds has an open urethral groove, or sulcus spermaticus, that facilitates directional flow of sperm along the penis. One condition of structural homology is that the organs should share a common developmental origin; de novo development from different embryonic progenitors would indicate that the structure re-evolved in a new position. Although a common developmental origin does not itself demonstrate homology, different origins could indicate a lack of homology. To further understand how development of external genitalia evolved in amniotes, we examined this in the turtle Trachemys scripta. We found that phallus development in the turtle closely resembles that of mice at the tissue, cellular, and molecular levels, consistent with the hypothesis that their phalluses are homologous structures. We find that acquisition of specialized characters, such as a closed urethral tube, involved lineage-specific specialization of the common plan for amniote phallus development. © 2014 S. Karger AG, Basel.
Article
Full-text available
In this work the authors are describing cloaca anatomy, pathological findings and endoscopic technique applied to Emys trinacris (Fritz et al., 2005). The study has been performed on 51 wild subjects of different age and size hosted in a rescue center. Cloacoscopy is proposed as a tool for sexing turtles with reduced sexual dimorphism.
Article
Full-text available
Coelioscopy has been proven to be a valuable technique to determine the sex of juvenilechelonians. However, there has been controversy regarding the proper way to identify testes andovaries. Controversy has arisen from the lack of studies correlating histology of the gonad with theresults of the endoscopic examination. In this study, we assessed two methods of sexdetermination in 15 juvenile (93-164 g) Trachemys scripta : coelioscopy with direct gonadvisualization, and cloacoscopy with phallus/clitoris visualization. We later compared these withpost-mortem examination and histology of the gonads. The veterinarian performing cloacoscopy(AMS) did not know the results from the veterinarian performing coelioscopy (DP), and vice-versa.In addition, the pathologist (TC) did not know the results from coelioscopy and cloacoscopy.Histology correlated 100% with the results from coelioscopies, but only 53.33% of the sexingresults made by cloacoscopy were accurate. Cloacoscopy diagnosed 100% of males as femalesand 38.46% of females as males. Testicle in juvenile turtles was a round to oval, smooth, yelloworgan, with blood vessels on its surface and attached to the dorsal structures by short but evidentligaments on both poles. Ovaries were long, irregular, semi-transparent organs where developing,round, white to yellow follicles could be seen developing inside the organ. Follicles were separatedfrom each other and did not fill completely the parenchyma of the organ.
Article
Coelioscopic orchiectomy was performed in 27 male turtles (25 juvenile to adult red-eared sliders (Trachemys scripta elegans), one adult eastern painted turtle (Chrysems picta picta), and one juvenile male yellow-spotted Amazon River turtle (Podocnemis unifilis)). Orchiectomy was conducted under coelioscopic visualisation using ligation and transection of the mesorchium, or transection of the mesorchium with monopolar radiosurgical scissors. In 22 cases, bilateral orchiectomy was performed through a single incision; five turtles required bilateral incisions. All turtles recovered from anaesthesia. Nine turtles died within one year of surgery from conditions believed to be unrelated to surgery. One turtle was lost to follow-up. Seventeen turtles remain clinically healthy one to three years postoperatively. Coelioscopic orchiectomy provides a minimally invasive method for sterilisation of male chelonians and provides excellent visualisation during surgery. This technique is a useful model for the development of additional minimally invasive surgical techniques for chelonians.
Article
The costs of an aquatic life are likely to be strongly influenced by all animal's buoyancy, which call be measured as specific gravity (SG). The shells of chelonians are negatively buoyant, and the tendency to sink is opposed by air in the longs. Turtles call therefore regulate buoyancy by adjusting residual long volume, but must do so within the constraint of a relatively fixed body volume set by the rigid shell. Emydids have been reported to effect changes in lung volume with reciprocal changes in the volume of water stored ill the urinary bladder and, perhaps, for rapid short-term adjustments, the cloacal bursae. We examined buoyancy control in two species, the eastern painted turtle Chrysemys picta (Emydidae), which has well-developed cloacal bursae, and the common musk turtle Sternotherus odoratus (Kinosternidae), which lacks bursae. We measured SG in captive turtles, then manipulated SG by attaching either weights or floats, and measured SG again at 4 h and 24 h after attachment. Initial SG was consistently and significantly higher in bottom-walking Sternotherus (1.03) than in more free-swimming Chrysemys (1.01). Both species compensated nearly completely for weights up to 6% of body mass by decreasing weight ill water (reflecting higher long volumes); compensation in both species was mostly complete at 4 h. Both species also compensated for attached floats (buoyant forces equivalent to up to 4% of body mass in Sternotherus and at least 7% in Chrysemys) by decreasing lung volume. Long volume changes (ganged by underwater weight) were not matched by changes in stored water volume (ganged by body mass in air) in Sternotherus and only partially matched in Chrysemys. Changes in lung volume did not affect surfacing frequency. Small differences in buoyancy regulation between species reflect differences in natural history and, presumably, morphology, bot neither the mechanisms of chronic lung-volume maintenance nor the function of cloacal bursae are clear.