ArticlePDF Available

A prospective "Study by Correspondance" on the effects of Kneipp hydrotherapy in patients with complaints due to peripheral neuropathy

Authors:
  • Hochschule für Gesundheit und Sport, Berlin
  • Charité Universitätsmedizin Berlin and Immanuel Krankenhaus

Abstract and Figures

Background: Kneipp hydrotherapy is often recommended to reduce symptoms of peripheral neuropathy on the basis that the cold stimulus could influence neuronal networking and that improvement of circulation and metabolism could improve local neuronal function. However, no data on clinical effectiveness are available. Aim of the Study: To evaluate the effectiveness of and compliance with hydrotherapeutic self-treatment in patients with peripheral neuropathy (PNP). Design of the Study: Preliminary open prospective observational "study by correspondence": Patients received written information, instructions and questionnaires without direct contact with the study physician. Methods: Patients with interest in participation were enrolled from self-help groups and by TV and internet and were given instructions. They were asked to self treat at home daily using at least two out of four Kneipp hydrotherapeutic applications (knee affusion, cold foot-bath, alternating foot-bath, wet socks). After 8 weeks of treatment, patients returned their diaries with self-ratings of complaints before and after each application as well as their judgments before the cure and at its end. Results: We received completed forms from 27 patients (15 females, 12 males; mean age 68.2 years). Patients reported a significant decrease in dysesthesia from a mean of 3.4 (baseline) to 2.9 (t-test, 2p<0.04) after the cure. Hypesthesia (numbness) improved from 3.5 to 3.1 (2p<0.12). There were no significant changes for total pain (2.6 to 2.5) and paresis (0.8 to 0.8). Acute relief of symptoms was reported after 30-62% of applications with an increasing trend during the cure versus acute impairments only after 5 to 9% of applications. Conclusions: Our results give hints for effectiveness of self-treatment with hydrotherapy in patients with PNP - at least in a subgroup of them. Yet, there are limitations of the interpretation of the results of this uncontrolled study. Efficacy might be better after detailed and personal instruction on the hydrotherapeutic procedures. Conducting a prospective "study by correspondence" seems to be appropriate at least for generating preliminary data for natural healing self-treatments under realistic everyday conditions.
Content may be subject to copyright.
A Prospective “Study by Correspondence”
on the Effects of Kneipp Hydrotherapy in Patients
with Complaints due to Peripheral Neuropathy
Bernhard Uehleke1, Heike Wöhling2, Rainer Stange1
1Charité Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Immanuel-Krankenhaus, Dep. for Natural Healing, Berlin, Germany
2DABIO Gesellschaft für Auftragsforschung mbH, Höhenkirchen, Germany
Paresthesia and other malfunction
of sense are typical complaints of
peripheral neuropathy (PNP) which
are most often located symmetrically
in the lower limbs. In more severe
forms, there are also paresis, muscu-
lar atrophy and trophical changes of
the skin. The prevalence of PNP is esti-
mated at 1:2500 inhabitants in Ger-
many. Etiologic relations include meta-
bolic diseases, intoxications, infections
and immunological diseases, yet in
many patients their etiology remains
unclear. The diagnosis is based on
anamnesis, neurological examinations,
particularly on nerve conduction ve-
locity [1].
The therapy focusses on the under-
lying disease, provided there is one,
and consists of supplementation of
neurotrophic vitamins and α-liponic
acid, the latter mainly for patients with
diabetes mellitus [2]. Other sympto-
matic treatments with drugs include
calcium channel blockers in patients
with muscle cramps, antiphlogistics,
analgetics and antidepressants as well
as topically applied capsicum extract
standardized to capsaicin [3].
Various methods of physiotherapy
are also used for the treatment of the
symptoms of polyneuropathy, also hy-
drotherapy is recommended. There
are no systematic investigations about
hydrotherapy. Hydrotherapeutic appli-
cations in the tradition of Sebastian
Kneipp (1821–97) are administered lo-
cally as cold stimulus with short dura-
tion, thereby inducing a local reactive
hyperemia, involving neuronal, vege-
tative, endocrinal and immunological
systems [4]. Long-term treatment with
a series of hydrotherapeutic measures
Background: Kneipp hydrotherapy is often recommended to reduce symptoms of peripheral neu-
ropathy on the basis that the cold stimulus could influence neuronal networking and that improve-
ment of circulation and metabolism could improve local neuronal function. However, no data on clin-
ical effectiveness are available. Aim of the Study: To evaluate the effectiveness of and compliance
with hydrotherapeutic self-treatment in patients with peripheral neuropathy (PNP). Design of the
Study: Preliminary open prospective observational “study by correspondence”: Patients received
written information, instructions and questionnaires without direct contact with the study physician.
Methods: Patients with interest in participation were enrolled from self-help groups and by TV and
internet and were given instructions.They were asked to self treat at home daily using at least two
out of four Kneipp hydrotherapeutic applications (knee affusion, cold foot-bath, alternating foot-bath,
wet socks). After 8 weeks of treatment, patients returned their diaries with self-ratings of com-
plaints before and after each application as well as their judgments before the cure and at its end.
Results: We received completed forms from 27 patients (15 females, 12 males; mean age 68.2
years). Patients reported a significant decrease in dysesthesia from a mean of 3.4 (baseline) to 2.9
(t-test, 2p<0.04) after the cure. Hypesthesia (numbness) improved from 3.5 to 3.1 (2p<0.12). There
were no significant changes for total pain (2.6 to 2.5) and paresis (0.8 to 0.8). Acute relief of symp-
toms was reported after 30–62% of applications with an increasing trend during the cure versus
acute impairments only after 5 to 9% of applications. Conclusions: Our results give hints for effec-
tiveness of self-treatment with hydrotherapy in patients with PNP – at least in a subgroup of them.
Yet, there are limitations of the interpretation of the results of this uncontrolled study. Efficacy might
be better after detailed and personal instruction on the hydrotherapeutic procedures. Conducting a
prospective “study by correspondence” seems to be appropriate at least for generating preliminary
data for natural healing self-treatments under realistic everyday conditions.
Keywords: Kneipp, hydrotherapy, peripheral neuropathy, study by correspondence
Eine prospektive „Fernstudie“
(Study by Correspondence)
über die Wirkung der Kneipp Hydrotherapie bei Patienten
mit Beschwerden infolge einer Polyneuropathie
Hintergrund: Kneippsche Hydrotherapie wird zur Symptomlinderung im Rahmen von Polyneuro-
pathie empfohlen. Der Kältestimulus könnte die Funktion der neuronalen Netze beeinflussen und
die Anregung der Durchblutung könnte die neuronale Funktion lokal verbessern. Allerdings sind
keine Daten über die klinische Wirksamkeit bekannt. Studienziel: Untersuchung von Wirksamkeit
und Compliance einer hydrotherapeutischen Selbstbehandlung bei Patienten mit Polyneuropathie
(PNP). Studiendesign: Preliminäre offene prospektive Beobachtungsstudie („Fernstudie“, “Study
by correspondence“): Die Patienten erhielten schriftlich Informationen, Anleitungen und Fragebö-
gen ohne direkten Kontakt mit einem Prüfarzt. Methoden: Patienten mit Interesse an der Teilnahme
wurden über Selbsthilfegruppen sowie über TV und Internet angesprochen und erhielten die Unter-
lagen. Sie sollten mindestens zwei von vier Kneippanwendungen täglich zu Hause durchführen (Knie-
guss, kaltes Fussbad, Wechselfussbad und nasse Socken). Nach 8-wöchiger Behandlung schickten
die Patienten ihre ausgefüllten Fragebögen und Tagebücher mit Bewertungen der Beschwerden
vor und nach jeder einzelnen Anwendung ein sowie ihre Gesamtbeurteilung ihrer Beschwerden vor
und nach der Kur. Ergebnisse: Wir erhielten ausgefüllte Fragebögen von 27 Patienten (15 Frauen
und 12 Männer, durchschnittliches Alter 68,2 Jahre). Nach Abschluss der kurmässigen Anwen-
dungen berichteten die Patienten eine signifikante mittlere Abnahme der Dysaesthesie von 3,4 (Ba-
seline) auf 2,9 (t-test, 2p<0,04). Hypaesthesie (Taubheit) verbesserte sich von 3,5 auf 3,1 (2p<0,12).
Es gab keine signifikanten Änderungen für Gesamtschmerz (2,6 auf 2,5) und für Parese (0,8 auf
0,8). Eine akute Symptomlinderung wurde nach 30–62% der Anwendungen berichtet mit einer Zu-
nahme während der Kur, während akute Verschlimmerungen nur nach 5–9 % der Anwendungen
berichtet wurden. Schlussfolgerungen: Unsere Ergebnisse geben Hinweise auf eine Wirksamkeit
von Selbstbehandlung mit Hydrotherapie bei Patienten mit PNP – mindestens in einer Untergruppe.
Es gibt Limitierungen für die Interpretation der Ergebnisse in dieser speziellen unkontrollierten Stu-
die. Die Wirksamkeit könnte jedoch besser ausfallen nach einer detaillierten persönlichen Schulung
über die Wasseranwendungen. Die Methode einer „Fernstudie“ erscheint wenigstens zur Erhe-
bung preliminärer Daten über naturheilkundliche Selbstbehandlungen angemessen und zeigt ein
realistisches Bild unter Alltagsbedingungen.
Schlüsselwörter: Kneipp, Hydrotherapie, Wassertherapie, Polyneuropathie, Fernstudie
Schweiz. Zschr. GanzheitsMedizin 20 (5), September 2008 287
Schweiz. Zschr. GanzheitsMedizin 2008;20(5):287–291. © Verlag für GanzheitsMedizin, Basel. www.ganzheitsmedizin.ch
Originalarbeit R
Original Article
is expected to train sensory feeling,
circulation and metabolism in skin and
the peripheral muscle. In addition, a
series of hydrotherapy induces an
adaptation to stressor stimuli [5] and
influences local and systemic immuno-
logical functions (“hardening”).
There is a marked hyperemia for
about 1 hour after a short cold stimu-
lus in the affected skin region [6]. A
general improvement of peripheral
circulation after serial application of
Kneipp hydrotherapeutic measures
has been shown in several studies [7].
A better circulation should improve
the impaired neuronal function in PNP.
Furthermore, there are many complex
physiologic and psychologic aspects of
self-treatment with cold water applica-
tions which might be relevant for per-
ception and reporting of neuropathic
symptoms.
In order to investigate the efficacy
of Kneipp hydrotherapy, we performed
a first preliminary study as prospective
intervention study in outpatients with-
out personal contact to the study
physician. The patients were given
written information and instructions,
were asked to complete questionnaires
and to document in a diary symptoms
and applications over a study period of
8 weeks under self-treatment. This
type of study setting is new and was
named ‘study by correspondence’. The
only difference to normal open obser-
vational clinical studies is that there is
no direct contact between patient and
study physician. There is no reason
why a patient could not document his
history and his symptoms in well-ex-
plained questionnaires. Kneipp Hydro-
therapy with several daily applications,
on written or personal instruction, is
normally a self-treatment anyway.
Materials and Methods
Patients
This was an open prospective study on
the effects of Kneipp hydrotherapy in
patients with complaints due to PNP.
Study information material had been
distributed to approximately 100 inter-
ested patients (most of them by pa-
tients’ self-help groups, some patients
had become aware of this study on TV
and internet); only 27 patients, however,
returned completed questionnaires.
There was no inclusion limitation
with regard to severity of complaints,
yet, we did not advise to apply hydro-
therapy in more severe cases of pare-
sis. There were also no limitations re-
garding etiology and status of diagno-
sis but we asked in our questionnaires
for all available respective information.
Intervention
The intervention consisted of a series
of hydrotherapeutic applications ac-
cording Kneipp to be applied by the pa-
tients themselves. They were advised
to continue with any prior therapies.
They were given extensive written in-
structions how to apply the following
four Kneipp applications: cold “knee
affusion”, cold “wet socks”, “footbath”
(= cold bath of lower limbs), alternat-
ing foot bath. These applications have
in common that they provide a short
but intensive cold stimulus by using
water as cold as available (appr.
15° C). Patients were informed that the
applications should induce local physi-
ological reactions (initial vasoconstric-
tion, followed by a longer lasting hyper-
emia) as well as systemic vegetative re-
actions including neurohormonal and
circulatory reactions. As partial appli-
cations on the lower limbs, they should
lead to moderate reactions and should
usually be well tolerated.
A knee affusion is applied by means
of a wide-lumen (3/4”) water hose with
a steady low-pressure flow of cold wa-
ter in order to avoid mechanical stimu-
lation of the skin. It starts at the right
fore-foot, is then directed upwards the
calf to a few inches above the hollow of
the knee, remains there for about 10
seconds and goes down at the inner
side of the calf. Then the procedure is
repeated in similar manner at the front
side and afterwards the other leg is
treated. The affusion is terminated
with a short affusion of the soles. The
whole procedure takes no longer than
one minute.
For the foot-bath, a bucket filled
with cold water – its surface reaching
some inches below the knee – is re-
quired. The foot-bath lasts 10 to 30
seconds and is terminated immediately
as soon as a cold pain is felt.
For the alternating foot bath, two
buckets, one with cold (ca. 15° C) and
one with warm water (ca. 36° C) are
used. After having started with the
warm foot bath for 3 minutes, one
changes to the cold water bath for ap-
prox. 20 seconds. This procedure has
to be repeated immediately and has al-
ways to be finished with the cold bath
in order to induce the reactions after
the cold stimulus as described above.
Wet socks of cotton are moistened
with cold water and then applied. Hav-
ing warmed-up after approximately 30
minutes, they are taken off before on-
set of sweating
Patients were asked to apply two to
four of these Kneipp applications each
day. Patients were free to choose the
time of day and the type of each appli-
cation.
Questionnaire and diary
The questionnaire sent to the patients
asked for demographic data, general
feeling, physical activities, use of nico-
tine and alcohol, history and etiology
of PNP, former therapies and the
symptoms (pain, paresthesia, numb-
ness, paresis, other complaints, gen-
eral impairment and feeling). These
symptoms were to be rated in Likert
scales from zero (none) to six (most se-
vere complaints) before and after 8
weeks of treatment.
Patients were asked to record in the
diary time and type of each applica-
tion, the complaints before administra-
tion (from 0 to 6) and the immediate
change of pain, hyperaesthesia, and
paresthesia (unchanged, plus or mi-
nus) after each water application. In-
take of analgetics was also recorded.
Statistics
Data were analysed descriptively; t-
test was used, paired if appropriate.
The outcome parameters were symp-
tom scores before and after the treat-
ment period, course of symptoms
recorded in the diary, number of appli-
cations and initial changes of symp-
toms after each hydrotherapeutic
measure. Compliance (frequency of
applications) and questions regarding
tolerability were used as a measure for
practicability.
288 Schweiz. Zschr. GanzheitsMedizin 20 (5), September 2008
Originalarbeit R
Original Article
Ethic Comitee
There was no need for an approval by
an ethic comittee since it was an ob-
servational study with an intervention
which is usually recommended as self-
treatment in media and advisory books
for patients [8]. Consent for anony-
mous data processing was given by the
participants.
Results
Patients
We received completed questionnaires
from 27 patients (12 male, 15 female).
The patients’ mean age was 68 years,
their mean height 172 cm and mean
weight 75.5 kg. Two patients out of 27
stopped treatment after 3 weeks, four
patients reported intermediate discon-
tinuation of the hydrotherapy within
the first few days due to “worsening of
complaints”.
On the scale for physical activity
(from 0 = bed rest to 6 = practising
sports several times per week), the
mean value was 3.6 before the study.
Five patients reported that they could
walk only with the aid of sticks. Twelve
patients were smokers and 9 patients
ingested moderate amounts of alco-
holic beverages. In 12 patients, the
etiology of PNP was unknown, the oth-
ers reported: diabetes (2), cancer resp.
cancer treatments (2), arteriosclerosis
(2), rheumatic disease (2), neuroborre-
liosis (2), hormonal disease (1), meta-
bolic disorder (1), vitamin deficiency
(1), genetic disease (1), neuronal muscle
atrophy (1), “other etiologies” (10). 23
patients were under observation of a
neurologist, 13 patients of their gen-
eral practitioner; 5 patients saw other
medical specialists and 14 patients re-
ported previous hospital treatments
related to their PNP.
Twenty patients knew test results of
their glucose levels, 15 patients of their
lipids, 14 patients of levels of vitamin
B12 and folic acid. Seven patients re-
ported prior biopsies of muscle and
nerve; 6 patients remembered tests of
cerebral spinal fluid or NMR.
Concomitant therapy was reported:
18 patients took supplementations of
vitamins; 7 patients received infusions
and 11 patients orally applied α-liponic
acid. 13 patients took analgetics and
11 patients received physiotherapy.
23 and 22 patients had symptoms of
their right or left toes respectively. In-
volvement of the right or left lower
limbs was recorded each in 15 pa-
tients. Eleven and 10 patients had also
symptoms at the right or left hand re-
spectively.
Therapy/Compliance
The most-favored Kneipp application
was the knee affusion which was used
about 11 times per patient and per
week within the first week of treat-
ment. Towards the end of the treat-
ment period, this practice was reduced
to 9 times per week and per patient on
average. There was a wide variation in
the number of applications from pa-
tient to patient, e.g. a total of 8 to 179
knee affusions within 8 weeks. Cold
foot-bathes were used between 0 to
152 times per patient, giving a mean of
2 foot-baths per week per patient. Al-
ternating foot-bathes were used about
2 times per week and per patient. Wet
socks were used 14 times in 8 weeks
on average.
289
Schweiz. Zschr. GanzheitsMedizin 20 (5), September 2008
Originalarbeit R
Original Article
Symptomatiken
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
vorh er nachh er
Schmerzen (p= 0. 73) Empfindungsstörungen ( p=0.12)
Missempfin dun gen (p =0.04) Lähmun g en (p =1.00)
P
ain dysesthesia
paresthesia paresis
pre post
(
Fig. 1. Primary outcome parameters (mean on Likert Scale from 0=none to 6=most severe) be-
fore (pre) and after 8 weeks treatment (post).
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
vorher nachher
Sc hlafstörungen (p =0.65) Einsc hränkung Alltag (p=0.07)
ungüns tiger Einfluß Zukunft (p=0.21)
pre post
Slee p ing d is ord ers (p=0,65)
Everyday restrictions (p= 0,07)
Unforta ble influenc e on fu tur e (p=0,21)
Fig. 2. Further outcome parameters (mean on Likert Scale from 0=none to 6=most severe) be-
fore (pre) and after 8 weeks treatment (post).
Likert Scale
Likert Scale
Symptoms before/after treatment
All patients suffered from pain with a
mean score value of 2.6 at the begin-
ning of the study. Twenty-three pa-
tients gave their rating after 6 weeks’
therapy with a mean of 2.5 score
points. The mean intra-individual
change was 0.07 which means that
there was a minimal alleviation of pain
during the study which showed no sig-
nificance (Fig. 1). An intra-individual
improvement of 0.25 score points on
average (from an average of 3.5 at
baseline to 3.1 at termination) was
analysed for the change of sensibility
(numbness). This change in sensibility
failed significance (t-test: p = 0.12).
Paresthesia improved from a mean of
3.4 to 2.9 score points. The mean in-
tra-individual difference was 0.58
score points (p = 0.04). Paresis was not
very strongly pronounced, with an av-
erage of 0.8 score points and showed
no changes during the study.
The symptoms sleep disorders, dis-
ability in daily activities and anxiety
showed slight improvements. The im-
pairment of daily activities was im-
proved with an average intra-individ-
ual change of 0.38 score points (p =
0.07) (Fig. 2).
Symptoms recorded in diary
A completed diary was obtained from
23 patients. There was a very small in-
crease of pain in the first 2 weeks with
no clear relation to time of application.
Overall, there is no effect to the pain in
the time course (Fig 3). Similarily,
there are no clear effects neither on
sensibility nor on paresthesia.
Immediate effects after
hydrotherapeutic applications
Overall, 49.9% of the Kneipp applica-
tions were reported to have led to
acute improvements of pain; in 42.6%
of the applications no acute changes of
pain were observed. A worsening of
pain was reported after 7.5% of the ap-
plications. The improvement rate rose
during the study, with 40% improve-
ment during the first week, 43.6% in
week 2 compared to 62.4% in week 8.
This change, however, is to be seen in
coincidence with fewer applications
used during the time course. Some pa-
tients did not proceed with ineffective
Kneipp applications and continued
only the beneficial ones during the
treatment period (Fig. 4).
Overall, most applications (61.8%)
did not induce an acute change in sen-
sibility. However, 32.7% of the Kneipp
applications induced acute improve-
ments and only 5.6% impairments. The
improvement rate increased slightly
during the first 5 weeks and then
reached a plateau at about 35%.
In a similar manner, the rate of
acute reductions of paresthesia in-
creased from 30% of applications dur-
ing the first week to 41% at the end of
the treatment period, resulting in a
mean value of 33.7%. Only 9.5% of the
applications caused an acute worsen-
ing, the remaining Kneipp applications
did not lead to acute changes.
Analgetics’ consumption
Eleven patients reported use of oral
analgetics. During the first week, anal-
getics were taken 9.4 times per pa-
tient. This number decreased to 8 dur-
ing week 3 until week 5 and after-
wards to 6.5.
290 Schweiz. Zschr. GanzheitsMedizin 20 (5), September 2008
Originalarbeit R
Original Article
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
week 1 week 2 week 3 week 4 week 5 week 6 week 7 week 8
early midday afternoon evening total
Fig. 3. Mean values of pain (Likert Scale from 0=none to 6=most severe) over time reported
in patients’ diaries.
worsening
No cha ng e
Improvement
Fig. 4. Acute change of pain after Kneipp applications.
Likert Scale
week 1
week 2
week 3
week 4
week 5
week 6
week 7
week 7
TOTAL
Discussion
Due to the small number of 27 patients,
the analysis of the study parameters
was limited. There are no apparent
changes in the overall judgements of
pain before and after 8 weeks of self-
treatment using Kneipp hydrotherapy;
which is in line with the mainly un-
changed basic values of complaints be-
fore administrations recorded in the
diaries during the time course. How-
ever, there was a significant decrease
of paresthesia after 8 weeks. This mod-
erate decrease could possibly be ex-
plained by spontaneous course, regres-
sion to mean, reporting bias; one could
argue, however, that other symptoms
should then also have been changed by
this study-immanent factors.
There are relevant percentages (30–
62%) of patients who reported in their
diaries acute improvements of pain,
sensibility and paresthesia after each
single water application versus only
5–9% acute impairments. This per-
centage of Kneipp applications with
acute improvements increased during
the time course. However, it seems
probable that many patients who did
not experience acute improvement
stopped the participation in the study
or reduced the frequency of water ap-
plications during the 8 weeks. There-
fore, the increasing acute response
rate during the course of the study
might be due to the “withdrawals” and
not due to an adaptation process.
On the other hand, acute improve-
ments after more than a third of appli-
cations (in those who had finally par-
ticipated in the study) are reason
enough to consider cold water applica-
tions as probative therapy in patients
with PNP. Acute effects of a cold water
application are plausible and could be
explained by increased local circula-
tion; on the other hand, vasoactive
substances showed no improvement of
symptoms in patients with diabetic
polyneuropathy [9]. Hydrotherapeutic
measures might also stimulate the
same neurophysiologic mechanisms
which are relevant in manipulative
therapies including acupuncture for
pain relief.
A further limitation of the study re-
sults lies in the procedure “study by
correspondence”. The exact diagnosis
and etiology of this complex indication
was only rated by questionnaires and
is less accurate than a diagnosis by a
neurologist. The number of patients is
too small to look into subgroups with
different etiology of their PNP which
might respond in different manner to
Kneipp therapy.
Judging by some of the telephone
calls received during the study, it ap-
pears that many patients were not able
to fully understand the written instruc-
tions and, consequently, some more
patients did not return their question-
aires due to adverse reactions (they
had no reactive hyperemia due to a
prolonged cold application) and side
effects (common colds).
The “study by correspondence” is a
low-cost method to collect preliminary
data about self-treatments and there-
fore a suitable instrument in the field
of natural healing methods and some
of CAM. It would be preferable, how-
ever, to handle inclusion or registra-
tion of patients more restrictively in
order to obtain a more exact descrip-
tion of convenience sample and exact
figures of drop-outs. This could be
achieved by a two-step procedure
where patients would submit their
baseline data before receiving de-
tailled instructions for the intervention
and questionnaires for the course of
the intervention.
On the basis of these results, we
plan to conduct a further clinical study
with personal instruction, anamnesis,
controlled documentation as well as
with a control group (waiting group),
focussing on dysesthesia and paresthe-
sia as primary outcome variables.
Physiologic studies in patients with
PNP versus healthy volunteers about
acute effects on local circulation and
metabolism could clarify the mode of
action of a cold stimulus in PNP.
Acknowledgement
We thank Irmgard-Deutsch-Stiftung, Berlin,
for financial support of data entry and pro-
cessing.
References
1. Dengler R und Heidenreich F: Polyneuro-
pathien. Mainz, 1999
2. Argoff CE, Cole BE, Fishbain DA, Irving GA:
Diabetic peripheral neuropathic pain: clinical
and quality-of-life issues. Mayo Clin Proc.
2006;81(Suppl.4):3–11
3. Mason L, Moore RA, Derry S, Edwards JE,
McQuay HJ: Systematic review of topical cap-
saicin for the treatment of chronic pain. BMJ
2004;328:991
4. Brüggemann W (Ed): Kneipp-Therapie (2nd
ed.) Berlin-Heidelberg-New York 1986
5. Doering TJ, Thiel, J, Steuernagel B, Johannes
B, Konitzer M, Niederstadt C, Schneider B,
Fischer GC: Changes of cognitive brain func-
tions in the elderly by Kneipp therapy. Forsch
Komplementarmed Klass Naturheilkd 2001;
8(2):80–4
6. Grötsch R, Mikrozirkulation der Haut bei
Kältereizen – Untersuchungen mit Hilfe der
Laser-Doppler-Flussmessung, Inauguraldisser-
tation an der Medizinischen Fakultät, der
Ludwig-Maximilians- Universität zu München;
Institut für Medizinische Balneologie und
Klimatologie 1991
7. Young Aj, Muza sr, Sawka Mn et al, Human
thermoregulatory responses to cold are
altered by repeated cold water immersion, J
Appl Physiol 1986;60(5):1542–8.
8. Uehleke B, Hentschel HD: Das große Kneipp-
Gesundheitsbuch. Stuttgart 2006
9. Hilz MJ, Marthol H, Neuendofer B: Diabetic
somatic polyneuropathy. Pathogenesis, clini-
cal manifestations and therapeutic concepts.
Fortschritt Neurologie Psychiatrie 2000;68(6):
278
Disclosure Statement
The authors declare that no financial or
other conflict of interest exists in relation
to the content of this article.
Address for Correspondence:
Dr. med. Dr. rer. nat. Bernhard Uehleke
Charité Universitätsmedizin Berlin
Immanuel-Krankenhaus
Department for Natural Healing
Königstr. 63, DE-14109 Berlin
b.uehleke@immanuel.de
and
University of Zurich, University Hospital
Department of Internal Medicine
Institute of Complementary Medicine
Raemistrasse 100, CH-8091 Zurich
291
Schweiz. Zschr. GanzheitsMedizin 20 (5), September 2008
Originalarbeit R
Original Article
... Nach der Eignungsbeurteilung aufgrund des Volltextes wurden 31 Referenzen ausgeschlossen und 25 Studien für die Datenextraktion eingeschlossen. Von den eingeschlossenen Studien sind 12 in einer wissenschaftlichen Peer-Reviewed Zeitschrift [17][18][19][20][21][22][23][24][25][26][27][28] Indikationen für den Einsatz der Kneipp-Therapie Die Kneipp-Therapie, in Form alleiniger Hydrotherapie oder in verschiedensten Kombinationen von Hydrotherapie mit einer, mehreren oder allen 5 Elementen der Kneippschen Gesundheitslehre, wurde in den letzten 20 Jahren in einem breiten Spektrum von Gesundheitsstörungen und Erkrankungen angewendet und in wissenschaftlichen Studien untersucht. ...
... Bei Mammakarzinom-Patientinnen mit klimakterischen Beschwerden konnte nach einer ebenfalls 12-wöchigen Hydrotherapieserie keine signifikante Verbesserung von Depression und Angst (HADS) erreicht werden [35]. (Neuro)muskuloskelettale Beschwerden Kneippsche Hydrotherapie führte bei Patienten mit polyneuropathischen Beschwerden zu signifikanten Verbesserungen bei Parästhesien sowie leichten Verbesserungen bei Schlafstörungen, Einschränkungen der täglichen Aktivität und Ängstlichkeit [28]. Heusack-Anwendungen im Rahmen einer Kneippkur bewirkten bei Patienten mit rheumatischen Erkrankungen signifikante Verbesserungen von muskuloskelettalen Beschwerden und Schmerzen [27]. ...
Article
Full-text available
b> Einleitung: Ziel dieser systematischen Übersicht war die Bewertung der verfügbaren Evidenz zur Wirkung der Kneipp-Therapie. Methoden: MEDLINE, Embase, Web of Science, Cochrane-Library und CAMbase wurden nach relevanten Artikeln, veröffentlicht zwischen 2000 und 2019, durchsucht. Graue Literatur wurde über Google Scholar und andere Tools bezogen. Studien mit jeglicher Art von Studiendesign, die die Effekte der Kneipp-Therapie untersuchten, wurden eingeschlossen. Die Qualitätsbewertung erfolgte mittels EPHPP-QAT. Ergebnisse: 25 Quellen, darunter 14 kontrol­lierte Studien, wurden eingeschlossen. Gemäß EPHPP-QAT wurden 3 Studien “stark”, 13 “moderat” und 9 “schwach” bewertet. Neun (64%) der kontrollierten Studien berichteten signifikante Verbesserungen nach Kneipp-Therapie im Gruppenvergleich bei chronisch-venöser Insuffizienz, Hypertonie, leichter Herzinsuffizienz, menopausalen Be­schwerden und Schlafstörungen in verschiedenen Patientenkollektiven sowie verbesserte Immunparameter bei gesunden Probanden. Im Hinblick auf Depression und Angst bei Mammakarzinom-Patientinnen mit klimakterischen Beschwerden, Lebensqualität bei Post-Polio-Syndrom, krankheitsbedingten polyneuropathischen Beschwerden und Inzidenz von Erkältungsepisoden bei Kindern konnten keine signifikanten Gruppenunterschiede festgestellt werden. Elf unkontrollierte Studien berichteten Verbesse­rungen bei allergischen Symptomen, Dyspepsie, Lebens­qualität, Herzratenvariabilität, Infekten, Hypertonie, Wohlbefinden, Schmerz und polyneuropathischen Beschwerden. Diskussion/Schlussfolgerung: Die Kneipp-Therapie scheint bei zahlreichen Beschwerdebildern in verschiedenen Patientenkollektiven positive Effekte zu bewirken. Zukünftige Studien sollten noch stärker auf eine methodisch sorgfältige Studienplanung achten (Kontrollgruppen, Randomisierung, adäquate Fallzahlen, Verblindung), um Verzerrungen entgegenzuwirken.
... Most of the 22 uncontrolled studies report significant within-group improvements over time. In fact, evidence was found suggesting that (1) mineral water drinking cure may reduce dyspeptic symptoms (Anti et al. 2004;Bertoni et al. 2002;Gasbarrini et al. 2006); (2) inhalation therapy with sulphurous thermal water can improve middle ear function in patients with chronic inflammatory ear disease (Costantino 2008b;Costantino et al. 2006), nasal flows and nasal resistance in patients with chronic sinonasal disease (Staffieri and Abramo 2007) and, in combination with radon therapy, pulmonary function of asthmatics (Mitsunobu et al. 2003); inhalation therapy with radioactive hydrofluoric oligomineral water may reduce mucociliary transport time and can normalize the nasal cytology in patients with chronic sinonasal inflammation (Passali et al. 2013); (3) Kneipp applications may decrease dysesthesia in patients with peripheral neuropathy (Uehleke and Woehling 2008) and positively influence the frequency of respiratory infections and subjective well-being in patients with COPD (Goedsche et al. 2007); (4) balneotherapy administered in various modalities positively influences inflammation and qol in patients with atopic dermatitis and psoriasis (Casas et al. 2011;Merial-Kieny et al. 2011;Taieb et al. 2011;Tsoureli-Nikita et al. 2002) and improves qol and clinical symptoms in patients with inherited ichthyosis (Bodemer et al. 2011); (5) aquatic exercise may improve functional capacity and qol in patients with advanced heart failure (Municino et al. 2006); and (6) spa therapy can improve qol and mood in breast cancer patients (Strauss- Blasche et al. 2005), positively influence the steroid spectrum in thyroidectomized women (Jandova et al. 2008), improve burnout-related complaints and quality of sleep in subjects with mild or full burnout syndrome (Blasche et al. 2010), improve metabolic syndrome (Gin et al. 2013) and enhance exercise capacity in patients with COPD (Takata et al. 2008). ...
... The explanatory power of the studies is therefore restricted. Accordingly, several authors point out that their study should be replicated with more participants and/or a more rigorous design (Anti et al. 2004;Blasche et al. 2010;Municino et al. 2006;Olah et al. 2011;Staffieri and Abramo 2007;Strauss-Blasche et al. 2005;Uehleke and Woehling 2008;Zambo et al. 2008). Not only the heterogeneity of interventions, but also the non-standardized nomenclature and terminology (Gutenbrunner et al. 2010) restrict the comparability of study results. ...
Article
Health resort medicine (HRM; in German: Kurortmedizin) is a field of medicine with long-lasting tradition in several European countries. A number of systematic reviews have shown the effectiveness of HRM in musculoskeletal conditions. Reviews focusing on the effectiveness of HRM in non-musculoskeletal disorders are rare. This systematic review aims to provide an overview about all types of health resort treatments applied in non-musculoskeletal conditions, to summarize evidence for its effectiveness and to assess the quality of published studies. MEDLINE, Web of Knowledge and Embase were searched for articles published between January 2002 and December 2013. We used a broad search strategy in order to find studies investigating the effects of HRM in non-musculoskeletal disorders. Two authors independently extracted data and assessed quality using the Effective Public Health Practice Project Quality Assessment Tool for Quantitative Studies (EPHPP-QAT). Forty-one studies (19 of them with control group) from eight countries examining the efficacy of various forms of spa treatment for 12 disease groups were included. The studies are markedly heterogeneous regarding study design, population and treatment. HRM treatment is associated with clinical improvement in diseases of the skin, respiratory, circulatory, digestive and nervous system among others. However, small samples, the lack of control groups and an insufficient follow-up often limit the generated evidence. The scientific literature of the last decade has shown that a number of non-musculoskeletal disorders are treated with different kinds of HRM. The challenge for the future will be to carry out thoroughly designed studies in larger patient populations to corroborate the impact of HRM treatment on non-musculoskeletal disorders.
... Although contrast bath therapy is beneficial for sports injuries, joint pain, muscle fatigue, inflammation, and poor blood circulation [2], its application is limited due to the need for specialized equipment and professional instructors. Kneipp's foot-treading method originated in Europe enhances blood circulation, reduces foot swelling and fatigue, and improves joint mobility [3]. Footbath therapy, especially with hot water, has also been proven to be effective in promoting health and wellness by alleviating symptoms of pain, fatigue, and insomnia, improving circulation, and enhancing overall well-being [4]. ...
... Aquatic exercise can positively affect physical and motor fitness parameters particularly strength, endurance, flexibility, and body composition. These effects can bring positive physiological benefits for patients, including patients with motor and sensory disorders [12]. ...
Article
Background and purpose: Nerve growth factor (NGF) concentrations and balance are reduced in diabetic neuropathy (DN) patients. We examined the effects of hydrotherapy and massage on NGF, balance and glycemic markers in middle aged DN patients. Materials and methods Patients were randomly assigned into four groups, aquatic exercise (AE; n = 10), AE + massage (AM; n = 10), massage (M; n = 10) or control (C; n = 9). Subjects in AE and AM groups exercised three times per week. Subjects in the AM and M groups received massage during the same period. Glycemic markers, NGF and balance were evaluated prior to and following the interventions. Results NGF, glycemic markers and dynamic balance improved in AE, AM and M groups; however, the increase was greater following the AM trial (p < 0.01) when compared to the other trials. Conclusion A combination of hydrotherapy and massage enhances NGF concentrations, balance and the glycemic profile compared to hydrotherapy or massage alone.
Article
Full-text available
Background: Most individuals affected by cancer who are treated with certain chemotherapies suffer of CIPN. Therefore, there is a high patient and provider interest in complementary non-pharmacological therapies, but its evidence base has not yet been clearly pointed out in the context of CIPN. Methods: The results of a scoping review overviewing the published clinical evidence on the application of complementary therapies for improving the complex CIPN symptomatology are synthesized with the recommendations of an expert consensus process aiming to draw attention to supportive strategies for CIPN. The scoping review, registered at PROSPERO 2020 (CRD 42020165851), followed the PRISMA-ScR and JBI guidelines. Relevant studies published in Pubmed/MEDLINE, PsycINFO, PEDro, Cochrane CENTRAL, and CINAHL between 2000 and 2021 were included. CASP was used to evaluate the methodologic quality of the studies. Results: Seventy-five studies with mixed study quality met the inclusion criteria. Manipulative therapies (including massage, reflexology, therapeutic touch), rhythmical embrocations, movement and mind–body therapies, acupuncture/acupressure, and TENS/Scrambler therapy were the most frequently analyzed in research and may be effective treatment options for CIPN. The expert panel approved 17 supportive interventions, most of them were phytotherapeutic interventions including external applications and cryotherapy, hydrotherapy, and tactile stimulation. More than two-thirds of the consented interventions were rated with moderate to high perceived clinical effectiveness in therapeutic use. Conclusions: The evidence of both the review and the expert panel supports a variety of complementary procedures regarding the supportive treatment of CIPN; however, the application on patients should be individually weighed in each case. Based on this meta-synthesis, interprofessional healthcare teams may open up a dialogue with patients interested in non-pharmacological treatment options to tailor complementary counselling and treatments to their needs.
Article
Full-text available
The effects of repeated cold water immersion on thermoregulatory responses to cold air were studied in seven males. A cold air stress test (CAST) was performed before and after completion of an acclimation program consisting of daily 90-min cold (18 degrees C) water immersion, repeated 5 times/wk for 5 consecutive wk. The CAST consisted of resting 30 min in a comfortable [24 degrees C, 30% relative humidity (rh)] environment followed by 90 min in cold (5 degrees C, 30% rh) air. Pre- and postacclimation, metabolism (M) increased (P less than 0.01) by 85% during the first 10 min of CAST and thereafter rose slowly. After acclimation, M was lower (P less than 0.02) at 10 min of CAST compared with before, but by 30 min M was the same. Therefore, shivering onset may have been delayed following acclimation. After acclimation, rectal temperature (Tre) was lower (P less than 0.01) before and during CAST, and the drop in Tre during CAST was greater (P less than 0.01) than before. Mean weighted skin temperature (Tsk) was lower (P less than 0.01) following acclimation than before, and acclimation resulted in a larger (P less than 0.02) Tre-to-Tsk gradient. Plasma norepinephrine increased during both CAST (P less than 0.002), but the increase was larger (P less than 0.004) following acclimation. These findings suggest that repeated cold water immersion stimulates development of true cold acclimation in humans as opposed to habituation. The cold acclimation produced appears to be of the insulative type.
Article
Changes of Cognitive Brain Functions in the Elderly by Kneipp Therapy Introduction: Pharmacological and nonpharmacological treatment of brain syndrome is multifarious. Until now, plain external applications of physical stimuli, as used daily in geriatric care, were not explored regarding their influence on cognitive brain function.The aim of this randomized cross-over study was to examine the influence of dermatoreceptive stimuli on cognitive brain function of healty geriatric volunteers. Methods: 24 healthy volunteers (23 women, 1 man) were randomized into 2 groups (cross-over design). Group A (mean age ± SD: 68.8 ± 6.2 years) was treated according to the following regime: at first a 10–12 °C cold stimulus for 10 s (a so-called Kneipp face shower) and afterwards a cold wet pack of 10–12 °C at the neck for 1 min. Group B (age 69.8 ± 5.3 years) was subjected to an identical procedure but with warm thermoindifferent temperatures of 34–36 °C. After 1 week the two groups were interchanged. The parameters of interest were the critical flicker frequency (CFF) and the latencies of the event-related P300 potentials of the visually evoked potentials (VEP), which can be considered the electroencephalographic substrate of the cognitive functional ability. The CFFs and the P300 latencies and amplitudes were measured directly before and 10 min after the application of the above-mentioned stimuli. Furthermore, the CFFs were recorded a second and third time 30 and 60 min later. Results: Following application of cold-water stimuli, the CFF increased from (mean ± SE) 32.55 ± 0.44 s-1 to 33.06 ± 0.44 s-1 (p = 0.003) 10 min after the stimulus. 30 min later the CFF was still elevated at 32.95 ± 0.47 s-1 (p = 0.043). The P300 latencies decreased by 4.8% (p Conclusion: Cold water applied locally to face and neck region is able to provoke significant improvements of cognitive abilities.
Article
Diabetic polyneuropathy is the most frequent neuropathy in western countries. In Germany, there are 3.5 to 4 million diabetic patients. Diagnosis should rule out other polyneuropathies and assess two out of the five diagnostic criteria: neuropathic symptoms, neuropathic deficits, pathological nerve conduction studies, pathological quantitative sensory testing and pathological quantitative autonomic testing. So far, the pathophysiology of diabetic neuropathy remains to be fully understood. Among the various pathophysiological concepts are the Sorbitol-Myo-Inositol hypothesis attributing Myo-Inositol depletion to the accumulation of Sorbitol and Fructose, the concept of deficiency of essential fatty acids with reduced availability of gamma-linolenic-acid and prostanoids, the pseudohypoxia- and hypoxia-hypothesis attributing endothelial and axonal dysfunction and structural lesions to increased oxidative stress and free radical production. Obviously, the hyperglycemia induced generation of advanced glycation end products (AGEs) also contributes to structural dysfunctions and lesions. Elevated levels of circulating immune complexes and activated T-lymphocytes as well the identification of autoantibodies against vagus nerve or sympathetic ganglia support the concept of an immune mediated neuropathy. The reduction of neurotrophic factors such as nerve growth factor, neurotrophin-3 or insulin-like growth factors also seems to further diabetic neuropathy. The symmetrical, distally pronounced and predominantly sensory neuropathy is far more frequent than the symmetrical neuropathy with predominant motor weakness or the asymmetrical neuropathy. The painless neuropathy manifests with impaired light touch sensation, position sense, vibratory perception and diminished or absent ankle deep tendon reflexes. The painful sensory diabetic neuropathy primarily affects small nerve fibers and accounts for decreased temperature perception and paresthesias. The proximal, diabetic amyotrophy evolves subacutely or acutely, induces motor weakness of the proximal thigh and buttock muscles and is painful. Cranial nerve III-neuropathy is also painful and has an acute onset. Truncal radiculopathy follows the distribution of truncal roots and frequently causes intense pain. Autonomic neuropathy occurs with and without somatic neuropathy. The most important therapy is to attempt optimal blood glucose control, to reduce body weight and hyperlipidemia. Symptomatic therapy includes alpha-lipoic acid treatment, as the antioxidant seems to improve neuropathic symptoms. Aldose reductase inhibitors might reduce sorbitol and fructose production and normalize myo-inositol levels. However, there are no aldose reductase inhibitors available in Europe as yet. Evening primrose oil, containing gamma-linolenic acid, might improve nerve conduction velocities, temperature perception, muscle strength, tendon reflexes and sensory function. Substitution of nerve growth factor showed promising results in pilot studies but failed in a large-scale multicenter study. Symptomatic pain treatment can be achieved with tricyclic antidepressants, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, anticonvulsants such as carbamazepine, gabapentin or lamotrigine, or anti-arrhythmic drugs such as mexiletine. Topical capsaicin application should reduce neuropathic pain but also induces local discomfort in the beginning of therapy. Vasoactive substances, so far have not proven to be of major benefit in diabetic neuropathy. Physical therapy and thorough footcare are of primary importance and allow prevention of secondary complications such as foot amputations.
Article
Pharmacological and nonpharmacological treatment of brain syndrome is multifarious. Until now, plain external applications of physical stimuli, as used daily in geriatric care, were not explored regarding their influence on cognitive brain function. The aim of this randomized cross-over study was to examine the influence of dermatoreceptive stimuli on cognitive brain function of healty geriatric volunteers. 24 healthy volunteers (23 women, 1 man) were randomized into 2 groups (cross-over design). Group A (mean age +/- SD: 68.8 +/- 6.2 years) was treated according to the following regime: at first a 10-12 degrees C cold stimulus for 10 s (a so-called Kneipp face shower) and afterwards a cold wet pack of 10-12 degrees C at the neck for 1 min. Group B (age 69.8 +/- 5.3 years) was subjected to an identical procedure but with warm thermoindifferent temperatures of 34-36 degrees C. After 1 week the two groups were interchanged. The parameters of interest were the critical flicker frequency (CFF) and the latencies of the event-related P300 potentials of the visually evoked potentials (VEP), which can be considered the electroencephalographic substrate of the cognitive functional ability. The CFFs and the P300 latencies and amplitudes were measured directly before and 10 min after the application of the above-mentioned stimuli. Furthermore, the CFFs were recorded a second and third time 30 and 60 min later. Following application of cold-water stimuli, the CFF increased from (mean +/- SE) 32.55 +/- 0.44 s(-1) to 33.06 +/- 0.44 s(-1) (p = 0.003) 10 min after the stimulus. 30 min later the CFF was still elevated at 32.95 +/- 0.47 s(-1) (p = 0.043). The P300 latencies decreased by 4.8% (p < 0.001) after cold-water application from 266.5 +/- 5.28 to 253.7 +/- 4.22 ms. After warm stimuli they increased from 258.69 +/- 3.71 to 266.17 +/- 5.03 ms (p = 0.01). The P300 amplitudes were elevated by 5% only with the cold stimuli (p = 0.004). Cold water applied locally to face and neck region is able to provoke significant improvements of cognitive abilities.
Article
To determine the efficacy and safety of topically applied capsaicin for chronic pain from neuropathic or musculoskeletal disorders. Cochrane Library, Medline, Embase, PubMed, an in-house database, and contact with manufacturers of topical capsaicin. Randomised controlled trials comparing topically applied capsaicin with placebo or another treatment in adults with chronic pain. Primary outcome was dichotomous information for the number of patients with about a 50% reduction in pain. Outcomes were extracted at four weeks for musculoskeletal conditions and eight weeks for neuropathic conditions. Secondary outcomes were adverse events and withdrawals due to adverse events. Six double blind placebo controlled trials (656 patients) were pooled for analysis of neuropathic conditions. The relative benefit from topical capsaicin 0.075% compared with placebo was 1.4 (95% confidence interval 1.2 to 1.7) and the number needed to treat was 5.7 (4.0 to 10.0). Three double blind placebo controlled trials (368 patients) were pooled for analysis of musculoskeletal conditions. The relative benefit from topical capsaicin 0.025% or plaster compared with placebo was 1.5 (1.1 to 2.0) and the number needed to treat was 8.1 (4.6 to 34). Around one third of patients experienced local adverse events with capsaicin, which would not have been the case with placebo. Although topically applied capsaicin has moderate to poor efficacy in the treatment of chronic musculoskeletal or neuropathic pain, it may be useful as an adjunct or sole therapy for a small number of patients who are unresponsive to, or intolerant of, other treatments.
Article
Diabetic peripheral neuropathy (DPN) is estimated to be present in 50% of people living with diabetes mellitus (DM). Comorbidities of DM, such as macrovascular and microvascular changes, also Interact with DPN and affect its course. In patients with DM, DPN Is the leading cause of foot ulcers, which in turn are a major cause of amputation in the United States. Although most patients with DPN do not have pain, approximately 11% of patients with DPN have chronic, painful symptoms that diminish quality of life, disrupt sleep, and can lead to depression. Despite the number of patients affected by DPN pain, little consensus exists about the pathophysiology, best diagnostic tools, and primary treatment choices. This article reviews the current knowledge about and presents recommendations for diagnostic assessment of DPN pain based on a review of the literature.
Bernhard Uehleke Charité Universitätsmedizin Berlin Immanuel-Krankenhaus Department for Natural Healing Königstr
  • Dr
  • Dr
Dr. med. Dr. rer. nat. Bernhard Uehleke Charité Universitätsmedizin Berlin Immanuel-Krankenhaus Department for Natural Healing Königstr. 63, DE-14109 Berlin b.uehleke@immanuel.de and University of Zurich, University Hospital Department of Internal Medicine Institute of Complementary Medicine Raemistrasse 100, CH-8091 Zurich
Human thermoregulatory responses to cold are altered by repeated cold water immersion
  • Young Aj
  • Sawka Muza Sr
  • Mn
Young Aj, Muza sr, Sawka Mn et al, Human thermoregulatory responses to cold are altered by repeated cold water immersion, J Appl Physiol 1986;60(5):1542-8.
Das große Kneipp-Gesundheitsbuch
  • B Uehleke
  • H D Hentschel
Uehleke B, Hentschel HD: Das große Kneipp-Gesundheitsbuch. Stuttgart 2006