ArticlePDF Available

micromachines Dynamics of Electrowetting Droplet Motion in Digital Microfluidics Systems: From Dynamic Saturation to Device Physics

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

A quantitative description of the dynamics of droplet motion has been a long-standing concern in electrowetting research. Although many static and dynamic models focusing on droplet motion induced by electrowetting-on-dielectric (EWOD) already exist, some dynamic features do not fit these models well, especially the dynamic saturation phenomenon. In this paper, a dynamic saturation model of droplet motion on the single-plate EWOD device is presented. The phenomenon that droplet velocity is limited by a dynamic saturation effect is precisely predicted. Based on this model, the relationship between droplet motion and device physics is extensively discussed. The static saturation phenomenon is treated with a double-layer capacitance electric model, and it is demonstrated as one critical factor determining the dynamics of droplet motion. This work presents the relationship between dynamics of electrowetting induced droplet motion and device physics including device structure, surface material and interface electronics, which helps to better understand electrowetting induced droplet motions and physics of digital microfluidics systems.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Micromachines 2015, 6, 778-789; doi:10.3390/mi6060778
micromachines
ISSN 2072-666X
www.mdpi.com/journal/micromachines
Article
Dynamics of Electrowetting Droplet Motion in Digital
Microfluidics Systems: From Dynamic Saturation to
Device Physics
Weiwei Cui, Menglun Zhang, Xuexin Duan, Wei Pang *, Daihua Zhang and Hao Zhang *
State Key Laboratory of Precision Measuring Technology and Instruments, Tianjin University,
Tianjin 300072, China; E-Mails: weiweitsui@tju.edu.cn (W.C.); zml@tju.edu.cn (M.Z.);
xduan@tju.edu.cn (X.D.); weipang@tju.edu.cn (W.P.); dhzhang@tju.edu.cn (D.Z.)
* Authors to whom correspondence should be addressed; E-Mails: weipang@tju.edu.cn (W.P.);
haozhang@tju.edju.cn (H.Z.); Tel.: +86-22-2740-1248 (H.Z.).
Academic Editors: Andrew deMello and Xavier Casadevall i Solvas
Received: 5 May 2015 / Accepted: 16 June 2015 / Published: 19 June 2015
Abstract: A quantitative description of the dynamics of droplet motion has been a
long-standing concern in electrowetting research. Although many static and dynamic models
focusing on droplet motion induced by electrowetting-on-dielectric (EWOD) already exist,
some dynamic features do not fit these models well, especially the dynamic saturation
phenomenon. In this paper, a dynamic saturation model of droplet motion on the single-plate
EWOD device is presented. The phenomenon that droplet velocity is limited by a dynamic
saturation effect is precisely predicted. Based on this model, the relationship between droplet
motion and device physics is extensively discussed. The static saturation phenomenon is
treated with a double-layer capacitance electric model, and it is demonstrated as one critical
factor determining the dynamics of droplet motion. This work presents the relationship
between dynamics of electrowetting induced droplet motion and device physics including
device structure, surface material and interface electronics, which helps to better understand
electrowetting induced droplet motions and physics of digital microfluidics systems.
Keywords: droplet motion; dynamic saturation; electrowetting; digital microfluidics; device
physics; contact angle saturation
OPEN ACCESS
Micromachines 2015, 6 779
1. Introduction
As one of the most promising droplet-actuation technologies, electrowetting-on-dielectric (EWOD),
is considered one of most promising tools to realize lab-on-a-chip (LOC) devices by building digital
microfluidics platforms for chemical and biological detections. EWOD actuation is induced by the
electrowetting phenomenon that wetting can be effectively controlled by an electric field [1–3]. The
wetting is generally characterized by contact angle, and from its change the electrowetting force is born,
as shown in Figure 1a,b. Figure 1c indicates the driving force on a droplet generated by the surface
tension on the contact line. The traditional scheme of EWOD implies a droplet lying on a metal substrate,
covered by dielectric material and Teflon hydrophobic surface, and inserted with a metal line on the top,
as shown in Figure 1b.
Recently, a rapid growth in EWOD-based microfluidic systems has been seen with many biological
applications, such as DNA enrichment [4] and ligation [5], enzyme assays [6–8], cell-based assays [9],
polymerase chain reaction (PCR) [10], and proteomics [11–14]. At the same time, the fundamentals
of electrowetting have remained not fully understood. Figure 1d represents the contact angle
saturation phenomenon and pinning effect, and the explanations of them are very different and highly
debatable [15–17]. The dynamic saturation phenomenon, that droplet velocity would be limited by a
saturated value, is still imperfectly explained [18,19]. The developed dynamic models, represented by
Brochard’s theoretical model, cannot predict the dynamic saturation phenomenon (Figure 2). In the
present paper, a dynamic saturation model of droplets transported on a single-plate EWOD device, from
the common-sense electrowetting theories, such as Lippmann equation and three-contact-line theory,
is derived.
Additionally, the contact angle saturation is treated with a double-layer capacitance-based electric
circuit to further understand the dynamic saturation phenomenon.
Figure 1. Schematics of (a) surface tensions on the tri-line interface of droplet on an
electrowetting-on-dielectric (EWOD) device; (b) the electrowetting principle; (c) driving
force derived from integration of the surface tension in contacting line; and (d) static effects
on the droplet including the contact angle saturation (CAS) effect and pinning effect. The
surface tensions in (c) represent the component in the driving direction. Furthermore, θS in
(d) stands for the saturated contact angle when the applied voltage is large enough.
Micromachines 2015, 6 780
Figure 2. Comparison of curves induced by Brochard’s theoretical model (solid line) and
the saturation phenomenon found in experiments (dashed one), which indicates that the
dynamic saturation effect cannot be predicted by Brochard’s model.
2. Dynamic Saturation Model of Droplet Motion on the Open DMF Chip
The derivation of this model is based on the analysis of the kinetic equilibrium between driving force
and damp effects, and droplet deformation, t, is taken into account. The influences of pining effect and
errors caused by the droplet deformation, contact line length variation, and velocity measuring method
have been carefully considered. The modeling process and details are presented in the supplement.
Equation (1) presents the mathematical expression of the velocity of electrowetting droplet motion on
the open digital microfluidics (DMF) chip.
2
0
2
0
1
8
2(2)
2
r
r
cV
lVf
d
Ul
K
KC R V
d
εε ⋅−Δ
=εε
πμ+
(1)
where d is the thickness of the dielectric layer. εr and ε are the relative permittivity of the dielectric and
the vacuum permittivity, respectively. The hysteresis effect [20,21] in the EWOD surface should be
taken into account, which is assumed to be a constant f. l represents the effective contact line length,
and R is the droplet radium. K1, Kc, and CV, respectively, stand for the factor induced by the droplet
acceleration and deceleration process, the pinning effect in the triangle region, and the viscous damp
from the area on the chip the droplet covers. This model indicates the relationship between droplet
motion dynamics and the device physics including device structure properties (d, εr, and l), hydrophobic
surface (γ, f, and CV), and interface electronics (Kc). The consideration of these properties is presented
in the supplementary information.
Figure 3 shows the droplet velocity curve plotted based on the dynamic saturation model. Wherein,
the black dots represent the reported experimental data from reference [19]. The validity of the dynamic
model is limited to a certain value of the system parameters, which is influenced by the device properties.
The mismatch at low voltages mainly comes from the difficulty of estimating the parameters of the DMF
chip used in reference, especially ones related to the hydrophobic surface properties.
Micromachines 2015, 6 781
Figure 3. Comparison between the dynamic saturation model (line) and experiment results
in reference [20] (plots). The red curve is induced by Equation (1) and its modification,
taking the radium variation into account, is represented by the blue curve.
Compared with the conventional dynamic model of electrowetting droplet motion, Equation (1)
represents a novel expression of the dynamic properties of droplets motion on DMF chips. It is clear that
the role of 2
0
2
rVεε could be neglected when the applied voltage is high enough. Thus, the droplet velocity
is independent from the voltage. In other words, the saturated velocity of the droplet is determined by
the parameters of the DMF system, including the EWOD device and the droplet itself. Furthermore, it
suggests the importance of designing the EWOD device and controlling the droplet carefully to obtain
the optimized actuation effect.
Finally, the dynamic model developed in this paper provides one explanation of the dynamic
saturation phenomenon. The basic view of this model can be summarized as the following. The
electrowetting force increases with the applied voltage, and at the same time the damping force will get
larger as a result of the enlargement of the wetted surface. Both of these inverse effects are generated by
the electrowetting force; finally, the dynamic saturation occurs as a compromise between them.
3. Influence of Device Physics on the Dynamics of Droplet Motion
For a better understanding of the dynamic saturation model, the parameters in the model are discussed
in the following. In the discussion, the role of the electrowetting number is redefined. The influence of
structure parameters, such as dielectric thickness, permittivity and contact angle are presented in detail
from the view of device physics. The hydrophobic surface properties and interface electronics in the
triple line are also concluded. All the above discussions are based on Equation (1), neglecting the droplet
radium variation for simplicity.
3.1. Electrowetting Number, M
The relationship between droplet velocity and the applied voltage is plotted in Figure 4. For a better
understanding, the dynamic process is divided into linear, transition, and saturation regions, according
to the applicability of the traditional Lippmann static laws. Especially, the electrowetting number
Micromachines 2015, 6 782
2
0
2
rl
M
V
d
εε
=⋅
γ is redefined as the measure of the dynamic saturation model. The calculated velocity of the
droplet as a function of M is plotted in Figure 5a. When M is very small, the dynamic properties keep
consistent with the Lippmann static laws. However, when M is great enough, the dynamic properties fit
with the saturation region. The process between the linear and saturation is the transition region, where
the saturation effect comes to influence the velocity curve. The relationship between the electrowetting
number and the applied voltage is presented in Figure 5b. For thinner dielectric layers, M is larger with
the same voltage and thus the electrowetting process is more effective. In this way, the sensitivity of M
to applied voltage determines the EWOD actuation efficiency.
Figure 4. Calculated droplet velocity as a function of the applied voltage, according to
Equation (1). The parameters used in the calculation are summarized in Table S2 in the
supplementary information.
Figure 5. (a) Velocity of droplet motion as a function of the electrowetting number, M; and
(b) the electrowetting number varies with the applied voltage.
3.2. Dielectric Thickness, t, Permittivity, ε, and Contact Line l
An EWOD device consisting of a dielectric layer of thinner thickness and high permittivity is
preferred. The relationship between the droplet velocity and the dielectric thickness and permittivity are,
respectively, presented in Figure 6a,b. Obviously, the saturated velocity is independent of the dielectric
Micromachines 2015, 6 783
characters in the saturation region. However, the advantages of thinner thickness and higher permittivity
become attractive in the linear and transition regions. Both thinner thickness and higher permittivity
contribute to lower threshold voltage and more effective actuation. The droplet actuation efficiency is
defined by the value of dU/dV, i.e., the slope of the UV curve. Many attempts to improve EWOD
devices have concentrated on utilizing these features, and, at the same time, lower actuation voltages
and better dynamics have been achieved [22–24]. Moon et al. reported an EWOD with driving voltage
as low as 12 V by reducing the dielectric layer to the nanometer scale [22]. However, a thin dielectric
layer is prone to dielectric breakdown. Chang et al. presented an EWOD with Al2O3 of 127 nm as the
dielectric layer. The high permittivity and the ultrathin thickness of the Al2O3 layer reduced the EWOD
driving voltage to 3 V [23]. In addition, the Al2O3 film formed by atomic layer deposition (ALD) is
dense, with little pinholes, and the surface is very flat and smooth, which are critical to avoid dielectric
breakdown and enhance the dynamic performance of the EWOD device.
The connection part configuration of the two adjacent electrodes is of importance to the droplet
dynamic properties on EWOD device. This factor is treated by using an average contact line length in
the modeling (see Figure S2 in Supplementary Information). Meanwhile, the droplet velocity varies with
its positions on the EWOD following a function determined by the adjacent electrodes connecting
configure. This factor is critical in the EWOD device design, and many works have considered it
carefully [24–26].
Figure 6. Influence of (a) dielectric layer thickness and (b) relative permittivity on the
velocity of the droplet according to Equation (1), with the parameters in Table S2, as
presented in the supplementary information.
3.3. Super-Hydrophobic Surface
As much attention focuses on the improvement of the hydrophobic surface, different materials with
super-hydrophobic features have been utilized to replace traditional hydrophobic materials [27–30]. For
the purpose of droplet operations, the super-hydrophobic surface should satisfy the Cassie state, wherein
the damp force and hysteresis effect are reduced dramatically. Experiments of super-hydrophobic
materials have been presented to satisfy the condition for improved electrowetting applications [27,31–33].
Therefore, the model of super-hydrophobic surface discussed here is only suitable for the Cassie case.
Micromachines 2015, 6 784
To adjust the analysis of these applications, the initial contact angle is treated to be variable in the
modeling. Following the same modeling process, the relationship between initial contact angle θ0 and
droplet velocity U is obtained:
0
2
0
1
4(cos 1)
1
2
2
V
r
l
UCRd
dV
=⋅ θ+
πμ +
γεε
(2)
where, f is neglected due to the very low hysteresis effect of the super-hydrophobic surface.
The droplet velocity U, as a function of the initial contact angle from 120° to 180°, is plotted in Figure 7.
For the same applied voltage, the droplet velocity increases with larger initial contact angles, i.e., with
more hydrophobic surfaces. Especially in the region from 150° to 165°, the droplet velocity changes
violently with applied voltage. This region is “the most effective area”, as Figure 7 shows, where a
narrow voltage range can be used to achieve the same modulation of the droplet velocity. The different
curves in Figure 7 converge to the same point, which indicates that the saturation droplet velocity is
independent of the initial contact angle.
Figure 7. Effect of a droplet’s initial contact angle on velocity, according to Equation (2).
The initial contact angle is determined by the surface property of the EWOD device. The
applied voltages, respectively, are 10, 20, 30, 50, 70, and 160 V from bottom to top. For the
range from 150° to 165°, the velocity increases more rapidly with the applied voltage;
therefore, this range is “the most effective area” to convert electric energy into droplet kinetic
energy. When the applied voltage is greater than 160 V, the saturation velocity is
independent with the initial contact angle.
3.4. Influence of Interface Electronics and Contact Angle Saturation Effect
The above works are carried out based on the dynamic equilibrium between electrowetting force and
the damping force on the droplet. By taking into account the droplet deformation, a dynamic model of
droplet motion on a single-plate EWOD device was induced, which fits well with the dynamic saturation
phenomenon. Contact angle saturation is thought to be one cause of dynamic saturation, but it has not
been considered during this modeling due to the difficulty of describing it mathematically. Many models
or hypotheses have been proposed to explain the contact angle saturation, as reviewed by Mugele [34],
Micromachines 2015, 6 785
Chevalliot et al. [15], Koopal [16] and Sedev [35], as well as, more recently, by Chevalliot et al. [15].
These theories or hypotheses can be briefly summarized as dielectric breakdown, zero interfacial tension,
contact line instability, gas ionization or insulating fluid charging, minimization of the electrostatic
energy, and Tailor cone. At present, the formation of contact angle saturation remains unclear and it is
difficult to describe it quantitatively. In reference [15], it has been experimentally demonstrated that
contact angle saturation is invariant with numerous variables, including dielectric thickness, interfacial
tension, and the chemical properties of the droplet, such as pH, ion type/size, and solute/solvent
interaction. Here, a trial is made to treat this well-known but not well-understood effect as one factor
and discuss its influence on this model.
A generalized Lippmann Equation was derived from the first principles as the following [36]:
2
1()
cos ( ) cos (0) 24
VdCS
Vra
adr
θ=θ+ =
πγ (3)
where C is the capacitance of the Helmholtz double layer at the interface between droplet and EWOD
substrate. S is the wetted solid area, and 2
Sa. a is the radium of the wetted area.
As discussed in reference [34], the well-known Lippmann equation is a particular case of
electrowetting when the radial derivative of the capacitance of the double layer is constant. This is similar
to the situation where the Lippmann static law is applicable only when the applied voltage is low. This
work has demonstrated that the contact angle of electrowetting depends on the gradient of capacitance
of the double layer in the vicinity of the triple line, which is thought to be dependent on the distribution
of the accumulated charges [16], as shown in Figure 8a.
Figure 8. (a) Charges distribution on the liquid–solid interface and (b) the equivalent electric
circuit of the triangle line region. C1 is the capacitance of dielectric layer, and C2 is the
capacitance of the double layer that is determined by the accumulated charges distribution.
For a better description of the capacitance distribution in the triple line, an equilibrium electric model
is built, as shown in Figure 8b.
When the voltage is applied, the capacitances are charged. More charges will accumulate in the triple line
area due to its spiky shape, resulting in a stronger capacitance in this location than other wetted areas [1].
The fact that the triple line is usually de-pinned in the electrowetting and EWOD actuation experiments
is evidence of this [2]. By analyzing the electric model in Figure 8b, the effective voltage applied on the
triple line is obtained:
1
12
eff
C
VV
CC
=⋅
+ (4)
Micromachines 2015, 6 786
The electric energy working on the triple line region is:
2
22
21
2
12
11
22
eff eff
CC
ECV V
CC
== ⋅
+ (5)
With the applied voltage increasing, more charges accumulate in the triple line region. Furthermore,
the value of C2 would get larger due to the fact that the double layer would get thinner. While the
capacitance, C1, induced by the dielectric layer remains constant. Thus, the increase of effective voltage
cannot keep pace with the applied voltage due to the decrease of the transfer coefficient. There should
exist one point beyond which the effective voltage becomes independent of the applied voltage. At this
time, the voltage working on the electrowetting system keeps constant. From Equation (5), the effective
electric energy working on the triple line region varies in a similar way. As the applied voltage increases
and the transfer coefficient decreases, the value of E would become invariable when the well-known
contact angle saturation occurs. Meanwhile, the accumulated charges in the triple line region would
probably enhance the pinning effect, which helps to increase the damp force on the droplet.
Contact angle saturation effect is another crucial cause of the dynamic saturation, as a limited electric
energy effectively works on the triple line region. When the effective electric energy in the triple line
region is limited, the electrowetting force will be limited, and the droplet deformation induced by the
electric field will be suspended. Thus, it can be thought that the contact angle saturation accelerates the
dynamic saturation in the transition region and, finally, ends the dynamic process by limiting the
electrowetting force.
4. Conclusions
In summary, a dynamic saturation model of electrowetting droplet motion on the open DMF system
is presented in this work. On the basis of the present analysis, the dynamic saturation phenomenon is
primarily a consequence of dynamic equilibrium between driving force and damp effects, and the contact
angle saturation effect. Among them, dynamic equilibrium forms the configuration of the velocity curve
as a function of applied voltage. Meanwhile, contact angle saturation accelerates the saturation process by
limiting the electrowetting force with a finite value, which confines the translation of the electronic energy
to the mechanical energy of the droplet. The influence of device physics, including electrode formation,
dielectric layer, hydrophobic surface and interface conditions, have been discussed based on this model,
which fit well with reported methods to improve electrowetting induced droplet motions. Specifically,
the saturated velocity is independent of the dielectric thickness, as well as the permittivity. Meanwhile,
a dielectric layer of thinner thickness and higher permittivity contributes to more effective actuation and
lower threshold voltage. The “most effective area” of initial contact angle using super-hydrophobic
surface materials or structures helps to optimize the hydrophobic surface. This study helps to deeper
understand electrowetting, and shows practical value for further optimizing EWOD devices.
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC No. 51375341), the
Program of Introducing Talents of Discipline to Universities (111 project No. B07014) and the National
High Technology Research and Development Program of China (863 Program No.2015AA042603).
Micromachines 2015, 6 787
Author Contributions
Weiwei Cui, Hao Zhang and Wei Pang proposed the idea; Weiwei Cui and Menglun Zhang performed
the model derivation; Weiwei Cui and Hao Zhang prepared the manuscript; Xuexin Duan and
Daihua Zhang contributed to the discussion and gave valuable suggestions on the manuscript revision
according to the referee report.
Supplementary Materials
Supplementary materials can be accessed at: http://www.mdpi.com/2072-666X/6/6/778/s1.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
References
1. Lippmann, G. Relations entre les phénomènes électriques et capillaires. Ann. Chim. Phys. 1875,
5, 494.
2. Hayes, R.A.; Feenstra, B.J. Video-speed electronic paper based on electrowetting. Nature 2003,
425, 383–385.
3. Mugele, F.; Baret, J.C. Electrowetting: From basics to applications. J. Phys. Condens. Matter 2005,
17, R705.
4. Abdelgawad, M.; Freire, S.L.S.; Yang, H.; Wheeler, A.R. All-terrain droplet actuation. Lab Chip
2008, 8, 672–677.
5. Liu, Y.J.; Yao, D.J.; Lin, H.C.; Chang, W.-Y.; Chang, H.-Y. DNA ligation of ultramicro volume using
an EWOD microfluidic system with coplanar electrodes. J. Micromech. Microeng. 2008, 18, 045017.
6. Srinivasan, V.; Pamula, V.K.; Fair, R.B. An integrated digital microfluidic lab-on-a-chip for clinical
diagnostics on human physiological fluids. Lab Chip 2004, 4, 310–315.
7. Taniguchi, T.; Torii, T.; Higuchi, T. Chemical reactions in microdroplets by electrostatic
manipulation of droplets in liquid media. Lab Chip 2002, 2, 19–23.
8. Miller, E.M.; Wheeler, A.R. A digital microfluidic approach to homogeneous enzyme assays.
Anal. Chem. 2008, 80, 1614–1619.
9. Barbulovic-Nad, I.; Yang, H.; Park, P.S.; Wheeler, A.R. Digital microfluidics for cell-based assays.
Lab Chip 2008, 8, 519–526.
10. Chang, Y.H.; Lee, G.B.; Huang, F.C.; Chen, Y.Y.; Lin, J.L. Integrated polymerase chain reaction
chips utilizing digital microfluidics. Biomed. Microdevices 2006, 8, 215–225.
11. Moon, H.; Wheeler, A.R.; Garrell, R.L.; Loo, J.A.; Kim, C.J. An integrated digital microfluidic chip
for multiplexed proteomic sample preparation and analysis by MALDI-MS. Lab Chip 2006, 6,
1213–1219.
12. Wheeler, A.R.; Moon, H.; Bird, C.A.; Loo, R.R.; Kim, C.J.; Loo, J.A.; Garrell, R.L. Digital
microfluidics with in-line sample purification for proteomics analyses with MALDI-MS. Anal.
Chem. 2005, 77, 534–540.
Micromachines 2015, 6 788
13. Wheeler, A.R.; Moon, H.; Kim, C.J.; Loo, J.A.; Garrell, R.L. Electrowetting-based microfluidics
for analysis of peptides and proteins by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry.
Anal. Chem. 2004, 76, 4833–4838.
14. Luk, V.N.; Mo, G.C.H.; Wheeler, A.R. Pluronic additives: A solution to sticky problems in digital
microfluidics. Langmuir 2008, 24, 6382–6389.
15. Chevalliot, S.; Kuiper, S.; Heikenfeld, J. Experimental validation of the invariance of electrowetting
contact angle saturation. J. Adhes. Sci. Technol. 2012, 26, 1909–1930.
16. Koopal, L.K. Wetting of solid surfaces: Fundamentals and charge effects. Adv. Colloid Interface Sci.
2012, 179, 29–42.
17. Chen, L.; Bonaccurso, E. Electrowetting—From statics to dynamics. Adv. Colloid Interface Sci.
2014, 210, 2–12.
18. Wang, K.L.; Jones, T.B. Saturation effects in dynamic electrowetting. Appl. Phys. Lett. 2005,
86, 054104.
19. Bavière, R.; Boutet, J.; Fouillet, Y. Dynamics of droplet transport induced by electrowetting
actuation. Microfluid. Nanofluid. 2008, 4, 287–294.
20. Yeo, L.Y.; Chang, H.C. Static and spontaneous electrowetting. Mod. Phys. Lett. B 2005, 19,
549–569.
21. Gupta, R.; Sheth, D.M.; Boone, T.K.; Sevilla, A.B.; Fréchette, J. Impact of pinning of the triple
contact line on electrowetting performance. Langmuir 2011, 27, 14923–14929.
22. Moon, H.; Cho, S.K.; Garrell, R.L. Low voltage electrowetting-on-dielectric. J. Appl. Phys. 2002,
92, 4080–4087.
23. Chang, J.; Choi, D.Y.; Han, S.; Pak, J.J. Driving characteristics of the electrowetting-on-dielectric
device using atomic-layer-deposited aluminum oxide as the dielectric. Microfluidi. Nanofluid. 2010,
8, 269–273.
24. Berthier, J.; Peponnet, C. A model for the determination of the dimensions of dents for jagged
electrodes in electrowetting on dielectric microsystems. Biomicrofluidics 2007, 1, 014104.
25. Chen, J.; Yu, Y.; Li, J.; Lai, Y.; Zhou, J. Size-variable droplet actuation by interdigitated
electrowetting electrode. Appl. Phys. Lett. 2012, 101, 234102.
26. Pyne, D.G.; Salman, W.M.; Abdelgawad, M.; Sun, Y. Partially filled electrodes for digital
microfluidic devices. Appl. Phys. Lett. 2013, 103, 024103.
27. Accardo, A.; Mecarini, F.; Leoncini, M.; Brandi, F.; Di Cola, E.; Burghammer, M.; Riekel, C.;
Di Fabrizio, E. Fast, active droplet interaction: Coalescence and reactive mixing controlled by
electrowetting on a superhydrophobic surface. Lab Chip 2013, 13, 332–335.
28. Hill, R.M. Superhydrophobic surfaces. Curr. Opin. Colloid Interface Sci. 2006, 11, 193–202.
29. Vasudev, A.; Jagtiani, A.; Du, L.; Zhe, J. A low-voltage droplet microgripper for micro-object
manipulation. J. Micromech. Microeng. 2009, 19, 075005.
30. Sen, P.; Kim, C.J. Capillary spreading dynamics of electrowetted sessile droplets in air. Langmuir
2009, 25, 4302–4305.
31. Verplanck, N.; Coffinier, Y.; Thomy, V.; Boukherroub, R. Wettability switching techniques on
superhydrophobic surfaces. Nanoscale Res. Lett. 2007, 2, 577–596.
Micromachines 2015, 6 789
32. Li, Y.; Parkes, W.; Haworth, L.I.; Ross, A.; Stevenson, J.; Walton, A.J. Room-temperature
fabrication of anodic tantalum pentoxide for low-voltage electrowetting on dielectric (EWOD).
J. Microelectromech. Syst. 2008, 17, 1481–1488.
33. Jönsson-Niedziółka, M.; Lapierre, F.; Coffinier, Y.; Parry, S.J.; Zoueshtiagh, F.; Foat, T.; Thomy, V.;
Boukherroub, R. EWOD driven cleaning of bioparticles on hydrophobic and superhydrophobic
surfaces. Lab Chip 2011, 11, 490–496.
34. Mugele, F. Fundamental challenges in electrowetting: From equilibrium shapes to contact angle
saturation and drop dynamics. Soft Matter 2009, 5, 3377–3384.
35. Sedev, R. Electrowetting: Electrocapillarity, saturation, and dynamics. Eur. Phys. J. Spec. Top.
2011, 197, 307–319.
36. Bormashenko, E.; Gendelman, O. A generalized electrowetting equation: Its derivation and
consequences. Chem. Phys. Lett. 2014, 599, 139–141.
© 2015 by the authors; licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article
distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).

Supplementary resource (1)

... There are several types of microfluidic technologies most commonly used for cell cultures: microfluidics with mechanical traps [104,105], microfluidics for droplet formation [106][107][108][109][110], and microfluidics with microchambers [111][112][113][114][115] (Figure 5). Microfluidics with mechanical traps/pillars are used to retain cells in flow-through systems. ...
Article
Full-text available
One of the approaches widely used today to intensify processes is their miniaturization. Small, compact, portable devices that can be used directly in the field will become popular in the near future. The use of microstructured devices is becoming more widespread in diagnostics, analytics, and production, so there is no doubt that the same approach is being applied to energy production. The question is whether it is possible to create an energy production system that has all the external characteristics of a miniaturized device but is sustainable, durable, environmentally friendly, based on renewable sources, and cost-effective. The first challenge is to choose a production route, an energy source that has the required characteristics, and then to adapt this production on a microscale. Among the different energy sources, biohydrogen meets most of the requirements. The carbon emissions of biohydrogen are much lower, and its production is less energy-intensive than conventional hydrogen production. Moreover, it can be produced from renewable energy sources. The challenge today is to make this process sustainable due to the low substrate conversion, production rate, and yield. Microfluidic systems are one of the technologies that could address the above shortcomings of the current biohydrogen production processes. The combination of microdevices and biohydrogen production opens up new possibilities for energy production. Although this area of research is growing, the focus of this review is on the possibility of using microfluidics for biohydrogen production.
... This operation is widely used in chemical and biological fields. Some previous studies detected droplet merging by capacitive sensing and feedback [27,28]. However, this method is time consuming because it needs to scan every electrode. ...
Article
Full-text available
A digital microfluidic system based on electrowetting-on-dielectric is a new technology for controlling microliter-sized droplets on a plane. By applying a voltage signal to an electrode, the droplets can be controlled to move, merge, and split. Due to device design, fabrication, and runtime uncertainties, feedback control schemes are necessary to ensure the reliability and accuracy of a digital microfluidic system for practical application. The premise of feedback is to obtain accurate droplet position information. Therefore, there is a strong need to develop a digital microfluidics system integrated with driving, position, and feedback functions for different areas of study. In this article, we propose a driving and feedback scheme based on machine vision for the digital microfluidics system. A series of experiments including droplet motion, merging, status detection, and self-adaption are performed to evaluate the feasibility and the reliability of the proposed scheme. The experimental results show that the proposed scheme can accurately locate multiple droplets and improve the success rate of different applications. Furthermore, the proposed scheme provides an experimental platform for scientists who focused on the digital microfluidics system.
... Printed strain sensors based on an intermittent conductive pattern filled with resistive ink droplets were presented by Zymelka et al. [26]. Dynamics of electrowetting droplet motion in digital microfluidic systems was analyzed by Cui et al. [27]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The numerical simulation and analysis of the ejection of an ink droplet through a nozzle as well its motion through air until its contact with a surface and taking up of a stable form is performed. The fluid flow is modeled by the incompressible Navier–Stokes equations with added surface tension. The presented model can be solved using either a level set or a phase field method to track the fluid interface. Here, the level set method is used to determinate the interface between ink and air. The presented work concentrates on the demonstration how to check the suitability of ink for inkjet printhead nozzles, for instance, for the use in printers. The results such as velocity, change of size, and volume dependence on time of an ink droplet are presented. Recommendations for the use of specific inks are also given.
... As the droplet moves over the activated electrode, the effective contact line length (L(t)) changes with time. Following the approach of Cui et al. [31], the time variation of the effective contact line can be (Fig. 7), and the chord length L(t) can be expressed as, ...
Preprint
The improvements in the dynamic performance of droplet movement over a newly designed and fabricated triangular coplanar electrode system utilizing the principle of electrowetting on dielectric (EWOD) is extensively probed and compared with results available in the literature. The process is further explored by developing a model, taking into account the pertinent driving and retarding forces, the role of the effective contact line length and an in-situ evaluation of the contact line friction coefficient. Furthermore, the efficiency of the fabricated digital microfluidic platform is quantified and compared in terms of driving force and velocities.
... Electrowetting on dielectric (EWOD) is an emerging process with many applications, such as micro-drop generation, droplet mixing and splitting [10,11], liquid refractive index measurement [12], liquid lenses [13]. The use of electrowetting-controlled liquid lenses has emerged as a novel approach for solar tracking and concentration. ...
Article
Full-text available
Traditional tracking devices for solar energy applications have several disadvantages, such as bulky mechanical structure, large wind loads, and ease of misalignment. This study aims to design a flat, thin, and adaptive beam steering device to eliminate these drawbacks. A proof of concept device was fabricated to demonstrate this design. The novelty of the proof of concept device is the hexagonal structure of the electrowetting cell design. The hexagonal cell was dosed with two immiscible liquids with different refractive indices. The hypothesis of this design is that by deforming the liquid shape with the application of voltage, light can be steered and concentrated for solar energy applications. A maximum contact angle change of 44° was observed with the application of 26 V to one of the electrodes of the hexagonal cell. The device demonstrated a 4.5° change of laser beam path with only a 0.2 refractive index difference of the liquids. The 3D simulation model developed in this study shows that a tilted and flat interface can be achieved using higher dielectric constant dielectric materials. The device can facilitate the planer steering and concentration of sunlight for rooftop applications without moving mechanical parts.
Article
Electrowetting‐on‐dielectric (EWOD) devices have proven to be effective tools for precise microfluidic manipulation or in liquid lenses that surpass conventional solid lenses in versatility. However, the fabrication of these devices presents many challenges, such as their scalability or the growing concern on their environmental impact due to materials used in their fabrication. This review provides a comprehensive analysis of the materials currently used in the fabrication of EWOD devices and the characteristics they must meet. In addition, a discussion of future challenges in the fabrication of EWOD devices is presented, in particular the environmental problems presented by some of the materials currently in use. The popularity of electrowetting‐on‐dielectric devices (EWOD) has been growing exponentially in recent years. However, the fabrication of these devices presents many challenges. The purpose of this review is to provide a comprehensive analysis of the materials and their characteristics that are currently used in fabrication of EWOD devices. Futher, environmental challenges are discussed in relation to the future of the field.
Thesis
Full-text available
This thesis explores the design and development of an electrowetting-based digital microfluidic (DMF) platform with a novel triangular coplanar electrodes array and with the capability of working at a relatively low operating voltage. The dielectric material, placed in between the electrodes and the liquid droplet to prevent electrolysis, plays a vital role in the performance of any electrowetting based system. One of the major focus of the research is also to develop a new composite dielectric material that will allow low voltage actuation and provide enhanced dielectric strength for extended operation of any device. In the present research, a nanocomposite thin film of graphene oxide (GO) and polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) is synthesized and used as an insulating layer in the fabricated electrowetting-on-dielectric (EWOD) device. The nanocomposite of varying GO concentration is prepared using PDMS as a matrix and commercially available GO as a filling material. This whole nanocomposite preparation is accomplished through an in-situ polymerization process. Thorough characterizations of the GO nanofillers and the fabricated GO-PDMS nanocomposite films using transmission electron microscopy (TEM), field emission scanning electron microscopy (FESEM), and Raman spectroscopy reveal the morphology and distribution patterns of the GO nanofillers placed inside the PDMS matrix. Subsequently, dielectric characterization of the prepared GO-PDMS composite reveals that the dielectric constant and dielectric breakdown field of PDMS substantially get enhanced due to the incorporation of the GO fillers in the PDMS matrix. In contrast, a significant lowering of actuation voltage has been observed during the EWOD process, possibly owing to enhanced interfacial polarization of nanocomposite material. The above results from GO-PDMS composite characterization are achieved at a certain concentration of GO until the 'percolation threshold' is reached, following which the conductive properties of the composite start to surpass gradually. Finally, the results on droplet actuation and electrowetting studies on GO-PDMS composite are compared with bare PDMS as a dielectric for establishing the efficacy of the DMF devices. To facilitate smooth droplet actuation, an electrical switching circuit is developed using the following components: (i) Arduino Mega (microcontroller), (ii) electromagnetic relays (controlling switches), and (iii) DC-DC boost power amplifier. This circuit provides an opportunity to construct a robust and compact setup for droplet actuation over the fabricated DMF platform, thus making this ideal and flexible for a number of lab-onchip and point of care applications. An array of nine identical equilateral triangular geometry electrodes configured in sequential but opposite orientation is designed to facilitate as active working electrodes in the EWOD based DMF device. The fabrication process of the DMF device is followed by the droplet transportation experiments, and the immediate outcomes are compared with the results available in the reported literature. This process is further explored by developing a model based on the pertinent driving and retarding forces, the role of the effective contact line length, and an in-situ evaluation of the contact line friction coefficient. Finally, the droplet transport efficiency of the fabricated digital microfluidic platform is quantified and compared by computing the driving force and accurate measurement of the droplet velocities.
Article
The digital microfluidic system based on electrowetting on dielectric is a new technology that can control microliter droplets within the plane. Because of layout, fabrication, and driving uncertainties, feedback control schemes must be designed and implemented to ensure safety and reliability of digital microfluidic system for practical application. The basis for feedback is to realize the accurate droplet location. So, there is a strong need for the development of a digital microfluidic system integrated with position and feedback scheme for innovative biological research. In this paper, we propose a position and feedback scheme based on light intensity for digital microfluidic system. The verified experiment results show that the proposed position and feedback scheme can position multiple droplets accurately and improve the success rate of droplets transport application by feedback.
Article
Full-text available
Electrowetting has become one of the most widely used tools for manipulating tiny amounts of liquids on surfaces. Applications range from 'lab-on-a-chip' devices to adjustable lenses and new kinds of electronic displays. In the present article, we review the recent progress in this rapidly growing field including both fundamental and applied aspects. We compare the various approaches used to derive the basic electrowetting equation, which has been shown to be very reliable as long as the applied voltage is not too high. We discuss in detail the origin of the electrostatic forces that induce both contact angle reduction and the motion of entire droplets. We examine the limitations of the electrowetting equation and present a variety of recent extensions to the theory that account for distortions of the liquid surface due to local electric fields, for the finite penetration depth of electric fields into the liquid, as well as for finite conductivity effects in the presence of AC voltage. The most prominent failure of the electrowetting equation, namely the saturation of the contact angle at high voltage, is discussed in a separate section. Recent work in this direction indicates that a variety of distinct physical effects---rather than a unique one---are responsible for the saturation phenomenon, depending on experimental details. In the presence of suitable electrode patterns or topographic structures on the substrate surface, variations of the contact angle can give rise not only to continuous changes of the droplet shape, but also to discontinuous morphological transitions between distinct liquid morphologies. The dynamics of electrowetting are discussed briefly. Finally, we give an overview of recent work aimed at commercial applications, in particular in the fields of adjustable lenses, display technology, fibre optics, and biotechnology-related microfluidic devices.
Article
Full-text available
There has been recent renewed interest in electrocapillary and electrowetting phenomena given its potential for microfluidic actuation and manipulation. Different approaches, in which a variety of electrode configurations have been adopted, however, have dominated the developments in this field. These different approaches have given rise to rich and varied behavior, which has often led to some overlap and confusion in the literature. In this article, we delineate the different observations and elucidate the relationship between these phenomena by re-stressing classical concepts and examining their limitations. Particular emphasis is placed on the distinction between static and spontaneous electrowetting. In the former, a static change in the liquid-solid macroscopic contact angle results when a dielectric film-coated planar plate electrode is employed. In the latter, a spontaneous thin fron-t-running electrowetting film is pulled out ahead of the macroscopic drop with the use of planar parallel line electrodes. This dynamically evolving electrowetting film advances much faster than the macroscopic drop itself and behaves in a self-similar manner analogous to gravity spreading films.
Article
Full-text available
A novel electrowetting-on-dielectrics (EWOD) device in open planar geometry allows probing of droplet mixing on a superhydrophobic substrate under quasi contact-free conditions. We demonstrate a droplet-based microreactor with integrated convective-flow mixing for the reactive-mixing of CaCl(2)/Na(2)CO(3) solutions. The device provides unique conditions for scattering, spectroscopy and imaging probes requiring an unobstructed droplet-access.
Article
The thermodynamics of electrowetting is treated. A general equation of electrowetting is derived from the first principles. It is demonstrated that the well-known Lippmann Equation describes a particular case of electrowetting when the radial derivative of the capacitance of the double layer is constant. The apparent contact angle of electrowetting depends on the gradient of capacity of a double layer in the vicinity of the triple line. The role of the area adjacent to the triple line in constituting the equilibrium apparent contact angle of electrowetting is emphasized.
Article
As digital microfluidics technology evolves, the need for integrating additional elements (e.g., sensing/detection and heating elements) on the electrode increases. Consequently, electrode area for droplet actuation is reduced to create space for accommodating these additional elements, which undesirably affects force generation. Electrodes cannot simply be scaled larger to compensate for this loss of force, as this would also increase droplet volume and thereby compromise the advantages thought in miniaturization. Here, we present a study evaluating, numerically with preliminary experimental verification, different partially filled electrode designs and suggesting designs that combine high actuation forces with a large reduction in electrode area.
Article
We propose electrowetting on dielectric (EWOD) electrodes to actuate size-variable droplets. By using interdigitated fingers and maximizing them in optimized construction, we can control droplets in different sizes with the same electrode array automatically. We both do the theory calculation and experiment verification to study the electrode with rectangular fingers. It is found that the electrode with triangle fingers can actuate droplets as small as 1/36 of that actuated by conventional square electrode array. It can actuate large droplets more efficiently than rectangular fingers. This work provides an approach to achieve multifunctional EWOD devices in the future.
Article
Basic electrowetting theory predicts that a continued increase in applied voltage will allow contact angle modulation to zero degrees. In practice, the effect of contact angle saturation has always been observed to limit the contact angle modulation, often only down to a contact angle of 60 to 70°. The physical origins of contact angle saturation have not yet been explained successfully and unequivocally. At best, scientists have produced multiple disconnected hypotheses (droplet ejection, charge injection, a thermodynamic limit, etc.) that do not satisfactorily hold for the large body of electrowetting experimental results. Herein we experimentally demonstrate that when using DC voltage, electrowetting contact angle saturation is invariant with electric field, contact line profile, interfacial tension, choice of non-polar insulating fluid, and type of polar conductive fluid or ionic content. The selected experiments were performed and designed using conventional electrowetting materials, without bias toward supporting a particular theory. Because the experimental results show such a strong invariance of saturation to multiple parameters, a new theory for electrowetting saturation is suggested: micro-droplet ejection through “Taylor saturation”. Although this work does not unequivocally prove what does cause contact angle saturation, it reveals what factors play a very limited or no role, and how dominant factors causing saturation may change with time of voltage application. This study thereby provides additional direction to the continued pursuit of a universal theory for electrowetting saturation.
Article
An automatic ultramicro-volume DNA ligation process using a coplanar electrode type of electrowetting-on-dielectric (EWOD) microfluidic system was designed for economy of reagent. The droplets, containing DNA, a ligation enzyme and a multi-salt reaction buffer, served to complete the ligation using a developed EWOD system. Droplets of ultramicro volume (0.3 µL) were successfully generated from reservoirs between one plate with coplanar electrodes and another plate with a hydrophobic surface free of electrodes. In one successful cloning, the total usage of reagents in an ultramicro-volume EWOD chip was 2.1 µL; no volume was wasted, in comparison with 85% waste with the standard protocol and 80% waste with a free-cover coplanar EWOD chip. The results also show that the entire process was accomplished without damage to the chip surface and without biomaterial annulment. With a design consisting of electrode pathways in a flexible pattern and multiplex reservoirs, an EWOD digital microfluidic system with coplanar electrodes would be improved as an efficient parallel DNA-cloning system in the construction of an artificial library or expression library.