ArticlePDF Available

NATO and the Challenge of Sustainable Peacebuilding

Authors:

Abstract

This piece introduces the concept of sustainable peacebuilding and briefly examines the growing involvement of NATO in peacebuilding operations. It also previews the empirical articles in this special section, explaining how they advance our understanding of the challenges faced by NATO in its peacebuilding efforts.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
NATO and the Challenge of Sustainable Peacebuilding
Gheciu, Alexandra;Paris, Roland
Global Governance; Jan-Mar 2011; 17, 1; ProQuest
pg. 75
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
... Top of the list as regards the composition of NATO is that it is still a reflection of the Post World War II. [Gheciu, 2011]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The complexities inherent in the process of reconstruction is one that cannot be overemphasized, most importantly, the need to reconstruct NATO in the post Trump era. The North Atlantic Treaty Organization was established in 1949 with the aim of providing collective security against threats and ideological conflicts posed by the Soviet Union. The United States of America has since then played strategic, pivotal and leadership roles for the sustainability of NATO. The organization's essential purpose is to safeguard the liberty and security of all its members by both political and military endeavors. Collective defense and security heart is the alliance, as well as the need to foster unity, solidarity and cohesion amongst member states. This paper, hinged on historical and analytical approaches, examines the essence of NATO from a historical perspective, and proper solutions as regards the reconstruction of NATO in the post Trump era. Evidently, realities on ground show the need to reconcile alongside member states, the vision and purpose of NATO in the 21st Century.
... These are often described in the context of capturing, and changing the outcomes of, external intervention or resisting external interveners (Paris 2009), or regarding frictions and ensuing 'hybrid' outcomes (Mac Ginty 2010Richmond and Mitchell 2011;Höglund 2012;Jarstad and Belloni 2012;Björkdahl et al. 2016). In this context, external peacebuilders are described as a group of international organizations and agencies that engage in peacebuilding (Wallensteen 2002;Jarstad and Sisk 2008;Paris 2009Paris , 2010Gheciu and Paris 2011;Eriksson and Kostić 2013;Hensell 2015) and often implement reforms in the name of 'the international community' (Bliesemann de Guevara and Kühn 2011). ...
Article
Full-text available
This article explores the role of informal networks in producing strategic knowledge and influencing policy responses to the 2011 post-election crisis in Bosnia-Herzegovina. The analytical focus is on networks of shadow peacebuilders, defined as actors who are often not visible to the public and who promote a mix of altruistic and personal interests of their broader network by generating strategic narratives and influencing peacebuilding policy. As this article shows, shadow peacebuilders engage in diplomatic counterinsurgencies waged by means of diplomacy, politics, public relations and legal means. Strategic narratives are instrumental in legitimizing diplomatic counterinsurgency, inducing internal cohesion within the network and delegitimizing alternative narratives and policy solutions. Yet the production of strategic knowledge by shadow peacebuilders has its limitations. When the gap between strategic narrative and actions becomes too big, the network risks fragmentation and defeat by other networks that promote alternative strategic narratives and paths of action in the battle over control of peacebuilding policy.
... The first key gap concerns our understanding of process. With all the focus on antecedents, outcomes and the large body of political science and peacebuilding literature that examines the broader implications of comprehensive approach (Friis, 2012;Gheciu & Paris, 2011;M. J. Williams, 2011), there is limited systematic research at an organizational level of analysis on the detail-the messy and complex process of actually implementing comprehensive approach 1 . ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Comprehensive approach is often thought of in terms of “coherence and coordination,” which represent desirable qualities for any interorganizational interactions occurring in interventions. Much literature emphasises the antecedents to effective coherence and coordination, the postulated positive outcomes in their presence and observed negative outcomes in their absence, and the various individual, organizational, cultural and political challenges in implementation. A small but growing body of literature, mainly confined to defence research agencies, considers the detailed process of implementing comprehensive approach, yet there is little research considering interaction processes at an organizational level of analysis. By drawing on extensive research from the fields of organizational science, public administration and management, this paper argues for two points. First, greater conceptual clarity is needed in the use of basic terminology, but also understanding of the real implications of various levels of interagency interaction. Attempts to systematize definitions in typologies are presented, and a suggestion about how to use the typologies in the context of comprehensive approach research is made. Understanding interagency interaction from an organizational perspective is important to guide policy makers and leadership about the organizational implications of interagency interaction, and to manage expectations about the limitations of high coherence and coordination. Second, greater cross-disciplinary thinking is needed from the disciplines of organizational science, public administration and management. There are vast literatures on interorganizational relationships in organizational science, collaborative governance and multiorganizational policy implementation in public administration, and network dynamics in management. Comprehensive approach research would benefit from applying the multitude of theories and frameworks available, and applying organizational levels of analysis.
Article
Full-text available
In accordance with their constitutional prerogatives, members of the Church engage in activities that align with their designated roles and responsibilities. A review of both the history of the Church and the documents in force reveals that the Church, in its broadest sense, is concerned with the promotion of peace. Such areas are, by definition, those which fall within the purview of laypeople. The Second Vatican Council accorded particular attention to the promotion of social justice and peace, as well as to the apostolate of lay faithful. Consequently, the two areas were brought into contact and underwent further development. This paper presents the historical trajectory that has culminated in the most comprehensive positioning of the laity in the promotion of social justice, elucidating the legal distinctions pertaining to the most prevalent methods through which they can promote peace.
Article
Kurulduğu andan bugüne kadar profesyonel ajandasını geliştiren NATO Soğuk Savaş’tan bugüne ayakta kalan ve etkinliğini koruyan örgütlerin başında gelmektedir. Bu çalışmanın ortaya çıkışı, ABD gibi merkez ülkelerin politik istikrarlarının NATO’nun sürekliliğindeki yerinin sorgulanması ile ilgilidir. Çalışmanın yöntemi NATO içerisindeki devletlerin Fragile State Index ve The Worldwide Governance Indicators kapsamındaki politik faktörlerine dayandırılarak panel veri analizi ile değerlendirilmesi şeklinde kurgulanmıştır ve disiplinler arası bir bakış açısıyla, analitik bir bağlam oluşturulmuştur. NATO’nun sürekliliğine katkı sağlayan ülkelerin politik etkinlikleri incelendiğinde başta ABD olmak üzere birçok ülkenin diğer üyelere göre geride olduğu, kuzey ülkelerinin görece daha etkin olduğu sonucuna ulaşılmıştır.
Article
Full-text available
O presente artigo visa examinar os conceitos de construção de paz (peacebuilding) e da paz híbrida. Seu objetivo é analisar de maneira crítica o processo de construção de paz desenvolvido pela Organização das Nações Unidas (ONU) de maneira a compreender porque ela é caracterizada como um processo de pacificação liberal e, também, examinar o conceito da paz híbrida. A metodologia utilizada é a revisão bibliográfica da literatura para que sejam expostas as teorias dos temas pesquisados. De modo a desenvolver a sua análise, o artigo está dividido em três seções. A primeira trata do histórico da Construção de Paz no âmbito das Nações Unidas durante e após a Guerra Fria. Na segunda seção será abordado uma análise crítica das técnicas utilizadas na construção de paz e como essas caracterizam uma ‘paz liberal’. Com o intuito de compreender como e porque a paz híbrida é considerada uma alternativa à construção de paz liberal, será também analisado seus conceitos teóricos. Em um terceiro momento, será exposto como a construção de paz e técnicas da paz híbrida foram aplicadas ao contexto do Afeganistão após da invasão estadunidense e a remoção do grupo Talibã da condução política central.
Book
This unique handbook brings together a team of leading scholars and practitioners in order to map, synthesize and assess key perspectives on cooperation and rivalry between regional and global organizations in world politics. For the first time, a variety of inter-disciplinary theoretical and conceptual perspectives are combined in order to assess the nature, processes and outcomes of inter-organizational partnerships and rivalries across major policy areas, such as peace and security, human rights and democratisation as well as finance, development and climate change . This text provides scholars, students and policy-makers of International Relations with an exhaustive reference book for understanding the theoretical and empirical dimensions of an increasingly important topic in International Relations (IR), Global Governance and related disciplines.
Article
The article examines the development of the relationship and cooperation of the European Union (EU) and North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) in conflict regulation. It states that over three phases these two institutions deepened their relationship in the aspect of an intensification of their cooperation, an adoption of specific functions and a de facto clearer division of labour in conflict regulation. It will analyse whether and to what degree this cooperation and a functional division of labour is based on the functional ascription by member states or more on the activities of the institutions themselves. This comparative study will thereby contribute to a necessary theory-based analysis of the relationship of these two major international security institutions and to a deeper analysis of the inter-institutional cooperation of EU and NATO. Furthermore, it will show the importance of a combined principal- (states) and agent- (institutions) centred approach towards the shaping and explaining of inter-institutional relationships as well as going beyond the simple principal–agent relationship and advancing to the principal–agent–agent relationship.
Article
Full-text available
Focusing on relations between NATO and Russia surrounding the Alliance's decision to enlarge, this paper develops a theory of symbolic power that highlights the relationship between identities, narrative structures, institutions, and legitimate action in the construction of security policy. We demonstrate that such a theory provides a significant contribution to analysing the role of NATO in post-Cold War security, to understanding the evolution of NATO-Russia relations, to assessing the 'promise' of international institutions as a means of structuring security relations, as well as highlighting forms of power at work in the social construction of 'security communities'.
Article
Full-text available
This article demonstrates that there are more similarities between peacekeeping and counter-insurgency than often recognized. In today's 'war among the people', the counter-insurgent cannot succeed with offensive military capabilities alone and must seek to apply also non-kinetic and defensive methods; whereas the peacekeeper often is forced to apply 'robust' and kinetic means to implement a mandate. As a result, the two concepts seem to be converging and share some commonalities. The article compares the UN Department of Peacekeeping Operations 'capstone doctrine' and the US Army Counterinsurgency Field Manual to argue that the two doctrines share similarities in six areas: (1) a focus on civilian solutions; (2) a need for protection of civilians; (3) international coherence; (4) host-nation ownership; (5) use of intelligence in support of operations; (6) limitations on the use of force. The article suggests areas where the two doctrines could mesh with each other.
Article
Full-text available
Since the mid-1990s the UN, in tandem with major western powers, has embarked upon an ambitious effort of peace support operations in Africa. The results of what we may call the ‘Annan experiment’ are not yet in. But there are good reasons to fear that, in many African countries, such peace operations have defend normative outcomes that are beyond realistic expectation, so that they can never hope to ‘succeed’. This article examines the political and economic functioning of fragile African states using the lens of a ‘political marketplace’ in which local elites seek to obtain the highest reward for their loyalty, over short time horizons, within patrimonial systems. In such systems, political institutions are incapable of managing confect, which means that standard peacemaking efforts and peacekeeping operations do not align with domestic possibilities for settlement. To the contrary, external engagements can so distort domestic political markets that they obstruct national political bargaining and result in an open-ended commitment to peacekeeping in countries such as the Democratic Republic of Congo and Sudan.
Article
This new volume explores the crisis in transatlantic relations and analyses the role of NATO following the collapse of the Soviet Union. The book offers a unified theory of cooperation in the new security paradigm to explain the current state of transatlantic relations and NATO's failure to adequately transform itself into a security institution for the 21st century. It argues that a new preoccupation with risk filled the vacuum left by the collapse of the Soviet Union, and uses the literature of the Risk Society to analyse the strained politics of the North Atlantic community. Using case studies to show how the West has pursued a strategy of risk management, and the effect this has had on NATO's politics, the book argues that a better understanding of how risk affects Western political cohesion will allow policy makers a way of adapting the structure of NATO to make it more effective as a tool for security. Having analysed NATO's recent failings, the book offers a theory for the way in which it can become an active risk manager, through the replacement of its established structure by smaller, ad hoc groupings.
Article
AutesserreSéverine. The Trouble with the Congo: Local Violence and the Failure of International Peacebuilding. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2010. xvii + 311 pp. Maps. Figures. Tables. Notes. Appendix. Bibliography. Index. $90.00. Cloth. $28.99. Paper. - Volume 54 Issue 3 - Lisa Karlborg
Article
The Trouble with the Congo suggests a new explanation for international peacebuilding failures in civil wars. Drawing from more than 330 interviews and a year and a half of field research, it develops a case study of the international intervention during the Democratic Republic of the Congo's unsuccessful transition from war to peace and democracy (2003–6). Grassroots rivalries over land, resources, and political power motivated widespread violence. However, a dominant peacebuilding culture shaped the intervention strategy in a way that precluded action on local conflicts, ultimately dooming the international efforts to end the deadliest conflict since World War II. Most international actors interpreted continued fighting as the consequence of national and regional tensions alone. UN staff and diplomats viewed intervention at the macro levels as their only legitimate responsibility. The dominant culture constructed local peacebuilding as such an unimportant, unfamiliar, and unmanageable task that neither shocking events nor resistance from select individuals could convince international actors to reevaluate their understanding of violence and intervention.