A huge shortfin mako shark Isurus oxyrinchus Rafinesque, 1810 (Chondrichthyes: Lamnidae) from the waters of Marmaris, Turkey.

Full text

$11$/(6©6HUKLVWQDW©©©

6KRUWVFLHQWLILFSDSHU 8'&
5HFHLYHG
$+8*(6+257),10$.26+$5.,685862;<5,1&+865$),1(648(
&+21'5,&+7+<(6/$01,'$()5207+(:$7(56
2)0$50$5,6785.(<
+DNDQ.$%$6$.$/
,FKWK\RORJLFDO5HVHDUFK6RFLHW\7DQWDYLPDKDOOHVL0HQWHÝR
ç
OXFDGGHVL
î
GLODSW1R'hPUDQL\H75
î
VWDQEXO7XUNH\
(PDLOKDNDQNDEDVDNDO#VXSHUSRVWDFRP
$OHVVDQGUR'(0$''$/(1$
,WDOLDQ*UHDW:KLWH6KDUN'DWD%DQNYLD/$ULRVWR,0LODQR,WDO\
$%675$&7
$KXJHIHPDOHVKRUWILQPDNRVKDUN,VXUXVR[\ULQFKXVZDVFDXJKWLQWKHODWHV RII0DUPDULV6($HJHDQ6HD
7XUNH\E\DFRPPHUFLDOILVKHUPDQ3KRWRJUDSKLFGRFXPHQWDWLRQKDVEHHQ XVHGE\ WKHDXWKRUV WRHVWLPDWH WKHWRWDO
OHQJWKRIWKLVVSHFLPHQDWFPUDQJHIURPWRFP7KLVVL]HJUHDWO\H[FHHGVWKHSUHYLRXVPD[LPXPVL]H
UHFRUGHGIRUWKHVSHFLHVDFPORQJ IHPDOHFDXJKWLQ6HSWHPEHURII6L[)RXUVOHV3ODJHV)UDQFH,WLVEH
OLHYHGWKDWWKH0DUPDULVVSHFLPHQLVWKHODUJHVWVKRUWILQPDNRHYHUUHFRUGHGZRUOGZLGH
.H\ZRUGV
VKRUWILQPDNRVKDUN,VXUXVR[\ULQFKXVPD[LPXPVL]HODUJHVWVSHFLPHQ7XUNH\$HJHDQ6HD
81(1250(648$/20$.2'$//(3,11(&257(,685862;<5,1&+86
5$),1(648(&+21'5,&+7+<(6/$01,'$(&$7785$72
$0$50$5,6785&+,$
6,17(6,
8QHQRUPHIHPPLQDGLVTXDOR PDNRGDOOH SLQQHFRUWH,VXUXVR[\ULQFKXVYHQQH FDWWXUDWDDOODILQH GHJOLDQQL
DOODUJRGL0DUPDULV0DU(JHR1RUG2ULHQWDOH7XUFKLDGDXQSHVFDWRUHSURIHVVLRQLVWD/DGRFXPHQWD]LRQHIRW R
JUDILFDoVWDWDXVDWDGDJOLDXWRULSHUVWLPDUH ODOXQJKH]]DWRWDOHGLWDOHHVHPSODUH SDULDFPUDQJHFRPSUHVRWUD
HFP7DOHPLVXUDVXSHUDDPSLDPHQWHOHGLPHQVLRQLPDVVLPHUHJLVWUDWHLQSUHFHGHQ]DSHUODVSHFLHXQD
IHPPLQDGLFPSUHVDQHO6HWWHPEUHD6L[)RXUVOHV3ODJHV)UDQFLD3HUWDQWROHVHPSODUHGL0DUPDULVoLO
SL|JUDQGHGHOODVXDVSHFLHPDLUHJLVWUDWRDOLYHOORPRQGLDOH
3DUROHFKLDYH
VTXDORPDNRGDOOHSLQQHFRUWH,VXUXVR[\ULQFKXVGLPHQVLRQLPDVVLPH7XUFKLD0DU(JHR

$11$/(6©6HUKLVWQDW©©©
%=G=J(0()HAOO=J@NK!"*!!)"+
!
%2$"0%,/1#&+*(,0%/(
&02/20,56/&+ %20
/#&+"0.2"

,1752'8&7,21
7KHSHUHJULQHIDOFRQRIWKHVKDUNZRUOGWKHVKRUWILQ
PDNR,VXUXVR[\ULQFKXV5DILQHVTXHLVDFRVPR
SROLWDQVSHFLHV LQ WHPSHUDWH DQG WURSLFDO ZDWHUV RI WKH
$WODQWLF3DFLILFDQG,QGLDQ2FHDQV,WLVSHODJLFFRDVWDO
DQGRFHDQLFRFFXUULQJDWDGHSWKUDQJHIURPWKHVXUIDFH
WRP&RPSDJQR7KHVKRUWILQPDNRLVSUHV
HQW LQ WKH HQWLUH 0HGLWHUUDQHDQ 'H 0DGGDOHQD 
%DHQVFK  ZKHUH LW LV FDXJKW PDLQO\ LQ WKH WXQD
ORQJOLQHILVKHU\DQGRFFDVLRQDOO\LQWKHVZRUGILVKILVKHU\
XVLQJ ORQJOLQHV DQG GULIWQHWV &HORQD HW DO 
0HJDORIRQRXHWDO
)LJ7KLVHVWLPDWHGFP7/IHPDOHVKRUWILQPDNR
VKDUN
,VXUXV R[\ULQFKXV
 FDXJKW LQ WKH ODWH V RII
0DUPDULV 7XUNH\ LV EHOLHYHG WR EH WKH ODUJHVW RI LWV
VSHFLHVHYHUUHFRUGHGZRUOGZLGH
6O  7D SR QDÉLK RFHQDK  FP GROJD VDPLFD YUVWH
DWODQWVNLPDNR
,VXUXVR[\ULQFKXV
XMHWDYSR]QLKLK
RE REDOL NUDMD 0DUPDULV 7XUàLMD MH YHUMHWQR QDMYHàML
NDGDUNROL]DEHOHËHQSULPHUHNVYRMHYUVWH
7KH

SUHVHQFH

RI

,

R[\ULQFKXV

LQ

7XUNLVK

ZDWHUV

LV
NQRZQ

GXH

WR

WKH

SLRQHHULQJ

ZRUN

RI

$NÝ
u
UD\



LQ
%LOHFHQR
ç
OX

HW

DO



$IWHU

WKH

ILUVW

UHFRUG

RI

WKH

VSH
FLHV

LQ

WKH

VHDV

RI

7XUNH\

WKHUH

KDYH

EHHQ

QXPHURXV
VXEVHTXHQW

DFFRXQWV

RI

LWV

RFFXUUHQFH

RII

WKH

7XUNLVK
FRDVW

PDGH

E\

VHYHUDO

DXWKRUV

UHYLHZHG

LQ

.DEDVDNDO




,Q

WKH

SUHVHQW

DUWLFOH

ZH

UHSRUW

RQ

D
KLVWRULFDO

UHFRUG

RI

D

KXJH

VKRUWILQ

PDNR

IURP

7XUNLVK
ZDWHUV
0$7(5,$/6$1'0(7+2'6
$

VKRUWILQ

PDNR

)LJ



ZDV

FDXJKW

LQ

WKH

ODWH

V
RII

0DUPDULV

6(

$HJHDQ

6HD

7XUNH\

)LJ



E\

D

FRP
PHUFLDO

ILVKHUPDQ

XVLQJ

DQ

XQNQRZQ

W\SH

RI

ILVKLQJ

QHW
$GGLWLRQDO

GHWDLOV

RI

WKLV

FDSWXUH

DUH

XQNQRZQ

7KH

FDS
WXUHG

VSHFLPHQ

ZDV

KXQJ

RQ

D

SROH

IURP

D

EDWWOHVKLS

RI
WKH

7XUNLVK

1DY\

DQFKRUHG

QHDU

0DUPDULV

6SHFLHV
LGHQWLILFDWLRQ

LV

EDVHG

RQ

WKH

SKRWRJUDSK

ZKLFK

ZDV
WDNHQ

E\

WKH

VDLORUV

DQG

LV

EDVHG

RQ

'H

0DGGDOHQD

HW

DO


$V

LW

ZDV

SRLQWHG

RXW

LQ

'H

0DGGDOHQD

HW

DO


SKRWRV

PXVW

EH

XVHG

ZLWK

JUHDW

FDXWLRQ

ZKHQ

HV
WLPDWLQJ

WKH

VL]H

RI

D

ODUJH

VKDUN

VLQFH

WKHUH

LV

D

KLJK
SUREDELOLW\

RI

LQDFFXUDWH

UHVXOWV

,W

LV

DEVROXWHO\

QHFHVVDU\
WKDW

ZH

XVH

RQO\

SLFWXUHV

RI

WKH

ZKROH

VSHFLPHQ

RU

D
ZLGH

SDUW

RI

LW

WKDW

LV

QRW

GHIRUPHG

E\

LPSHUIHFWLRQV

LQ
WKH

FDPHUD

OHQV

RU

E\

WKH

SHUVSHFWLYH

RI

WKH

VKRW

,W

LV

DOVR
HVVHQWLDO

WKDW

D

ODUJH

REMHFW

RI

NQRZQ

VL]H

LV

ORFDWHG

LQ
WKH

SODQH

RI

WKH

VKDUN

LQ

WKH

SKRWRJUDSK

7KH

SKRWR

SRU
WUD\LQJ

WKH

0DUPDULV

VSHFLPHQ

PHHWV

WKHVH

FULWHULD

DQG
KDV

EHHQ

FRQVLGHUHG

VXLWDEOH

IRU

SURGXFLQJ

D

YDOLG
HVWLPDWH

RI

WKH

VSHFLPHQ

VL]H

7KH

SKRWRJUDSK

RI

WKH
VSHFLPHQ

LV

VWRUHG

LQ

WKH

DUFKLYHV

RI

WKH

,FKWK\RORJLFDO
5HVHDUFK

6RFLHW\

,56
5(68/76$1'',6&866,21
7KH

IROORZLQJ

PRUSKRORJLFDO

IHDWXUHV

RI

WKH

VSHFLPHQ
SRUWUD\HG

LQ

WKH

SKRWR

DOORZHG

WKH

DXWKRUV

WR

PDNH

DQ
LPPHGLDWH

LGHQWLILFDWLRQ

RI

WKH

VSHFLPHQ

DV

,VXUXV
R[\ULQFKXV

VWURQJO\

VSLQGOHVKDSHG

ERG\

SRLQWHG

FRQL
FDO

VQRXW

SUHVHQFH

RI

FDXGDO

NHHO

ORQJ

JLOO

VOLWV

RULJLQ

RI
GRUVDO

ILQ

SRVWHULRU

WR

SHFWRUDO

ILQ

IUHH

UHDU

WLSV

UHODWLYHO\
VKRUW

SHFWRUDO

ILQV

KLJK

DQG

HUHFW

ILUVW

GRUVDO

ILQ

QDUURZ
DQG

FXUYHG

WHHWK

QR

EODFN

VSRW

RQ

WKH

YHQWUDO

VXUIDFH

RI
WKH

DSH[

RI

SHFWRUDO

ILQV

'H

0DGGDOHQD

HW

DO


7KHVL]HRI WKHVKDUNZDVQRWUHSRUWHG DQGLWLVQRW
NQRZQZKHWKHULWZDVPHDVXUHGDW WKHWLPHRIFDSWXUH
RUQRW+RZHYHUWKHH[FHSWLRQDOVL]HRIWKLVVSHFLPHQLV
FOHDUO\ GHPRQVWUDWHG E\ WKH SKRWRJUDSKLF GRFXPHQWD
WLRQ7KHDXWKRUVXVHGWKHSKRWRRIWKH0DUPDULVPDNR
WR SURGXFH DQ DFFXUDWH HVWLPDWH RI WKH VL]H RI WKLV
VSHFLPHQ:HXVHGWKHILUVWVDLORUVWDQGLQJDWWKHWRSRI
WKH VWDLUV RI WKH EDWWOHVKLS DV D UHIHUHQFH 6LQFH WKH
7XUNLVK 1DY\ LV NQRZQ WR WDNHVDLORUV WKDW DUH DW OHDVW
FPWDOOZHRQDVVXPHGWKHVDLORUXVHGDVWKHUHIHU

$11$/(6©6HUKLVWQDW©©©
%=G=J(0()HAOO=J@NK!"*!!)"+
!
%2$"0%,/1#&+*(,0%/(
&02/20,56/&+ %20
/#&+"0.2"

)LJ&DSWXUHORFDWLRQ0DUPDULV7XUNH\RIWKHHVWLPDWHGFP7/IHPDOHVKRUWILQPDNRVKDUN
,VXUXVR[\ULQFKXV
SKRWRJUDSKFRXUWHV\RI$WHÜ(YLUJHQ
6O/RNDFLMD0DUPDULV7XUàLMDNMHUMHELODXMHWDFPGROJDVDPLFDDWODQWVNHJDPDNRMD
,VXUXVR[\ULQFKXV
IRWRJUDILMDODVW$WHÜD(YLUJHQD
HQFHZDVRIWKDWKHLJKW+RZHYHUWKHVDLORULVQRWLQWKH
VDPH SODQH DV WKH VKDUN EHLQJ IXUWKHU DZD\ IURP WKH
SKRWRJUDSKHU 7KHUHIRUH ZH QHHGHG WR FDOFXODWH KRZ
PXFKWKH VDLORUV KHLJKW KDV EHHQ UHGXFHG E\ WKHSHU
VSHFWLYHFRPSDUHGWRKLVVL]HLIKHKDGEHHQORFDWHGLQ
WKHVDPHSODQHDVWKHVKDUN:HFRPSDUHGWKHKHLJKWRI
WKH VWHSV DW WKH EDVH RI WKH VWDLUV QHDU WKH VKDUN ZLWK
WKRVHDWWKHWRS7KHSKRWRZDVVFDQQHGDQGHQODUJHG
DQGWKHVWHSVZHUHPHDVXUHGDVDFFXUDWHO\DVSRVVLEOHWR
REWDLQ D VFDOLQJ IDFWRU :H FRQFOXGHG WKDW WKH VDLORU
ZRXOGDSSHDURIKLVVL]HZKHQWUDQVSRVHGWRWKH
VDPHSODQHDVWKHVKDUN7KHVFDOLQJIDFWRUPD\
KDYH D PLQRU GHJUHH RI HUURU EHFDXVH ZKHQ HQODUJHG
WKHROGSKRWRLVQRWVKDUSZKLFKPDNHVLWLPSRVVLEOHWR
REWDLQ D PRUH DFFXUDWH PHDVXUHPHQW 7KHQ ZH HDVLO\
FDOFXODWHG WKH VL]H RI WKH VKDUN DW  FP SUHFDXGDO
OHQJWK3&/7KHIROORZLQJUHODWLRQVKLSVZHUHWKHQXVHG
WRFDOFXODWHWKHWRWDOOHQJWKRIWKHVKDUNIURPWKH3&/
8&/ XSSHU FDXGDO OHQJWK   3&/  
&OLIIHWDO
7/WRWDOOHQJWK 3&/8&/%DVVHWDO
:HWKHUHIRUHREWDLQHGDPHDVXUHPHQWRIFP7/
IRUWKH0DUPDULVVSHFLPHQ
$FFRUGLQJ WR 'H 0DGGDOHQD HW DO  VKRUWILQ
PDNRV3&/UDQJHVIURPWRRI7/VRDUDQJH
IRU WKH 0DUPDULV VSHFLPHQ ZRXOG EH IURP  WR
FP7/
:H EHOLHYH WKDW WKH VKRUWILQ PDNR UHSRUWHG LQ WKLV
ZRUNLVWKHODUJHVWVSHFLPHQHYHUUHFRUGHGZRUOGZLGH
$

UHFHQW

VWXG\

RI



VSHFLPHQV

VKRZHG

WKDW

WKH

DY
HUDJH

WRWDO

OHQJWK

LV



FP

.RKOHU

HW

DO



7KH
SUHYLRXV

PD[LPXP

UHSRUWHG

OHQJWK

IRU

,

R[\ULQFKXV

ZDV


FP

IRU

D

KXJH

VSHFLPHQ

FDXJKW

RII

6L[)RXUV

OHV
3ODJHV

)UDQFH

LQ

6HSWHPEHU



&DSDSp



2WKHU
ODUJH

VSHFLPHQV

KDYH

EHHQ

UHFRUGHG

LQ

WKH

0HGLWHUUD
QHDQ

DUHD

$

ODUJH



FP

VKRUWILQ

PDNR

ZDV

FDXJKW

RII
/D

*DOLWH

,VODQG

7XQLVLD

RQ

6HSWHPEHU





DQG

LWV
MDZV

DUH

SUHVHUYHG

LQ

WKH

1DWXUDO

+LVWRU\

0XVHXP

RI
*HQRD

,WDO\

'RULD



*HVWUR



/DZOH\


UHSRUWHG

RQ

D



P

ORQJ

VSHFLPHQ

WKDW

ZHLJKHG



NJ
ZKLFK

ZDV

REVHUYHG

LQ

D

ZDUHKRXVH

RI

D

ILVKPRQJHU

LQ
/LYRUQR

DQG

ZDV

FDXJKW

RII

3LRPELQR

,WDO\

$QRWKHU


FP

ORQJ

VKRUWILQ

PDNR

ZDV

FDSWXUHG

RII

&DVND

1RYDOMD
&URDWLD

RQ

0D\





DQG

ZDV

UHSRUWHG

E\

%UXVLQD


0RUH

UHFHQWO\

D



FP

ORQJ

VKRUWILQ

PDNR

ZDV
FDXJKW

RQ

1RYHPEHU





RII

%DJQDUD

&DODEUD

,WDO\
6WRUDL

HW

DO



$QRWKHU



FP

ORQJ

VSHFLPHQ
ZHLJKLQJ



NJ

ZDV

FDXJKW

RQ

6HSWHPEHU





RII
3XQWD

$OLFH

,WDO\

6WRUDL

HW

DO



$



FP

ORQJ

IH
PDOH

ZDV

FDXJKW

RQ

-XO\





RII

6FDOHWWD

=DQFOHD
,WDO\

DQG

DQRWKHU

IHPDOH

PHDVXULQJ



FP

7/

ZDV
FDXJKW

EHWZHHQ

3RUWRSDOR

GL

&DSR

3DVVHUR

DQG

0DU]D
PHPL

,WDO\

RQ

-XQH





&HORQD

HW

DO


$&.12:/('*(0(176
7KH

DXWKRUV

ZLVK

WR

WKDQN

0U

$WHÝ

(YLUJHQ

DQ

,VWDQ
EXO

EDVHG

XQGHUZDWHU

SKRWRJUDSKHU

IRU

WKH

SKRWRJUDSK
DQG

FDWFK

GDWD

RI

WKH

VKRUWILQ

PDNR

VKDUN

DQG

:DOWHU
+HLP

ZKR

WRRN

WKH

WLPH

WR

HGLW

WKH

PDQXVFULSW

+DNDQ
.DEDVDNDO

H[WHQGV

SURIRXQG

JUDWLWXGH

WR

KLV

ZLIH

g]JU
DQG

WR

KLV

VRQ

'HULQ

$OHVVDQGUR

'H

0DGGDOHQD

WKDQNV
KLV

ZLIH

$OHVVDQGUD

DQG

KLV

VRQ

$QWRQLR

IRU

WKHLU

VXSSRUW
DQG

ORYH

$11$/(6©6HUKLVWQDW©©©
%=G=J(0()HAOO=J@NK!"*!!)"+
!
%2$"0%,/1#&+*(,0%/(
&02/20,56/&+ %20
/#&+"0.2"

25-$É.,35,0(5(.9567($7/$176.,0$.2,685862;<5,1&+865$),1(648(
&+21'5,&+7+<(6/$01,'$(8-(735,.5$-80$50$5,6785à,-$
+DNDQ.$%$6$.$/
,FKWK\RORJLFDO5HVHDUFK6RFLHW\7DQWDYLPDKDOOHVL0HQWHÝR çOXFDGGHVLîGLODSW1R'hPUDQL\H75îVWDQEXO7XUNH\
(PDLOKDNDQNDEDVDNDO#VXSHUSRVWDFRP
$OHVVDQGUR'(0$''$/(1$
,WDOLDQ*UHDW:KLWH6KDUN'DWD%DQNYLD/$ULRVWR,0LODQR,WDO\
329=(7(.
2UMDÈNRVDPLFRYUVWHDWODQWVNLPDNR,VXUXVR[\ULQFKXVMHYSR]QLKLKSULNUDMX0DUPDULV-9(JHMVNRPRUMH
7XUßLMDXMHONRPHUFLDOQL ULELß $YWRUMLVR QD SRGODJL IRWRJUDIVNH GRNXPHQWDFLMH RFHQLOL GDMHELOD FHORWQD GROÊLQD
WHJD SULPHUND  FP RG  GR  FP 2FHQMHQD YHOLNRVW ]HOR SUHVHJD GR VHGDM ]DEHOHÊHQR PDNVLPDOQR
YHOLNRVW SULPHUND WH YUVWH  FP GROJH VDPLFH XMHWH VHSWHPEUD  SUL NUDMX 6L[)RXUV OHV3ODJHV )UDQFLMD
3ULPHUHNL]0DUPDULVDMHWDNRYHUMHWQRQDMYHßMLNDGDUNROL]DEHOHÊHQDWODQWVNLPDNR
.OMXÞQHEHVHGH
DWODQWVNLPDNR,VXUXVR[\ULQFKXVPDNVLPDOQDYHOLNRVWQDMYHáMLSULPHUHN7XUáLMD(JHMVNRPRUMH
5()(5(1&(6
$NÚ
u
UD\

)



7UNL\H

'HQL]

%DO
u
NODU
u

7D\LQ

$QD
KWDU
u


+LGUREL\RORML

$UDÝW
u
UPD

(QVWLWV

<D\
u
QODU
u


6D\
u


î
VWDQEXO
%DVV

$

-

-

'

'¡$XEUH\



1

.LVWQDVDP\


6KDUNV

RI

WKH

(DVW

&RDVW

RI

6RXWKHUQ

$IULFD

,9

7KH

)D
PLOLHV

2GRQWDVSLGLGDH

6FDSDQRUK\QFKLGDH

,VXULGDH
&HWRUKLQLGDH

$ORSLLGDH

2UHFWRORELGDH

DQG

5KLQLRGRQ
WLGDH

,QY

5HS

2FHDQRJU

5HV

,QVW




%LOHFHQR
ç
OX

0

(

7DVNDYDN

6

0DWHU



0

.D\D


&KHFNOLVW

RI

WKH

PDULQH

ILVKHV

RI

7XUNH\

=RRWD[D



%UXVLQD

6



0RUVNL

SVL

6UHGR]HPQRJD

L

&UOMHQRJ
PRUD

6KDUNV

RI

WKH

$GULDWLF

DQG

WKH

%ODFN

6HD

*ODVQLN
KUYDWVNRJD

QDUDYRVORYQRJD

GUXÌWYD

,,,


&DSDSm

&



/LVWH

FRPPHQWpH

GHV

VpODFKLHQV

GH

OD
UpJLRQ

GH

7RXORQ

GH

/D

&LRWDW

j

6DLQW7URSH]

%XOO

0XV
+LVW

1DW




&HORQD

$

/

3LVFLWHOOL



$

'H

0DGGDOHQD



7ZR
ODUJH

VKRUWILQ

PDNRV

,VXUXV

R[\ULQFKXV

5DILQHVTXH


FDXJKW

RII

6LFLO\

ZHVWHUQ

,RQLDQ

6HD

$QQDOHV

6HU
KLVW

QDW




&OLII

*

6

)

-

'XGOH\



%

'DYLV



6KDUNV

FDXJKW
LQ

WKH

SURWHFWLYH

JLOO

QHWV

RII

1DWDO

6RXWK

$IULFD



7KH
VKRUWILQ

PDNR

VKDUN

,VXUXV

R[\ULQFKXV

/LQQDHXV

6

$IU
-

0DU

6FL




&RPSDJQR

/

-

9



6KDUNV

RI

WKH

ZRUOG

$Q

DQ
QRWDWHG

DQG

LOOXVWUDWHG

FDWDORJXH

RI

VKDUN

VSHFLHV

NQRZQ
WR

GDWH

9ROXPH



%XOOKHDG

PDFNHUHO

DQG

FDUSHW

VKDUNV
+HWHURGRQWLIRUPHV

/DPQLIRUPHV

DQG

2UHFWRORELIRU
PHV

)$2

6SHFLHV

&DWDORJXH

IRU

)LVKHU\

3XUSRVHV

1R


9RO



)$2

5RPH



S
'H

0DGGDOHQD

$



+

%DHQVFK



+DLH

LP

0LW
WHOPHHU

)UDQFNK.RVPRV

9HUODJV*PE+



&R

6WXWW
JDUW



S
'H

0DGGDOHQD

$

$

3UHWL



5

6PLWK



0DNR
VKDUNV

.ULHJHU

3XEOLVKLQJ

0DODEDU



S
'H

0DGGDOHQD

$

0

=XIID

/

/LSHM



$

&HORQD


$Q

DQDO\VLV

RI

WKH

SKRWRJUDSKLF

HYLGHQFHV

RI

WKH

ODUJHVW
JUHDW

ZKLWH

VKDUNV

&DUFKDURGRQ

FDUFKDULDV

/LQQDHXV


FDSWXUHG

LQ

WKH

0HGLWHUUDQHDQ

6HD

ZLWK

FRQ
VLGHUDWLRQV

DERXW

WKH

PD[LPXP

VL]H

RI

WKH

VSHFLHV

$Q
QDOHV

6HU

KLVW

QDW




'RULD

*



5

*HVWUR



&URFLHUD

GHO

9LRODQWH
FRPDQGDWR

GDO

FDSLWDQR

DUPDWRUH

(QULFR

'¤$OEHUWLV

GX
UDQWH

O¤DQQR



$QQ

0XV

&LY

6WR

1DW

*

'RULD



.DEDVDNDO

+



(ODVPREUDQFK

VSHFLHV

RI

WKH

VHDV
RI

7XUNH\

$QQDOHV

6HU

KLVW

QDW




.DEDVDNDO

+



7UN

6XODU
u
QGD

.{SHNEDO
u
NODU
u



'HQL]

<D\
u
QODU
u


î
VWDQEXO



S
.RKOHU

1(

-

*

&DVH\



3$

7XUQHU



/HQJWK
OHQJWK

DQG

OHQJWKZHLJKW

UHODWLRQVKLSV

IRU



VKDUN

VSH
FLHV

IURP

WKH

:HVWHUQ

1RUWK

$WODQWLF

12$$

7HFK
0HPR

10)61(


/DZOH\

5



6WXGL

FRPSDUDWLYL

VXL

SHVFL

IRVVLOL

FRL
YLYHQWL

GHL

JHQHUL

&DUFKDURGRQ

2[\UKLQD

H

*DOHRFHUGR
1LVWUL

3LVD



S
0HJDORIRQRX

3

&

<DQQRSRXORV

'

'DPDODV

*

'H
0HWULR

0

'HIORULR

-

0

'H

/D

6HUQD



'

0DFLDV


,QFLGHQWDO

FDWFK

DQG

HVWLPDWHG

GLVFDUGV

RI

SH
ODJLF

VKDUNV

IURP

WKH

VZRUGILVK

DQG

WXQD

ILVKHULHV

LQ

WKH
0HGLWHUUDQHDQ

6HD

)LVK

%XOO




6WRUDL

7

=XIID

0



5

*LRLD



(YLGHQ]H

GL
SUHGD]LRQH

VX

RGRQWRFHWL

GD

SDUWH

GL

,VXUXV

R[\ULQFKXV
5DILQHVTXH



QHO

7LUUHQR

0HULGLRQDOH

H

0DU

,RQLR
0HGLWHUUDQHR

$WWL

6RF

WRVF

6FL

QDW

0HP

6HULH

%


