ArticlePDF Available

Properly equipping our teachers for the future: re-reading research in practice as an everyday habit of professional practice

DOI:10.5920/till.2009.1245
Authors:
Alex Kendall at Birmingham City University
Alex Kendall
Margaret Herrington
Margaret Herrington
Download full-text PDFDownload full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

In this article we make the case that Research in Practice (RiP) is intrinsic to the role of the professional teacher and as such should be an ongoing (supported) entitlement for all teachers throughout their career trajectory. This is not in itself a new call; what is different is our contention that the current policy context of post-compulsory education makes such demands more urgent, more purposeful and, crucially, of new pedagogical significance. We argue that the consequences of Equipping our Teachers for the Future (DfES, 2004) may be highly restrictive for teacher educators and the teachers they work with. We consider how RiP might facilitate new vantage points from the lived experience of working in the sector, and how the latter might be (re)viewed. We go on to suggest that RiP may also yield important pedagogical benefits for teachers and their communities, as well as contributing to knowledge and understanding about the sector more broadly. In conclusion we argue that teacher educators must take seriously the responsibility to nurture RiP as an everyday habit of professionalism and to give serious thought to providing spaces and places for RiP. We ask whether the new opportunities provided by the Institute for Learning framework can be exploited to support longitudinal research practices.
55e891f708ae65b6389986
40.pdf
Content uploaded by Alex Kendall
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Alex Kendall on Sep 03, 2015
Content may be subject to copyright.
Properly equipping our teachers for the future: re-reading research in practice as an everyday habit of professional practi
ce.pdf
Available via license: CC BY 4.0
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... 17). Whilst it appears that Equipping our Teachers can be viewed as an attempt to enhance teachers' professional status, serious limitations of the new framework and ensuing implications for understanding the notion of professionalism within the sector have been broached (Kendall and Herrington, 2009). According to them, the reform might be viewed "as evidence of an increasingly frantic impulse to regulate teacher education" (p. 2), and a further attempt to implement the government's political agenda of addressing a perceived skills deficit and enhancing economic productivity through the lifelong learning sector. ...
The perceptions of FE teachers about the impact of in-service initial teacher education on their professional development and practice Titilola Olukoga
Thesis
Full-text available
  • Jan 2015
Since 1997, successive governments in England have consistently introduced a range of interventions aimed at developing the quality of training of FE teachers. It has been suggested that these should engender better teaching, which in turn should improve achievement of learners, and subsequently produce a workforce with global competitive advantage. This study explores and analyses the views of a sample of FE teachers and their managers on the impact of an in-service initial teacher education programme on teachers' development and practice. The case study research uses online questionnaires and semi-structured interviews to collect data from participants drawn from both academic and vocational curriculum areas of a large FE college. The study employs Bourdieu's concepts of habitus, field and capital and Giddens' structuration framework of structure and agency to interpret and explain social practices and actions. Even though the past can frame agents' dispositions, agents also have the capacity to accommodate and integrate new conditions in shaping future practices. An understanding of power relations within and between fields has been useful in explaining practitioners' actions, and the concept of capital has been beneficial in analysing practitioners' influence, and some factors that drive their actions. Initial findings from this study indicate that while structure can constrain agents' actions, it can also be enabling. Although teachers have faced some constraints and challenges whilst on the training programme, there is a significant positive perception of the knowledge, skills and competencies that they have acquired. Findings also indicate that the social-cultural construction of knowledge approach and teachers' own passion are significant to their professional development. The thesis proposes a case for reflexive breakout, a phrase used to portray the transformative capacity of teachers in developing their professional practice. This perhaps has some implications for further research in understanding the professional development of trainee teachers. 4
View
... Urban (2009) recognises this version of professionalism as a new paradigm within which professionals must be re-known, re-shaped and disciplined, and through which 'a maze of regulation, accountability, universality and technocratic measurability' are legitimated in the name of 'quality'. Similar arguments have been made about the renegotiation of professional identities through the imposition of cultures of instrumentalism (see for example Ball 2003) in other sectors of education (McDougall et al. 2006, Kendall andHerrington 2009) or what Ball (2003) calls the terrors of performativity. Citing Apple (2004), Moss (2010) argues that this is an outcome of a 'new hegemonic bloc' 'of neo-liberals and neo-conservatives … the former emphasising the relationship between education and the market, the latter agreeing with the … emphasis on the economy but seeking stronger control over knowledge, morals and values through curricula, testing and other means' (Moss 2010, 12). ...
Barriers and solutions to HE progression for Early Years’ practitioners
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2012
Shifts in UK social and economic policy have focused on education and care in the Early Years as key to improving social inclusion, skills acquisition and longer term social and economic prosperity. The implications for practitioners in the sector have been significant as roles, functions and foci have been renegotiated through the processes of professionalising the workforce. Drawing on the outcomes of a qualitative study of the career trajectories and aspirations of Early Years educators working in the private, voluntary and independent sector, this paper explores the processes of professionalisation as they collide with the lived experiences of practitioners at the chalk face. The project, funded by the Lifelong Learning Network, aimed to achieve understanding of the influence on career development decision making, particularly in relation to progression to higher education. Our findings suggest that many practitioners fall into the category of ‘non-traditional learners’ and that socio-cultural issues may be key factors in determining decision-making about career development. By bearing witness to the lived experience of practitioners we argue that the processes of workforce development must place greater emphasis on the contestable nature of professionalism and the plurality of professional identity and that Universities are key to achieving this.
View
Listening to old wives’ tales: small stories and the (re)making and (re)telling of research in HE/FE practitioner education
Article
Full-text available
  • Jan 2016
In this paper we share the outcomes of a project that sought to take up Nutbrown’s challenge to ‘push out from the safe(er) boundaries of established methodologies’ in early years research. We explore the value of auto-ethnographic storytelling, Lyotard’s ‘petit récit’, to the processes of doing and learning about research in the context of practitioner education. We offer a rationale for the use of creative methods in (post?) professional learning and describe the process of working with identity boxes and symbolic objects, to produce a collection of auto-ethnographic narratives, the old wives’ tales of the title, through which to explore practitioners’ experiences of professional identity formation. We consider the opportunities such methods offer for reflexive learning about practitioner positionality within the knowledge-making practices of research and attempt to (re)position ourselves differently as writers and makers of research. Towards a conclusion we review and theorise meanings participant-researchers make about their career trajectories and proffer auto-ethnography as a dynamic modality for practitioner learning. We mobilise Patti Lather’s notion of methodological proliferation to re-think practitioner education as a wild profusion of post-professional possibilities.
View
View
View
Managerialism and professionalism in the Cinderella service
Article
Full-text available
As a result of the process of incorporation following the Further and Higher Education Act of 1992, Cityshire College, a large further education college left the jurisdiction of the local authority and gained greater responsibility for managing its own affairs. Arising from a case study based on interviews and questionnaires the paper considers the impact of changes within the College which took place between 1991 and 1994. Of particular interest is the development of a “new managerialism”, a management style which spread throughout public sector organizations during the 1980s. The evidence from the lecturer questionnaire suggests that staff reject the values represented by this development and are opposed to the threat they perceive to the professional culture of further education. In considering new modes of learning, notions of quality in education and the intrusion of the market into the college, the deprofessionalisation and, indeed, “proletarianisation” of the FE lecturer is suggested as a possible outcome.
View
View
View
View
View
View
Literacies within Prison Settings: A Fourth Space?
Article
  • Jan 2001
Discusses literacy practices in prisons as a "third space" between outside and inside prison walls. Examples of one prisoner's engagement in literacy development illustrate how formal and informal literacies intertwine and how correctional education creates a fourth space that can serve as a bridge to the outside world. (SK)
View
The Practice of Research on Practice
Article
  • Jan 1989
A major focus for research in preparation programs should be on the practice of administration. For some time, the preparation of educational administrators has been rooted in the traditional liberal arts approach--the approach of a discipline--as a model for preparing the practitioner. Emphasis has shifted to the concept of the accurate identification/diagnosis of the problem and correct assessment of the results and application of research-based knowledge. The research emphasis leans toward decision-making and improvement of practice, although it may relate practice to theory. Examples of dissertation research are provided to demonstrate the problem of translating practice into the theories that seem best suited to explain or describe the problem phenomenon. The problem is not singularly the focus of research, but extends to current faculty untrained in research on practice, to preparation programs, and to faculty who are not active researchers. Appended are preliminary considerations of research issues in educational administrator preparation, a figure of research elements, and a figure of the "5 Strands" preparation program. (19 references) (SI)
View