ArticlePDF Available

Why Minimal Guidance During Instruction Does Not Work: An Analysis of the Failure of Constructivist, Discovery, Problem-Based, Experiential, and Inquiry-Based Teaching

Authors:

Abstract

Evidence for the superiority of guided instruction is explained in the context of our knowledge of human cognitive architecture, expert–novice differences, and cognitive load. Although unguided or minimally guided instructional approaches are very popular and intuitively appealing, the point is made that these approaches ignore both the structures that constitute human cognitive architecture and evidence from empirical studies over the past half-century that consistently indicate that minimally guided instruction is less effective and less efficient than instructional approaches that place a strong emphasis on guidance of the student learning process. The advantage of guidance begins to recede only when learners have sufficiently high prior knowledge to provide “internal” guidance. Recent developments in instructional research and instructional designmodels that support guidance during instruction are briefly described.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... Sin embargo, la definición de la ECBI no es sencilla, dado que dentro de esta denominación se enmarcan tantas intervenciones didácticas que es difícil encontrar dentro de la literatura publicada una definición aceptada por todos (Hayes, 2002;Capps y Crawford, 2013;Couso, 2014). Esta indefinición lleva, por un lado, asociada la existencia de varios tipos de indagación, desde una indagación abierta en la que el alumno decide la pregunta de investigación y el camino a seguir en la búsqueda de su respuesta, hasta una indagación guiada que simplemente responda preguntas propuestas en clase (Windschitl, 2003;Kirschner, Sweller y Clark, 2006; Aguilera Morales, Martín-Páez, Valdivia-Rodríguez, Ruiz-Delgado, Williams-Pinto, Vílchez-González y Perales-Palacios, 2018). Existe en la literatura una discusión al respecto, no sólo de la concepción de la indagación a la hora de implementarla en las aulas sino también de su efectividad dependiendo de cuál sea dicha implementación (Kirschner et al., 2006y Sweller, Kirschner y Clark, 2007Romero-Ariza, 2017). ...
... Esta indefinición lleva, por un lado, asociada la existencia de varios tipos de indagación, desde una indagación abierta en la que el alumno decide la pregunta de investigación y el camino a seguir en la búsqueda de su respuesta, hasta una indagación guiada que simplemente responda preguntas propuestas en clase (Windschitl, 2003;Kirschner, Sweller y Clark, 2006; Aguilera Morales, Martín-Páez, Valdivia-Rodríguez, Ruiz-Delgado, Williams-Pinto, Vílchez-González y Perales-Palacios, 2018). Existe en la literatura una discusión al respecto, no sólo de la concepción de la indagación a la hora de implementarla en las aulas sino también de su efectividad dependiendo de cuál sea dicha implementación (Kirschner et al., 2006y Sweller, Kirschner y Clark, 2007Romero-Ariza, 2017). Existe también un debate interesante sobre si la indagación consiste en el aprendizaje de los métodos científicos o si consiste en aprender a través de los métodos -se entiende, habiéndolos aprendido con antelación o aprovechando el mismo proceso para hacerlo - (Kirschner et al. 2006;Sweller et al., 2007). ...
... Existe en la literatura una discusión al respecto, no sólo de la concepción de la indagación a la hora de implementarla en las aulas sino también de su efectividad dependiendo de cuál sea dicha implementación (Kirschner et al., 2006y Sweller, Kirschner y Clark, 2007Romero-Ariza, 2017). Existe también un debate interesante sobre si la indagación consiste en el aprendizaje de los métodos científicos o si consiste en aprender a través de los métodos -se entiende, habiéndolos aprendido con antelación o aprovechando el mismo proceso para hacerlo - (Kirschner et al. 2006;Sweller et al., 2007). Cierto es que el nivel de complejidad de esta discusión puede diferir dependiendo del nivel educativo al cual se está aplicando la indagación. ...
Article
En el presente trabajo se analizan 84 guías docentes de asignaturas de ciencias experimentales y/o su didáctica impartidas en el Grado en Maestro en Educación Primaria de universidades españolas. El análisis de la información contenida en ellas nos permite conocer la formación que proponen las guías docentes de asignaturas científicas de dicho grado y hasta qué punto la enseñanza de la ciencia por indagación está presente en su plan de formación. Los resultados indican una escasa formación científica de los futuros maestros y con poca presencia de la indagación
... It is more likely seen as the teachers' need for integrating ICT into pedagogical learning to optimize the absorption of material from the teacher to the students within classroom. In relation to this issue, Kirschner, Sweller, & Clark (2006) [31] find that it is important for teacher education programs to focus on digital competencies to avoid loss of time and energy when starting to be teachers in schools. The presence of teachers as role models is also needed during their practicum [32]. ...
... It is more likely seen as the teachers' need for integrating ICT into pedagogical learning to optimize the absorption of material from the teacher to the students within classroom. In relation to this issue, Kirschner, Sweller, & Clark (2006) [31] find that it is important for teacher education programs to focus on digital competencies to avoid loss of time and energy when starting to be teachers in schools. The presence of teachers as role models is also needed during their practicum [32]. ...
... Critics of IBL, such as Kirschner et al. (2006), argue that constructivist learning pedagogies are ineffective and do not take into account empirical evidence that has found minimally guided instruction does not work over the long term. They posit that this pedagogy ignores what is known about human cognitive architecture and memory; that if instructional practice does not impact a student's long-term memory, then nothing has been gained. ...
... First, it incorrectly conflates IBL learning pedagogies with discovery learning, and second, it ignores the key practice of scaffolding. Hmelo-Silver et al. (2007) argue that Kirschner et al. (2006) grouped several pedagogies and practices together erroneously, concluding the process of IBL involves minimal guidance. In fact, within IBL, students are provided with a range of instructional guidance through several key activities such as the practice of scaffolding (Hmelo-Silver et al., 2007;Lazonder & Harmsen, 2016). ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper situates inquiry-based learning (IBL) in a post-secondary context while examining possibilities for social work education and practice. Specifically, in what ways has IBL been utilized in higher education, and how might IBL be compatible with social work values that promote social justice? This paper begins with a brief overview of the definitions of IBL and associated theory, then illustrates the benefits of the approach and varying experiences of its application, and finally considers how IBL and social work are complementary insofar as IBL upholds various social work principles and supports the linking of theory to practice during service-learning.
... Lebih khusus lagi, selama proses pembelajaran guru harus memiliki keterampilan dalam menstimulasi, membimbing dan menyediakan sumber-sumber yang relevan bagi siswa (Phumeechanya & Wannapiroon, 2014). Selama setengah abad terakhir, penelitian empiris telah memberikan bukti yang tidak ambigu bahwa bimbingan yang minimal kepada siswa selama pembelajaran kurang efektif dan efisien (Kirschner et al., 2006). Sehingga diperlukan pemberian bantuan dalam proses pembelajaran berbasis masalah. ...
... Proses pembelajaran berbasis masalah juga ditemukan sebanding dengan pendekatan pembelajaran tradisional ketika ditanya akuisisi konten (Strobel & Van Barneveld, 2009). Semua pencarian berbasis masalah menuntut banyak memori kerja (Kirschner et al., 2006). Sehingga memang perlu sekali bantuan khusus terhadap siswa terkait setiap kesulitan yang mereka hadapi untuk mengetahui bagaimana cara mendapatkan informasi pengetahuan yang sesuai dengan tujuan pembelajaran. ...
Article
One of the main goals of school mathematics is the achievement of mathematical problem-solving abilities through problem-based learning. It is expected that these abilities can be achieved well by students. However, the complexity of the problem and minimum confidence become a problem when students experience complex situations created in the problem-based learning process. Scaffolding becomes essential because of the differences in each student's knowledge stored in long term memory. The purpose of the study was to analyze differences in mathematical problem-solving abilities with two different learning and based on initial mathematical abilities. Learning in the experimental class is problem-based learning with scaffolding, and then control class learning is problem-based without scaffolding. The research method used was a quasi-experimental design with a matching-only pretest-posttest control group design. Sample selection using purposive sampling to get samples with the same characteristics, the total number of samples is 60 students with each division 30. The initial mathematics ability has the same role in the mathematical problem-solving ability in the experimental and control classes. That is when students are in the high category then the ability of severe mathematical problem-solving. However, when the two classes are compared, the results are significantly different. Scaffolding becomes a factor that distinguishes the ability to solve mathematical problems.
... Examples of measuring students' information retention in classroom demonstrations, have been shown by promoting engagement and deep learning (Crouch & Mazur, 2001;Mazur, 2009;Direnga et al., 2015), and these studies emphasize that active learning approaches facilitate the understanding of concepts. However, this practice is in direct contrast with the concern of other educational practitioners that students do not learn standard content from textbooks properly when working with more open, authentic and complex tasks (Moreno, 2004;Kirschner, Sweller, & Clark, 2006). The dilemma lies in that complex tasks might not cover all the standard knowledge students need to learn in a course. ...
Article
Full-text available
Retention and transfer of information were tested in a second-year bachelor design-based learning project, and compared with a traditional bachelor level course. The project Signal and Systems is a core and compulsory course within the physics curriculum of the Applied Physics Department at the Eindhoven University of Technology, the Netherlands. Students from different year-level cohorts participated in a study consisting of a 15-open question test on systems, control technology, and Laplace transform. Students' perceptions of active learning educational factors that may support understanding and the retention and transfer of information were also measured. A small number of students were interviewed in focus groups to validate the data on elements that promote retention and transfer. Results indicate that students following the design-based learning project recorded higher median marks in their assignments compared to those enrolled in the traditional course. Students from all cohorts agreed that the educational factors promoting learning were repetition of topics throughout the bachelor curriculum, practicing and providing feedback, and an explanation on errors made. Results from this study serve as a suitable example for tertiary educational practitioners to use design-based learning to facilitate retention and transfer.
... As a pedagogical approach, it can also reinforce knowledge, improves student attainment, and positively changes student's attitudes towards the subject studied [11]. However, positive outcomes of CPS is highly correlated with students' engagement with the CPS activities and students should be appropriately guided in their interactions to achieve the expected learning outcomes [4,13]. Direct analysis and guidance by a teacher or an expert is desirable, yet scaling this approach to the large number of learners is often not feasible. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Automatic analysis of students’ collaborative interactions in physi- cal settings is an emerging problem with a wide range of applica- tions in education. However, this problem has been proven to be challenging due to the complex, interdependent and dynamic na- ture of student interactions in real-world contexts. In this paper, we propose a novel framework for the classification of student engage- ment in open-ended, face-to-face collaborative problem-solving (CPS) tasks purely from video data. Our framework i) estimates body pose from the recordings of student interactions; ii) combines face recognition with a Bayesian model to identify and track stu- dents with a high accuracy; and iii) classifies student engagement leveraging a Team Long Short-Term Memory (Team LSTM) neural network model. This novel approach allows the LSTMs to cap- ture dependencies among individual students in their collaborative interactions. Our results show that the Team LSTM significantly improves the performance as compared to the baseline method that takes individual student trajectories into account independently.
... Examples of measuring students' information retention in classroom demonstrations, have been shown by promoting engagement and deep learning (Crouch & Mazur, 2001;Mazur, 2009;Direnga et al., 2015), and these studies emphasize that active learning approaches facilitate the understanding of concepts. However, this practice is in direct contrast with the concern of other educational practitioners that students do not learn standard content from textbooks properly when working with more open, authentic and complex tasks (Moreno, 2004;Kirschner, Sweller, & Clark, 2006). The dilemma lies in that complex tasks might not cover all the standard knowledge students need to learn in a course. ...
Book
Full-text available
This book provides a detailed and up-to-date overview of works in education, science and mathematics education. This book is informative for especially educators, reseachers, academics, postgraduate students, preservive teachers, teachers and school leaders own development. It gives suggestions to educators, reseachers, academics, postgraduate students, preservive teachers, teachers, school leadersand policy makers and so on... The book presents educational articles on various aspects, all of them centred on the area of Area of Education and Pandemia. The book consists of eleven chapters and 173+-page work.Thus, first paper – “Opinions of the High School Students Regarding the Flipped Classroom Practice…”. The next work is “The Content Analysis of Studies on Individual Differences in Education In Turkey From 2000 to 2020”. After that, the paper entitled “Effectiveness of Remote Training with Covid19 Pandemic Source”, Another study “Investigatıon Of Awareness of Parents in the Pandemic Process and the Perspectives Related to Science and Education In This Process”, and other namely: “Multiple Intelligence Theory and Effective Learning in Visual Arts Education” , “The Relationship Between the Views of The Preservice Mathematics Teachers on Proof and Their Multiple Intelligence…”, “The Significance of Science Centers in Science Education…”, “The Effect of Positivist And Post-Positivist Paradigms on The Change of Validity Conceptualization”, “A Psychological Perspective on Organizational Loneliness…” and “Studies on Cognitive Load Theory in Turkey: A Literature Survey”. December, 2020 Prof. Dr. Hulya GUR Balikesir University
Article
Full-text available
Adaptive Comparative Judgment (ACJ), an approach to the assessment of open-ended problems which utilizes a series of comparisons to produce a standardized score, rank order, and a variety of other statistical measures, has demonstrated high levels of reliability and validity and the potential for application in a wide variety of areas. Further, research into using ACJ, both as a formative and summative assessment tool, has been conducted in multiple contexts across higher education. This systematized review of ACJ research outlines our approach to identifying, classifying, and organizing findings from research with ACJ in higher education settings as well as overarching themes and questions that remain. The intent of this work is to provide readers with an understanding of the current state of the field and several areas of potential further inquiry related to ACJ in higher education.
Chapter
Full-text available
The studies examined in this research, doctoral theses, master theses, and the main subject of education and individual differences are limited to the sources and data reviews. In this sense, more comprehensive and detailed content analysis can be made for individual differences. In this sense, broader and more detailed content analysis could be made regarding individual differences. In the studies reviewed, the suggestions variable was not included in the current study since it was not available in every study and was not generalizable. It was revealed that the effects of individual differences in students' attitudes and achievements in the learning process have a positive meaning. This finding is important data for us to see the importance of the subject. Therefore, quantitative, qualitative, and mixed studies and quasi-experimental studies could be done in this field. The findings examined from the research results show that individuals have significant individual differences in learning characteristics. Traditional methods do not provide equal benefits for all individuals. Individual differences, quantity and quality problems in learning, the structure of teaching materials, the impossibility of having a mental knowledge level, and similar reasons require education according to the individual and his / her needs.
Article
Full-text available
Instructional research is reviewed where teaching failures have produced students who are less able to use learning skills or had less access to knowledge than before they were taught. Three general types of "mathemathantic" (i.e. where instruction "kills" learning) effects are hypothesized, theoretical explanations for each effect are examined and representative studies in each area are described. The three types of effects described are where instruction serves to: 1) Substitute learning procedures (e.g. Novel learning strategies are hypothesized to interfere with the learning of higher general ability learners and inadequate learning strategies are provided to those with lower general ability); 2) Impose less desirable motivational goals on learners (e.g. when teaching methods lead constructively motivated learners to believe that failure avoidance has replaced achievement directed goals and, conversely, when defensively motivated students believe that achievement directed goals have replaced the opportunity to avoid failure); and 3) Substitute student control for system control over instructional method (e.g. by allowing lower cognitive load instructional methods to be chosen by high general ability, constructive students and/or by allowing higher cognitive load methods to be chosen by defensive students who have low general ability)
Article
How do academic activities and discourse work together in classrooms to shape learning and instruction? This complex question was answered in a case study of underachieving students in a Grade 8 history class. Data were collected through class observation and interviews with experienced teachers and students in 2 classrooms. Teachers taught history content and learning strategies. Theories of social constructivism predict that the discourse arising before, during, and after activities can explain variability in students' social and academic participation in curriculum events, as can the nature of the instructional approach students experience when teachers hold similar goals. Patterns of co-occurring forms of discourse and activities across sequences of lesson events provided a useful window into interactions between learning and instruction.
Article
This article reports experimental work comparing exploration and worked-examples practice in learning to use a database program. Exploration practice is based on discovery learning principles, whereas worked-examples practice arose from the development of cognitive load theory. Exploration practice was expected to place a considerable load on working memory, whereas a heavy use of worked examples was hypothesized to lead to more effective processing by reducing extraneous mental load. Students with no previous domain familiarity with databases were found to substantially benefit from worked examples in comparison to exploration. However, if students had previous familiarity with the database domain, the type of practice made no significant difference to their learning because the exploration students were able to draw on existing, well-developed domain schemas to guide their exploration.
Article
In the 2 experiments reported here, high school students studied worked examples while learning how to translate English expressions into algebraic equations. In Experiment 1, worked examples were used as part of the regular classroom instruction and as a support for homework. In Experiment 2, students in a remedial mathematics class received individual instruction. Students using worked examples outperformed the control group on posttests after completing fewer practice problems; they also made fewer errors per problem and fewer types of errors during acquisition time, completed the work more rapidly, and required less assistance from the teacher.