ArticlePDF Available

The Effects of Teaching Methods in Leadership Knowledge Retention

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Finding an effective teaching methodology for leadership educators is daunting. In this experimental study undergraduate leadership students' retention of knowledge was tested after receiving leadership instruction via lecture, experiential learning, and public pedagogy. Results show lecture is an inferior method of teaching leadership while public pedagogy had effective and consistent results.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Journal of Leadership Education Volume 9, Issue 2 – Summer 2010
86
The Effects of Teaching Methods in Leadership
Knowledge Retention: An Experimental Design of
Lecture, Experiential, and Public Pedagogy
Jennifer Williams, Ph.D.
Texas A&M University
dr.jen@tamu.edu
Megan McClure, MAL
University of Georgia
mcclurem@tamu.edu
Abstract
Finding an effective teaching methodology for leadership educators is daunting.
In this experimental study undergraduate leadership students’ retention of
knowledge was tested after receiving leadership instruction via lecture,
experiential learning, and public pedagogy. Results show lecture is an inferior
method of teaching leadership while public pedagogy had effective and consistent
results.
Introduction
Teachers of leadership face the difficult task of explaining abstract concepts and
ideas to students. The lecture method has long since failed these educators as an
effective way to present their information (Halpern, 2000
)
. Therefore, exploring
the efficacy of a variety of teaching methods for leadership educators is important
due to the potential to determine best practices for classroom delivery.
Popular culture surrounds us in the form of mass media and social interaction.
This constant exposure to cultural expression has the ability to teach its
consumers, whether they are aware of it or not, through non-formal learning.
When non-formal learning from popular culture can, and does, occur daily within
the lives of adults, it might be a natural progression to move the site of learning
into a formal environment (Callahan & Rosser, 2007). Adult educators have
recognized the potential for popular culture to impact education and are
subsequently utilizing it as a teaching method. More specifically, leadership
educators have established the use of popular media in the classroom in an effort
to assist students’ in learning complex concepts such as leadership theory. This
utilization of popular media in the classroom relies on the ability of popular
culture to act as an educational tool, which is considered public pedagogy
(Giroux, 2000).
Journal of Leadership Education Volume 9, Issue 2 – Summer 2010
87
Educators wishing to maintain the full attention of students, particularly those
educators teaching subjects that have nebulous concepts such as leadership, may
be interested in new instruction methods. Due to the lack of historical precedence
regarding the best method for teaching leadership, further exploration of new
teaching methods is required. Public pedagogy is one such new teaching method
and has not been researched to determine its effectiveness when applied to
leadership. For this study a static-group comparison design was utilized to test the
knowledge retention of three sections of ALDR 3900 Leadership and Service
students on the Kouzes and Posner (2007) leadership practice of Challenge the
Process. The content was delivered to the students via lecture, experiential
learning, or public pedagogy design.
Review of Literature
Educators and researchers have repeatedly acknowledged the drawbacks of
teaching with a strict lecture format. This format has been referred to as “a
method resulting in long periods of uninterrupted teacher-centered, expository
discourse which relegates students to the role of passive ‘spectators’ in the college
classroom” (Cooper, Prescott, Cook, Smith, Mueck, & Cuseo, 1990, p. 1).
Having students serve as passive spectators in the classroom may encourage a
drop in attention and decreases their retention of knowledge. Young, Robinson,
and Alberts (2009) found that the drop in attention “is avoided when presentation
is varied, though this is not necessarily associated with interactive participation
techniques” (p. 41). The incorporation of popular culture into presentations
provides for a variety in lecture and does not require interactive participation, thus
serving as a viable way to avoid a drop in attention.
Popular Culture
“Recognizing the influence of popular culture in our own lives is the first step to
harnessing its educational potential” (Thompson, 2007, p. 83). What exactly is
popular culture? A variety of meanings exist, but Lull’s (as cited in Rogers, 2002)
definition is the most applicable to this research: “commercially successful,
mainstream, mass mediated cultural artifacts and personalities” (p. 190). These
cultural artifacts include newspapers, books, the Internet, music and movies, all
which serve to entertain and educate us. The effects of such entertaining and
educating gives rise to two views on popular culture and its use for society.
One view of popular culture insists that it is “a space where learners are taught
hegemonic ways of being in the world” (Wright & Sandlin, 2009, p. 126). This
view, based on Antonio Gramsci’s (1971) idea of hegemony, casts popular culture
in a negative light due to its influence on consumers. While it is acknowledged
that popular culture can have a negative impact on consumers and critical media
literacy is suggested, this view is beyond the focus of the proposed research.
Journal of Leadership Education Volume 9, Issue 2 – Summer 2010
88
A second, and more applicable, view of popular culture is as “a tool to promote
learning in the classroom because it is deemed a way to connect with adult
learners” (Wright & Sandlin, 2009, p. 125). Considering the previously mentioned
cultural artifacts and their application to learning has generated the idea of public
pedagogy (Giroux, 2000), or education that occurs informally and incidentally
(Wright & Sandlin, 2009). Giroux (1992) has found popular culture can help
create meaning and aid in the construction of knowledge, whether the consumer is
aware of the act of learning or not.
Non-formal Learning
Learning happens daily, whether through formal or non-formal applications.
Non-formal learning, also called incidental learning, can happen through activities
that are unplanned and informal (Foley, 2001). This non-formal learning can
happen daily and through a variety of activities. Kamis, Muhamad, Junoh,
Asmuni, and Idris (2005) found that 94% of adults in Malaysia participated in
non-formal learning by watching television, video, and film. Such a high rate of
non-formal learning supports Fieldhouse’s (1995) assertion that “it is arguable
that broadcasting has been the major adult education agency of the twentieth
century” (p. 81).
Certainly the popularity of television has increased the occurrence of non-formal
education, particularly through the demand for, and support of, television
channels that serve to educate while they entertain. In a study of women who
watched the British television show The Avengers, Wright (2006) found multiple
instances of non-formal learning. Additionally, Coles and Armstrong (2007) note
that historical films and television are shows popular in the United Kingdom
where not one, but two history channels are offered to television watchers.
Similarly, a quick look through the types of channels offered in the United States
such as Food Network, Discovery Channel, National Geographic Channel, and
Science Channel also would support the idea that non-formal education is
occurring while audiences are being entertained.
Non-formal learning also takes place via other popular culture media as found by
Jarvis (2000). In a case study conducted throughout a cultural studies course
examining popular romance books, Jarvis found “[v]ery few women chose
‘escapism’ as their reason for reading and were much more likely to say that they
read ‘in order to learn more about people and the world’” (2000, p. 198). This
non-formal learning via popular media also occurs through film as “cinema
assumes a pedagogical role in the lives of many people” (Hooks as cited in
Rogers, 2002, p. 2).
Adult Education
Knowles, Holton, and Swanson (1998) assert that adults’ learning is increasingly
self-directed as they mature. This self-directed education occurs via popular
Journal of Leadership Education Volume 9, Issue 2 – Summer 2010
89
media (Kamis, Muhamad, Junoh, Asmuni, & Idris, 2005; Jarvis, 2000). Wright
and Sandlin (2009) posit that educators “must recognize and use the power pop
culture wields in the lives of adult learners if they are to fulfill a meaningful role
in the education of adults” (p. 126). Teaching with popular media may help
students determine meaning of the material because “concentration on words
alone is not enoughno single code can be successfully studied or fully
understood in isolation” (Hodge & Kress, 1988, p. vii). Wright (2007) builds upon
Knowles, Holton, and Swanson (1998) finding educators should connect to the
learning that occurs outside of the classroom to help learners make sense of their
experiences. Educators who do not reflect on their personal engagement with
popular culture “may find themselves ineffective in facilitating learning because
they are too far removed from the lived experiences of the adults they seek to
instruct” (Wright & Sandlin, 2009, p. 124).
Educators who utilized public pedagogy found that students were able to critically
analyze topics seen within the popular media (Marshall, 2001), and became more
critically conscious (Jarvis, 2000). Wright’s (2007) findings that a popular British
television show from the 1960s informally educated viewers lead her to determine
that “[e]ducators in all disciplines can benefit from incorporating popular culture
into their teaching” (p. 70).
Theoretical Frame
The concept of public pedagogy is a variation of the Kolb (1984) experiential
learning model and the notion of constructivism in education. The theoretical
framework of this study is a combination of Kolb’s experiential learning model
and Dewey’s (1938) theory of authenticity in constructivist education. Basing his
work on Piaget and Dewey, Kolb describes four steps in the experimental learning
cycle. Figure 1.1 denotes Kolb’s model.
Figure 1.1 Kolb’s Model of Experiential Learning.
Concrete
Experience
Testing implications of
concepts in new
situations
Formation of
abstract concepts
and generalization
Observations
and Reflections
Journal of Leadership Education Volume 9, Issue 2 – Summer 2010
90
Kolb defines concrete experience as a “here-and-now” incident in which the
learner has full involvement. The observation and reflection stage is where the
learner reflects on the experiences from multiple perspectives. In the formation of
abstract concepts and generalization stage, students integrate theoretical concepts
into their actions. The final stage of Kolb’s model, testing implications of new
concepts in new situations, encourages students to utilize new theories to make
decisions and problem solve (Knowles, Holton, & Swanson, 1998). Svinicki and
Dixon (1987) note Kolb’s model integrated into the collegiate classroom has been
shown to increase students’ retention of material.
Constructivism “stresses all knowledge is context bound, and individuals make
personal meaning of their learning experiences” (Knowles, Holton, & Swanson
1998, p. 142). Dewey (1938) stresses the importance of not only contextualizing
material, but assuring the contextual frame is familiar to the student. Public
pedagogy is a pedogological tool which not only contextualizes theories and
concepts for the student, but also allows the student to be guided through the Kolb
cycle.
Methods
Hypothesis
H
0
: There is no difference in the rate of knowledge retention between students
taught the leadership behavior of Challenge the Process using lecture, experiential
learning, or pubic pedagogy.
Population and Sample
The population of this study consists of all students at The University of Georgia
enrolled in ALDR 3900, Leadership and Service (n=70). Students were enrolled
in three sections of ALDR 3900 on the Athens campus. They represented the
sophomore, junior, and senior classes. Subject selection was made by randomly
assigning each section of ALDR 3900 taught during the Fall of 2009. One of three
teaching methods was used in each section including lecture, experiential
learning, or pubic pedagogy. Section A had an enrollment of 18, section B had an
enrollment of 20, and section C had an enrolment of 32.
Instrumentation
Researchers developed the instrument utilizing Challenge the Process (Kouzes &
Posner, 2007) material as a basis. Eight questions consisting of six multiple
choice and two fill-in-the blank were developed using the sub-constructs
highlighted by Kouzes and Posner as essential learning in both the Leadership
Challenge (4th ed.) and the Student Leadership Challenge (2008). The instrument
was sent to a panel of experts to test face validity.
Journal of Leadership Education Volume 9, Issue 2 – Summer 2010
91
Design
A static-group comparison design was utilized for this study with the groups
consisting of the three sections of ALDR 3900 (Fraenkel & Wallen, 2008).
Traditional lecture was treated as the control group while experiential learning
and public pedagogy methods were treated as the experimental groups. To lessen
experimental bias, the researchers were not the instructor of record for any class
sections in the experiment.
Section A was randomly selected to receive the contextual information of
Challenge the Process via pubic pedagogy. Popular media clips including the
music video for Here it Goes Again by Ok Go, a College Sports TV story on a
deaf NCAA football player, and a Nike commercial featuring Michael Jordan
were infused into the base power point to illustrate conceptual points. Discussions
on iPods vs. Zunes, different symbols of change, and examples of Challenge the
Process seen on campus were discussed to aid in their assimilation of content to
popular culture.
Section B was randomly selected to receive the contextual information of
Challenge the Process via traditional lecture. A base power point was created to
teach the two main conceptual points of Kouzes and Posner’s Commitment 5 – (a)
search for opportunities and (b) experiment and take risks. In addintion, the five
sub points of (a) seize the initiative, (b) exercise outsight, (c) treat every job as an
adventure, (d) question the status quo, and (e) send everyone shopping for ideas
were used in the study (Kouzes & Posner, 2007).
Section C was randomly selected to receive the contextual information of
Challenge the Process via experiential learning. The base power point lecture was
used and two experiential activities were added. The Kolb (1984) model of
experiential learning was used to process the activities. Students were asked to
tell, pair and share an example of change they have been a part of, and role-played
the children’s book The Little Engine that Could.
The instrument was given to students post instruction as a closed note, closed text
quiz by the researcher. Two weeks after the initial experiment, the regular
instructor gave the students the instrument again. Four weeks after the initial
experiment, the instrument was given a third time to the students by the instructor.
Table 1 shows the number of students participating in the treatments and
subsequent quizzes.
Journal of Leadership Education Volume 9, Issue 2 – Summer 2010
92
Analysis
Due to absences of the students over the period of experimentation, 38 students
were present in class to take all three quizzes (54% retention rate). Data was
entered into the Statistical Package for Social Sciences 18.0 and means were
calculated and compared to delineate differences between and among the
treatments. Mean differentiation and summation was chosen as the proper
statistical methodology due to the low n for this study.
Findings
The null hypothesis of this study postulated there is no difference in the rate of
knowledge retention between students taught the leadership behavior of
Challenge the Process using lecture, experiential learning, or pubic pedagogy. A
comparison of the quizzes using descriptive analysis showed a difference between
mean scores between treatments. An analysis of summated means showed
differences in the mean scores. By both measures, the null hypothesis is rejected.
Retention of Material
Quiz 1
After each class period, students were given the first of three quizzes
(instruments). Table 2 shows the descriptive results. Section A, public pedagogy,
had the highest mean (76.39), Section C, experiential, had the second highest
mean (73.33), and Section B, lecture, had the lowest mean (62.50). It is
interesting to note the range between public pedagogy and traditional lecture.
Table 1. Participation in quizzes
Method Quiz 1 Quiz 2 Quiz 3
Group A 15 12 13
Group B 13 16 12
Group C 25 19 24
Journal of Leadership Education Volume 9, Issue 2 – Summer 2010
93
Quiz 2
Two weeks after the experiential treatment, the quiz (instrument) was given to the
students by the instructor of record. Table 3 shows the descriptive results. Again,
section A, public pedagogy, had the highest mean (73.61), Section C, experiential,
had the second highest mean (67.50), and Section B, lecture, had the lowest mean
(47.22). There was more than a 30 point range between public pedagogy and
traditional lecture.
Quiz 3
Four weeks after the experiential treatment, the quiz (instrument) was given to the
students by the instructor of record. Table 4 shows the descriptive results. Section
C, experiential learning, had the highest mean (76.67) followed closely by Section
A, public pedagogy, (73.61) and 30 points lower was Section B, lecture, (48.61).
It should be noted Section C had completed a test two days prior to the third quiz
which may account for the increase in mean between the second and third quiz.
Teaching Methods
Table 2. Quiz 1 Scores
M SD Min Max Mdn
Quiz 1
Section A (n=9) 76.39 11.60 62.50 87.50 75.00
Section B (n=9) 62.50 17.68 37.50 87.50 62.50
Section C (n=15) 73.33 19.97 37.50 100.00 75.00
Table 3. Quiz 2 Scores
M SD Min Max Mdn
Quiz 2
Section A (n=9) 73.61 15.87 50.00 87.50 75.00
Section B (n=9) 47.22 24.83 12.50 87.50 50.00
Section C (n=15) 67.50 22.56 12.50 100.00 62.50
Table 4. Quiz 3 Scores
M SD Min Max Mdn
Quiz 3
Section A (n=9) 73.61 15.87 37.50 87.50 75.00
Section B (n=9) 48.61 23.75 12.50 87.50 50.00
Section C (n=15) 76.67 19.40 25.00 100.00 75.00
Journal of Leadership Education Volume 9, Issue 2 – Summer 2010
94
Analysis of the summated means of the three treatments and the three quizzes
compared to the grand mean resulted in a discrepancy between public pedagogy
and experiential learning and lecture. Public pedagogy’s summated mean of 74.54
and experiential learning’s summated mean of 72.50 was above the grand mean of
67.68, while the summated mean of traditional lecture fell below the grand mean
with a value of 51.04. Table 5 shows the differences between the summated
means and grand mean.
Table 5.
Section Grand M SD
A 74.54 14.10
B 51.04 22.60
C 72.50 20.60
All 67.68 21.50
Conclusions/Implications
A main component of leadership development is education (Brungardt, 1996). As
more colleges and universities continue to add collegiate leadership theory and
application courses, it becomes more imperative for pedagogy of teaching
leadership to be studied (Williams, Townsend & Lindner, 2005). In this study
three teaching methods including lecture, experiential learning, and public
pedagogy were tested to determine the difference in student learning and content
retention.
Faculty has a direct impact on the learning of their students. Dewey (2006) states
that if the “habits of the teacher are so narrow and fixed, his imagination and
sympathies so limited, his own intellectual horizon so bounded, he brings [ideas]
to bear in a wrong way” (p. 549). Faculty must be open to modifying their
teaching methods. For the millennial student “it is not easy for experienced
instructors to recognize that the way they were taught and the way they have
taught is not effective” (Taylor, 2006, p. 251).
The findings of the study showed knowledge retention was highest and most
consistent over time for the students who received their information via public
pedagogy. This supports the findings of Jarvis (2000), Marshall (2001), and
Wright (2007) who found students engaged more in the curriculum when public
Journal of Leadership Education Volume 9, Issue 2 – Summer 2010
95
pedagogy methods were used. Kamis et al. (2005) noted that for adult learners
engagement equals knowledge retention.
It can also be concluded that traditional lecture utilizing only slides with key
information on them is ineffective in the knowledge gain and retention of the
leadership practice, Challenge the Process. The dramatic decrease in mean scores
for Section B between the first quiz and the subsequent quizzes show a severe
lack of retention of the material. This finding supports the work of Young, et al.
(2009) who found lack of engagement brought on by students being passive
spectators in the classroom led to decreased retention in material. The summated
mean scores of Section B being lower than the grand mean also shows it is an
inferior way of teaching Challenge the Process.
It can be concluded public pedagogy and experiential learning are more effective
ways of teaching Challenge the Process, with public pedagogy slightly more
consistent and effective. This supports the work of Champoux (2005) who
concluded that supplementing lectures with verbal and visual material enhances
the learning of the student.
If this study is generalized, the implications for leadership educators are simple:
lecture is ineffective. Understanding the teaching methodologies of public
pedagogy and experiential learning are paramount in students learning of
leadership. To test this implication, more research should be conducted.
Repeating this study on a larger scale, repeating with different leadership content,
and looking at the use of public pedagogy with other adult learners will strengthen
and add to the results of this study. As leadership education moves forward,
connecting leadership theory to students everyday world is imperative in the role
of leadership educators.
Journal of Leadership Education Volume 9, Issue 2 – Summer 2010
96
References
Brungardt, C. (1996). The making of leaders: A review of the research in
leadership development and education. The Journal of Leadership Studies,
3(3), 81-95.
Callahan, J. L., & Rosser, M. H. (2007). Pop goes the program: Using popular
culture artifacts to educate leaders. Advances in Developing Human
Resources, 9(2), 269-287.
Callahan, J. L., Whitener, J. K., & Sandlin, J. A. (2007). The art of creating
leaders: Popular culture artifacts as pathways for development. Advances
in Developing Human Resources, 9(2), 146-165.
Champoux, J. E. (2005). Comparative analyses of live-action and animated film
remake scenes: Finding alternative film-based teaching resources.
Educational Media International, 42(1), 49-69.
Coles, J., & Armstrong, P. (2007). Dumbing down history through popular
culture: Communities of interest or learning as consumption. Proceedings
of the 37th Annual Standing Conference on University Teaching and
Research in the Education of Adults, Queen’s University, Belfast,
Northern Ireland.
Cooper, J., Prescott, S., Cook, L., Smith, L., Mueck, R., & Cuseo, J. (1990).
Cooperative learning and college instruction: Effective use of student
learning teams. Long Beach, CA: California State University Foundation.
Dewey, J. (2006). Individuality and experience (1926). In Forgotten Heroes of
American Education, p. 589-594.
Dewey, J. (1938). Experience and education. New York: Macmillan.
Fieldhouse, R. (1995). Historical perspectives on future developments and
diversity in British adult education. Proceedings of the 25
th
Annual
Standing Conference on University Teaching and Research in the
Education of Adults, University of Southampton, Winchester, England.
Foley, G. (2001). Radical adult education and learning. International Journal of
Lifelong Education, 20(1/2), 71-88.
Journal of Leadership Education Volume 9, Issue 2 – Summer 2010
97
Franenkel, J. R., & Wallen, N. E. (2008). How to design and evaluate research in
education (7
th
ed). Boston: McGraw-Hill.
Giroux, H. (1992). Border crossings: Cultural workers and the politics of
education. New York: Routledge.
Giroux, H. (2000). Public pedagogy as cultural politics: Stuart Hall and the crisis
of culture. Cultural Studies, 14(2), 341-360.
Gramsci, A. (1971). Selections from the prison notebooks. New York:
International Publishers.
Halpern, D. F. (2000, March). Creating Cooperative Learning Environments. APS
Observer, p. 14-15, 29-31.
Hodge, R, & Kress, G. (1988). Social semiotics. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University
Press.
Jarvis, C. (2000). Researching adult learners’ reading histories and practices.
Proceedings of the 41
st
Annual Adult Education Research Conference (p.
196-200), University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada.
Kamis, M., Muhamad, M., Junoh, A. M., Asmuni, A., & Idris, K. (2005).
Informal learning in Malaysia. Proceedings of the 46th Annual Adult
Education Research Conference, University of Georgia, Athens.
Knowles, M. S., Holton III, E. F., & Swanson, R. A. (1998). The adult learner (5
th
ed). Houston: Gulf.
Kolb, D. A., (1984). Experiential learning: Experience as the source of learning
and development. Englewood-Cliffs, CA: Prentice-Hall.
Kouzes, J., & Posner, B. (2007). The leadership challenge, (4
th
ed.). San
Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Kouzes, J., & Posner, B. (2008). The student leadership challenge: Five practices
for exemplary leaders. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Lull, J. (1995). Media, communication, culture: A global approach. New York:
Columbia University Press.
Journal of Leadership Education Volume 9, Issue 2 – Summer 2010
98
Marshall, D. M. (2001). Thinking outside the box: Using popular culture to
stimulate a critical thinking process. Unpublished master of education
thesis. University of Alaska, Anchorage.
Rogers, E. E. (2002). Waiting to exhale: African American women and adult
learning through movies. Proceedings of the 43rd Annual Adult Education
Research Conference (p. 327-332), North Carolina State University,
Raleigh.
Svinicki, M. D., & Dixon, N. M. (1987). The Kolb model modified for classroom
activities. College Teaching, 35(4) 141-146.
Taylor, M. L. (2006). Generation next comes to college: 2006 updates and
emerging issues. Self-study and Institutional Improvement, 2(2), 248-255.
Thompson, P. M. (2007). The influence of popular culture and entertainment
media on adult education. In E. J. Tisdell & P. M. Thompson (Eds.), New
directions for adult and continuing education: No. 115. Popular culture
and entertainment media in adult education (p. 83-90). San Francisco:
Jossey-Bass.
Williams, J. R., Townsend, C. D., & Lindner, J. (2005). Teaching leadership: Do
students remember and utilize the concepts we teach? Journal of
Leadership Education, 4(1), 66-78.
Wright, R. R. (2006). Popular culture, cult TV, and gender resistance: Informal
learning from primetime feminism. Proceedings of the 36th Annual
Standing Conference on University Teaching and Research in the
Education of Adults (p. 449-464), All Saints College, Leeds, United
Kingdom.
Wright, R. R. (2007). The Avengers, public pedagogy, and the development of
British women's consciousness. In E. J. Tisdell & P. M. Thompson (Eds.),
New directions in adult and continuing education: No. 115. Popular
culture and adult education (p. 63-73). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Wright, R. R., & Sandlin, J. A. (2009). Cult TV, hip hop, shape-shifters, and
vampire slayers: A review of the literature at the intersection of adult
education and popular culture. Adult Education Quarterly, 59(2), 118-141.
Young, M., Robinson, S., & Albert, P. (2009). Students pay attention! Combating
Journal of Leadership Education Volume 9, Issue 2 – Summer 2010
99
the vigilance decrement to improve learning during lectures. Active Learning in
Higher Education, 10(1), 41-55.
Journal of Leadership Education Volume 9, Issue 2 – Summer 2010
100
Author Biographies
Jennifer Williams is an Assistant Professor in Agricultural Leadership, Education,
and Communications at Texas A&M. She teaches undergraduate and graduate
courses in leadership theory and application.
Megan McClure is a graduate student at The University of Georgia in the
Department of Agricultural Leadership, Education, and Communication where
she is pursuing her Master of Agricultural Leadership degree.
... When taught using demonstration. The findings are also not agreement with the findings of Williams and McClure [24] who opined that knowledge and skill retention is high and always consistent over time for the learners who received their learning process through demonstration than lecture and discussion method of teaching. The present findings are also not in agreement with Auwal [25] who is of the view that demonstration method of teaching and learning brings about better retention of learned materials than lecture and discussion methods of teaching. ...
... Bush and Glover (2016) define monitoring as the regular collection and analysis of information which is then used to guide a particular project, regarding whether to continue on its course or change direction. According to Williams and McClure (2010) monitoring is the on-going assessments of progress during project or program implementation, it checks progress, take remedial actions and enable the updating of plans. In their study, Kanyamuna and Phiri (2019) observed that the major role of monitoring is to determine the acquired levels of knowledge, skills or understanding, to diagnose problems that trainees may be encountering, to make decisions about the next instructional steps to be taken, and to evaluate the learning that has taken place in the trainees. ...
Article
Full-text available
Monitoring and evaluation of peer led group training programmes is critical in ensuring that peer leaders are equipped with the necessary skills in the provision of psychosocial support to vulnerable learners. This study aimed to investigate the practice of monitoring and evaluation of peer led group training programmes. A qualitative approach and a case study research design were used. Semi-structured interviews were used to collect data. Four secondary schools and 38 participants were purposively selected. Data were analysed using a thematic approach. The major finding was that peer led group training programmes were not effectively being monitored and evaluated due to limited funding for the programme, lack of monitoring and evaluation technical skills, too much reliance on self-monitoring and evaluation which raises loyalty issues thereby compromising the effectiveness of peer led group training programmes. The study recommends that there must be regular monitoring and evaluation of these training programmes and the need for the provision of adequate financial resources.
... Researchers and scholars have continuously remarked on the drawbacks of teaching with a strict lecture format. The format is usually referred to as a method resulting in long periods of uninterrupted teacher-centered, expository discourse which subjects students to the role of passive 'spectators' in the classroom (Williams and McClure, 2010). Hence, there have been several attempts (Arslan ,Akın & Çitemel, www.ijere.com ...
... When taught using demonstration. The findings are also not agreement with the findings of Williams and McClure [24] who opined that knowledge and skill retention is high and always consistent over time for the learners who received their learning process through demonstration than lecture and discussion method of teaching. The present findings are also not in agreement with Auwal [25] who is of the view that demonstration method of teaching and learning brings about better retention of learned materials than lecture and discussion methods of teaching. ...
... Leadership educators have the challenging task of explaining abstract concepts and ideas to their students. Teachers of leadership have recognized the potential of popular media to illustrate abstract leadership concepts and have been utilizing PCAs (such as movies, newspapers, television, books, and social media) in classroom settings to pursue this goal Williams & McClure, 2010;Odom et al., 2013) English & Steffy, 1997). Furthermore, PCAs provide vicarious learning experiences, without the need to make mistakes personally to learn the leadership lessons . ...
Article
Full-text available
Classroom leadership instruction can be monotonous at times, especially for undergraduate students, who may not have extensive experiences to connect course content to “real world” applications. A number of scholars have indicated that popular culture resources can be beneficial in fostering the active engagement of participants during the learning process. This article explains how the 2019 Chernobyl historical drama television miniseries can be used to illustrate ethical theories. In addition, the article offers discussion questions to guide the facilitators in classroom interaction. Link: https://journalofleadershiped.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/19_4_Cenkci.pdf
... Bush and Glover (2016) define monitoring as the regular collection and analysis of information which is then used to guide a particular project, regarding whether to continue on its course or change direction. According to Williams and McClure (2010) monitoring is the on-going assessments of progress during project or program implementation, it checks progress, take remedial actions and enable the updating of plans. In their study, Kanyamuna and Phiri (2019) observed that the major role of monitoring is to determine the acquired levels of knowledge, skills or understanding, to diagnose problems that trainees may be encountering, to make decisions about the next instructional steps to be taken, and to evaluate the learning that has taken place in the trainees. ...
Article
Full-text available
The economies of many African countries are largely agrarian driven and there are increasing revelations that climate extreme events present a negative influence on biophysical, social and livelihood system of human sustenance. This research therefore investigated farmers’ adaptive capacity in the North West Province of South Africa. Cross-sectional data obtained from the randomly drawn 346 maize farmers were analysed using descriptive statistics, composite technique and finite mixture semi-parametric model. From the result, majority (60.69%) have a moderate adaptive capacity, while farmers’ adaptive capacities are distinguishable in terms of farmers’ characteristics and livelihood capital assets. Further, the results also indicated that about sixty-three percent of the farmers are likely to be in the low AC class, and twenty-two percent are expected to be in the moderate AC class. However, approximately fifteen percent are expected to be in the high AC class. Consequent on these findings, a sustainable adaptive capacity driven policy is of paramount importance to ensure functioning food systems and agrarian welfare.
... Bush and Glover (2016) define monitoring as the regular collection and analysis of information which is then used to guide a particular project, regarding whether to continue on its course or change direction. According to Williams and McClure (2010) monitoring is the on-going assessments of progress during project or program implementation, it checks progress, take remedial actions and enable the updating of plans. In their study, Kanyamuna and Phiri (2019) observed that the major role of monitoring is to determine the acquired levels of knowledge, skills or understanding, to diagnose problems that trainees may be encountering, to make decisions about the next instructional steps to be taken, and to evaluate the learning that has taken place in the trainees. ...
Article
Full-text available
Monitoring and evaluation of peer led group training programmes is critical in ensuring that peer leaders are equipped with the necessary skills in the provision of psychosocial support to vulnerable learners. This study aimed to investigate the practice of monitoring and evaluation of peer led group training programmes. A qualitative approach and a case study research design were used. Semi-structured interviews were used to collect data. Four secondary schools and 38 participants were purposively selected. Data were analysed using a thematic approach. The major finding was that peer led group training programmes were not effectively being monitored and evaluated due to limited funding for the programme, lack of monitoring and evaluation technical skills, too much reliance on self-monitoring and evaluation which raises loyalty issues thereby compromising the effectiveness of peer led group training programmes. The study recommends that there must be regular monitoring and evaluation for these training programmes and the need for the provision of adequate financial resources.
... This is also supported by Ogbuanya and Owodunni (2013) who discovered that the persistent poor academic achievement as well as retention in courses is as a result of the inappropriate teaching methods adopted by teachers. Therefore, as stated by Williams and McClure (2010) teachers must find the most suitable methods to teach the students in order to determine best practices for classroom delivery and minimize achievement loss, using the resources available to them. ...
Article
Full-text available
The study examined Student Engagement Variables and First Year Undergraduate Retention Rate in University of Uyo, Akwa Ibom State, Nigeria. Five research questions and four hypotheses guided the study. The descriptive survey research design was used for the study. The population comprised 3,447 first year undergraduates from University of Uyo. Purposive and simple random sampling techniques were used to select 548 first year undergraduates studying four-year courses in University of Uyo. Two instruments titled; "Student Engagement Questionnaire (SEQ)" and a documentary analysis checklist were used for data collection. The reliability coefficient of SEQ was determined using the Cronbach Alpha Analysis and a reliability index of 0.82 was obtained. Mean, coefficient of R value and R2 of Simple Linear Regression were used to answer research questions while F ratio of Simple Linear Regression Analysis was used to test the null hypotheses at 0.05 alpha level. The findings of the study revealed that student engagement variables of active learning, student-faculty interaction, teaching strategies and co-curricular activities significantly predicts first year undergraduate retention rate in University of Uyo, Akwa Ibom State. It was therefore concluded that, student engagement variables relate significantly to first year undergraduate retention rate in University of Uyo. Based on the findings of this study, it is therefore recommended amongst others that, faculties should create a healthy learning atmosphere and positive student-faculty interactions in order to guarantee student retention. Highlights of this paper  The study examined Student Engagement Variables and First Year Undergraduate Retention Rate in University of Uyo, Akwa Ibom State, Nigeria.  The results of the study revealed that student engagement variables of active learning, student-faculty interaction, teaching strategies and co-curricular activities significantly predicts first year undergraduate retention rate in University of Uyo, Akwa Ibom State. Nigeria.
Article
Peer teaching among students has a powerful role in the learning process and has been studied and recognized as an effective teaching method. Research on peer teaching applied in different contexts has shown that learning through the process of teaching others increases students' academic performance. In Indonesia, some research on peer teaching has been conducted, but there has been no research on peer teaching in the context of theological studies. Hence, this empirical study aims to verify whether peer teaching is effective when applied in a theological school setting. In this study, students of a homiletics course were the research sample. Results show that peer teaching had a positive effect on students' academic performance. However, further research is recommended on the application of peer teaching in other subject areas to confirm the effectiveness of peer teaching in a theological school context.
Article
Full-text available
The motive behind the Government step that 500 and 1000 currency notes will no longer be a legal tender from 8th November 2016 midnight in a helicopter how over manner was mainly to curb black money with other objectives like to tackle corruption, terror finance, counterfeiting and others. The question which was raised after this step among most of us was that what will have been gained from this step, and at what cost and mostly borne by whom. The present study is conducted to access that how well the implementation process would open out to the economy. The objective of the present study is to analyze the impact of demonetization and to study whether it has shown success in reducing black money and other problems facing by Indian economy at present. The research methodology used in the present study is based on primary and secondary data. A well designed questionnaire was prepared for the study. The paper concludes that demonetization proved to be a successful measure initiated by government and also it will prove to be a game changer in long term as it helped to curb black money and disclosing hidden income. The results shows that it is also a truly daring step in the best interests of India and its people. The step of demonetization also promoted the economy to shift towards cashless or going digitization which further have many benefits.
Article
The University of Missouri–Columbia has brought Freshman Interest Groups into the residence halls. The residential life director reports on why they made this move—and the results they are seeing.
Article
Despite increasing attention on the topic of empowerment, our under-standing of the construct and its underlying processes remains limited. This article addresses these shortcomings by providing an analytical treatment of the construct and by integrating the diverse approaches to empowerment found in both the management and psychology literatures. In addition, the authors identify certain antecedent conditions of powerlessness and practices that have been hypothesized to empower subordinates.