ArticlePDF Available

Coming Clean: Overcoming Addiction without Treatment

DOI:10.2307/2654369
Authors:
Leslie Irvine at University of Colorado Boulder
Leslie Irvine
Robert Granfield at University at Buffalo, The State University of New York
Robert Granfield
William Cloud
William Cloud
William Cloud
  • This person is not on ResearchGate, or hasn't claimed this research yet.
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

Despite the widely accepted view that formal treatment and twelve-step groups are essential for overcoming dependencies on alcohol and drugs, each year large numbers of former addicts quietly recover on their own, without any formal treatment or participation in self-help groups at all. Coming Clean explores the untold stories of untreated addicts who have recovered from a lifestyle of excessive and compulsive substance use without professional assistance. Based on 46 in-depth interviews with formerly addicted individuals, this controversial volume examines their reasons for avoiding treatment, the strategies they employed to break away from their dependencies, the circumstances that facilitated untreated recovery, and the implications of recovery without treatment for treatment professionals as well as for prevention and drug policy. Because of the pervasive belief that addiction is a disease requiring formal intervention, few training programs for physicians, social workers, psychologists, and other health professionals explore the phenomenon of natural recovery from addiction. Coming Clean offers insights for treatment professionals of how recovery without treatment can work and how candidates for this approach can be identified. A detailed appendix outlines specific strategies which will be of interest to addicted individuals themselves who wish to attempt the process of recovery without treatment.
Content uploaded by Leslie Irvine
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Leslie Irvine on Aug 04, 2015
Content may be subject to copyright.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Coming Clean: Overcoming Addiction without Treatment
Irvine, Leslie
Contemporary Sociology; Jan 2001; 30, 1; ProQuest Central
pg. 86
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
... For instance, individuals who experienced sexual violence may be less apt to seek help and are less likely to be believed by others if their narrative varies from stereotypical depictions of rape in media (Loseke, 2001;Polletta, 2009;Polletta et al., 2013;Scheppele, 1992;Wood, 2001). Crucially, narratives can affect the ability of individuals to grapple with hardships if the narratives lack saliency or fail to chart an effective way forward (Granfield & Cloud, 1999). ...
... Recent evidence also demonstrates the promise of recovery narratives in promoting healing and providing support to people with EDs (Rennick-Egglestone et al., 2019). Stigma around mental illness has frequently constricted the development of effective recovery narratives and notions of self (Charmaz, 1991(Charmaz, , 1994Granfield & Cloud, 1999;Gubrium & Holstein, 2001;Link et al., 1989;Strauss, 1969;Thoits, 1985). Recovering from illness under a cloud of stigma and weakened community ties can cause individuals to make recovery identities ends-in-themselves, thereby stunting development and recovery (Haworth-Hoeppner & Maines, 2005;Howard, 2006;Garrett, 1996). ...
Men in online eating disorder recovery spaces: Gendered barriers, content moderation, and narrative experimentation
Article
Full-text available
  • Oct 2023
Eating disorders (EDs), once considered solely a women's health problem, have increasingly affected men. Previous research on recovery from addiction has emphasized the importance of narratives, which help provide structure and make sense of events. While narratives are often important for an individual's recovery from hardship, hegemonic narratives can be invalidating and obstacles to wellbeing. The highly gendered nature of ED recovery narratives has posed a barrier to men adopting alternative, more successful narratives, particularly in female‐dominated spaces. This study examines how content moderation policies and enforcement on Tumblr, Reddit, and an ED recovery website shape men's participation in ED recovery support groups dominated by women. We find that high degrees of moderation and censorship limit men's platform participation and narrative experimentation. However, platform rules without active censorship face the same challenges. Instead, narrative experimentation and greater participation from men occur during moderate regulation because they can share their experiences while also being encouraged to find salient aspects of other, healthier narratives. We observed that men were able to break from unhelpful recovery narratives when they could masculinize the suggestions from women with more productive approaches. While past research has shown that men are particularly reliant on hegemonic masculinity when their gender is challenged, we find that phenomenon is part of a more fundamental process of reconciling ideas into one's self‐concept.
View
... While the intensive nature of the AA groups and the emphasis on sharing and opening up might certainly provide a rich environment for identity transformation, the stress on the 'alcoholic's' inability to control alcohol use might enhance a fatalistic view of the new identity (which is powerless against substances) thereby facilitating self-defeating behaviours (Peele, 1984;Granfield and Cloud, 1999). ...
... Inmates who believe they have no control over their own success or failure may be more likely to engage in self-defeating behaviors. (Severance, 2004, p. 93) As previously suggested, perceiving oneself as unable to control alcohol use might enhance the view of a powerless identity and trigger self-defeating behaviours, in addition to increasing the risk of a chain-reaction of events confirming a selffulfilling prophecy (Peele, 1984;Granfield and Cloud, 1999). ...
View
... They use community-based intervention, such as recovery capital. Recovery capital refers to the sum of resource that individuals can draw upon to initiate and sustain processes od addiction recovery (Irvine et al., 2001) . However, the recovery processes is not as simple as imagined, the client should have inner strength to hold on in abstinence (Harrison et al., 2020). ...
A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW PROTOCOL OF RECOVERY SOCIAL SUPPORT FOR WOMEN WITH DRUGS ADDICTION
Article
Full-text available
  • Nov 2022
Introduction: The women with drugs addictive were increasing significantly. As consequence, the recovery was needed to make a better quality of life. In the recovery process they needed social support to prevent relapsing. This study to review how the experience of the women with drugs addiction in their recovery process. Methods: This study used database in early 2011 until 2021, there were BMC, CINAHL, ClinicalKey for Nursing, Embase, Emcare, Emerald Insight, Gale OneFile: Nursing and Allied Health, Informit, Joanna Briggs Institute EBP Database, Medline, Nursing & Allied Health, Proquest, Psycarticles, Psycinfo, Public Health Database, Pubmed, Pubmed Central (PMC), Sciencedirect, Scopus, and Wiley Online Library. The inclusion articles were qualitative original research dan research subject is relevant with the interest of this study. This study will use meta-aggregation for the analysis method. Result: Discussion of result will be made Conclusion: Conclusion and recommendations will be made
View
... Furthermore, groups also provide direct and indirect social support, a sense of personal control through the group's ability to affect change, and the social power and agency that the opportunity for collective action brings [4,22]. Similarly, recovery capital can be built by developing and strengthening links with those who are in recovery (bonding) and the wider community that may provide support (bridging) [3,23,24]. ...
Effects of substance-use, recovery, and non-drug-related online community participation on risk of a use episode during remission from opioid use disorder (OUD): A longitudinal observational study (Preprint)
Article
Full-text available
Background: Opioid addiction is currently one of the most pressing public health issues. Despite several treatment options for opioid addiction, the recurrence of use episodes during remission remains high. Research indicates that meaningful membership in various social groups underpins the successful transition from addiction to long-term remission. However, much of the current literature focuses on online peer-support groups for individuals in remission from substance use, sometimes also called recovery groups, a term we will use in line with the terminology used by the online community we studied. In contrast, online group memberships that promote substance use and groups that are unrelated to substance use and remission (non-drug-related groups) are rarely studied. Objective: This study aims to understand whether engagement with a variety of Reddit subforums (subreddits) provides those in remission from opioid use disorder (OUD) with social capital, thereby reducing their risk of a use episode over several years. More specifically, it aims to examine the different effects of engagement with substance use, recovery, and non-drug-related subreddits. Methods: A data set of 457 individuals in remission from OUD who posted their remission start date on Reddit was collected, of whom 219 (47.9%) indicated at least one use episode during the remission period. Using a Cox proportional hazards model, the effects of the number of non-drug-related, recovery, and substance use subreddits an individual had engaged with on the risk of a use episode were tested. Group engagement was assessed both in terms of the absolute number of subreddits and as a proportion of the total number of subreddits in which an individual had posted. Results: Engagement with a larger number of non-drug-related online communities reduced the likelihood of a use episode irrespective of the number of posts and comments made in these forums. This was true for both the absolute number of non-drug-related communities (P<.001) and the proportion of communities with which a person engaged (P<.001). The findings were less conclusive for recovery support and substance use groups; although participating in more recovery support subreddits reduced the risk of a use episode (P<.001), being part of a higher proportion of recovery support groups relative to other subreddits increased the risk (P=.01). A higher proportion of substance use subreddits marginally increased the risk of a use episode (P=.06); however, the absolute number of substance use subreddits significantly reduced the risk of a use episode (P=.002). Conclusions: Our work indicates that even minimal regular engagement with several non-drug-related online forums may provide those in remission from OUD with an opportunity to grow their social capital and reduce the risk of a use episode over several years.
View
View
EDITORIAL. Sobre la recuperación en adicciones
Article
Full-text available
  • Jan 2023
Las adicciones continúan siendo hoy en día uno de los principales problemas de salud pública a nivel mundial. Apesar de que el campo de la prevención y tratamiento de las adicciones ha recibido mucha atención científica, aúnexisten muchos debates abiertos sobre el concepto de adicción y otros que le rodean, como es el caso de la recuperación a través de diferentes modelos. Desde el modelo biomédico se entiende que no es posible la remisión sin tratamiento ni la curación total por la posibilidad constante de la recaída, proponiéndose como única alternativa la abstinencia total. Sin embargo, ante este modelo, la evidencia muestra la necesidad de establecer nuevas teorías y modelos que expliquenmejor la complejidad multicausal de las adicciones, así como su tratamiento y prevención lo que pasa necesariamente por definir el concepto de recuperación en adicciones.
View
Identity Construction in Recovery from Substance Use Disorders
Article
  • Dec 2022
Long-term recovery from substance use disorders has been described as a process of identity construction, through which the stigma of being a substance user is replaced by a new identity of a non-user. Identity construction has been widely acknowledged as a significant factor in different pathways of substance use cessation, such as self-change and treatment-change. However, almost no articles have discussed the role of identity construction in desistance and recovery among both self-changers and treatment-change. The aim of this narrative review was to explore this subject in the two groups. Based on the recovery capital approach and the social identity model of recovery, I posited that self-changers and treatment-changers undergo different processes of identity construction. Moreover, the prospects for successful identity construction depend upon personal and social resources (recovery capital) that provide identity-building materials such as relationships, attitudes, and role models. This article contributes to the field by presenting the different identity constructions in the process of long-term recovery from SUDs.
View
Partnering with recovery community centers to build recovery capital by improving access to reproductive health
Article
  • Nov 2022
Background: People with substance use disorders (SUD), especially opioid use disorder (OUD) have the highest rates of unintended pregnancies (80-95%) and report unmet reproductive health needs. Women of childbearing age have some of the highest death rates from opioids and are notably rising the most rapidly, and when pregnancy does occur overdose is one of the leading causes of maternal mortality. There are numerous gender-based health disparities and social determinants of health shaped by the distribution of power and privilege that influence the risk trajectories of people who can get pregnant or are pregnant with a substance use disorder (SUD). Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to describe how reproductive health is essential to recovery and building recovery capital for people who can get pregnant, (1) introduce a pilot implementation science study working with trained peer support coaches to promote reproductive autonomy in the community, and (2) make policy and advocacy recommendations relevant to the new reproductive health landscape in the United States. We will also describe the adaptation and feasibility of the initial pilot study where we partnered with a recovery community center to train peer recovery coaches to provide low barrier resources (contraception, pregnancy tests and prenatal vitamins) and referrals to health care. Methods: This initiative is the merging of best practices in recovery and community-based global reproductive health, to empower people with SUD who can get pregnant in an implementation science framework. The pilot study will last 3 months in each city and aims to (1) assess and describe the effectiveness of the training of local peer recovery coaches on the link between recovery capital and reproductive health, and (2) assess the feasibility, acceptability, appropriateness, scalability, sustainability, and uptake and reach of low barrier reproductive health resources (pregnancy tests, prenatal vitamins, and emergency contraception). In this paper we are only reporting the initial findings regarding adaptation and feasibility. Findings: Informed by qualitative interviews with stakeholders and participants, the method of contraception was adapted from injectable to emergency to meet the needs and context of the community with SUD. Early outcomes such as uptake and acceptability indicate that this is a feasible model with peer recovery coaches and recovery community centers, with the greatest uptake of emergency contraception and pregnancy tests. Conclusion: Considering recent policies limiting access to reproductive health, innovative community-based solutions are needed to engage and empower people who can get pregnant or are pregnant while in active drug use and in recovery. Providing low barrier reproductive health items by people with lived experience with SUD can serve as a valuable harm reduction model and improve recovery capital. Clinical relevance: This is the first study to propose a methodology and context to implement a community-based study merging best practices in recovery with those in reproductive health with the potential to improve recovery capital and maternal/child health trajectories for people with SUD.
View
Treatment Rules
Chapter
  • Oct 2022
This chapter is focused on informants’ compliance with formal rules and regulations in TCs. While staying at TC, rules are addressed with particular attention to the specifics of the socio-cultural background of individuals in the research sample. Inpatients/clients from all countries where the fieldwork was done referred to intimate relationships and sexual abstinence in their narratives. Nicaraguan informants also discussed treatment fees in the context of treatment rules and the importance of discipline. At the end of the chapter, machine-generated summaries of 5 relevant scientific papers are included.
View
Mentoring the Next Generation of Recovery Researchers: A Summer Course in Addiction-Recovery Studies
Article
  • Sep 2022
This perspective paper overviews the intergenerational coming together of a focused subset of the foundational addiction-recovery researchers and a highly motivated group of student researchers. It explores the process of science and practice of adult learning throughout the process. Multiple research areas were explored as the students engaged in active discussion with the presenters who spoke about their careers, their current work, what they envisioned for the future. This experience showed the importance of mentorship of new researchers by the pioneers in the field of addiction-recovery research.
View
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.