Power theorists are divided on the question of whether individual powers are single-track (for a single manifestation type)
or are multi-track (capable of producing distinct manifestation types for distinct stimuli). EJ Lowe has recently defended
single-tracking, arguing that the multi-tracker can provide no adequate reason for treating powers as capable of having multiple
manifestation types,
... [Show full abstract] and claiming that putative instances of multi-track powers are either single-track powers in need of
unifying descriptions or are merely several single-track powers. I respond to Lowe on behalf of the multi-tracker, first by
arguing that he overlooks the extra-empirical features of the debate, then by posing a dilemma for any single-track account
of powers concerning the single-tracker’s ability to appropriately deal with fine-grained manifestation types. Finally I provide
the aforementioned reason for thinking that there are multi-track powers.
KeywordsPowers–Dispositions–Multi-track–Individuation–Essence