ChapterPDF Available

Women, ‘double work’ and mobile media: The more things change, the more they stay the same

Authors:

Abstract

Research on women’s use of mobile media has also been largely ordered by their spheres of existence, namely the home and the workplace, while capturing the rapidly blurring boundaries between these closely intertwined milieu. Felicitously, even though research on mobile media use by women has been understandably dominated by regions where ICT penetration is higher and access more forthcoming, the research landscape has evolved along with the rapid diffusion of mobile media. Mobile phones in particular, are manufactured for and marketed to consumers across all socio-economic sectors, making mobile phone ownership commonplace in both developed and developing countries. Findings are thus emerging from Asia and the Global South, focusing on hitherto understudied groups such as migrant women workers and transnational families. Such studies lend depth and diversity to our understanding of the role of mobile media in women’s performance of domestic duties, focusing as they do on families which defy conventional classification, whose members are not physically proximate, and whose ‘away’ and ‘left-behind’ members encounter vastly contrasting levels and quality of mobile media access. And yet, as this chapter seeks to elucidate, even as the technological landscape of mobile media changes with the constant appearance of disruptive technologies such as the recent tablet phenomenon, the social settings within which women appropriate mobile media remain fundamentally unaltered. The socio-cultural norms and expectations surrounding women’s roles in society, as daughters, spouses, mothers and individuals in their own right, are as circumscribing as they are circumscribed, as can be witnessed in women’s use of mobile media as they strive to fulfil both familial and professional obligations. As Leopoldina Fortunati astutely observed, women are more vulnerable than men to the pressure of “double work” - the challenges of balancing obligations in both the home and the workplace. Taking women’s navigation of this “double work” environment as the departure point, this chapter will review how women’s use of mobile media in the home and the workplace has evolved over the years, while remaining unchanged in particular respects. In so doing, it will incorporate studies from a range of geographical regions, both developed and developing, thus capturing the varying social norms which can impinge on women’s engagement with mobile media. Issues surrounding the duality of mobile media, simultaneously limiting and enabling, and the shifting, yet persistent, liminalities that women negotiate will also be discussed. The chapter then concludes with a call for urgent imperatives to be met in research on women’s use of mobile media .
This is the postprint version of: Lim, S. S. (2014). Women, ‘double work’ and mobile media: The more things change, the more they stay the
same. In G. Goggin & L. Hjorth (Eds.) Routledge Companion to Mobile Media (pp. 356-364). London: Routledge.
Women, ‘double work’ and mobile media:
The more things change, the more they stay the same
Sun Sun Lim
Introduction
Lying at the intersections of disciplines such as of gender studies, media and communications,
social psychology, sociology, anthropology and science, technology and society, women’s
engagement with mobile media has been the subject of provocative and innovative research that
have provided as much insight as they have inspired points of reflection. Encouragingly, there
has been significant growth in the diversity of subjects studied over time, from nuclear families
to single parent households, from working adults to the elderly, as well as a widening range of
issues being investigated, including household coordination, family relationships, romantic
partnerships and workplace (dis)empowerment.
Research on women’s use of mobile media has also been largely ordered by their spheres
of existence, namely the home and the workplace, while capturing the rapidly blurring
boundaries between these closely intertwined milieu. Felicitously, even though research on
mobile media use by women has been understandably dominated by regions where ICT
penetration is higher and access more forthcoming, the research landscape has evolved along
with the rapid diffusion of mobile media. Mobile phones in particular, are manufactured for and
marketed to consumers across all socio-economic sectors, making mobile phone ownership
commonplace in both developed and developing countries. Findings are thus emerging from
Asia and the Global South, focusing on hitherto understudied groups such as migrant women
workers and transnational families. Such studies lend depth and diversity to our understanding of
the role of mobile media in women’s performance of domestic duties, focusing as they do on
families which defy conventional classification, whose members are not physically proximate,
and whose ‘away’ and ‘left-behind’ members encounter vastly contrasting levels and quality of
mobile media access.
And yet, as this chapter seeks to elucidate, even as the technological landscape of mobile
media changes with the constant appearance of disruptive technologies such as the recent tablet
phenomenon, the social settings within which women appropriate mobile media remain
fundamentally unaltered. The socio-cultural norms and expectations surrounding women’s roles
in society, as daughters, spouses, mothers and individuals in their own right, are as
circumscribing as they are circumscribed, as can be witnessed in women’s use of mobile media
as they strive to fulfil both familial and professional obligations. As Leopoldina Fortunati
astutely observed, women are more vulnerable than men to the pressure of “double work” - the
challenges of balancing obligations in both the home and the workplace
1
.
Taking women’s navigation of this “double work” environment as the departure point,
this chapter will review how women’s use of mobile media in the home and the workplace has
evolved over the years, while remaining unchanged in particular respects. In so doing, it will
incorporate studies from a range of geographical regions, both developed and developing, thus
capturing the varying social norms which can impinge on women’s engagement with mobile
media. Issues surrounding the duality of mobile media, simultaneously limiting and enabling,
and the shifting, yet persistent, liminalities that women negotiate will also be discussed. The
chapter then concludes with a call for urgent imperatives to be met in research on women’s use
of mobile media.
Home
It must be remembered, however, that cellular telephones are not available to all
economic strata of society, nor are they likely to be. Lana Rakow and Vija Navarro
2
While access to mobile media devices has improved dramatically for all sectors of society from
the early 1990s, when Lana Rakow and Vija Navarro completed their pioneering study of
women’s use of cellular telephones in cars
3
, the ways in which mobile media are incorporated
into the domestic lives of women has not departed that dramatically from their original findings.
Whereas Rakow and Navarro found that women actively used car phones for the micro-
coordination of family schedules and general household management, study after study has since
found that women use the mobile phone and other mobile media for the same because they
continue to bear the brunt of these duties
4
. Indeed, Rakow and Navarro were prescient in
identifying the phenomenon of ‘remote mothering’, a term that is becoming increasingly loaded
as mobile media become more ubiquitous and multi-functional.
Rakow and Navarro’s work also struck an early note of ambivalence, arguing that even as
women appreciated the benefits of the cellular phone, it also served to heighten their sense of
responsibility, establishing an inextricable link to home life that could be burdensome. The
women they interviewed were not too enthused about owning a mobile phone and saw it as more
of an instrumental tool for enhancing their personal safety and their availability to their children.
These reservations were echoed in Sun Sun Lim and Carol Soon’s study of middle-class families
in China and Korea which discovered that mothers are unnerved by the constant connectivity
binding them and their children because mobile communication facilitated “perpetual contact
[that] translated into a state of perpetual concern for their children’s well-being
5
. Robyn
Longhurst’s study of mothers who keep in touch with their children via Skype demonstrates yet
another facet of mediated mothering, where mothers use real-time video to gauge the wellbeing
of children who are away from home, thus extending the boundaries of maternal care
6
.
Most recently, in Lynn Schofield Clark’s The Parent App, she notes that even as
smartphones and their slew of apps are increasingly indispensable in helping parents coordinate
the family’s daily whirr of activities, these gadgets are yet another imposition on parents,
necessitating the constant updating and synchronisation of schedules among all family
members
7
. Hence, while innovations in mobile media have helped women execute their
mothering duties more efficiently and effectively, research suggests that this heightened
connectivity serves to exacerbate rather than alleviate their mothering burden, further ossifying
women’s position in the home as “Mom-in-Chief”
8
.
The same can be said for transnational mothers even though the distance separating them
and their families makes it impractical and impracticable for them to be actively embedded in
family life. Yet, research clearly demonstrates that these women have strategically and
ingeniously deployed a wide range of media to be active mothers even though they are
physically absent from home. They, too, avidly use mobile media to fulfil micro-coordination
and household management duties in creative ways that suit their unique and complicated
personal circumstances. Pierrette Hondagneu-Sotelo and Ernestine Avila’s early study of El
Salvadorian transnational mothers working in the US in the 1990s found that the mothers used
phone calls and letters to express their care and concern, reminding their children to take their
vitamins and to eat regular meals
9
. Academic investigation of migrant women workers has
flourished further since, reflecting an intensification in these women’s use of mobile media as
mobile phones and associated services have become more affordable over time.
10
Cecilia Uy-Tiocos study of Filipinas working in the US provided insights into how these
women wielded considerable authority over their left-behind children, using calls and text
messages to decide on matters large and small, from managing finances to granting permission to
drive the family car
11
. Similarly, Mirca Madianou and Daniel Miller note that Filipino nurses and
domestic workers based in the UK engage in “intensive mothering” through mobile and online
communications, involving themselves in “everyday parenting and micromanaging of their
children’s meals, homework and disciplinary issues”
12
. As Uy-Tioco observes therefore, while
these migrant mothers may have been “masculinised” by their overseas employment and
elevated to the position of economic provider, the connectivity facilitated by phone calls and text
messages continues to relegate them to their traditional mothering roles
13
.
Beyond more instrumental uses of mobile media, extensive research has also been
conducted on women’s use of mobile media for kin keeping—the nurturance of emotional ties
with their significant others. Larissa Hjorth and Sun Sun Lim note that mobile media have a
palpable affective dimension for women, who actively used them to foster feelings of intimacy
with friends and family so as to forge strong(er) relationship bonds.
14
Extant research supports
this observation, with findings from various countries demonstrating that mobile phone calls tend
to be made for social and interpersonal purposes and for managing the family, rather than for
extending work commitments
15
. Notably, based on a large scale survey of Australian mobile
phone users’ habits, Judy Wajcman, Michael Bittman and Judith Brown argue that the mobile
phone bolsters people’s ability to express feelings of intimacy and to nourish relationships
through brief but perpetual and intermittent contact. In particular, they found that women were
more likely to recognise value in maintaining ties with relatives, thus resonating with prior
literature that argues that kin-keeping tasks are fundamentally borne by women
16
. Qualitative
research has fleshed out how women appropriate mobile communications for kin-keeping and
relationship management. Notably, Jo Tacchi, Kathi Kitner and Kate Crawford probed into the
“meaningful mobility” of rural women in India and revealed a concerted effort by women in this
patrilineal society to maintain ties with mothers and daughters from whom they lived apart after
marriage
17
. These women made use of their husbands’ mobile phones when the latter returned
home in the evenings, thereby benefiting from the lower call rates to make what they considered
to be essential connections to their loved ones.
Studies focusing on migrant mothers have also noted how these transnational women
reinforce their love for their families through mobile media, so as to maintain their presence at
home despite the geographical distance. Indeed, Deirdre McKay notes that in the process of
sustaining bonds of intimacy with their loved ones back home, migrants acquire ‘new emotional
grammars’ that are reflected in the communication practices they adopt in their newfound
circumstances, including phoning home whenever they are overwhelmed by homesickness,
remitting money home and servicing bank loans of left-behind family members as a
demonstration of their love.
18
Notably though, Rhacel Salazar Parrenas discovered that unlike
migrant mothers, migrant fathers seem content with maintaining merely instrumental
communication with their families, thus underlining observations that kin-keeping remains a
gendered task
19
.
As well, in particular cultural settings, kin-keeping is slightly more textured in light of
prevailing socio-cultural norms. Lim’s study of Chinese and Korean families’ media use found
that the role- and rule-bound communication in those societies saw mothers using mobile
communications in particularly strategic ways
20
. For example, after an altercation between father
and child, one mother urged her husband to apologise to their child via text messaging so that his
position of authority remained undiminished, while his ‘loss of face’ was avoided. She was thus
able to maintain family harmony while helping to cement her husband’s position as head of the
household. Other women in the study also found their communication options with their loved
ones increased and enhanced as matters that were too awkward to broach in person now found
their voice in faceless text messages. Although research on kin-keeping via ICTs and mobile
media has clearly flourished, it has primarily centred around women between their 20s and 40s
who are in the prime of working adulthood and the throes of active parenthood.
A notable exception is Heather Horst’s study of Jamaican transnational grandmothers
who, after their overseas stints, had mixed feelings about returning to more traditional gender
roles back home. But these women assuaged such feelings of residual resentment by using
mobile phone plans and cards for kin-keeping with family members who were overseas, thereby
actualising themselves to an extent
21
. More recently, Kim Sawchuk and Barbara Crow’s study of
Canadian grandmothers showed how these women seek to overcome the challenges of
generational differences and technological advancements to actively participate in family life
22
.
Their desire to bond with their grandchildren motivates them to adopt otherwise alien and
discomfiting practices such as text messaging, thus drawing them into a circle of mediated
family intimacy from which they would otherwise be excluded.
Besides matters of micro-coordination and relationship management, the enlarged
presence of mobile media in the domestic space has yet another significant implication for
women. Given their greater involvement in home life, women necessarily bear a heftier load in
the supervision of children’s media use
23
. In this regard, a burgeoning body of work has emerged
to question how mobile media presents new issues for parental oversight. Societal expectations
around good parenting increasingly dictate that parents should be more engaged in the lives of
their children, including managing their access to ICTs and mobile media
24
. In particular, the
risk/safety debate tends to underscore parental perceptions of children’s need for personal mobile
phones
25
. This is especially discernible in Japan, where Misa Matsuda’s investigation into
mothers of elementary school children reveals that concerns about children’s safety elide with
notions of maternal responsibility, thus engendering a climate where giving children their own
mobile phones is a must
26
. Again this example vividly highlights the point that as more
electronic devices encroach into the home, the list of duties associated with mothering grows in
length and difficulty.
Furthermore, managing children’s access to mobile media seems but a trifling aspect of
parental supervision when compared to the task of monitoring children’s actual usage of these
devices. In particular, the portability and personally-owned nature of mobile media devices add
complexity to parental mediation because children can use these devices on the go, without being
confined to a fixed location in which adults can impose supervision fairly predictably and
reliably
27
. With personal device ownership, children’s online communications are less
transparent to parents because they have more opportunities to engage in unsupervised peer
interaction, yet are paradoxically more transparent in view of the digital communication trail that
can be revisited and scrutinised. In Lim and Soon’s study of Korean middle-class families, half
the mothers admitted to secretly viewing their children’s mobile phone text messages so as to
better understand their children, but their children eventually realised and resented this
28
. When
monitoring their children’s use of mobile media, mothers have to therefore tread the fine line
between supervision and surveillance and beware of their concern translating into conflict. On
this point, Clark cautions that parents should refrain from surveillance and over-involvement in
their children’s digital communications, and give their children the autonomy to make their own
decisions and acquire life experience
29
. In sum, as mobile media use starts to pervade the
everyday lives of families and introduce unprecedented scenarios for parental oversight, women
who already shoulder the bulk of parenting duties have the added responsibility of coping with
such intractable issues.
Work
“…the fact that labour now escapes spatial and temporal measure poses obvious problems
for defining work limits.” Melissa Gregg
30
While women’s domestic responsibilities have been intensively studied, considerable attention
has also been paid to working women’s use of ICTs to manage work-life balance, without a
correspondingly fervent interest in similar issues for men. This apparent asymmetry can be
attributed to the acknowledgement that women bear a greater domestic burden that is not equally
shared with their male counterparts. As Noelle Chesley evinced through her study exploring the
relationship between information technology use, distress and family satisfaction, both men and
women experienced the negative implications of work demands spilling into family life, but only
women experienced the adverse impact of family demands spilling into work life
31
. Indeed,
Gregg used the term “presence bleed”
32
to capture how women feel compelled to reconcile their
involvement in these overlapping spheres.
Concerns about the growing pressure from managing both personal commitments and
workplace obligations would intensify as ICTs began to be more actively deployed in the
proverbial “new economy” of the late 1990s and early 2000s
33
. At the same time, there was also
optimism that ICTs would help to correct gender inequalities in the labour market because
women could potentially earn higher salaries, enjoy more flexible hours and venture into
independent self-employment
34
. As mobile media began to saturate the workplace from around
the mid-2000s, delivering a further shot in the arm for this new economy, the same concerns
about work-life balance would arise, again answered by hopes of rectifying gender imbalances in
the workplace. The advent of versatile, multi-functional smartphones and portable yet powerful
tablets have further amplified these views, creating perspectival divides on benefits and ills of
being “always on”
35
.
Recent research indicates that women’s strategic appropriation of mobile media and
being “always on” has been both empowering and encumbering. They feel simultaneously
liberated by the enhanced connectivity, while burdened by the heightened, persistent familial
responsibilities that such connectivity sustains. A recent study of Canadian mothers’ use of
smartphone apps by Julie Frizzo-Barker and Peter Chow-White finds these women exploiting an
extensive range of the phone’s affordances to manage their multiple obligations, including using
an app to shut down Internet access so as to minimise distractions, Skype to send text messages
and Dropbox for sharing files with co-workers
36
. While energised by and appreciative of the
smartphone’s many conveniences, these women were also at pains to moderate the pressures that
the phone’s relentless connectivity brought them, strategically managing their availability to their
employers and significant others.
Similarly, Rachel Crowe and Catherine Middleton’s studied female professionals’ use of
the Blackberry to gain insights into how these middle to upper middle class women calibrate
their smartphone use
37
. The younger women in their sample assiduously convey an image of
responsiveness and dependability to their colleagues and superiors by responding promptly to
emails and texts, with some sustaining this “habit of responsibility” even when on vacation. For
them, being available, even at the cost of disruptions to family life is seen as a given, and as
small sacrifices which their families should accept. In contrast, the older women who are also
more established in their careers can afford to be more particular about restricting their
availability to their colleagues, and guard their private time more jealously. The contrasts
between the younger and older women raise serious questions about the “cohort effect” when
these younger professionals attain seniority, will they continue to sustain this level of unbridled
availability and will such practices intensify as mobile media become even more deeply
incorporated into the workplace? Will their expectations percolate to their even younger
subordinates, making the culture of being ‘always-on’ more entrenched? Such questions need to
be pondered as the climate of work-life balance seems to be giving way to one of work-life
merge.
These tensions between empowerment and encumbrance via mobile media are more
pronounced and also more nuanced for transnational women. Heather Horst observed that
improved communication opportunities enabled Jamaicans who worked abroad to be more
sensitive to and well-informed about the grim realities of overseas employment. As well, some
found the pressure of providing support to family members oppressive and managed such
obligations by using caller ID to screen calls from particular individuals
38
. Similarly, Minu
Thomas and Sun Sun Lim’s study of Filipino and Indian female migrant domestic workers in
Singapore found that despite the isolation these women experience as live-in help, unlike those
working in factories who enjoy the company of co-workers, mobile phones ease their solitude by
provide them with a link to their families. However, being constantly connected to family meant
being drawn into everyday affairs and family emergencies which these women found to be
emotionally draining
39
. Madianou and Miller also point to the equivocal position that migrant
women occupy as they struggle to reconcile their love for their left-behind kin, with the esteem
and value they derive from their overseas employment
40
. The constant communication afforded
by mobile and online communications facilitates a more active involvement in family life that
helps them to cope with these feelings of ambivalence and in some cases, gives them the
confidence to prolong their migration. Despite the distinguishing characteristics of this recent
swathe of research, it is notable that the dual pressures of family and work that confront women
resonate with those of earlier studies.
Conclusion
As this chapter has shown, women across all socio economic sectors are appropriating mobile
media with growing intensity, motivated by a confluence of socio-cultural expectations, peer
norms and institutional factors. While not necessarily exacerbating the double work
phenomenon, mobile media has hardly contributed to its alleviation. The thread of double work
has dominated much of the research on women and mobile media and has even persisted and
amplified over time. There is no escaping the richness of empirical evidence from diverse
countries that articulates the emic voice of women, capturing the multitude of stresses they have
to negotiate via their appropriation of mobile media as they fulfil their double duties, in both
proximate and transnational settings. However, it behoves us to ask how the design of mobile
media can be more sensitive to and empathetic of women in these different situations, so that
they can benefit from a greater sense of agency and control as they incorporate mobile media
into their management of work and family. How can children’s media devices be refined to
lighten the load of maternal mediation and supervision? How can mobile phones be further
developed to enable erecting boundaries between one’s personal and professional time? What
innovations in mobile media can we create to mitigate the task of kin-keeping and relationship
management?
Unfortunately, in the design and marketing of technology products, women are typically
scripted to be more preoccupied with the appearance rather than the functions of technological
products, thereby undermining rather than bolstering women’s domestication of technology
41
.
Disturbingly, women have themselves become unwitting accomplices where even those involved
in the technology industry have been known to adopt a gender- and class-biased script in
designing technology for other women
42
. To put a brake to this self-perpetuating cycle that
would otherwise determine that “the more things change, the more they stay the same”, we need
to heed the call to shift our research energies away from consumption
43
to more aggressively
investigate the links between gender relations and design and infocomm policy, and put the
needs of women at the forefront of design imperatives
44
. Failing which, as mobile media
becomes ever more potent and ubiquitous, the opportunity for women to be empowered with and
through their adoption of mobile media will be ripe, yet unmaximized.
Notes
1
Leopoldina Fortunati, “Gender and the mobile phone, “ in Gerard Goggin and Larissa Hjorth, eds., Mobile
Technologies: From Telecommunications to Media (New York: Routledge, 2009), 23-36.
2
Lana Rakow and Vija Navarro, “Remote mothering and the parallel shift: women meet the cellular telephone,”
Critical Studies in Mass Communication 10(2), 1993: 155.
3
Lana Rakow and Vija Navarro, “Remote mothering and the parallel shift: women meet the cellular telephone,”
Critical Studies in Mass Communication 10(2), 1993: 144-157.
4
Judy Wajcman, Michael Bittman and Judith E. Brown, Families without borders: mobile phones, connectedness
and workhome divisions,Sociology 42(4), 2008: 635-652.; Valerie A. J. Frissen, “ICTs in the rush hour of life,The
Information Society: An International Journal 16(1), 2000: 6-75.; Rich Ling, The Mobile Connection: The Cell
Phone’s Impact on Society (Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2004); Rich Ling and Leslie Haddon, “Mobile telephony, mobility
and the coordination of everyday life, “ in James Katz, ed., Machines that Become Us: The Social
Context of Personal Communication Technology (New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction, 2003), 245-266.
5
Sun Sun Lim and Carol Soon, “The influence of social and cultural factors on mothers' domestication of household
ICTs - experiences of Chinese and Korean women,” Telematics and Informatics 27 (3), 2010: 205-216.
6
Longhurst, Robyn, "Using Skype to Mother: Bodies, Emotions, Visuality, and Screens," Environment and Planning
D: Society and Space 31(4 ), 2013: 664-79.
7
Lynn Schofield Clark, The Parent App: Understanding Families In The Digital Age (New York: Oxford University
Press, 2013).
8
This term was famously used by Michelle Obama, the First Lady of the United States, in a speech she made during
President Barack Obama’s campaign for a second presidential term in September 2012. She used “Mom-in-Chief”
to describe her position in her household as primary caregiver to their children, as opposed to President Barack
Obama’s role as Commander-in-Chief of the United State Armed Forces. Her use of the term was widely criticized
by feminists for limiting women’s role in society to that of managing the domestic realm. See Amanda Marcotte,
“On Mom-in-Chief” The American Prospect, September 6, 2012. Accessed January 26, 2013.
http://prospect.org/article/mom-chief.
9
Pierrette Hondagneu-Sotelo and Ernestine Avila, “I’m here, but I’m there: The meanings of Latina transnational
motherhood,” Gender & Society 11(5), 1997: 548-571.
10
Steven Vertovec, “Cheap calls: The social glue of migrant transnationalism,” Global Networks 4(2): 2004: 219
224.
11
Cecila Uy-Tioco, “Overseas Filipino workers and text messaging: Reinventing transnational mothering,”
Continuum: Journal of Media & Cultural Studies 21(2), 2007: 253-265.
12
Mirca Madianou and Daniel Miller, “Mobile phone parenting: Reconfiguring relationships between Filipina
migrant mothers and their left-behind children,” New Media & Society 13(3), 2011: 457-470.
13
Cecila Uy-Tioco, “Overseas Filipino workers and text messaging: Reinventing transnational mothering,”
Continuum: Journal of Media & Cultural Studies 21(2), 2007: 253-265.
14
Larissa Hjorth and Sun Sun Lim, “Women and mobile intimacy in an age of social media and affective
technology,” Feminist Media Studies 12(4), 2012: 477-484.
15
'Judy Wajcman, Michael Bittman and Jude Brown, “Families without borders: mobile phones, connectedness and
work-home divisions,” Sociology 42(4),2008: 635-652.; Dafna Lemish and Akiba A. Cohen, “On the gendered nature
of mobile phone culture in Israel, “Sex Roles 52(7/8), 2005: 511-521.
16
Ann Moyal, “The gendered use of the telephone: an Australian case study, “ Media, Culture & Society 14(1),
1992: 5172.; Lana Rakow, Gender on the Line. Women, the Telephone, and Community Life (Chicago: University of
Illinois Press, 1992).
17
Jo Tacchi, Kathi R. Kitner and Kate Crawford, “Meaningful mobility: Gender, development and mobile phones, “
Feminist Media Studies 12(4), 528-537.
18
McKay, Deirdre, “’Sending Dollars Shows Feeling’ – Emotions and Economies in Filipino Migration." Mobilities
2(2), 2007: 175-94.
19
Rhacel Salazar Parrenas , “Long distance intimacy: Class, gender and intergenerational relations between
mothers and children in Filipino transnational families, “ Global Networks 5(4), 2005: 317336.
20
Sun Sun Lim, “Technology domestication in the Asian homestead: comparing the experiences of middle class
families in China and South Korea,” East Asian Science, Technology and Society 2 (2), 2008: 189-209
21
Horst, Heather A., "Grandmothers, Girlfriends and Big Men: The Gendered Geographies of Jamaican
Transnational Communication." In Leopoldina Fortunati, Raul Pertierra and Jane Vincent, eds., Migration, Diaspora
and Information Technology in Global Societies (New York: Routledge, 2011), 65-76.
22
Kim Sawchuk and Barbara Crow, “’I’m G-mom on the phone: Remote grandmothering, cell phones and inter-
generational dis/connections, “ Feminist Media Studies 12(4), 496-505.
23
See for example Shingo Dobashi, “The gendered use of keitai in domestic contexts,” in Mizuko Ito, Daisuke
Okabe and Misa Matsuda, eds., Personal, Portable, Pedestrian : Mobile Phones in Japanese Life (Cambridge, MA:
MIT, 2006), 219-236.
24
Nicola Green and Leslie Haddon, Mobile Communications: An Introduction to New Media (Oxford: Berg, 2009)
25
Rich Ling and Birgitte Yttri, "Hyper-coordination via mobile phones in Norway, " in James Katz and Mark Aakhus,
eds., Perpetual Contact: Mobile Communication, Private Talk, Public Performance (Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, 2002).
26
Misa Matsuda, “Children with Keitai : When Mobile Phones Change from “Unnecessary” to “Necessary”, “ East
Asian Science, Technology & Society 2(2), 2008: 167-188.
27
Hee Jhee Jiow and Sun Sun Lim, “ The evolution of video games and growing challenges for parental mediation, “
Bulletin of Science, Technology & Society 32(6), 2012: 452 459.
28
Sun Sun Lim and Carol Soon, “The influence of social and cultural factors on mothers' domestication of
household ICTs - experiences of Chinese and Korean women,” Telematics and Informatics 27 (3), 2010: 205-216.
29
Lynn Schofield Clark, The Parent App: Understanding Families In The Digital Age (New York: Oxford University
Press, 2013).
30
Melissa Gregg, The normalisation of flexible female labour in the information economy, “ Feminist Media
Studies 8(3), 2008: 285-299.
31
Noelle Chesley, Blurring Boundaries? Linking Technology Use, Spillover, Individual Distress and Family
Satisfaction,” Journal of Marriage and Family 67, 2005: 1237-1248.
32
Melissa Gregg, The normalisation of flexible female labour in the information economy, “ Feminist Media
Studies 8(3), 2008: 285-299.
33
Manuel Castells, “Materials for an exploratory theory of the network society,” British Journal of Sociology, 51(1),
2000: 524; Martin Carnoy, M. Sustaining the New Economy: Work, Family, and Community in the
Information Age (New York: Russell Sage Foundation, 2000).
34
Diane Perron, “The new economy and the worklife balance: conceptual explorations and a case study of new
media,” Gender, Work & Organization 10(1), 2003:6593.
35
Sherry Turkle, “The Tethered/Untethered Self,” in James Katz, ed., Handbook of Mobile Communication Studies
(Cambridge, MIT Press, 2008), 121-138.
36
Julie Frizzo-Barker and Peter Chow-White, “’There’s an app for that’: mediating the mobile moms and the
connected careerists through smartphones and networked individualism,” Feminist Media Studies 12(4), 2012:
580-589.
37
Rachel Crowe and Catherine Middleton, “Women, smartphones and the workplace: pragmatic realities and
performative identities,” Feminist Media Studies 12(4), 2012: 560-569.
38
Horst, Heather A., "The Blessings and Burdens of Communication: Cell Phones in Jamaican Transnational Social
Fields," Global Networks 6( 2), 2006: 143-59.
39
Minu Thomas and Sun Sun Lim, "On Maids and Mobile Phones: ICT Use by Female Migrant Workers in Singapore
and Its Policy Implications," in James Everett Katz, ed., Mobile Communication: Dimensions of Social Policy (New
Brunswick: Transaction Publishers, 2011), 175-190.
40
Mirca Madianou and Daniel Miller, Migration and New Media: Transnational Families and Polymedia (London:
Routledge, 2011)
41
Leslie Regan Shade, “Feminizing the mobile: Gender scripting of mobiles in North America, “ Continuum: Journal
of Media and Cultural Studies 21(2), 2007:179-189.
42
Els Rommes, “Creating places for women on the internet: the design of a “women’s square” in a digital city,” The
European Journal of Women’s Studies 9(4), 2002: 400429.
43
Judy Wajcman, “Reflections on Gender and Technology Studies: In What State is the Art?,” Social Studies of
Science 30(3), 2000: 447-464.
44
Micky Lee, “What's Missing In Feminist Research In New Information And Communication Technologies?,”
Feminist Media Studies, 6(2), 2006: 191-210.
... Para Chesley (2005) la relación entre trabajo y hogar produce un desbalance que afecta sobre todo a la mujer. Lim (2014) definirá esta situación de convivencia paralela entre el escenario laboral y el familiar, como "doble trabajo", lo que ya había sido definido tempranamente por Rakow (1992), para quien el teléfono móvil permitirá a la mujer, participar simultáneamente en el mundo del trabajo y en el mundo doméstico. Este desbalance, como lo señala Gregg (2011), implica que las plataformas móviles y online están presentes de forma ineludible en las actividades laborales y de hogar, permeando los entornos físicos y psicológicos de la mujer. ...
... En un contexto de persistencia del concepto, aún más en la medida en que los dispositivos móviles han sido cada vez más ubicuos y funcionales (Lim, 2014), Longhurst (2013) describe en su estudio de la plataforma Skype, cómo esta permite a las madres ejercer la maternidad remota con sus hijos, en períodos largos fuera de casa debido a obligaciones laborales. Incluso el concepto es perceptible en los estudios de la familia transnacional; con madres que supervisan la alimentación de los hijos (Madianou, 2012), gestionan el manejo del dinero de estos (Uy-Tioco, 2007), llaman a casa para saber si hijas e hijos se encuentran a determinada hora en casa (Chib et al., 2014) o para despertarles por la mañana, ayudarles en las tareas y hasta determinar el tipo de juegos de video que utilizan (Madianou y Miller, 2011). ...
... El cuidado de los familiares y seres queridos en muchas ocasiones se encuentra presente también en las tareas de coordinación, así como la demostración expresa de afecto (Tacchi et al., 2012;Lim, 2014). Estas funciones sociales contribuirían a mantener a la familia unida durante el día al encontrarse fuera de casa (Wei y Lo, 2006;Hermida y Casas-Mas, 2020) y pueden presentarse como una mediación tecnológica de la autoridad paterna, que se expresa en el cuidado de los hijos a través de familiares (Tacchi et al., 2012), así como una expresión de cuidado de la familia con énfasis en usos marcadamente distintos en relación con los hombres (Sreekumar, 2011). ...
Article
Full-text available
This research aimed to learn how mothers use smartphones, in the city of Valparaíso —the main Chilean port city. In a context of high penetration of mobile devices, the lack of empirical studies that delve into the use and appropriation of mobile technologies and their impact and influence in mothers’ daily life motivated this research work. The research design was based on a qualitative, non-experimental, cross-sectional, exploratory, and descriptive study. Five focus groups were conducted in the city of Valparaíso, along with five semi-structured interviews with participants selected from the focus groups. Fieldwork was carried out between October and December 2019 and January 2020, in the context of the mobilizations under the so-called "social outbreak," with a conspicuous representation of feminist groups. Content analysis was performed with its findings aligned to the data gathered in the focus groups between October and December 2019. The main finding of the study shows prevalent presence of mobile phones in all the stages of upbringing and mother-child relationship, even before birth and early pregnancy stages.
... Although these idealised expectations of intensive mothering are unrealistic, mothers expend considerable efforts trying to meet these conditions to avoid being perceived as a bad mother. As Huppatz and Goodwin (2010) workplace, yet on the other hand, this 'double-work' (Lim 2014) can enslave mothers and make them feel pressured to be always available (Madianou & Miller 2012;Pascaul 2016, p. 151;Sowon et al. 2019). In both instances, digital media use implies an intensification of the mothering experience. ...
... However, the persistent merging of professional and private time can also leave mothers feeling encumbered by expectations of being available 24/7 which can destabilise the work-life balance (Lim 2014;Rose 2017;Sowon et al. 2019). Whilst smartphones were found to support mothers' participation in the workforce, the study revealed that their use for work-related purposes also impinged on the quality of time they spent with children in the home, thus producing an additional empowerment/enslavement paradox for mothers (Sowon et al. 2019). ...
... As other research shows, mothers who use the phone for parenting whilst engaged in paid work undertake a 'parallel shift' (Rakow & Navarro 1993) or 'double-work' (Lim 2014) in their attempt to balance professional and maternal roles. Mothers who blog about their children are transforming their personal narratives of struggle and challenge into interactive conversations with other mothers, and in so doing, are beginning to expand our notion of motherhood, women bloggers and the mother's place within the public sphere. ...
Thesis
Mothers are both users of digital media and facilitators of children’s use, yet little research has explored how these intersecting points of digital interaction shape their mothering experience. This thesis explored how the growing importance placed on digital media use for everyday societal functions impacts the role and experience of mothering in the home. Qualitative interviews with mothers revealed that changes in the digital learning practices of schools, and the need to maintain a digital umbilical cord with children, increased ownership and use of digital devices in the home. Time-poverty was alleviated and exacerbated by mother’s own use of digital media and intensified by the need to manage children’s use. The study concludes that contemporary mothering manifests as digital mothering, a state that is experienced and interceded through complex interactions with digital media in the home.
... In his study, Kyle (2000) finds that Ecuadorian male migrants in New York and Europe deliberately restrict the information they share about their migrant lives with their left-behind wives and families as a strategy of gender control to maintain their sense of masculinity. It is clear from extensive research that the transnationalisation of familial intimacy has not substantially altered gender norms and relations in the familial institution (Lim, 2014;Parreñas, 2015). ...
Chapter
In this chapter, we develop the ‘transnationalisation of intimacy’ as a conceptual lens to investigate the performance, embodiment and negotiation of transnational familial intimacy in a globalising and digital society. This is achieved by conducting a state-of-the-art review of theories and empirical studies on family relations and practices at the intersection of structural and technological forces in a transnational context. We first show that intimate family practices are engendered and undermined by mobility regimes and infrastructures. We then illuminate how communicative practices pave the way for transnational linkages but in an unequal manner, especially when material and symbolic forces are embedded in an unequal terrain. Finally, we consider the implications of transnationalism for (de)normalising family relations and practices, in creating distinctive, new transnational forms of familial intimacy. This chapter draws attention to the mutually constitutive nature of transnationalism and changing family relations and practices in a global and digital age.
... On the one hand, mediated communication offers new and effective approaches to expressing affection and building intimate relationships (Clark, 2012;Licoppe, 2004;Wajcman et al., 2008). On the other hand, the wealth of technological affordances may also cause emotional burdens and impair rather than nurture intimacies (Lim, 2014;Lim and Soon, 2009;Madianou and Miller, 2012;Turkle, 2011). ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper critically examines how 15 aging Filipina Australians in Victoria, Australia use mobile devices and online channels in their everyday care practices. Deploying in-depth interviews and visual methods, the study unravels the diverse modes of mobile care practices, including caring for oneself and for local and transnational networks. We apply an intersectional lens to identify and scrutinize the contradictory outcomes of mobile care work as shaped by interconnected axes of structural and digital inequality. The findings reveal the paradoxical and multifaceted experiences of these older Filipina Australians in embodying mobile care practices. We find that through mutually reinforcing factors, including gendered duties, familial responsibilities, economic and citizenship status, and digital access and abilities, care work is made easier yet is also made more imperative. These factors position our respondents unequally in the digital care landscape, highlighting the centrality of intersectionality in understanding their care experiences. This paper contributes to the literature on the intersections of digital media, migration, and care by illuminating the gendered dimensions of mobile care work and its significance to transnational caregiving practices.
Chapter
Faced with the multifaceted challenges of modern motherhood, more women are gravitating toward online forums such as Reddit to seek support. The inherent anonymity of such platforms helps to create safe virtual spaces where women can openly share their concerns and participate in dialogues about sensitive topics without the burden of judgment or stigma. This book chapter delves into the exchanges that populate these digital spaces to offer fresh insights into the collective work-life experiences of working mothers in Singapore as they navigate the challenges of balancing their professional and familial roles. A thematic analysis of 10 most related discussion threads sourced from 2 Singapore-focused subreddit communities was conducted. The uneven distribution of mental load of mothers to the dilemmas, conflicts, and societal judgements around full-time working parenthood and outsourcing childcare to others emerged as salient themes. Overall, our findings reveal the stubborn influence of traditional gender norms and unrealistic societal expectations placed on working parents, especially mothers, in Singapore. Nevertheless, there is clear evidence of peer affirmation and digitally enabled solidarity that demonstrates the social shaping of these digital domains as virtual circles of support.
Article
Full-text available
As primary carers of children, mothers provide a central role in mediating and negotiating children's digital media use in the home. In parental mediation research, this work is often reported with a gender-neutral tone, implying both parents play an equal role. This study challenges this bias by unmasking the mediation practices and experiences of mothers. Qualitative interviews revealed mediation is bound by maternal desires to protect, guide and educate children in their media use. The intensity of this care role, often conducted in parallel with other unpaid and paid work, also leads mothers to deploy self-satisfying strategies that facilitate repose. The study illustrates how the gendered role and experience of mothering influences the mediation strategies mothers' use and argues for broader recognition of these nuanced practices in parental mediation research. It also discusses the implications and impact of parental mediation on the unpaid digital care work of mothers.
Article
In this article, I argue that while smartphones can increase women's capacities to act for themselves and others, smartphones can also act agentially in the interests of corporations and limit women's capacity to act. To make this argument, I consider the value of Rosi Braidotti's [2019. Posthuman Knowledge. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press] posthuman knowledge theory of ‘affirmative ethics’ for understanding women's relationships with their smartphones. Applying a posthuman lens shows how the smartphone can increase women's capacities to affect and be affected [Gatens and Lloyd. 1999 Gatens, Moira, and Genevieve Lloyd. 1999. Collective Imaginings: Spinoza, Past and Present. New York: Routledge. [Google Scholar]. Collective Imaginings: Spinoza, Past and Present. New York: Routledge]. However, this potential for positive feelings or relations must be considered in light of how the agency of the smartphone itself may interrupt these capacities through data sharing, targeted advertising and other capitalist practices. I argue that we must situate smartphone as part of the messy, incomplete and ongoing process of trying to live well and ethically in the present moment.
Chapter
This chapter examines the role of mobile media in Korean kirogi (wild goose, 기러기) families, a distinct kind of transnational migrant family that splits their household for a temporary period of 6 months to more than 10 years so that the children can be educated in an English-speaking country. Typically, dual-continent households, they consist of a mother and children living in an English-speaking country while the father lives on his own in Korea, sending money to support and maintain their lifestyle. This chapter looks particularly at mobile media’s role in the place-making of these kirogi families. Through an examination of two distinct Korean communities in Northern Virginia in the USA, I show that these technologies play a key role in enabling the achievement of familial goals regarding children’s education, transforming conceptions of family, and cultivating a sense of belonging and community for kirogi mothers. All in all, I underscore how mobile media play an important role in place-making for transnational families like the kirogi.
Conference Paper
Globally, there is a gross shortage of professionals in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM) field due to several factors including scarcity of graduates with STEM skills, lack of qualified technicians, loss of high skilled STEM professionals, untapped pools of STEM talent at primary and secondary school level, limited STEM training infrastructure and lack of human capital in learning institutions and limited funding on STEM subjects. The purpose of this study was to investigate the adoption and use of Free and Open Source Software in teaching and learning R-programming language in high schools. The questionnaire was used to collect quantitative data and results were analyzed using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences. The findings of the study revealed the following: i) the availability of computers in private and public schools will assist in the adoption of FOSS ii) the popular use of commercialized/proprietary software in high schools will affect the adoption of FOSS iii) the interest of high school students in computer programming will expedite the adoption of FOSS iii) lack of personal computers at home in schools will have a negative effect on the adoption of FOSS. Therefore, the study seeks to recommend the use of Free and Open Source Software to teach computer programming in the primary and secondary school to incentivize STEM innovation, and inspiring STEM culture, thereby equipping pupils and students with software programming skills. The teaching and learning of computer programming in secondary school curriculum should be a joint and collective effort between all interested stakeholders including the government authorities, the Ministry of Education and Training, teachers, learners, higher learning institutions and also captains of the industry to ensure smooth adoption and implementation
Article
Full-text available
This paper explores the ways that a sample of professional women use smartphones to manage their personal activities and work responsibilities. It reveals a number of specific, mindful practices used to convey and enable accessibility, professionalism and responsiveness to colleagues and clients, showing how smartphones are used to shape and maintain professional identities. At the same time, women also choose to set boundaries to ensure that the immediacy enabled by their smartphones does not encroach upon their personal relationships in undesirable or unpredictable ways, and to allow them to choose when to engage with work while outside the office. The paper reveals the nuances of smartphone use in this group of women, demonstrating various approaches to managing a potentially disruptive communications device to professional and personal advantage.
Chapter
Full-text available
This paper explores ICT use by Indian and Filipino female migrant workers who are employed as live-in maids in Singapore through ethnographic interviews with twenty women. Their particular employment circumstances translate into a circumscribed and isolated living and working experience which makes their access and use of ICTs even more significant. Our findings show that these women employ a variety of technologies for everyday communication, including letters, the mobile phone and the Internet, with the mobile phone being the most crucial communication device for most of them. Mobile communications enable them to foster emotional links with their friends and family, grow their social networks and afford them greater autonomy in seeking better job opportunities and the management of their personal matters. The paper concludes by making three policy recommendations aimed at improving ICT access for migrant workers. First, upon arrival in their host countries, all migrant workers should be educated about the access, use and cost of different communication devices and services available to them. Second, contracts between employers and migrant workers should have clear provisions for the employees’ rights to communication and specifically, mobile communications. Third, governments, nongovernmental organisations and the private sector should actively seek to narrow the technological divide between migrant workers’ home and host countries so that these workers’ communications with individuals and organisations in their home countries are not impeded
Article
Full-text available
The ubiquitous use of mobile smartphones and Internet-based applications commonly known as “apps,” can be viewed as simultaneously empowering and constraining for women's experiences and identities due to their potential to foster “always on” forms of sociability in both public and private spheres. We conduct in-depth interviews with women who daily use smartphone apps to understand how they use and make meaning through social media and popular apps to do with parenting (using the “Total Baby” app), fitness (“Runmeter”), finances (“Mint”) and daily tasks (“Evernote”) through Judy Wajcman's technofeminist approach, which suggests that people and artifacts co-evolve, and technology can facilitate and restrain gender power relations.
Article
Full-text available
In this paper we explore development, gender and technology through a focus on mobile phones and examples of their everyday use by rural women in India. We introduce ways in which technologies might be thought about in terms of “meaningful mobilities” by discussing attachments, structures of labour, agency and specifically how mobiles are an active agent in complex and evolving gendered relationships.
Article
This research examines how a group of mothers in Hamilton, Aotearoa New Zealand are developing and maintaining emotional and familial links with their children of a variety of ages via video calls using Skype. More specifically it seeks to deepen understanding of how seeing one's child or children as part of the communication affects mothers' feelings towards their children. The research is informed by Sara Ahmed's work on 'queer phenomenology' and the 'cultural politics of emotions', which enabled a critical engagement on mothers' and children's embodied and emotional relationships via screens that convey 'real-time' images. Interviews with thirty-five mothers, twenty-four of whom use Skype to contact their children or maintain contact with their own mothers, revealed that the dwelling places of bodies are no longer just rooms in homes where mothers, and children's flesh and emotions rub up against each other on a daily basis but screens across which voices and, even more importantly, images are shared. More than half the mothers who were interviewed reported that using Skype with real-time video to see their children reduced feelings of distance. They also reported that 'seeing' their child or children enables them to assess their children's well-being more accurately. In this way the computer screen, as object, by portraying moving visual images, is 'reorientating' mothers' and children's bodies offering a seemingly closer physical and emotional proximity than in the past.
Book
Ninety-five percent of American kids have Internet access by age 11; the average number of texts a teenager sends each month is well over 3,000. More families report that technology makes life with children more challenging, not less, as parents today struggle with questions previous generations never faced: Is my thirteen-year-old responsible enough for a Facebook page? What will happen if I give my nine year-old a cell phone? In The Parent App, Clark provides what families have been sorely lacking: smart, sensitive, and effective strategies for coping with the dilemmas of digital and mobile media in modern life. Clark set about interviewing scores of mothers and fathers, identifying not only their various approaches, but how they differ according to family income. Parents in upper-income families encourage their children to use media to enhance their education and self-development and to avoid use that might distract them from goals of high achievement. Lower income families, in contrast, encourage the use of digital and mobile media in ways that are respectful, compliant toward parents, and family-focused. Each approach has its own benefits and drawbacks, and whatever the parenting style or economic bracket, parents experience anxiety about how to manage new technology. With the understanding of a parent of teens and the rigor of a social scientist, she tackles a host of issues, such as family communication, online predators, cyber bullying, sexting, gamer drop-outs, helicopter parenting, technological monitoring, the effectiveness of strict controls, and much more. The Parent App is more than an advice manual. As Clark admits, technology changes too rapidly for that. Rather, she puts parenting in context, exploring the meaning of media challenges and the consequences of our responses--for our lives as family members and as members of society.
Article
We explore how a diverse group of grandparents, mostly grandmothers, use the cell phone to interact with their grandchildren. Through “remote” grandparenting seniors found ways into relationships with their grandchildren like many of them had experienced as grandchildren and simultaneously provided insightful commentary on changing communication relations.
Article
The Philippines is an intensely migrant society with an annual migration of one million people, leading to over a tenth of the population working abroad. Many of these emigrants are mothers who often have children left behind. Family separation is now recognized as one of the social costs of migration affecting the global south. Relationships within such transnational families depend on long-distance communication and there is an increasing optimism among Filipino government agencies and telecommunications companies about the consequences of mobile phones for transnational families. This article draws on comparative research with UK-based Filipina migrants — mainly domestic workers and nurses — and their left-behind children in the Philippines. Our methodology allowed us to directly compare the experience of mothers and their children. The article concludes that while mothers feel empowered that the phone has allowed them to partially reconstruct their role as parents, their children are significantly more ambivalent about the consequences of transnational communication.