... The theory of over-water dispersal is enjoying growing popularity among biogeographers, neontologists, and palaeontologists (de Queiroz, 2005(de Queiroz, , 2014Van den Hoek Ostende, Meijer & van der Geer, 2009;Ali & Huber, 2010;Van der Geer et al., 2010;Balme, 2013;Ceríaco et al., 2015;Hofman et al., 2015Hofman et al., , 2016Leppard, 2015;Taylor, Myers & Hoffman, 2015;Van der Geer, Anastasakis & Lyras, 2015;Anderson et al., 2016;Beard, 2016;Duggins et al., 2016;Holcomb, 2016;O'Dea et al., 2016;Carlton et al., 2017Carlton et al., , 2018Duffy & Vargas, 2018;Palombo, 2018). However, doubts are beginning to emerge (MacPhee & Iturralde-Vinent, 2005;Tattersall, 2006Tattersall, , 2008Alonso, Crawford & Bermingham, 2011;Heads, 2015), especially concerning homeotherms such as mammals (Masters, De Wit & Asher, 2006;Stankiewicz et al., 2006;Masters, Lovegrove & De Wit, 2007;Mazza et al., 2013;Mazza, 2014Mazza, , 2015. Over-sea dispersal is plausible only if intricate networks of variables are coordinated and various conditions satisfied. ...