ArticlePDF Available

Protective Clothing’s Function and Application - Analysis of Outdoor Protective Clothing Design and Comfort Performance

Trans Tech Publications Ltd
Advanced Materials Research
Authors:

Abstract

Function and comfort are the main two aspects of outdoor protective clothing design. Outdoor clothing industry market has grown rapidly in recent years. There exists a strong market competation in apparel industry. Satisfaction in consumer's demands is the crucial. In this paper, the trends of demands from four aspects factors were analyzed. Thses trends include potential consumer's market; consumer's aesthetic and fit demands, functions and fashion construction design demands, optimization construction design and wear comfort demands. Optimization construction design directly impacts air gap size and distribution, the air gap layers between skin and clothing is determined by clothing construction design. 3D scanning provides a novel method to visualize and quantify the air gaps. But optimization construction design need more experiences and tests.
Protective Clothing’s Function and Application
——Analysis of Outdoor Protective Clothing Design and Comfort
Performance
Chunyan Wu
1, a
, Guowen Song
1, b
, Changfeng Qu
2, c
and Lanbin Xu
1, d
1
Department of Fashion Design and Engineering, College of Quartermaster Technology Jilin
University, China
2
Department of Engineering and Technology Changchun, China
a
wucy@jlu.edu.cn,
b
guowen.song@ales.ualberta.ca,
c
2234929241@qq.com,
d
xlb822@163.com
Keywords: outdoor clothing, protective clothing, design, comfort, function, construction, air gap,
aesthetic, fit.
Abstract.
Function and comfort are the main two aspects of outdoor protective clothing design.
Outdoor clothing industry market has grown rapidly in recent years. There exists a strong market
competation in apparel industry. Satisfaction in consumer's demands is the crucial. In this paper, the
trends of demands from four aspects factors were analyzed. Thses trends include potential consumer's
market; consumer's aesthetic and fit demands, functions and fashion construction design demands,
optimization construction design and wear comfort demands. Optimization construction design
directly impacts air gap size and distribution, the air gap layers between skin and clothing is
determined by clothing construction design. 3D scanning provides a novel method to visualize and
quantify the air gaps. But optimization construction design need more experiences and tests.
Introduction
Outdoor protective clothing requires functional features to protect human body from different weather
conditions, such as low temperature, or high wind conditions. Normally, functional garments
emphasize more on functional properties and less aesthetics properties. They can be active
sportswear, coveralls, medical wear, personal protective garments, and smart garments. In order to
achieve functions, garments are made from special fabric, it may come with a specific finishing, or
laminating. The fibre used for these fabrics are normally high performance fiber, such as Kevlar,
Nanofibres, spandex blends, and speciality fibres like bamboo[1]. There are different functional
constructions in different functional garments. Fabric can be joined by sewing, bonding and seam
welding technique, and some functional garments are made seamless design in order to increase its
function performance, such as special match swimming suit. In addition to these functions, outdoor
clothing also requires high aesthetic properties. Outdoor clothing is used to protect the human body
from cold, hot and huge wind, in order to achieve comfort under various weather conditions,
appropriate designed outdoor clothing should be worn. In cold weather condition the outdoor
protective clothing should be provide enough thermal insulation, and keep thermal balance of the heat
production and heat loss from the human body. The outdoor protective clothing should have good
water vapor permeability to ensure that the water vapor produced by the body can be easily
disseminated through the clothing system. Therefore, the human body regulates temperature
effectively through the evaporation of perspiration [2]. Different outdoor activities need to wear
associated garments.
The demands of outdoor protective clothing design.
1.1 Outdoor protective clothing has an enormous potential market and consumers. The
market of outdoor industry products continued to grow rapidly in recent years. According to market
survey, from 2006 to 2009, industry sales of outdoor products has maintained growth of more than
30% in China, mainly by the clothing, footwear, backpacks and other outdoor supplies[3]. In 2006,
Advanced Materials Research Online: 2012-12-27
ISSN: 1662-8985, Vol. 627, pp 581-584
doi:10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMR.627.581
© 2013 Trans Tech Publications, Switzerland
All rights reserved. No part of contents of this paper may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means without the written permission of Trans
Tech Publications, www.ttp.net. (#71038772, Iowa State University, Ames, USA-04/11/16,02:27:37)
the sales of outdoor products were only 15 billion in China, and in 2009 however, it had reached
nearly 50 million. In the Asia Outdoor Show, the exhibition scale exceeded 30,000 square meters, an
increase of more than 20% in 2009, with 321 foreign and domestic exhibitors’ brands. According to
data statistics, Asia Outdoor Trade Fair in terms of exhibition scale, brand or professional audience
participation quantity, have been maintained the growth rate for more than 15% average annual. In 3
years time Asia Outdoor Trade Fair has reached a five year European scale in outdoor exhibition. Asia
Outdoor launched the first industrial design awards in 2010, in order to seek to deepen the green,
green ideas, for the best original designs on display platform to promote the brand outside of China
development from the "Asian" to "Asia to create" change[4]. In North America, outdoor apparel has
grown 19% from 2004 to 2010, and it is expected that it will go with this trend to 2016[5]. For the
market in Europe, future growth is forecasted at 18%. Performance outdoor apparel has gradually
increased its share of the total active sportswear market from 3.4% in 2004 to 3.8% in 2010. By 2016
it is expected to be 4.1% of active sportswear [5]. Outdoor gear retail sales were shown in Fig.1 [6].
Fig.1, Outdoor Gear Retail Sales, (Source: China Outdoor Commerce Alliance)
1.2 Aesthetic and fit demands of outdoor protective clothing to the consumer. Clothing
function is involved practicality, society and aesthetic. Currently people focus on not only the
practicality and society of clothing, but also aesthetics properties of garments. Aesthetics, fit and
function of outdoor protective clothing are the crucial elements in the outdoor clothing market
competition. It consists of color, style material, lines, mass, integrity and balance etc. People have
different tastes in style and color. It is believed to a big challenge to every designer to meet the
aesthetic and functional needs of the consumer. The designer and engineer must capture the
significant relationship of clothing and body and must understand the nuances of body measurements
if we are to achieve apparel with satisfactory fit. The good fit is a crucial factor in the acceptance or
rejection of clothing [7]. Studies indicate that as high as 62% in men and 50% in women are
dissatisfaction with the fit of clothing. In another report that about 50% of younger women and up to
70% of older American women are dissatisfied with apparel fit [8] [9]. Fit is first evaluated by
manufacturers and consumers assess aesthetics and comfort prior to purchase. The fit of garment
involves multiple factors, including the dimensions and drape of the garment, size, proportions,
posture of the wearer, current fit fashion, style, function of garment, fit preference of the wearers [10].
Traditional fit is defined as five factors: line, grain, ease, set and balance [11]. Current fit is a complex
factor. The critical elements for fit include aesthetics, fashion trend, understanding consumer’s
preferences, psychology and the purposes and functions of particular garments [12].
1.3 Combination of functions and fashion construction design. Functional construction design
can provide comfort properties. Fashion construction design can be successfully satisfaction in
garment fit and aesthetic. With the people’s increasing of living level and protective awareness, the
trends for function garment are increasing and at the same time the sophisticated new technology and
equipment are available to the clothing industry for garment functions. Apparel industry has a quickly
582 Advances in Textile Engineering and Materials
development and the demands of outdoor protective clothing are gradually increased. The consumers'
demands are not only focused on function and comfort, but also concerned fit, aesthetic idea and
popular trend. Especially they have a critical view to choose outdoor protective clothing. It is a
challenge to designer and textile engineer [13]. Clothing structure design must satisfy the functional
demands and the freedom of human movement. Such as, ventilation (opening) design can dissipate
excess to body heat into the environment, and can reduce the discomfort of wear [14]. The clothing
ventilation (opening) design has two categories: nature ventilation at location of neck, waist, wrist,
ankles; special ventilation openings inserted in a clothing system like pit zips, pockets, venting back
[15]. Combination of functional and fashion construction design is a significant factor that determine
the relationship of market's supply and demand of outdoor clothing.
Optimization construction design and wear comfort of outdoor protective clothing.
Clothing comfort is influenced by a number of factors, such as thermal aspects, ease of movement, fit,
pressure of the body, tactility and propensity to generate static electricity [16]. Function construction
design is first step to satisfy requirements of movement, and second is optimization construction
design which adds slash in some garment areas, in order to add more mobility, comfort and aesthetics.
To design protective clothing, it is necessary to identify what tasks it would be used, and what
environments that would be worn, different requirement should determine different priorities.
Outdoor clothing design must have sufficient ease to allow wearers to move uninhibited. Protective
clothing design should provide maximum protection and comfort. Protective clothing fits properly is
a significant aspect so that wearer movement is not restricted [17]. The case of research analysis,
multiple constructions design which hook of outdoor clothing design. Setting up two puckers in the
two sides of the ears, under the pucker add two zips. It can provide ventilation and more mobility and
aesthetics from visual evaluation. Optimization construction design directly affects air gap
distribution, the air gap layers between skin and clothing is determined by clothing design. Today's
3D scanning technique provides a novel method to visualize and quantify the air gaps between the
wearer and clothing. More experiments have demonstrated that the air gap size is critical factor for
wearing comfort. It can provide a way to understand how heat and vapor can be transferred through air
gap. The application of 3D body scanning and understanding air gap distribution can improve the
protective performance of clothing [18].
Summary
The outdoor protective clothing has a huge market. Successfully satisfy the demands of consumer
involve several aspects. The consumer satisfaction is the main competition factors in the apparel
industry. Therefore, it is critical to improve optimization construction design and wear comfort. It
needs a large number of measurement, experiences and tests. It is necessary to develop an approach to
determine the garment air gap using 3D body scanning and standards to identify and quantify wear
comfort, garment fit and aesthetics and fashion style of outdoor protective clothing.
References
[1] Prabir Jana: Assembling Technology for Functional Garments---An Overview, accepted by
Indian Journal of Fibre & Research Vol. 36, December 2011, pp.380-387.
[2] S. X. Wang, Y. Li. Kwok and R. W. Au: Effect of Moisture Management on Functional
Performance of Cold Protective Clothing, accepted by Textile Research Journal Vol.77
(12):968-980.
[3] Information on http://www.devetexsoho.com/en/News.asp?id=11
[4] Information on http://www.devetexsoho.com/en/News.asp?id=11
[5] Information on http://www.just-style.com/analysis/performance-outdoor-apparel-on-a-winning-
streak_id111013. Aspx
Advanced Materials Research Vol. 627 583
[6] Information on http://www.just-style.com/analysis/performance-outdoor-apparel-on-a-winning-
streak_id111013. Aspx
[7] Susan P. Ashdown, Elizabeth K. O’Connell, Comparison of Test Protocols for Judging the Fit of
Mature Women’s Apparel: accepted by International Textile & Apparel Association, Vol. 24, #2,
2006. pp 137.
[8] DesMarteau, K, CAD: Let the fit revolution begin. Bobbin, 42-56, October, 2000.
[9] Goldsberry, E, Shim, S, and Reich, N, Women 55 years and older: Part II: Overall satisfaction
and dissatisfaction with the fit of ready-to-wear. Clothing and Textiles Research Journal, 14(2),
121-131. (1996).
[10] Susan P. Ashdown, Elizabeth K. O’Connell, Comparison of Test Protocols for Judging the Fit of
Mature Women’s Apparel: accepted by International Textile & Apparel Association, Vol. 24, #2,
2006.
[11] Erwin, M., Kinchen, L. & Peters, K: Clothing for Moderns, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
(6th ed.), (1979).
[12] Elizabeth Bye, Karen L. LaBat: Analysis of body measurement systems for apparel: submitted to
Clothing & Textiles Research Journal Vol. 24, #2, 2006.
[13] Chunyan Wu, Changfeng Qu, Guowen Song: Analysis of Cold Protective Clothing’s Design and
Market---Functional & Structural Design, submitted to Applied Mechanics and Materials Vols.
215-216(2012) pp 532-535.
[14] Ruckmanje, MurrayR, Choihs: Engineering of clothing systems for Improved
Thermophysiological Comfort: the Effect of Opennings [J]: submitted to International Journal of
Clothing Science and Technology, 1999, 1(1): 37-52.
[15] Zhang Xianghui, Li Jun, Wang Yunyi: Effects of Clothing Construction Design on Protective
Clothing Comfort: accepted by Journal of Xi An Polytechnic University, Vol.23, No.2 (Sum. No.
96).
[16] E Rosenblad-Wallin: User-oriented Product Development Applied to Functional Clothing
Design [J]: submitted to Applied Ergonomics, 1985, 16(4): 279-287.
[17] Janice Huck, Oprah Maganga and Younghee Kim: Protective Overalls: evaluation of garment
design and fit: accepted by International Journal of clothing Science and Technology, Vol.9 No.1,
1997, pp. 45-61.
[18] II Young Kim, Calvin Le, Peng Li, Brain D. Corner and Steven Paquette: Investigation of Air
Gap Entrapped in Protective Clothing Systems, in Fire Mater. 2002; 26: 121-126
(DOI:10.1002/fam.790).
584 Advances in Textile Engineering and Materials
Conference Paper
In this paper, we will firstly pay attention to the holistically external business environment of the outdoor adventure clothing in the UK and present a full picture of its market based on the UK. By giving this full picture, we will also identify the economic and sociocultural factors as two main factors from the PESTEL tool. They both are believed to have the most significant impact for the market of outdoor adventure clothing. Besides, their commercial effects, inherent marketing mechanisms and significances will also be discussed and analysed in depth. Whereby two potential opportunities of the UK-based outdoor adventure clothing market corresponding to the new entrant will be presented. The first is to reduce the costs of the products by its advanced fabric and improve the performance simultaneously. By this way, they can reduce the brand loyalty to their commercial competitors and thereby attract more consumers. The second is to enhance the recognition of the new entrant and its products by a series of promotion activities and whereupon gain a sound reputation in a short period. Finally in this paper, the potential niche markets will be pointed out and several specific recommendations for the new entrant will be provided.
Article
Comfort is an important factor affecting the performance of protective clothing. In this paper, the cutting-edge achievements of research in protective clothing comfort were summarized from different aspects. The effect of modification in fiber, yarn and fabric on comfort improvement of protective clothing was first introduced, and then the parameters of the inner space control, inner layer material improvement, interlayer materials selection and clothing opening on the comfort of protective clothing were discussed. At last, the cooling methods such as liquid cooling, air cooling and phase change materials on the comfort improvement of protective clothing was demonstrated. ©, 2014, Beijing Institute of Clothing Technology. All right reserved.
Article
Full-text available
Functional garments have higher functional properties and lesser aesthetic properties. They can be workwear, active sportswear, medical wear, personal protective garments, and smart garments. The fibre contents used are mainly polyester, polyethylene, kevlar, and spandex blends which can be woven, knitted and nonwoven, albeit the list is increasing day by day to include speciality fibres like bamboo, banana to name a few. These garments are made up by joining several pattern pieces together and the pieces, in turn, are joined with accessories comprising membranes, linings, buttons, zippers, tapes and waddings to create a composite garment. While fabric can be joined by sewing, seam welding or bonding technique, accessories can be joined by sewing, welding, pasting or using combination method. Some functional garments are made seamless thus requiring little or no assembling technologies. Different new technologies for joining fabric pieces and assembling of accessories have been explored so far. There is a distinct shift towards use of welding and bonding technologies in functional clothing because of the reduced bulk and weight, cleaner appearance and sealing qualities offered by them. Some challenges still continue to exist. This paper reports the distinguished characteristics and developments in assembling technologies, such as sewing, welding and bonding along with the challenges ahead in this area.
Article
Full-text available
Relationships of cold protective clothing design and market were explored for apparel function and structure, and cold protective clothing company product to successful meet market demand. People require a large number of outdoor cold protective clothing that makes a chain of market, designer, consumer and manufacturer. They are not only focus on apparel functional comfort but also garment style preference structural design. Sophisticated new technologies are available to the apparel industry to create automated custom-fitted clothing, using 3-D body scanning and software designed to automate patternmaking to effectively improve productivity [1]. Currently, the quantification of fit is complex and ambiguous and objective methods. The purpose of this study was to explore the cold protective clothing manufacturer should have the necessary conditions on function and structure for the market demand.
Article
Full-text available
This paper reports a study on the effect of moisture management in the design of cold protective clothing. In this research, two kinds of clothing systems were tested, a traditional clothing system (clothing A), and a specially designed moisture management clothing system (clothing B). Both clothing systems have the same four-layer structure (underwear, vest, coat, and outer jacket), but with use of different functional fabrics. The experiments were conducted in a climate chamber where the temperature was controlled at —15 °C. Eleven young male subjects took part in wear trial experiments, in which they were dressed in clothing A or B and walked on a treadmill. The humidities and temperatures at the skin surface and at different layers of the clothing system were measured together with measurements of thermal and moisture sensations. The experimental results showed that the moisture management property of fabrics significantly affected the moisture diffusion and temperature distributions in the cold protective clothing systems, and influenced the thermal and moisture sensations.
Article
Functional garments have higher functional properties and lesser aesthetic properties. They can be work wear, active sportswear, medical wear, personal protective garments, and smart garments. The fibre contents used are mainly polyester, polyethylene, kevlar, and spandex blends which can be woven, knitted and nonwoven, albeit the list is increasing day by day to include speciality fibres like bamboo, banana to name a few. These garments are made up by joining several pattern pieces together and the pieces, in turn, are joined with accessories comprising membranes, linings, buttons, zippers, tapes and waddings to create a composite garment. While fabric can be joined by sewing, seam welding or bonding technique, accessories can be joined by sewing, welding, pasting or using combination method. Some functional garments are made seamless thus requiring little or no assembling technologies. Different new technologies for joining fabric pieces and assembling of accessories have been explored so far. There is a distinct shift towards use of welding and bonding technologies in functional clothing because of the reduced bulk and weight, cleaner appearance and sealing qualities offered by them. Some challenges still continue to exist. This paper reports the distinguished characteristics and developments in assembling technologies, such as sewing, welding and bonding along with the challenges ahead in this area.
Article
Technological advances and new size data offer the possibility of solving the apparel fit problems which continue to plague many consumers, retailers and manufacturers. This article explores the roots of the industry's fit problems, as well as some innovative solutions that are currently available or soon to be commercialized. The special fit problems of the online apparel sector are also considered.
Article
To evaluate the effectiveness of ventilation systems in outdoor jackets, two jackets were purchased and modified, one made of PTFE laminated fabric and the other made of polyurethane coated fabric. Six male subjects undertook exercise routines simulating fell walking while wearing these jackets. The skin temperature at four different locations and the amount of perspiration generated during exercise were recorded for analysis. The experimental results were analysed using two- way analysis of variance. From the analysis it was found that during the exercise the design of the pit zip openings, especially with pit zip openings at both sleeve and side seams, in a jacket has an effect on thermal regulation, limiting the rate of temperature increase; however, during rest it is the fabric that plays the more important role. The results for the period of exercise suggest that the provision of ventilation at appropriate positions in the jacket could contribute considerably to heat loss irrespective of the use of breathable fabrics.
Article
The purpose of this study was to compare reliability and validity of trained paraprofessional judges' responses and expert judges' responses in a garmentfit test. The study addressed the relationships amongparticipants' body and garment measurements, participants'perceptions of garmentfit, and fit assessments of the trained and expert judges. Paraprofessional judges participated in fit training sessions. Judges assessedfitfrom videotapes ofparticipants in testjackets, and made second assessments one to two weeks later. T-testsfor paired samples were runfor reliability between judges'first and second evaluations. The trained paraprofessionals' judgments were equally reliable as the expert assessments. Validity was measured by comparing the differences ofparticipants' body measurements and test jacket measurements, and the judges' and participants'fit assessments of the test jacket. None of the measures (judges' responses, subjects' responses, measurements) showed a very high level of agreement infit assessment.
Article
Using the data collected through interview questions, Part II of this nationwide study on women 55 years and older examined factors which might be related to older women's overall satisfaction and dissatisfaction with the fit of ready-to-wear. In general, 70% (n = 4,086) of the respondents indicated dissatisfaction with the fit of ready-to-wear, while 31% (n = 1,826) indicated satisfaction. By using chi-square analyses, these two groups were then compared on demographics, clothing buying practices, and self-reported clothing problem locations. The majority of variables significantly differentiated the satisfied and the dissatisfied group. More dissatisfied consumers tended: (a) to be younger (e.g., 55-to-65 age category); (b) to be in the higher income category; (c) to be Caucasian; (d) to buy clothes mostly at discount/off-price stores, at department stores and through mail-order/catalog as compared to at specialty store/boutique or by custom-made/home sewing; (e) to live in the west coast area; and (f) to buy commercial patterns but to be dissatisfied with the fit of commercial patterns as well. The actual figure type purchased (e.g., Misses, Misses Petite) in ready-to-wear also was a significant factor affecting the older women's satisfaction level. Those who identified problems with each of the 15 body or garment locations had a greater dissatisfaction level with the fit of ready-to-wear than those who did not have problems. By using logistic regression analyses, some selected body measurements were found to be significant predictors of older women's satisfaction with the fit of ready-to-wear.
Article
Many methods have been developed to measure the body in an effort to capture its dimensions for clothing. Measuring the human body has been important in developing garments tofit the body, and systems have reflected technology, needs of the consumer, andfocus of the apparel industry. The U. S. apparel industry has developed many techniques to measure the body, including custom-fitted to the individual, mass-sized and produced, and now, mass-customized. This paper reviews and evaluates historic and current methods of capturing body measurements, which are presented as linear methods, multiple probe methods, and body form methods, that use one or more of the following elements: point, length, surface, shape, and volume.
Article
Protective clothing should ideally provide maximum comfort and protection for the wearer. The design and fit of a garment are factors which can affect both the protective aspects of a garment as well as its comfort. Proper garment fit depends on the relationship of the size of the garment compared with the size of the wearer. Garment ease (where the garment is larger than the wearer) should allow for comfort and mobility; both too much or too little ease can result in a garment that is uncomfortable and restrictive to movement. The purpose of this study was to explore a research technique to isolate the effects of garment ease in one area of a garment while ease in all other garment areas was controlled, and to determine a design that would maximize wearer mobility. Using five male subjects, protective overalls with differing amounts and garment location of crotch ease were evaluated for their effects on mobility and wearer acceptance. Range of motion measurements for selected joints were evaluated using a Leighton Flexometer. Subjects completed a subjective evaluation scale after performing an exercise protocol while wearing the overalls. Results indicated that a specific amount of ease in the crotch length of overalls may be appropriate. Additionally, an overall design that had all needed crotch ease in the back waist area of the garment may be desirable over the more conventional method of adding ease evenly between the front and back sections of the garment. The methodology used in this study provides a means of evaluating not only the potential for design variations in protective clothing, but provides a means to evaluate the dynamic aspects of fit of clothing.