ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

The Atacama region has the highest concentration of hallucinogenic paraphernalia from prehistoric cemeteries on the planet. These artifacts have been studied since the late 19th century, primarily from the perspective of stylistic classification, which has been used to infer their temporal assignation. However, direct chronological dating of the snuff trays has not been addressed until now, through an interdisciplinary study conducted in San Pedro de Atacama on the psychotropic paraphernalia collection of the Instituto de Investigaciones Arqueológicas y Museo R.P. Gustavo Le Paige S.J. (IIAM), part of the Universidad Católica del Norte. In this study, samples were taken from eight snuff trays for radiocarbon dating and to develop a suitable procedure and protocol for sample extraction and handling of wooden archaeological pieces. This article provides the results of these activities by establishing the existence of a sequence of styles in the hallucinogenic paraphernalia that goes from the Middle to Late Intermediate period (ca. AD 300 to 1.400), which shows that in this time span there were two styles (Tiwanaku and local) , and then both were replaced by a macro - regional style.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Corrected Proofs
RADIOCARBON DATING OF ATACAMA (CHILE) SNUFF TRAYS: AN UPDATE ON
STYLISTIC AND CHRONOLOGICAL CORRELATIONS
Pascale Richardin1 • Catherine Lavier2 • Helena Horta3 • Valentina Figueroa3 • Nicolás Lira4
ABSTRACT. The Atacama region of Chile has the highest concentration of hallucinogenic paraphernalia from prehistoric
cemeteries on the planet. These artifacts have been studied since the late 19th century, primarily from the perspective of
stylistic classication, which has been used to infer their temporal assignation. However, direct chronological dating of the
snuff trays has not been addressed until now, through an interdisciplinary study conducted in San Pedro de Atacama on the
psychotropic paraphernalia collection of the Instituto de Investigaciones Arqueológicas y Museo R.P. Gustavo Le Paige S.J.
(IIAM), part of the Universidad Católica del Norte. In this study, samples were taken from eight snuff trays for radiocarbon
dating and to develop a suitable procedure and protocol for sample extraction and handling of wooden archaeological pieces.
This article provides the results of these activities by establishing the existence of a sequence of styles in the hallucinogenic
paraphernalia that goes from the Middle to Late Intermediate period (about AD 300 to 1400), which shows that in this time-
span there were two styles (Tiwanaku and local), and then both were replaced by a macroregional style.
INTRODUCTION
According to archaeological investigations conducted to date, and thanks to the extraordinary cli-
matic conditions of the Atacama Desert, which enable the conservation of organic materials, we
know that in this South Andean region the inhalation of powder obtained from plants with alkaloid
components that alter the state of consciousness of those who consume them was practiced for a
long period of time (e.g. Uhle 1898, 1913, 1915; Núñez 1962, 1963, 1967, 1994; Tarragó 1968,
1989; Thomas and Benavente 1984; Torres 1984a,b, 1986, 1987a,b, 1998, 2001a,b, 2004; Torres
et al. 1991; Torres and Conklin 1995; Chacama 2001; Hermosilla 2001; Torres and Repke 2006).
This practice and the instruments associated with it—snuff trays and tubes, large and small spoons,
dispensers, stone and wood mortars, spatulas, pouches to hold the pulverized seeds, woven bags,
cane and wooden recipients—have been collectively called the “hallucinogenic complex” in the
specialized literature. The grave goods of hundreds of tombs dating from the Late Formative period
to the arrival of the Spanish conquistadors bear witness to this deep-rooted custom and in turn have
enabled the preservation of a variety of snuff paraphernalia, most of it made of wood, some of it
stone. Notable among those instruments are the snuff trays, which were used to hold the powder
from the cebil seeds (Anadenanthera colubrina var. Cebil) (Reis Altschul 1964, 1972; Torres et
al. 1991; Torres 1998) so they could be snuffed through tubes. Investigation of the hallucinogenic
complex began more than a century ago, but to date none of the psychotropic paraphernalia men-
tioned have been subjected to radiocarbon dating. An interdisciplinary team composed of French
researchers from the Centre de Recherche et de Restauration des Musées de France and CNRS, and
Chilean researchers from the Department of Anthropology of the Universidad de Chile and from
the Instituto de Investigaciones Arqueológicas y Museo R.P. Gustavo Le Paige S.J. (IIAM), of the
Universidad Católica del Norte, performed the aforementioned dating in 2012. Given that the idea
was to employ for the rst time on these objects a procedure to extract samples from archaeological
material, among other precautions the team decided to subject a smaller number of trays to analysis,
focusing especially on those that were already showing signs of deterioration, as can be observed in
the photograph of the samples studied.
Traditionally, the paraphernalia studied has been chronologically assigned on the basis of (1) its
association with other materials found among the same set of grave goods (essentially ceramics,
1. Centre de Recherche et de Restauration des Musées de France, Palais du Louvre, Porte des Lions, 14 quai François
Mitterrand, F-75001 Paris, France. Corresponding author. Email: pascale.richardin@culture.gouv.fr.
2. Université Pierre et Marie Curie, UPMC Paris 06, UMR 8220, Laboratoire d’Archéologie Moléculaire et Structurale,
LAMS, Paris, France.
3. Instituto de Investigaciones Arqueológicas y Museo R.P. Gustavo Le Paige S.J., Universidad Católica del Norte, Chile.
4. Université Panthéon-Sorbonne, Paris 01, UMR 8096, Paris, France.
Radiocarbon, Vol 57, Nr 5, 2015, p 1–10 DOI: 10.2458/azu_rc.57.18318
© 2015 by the Arizona Board of Regents on behalf of the University of Arizona
Corrected Proofs
2P Richardin et al.
charcoal and bones), which could be dated by thermoluminescence or 14C; and (2) its stylistic and
iconographic correspondence. Our goal has thus been to develop a more accurate methodology for
dating these materials.
SAN PEDRO DE ATACAMA IN THE MIDDLE PERIOD
During the period traditionally considered the rise of Tiwanaku inuence (about AD 400–1000),
San Pedro society had a tremendous cultural vitality owing to its unique geographic location at the
heart of a group of oases in the middle of the Atacama Salt Plateau (2450 m asl) and the fact that it
was situated at the halfway point on the route stretching from the Pacic coast through the Atacama
Desert and the eastern watershed of the Andes Mountains (Figure 1). The Atacameño people took
full advantage of these conditions. From early on, they became skillful at beneting from an exten-
sive network of kinship-based political alliances that were built not only with Altiplano societies but
also with others adjoining that region, such as the peoples of what is now northwest Argentina and
those that lived in the Southern Altiplano of what is today Bolivia. The cultural richness that result-
ed from those alliances is more than evident in a variety of local traditions ranging from the textile
traditions displayed in their clothing and identifying headwear (Agüero 2000, 2004) to the Black
Polished ceramics (Stovel 2005, 2008) and the manufacturing of copper ore beads and psychotropic
paraphernalia (Salazar et al. 2014), all of which were clearly congured in the Atacameño style.
In connection with the hallucinogenic complex, interest initially focused on snuff trays and other
psychotropic elements of Tiwanaku style, but has now spread to the denition of other styles, in-
cluding a so-called Atacamenian local style (Llagostera et al. 1988; Llagostera 2001, 2006) or “local
production” (Núñez 1963), or San Pedro style (Horta 2014), and one macroregional style (Circum-
puneño). The latter has been described as a post-Tiwanaku style frequently represented in the basin
of the Loa River, the Puna de Jujuy, and northwestern Argentina, and infrequently represented in the
oasis of San Pedro de Atacama (Horta 2012).
Figure 1 Map of San Pedro de Atacama
Corrected Proofs
3
14C Dating of Atacama (Chile) Snuff Trays
SNUFFING PRACTICE AND STYLES
In this macroregional context, San Pedro de Atacama was a pole of attraction for different pre-
Hispanic societies that wished to exchange different products for the copper ore found in the
area. Exchange was practiced intensely at this time, and the products traded were not limited to
domestic and other everyday goods but also included ritual and symbolic items associated with the
religious sphere. Thus, during the Middle period, snuff trays and other paraphernalia made their
way to San Pedro from different places, such as the Southern Altiplano of Bolivia and northwestern
Argentina; nevertheless, about 25% of the IIAM registered paraphernalia was manufactured locally
(Horta 2014).
Regarding stylistic diversity, early investigations of the hallucinogenic complex focused on a lim-
ited number of items displaying Tiwanaku iconography and formats and ignored those that did not
correspond to that style. Torres was the rst researcher to attempt to dene the Tiwanaku style based
on the collection of trays and tubes preserved by IIAM, using a sample of around 500 items for his
analysis5 (Torres 1984a). It should be noted here that formal iconographic analysis of hallucinogenic
paraphernalia has generated a prolic body of literature by researchers of different nationalities.
Figure 2 shows the eight snuff trays from the archaeological Museum of San Pedro de Atacama,
selected for this study.
5. Currently, the IIAM has a records database that includes digital images of these objects, which has greatly facilitated their
study and enabled registration of nearly 700 pieces.
Figure 2 Studied snuff trays from the Archaeological Museum of San Pedro de Atacama: (1) IIAM 351, Tiwanaku style, Qui-
tor 6 grave 2509, snuff tray 9076; (2) IIAM 024, San Pedro style, Quitor 5 grave 2077-2089, snuff tray 9148; (3) IIAM 340,
San Pedro style, Sequitor Alambrado grave 5203-5205, snuff tray 9065; (4) IIAM 393, Tiwanaku style, Sequitor Alambrado
grave 1702, snuff tray 9079; (5) IIAM 275, Tiwanaku style, Catarpe 5 grave 2351, snuff tray 9075; (6) IIAM 205, San Pe-
dro style, Quitor 5 grave 2163, snuff tray 9149; (7) IIAM 038, Circumpuneño style, Quitor 1 grave 1178, snuff tray 8890;
(8) IIAM 387, Circumpuneño style, Pucara de Quitor without context, snuff tray 9055.
Corrected Proofs
4P Richardin et al.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Sampling
Sampling of the wooden objects in this study is very delicate because it raises several problems
based on their fragility and conservation, and on their representativity and signicance. The pres-
ervation of these snuff trays is particular because of the very low humidity contained in the bers.
This is due to the cutting and the wood work used in the past, but also due to the conditions of dis-
coveries and conservation in the region and the museum. The free water is completely evaporated,6
the saturation level is overtaken7, and the bound water in cellular membranes falls below the limit
of the natural drying8, reaching an almost “oven-dried” state. During this phase, the wood can un-
dergo structural modications and can deform (and/or during and after excavation), as far as, once
dried, it is capable of absorbing the humidity of the air (hygroscopy). Fortunately, the environmental
conditions in the Atacama region are constant and without abrupt variations.9 The water rate in the
wood reaches a low level of hygroscopic balance10 and it stabilizes, thus avoiding any change, and
explaining the generally very good conservation of the tablets.
However, the difculties of the wood sampling is due to the tablets’ rather small size, their whole
aspect, and their hardness, which can make visible and invasive any taking of matter. Using methods
developed at the C2RMF (Richardin and Gandolfo 2013a,b), microsampling is performed in order
to keep the integrity of the object, while gathering sufcient quantity (between 2–10 mg) for 14C
measurement (Figure 3).
6. Water situated in the space of the wood (bers, vessels, tracheids, etc.).
7. Over the bers saturation point (PSF) at around 30% depending of the wood species, their age, their volumetric mass, their
percentages of components (e.g. cellulose, hemicelluloses, lignin, and extractives) and the climatic conditions (temperature,
hygrometric degree, atmospheric pressure, etc.).
8. Depending also of those same factors, below 18/15%.
9. From 15/20% during the “wet” season and some 5% in the dried areas.
10. Probably around 5% for the tablets.
Figure 3 Location the sample taken from the snuff tray IIAM 351 (a) before and (b) after
sampling. Binocular picture of the collected sample (3.93 mg): (c) recto and (d) verso.
Corrected Proofs
5
14C Dating of Atacama (Chile) Snuff Trays
Moreover, analyzing wood with a dendrometrical approach also generates usable information and
data for the next steps of the snuff trays’ analysis. At the moment, certain information like the
number of tree rings and their growth, does not interfere in the interpretation of the 14C dates. The
number of snuff trays is limited due to current restrictions to preserve the integrity and preservation
of such artifacts; however, from the tray sample some degree of categorization was able to be made
according to style: Tiwanaku (samples 351, 393, and 275), San Pedro (024, 340, and 205), and
Circumpuneño (038 and 387) style. Thus, the selection criterion was the feasibility of sampling and
then the assignment to a particular style.
Next, the question arose as to whether the tables could be ordered chronologically. This dendro-data
can be used to date a large lot of tablets and to classify them in contemporary groups: wood series
will be correlated between them and the styles will benet from an higher chronological neness.
It will then be possible to better specify information such as circulation axis, speed of propagation,
arrival and term, acculturation, and adaptation.
Sample Preparation
Three steps for the sample preparation for 14C dating are necessary: a chemical pretreatment (clean-
ing or extraction of the carbonaceous matter), a combustion (or extraction of CO2), and a graphiti-
zation (transformation of CO2 into graphite). Only the two rst steps are performed at the C2RMF
while the graphitization step is done at the Commissariat à l’Énergie Atomique et aux Énergies
Alternatives (CEA) of Saclay, France (Cottereau et al. 2007; Moreau et al. 2013).
Chemical Pretreatment
In order to eliminate all insoluble impurities (e.g. dust or textile bers due to the manipulation of
museum objects), samples are initially washed in an ultrasonic bath with ultrapure water (Direct-Q
system, Millipore). Then, because they can be polluted by varnishes, waxes, and other organic com-
pounds or even by oils and resins from within the wood itself, the samples are also washed with a
mixture of dichloromethane/methanol (1/1) and then with acetone (AnalaR Normapur, VWR Inter-
national). Between each cleaning, 3–4 rinses with ultrapure water are performed. This is the routine
solvent extraction sequence for samples collected from museum objects and treated at C2RMF
(Richardin and Gandolfo 2013a).
The wood samples were then subjected to a routine acid-base-acid method (Richardin et al. 2010).
This consists of sequential washes (80°C, 1 hr) with 0.5M HCl, 0.05M NaOH, and once again with
0.5M HCl. After each step, the supernatant was removed and the remaining sample rinsed with
ultrapure water until neutrality of the washing water was achieved.
Combustion
Finally, the clean samples were dried overnight in a low-vacuum (100 mbar) oven at 60°C. The
dried samples were then combusted to CO2 at high temperature (5 hr at 850°C) under high vacuum
(at 10–6 Torr) using a homemade combustion bench. To control the sample preparation, we used a
standard: a calibration sample (FIRI H) or a charcoal from South Africa, with an innite age (CB-
AFS). Yields are between 30 and 55% and the CO2 amounts (between 0.1 and 0.9 mg) are sufcient
for 14C measurement.
Graphitization
CO2 samples were reduced to graphite at 600°C using Fe powder as catalyst prior to accelerator
mass spectrometry (AMS) 14C dating.
Corrected Proofs
6P Richardin et al.
Radiocarbon Measurements
Measurements were conducted at the AMS facility of the CEA of Saclay (Moreau et al. 2013). The
14C activity is calculated by comparing the measured intensities of the 14C, 13C, and 12C beams from
each sample with those of CO2 standards, prepared with HOx (I) oxalic acid reference, normalized
with a δ13C value of –25‰. The 14C ages (in yr BP = years before 1950) are calculated by correcting
the isotope fractionation δ13C, measured by AMS with the 13C/12C ratio. Calendar ages are deter-
mined using the OxCal v 4.2.3 program (Bronk Ramsey 1995; Bronk Ramsey and Lee 2013) and
the most recent calibration curve data for the Southern Hemisphere, SHCal13 (Hogg et al. 2013).
Calibrated age ranges correspond to 95.4% probability (2σ) and are expressed in years cal BC.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The 14C ages (in yr BP), and calibrated calendar age ranges of the individual samples are given in
Table 1 and compared in Figure 4.
Table 1 Radiocarbon ages (BP) and calibrated ages of samples.
Inventory nr Lab code
14C age
(yr BP)
95.4 % (2σ) calibrated
age ranges (relative
area under distribution) Style
IIAM 351 SacA-33697 1845 ± 30 AD 125 (83.4%) 254
AD 294 (12.0%) 335
Tiwanaku, “Sacricer”
reused sample
IIAM 024 SacA-33785 1635 ± 30 AD 390 (95.4%) 543 San Pedro
IIAM 340 SacA-33292 1590 ± 30 AD 426 (95.4%) 584 San Pedro
IIAM 393 SacA-33686 1525 ± 30 AD 534 (95.4%) 643 Tiwanaku, volumetric
IIAM 275 SacA-33291 1340 ± 30 AD 655 (93.9%) 774
AD 820 (1.5%) 832
Tiwanaku, “Sacricer,”
reused sample
IIAM 205 SacA-33696 1150 ± 30 AD 885 (93.8%) 996
AD 1005 (1.6%) 1013
San Pedro
IIAM 038 SacA-33290 1135 ± 30 AD 892 (95.4%) 1016 Circumpuneño
IIAM 387 SacA-33685 660 ± 30 AD 1299 (95.4%) 1399 Circumpuneño
According to the calibrated dates, the Tiwanaku and San Pedro styles are contemporary, and were
clearly in effect during the Middle period, about AD 300–1000, while the Circumpuneño style was
present during the period AD 900–1400, and thus is an expression of the Late Intermediate period.
The date obtained for snuff tray IIAM 351 (Figure 2.1) corroborates the early chronological place-
ment of the Tiwanaku Sacricer,11 a gure depicted in prole with the head front-facing or turned
upwards, visual attributes related to decapitation (a human head and ax), feline features (teeth and
ears), and occasionally, wings. According to observations made by Torres (2001a), this is the most
frequently found icon on Tiwanaku snuff trays discovered in San Pedro de Atacama, and according
to our records it is found on 24% (15/62) of the imported paraphernalia in the collection of Horta
(2014). Additionally, snuff tray IIAM 275 (Figure 2.5) demonstrates that the icon in question was
used for an extended period that lasted at least until AD 700–800, with the additional information
obtained from the Solcor 3 snuff tray (AD 500–1000; see Note 11).
11. This refers to thermoluminescence (TL) dates obtained previously for trays 8844 from Toconao Oriente, tomb 4229-4230
(AD 190 ± 140; Berenguer et al. 1986; Torres 2001a) and 9106 from Quitor 8, tomb 3229-3230 (AD 180; Berenguer et al. 1986;
Torres 2001a; Tarragó 1989). For tomb 107 of Solcor 3, which includes a beautiful tray with the Tiwanaku Sacricer,
three 14C dates were also obtained: AD 490 ± 100; AD 730 ± 60; AD 930 ± 120 (Llagostera et al. 1988). These demonstrate
the extensive period during which this important icon was in use.
Corrected Proofs
7
14C Dating of Atacama (Chile) Snuff Trays
Furthermore, the date for snuff tray IIAM 393 (Figure 2.4) is consistent with the classical Tiwanaku
period and establishes a more precise temporal range for this singular representation, which depicts
a human gure reclining backwards, an image seldom found in the snuff trays identied to date from
the south-central Andean region12 (Llagostera 2006:Figure 6c).
Also worth mentioning are the dates obtained for snuff trays IIAM 024, 340, and 205, in the San Pe-
dro style (Figures 2.2 and 2.3). This style, which features human gures and images of shamans and
their alter egos on rectangular trays, is only found in the central oases of the Atacama Salt Plateau
(present-day San Pedro de Atacama), and as such it can be considered a local style. The range of
dates obtained from these three snuff trays indicates that the San Pedro style was contemporary with
that of Tiwanaku (about AD 400–1000), which contradicts the idea put forward by other researchers
that the Atacameño people had begun to practice snufng and developed their own unique style
before the inuence of that Altiplano state took hold (Llagostera et al. 1988).
The results of the 14C dating obtained for snuff trays IIAM 038 and 387 (Figures 2.7 and 2.8) are
fully coherent with the proposal that the Circumpuneño style was in effect in post-Tiwanaku times
(Horta 2012). The tray IIAM 038 is fractured today, but the notes left by Le Paige (1964, 1965) tell
us that the upper middle section originally bore the gure of a bird that is now missing (“beautiful
snuff tray with a condor with outspread wings”). This description and the general format of the piece
allow us to assign it to the Circumpuneño style.
CONCLUSIONS
As discussed in the Introduction, for the rst time samples have been obtained directly from Chilean
snuff trays for 14C analysis, with the double aim of developing a procedure and protocol for studying
wooden archaeological material and to test 14C and thermoluminescence (TL) dates obtained over
12. In the IIAM collection only two other examples are known: IIAM 403, tray 9071, no tomb, from Solor Túmulo Sur, and
the other from Solor 3, also without context. The most spectacular of this series—for its degree of integrity and the
preservation of iconographic detail—is tray N°41.0.8911, from San Pedro de Atacama, which today is housed in the
American Museum of Natural History in New York (Torres 1987b:Plate 97).
Figure 4 Calibration plots of the calibrated dates of the samples
Corrected Proofs
8P Richardin et al.
the past 30 yr for a variety of grave goods including snuff trays. Thus, the indirect dating by asso-
ciation with ceramics or bone (conducted in 16 different contexts) can now be complemented by
direct dating of the material performed by our team on the aforementioned snuff trays. Indeed, the
results presented do no invalidate the time ranges that were previously established by TL dating (six
tombs) and 14C (10 tombs) dating. [Recently, Torres-Rouff and Hubbe (2013) have 14C dated a large
sample of osteological material with interesting facts about the prolonged duration in time of several
cemeteries of the Salar de Atacama.] On the contrary, our results reinforce the previous ones and
even expand the period during which snufng was practiced in the Atacama region up to Inca times.
As indicated above, up to now the usual archaeological practice in relation to the hallucinogenic
complex has been to date a piece of ceramic, charcoal, or bone from a certain tomb and then extend
the date obtained to the paraphernalia found in the same tomb. Using this method, researchers have
found most of the paraphernalia in association with Polished Black and Almost-Polished Black ce-
ramics, giving a date range of approximately AD 100–700 (Tarragó 1989; Torres 1998). Neverthe-
less, the direct 14C dates obtained for these eight snuff trays enable us to both expand the dates pre-
viously assigned and establish the time ranges for each style dened to date, namely Tiwanaku, San
Pedro, and Circumpuneño. In effect, the rst two styles were found to be contemporary, falling into
the Middle period, while the third was conrmed to have been in effect during the Late Intermediate
period. Thus, the variations in stylistic and iconographic attributes established for each style have
chronological signicance, and when conducted on a broad sample, stylistic and iconographic anal-
ysis as a method in itself can indeed provide independent verication through the use of 14C dating.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This paper was nanced under the Proyecto de Investigación Asociativa Conicyt Anillo ACT-96.
We want to thank Bernard Berthier and his team from the Laboratory of Measurement of Carbon 14
(LMC14 - UMS2572) for the graphitization step of the gas samples and the 14C measurements, and
Nathalie Gandolfo from the C2RMF for the sample preparation.
REFERENCES
Agüero C. 2000. Fragmentos para armar un territorio.
La textilería en Atacama durante los períodos In-
termedio Tardío y Tardío. Estudios Atacameños
20:7–28.
Agüero C. 2004. Componente Tiwanaku vs. componente
local en los oasis de San Pedro de Atacama. Tejien-
dosueños en el Cono sur. Textiles andinos: pasado,
presente y futuro. In: Actas del 51º Congreso Inter-
nacional de Americanistas. Barcelona: Departamen-
to de Artes, Universidad de Barcelona, Grup d’Estu-
dis Precolombins. p 180–98.
Berenguer J, Deza A, Román A, Llagostera A. 1986. La
secuencia de Myriam Tarragó para San Pedro de
Atacama: un test portermo luminiscencia. Revista
Chilena de Antropología 5:17–54.
Bronk Ramsey C. 1995. Radiocarbon calibration and
analysis of stratigraphy: the OxCal program. Radio-
carbon 37(2):425–30.
Bronk Ramsey C, Lee S. 2013. Recent and planned
developments of the program OxCal. Radiocarbon
55(2–3):720–30.
Chacama J. 2001. Tabletas, tubos y espátulas. Aproxima-
ción a un complejo alucinógeno en el área de Arica,
extremo norte de Chile. Eleusis 5:85–100.
Cottereau E, Arnold M, Moreau C, Baqué D, Bavay D,
Caffy I, Comby C, Dumoulin J-P, Hain S, Perron
M, Salomon J, Setti V. 2007. Artemis, the new 14C
AMS at LMC14 in Saclay, France. Radiocarbon
49(2):291–9.
Hermosilla N. 2001. The people of the Tumi, the Condor
and the Jaguar. Psychoactive plant use in the Loa
River Basin, Atacama Desert. Eleusis 5:123–36.
Hogg A, Hua Q, Blackwell P, Niu M, Buck C, Guilder-
son TP, Heaton T, Palmer J, Reimer P, Reimer R,
Turney C, Zimmerman S. 2013. SHCal13 Southern
Hemisphere calibration, 0–50,000 years cal BP. Ra-
diocarbon 55(4):1889–903.
Horta H. 2012. El estilo Circumpuneño en el arte de la
parafernalia alucinógena prehispánica (Atacama y
noroesteargentino). Estudios Atacameños 43:5–34.
Horta H. 2014. Lo propio y lo ajeno. Denición del es-
tilo San Pedro en la parafernalia alucinógena de los
oasis del salar de Atacama. Chungara, Revista de
Antropología Chilena 46(4):559–83.
Latcham R. 1938. Arqueología de la región Atacameña.
Santiago: Prensas de la Universidad de Chile.
Le Paige G. 1964. El Precerámico en la cordillera Ata-
cameña y los cementerios del Período Agroalfarero
Corrected Proofs
9
14C Dating of Atacama (Chile) Snuff Trays
de San Pedro de Atacama. Anales de la Universidad
del Norte 3, Chile.
Le Paige G. 1965. San Pedro de Atacama y su zona (14
temas). Anales de la Universidad del Norte 4, Chile.
Llagostera A. 2001. Archaeology of hallucinogens in San
Pedro de Atacama (north Chile). Eleusis 5:101–21.
Llagostera A. 2006. Contextualización e iconografía de
las tabletas psicotrópicas Tiwanaku de San Pedro de
Atacama. Chungara 38(1):83–111.
Llagostera A, Torres C, Costa MA. 1988. El complejo
psicotrópico en Solcor-3 (San Pedro de Atacama).
Estudios Atacameños 9:61–98.
Moreau C, Caffy I, Comby C, Delqué-Kolic E, Dumou-
lin J-P, Hain S, Quiles A, Setti V, Souprayen C, Thel-
lier B, Vincent J. 2013. Research and development
of the Artemis 14C AMS Facility: status report. Ra-
diocarbon 55(2–3):331–7.
Núñez L. 1962. Tallas prehispánicas en madera. Contri-
bución a la arqueología del norte de Chile [unpub-
lished thesis]. Santiago: Instituto Pedagógico, Fac-
ultad Filosofía y Educación, Universidad de Chile.
Núñez L. 1963. Problemas en torno a la tableta de rapé.
In: Anales de la Universidad del Norte 2, Congreso
Internacional Arqueología de San Pedro de Ataca-
ma. p 149–68.
Núñez L. 1967. Informe arqueológico sobre una muestra
de posible narcótico del sitio Patillos-1 (Provincia
de Tarapacá, Norte de Chile). Arstryck 1967–1968:
83–90.
Núñez L. 1994. Cruzando la cordillera por el norte: se-
ñoríos, caravanas y alianzas. In: Francisco Mena,
editor. La Cordillera de los Andes: Ruta de encuen-
tros. Santiago: Exhibition Catalogue Museo Chileno
de Arte Precolombino. p 9–21.
Reis Altschul S. 1964. A taxonomic study of the genus
Anadenanthera. In: Contributions from the Gray
Herbarium of Harvard University N°CVCIII. Cam-
bridge, Massachusetts p 3–65.
Reis Altschul S. 1972. The Genus Anadenanthera in Am-
erindian Cultures. Cambridge: Botanical Museum,
Harvard University.
Richardin P, Gandolfo N. 2013a. Datation et authenti-
cation des œuvres de musée - Apports de la datation
par le carbone 14. Spectra Analyse 292:55–60.
Richardin P, Gandolfo N. 2013b. Radiocarbon dating
and authentication of objects from ethnographic
museums. Radiocarbon 55(3–4):1810–8.
Richardin P, Cuisance F, Buisson N, Asensi-Amoros V,
Lavier C. 2010. AMS radiocarbon dating and sci-
entic examination of high historical value man-
uscripts: application to two Chinese manuscripts
from Dunhuang. Journal of Cultural Heritage
11:398–403.
Salazar D, Niemeyer HN, Horta H, Figueroa V, Manrí-
quez G. 2014. Interaction, social identity, agency
and change during Middle Horizon San Pedro de
Atacama (northern Chile): a multidimensional and
interdisciplinary perspective. Journal of Anthropo-
logical Archaeology 35:135–52.
Stovel E. 2005. The archaeology of identity construc-
tion: ceramic evidence from northern Chile. In:
Funari PP, Zarankin E, Stovel E, editors. Global
Archaeological Theory. Contextual Voices and Con-
temporary Thoughts. New York: Kluwer Academic.
Stovel E. 2008. Interaction and social elds in San Pedro
de Atacama, northern Chile. In: Silverman H, Isbell
WH, editors. The Handbook of South American Ar-
chaeology. Berlin: Springer. p 979–1002.
Tarragó M. 1968. Secuencias culturales en la etapa agro-
alfarera de San Pedro de Atacama (Chile). In: Actas
del XXXVII Congreso Internacional de Americanis-
tas. Volume II. Buenos Aires. p 119–44.
Tarragó M. 1989. Contribución al conocimiento arqueo-
lógico de las poblaciones de los oasis de San Pedro
de Atacama en relación con los otros pueblos pu-
neños, en especial, el sector septentrional del valle
Calchaquí [unpublished PhD thesis]. Facultad de
Humanidades y Artes, Universidad Nacional de Ro-
sario, Argentina.
Thomas C, Benavente MA. 1984. Reexiones meto-
dológicas acerca de las creencias en la cultura San
Pedro a través del análisis de correspondencia de las
tabletas de rapé. In: Simposio Culturas Atacameñas.
44º Congreso Internacional de Americanistas, Man-
chester, UK. p 157–74.
Torres C. 1984a. Tabletas para alucinógenos de San
Pedro de Atacama: estilo e iconografía. In: Teso-
ros de San Pedro de Atacama. Santiago: Exhibition
Catalogue Museo Chileno de Arte Precolombino.
p 23–36.
Torres C. 1984b. Iconografía de las tabletas para inha-
lar sustancias psicoactivas de la zona de San Pedro
de Atacama, norte de Chile. Estudios Atacameños
7:178–96.
Torres C. 1986. Tabletas para alucinógenos en Suda-
mérica: tipología, distribución y rutas de difusión.
Boletín del Museo Chileno de Arte Precolombino
1:37–53.
Torres C. 1987a. The Iconography of South American
snuff trays and Related Paraphernalia. Göteborg:
Etnologiska Studier 37, Etnograska Museet.
Torres C. 1987b. The iconography of the Prehispanic
snuff trays from San Pedro de Atacama, northern
Chile. Andean Past 1:191–254.
Torres C. 1998. Psychoactive substances in the archaeol-
ogy of northern Chile and NW Argentina. Chungara
30:49–63.
Torres C. 2001a. Iconografía Tiwanaku en la parafernalia
inhalatoria. In: Kaulicke P, Isbell WH, editors. Hua-
ri y Tiwanaku: Modelos versus evidencias. Second
Part. Boletín PUCP, Departamento Humanidades,
Ponticia Universidad Católica del Perú. p 247–54.
Torres C. 2001b. Shamanic inebriants in South America
archaeology: recent investigations. Eleusis 5:3–12.
Torres C. 2004. Imágenes legibles: la iconografía Tiwan-
aku comosignicante. Boletín del Museo Chileno de
Arte Precolombino 9:55–73.
Torres C, Conklin W. 1995. Exploring the San Pedro de
Atacama/Tihuanaku relationship. In: Dransart P, ed-
itor. Andean Art: Visual Expression and Its Relation
Corrected Proofs
10 P Richardin et al.
to Andean Beliefs and Values. Avebury: Worldwide
Archaeology Series, Volume 13. p 79–108.
Torres CM, Repke DB. 2006. Anadenanthera. Visionary
Plant of Ancient South America. New York: Ha-
worth Herbal Press.
Torres C, Repke DB, Chan K, Mackenna D, Llagostera
A, Schultes RE. 1991. Snuff powders from Pre-His-
panic San Pedro de Atacama: chemical and contex-
tual analysis. Current Anthropology 32:640–9.
Torres-Rouff C, Hubbe M. 2013. The sequence of hu-
man occupation in the Atacama oases, Chile: a ra-
diocarbon chronology bases on human skeletal re-
mains. Latin American Antiquity 24(3):330–44.
Uhle M. 1898. A snufng-tube from Tiahuanaco. Bul-
letin of the Free Museum of Science and Art. Phil-
adelphia: University of Pennsylvania. Volume 1(4).
Uhle M. 1913. Tabletas de Chiu Chiu. Revista Chilena
de Historia y Geografía 8:454–7.
Uhle M. 1915. Los tubos y tabletas para rapé de Chile.
Revista Chilena de Historia y Geografía XVI:114–
36.
... De hecho, la datación obtenida por Albarracín-Jordán et al. (2014) para dos tabletas con apéndices antropomorfos en Cueva del Chileno (norte de Lípez) demuestran que, en algunos lugares al menos, dicho estilo ya se usaba a comienzos del segundo milenio (cf. Richardin et al. 2015). ...
Article
Full-text available
This work introduces an archaeological collection from the Province of Jujuy, currently housed in the National Museum of the American Indian, discussing its origin and revealing its research potential. Most materials have been classified as from Calilegua, but there are reasons to infer that their true origin is in the Quebrada de Humahuaca and that they are part of the vast collection gathered by Karl Schuel between 1920 and 1923. The study of these pieces can provide valuable information about the past of the quebrada, particularly from the lastpre-Hispanic centuries, as demonstrated by the analysis of snuffing trays and tubes, and their relationships with similar implements from Mu- yuna and other parts of the circum-Puna regions of the Andes.
Article
Full-text available
This research explores the role of minerals in propitiation and fertility rites in the Andes. An ontological perspective is employed, using an ethnohistorical account and ethnographic sources, to open the way to discussion and contextualization of the archaeological evidence of copper found in the Atacama Desert. Focusing on its affective and propitiatory potential for the germination of life, we look at the presence of copper elements in various archaeological contexts. The so-called “hallucinogenic tablets” associated with these pieces suggest a new understanding of the ritual consumption of psychotropic plants, where the offering and dialogue with non-human entities played important roles.
Article
Full-text available
Throughout Earth’s most extreme environments, such as the Kalahari Desert or the Arctic, hunter–gatherers found ingenious ways to obtain proteins and sugars provided by plants for dietary requirements. In the hyperarid Atacama Desert, wild plant resources are scarce and unevenly distributed due to limited water availability. This study brings together all available archaeobotanical evidence gathered in the Atacama Desert from the Late Pleistocene (ca. 13,000 cal bp) until the Inka epoch (ca. 450 cal bp) to help us comprehend when these populations acquired and managed useful plants from the coastal zone, Intermediate Depression, High Andes, as well as tropical and subtropical ecosystems. Widespread introduction of farming crops, water control techniques and cultivation of diverse plants by 3,000 cal bp ended not only a chronic food shortage, but also led to the establishment of a set of staple foods for the Atacama Desert dwellers, a legacy that remains visible today. By contrasting these trends with major sociocultural changes, together with palaeodemographic and climatic fluctuations, we note that humans adapted to, and transformed this hyperarid landscape and oscillating climate, with plants being a key factor in their success. This long-term process, which we term the “Green Revolution”, coincided with an exponential increase in the number of social groups inhabiting the Atacama Desert during the Late Holocene.
Chapter
Full-text available
Phénomène emblématique de l’Égypte pharaonique, la momification d’animaux est globalement datée de la Basse époque à l’époque romaine (VIIIe siècle avant J.-C. jusqu’au IVe siècle après J.-C.). Malgré le nombre impressionnant de momies disponibles pour la recherche, mais aussi le nombre de programme d’études actuellement en cours sur le sujet, force est de constater que notre connaissance chronologique du phénomène dans sa globalité se limite à ce type de datations relatives très larges fondées sur les grandes périodes historiques de la chronologie égyptologique (Basse époque, époque ptolémaïque, époque romaine). Dans le cadre du programme inter- et pluridisciplinaire MAHES, une série de datations par le carbone 14 a été réalisée sur un lot de 63 spécimens jugés représentatifs de la diversité de la riche collection du musée des Confluences de Lyon (diversité d’espèces et de provenances). Cet article propose les premiers résultats d’un projet plus ambitieux de datation par le carbone 14 de momies animales égyptiennes.
Article
Full-text available
Significance Humans have a long history of using natural resources, especially plants, to induce nonordinary states of consciousness. Imbibing substances derived from plants have been linked to ancient and elaborate knowledge systems and rituals. While archaeological evidence of the consumption of psychotropics, such as alcohol or caffeine, dates back thousands of years, evidence of the use of other psychoactive substances has been more difficult to document. This article presents the results of chemical analyses of organic residues found in a 1,000-year-old ritual bundle recovered from the highland Andes. The analyses provide evidence of the use of multiple psychoactive plants associated with a sophisticated botanical knowledge system among ritual specialists (shamans) during pre-Columbian times.
Article
Este trabajo integra los datos de una serie de análisis realizados sobre tabletas y tubos procedentes del sitio de La Paya en el Valle Calchaquí, en el Noroeste argentino. Se pone énfasis en los fechados radiocarbónicos y datos contextuales, buscando completar y enriquecer nuestra información sobre la procedencia de las maderas y sobre la vinculación estilística con otras regiones. Los resultados de los fechados, junto con la información contextual, señalan que los artefactos para inhalación de alucinógenos se asocian más fuertemente al período de Desarrollos Regionales en el Valle Calchaquí, con escasa vinculación a contextos Inkaicos. Esto indicaría que los circuitos que permitieron el aprovisionamiento de maderas de otras regiones para algunas de las tabletas y tubos calchaquíes se encontraban vigentes para dicho período. Lo mismo sucedía para aquella esfera por la que circuló información estilística relativa a tabletas y tubos, que abarcó las áreas del Valle Calchaquí, la puna de Jujuy, la Quebrada de Humahuaca y la región del Río Loa.
Article
Full-text available
The new facility Artemis was installed in 2003 in Saclay, France. This 3MV NEC Pelletron is dedicated to high-precision radiocarbon measurements for French 14C laboratories. We will present information on Artemis along with our sample preparation methods. Results from measurements on some intercalibration samples will be given along with the values of measured blanks. Finally, we report on some problems we have encountered when measuring sputter cathodes with high CH-outputs. © 2007 by the Arizona Board of Regents on behalf of the University of Arizona.
Article
Full-text available
This work is based on a stylistic and contextual analysis of hallucinogenic paraphernalia from funerary contexts in the circum-Puna area. By considering a broad ranging archaeological sample and a thorough literature review, a circum-Puna style is defined that has a macro-regional character due to its wide field of dispersion (in Chile: Atacama coast, Loa River basin, and Salar de Atacama; in northwestern Argentina: Quebrada de Humahuaca and the Puna of Jujuy). This style is distinct from that of Tiawanaku both in its formal elements as well as its temporal placement. Here I define those features which classify this circum-Puna pattern as a separate style. These characteristics are those that possess a deep rooted relationship with the circum-Puna, although there is evidence of altiplano-inspired concepts such as the decapitation of individuals who appear to be sacrificed in the framework of a shamanic ritual.
Article
Full-text available
This article describes the contribution of the radiocarbon dating method to the authentication of ethnographic objects on some significant examples coming from the collections of the Quai Branly Museum (Paris, France) and the Museum of African Arts (Marseilles, France). The first object is a bludgeon of hard wood from the Tupinambá ethnic group and thought to be brought from Brazil by Andre Thévet, cosmographer of King Francis I. This object supposedly dates to the 16th century. Another example concerns a series of architectural columns, brought from Peru in 1910 by Captain Paul Berthon from the archaeological site of Pachacamac, the largest sanctuary on the central coast of Peru. These pieces have induced a strong reaction in the French scientific community, which has described them as “some vulgar fake” because of a particular decoration and also their unique typology. We will present also the dating of 2 Tibetan textiles and 2 pre-Columbian ponchos made with feathers, which were not well documented. The last example concerns a decorated skull covered with a mosaic of blue and black turquoises and belonging to a civilization predating the Aztecs (AD 1300–1500). All these examples illustrate the decisive contribution of ¹⁴ C dating to the authentication of museum objects that lack information about their origin.
Book
A multidisciplinary study of pre-Columbian South America—centering on the psychoactive plant genus Anadenanthera As cultures formed and evolved in pre-Columbian South America, Anadenanthera became one of the most widely used shamanic inebriants. Anadenanthera: Visionary Plant of Ancient South America is more than a comprehensive reference on shamanic visionary substances; it is a useful tool for archeologists and pre-Columbian art historians. This thorough book examines the ritual and cultural use of Anadenanthera from prehistory to the present, along with its botany, chemistry, pharmacology, anthropology, and archeology. The earliest evidence for the use of psychoactive plants in South America is provided by remains of seeds and pods recovered from archeological sites four millennia old. Various preparations were derived from it with the intent of being a shamanic inebriant. Inhaled through the nose, smoked in pipes or as cigars, and prepared in fermented drinks, Anadenanthera served a central role in the cultural development of indigenous societies in South America. Anadenanthera: Visionary Plant of Ancient South America explores the full spectrum of information gleaned from research, covering numerous archeological sites in the Andean region, as well as discussing Amazonian shamanic rituals and lore. Analyses of the artistic expressions within the decorations of associated ceremonial paraphernalia such as ritual snuffing tubes and snuff trays are included. The text is richly illustrated with photographs and images of decorated ritual implements, and provides a comprehensive bibliography. Anadenanthera: Visionary Plant of Ancient South America explores: • botanical aspects, taxonomy, and geographical distribution of Anadenanthera • ethnographical, historical, and traditional aspects of Anadenanthera use • chemical and pharmacological investigations of the genus and the various visionary preparations derived from it—with emphasis on the biologically active constituents • theories of the mechanisms of action of the active tryptamines and carboline alkaloids • comparisons of wood anatomy, morphology, and percentage of alkaloid content • evaluation of stylistic and iconographic traits Anadenanthera: Visionary Plant of Ancient South America is a thorough, useful resource for archeologists, anthropologists, chemists, researchers, pre-Columbian art historians, and any layperson interested in pre-Columbian art, archeology, or visionary plants.
Article
OxCal is a widely used software package for the calibration of radiocarbon dates and the statistical analysis of ¹⁴ C and other chronological information. The program aims to make statistical methods easily available to researchers and students working in a range of different disciplines. This paper will look at the recent and planned developments of the package. The recent additions to the statistical methods are primarily aimed at providing more robust models, in particular through model averaging for deposition models and through different multiphase models. The paper will look at how these new models have been implemented and explore the implications for researchers who might benefit from their use. In addition, a new approach to the evaluation of marine reservoir offsets will be presented. As the quantity and complexity of chronological data increase, it is also important to have efficient methods for the visualization of such extensive data sets and methods for the presentation of spatial and geographical data embedded within planned future versions of OxCal will also be discussed.
Article
People usually study the chronologies of archaeological sites and geological sequences using many different kinds of evidence, taking into account calibrated radiocarbon dates, other dating methods and stratigraphic information. Many individual case studies demonstrate the value of using statistical methods to combine these different types of information. I have developed a computer program, OxCal, running under Windows 3.1 (for IBM PCs), that will perform both 14 C calibration and calculate what extra information can be gained from stratigraphic evidence. The program can perform automatic wiggle matches and calculate probability distributions for samples in sequences and phases. The program is written in C++ and uses Bayesian statistics and Gibbs sampling for the calculations. The program is very easy to use, both for simple calibration and complex site analysis, and will produce graphical output from virtually any printer.
Article
The Artemis accelerator mass spectrometry (AMS) facility is dedicated to high-precision radiocarbon measurements. It routinely measures over 4500 samples a year for French laboratories. This paper is a status report, showing the measurements of standard, blank, and FIRI intercomparison samples. Since 2008, research and development programs have been established by the Artemis team. During the collaborations with other research laboratories, intercomparisons on archaeological samples were performed and are listed here to show the quality of the Artemis measurements. Three areas of specific research and development are investigated: technical development, beam optic simulations, and specific archaeological studies. The technical developments of the facility are based on the setup of a new bench for water sample preparation and routine microsample preparation and measurement. Beam optic simulations are carried out to control the quality of the measurement related to the tuning of the facility. International collaborations are always in progress. In 2012, the programs include improving the accuracy of reigns for the dynastic Egypt period and the C-14 dating of ancient iron.