ArticlePDF Available

A late-surviving basal theropod dinosaur from the latest Triassic of North America

The Royal Society
Proceedings of the Royal Society B
Authors:
Hans-Dieter Sues at Smithsonian Institution
Hans-Dieter Sues
Sterling Nesbitt at Virginia Tech
Sterling Nesbitt
David S Berman at Carnegie Learning Museum of Natural History
David S Berman
  • Carnegie Learning Museum of Natural History
Amy Henrici at Carnegie Museum Of Natural History
Amy Henrici
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract and Figures

The oldest theropod dinosaurs are known from the Carnian of Argentina and Brazil. However, the evolutionary diversification of this group after its initial radiation but prior to the Triassic-Jurassic boundary is still poorly understood because of a sparse fossil record near that boundary. Here, we report on a new basal theropod, Daemonosaurus chauliodus gen. et sp. nov., from the latest Triassic 'siltstone member' of the Chinle Formation of the Coelophysis Quarry at Ghost Ranch, New Mexico. Based on a comprehensive phylogenetic analysis, Daemonosaurus is more closely related to coeval neotheropods (e.g. Coelophysis bauri) than to Herrerasauridae and Eoraptor. The skeletal structure of Daemonosaurus and the recently discovered Tawa bridge a morphological gap between Eoraptor and Herrerasauridae on one hand and neotheropods on the other, providing additional support for the theropod affinities of both Eoraptor and Herrerasauridae and demonstrating that lineages from the initial radiation of Dinosauria persisted until the end of the Triassic. Various features of the skull of Daemonosaurus, including the procumbent dentary and premaxillary teeth and greatly enlarged premaxillary and anterior maxillary teeth, clearly set this taxon apart from coeval neotheropods and demonstrate unexpected disparity in cranial shape among theropod dinosaurs just prior to the end of the Triassic.
Figures - uploaded by Hans-Dieter Sues
Author content
All figure content in this area was uploaded by Hans-Dieter Sues
Content may be subject to copyright.
SUES_ET_AL_20
11.pdf
Content uploaded by Hans-Dieter Sues
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Hans-Dieter Sues on Mar 18, 2015
Content may be subject to copyright.
00b7d5224db84d4d350000
00.pdf
Content uploaded by Hans-Dieter Sues
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Hans-Dieter Sues
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
A preview of this full-text is provided by The Royal Society.
Learn more
Content available from Proceedings of the Royal Society B 
This content is subject to copyright.
... The most significant event that determined the appearance of the new higher group of reptiles and the rise in the level of organization of its representatives was the appearance of first archosaurs in the large size class as active predators at the end of the Permian. They occupied the levels of higher-order consumers, i.e., the top of the food pyramid of the dominant terrestrial community (Sennikov, 1995). This was accompanied by significant morphological transformations in the first archosaurs with respect to their ancestors, small early diapsids, such as Eosuchia. ...
... It is very likely that the early small theropod Daemonosaurus (Sues et al., 2011;Nesbitt and Sues, 2021) with a very short skull and jaws and with a small number of strongly anisodont, very large teeth (Fig. 14) was adapted to macrophagy, like ornithosuchids. One should note a sharp difference in the structure of its jaw apparatus from that of another Triassic theropod, Coelophysis, which indicates different strategies for capturing and killing prey. ...
Ornithosuchidae – Early Archosaurs with a Hyper-Specialized Jaw Apparatus
Article
  • Nov 2024
Among the early archosaurs, various ecological types are represented – from predators to herbivores, from terrestrial to semi-aquatic forms. A special place among them is occupied by the family Ornithosuchidae, which are traditionally considered as active predators. The unique structure of the jaw apparatus and the morphology of the postcranial skeleton of Ornithosuchidae indicate the formation in them the only special ecological type among archosaurs – a hyperanisodont macrophagous predator. At the same time, some analogies can be noted between ornithosuchids and saber-toothed therapsids and mammals.
View
... The most significant event that determined the appearance of the new higher group of reptiles and the rise in the level of organization of its representatives was the appearance of first archosaurs in the large size class as active predators at the end of the Permian. They occupied the levels of higher-order consumers, i.e., the top of the food pyramid of the dominant terrestrial community (Sennikov, 1995). This was accompanied by significant morphological transformations in the first archosaurs with respect to their ancestors, small early diapsids, such as Eosuchia. ...
... It is very likely that the early small theropod Daemonosaurus (Sues et al., 2011;Nesbitt and Sues, 2021) with a very short skull and jaws and with a small number of strongly anisodont, very large teeth (Fig. 14) was adapted to macrophagy, like ornithosuchids. One should note a sharp difference in the structure of its jaw apparatus from that of another Triassic theropod, Coelophysis, which indicates different strategies for capturing and killing prey. ...
View
... Though specimens from other sites in the region have been referred to C. bauri (Padian 1986;Colbert 1989), these referrals are uncertain, so only the Ghost Ranch Coelophysis Quarry specimens can confidently be assigned to C. bauri Marsh and Parker 2020). One other dinosaur has been identified in the Ghost Ranch Coelophysis Quarry sample: Daemonosaurus chauliodus, an early-diverging saurischian known from a single skull and associated partial cervical series (Sues et al. 2011;Nesbitt and Sues 2021). The Ghost Ranch Coelophysis Quarry assemblage also includes phytosaurs (Hunt and Lucas 1993;Goldsmith et al. 2023), drepanosauromorphs (Harris and Downs 2002;Pritchard and Nesbitt 2017), shuvosaurids (Nesbitt 2007), crocodylomorphs (Nesbitt et al. 2006;Rinehart et al. 2009;Nesbitt 2011), sphenodontians (Heckert et al. 2008) and fish (Schaeffer 1967). ...
Immature skulls of the theropod dinosaur Coelophysis bauri from Ghost Ranch, New Mexico
Article
Full-text available
  • Oct 2024
  • ACTA PALAEONTOL POL
The theropod dinosaur Coelophysis bauri is well known from the famous Rhaetian, Late Triassic mass death assemblage from the Coelophysis Quarry at Ghost Ranch, New Mexico. This research describes the skulls of two small individuals of C. bauri. Both skulls are mostly complete, though they are missing premaxillae, and most posterior skull bones are either missing or badly damaged. Both specimens preserve hyoids, making them excellent candidates for hyoid histology. These two skulls have different proportions from other Coelophysis skulls from Ghost Ranch, especially in the large size of the orbit, short and flat triangular teeth, and thinner bones. These differences are interpreted as representing ontogenetic variation, with these skulls representing skeletally immature, partially developed individuals.
View
... Such assertions were partially modified with the discovery of Silesaurus and its kin (e.g., Cabreira et al., 2016;Ezcurra, 2006;Irmis et al., 2007;Nesbitt et al., 2009Nesbitt et al., , 2010Novas et al., 2021;Sues et al., 2011). The elongate forelimbs of this dinosauriform suggest a quadrupedal gait (Dzik, 2003;Dzik & Sulej, 2007;Kubo & Kubo, 2012), which raises doubts that the bipedal condition was ancestral for Ornithodira (Novas et al., 2021). ...
Comments on the pelvic girdle anatomy of Lagerpeton chanarensis Romer, 1971 (Archosauria) and its implications on the posture and gait of early pterosauromorphs
Article
Lagerpeton chanarensis is an early avemetatarsalian from the lower Carnian (lowermost Upper Triassic) levels of the Chañares Formation, La Rioja Province, Argentina. Lagerpeton and its kin were traditionally interpreted as dinosaur precursors of cursorial habits, with a bipedal posture and parasagittal gait. Some authors also speculated saltatorial capabilities for this genus. Recent analyses indicate that lagerpetids are early‐diverging pterosauromorphs, a hypothesis that invites a review of most aspects of their anatomy and function. A revision of available specimens and additional preparation of previously known individuals indicate that Lagerpeton lacked a parasagittal gait and was probably a sprawling archosaur. This latter inference is based on the femoral head articulation with the acetabulum. The acetabular rim has a strongly laterally projected posteroventral antitrochanteric corner, which results in a position of the legs that recalls that of sprawling living reptiles, such as lizards, and departs from the parasagittally positioned limbs of dinosaurs. This may indicate that early pterosauromorphs had a sprawling posture of their hindlegs, casting doubts on the significance of bipedal posture and parasagittal gait for the radiation of early ornithodirans, given that both traits have been regarded as key features that triggered the ecological and evolutionary success of the clade. Our results bolster recent claims of a high ecomorphological diversity among early avemetatarsalians.
View
... Other sphenosuchids such as the late Carnian-Norian Dromicosuchus grallator (Sues et al., 2003) and the Norian Saltoposuchus connectens (Spiekman, 2023), also have finely serrated teeth, whereas the Lower Jurassic Kayentasuchus walkeri lacks serrations (Clark and Sues, 2002). The theropod Daemonosaurus chauliodus (Sues et al., 2011), is similar, although the teeth are notably taller and the denticle serrations and oval bases in some phytosaurs (Brusatte et al., 2013;Datta et al., 2021) make them possible candidates. However, the comparative figures in Heckert (2004, fig . ...
View
... The dorsal projection of LFKL-004 from dorsal view shows no rapid expansion at orbit as what is found in tyrannosaurids and abelisauroids, making the projection close to a slim isosceles triangle. This is similar to allosauirds (Madsen 1976;Rauhut and Pol 2019;Baiano and Eonardo 2022), D. wetherilli (Marsh 2015;Marsh and Rowe 2020), ceolophysoids (Rowe 1989) , H. ischigualatoensis (Sereno and Novas 1994) and other early-derivied theropods (Sues et al. 2011;Pacheco et al. 2019;Nesbitt and Sues 2021). The width of the skull in occiput measured at the jaw joint of quadratojugal is 224.8 mm, and the mandible measured at the posterior ends of articulars is 213.1 mm. ...
A New Specimen of Sinosaurus triassicus (Dinosauria: Theropoda) from the Early Jurassic of Lufeng, Yunnan, China View supplementary material A New Specimen of Sinosaurus triassicus (Dinosauria: Theropoda) from the Early Jurassic of Lufeng, Yunnan, China
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 2023
The holotype of Sinosaurus triassicus is poorly preserved, and no previous research has focused exclusively on its anatomy. This research reports a new specimen recovered near the locality of the holotype of S. triassicus including a complete skull with mandible and 11 cervical vertebrae. Three newly identified traits are proposed to be unique of the species-(1) a vertical crest developed dorsoventrally from the ventral portion of the maxilla to the nasal crest; (2) ventral border of the antorbital fenestra formed mostly by the anterior process of the jugal; and (3) a fenestra between the nasal, the lacrimal and the prefrontal. This research provides new information on the cranial anatomy of this species as well as the genus Sinosaurus, offering more accessibility for later research concerning the evolution of early deriving neotheropods. ARTICLE HISTORY
View
... Langer and Benton 2006;Upchurch et al. 2007; Yates 2017a, b;Nesbitt and Chatterjee 2008;Martínez and Alcober 2009;Alcober and Martínez 2010). Yet, other analyses continued to recover the more traditional theropodan position of E. lunensis (e.g.Ezcurra 2006Ezcurra , 2010Ezcurra and Novas 2007;Nesbitt et al. 2009;Langer et al. 2011;Novas et al. 2011;Sues et al. 2011). More recently, a third alternative was proposed, this time placing E. lunensis as one of the earliest branching sauropodomorphs.This hypothesis was supported by multiple subsequent studies (e.g. ...
The Early Radiation of Sauropodomorphs in the Carnian (Late Triassic) of South America
Chapter
  • Apr 2022
Carnian (Late Triassic) deposits of South America provide the oldest unequivocal dinosaur records worldwide, most of which has been assigned to the sauropodomorph lineage. This includes Eoraptor lunensis, Panphagia protos, and Chromogisaurus novasi, from the Ischigualasto Formation, Argentina, and Saturnalia tupiniquim, Pampadromaeus barberenai, Buriolestes schultzi, and Bagualosaurus agudoensis, from the Santa Maria Formation, Brazil. Here, we demonstrate that their holotypes anatomically differ from one another, supporting the taxonomic validity of the species. In addition, a morphological disparity analysis, with significant statistical support, clustered some of the better-known specimens of E. lunensis, Sat. tupiniquim, and Bu. schultzi, with the respective holotypes. For the latter two taxa, this was corroborated by a specimen-level phylogenetic analysis that also found Ba. agudoensis as the sister taxon to post-Carnian sauropodomorphs. Our results also suggest that Bu. schultzi and E. lunensis are the earliest branching sauropodomorphs and that Sa. tupiniquim and Pam. barberenai are closer to Bagualosauria. A species-level phylogenetic analysis further suggests that Bu. schultzi and E. lunensis form a clade, that Sa. tupiniquim is the sister taxon to Bagualosauria, and that Pan. protos and Ch. novasi are also more highly nested, forming a clade with Pam. barberenai.
View
... Tawa has been found to be a theropod in several analyses (e. g. Nesbitt et al., 2009;Sues et al., 2011;Martill et al., 2016;Baron et al., 2017) and lacks a fibular flange (Nesbitt et al., 2009). Chilesaurus also lacks a fibular flange, and although it has been considered to be a theropod (Novas et al., 2015), it has also been suggested to be an ornithischian (Baron et al., 2017a). ...
PhD thesis: REASSESSMENT OF THE EVOLUTIONARY HISTORY OF THE LATE TRIASSIC AND EARLY JURASSIC SAUROPODOMORPH DINOSAURS THROUGH COMPARATIVE CLADISTICS AND THE SUPERMATRIX APPROACH
Thesis
Full-text available
  • Oct 2020
Non-sauropod sauropodomorphs, also known as 'basal sauropodomorphs' or 'prosauropods', have been thoroughly studied in recent years. Several hypotheses on the interrelationships within this group have been proposed, ranging from a complete paraphyly, where the group represents a grade from basal saurischians to Sauropoda, to a group on its own. The grade-like hypothesis is the most accepted; however, the relationships between the different taxa are not consistent amongst the proposed scenarios. These inconsistencies have been attributed to missing data and unstable (i.e., poorly preserved) taxa, nevertheless, an extensive comparative cladistic analysis has found that these inconsistencies instead come from the character coding and character selection, plus the strategies on merging data sets. Furthermore, a detailed character analysis using information theory and mathematical topology as an approach for character delineation is explored here to operationalise characters and reduce the potential impact of missing data. This analysis also produced the largest and most comprehensive matrix after the reassessment and operationalisation of every character applied to this group far. Additionally, partition analyses performed on this data set have found consistencies in the interrelationships within non-sauropod Sauropodomorpha and has found strong support for smaller clades such as Plateosauridae, Riojasauridae, Anchisauridae, Massospondylinae and Lufengosarinae. The results of these analyses also highlight a different scenario on how quadrupedality evolved, independently originating twice within the group, and provide a better framework to understand the palaeo-biogeography and diversification rate of the first herbivore radiation of dinosaurs.
View
View
The effect of character and outgroup choice on the phylogenetic position of the Jurassic dinosaur Chilesaurus diegosaurezi
Article
  • Dec 2022
  • Palaeoworld
The systematic position of the unusual Late Jurassic dinosaur Chilesaurus diegosaurezi remains an area of real uncertainty. Originally thought to be an unusual theropod, Chilesaurus has, since its first discovery, been suggested to either be a sauropodomorph dinosaur, an early diverging, ‘transitional’ ornithischian, or a more ‘derived’ neornithischian dinosaur, close to the heterodontosaurs. However, despite these recent fluctuations, the original placement within Theropoda remains the most prevalent phylogenetic hypothesis. This study looks to critically assess these various competing hypotheses regarding Chilesaurus and to analyse various aspects of the anatomical datasets that have placed it within Theropoda, Sauropodomorpha and Ornithischia. The choice of anatomical characters in past studies is considered and, crucially, so too is the choice of operational taxonomic units. By revising the datasets used in the initial analyses of Chilesaurus, one cause of this phylogenetic uncertainty has been clearly identified – outgroup choice. The total absence of members of Ornithischia from the predominantly saurischian-taxon-based datasets used in the original phylogenetic analyses of Chilesaurus is here shown to have had a substantial effect on the systematic position that was first recovered for this taxon. By scoring a selection of basal ornithischian taxa into the primarily saurischian datasets previously used, this study has recovered a different position for the Chilesaurus within Dinosauria, different internal topologies within Theropoda, and even a different arrangement of three major dinosaurian groups. The inclusion of an ornithischian outgroup in an otherwise predominantly saurischian focused dataset has produced results that again suggest that Chilesaurus could be an early diverging member of Ornithischia. What is more, this result was achieved without the addition of any classical ornithischian-like characters to the data. Whilst the results of this analysis do not by any means end the debate on the phylogenetic position of Chilesaurus, or on the fundamental relationships within Dinosauria, they do serve to highlight the current instability of such cryptic taxa in phylogenetic analyses, as well as the need for more comprehensive taxon sampling in such analyses generally. The results further highlight the potentially adverse effects of the omission of certain outgroup taxa on the overall topologies recovered within clades.
View
The interrelationships and evolution of basal theropod dinosaurs
Article
Full-text available
  • Jan 2003
  • Spec Paper Palaeontology
Many recent studies of theropod relationships have been focused on the phylogeny of coelurosaurs and the question of the origin of birds, but the interrelationships and evolution of basal theropods are still poorly understood. Thus, this paper presents a phylogenetic analysis of all theropods, but focuses on the basal members of this clade. The result supports the inclusion of Eoraptor and herrerasaurids in the Theropoda, but differs from other recent studies in two main aspects: (1) The taxa usually grouped as ceratosaurs form two monophyletic clades that represent successively closer outgroups to tetanurans. The more basal of these clades, the Coelophysoidea, comprise the majority of Late Triassic and Early Jurassic theropods. The other clade of basal theropods that are usually included in the Ceratosauria comprises Ceratosaurus, Elaphrosaurus, and abelisaurids. (2) Two monophyletic groups of basal tetanurans are recognized: the Spinosauroidea and the Allosauroidea. In contrast to other recent phylogenetic hypotheses, both clades are united in a monophyletic Carnosauria. The branching pattern of the present cladogram is in general accordance with the stratigraphic occurrence of theropod taxa. Despite the differences in recent analyses, there is a significant level of consensus in theropod phylogeny. At least four different radiations of non-avian theropods can be recognized. These radiations show different patterns in Laurasia and Gondwana, and there are increasing differences between the theropod faunas of the two hemispheres from the Triassic to the Cretaceous.
View
View
Geology and taphonomy of the Coelophysis Quarry, Upper Triassic Chinle Formation, Ghost Ranch, New Mexico
Article
Full-text available
  • Sep 1994
The main bone-bearing strata are abandoned channel deposits that are part of a siltstone overbank sequence. The Coleophysis remains found at the quarry are remarkably whole and well preserved, though they range in degree of articulation from complete skeletons to isolated limbs and bones. Skeletons, partial skeletons, and bones are crudely aligned and show little evidence of predator or scavenger disturbance or surface weathering. Geologic and taphonomic evidence suggests that the dinosaurs preserved in the Ghost Ranch quarry were transported to the site as carcasses by fluvial currents. -from Authors
View
Ceratosauria
Chapter
Full-text available
  • Dec 2004
Ceratosauria represents the first widespread and diverse radiation of theropod dinosaurs comprising two main sister clades, Neoceratosauria and Coelophysoidea. This chapter discusses the diagnostic features, phylogenetic placement, and paleobiology of ceratosaurians. The fossil record for Ceratosauria spans a minimum of 155 million years, from the late Carnian of the Late Triassic to the end of the Cretaceous. Ceratosaurs had an essentially global distribution, their remains being found on every continent except Australia and Antarctica. Ceratosaurs evolved into a broad range of sizes and body forms, from lightly built, diminutive taxa such as Segisaurus (1 to 1.5 m in length) to the large abelisaurids, such as Carnotaurus (10 to 11 m). Several coelophysoid taxa were collected from mass burials, where multiple individuals were preserved together. In particular, Syntarsus rhodesiensis is known from at least thirty individuals found at localities in Zimbabwe and South Africa.
View
View
View
View
A juvenile coelophysoid skull from the Early Jurassic of Zimbabwe, and the synonymy of Coelophysis and Syntarsus
Article
  • Jan 2004
Several authors have drawn attention to the close similarities between the neotheropod dinosaurs Coelophyis and Syntarsus. Reconstruction and analysis of a skull from a juvenile specimen of Syntarsus (collected from the Forest Sandstone Formation of Zimbabwe) show that cranial characters previously used to distinguish these taxa and justify their generic separation (namely the presence of a 'nasal fenestra' in Syntarsus and the length of its antorbital fenestra), were based on erroneous reconstructions of disassociated cranial elements. On the basis of this reinterpretation we conclude that Syntarsus is a junior synonym of Coelophysis. Variations are noted in three cranial characters - the length of the maxillary tooth row, the width of the base of the lachrymal and the shape of the antorbital maxillary fossa - that taken together with the chronological and geographical separation of the two taxa justify separation at species level.
View
Variation in Coelophysis bauri
Chapter
  • Nov 1990
The large series of skeletons and partial skeletons of Coelophysis bauri collected from the Upper Triassic Chinle Formation at Ghost Ranch, New Mexico, affords an opportunity to study the ontogeny, individual variation, and possible sexual dimorphism in this species. It is estimated that there was probably between a ten to fifteenfold increase in size from hatchling to adult, during which there were proportional changes in the size of the orbit, length of the neck, and length of the hind limb and some changes in skull proportions. Substantive differences are to be seen in individual variations, which are especially marked between two adult specimens of approximately the same size. These differences may be an expression of sexual dimorphism. Fusion or the lack of fusion in the ankle seems to be independent of size, and seemingly is a mark of individual variation. -from Author
View
The Triassic Dinosaur Coelophysis
Article
  • Jan 1989
lots o measurements!
View