Content uploaded by Guus Labooy
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Guus Labooy on Oct 15, 2016
Content may be subject to copyright.
An assessment of Stenmarks
1 Introducon
! " #
$" ! %%& & #
'(%)%$*(%
+ ( % , '
!-%#.%
#) !%!!#* .!&
! # ! # " "
% !%.!# !
/ # # -% ! % !
%#& !0 % %% 1" # #
! & # ! !
!,
% #!#% % 2
,#! %
3#! "%,!(4
3 % !!% & )&
! ! &*
3 ! % & &
%
3%&&%% &
5 %!#! #,
!! ! ! )* & " %%
%% ! &%""%6"
&!%!!!!%!
%%7!#.!#
( & % %
%worldview-parsan science&899:#
2 Stenmarks concept of Parsan Science
#"!%%% 0!
%!#!#0!(,
; )%* !#
!%%%! &" "#!#
8 )%* !#
%%%! &" "#!#
< !(" " = + !
- ! #!#% >-" #
!!!,
$ )%*&'(!#&%
#&
: ) % * & '(! #&
%#&
># ; ! 8 % # :, &
% !% ; %#$& !(,
&!=# -"&
!!##%"
%!%!3!"
, ! -- &#&" !%
!"#%%!#,
!-
!#" &!
" !! %?!!&"
%" /& /
@ & # ! !=!!" #" !
"#! %0!#,
A&" ! ! # % (
%,
; ;
8 % 8
$ B( $
: %% :
C!-% #!!&8 !$!
" % 8 )8*" & (! ! %" &
!% &% #!%!!A -%%!
! #&! !%$" &
(&!A&-%!
%!%!& (&'(! - 0%
B( ! -!& -'(
! C !" %% #! '! !
&% #!!! '(%"
!%%! %-%"'(%%
!! ! .A# %%%& &
& (&)$*
#%!%#
>-"##!%%&%#!#%
!%D ! %;"8!:" #!,
"#$%! 0 #"%&%!&
! #!#0 % ) * -% &
!& ! "-!-%
#!#% &8, # % =# ! 3 3 # !
!% &" ! -%& & % 2 #
=# & !%%? #"#"
!%, %;" 8! :'%% %3!
E !! !!2#!#
% ( %5 "A( 5
%&&%#!#"(&#!
#!&!&
= &
% !! #! %%,
!%&"& %$
"#A
3 The demarcaon of phase 2 and 3
C-&!#EA,$! &
%%%&%#!#"
! &- !, 0 ! %! & ( & &
! %!" %!" !
&" %&" ! -%& %# C # !F& # -&
7%$02(%$!
%!G# !& %8" %$
#& !!! %& % =#" & &
#! %!"!
# % 8 ! % $ % % ! #
(&&%'(%"&
"#! 0 !'(%!
#!%!"# &% #!!
!-#%!(%8!$"#
!F&,!%#%&
A%%%$#%!&%8#
!! %%8!$"!"&
-C#'#
0!%&!(0!(:,
& '(! #&%#&
! " : %#8"%& % "
%#%$ #="#E&
%$!!!'&"2!E#
E 5 ! %& #
%!!%E"#"&!:!8
!&%)'(*
4 Pung non-parsan science3 to the test
##!!%$&"&% &
!( 0 %&&# A#
># 0%( -% & - H&"
-%%%%#&!%;!8
# C '(%"#"& !!%&
A" & &% ! ) !
! 4*" %%% <! & ! & ! % &
"& !!(%C
#!!F&&' & &
%! A&
-%#!&%<!!%&%
# # ! '% ) " '%
!-* 0 &% ! & 0H )0& H &* 0H " "
%#C#%!#&%"#%%#
# ! %&,#! # ' <! E--
#&&#&(-! #" #0H" ! = & ## E
=#"!!$"#
"&!!7 !%& !<!
#& &&&%%#!#"
" 5 ! # &% % 8 ! !&
! !% A&# %$EB&
&''E3%%&#%8
# !%$%!!!&,A%%
%$-!&%83!%,&#!
%)%8*" %)%;*
5 %& & %% #& %%
<! # A$" #
% , =& % # &4 >
())8*%!2!&%%"
1&!! 3 # !
##%&EB#0H"!!
! !A %
&% !'! &#! !
#!#"&%"#%"%%%
! & % % $ &" # &
2!%8)!%;*"'
0!&&&%!! %
;"8!:0&!&#!%!%&
&"(I!!!--3#&
'&&&%!&!%#(
'(% & % &&%E C&!%%, &
%A# !)2
&" %%!&<!*
!&#!! !!!#0
-%,3!
! ( & - !'!
!(&--0% %$"
3 # !, !'! ! ! 3 # & &
!! %! ! #! ! ' <!
<%!!# -%# %+&
!!30-%#&!& &
" " & ! " !%
&%! !"!##)&*##
!BB"#! &%
J(-K" 3! "
#! & (- " !
"#!# %! !"#&!#
%%&E
5 Some pros of non-parsan science3
+! 0(!#
#!! &!##
% $ &# $ !(
%,&%%$ !
@ !!"4=#"!
%$ &"!& !
3 % ! 0
!&%&&&!(! &
>! &% # %
!!"#!! ""
&5#!-!0" #%
! &#"
#%!2!" %
=! ,#H #3
#!<!!!%(-!
& - ! & ! !! %
(A&--#&%&!$"
0%# !!&
%,#!! %#%'% E
"! -% & ! $ ! !%
%E > !" & = # & #
% I % & #!# &"
!%"H!'!
#0-%#& !( !!
%!!5%!#%"!"&!!#
!&&!%##!#0
#& !!%%!(!%"
!# !2( !$
3 %% !! %$ %%&(!% "
#'& !#!#E%%
#%'%�H# !#& "
# "!!!
-H'! '%& #
L " &" & !" # &
%! &)& " " ! # & #
/!&& !# "'-%*
% % H #!# # %%%
%#!#'(%)%8*>!"
!!&I &&0"
#& %%% #!#" , !! !
F
=#"! (&
!0!&!"! "& !
# ! % % !&!#
% &!! 'E 3 ! %
! ! " & &" %" ! #
=#"# !%% #C
#!A!EL#&!3&"!
%% &" # " !& 0 #
! & %( % ! %% ! #
#"#!"%$ ,C&
!#& ##E--5&#&%!!
%#!##!%%% " #&
! !! ! !!! %
( ! $ ! %"
'(&%%%&'(!"&
-%!& %#!#B #!!" & '(
%$!&%2.
(!
6 No neutral science3
C!#&%$&&% <!C#
! %&!F(%$!"
!%! 3!
"&%#"#L
%& <! #! " ! !
3&!!!
!" %& !, % #!#
--
5 ! <! #& & & @
# %%&" &" &"%& &! &--
#%(HA&" !!
( ! & 3 ! &
"#!!&C%!<!%
)"#%%%%%,&%!&%/
%!/*0"2!
! ! )&
%!*5#!'(-%"
! ! " # %%% & # & # &
--
7 To conclude
!(%$!A&! &!!
! ! 0!F& # %$ !
( %" '( % ! !
"%%&!"&!! %$"
%%%! &" &! % $!&"
%%&%&%! 7%%&
" # %-%=#" #! !&#
0 -%! #-- 0 #
! ,&%#!!
!%6I #!!%!
% $ ! ! & < ! @
!" %! #! %% ! ( !
!&3!#! &!! &
& !& %!"! &(!
" ! ! & % " !
% $" % % 0 A& #
!!
Abstract
"
#%, !#%%%
! &" " #!# =#" # !
-%,'(%)%$*A 0"
$ " $(!
# !# !#!!
Key words: %$"%"! " "
0-!!&% *)*
89;;"!"L?&
"")<!D%!" ,M!"899:*
!"N;O
!";PQ;
% )899:* ! )89;8*, J=# D HL !
K,B3%)M!*"<! 2)M!*"+,*
*")3#"89;8*"P$R$0#*)*89;;C
0D!"<M! DH"#
%!&%% & #%!!!
!" !& & %%%! &
(#! (#%!#&% &
%%!<!# &""#"! !
"<!! !!!"
%#! #<!!
!
)899:*"%O
!";RO;RR0(@"A
- "J, EK - )";$);NNP*,$PQ
$N:)899:*,;Q:;QO
-!!&" !(,!";RR;Q9
O )%* )*%#&
P )%* #!
!%%!! " "#!#
R )%* #!
!%%!! " "#!#
-!"8;:
-!";RQ
-!"8;O
-!"8$;
-= %!%,-('(
& #&!! #
-=!-!&-
'(!=!%!!!
'(%%#&=#"%%%
%#%# &&
!&# ,%#"&#,
#&F#)899:*"8;P!!#!#
$"A !%%%#&!
0!&(& &!(%2
- <=+&"J0=&S H%!& K"
./+;$,8)899:*,N;;9;
-& 6=# "0&!0.1
.) "899P*";;8;;$
-- JM" >&" ! ! &, D%& ! S 0K" ,
"D0)!*"2(**)H! ,0"899;*"
;RN8$P
--0" !!%!%!I!!!%&!
.%!#!!
! %!A! % &
--!"8$O
--!"8$R
-- J! >K" , " D0 )!*" 2 ( *
*)H! ,0"899;*"$OQ
--0%!'%!!,
!!&#
&#"! "<!)*
--&-(##
"H%0 &")3>#G,+ "
8998*
-- "34)5-!,5?"89;;*";PQ;R:"#
!##! !
-- C + H " B ! )M!*" + , * 5
+")C&3#"89;8*