ArticlePDF Available

A General Theory of Network Governance: Exchange Conditions and Social Mechanisms

DOI:10.2307/259249
Authors:
Candace Jones at The University of Edinburgh
Candace Jones
William Hesterly at University of Utah
William Hesterly
Stephen P Borgatti at University of Kentucky
Stephen P Borgatti
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

A phenomenon of the last 20 years has been the rapid rise of the network form of governance. This governance form has received significant scholarly attention, but, to date, no comprehensive theory for it has been advanced, and no sufficiently detailed and theoretically consistent definition has appeared. Our objective in this article is to provide a theory that explains under what conditions network governance, rigorously defined, has comparative advantage and is therefore likely to emerge and thrive. Our theory integrates transaction cost economics and social network theories, and, in broad strokes, asserts that the network form of governance is a response to exchange conditions of asset specificity, demand uncertainty, task complexity, and frequency. These exchange conditions drive firms toward structurally embedding their transactions, which enables firms to use social mechanisms for coordinating and safeguarding exchanges. When all of these conditions are in place, the network governance form has advantages over both hierarchy and market solutions in simultaneously adapting, coordinating, and safeguarding exchanges.
Content uploaded by Stephen P Borgatti
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Stephen P Borgatti on Mar 16, 2016
Content may be subject to copyright.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
... Where networks are "lighter on their feet than hierarchies", and exchanges are carried out only by the members of the network(s) through "reciprocal, preferential, mutually supportive actions" (Powell et al., 1990). A similar definition was also proposed in the work of Jones, Hesterly, and Borgati, which views NG as a select, persistent, and structured set of autonomous organisations engaged in non-legally binding contracts to adapt to environmental contingencies and to coordinate and safeguard exchanges (Jones et al., 1997). Thus, NG presents itself as a useful framework with its emphasis on the importance and precedence of states (states' autonomy) and the exchanges between member states that define the networks forged in the organisation itself (Kim, 2006). ...
... The participants of ARF are the ASEAN member states and Australia, Bangladesh, Canada, China, India, the EU, Japan, Mongolia, New Zealand, North Korea, Pakistan, Papua New Guinea, Russia, South Korea, Sri Lanka, Timor Leste, and the US. This set of fixed members in the ARF network hold repeated interactions with each other over time through annual ministerial meetings, aligns with the concept of NG as involving a "select, persistent, and structured set of autonomous entities [firms] based on implicit contracts to adapt to environmental contingencies and to coordinate and safeguard exchanges" (Jones et al., 1997). ...
ASEAN as network governance: An alternative lens to evaluate policymaking and performance
Article
Full-text available
  • Oct 2023
Background: This article offers a new perspective of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) as network governance (NG) using the policy network theory (PNT) for the analysis. Methods: Two case studies were selected from the ASEAN Community to examine the applicability and effectiveness of NG in promoting ASEAN cooperation. These case studies were chosen due to their prominence and the prevalence of critical comments about their effectiveness in promoting cooperation. The content analysis utilised primary data from ASEAN reports, documents, research articles and processes, and studies on NG and policy networks. A literature review was conducted using online academic databases and ASEAN-related websites. The search covered the period from June 2019 to March 2021, with further searches conducted between January and July 2023. These data collection efforts provided a robust analysis of the case studies within the NG and ASEAN integration contexts. Results: The findings show ASEAN as a hybrid structure which has supported its survival and relevance. This approach provides legitimacy for ASEAN globally by purposefully adopting structures similar to the EU without the supranational elements. It also showcases ASEAN’s motivation for asserting its centrality. Adopting a hybrid structure has led to ASEAN's soft institutionalisation, driven by its norms and characterised by a less empowered secretariat, where the member states are the decision-makers and implementors of policies. It opens a pathway to recognising ASEAN states’ autonomy, where the actors’ will and interests affect decision-making and define performance. Conclusions: This article demonstrates NG's viability in promoting ASEAN's centrality in regional cooperation and institutional arrangements and allows for a nuanced assessment of its performance considering the context of the issue and ASEAN's history and emphasising the member states' primacy in policymaking. The NG framework contributes to ASEAN’s legitimacy, regional cooperation and performance despite its inherent limitations.
View
... Al estructurar la red a partir del criterio del intercambio de recursos cabe resaltar la importancia que adquieren las propiedades estructurales de la red por cuanto que el modo como se estructuran los actores participantes en las redes de política pública al intercambiar recursos es un factor determinante de que se generen una serie de objetivos (ver a Jones, Hesterly y Borgatti, 1997y Crozier y Friedberg, 1980, que si bien no igualmente esperados, si en cierto modo interdependientes (Carlsson, 2000). ...
Gobernanza y redes de política pública: un estudio de la vinculación entre gobierno, actores público-sociales y privados en un área local turística
Article
  • Aug 2014
Desde el marco conceptual de las redes de política pública, este trabajo analiza algunos de los rasgos de los esquemas de gobernanza contemporáneos. Para ello, utilizo el análisis de redes sociales a fin de sistematizar una red de política pública estimulada por un programa público implementado en el pueblo turístico de Valle de Bravo. Los resultados sugieren que se han generado estructuras alternativas para atender los asuntos públicos, en las cuales hay actores no gubernamentales con mayor dominio, así como hay recursos de mayor importancia que los gubernamentales a efecto deque la política funcione.Palabras Clave: dependencia de recursos, propiedades estructurales, actores, red y asuntos públicos.
View
... Theoretical bases are helpful to provide important lenses for understanding SA research (Rabetino et al., 2021). Previous studies have summarized some widespread popular theories applied to SA research, such as the resource-based view (RBV) (Barney, 1991), transaction cost economics (TCE) (Williamson, 1991), the social network theory (SNT) (Jones et al., 1997), the knowledge-based view (KBV) (Grant, 1996), the organizational learning theory (OLT) (Crossan et al., 1999), the institutional theory (IT) (Dacin et al., 2007), and the dynamic capability theory (DCT) (Teece et al., 1997). This paper focuses more on reviewing these popular theories on SA research under three main headings: formation, governance, and achieving alliance performance. ...
What Changes and Opportunities Does Big Data Analytics Capability Bring to Strategic Alliance Research? A Systematic Literature Review
Article
Full-text available
Strategic alliance theories have been studied widely over the past few decades. However, their key arguments may face new limitations and challenges brought by emerging technologies such as big data analytics capability (BDAC). This paper aims to identify the challenges BDAC brings to strategic alliance theories and the associated changes to strategic alliance research. Specifically, this paper systematically reviews and identifies how BDAC challenges the key arguments in the strategic alliances' theories through the lens of three stages of strategic alliances: formation, governance and achieving alliance performance. Meanwhile , this study also finds some changes in strategic alliance research brought by BDAC. Finally, this study proposes promising directions for future research on strategic alliances under the influences of BDAC.
View
... Development of a pilot sampling strategy for fine unit sampling in small areas (from pump-station to manhole) First detection of COVID-19 in rivers downstream of informal settlements, and in greywater run-off from these settlements The SACCESS network can be thought of as an example of network governance which is defined as co-ordination between organisations characterised by an organic or informal social system. 15 Networks and network governance have been theorised extensively. Network trajectories can be either serendipitous or goal-directed, with differing operational and structural dynamics. ...
The SACCESS network for COVID-19 wastewater surveillance: a national collaboration for public health responsiveness
Article
Full-text available
  • Apr 2022
The global COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the need for stronger health systems, and the potential role of networks in this strengthening. In the early phase of the pandemic, wastewater surveillance as a predictive and monitoring tool for COVID-19 was identified internationally. This realisation alerted researchers in South Africa, who through various pathways formed the South African Collaborative COVID-19 Environmental Surveillance System (SACCESS) network. Made up of a wide range of actors, SACCESS has progressed rapidly in a field with many unknowns. This qualitative case study aimed to explore the lessons that the SACCESS network provides in terms of network governance and bottom-up collaboration, and to apply this to health system strengthening. Key informant interviews (n=12) were conducted with purposively selected members of the SACCESS network. Data were analysed thematically. Four main themes emerged: the enabling factors of network formation in the time of COVID-19; the importance of relationships; strengths and challenges of an informal network; and lessons for building health systems. Several lessons emerged for health system strengthening in the time of COVID-19 and beyond: the importance of informal networks, and bottom-up collaboration; recognition that individuals, not institutions, are key in informal networks; and the time required for building trust. It is important for network governance to be flexible as it evolves, particularly in times of crisis. It may be difficult for an informal network to interact with more formal, bureaucratic structures. There is need to explore how to create a recognised role and space for informal networks, such as the SACCESS network, to move towards stronger health systems.
View
Innovating toward CSR: Creating Value by Empowering Employees, Customers and Stockholders
Conference Paper
Full-text available
  • Nov 2023
This paper examines innovation through corporate social responsibility (CSR), which among other things, encourages corporations to represent more stakeholder interests than just those of stockholders. Limitations of the traditional corporation relate to internalization and hierarchy, as the traditional goal of the corporation is to maximize internalized value, perhaps even at the expense of its customers and employees. However, a problem with stakeholder capitalism may occur when value and power are too dispersed, and value-creation is not measured. To address these problems, the organization must innovate how it organizes, and engage its most critical stakeholders-its employees and customers.
View
Performance implications of match between social media–enabled interactions and contracts in interfirm governance
Article
Purpose Integrating transaction costs economics and task-technology fit theory, this study distinguishes two categories of social media–enabled interactions, namely task-related interactions and tie-related interactions, and explores the match between these two and firms' use of contracts in achieving safeguarding and coordinating purposes in interfirm governance. Design/methodology/approach Two studies were conducted to test the hypotheses. In Study 1, this study collaborated with a professional market research firm and collected responses from Chinese manufacturing firms in a survey. In Study 2, this study designed a scenario-based experiment and collected 239 participants from the Credamo platform. Findings This study categorized social media–enabled interactions into task-related interactions and tie-related interactions and conducted two studies to reveal that the safeguarding purpose of contract specificity is amplified by tie-related interactions, whereas the coordinating purpose of contract specificity is strengthened by task-related interactions. Research limitations/implications This study assumes that firms permit and encourage the use of social media. However, some firms might prohibit the use of social media due to risk issues, or their partners may be prohibited from using social media. Practical implications Given that social media–enabled interactions have joint effects with contracts in achieving safeguarding and coordinating purposes, a firm's employees should match their goals with an appropriate type of social media–enabled interactions. Originality/value This study enriches the interfirm governance literature by uncovering the roles of these two types of interactions in matching contract specificity to achieve safeguarding and coordinating purposes, which provides actionable insights for managers in governing interfirm relationships.
View
Vantagens competitivas observadas em uma rede de cooperação para comercialização de artigos esportivos
Article
  • Apr 2009
O objetivo deste artigo foi identificar e analisar vantagens competitivas que surgiram pela ação em rede de lojas de material esportivo no RS, participantes do programa Redes de Cooperação da Secretaria de Desenvolvimento e Assuntos Internacionais do Estado. A rede é formada por vinte e três lojas, que têm quarenta pontos de venda. O método de pesquisa foi o estudo de caso exploratório. As principais vantagens competitivas identificadas foram: vantagens nas negociações e poder de barganha; redução de riscos; conhecimento; marketing compartilhado e troca de informações. Também, foram identificadas e comentadas as principais informações trocadas por lojas em uma amostra da região central do Estado. Palavras–chave: Redes de Cooperação, Competitividade em rede, Informação em rede.
View
View
Can we replicate eco-industrial parks? Recommendations based on a process model of EIP evolution
Article
Full-text available
This article develops a process model of eco-industrial park evolution. It draws on two article communities previously identified through a scoping literature review, concerning the development of eco-industrial parks and industrial symbiosis, respectively. The study seeks to find answers to the main research question: How should phases of eco-industrial park evolution and their critical factors be considered when replicating or reproducing existing eco-industrial park successes in new contexts? By identifying four phases of eco-industrial park evolution and shedding light on the critical factors influencing these, the study presents replication and reproduction recommendations, and thereby provides knowledge to diffuse success stories into other contexts. The study undersores the need for a flexible and adaptive approach to diffusion of EIP successes, considering elements such as the costs and benefits of replication, the idiosyncratic nature of some critical factors, and their relevance in the new context. Moreover, the results of the study highlight the need for capacity building in the replicatee context, focusing on mobilizing and activating existing resources to curate initiatives for EIP formation. Strong collaboration between the replicator and replicatee, where empowerment is central, is seen as a key factor in effective EIP replication.
View
Partnership for Improvement: How a Leadership Compact Fostered Relational Change Between Five Hospital Chief Executives and Their Regulator
Chapter
  • Oct 2023
In this chapter, we present an empirical example of a novel partnership between five hospital chief executives (CEOs) and members of their healthcare regulator to explicate how and why a leadership ‘compact’ fostered relational change for inter-organizational learning and improvement. The compact was a written document co-created by the five CEOs with members of the regulator that formalized a shared partnership goal, alongside a set of relational behaviours the five hospital leaders and members of the regulator each agreed to enact. Far from a fanciful set of promises soon to be forgotten, the compact became a ‘living document’ that successfully fostered relational change, highlighting the benefit of a softer, more collaborative approach to regulation for improvement. Drawing upon longitudinal observational data, we describe how a monthly ‘partnership meeting’ acted as a regular, formal trigger for the cognitive appraisal of the promises set out in the compact, reinforcing the shared goals of the partnership and providing a safe relational space for conflict resolution. Our findings shine a light on the how of relational change between organizations where asymmetries of power and authority persist, and how a softer, more collaborative approach to regulation could play a vital role in shaping high quality, affordable and equitable healthcare.
View
View
Toward the Flexible Form: How to Remain Vital in Hypercompetitive Environments
Article
Full-text available
Hypercompetition has received much attention, but an important question has not been answered: What organizational forms lead to success in hypercompetitive environments? Hypercompetition forces firms to move more quickly and boldly and to experiment in ways that do not conform to traditional administrative theory. Bureaucratic vertical forms severely hamper the ability to respond to accelerating competition. Flexible forms, in contrast, can respond to a wide variety of changes in the competitive environment in an appropriate and timely way. The author examines several alternative flexible forms for coping with hypercompetitive environments. Flexibility derives from the repertoire of managerial capabilities (management challenge) and the responsiveness of the organization (organization design challenge). On the basis of theories of control, the author argues that organizational flexibility is inherently paradoxical and requires a constructive friction between change and preservation. The paradox of flexibility is portrayed in a conceptual model that relates competitive environments, certain types of flexibility, and organizational conditions. The author develops a rich typology of organizational forms for coping with hypercompetition, each of which reflects a particular way of addressing change and preservation. Furthermore, he explores different trajectories of organizational development over time, especially those relating to revitalization. The implications of the typology for strategy and organization design research in hypercompetitive environments are profound.
View
United artists: The company that changed the film industry
Book
  • Jan 2009
In this second volume of Tino Balio's history of United Artists, he examines the turnaround of the company in the hands of Arthur Krim and Robert Benjamin in the 1950s, when United Artists devised a successful strategy based on the financing and distribution of independent production that transformed the company into an industry leader. Drawing on corporate records and interviews, Balio follows United Artists through its merger with Transamerica in the 1960s and its sale to MGM after the financial debacle of the film Heaven's Gate. With its attention to the role of film as both an art form and an economic institution, United Artists: The Company That Changed the Film Industry is an indispensable study of one company's fortunes from the 1950s to the 1980s and a clear-eyed analysis of the film industry as a whole. This edition includes an expanded introduction that examines the history of United Artists from 1978 to 2008, as well as an account of Arthur Krim's attempt to mirror UA's success at Orion Pictures from 1978 to 1991. © 1987, 2009 The Board of Regents of the University of Wisconsin System. All rights reserved.
View
View
View
View
View
View
View
View