ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

This paper presents a comparison of the characteristics of the tyres of a full-size vehicle with the tyres of a physical model scaled 1:5. This is a continuation of studies on the use of a scaled vehicle to test the stability of a vehicle. The results presented are based on analysis of a scaled vehicle and a full-size vehicle on a stand and during road tests. Tests were carried out involving manoeuvres based on the ISO standard. The effects of the differences in the construction of the tyres of the scaled vehicle and their impact on the tyre characteristics and its behaviour during testing were compared. This paper presents the results of a comparison of selected parameters of motion for a real vehicle and for a mobile scale model. These tests allowed a statement to be made about the suitability of the used tyres and the entire physical model for lateral stability analysis of a full-size vehicle.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Original Article
Proc IMechE Part D:
J Automobile Engineering
2015, Vol. 229(10) 1419–1426
ÓIMechE 2015
Reprints and permissions:
sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/0954407014563734
pid.sagepub.com
The tyre characteristics of the physical
model used to investigate the lateral
stability of a vehicle
Krzysztof Parczewski and Henryk Wne˛k
Abstract
This paper presents a comparison of the characteristics of the tyres of a full-size vehicle with the tyres of a physical
model scaled 1:5. This is a continuation of studies on the use of a scaled vehicle to test the stability of a vehicle. The
results presented are based on analysis of a scaled vehicle and a full-size vehicle on a stand and during road tests. Tests
were carried out involving manoeuvres based on the ISO standard. The effects of the differences in the construction of
the tyres of the scaled vehicle and their impact on the tyre characteristics and its behaviour during testing were com-
pared. This paper presents the results of a comparison of selected parameters of motion for a real vehicle and for a
mobile scale model. These tests allowed a statement to be made about the suitability of the used tyres and the entire
physical model for lateral stability analysis of a full-size vehicle.
Keywords
Lateral stability of a vehicle, scaled vehicle, physical model of a vehicle, tyre characteristics, dynamics of vehicle motion,
similarity
Date received: 29 April 2014; accepted: 17 November 2014
Introduction
During vehicle motion, the transmission of forces
from a vehicle to the ground depends on the condi-
tions of the tyres and the road surface. The wheels,
which are in contact with the road, allow reaction
forces to be generated, which counterbalance the
forces acting on the vehicle in motion or the forces
generated by the powertrain system. The tyres trans-
mit the forces generated in the tyre– road contact
patch, and the behaviour of the vehicle depends on
their properties. The mathematical terms for the reac-
tion between the tyres and the road surface and their
properties describe the tyre models mentioned in the
literature.
1–5
The motion of a car is affected by para-
meters such as the effective wheel radius, the wheel
slip, the rolling resistance and the transmission of the
longitudinal forces and the transverse forces from the
tyre to the road depending on the adhesion condi-
tions, namely the longitudinal, transverse and lateral
slip phenomena. The dynamics of physical models,
regardless of the scale of the vehicle, are studied, and
this shows that the tyre characteristics will influence
the transmission of the forces to the road.
Description of the tests
Ensuring safety in the use of complex technical struc-
tures such as aircrafts, ships or vehicles requires a series
of tests allowing the behaviour of the vehicle to be
checked under the conditions of use. In many cases, it
is possible to test the actual object but, with large items,
these studies are difficult to implement, expensive and
often dangerous. In such cases, the use of smaller-scale
physical models or computer simulations is helpful.
Computer models require determination of and expres-
sions for a large number of parameters characterizing
the vehicle as a whole and its parts. The accuracy of
the calculation depends on the details of the model and
the considered parameters.
Department of Combustion Engines and Vehicles, Faculty of Mechanical
Engineering and Computer Science, University of Bielsko-Biala, Bielsko-
Biala, Poland
Corresponding author:
Krzysztof Parczewski, Department of Combustion Engines and Vehicles,
University of Bielsko-Biala, Willowa 2, Bielsko-Biala 43-309, Poland.
Email: kparczewski@ath.bielsko.pl, hwnek@ath.bielsko.pl
by guest on September 3, 2015pid.sagepub.comDownloaded from
Physical models are based on dimensional analysis
and similarity theory. Preserving similarity allows the
measured motion parameters of the scaled vehicle to be
transposed to the parameters of the real object tested.
The use of the theory of similarity requires preserving
the similarity of the geometric, kinematic and dynamic
models to the real vehicle. This can be achieved by
extracting a number of parameters which, in non-
dimensional notation for the real vehicle and the model,
should be the same.
Fulfilling the criteria of similarity allows interpreta-
tion of the research results on the model and enables
those results to be related to the dynamics of the real
motion of the vehicle. The Buckingham ptheory was
used to determine the scale of the similarity of the indi-
vidual parameters.
6–8
The first step in applying this the-
orem is to collect the vehicle parameters into groups of
dimensionless parameters, also known as the ppara-
meters. These groups can be equivalently obtained by
normalizing the mass scale, the length scale and the
time scale by scaling factors dependent directly on the
vehicle’s mass m, the vehicle’s length Land the vehicle’s
longitudinal velocity Urespectively. For the chosen
scaled vehicle, the dimensionless parameters are pre-
sented in Table 1.
In 1937, Huber and Dietz
9
had already considered
the dynamics of motion of a tractor with a semitrailer.
In 1959, Zakin
10
worked on the instability of tractors.
Japanese researchers have used a rolling roadway simu-
lator as a test bench for analysis of the control algo-
rithms for suspensions, which could take into account
the features of the vehicle. The first computer-
controlled roadway simulator was developed by
Brennan and Allyene
11
and Lapapong et al.
12
at Illinois
University at Urbana-Champaign. Polley et al.
13
devel-
oped and manufactured in a testing laboratory the
Pennsylvania University Rolling Roadway Simulator.
There are several advantages of using a mobile vehi-
cle model, made to scale, instead of the full-size vehicle
for experimental testing of the dynamics of motion.
1. The costs of vehicle tests performed on a scale
model are much less than when tests are made on
the full-size vehicle; the same applies to supplies
and spare parts.
2. The testing of a mobile vehicle model requires less
space and is much safer to handle.
3. It is easier to make changes to the vehicle on a
smaller scale.
4. The scope of the research can be wider. A rollover
vehicle model implies a much lower repair cost.
5. The testing time is shorter.
6. The vehicle model made to scale, except for the
similarity parameters analysed in its construction,
is also characterized by the structural similarity of
the whole model and its bands.
Research on scaled vehicle models has also been car-
ried out in the Department of Combustion Engines and
Vehicles, University of Bielsko-Biala. Currently the
Department has a number of different scale models
used for research and for road tests and tests on a
stand. This allows the characteristics of model assem-
blies and components to be achieved.
14,15
During the construction of a physical model, one of
the problems that required solution was the choice of
tyre parameters on the basis of their characteristics.
Tyre characteristics
The tasks of the tyre are the smooth transfer of power
from the vehicle to the road in various traffic conditions
and provision of adequate isolation of the vibrations
generated by a rough road. Providing similarities of the
Table 1. Dimensionless parameter matching.
No pparameters Full-sized Scaled vehicle
p
1
a1
=
Lw0.650 0.648
p
2
a2
=
Lw0.350 0.349
p
3
CafLw
mU20.392 0.513
p
4
CarLw
mU20.434 0.655
p
5
Izz
mL2
w0.214 0.263
p
6
hGC
=
Lw0.350 0.267
p
7
B
=
L0.562 0.560
p
8
Ixx
mL2
w0.045 0.063
p
9
Iyy
mL2
w0.244 0.210
p
10
ms
=
m0.897 0.863
p
11
ðhGC hRCÞ
=
Lw0.243 0.128
p
12
Kfr
mU20.392 0.216
p
13
Df
mULw0.163 0.058
1420 Proc IMechE Part D: J Automobile Engineering 229(10)
by guest on September 3, 2015pid.sagepub.comDownloaded from
real vehicle and the scaled physical model required choos-
ing comparable isolation parameters of the tyres.
16
Another problem is that, in models with a length
from 0.5 m to 1 m (scale, approximately 1:5), tyres with
polyurethane inserts are usually used. The inserts are
divided into two groups of stiffness: soft and hard.
Pneumatic tyres are not generally produced with these
dimensions. The studies were designed to show the
impact of using tyres of different constructions on the
test results. For comparison we selected 185R15C auto-
mobile tyres (used in the comparable vehicle) and the
tyres used in the physical model (Figure 1) with the fol-
lowing inserts: soft, hard and pumped (inserts used in
place of the inner tube).
Table 2 presents a comparison of the tyres selected.
Comparison of the tyre parameters is required to
carry out a series of tests to identify the radial and longi-
tudinal stiffnesses, the lateral cornering stiffnesses of the
tyres, the rolling resistance, the footprint (the contact
patch area) of the tyres, etc. The study omitted determi-
nation of the coefficient of adhesion because testing was
carried out on a clean dry surface. Because it was impos-
sible to measure the cornering stiffnesses of the automo-
tive tyres, an elastic beam analogy was used.
17
Using the Hewson model, the cornering stiffness of
the tyres was determined on the basis of the
relationship
17
Ca=2Ebw3
(r+wa)2sinfarccos½1swa=(r+wa)g
1
psinfarccos½1swa=(r+wa)g
ð1Þ
Analysis was also used to determine the steering
angle dof the wheel (see equation (2a)), the angle d
A
resulting from the Ackermann relationship (see equa-
tion (2b)), the side-slip angle of the rear wheels (see
equation (3a)), the side-slip angle of the front wheels
(see equation (3b)) and the index of understeer (see
equation (4)). These relations are shown below. Other
parameters of the model motion were measured during
polygon tests. To determine the motion parameters of
the vehicle a bicycle model was used, assuming that the
lateral accelerations do not exceed 4 m/s
2
and that the
roll angle of the model was small. In other cases, for
higher lateral accelerations, the wheel load distributions
for the left wheels and the right wheels will change and
the cornering stiffness has non-linear characteristics. In
addition, there are many other motion parameters
which generate differences between the cornering stiff-
nesses of wheels on one axle, e.g. the flexibility of the
steering system or the lateral slipping of the tyres.
4, 5
The steering angle was determined from the
Ackermann relationship and, after taking into account
the side-slip angles of the wheels, it was found that
dA=R
Lw
ð2aÞ
d=R
Lw
+Wf
Caf
Wr
Car

U2
gR ð2bÞ
The side-slip angle of the rear wheels and the side-
slip angle of the front wheels were determined from the
relations
ar=ba2
_
c
Uð3aÞ
and
af=b+a1
_
c
Udð3bÞ
respectively.
Table 2. Tyres selected for comparison.
Parameter of tyre (units) Value for the following
185R15C SAVA 190/60 Desert
Buster HD
190/60 Desert
Buster HD
190/60 Desert
Buster HD
Aspect ratio (%) 80 50 50 50
Diameter (in) 15 4.5 4.5 4.5
Width (mm) 185 60 60 60
Spring element Air Soft insert Hard insert Air
Air pressure (MPa) Front, 0.32; rear, 0.40 — — 0.06
Type of tread Road Road Road Road
Figure 1. A tyre used in the scaled vehicle.
Parczewski and Wne˛k 1421
by guest on September 3, 2015pid.sagepub.comDownloaded from
The understeer index Kwas determined from the
relation
K=Wf
Caf
Wr
Car
ð4Þ
The characteristics of the tyres were established during
measurements carried out on testing stands.
Measurements of characteristic
parameters of the tyres
Measurements of the radial stiffness, the longitudinal
stiffness and the lateral stiffness were performed in sta-
tic conditions. The effect of the wheel camber was
omitted. The deformations (vertical, longitudinal and
transverse) of the tyres were measured for real tyre
pressures of 0.33 MPa and 0.43 MPa, and for the mod-
els having tyres with soft, hard and pumped inserts.
Table 3 shows the stiffness of each tyre. The radial stiff-
ness of the vehicle tyre 185R15C was obtained by mea-
surements and was 923 N/mm.
A test bench with a moving path was used to mea-
sure the cornering stiffnesses of the tyres of the model;
the tyre was placed on this bench and performed set
moves at a predetermined angle to the moving tread-
mill. The side-slip angle was measured from the longitu-
dinal direction of the tyre. A lateral force was generated
in these measurements.
The cornering stiffness of the scaled model tyre was
based on measurements. Figure 2 shows the test stand
for measuring the cornering stiffnesses (in the labora-
tory at the University of Bielsko-Biala).
The results shown in Figure 3 present measurements
(for side-slip angle a4°of the wheel) for the three
types of tyre used in the model. The cornering stiffness
of the real vehicle tyre was determined from equation
(1) and equals 75,170 N/rad.
After determining the various tyre parameters, they
were converted into the dimensionless values presented
in Table 4. The parameters for two different conditions
of inflation pressure of the real tyres (used on the front
axle and the rear axle) are given.
As can be noted, the comparisons between the
dimensionless parameters of the tyres are quite similar.
The radial stiffnesses of real vehicle tyres are slightly
larger and significantly increase with increasing pres-
sure in the tyre. In the analysis of the moving vehicle
dynamics, the radial stiffnesses are relatively small and
do not affect the results of the tests significantly. The
Table 3. Tyre stiffnesses of the Lublin II vehicle and the scaled model.
Parameter Value for the following
185R15C SAVA 190/60 Desert Buster HD
0.33 MPa 0.43 MPa Load (N) Soft insert Hard insert Pneumatic Load (N)
Radial stiffness (N/mm) 923 1151 14.09 17.09 15.4
Longitudinal stiffness (N/mm) 376.72 387.12 4340 10.74 15.0 6.06 48
362.51 379.58 8240 11.59 15.5 5.7 88
372.36 384.33 12,400 13.99 15.5 6.27 128
14.32 16.3 6.6 168
Lateral stiffness (N/mm) 66.89 73.53 4340 3.21 6.05 4.2 48
66.63 88.83 8240 4.5 6.0 4.1 88
68.28 84.14 12,400 5.5 5.8 4.1 128
5.69 8.02 4.5 168
Figure 2. The test stand for measuring the cornering
stiffnesses of the tyres of the scaled vehicle.
Figure 3. The results of measuring the cornering stiffnesses of
various tyres of the scaled vehicle (own research).
1422 Proc IMechE Part D: J Automobile Engineering 229(10)
by guest on September 3, 2015pid.sagepub.comDownloaded from
longitudinal stiffnesses of all tyres are similar. The lat-
eral stiffnesses are rarely used during the analysis; the
cornering stiffnesses of the tyres have more influence.
The measurements suggest that the tyre with a soft
insert has the lowest rigidity value. The pneumatic tyre
and the tyre with the hard insert have similar cornering
stiffnesses. A slightly larger cornering stiffness occurred
for full-sized tyres. Because of the different structures
of the tyres with a liner, belt mapping was not possible.
For partial belt stimulation of a pneumatic tyre, an
additional rubber strap was used for further stiffening
of the upper part of the tyre.
Because of the impossibility of accurate representa-
tion of the real tyre by those used in the model, a num-
ber of behaviour comparisons of real vehicles and
model vehicles during motion were made.
Assessment of the influence of the tested
tyres on the motion dynamics of the
vehicle
Road tests were performed in order to compare the
influences of the tyres on the motion parameters of the
vehicle.
A sample chosen for comparison was fixed by driv-
ing on a circular path. The test was performed on a cir-
cle at a fixed speed according to ISO 4138:2012.
18
A
full-size vehicle was moving along a track with a radius
of 21.5 m. The vehicle model was tested on the track
with a radius of 5.61 m. This scaled model, which was
equipped with the investigated tyres, fulfilled the condi-
tions resulting from the behaviour of similarity. The
scaled vehicle during driving tests at a fixed speed along
a circular path is shown in Figure 5 (built in the labora-
tory at the University of Bielsko-Biala).
In both cases, for the scaled vehicle and the full-size
vehicle, the steering angles resulting from the
Ackermann relation were the same, i.e. d
A
= 7.7°
(Figure 6).
Based on the tests, under the conditions of similarity,
the yaw rates, the yaw angles, the side-slip angles of the
vehicles and the side-slip of the wheels were specified, in
the case of installation of each type of tyre in model.
Figure 7 presents the results of the research and
analysis of the scaled vehicle tyres with a soft insert,
scaled vehicle tyres with a hard insert, pneumatic tyres
Table 4. The dimensionless parameters of the tyres.
Wheel parameter Value for the following
185R15C SAVA x190/60 Desert Buster HD
0.33 MPa 0.43 MPa Soft insert Hard insert Pneumatic
Aspect ratio 0.8 0.8 0.5 0.5 0.5
Effective radius 1.66 1.66 1.50 1.50 1.50
Tyre width 0.97 0.97 1.17 1.17 1.17
Radial stiffness 39.77 49.98 19.40 20.27 15.82
Longitudinal stiffness 14.56 15.21 13.11 17.04 9.74
Lateral stiffness 3.04 3.56 5.35 9.10 5.23
Cornering stiffness 10.10 11.14 3.05 7.20 6.79
Length of contact with the road 1.26 1.26 1.04 1.04 1.04
Rolling resistance coefficient 0.10 0.10 0.14 0.12 0.12
Figure 5. View of the scaled vehicle during driving tests at a
fixed speed along a circular path.
Figure 4. Comparison of the dimensionless stiffness values for
various types of tyre (own research).
Parczewski and Wne˛k 1423
by guest on September 3, 2015pid.sagepub.comDownloaded from
and real vehicle tyres (dimensions, 185R15C). The fol-
lowing parameters were compared: the side-slip angles
bof the vehicle’s centre of mass, the side-slip angles
a
f
of the front wheels, the side-slip angles a
r
of the
rear wheels, the average steering angles dof the front
wheels, the Ackermann steering angle d
A
and the dif-
ferences between the side-slip angles of the front
wheels and the rear wheels. The comparison shows
that the real vehicle is characterized by a larger side-
slip angle of the vehicle’s centre of mass and larger
side-slip angles of the wheels. The measured steering
angles and the Ackermann steering angles were very
close.
The larger differences in the slip angles were due to
the high aspect ratio (h
tyre
/b
tyre
= 0.8) for the tyres used
in the real vehicle. The tyres used in the scaled vehicle
had a lower aspect ratio (0.5). The increased rigidity of
the angle for the real tyres (approximately 30%) com-
pensated for this difference.
The coefficient K, which was determined during the
tests at the proving ground, is shown in Figure 8. A
negative value of the coefficient means that the tested
vehicle has understeer characteristics. The use of tyres
with a soft insert in the model increases the doubled
understeer. The tyre model with a hard insert and the
pumped-tyre model reduce that coefficient to –0.07.
The understeer coefficient for the real vehicle was
–0.095 and is slightly larger than for the scaled vehicle.
Summary and conclusions
Based on the analysis the following can be concluded.
1. As in the real vehicle, the tyres significantly affect
the motion parameters of the scaled vehicle.
Providing similarity of the tyres is one of the condi-
tions for preserving the similarity of the dynamics
of the vehicle motion during testing.
2. Difficulties in obtaining the compliance of the
dimensionless parameters of the full-size vehicle
and the reduced-scale vehicle result from the differ-
ent production technologies of the tyres. The con-
struction of the tyre on a smaller scale is
significantly different from the construction of a
radial tyre. Therefore, it was decided to carry out
several tests to obtain answers to how the differ-
ences in the tyre construction influenced the
dimensionless parameters of vehicle motion.
3. Pneumatic tyres and tyres with hard inserts
resulted in similar motion parameters of the scaled
vehicle. In driving tests along a circular path using
a scaled vehicle and a real vehicle, the steering
angles of the front wheels are similar and the dif-
ference does not exceed 0.2°.
Figure 6. Schematic diagram for driving tests at a fixed speed
along a circular path.
19
Figure 7. Selected parameters of the vehicle’s motion, during
the driving tests at a fixed speed along a circular path for the
scaled vehicle and the full-size vehicle (own research).
Figure 8. The vehicle understeer coefficient Kfor a real
vehicle and a scaled vehicle determined during driving tests at a
fixed speed along a circular path (own research).
1424 Proc IMechE Part D: J Automobile Engineering 229(10)
by guest on September 3, 2015pid.sagepub.comDownloaded from
4. Real vehicle tyres have a higher aspect ratio of 0.8
and the tyres tested on a scaled vehicle have a lower
aspect ratio of 0.5. This resulted in the occurrence
of larger side-slip angles of wheels for the real vehi-
cle during the tests. When similar aspect ratios are
maintained for the tyres, the side-slip angles should
be similar.
5. The increased stiffness of the tyre angle reduces the
real value of the average steering angle of the front
wheels. The change is small; however, its impact
on the measurement results should be taken into
account.
6. Preserving similarities during the driving tests on a
circular track at a fixed velocity requires adjust-
ments of the steering angle of the wheels. In the
case of the tyres with a soft insert on the scaled
vehicle, the correction is the highest. Tyres with a
hard insert and pumped tyres require significantly
less correction. The average steering angle of the
front wheels of a real vehicle is intermediate
between that of a scaled vehicle with tyres with a
hard insert and that of a scaled vehicle with tyres
with a soft insert.
7. The scaled model and the real vehicle were under-
steering. For tyres with a soft insert, the coefficient
Kis more than twice the Kvalues for the tyres with
a hard insert and for tyres with a tube. Kfor a real
vehicle is somewhat higher than that for the tyres
with a hard insert.
The analysis shows that preserving the similarity of
the tyres allows the use of the model test scaled vehicle
with tyres with a hard insert to assess the real vehicle
behaviour, especially in terms of the lateral stability.
The tests on scaled vehicles allow the vehicle’s lateral
stability to be evaluated and can be used when the test-
ing of full-size vehicles is not practicable to carry out.
Declaration of conflict of interest
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.
Funding
This work was partially supported by the project R&D
NCBR ‘Evaluation of the stability of the vehicle on the
basis of the scaled vehicle’ (grant number PB 5478/B/
T02/2011/40). The material presented in our paper has
not been previously published; the diagrams and figures
are new and original.
References
1. Je˛drzejczak A.Modele wspo
´1pracy opony z nawierzchnia˛
(Models of interaction between the tyre and the road sur-
face). Tech Motoryzacyjna 1980; 8: 13–19.
2. Lozia Z. A two-dimensional model of the interaction
between pneumatic tire and an uneven road surface. In:
The dynamics of vehicles on roads and tracks, 10th IAVSD
symposium, Prague, Czech Republic, 24–28 August 1987,
pp. 227–238. Lisse: Swets & Zeitlinger.
3. Luty W and Prochowski L. O mo _
zliwos
´ci przenoszenia
si1bocznych przez ogumienie samochodu cie˛ _
zarowego na
1uku drogi (The possibility of transferring lateral forces
by the tyres of a truck on a bend of the road.). Zesz
Nauk Inst Pojazdo
´w2004; 3(54): 61–70.
4. Pacejka HB. Tyre and vehicle dynamics. 2nd edition.-
Warrendale, Pennsylvania: SAE International, 2006,
pp. 1–60.
5. Ren
´ski A. Bezpieczen
´stwo czynne samochodu: zawieszenia
oraz uk1ady hamulcowe i kierownicze (Active safety of
vehicles: the suspension, steering and braking systems). 1st
edition. Warsaw: Oficyna Wydawnicza Politechniki
Warszawskiej, 2011, pp. 31–36.
6. Baker WE, Westine PS and Dodge FT. Similarity meth-
ods in engineering dynamics. Theory and practice of scale
modeling. 9th edition.Rochelle Park, New Jersey: Spartan
Books, 1978, p. 35.
7. Buckingham E. On physically similar systems: illustra-
tion of the use of dimensional equations. Phys Rev 1914;
4: 345–376.
8. Parczewski K. Effect of tire inflation preasure on vehicle
dynamics during braking manouvre. Maintenance Relia-
bility 2013; 15(2): 134–139.
9. Huber L and Dietz O. Pendelbewegungen von Lastkraft-
wagen-Anhaengern und ihre Vermeidung (The snaking
of truck trailers). Ver Deutscher Ing Z 1937; 81(16):
459–463.
10. Zakin YH. O pritchine vozniknovenya pritsepov (The
cause of instability of trailers). Avtom Promyshlennost
1959; 11: 16–17.
11. Brennan S. and Alleyne A. The Illinois roadway simu-
lator: a mechatronic test bed for vehicle dynamics and
control. IEEE Trans Mechatronics 2000; 5(4): 349–359.
12. Lapapong S, Gupta V, Callejas E and Brennan S. Fidelity
of using scaled vehicles for chassis dynamic studies. Veh
System Dynamics. 2009; 47(11): 1401–1437.
13. Polley M, Alleyne A and De Vries E. Scaled vehicle tire
characteristics: dimensionless analysis. Veh Systems
Dynamics 2006; 44(2): 87–105.
14. Parczewski K and Wne˛k H. Using mobile scaled vehicle
to investigate the truck lateral stability. Maintenance
Reliability 2013; 15(4): 415–421.
15. Romaniszyn KM. Mobilne modele samochodo
´wd
o
badan
´statecznos
´ci (Mobile car models to study vehicle
stability). Logistyka 2012; 3: 1927–1934.
16. Travis WE, Whitehead RJ, Bevly DM and Flowers
GT. Using scaled vehicles to investigate the influence
of various properties on rollover propensity. In: Amer-
ican control conference, Boston, Massachusetts, USA,
30 June–2 July 2004, Vol 4, pp. 3381–3386. New York:
IEEE,
17. Hewson P. Method for estimating tire cornering stiffness
from basic tire information. Proc IMechE Part D: J Auto-
mobile Engineering 2005; 219(12): 1407–1412.
18. ISO 4138:2012Passenger cars – steady-state circular driv-
ing behaviour – open-loop test methods. Geneva: Interna-
tional Organization for Standardization, 2012.
19. Jazar RN. Vehicle dynamics, theory and application.9th
edition.New York: Springer, 2009, p. 589.
Parczewski and Wne˛k 1425
by guest on September 3, 2015pid.sagepub.comDownloaded from
Appendix 1
Notation
aratio of the height to the width of the tyre
a
1
distance from the centre of gravity to the
front axle (m)
a
2
distance from the centre of gravity to the
rear axle (m)
bthickness of the belt material (m)
Bwheel track (m)
C
a
cornering stiffness of the tyres (Nms)
C
af
cornering stiffness of the front tyres (N/rad)
C
ar
cornering stiffness of the rear tyres (N/rad)
D
f
rotational damping coefficient (Nms/rad)
Emodulus of elasticity of the material of the
belt (N/m
2
)
h
GC
height of the centre of mass (m)
h
RC
height of the centre of rotation (m)
I
XX
roll moment of inertia of the vehicle (kg m
2
)
I
YY
pitch moment of inertia of the vehicle (kg m
2
)
I
ZZ
yaw moment of inertia of the vehicle (kg m
2
)
K
f
rotational stiffness coefficient (Nm/rad)
Llength of the tyre contact with the road (m)
L
w
wheelbase = a
1
+a
2
(m)
mmass of the vehicle (kg)
m
s
sprung mass of the vehicle (kg)
rradius of the wheel rim (m)
Rradius of the track (m)
R
A
radius of the track on the Ackermann
vehicle (m)
slateral deformation of the tyre under a
load (%)
Ulongitudinal speed of the vehicle (m/s)
wwidth of the belt (m)
W
f
load on the front axle (N)
W
r
load on the rear axle (N)
a
f
side-slip angle of the front wheels (rad)
a
r
side-slip angle of the rear wheels (rad)
bside-slip angle of the centre of mass of the
vehicle (rad)
daverage steering angle of the front wheels
(rad)
d
A
Ackermann steering angle (rad)
pdimensionless parameter
_
cyaw rate (rad/s)
1426 Proc IMechE Part D: J Automobile Engineering 229(10)
by guest on September 3, 2015pid.sagepub.comDownloaded from
... During the testing on the testing track were analyzed behavior of the vehicle during tests: the first one -driving on the circle track (quasi-static driving conditions) and the second onesudden changes of vehicle direction (dynamic driving conditions) [5,6]. The study allowed to determine the effects of the suspension on the vehicle behavior [10]. ...
... They were defined functional dependencies of wheels camber angle as a function of vehicle body roll angle and a vehicle body roll as a function of lateral acceleration, based on the results of research and analysis for various types of suspensions. The values of tires cornering stiffness and camber stiffness were determined from measurements on the test stand [10]. ...
... Lateral force measurements were conducted on a test stand [10] using the tire used in physical model for various wheel sideslip angles α at fixed value of camber angles γ (in the range of 0 to 10 deg). Figure 9a shows a comparison of the lateral force determined from the equation (6b), and obtained from measurements on the test stand [10]. The lateral force -F y decreases with increasing camber γ from a few to several percent, proportional to the wheels sideslip angle. ...
Article
Full-text available
The article discusses the impact of design solutions of vehicle suspensions into angles of body roll. It was shown which type of suspensions is better from this point of view. There were examined the dependence of the suspensions parameters on the vehicle body roll angle. The influence of camber angle on the force transmitted to the tire contact with the road surface was analysed. The lateral forces were measured on the test stand. There was tested dependency of lateral forces from the sideslip angle for different angles of camber. Was analysed change of lateral forces generated by camber angle on the vehicle which was made on a scale ~ 1:5 during tests carried out on the testing track. For this purpose, two tests have been selected: first one allowing the measurement in steady motion conditions, the second one with dynamic change of direction of vehicle motion. The graphs show the effect of camber angles on the controllability and stability of the vehicle motion.
... δ -average steering angle of the front wheels, rad, δA -average steering angle of the front wheels from the Ackermann's dependence, rad, C α -tire cornering stiffness of front/rear wheels, N/rad, g -acceleration of gravity, m/s 2 , Lw -wheelbase (Lw = a1 + a2), m, R -radius of the track, m, V -vehicles speed, m/s, Wf, Wr -load on the front/rear axle, N. The wheel side-slip angles can be determined from the relationship: (8,9) where: ...
... Strain measurement of tires: the vertical longitudinal and transverse, was carried out for the fullsize tire with air pressures of the tire: reduced 0.22 MPa and 0.33 MPa nominal, for the tire of vehicle in scale with the hard and soft inserts. The problems associated with the choice of tire for the vehicle scale have been described in the literature [9,13]. Fig. 5 shows the change of cornering stiffness of tires depending on the side-slip angle of the tire. ...
Article
Full-text available
The use of physical models of vehicles, at a scale allows them to be used when measuring the behavior of the full-size vehicles. The characteristics of the various systems and their impact on the dynamics of motion of the vehicle can be determined during stand tests or simulation and confirmed during testing of vehicles on test tracks. Testing vehicles built in small series, oversized or performed individually are conducted infrequently or not at all. In such cases, the alternative may be conducting tests of vehicles carried out at a scale. Research may be conducted in the boundary conditions (which could lead to loss of stability or overturning of the vehicle) impossible to achieve during testing of actual vehicles. They are particularly useful for assessing the stability of vehicles, the impact of the solutions or actions of a driver assistance system. Conducting research vehicles at a scale for the assessment of full-size vehicle must meet the criteria of similarity in the study of physical models of vehicles. One of the major issues is interaction of wheels and road. This article describes the results of wheels interaction with the road for tires with different characteristics used in the mobile model of the car and on the actual vehicle. The aim of the study was to prepare reference material to determine the correlation between the characteristics of the tire model and the full scale tires. This will allow for made adjustment resulting from the impact of the characteristics of the tires on the motion dynamics of comparable cars especially in the curvilinear motion.
... The utilisation of these wastes on a large scale is not yet common in India, probably due to a lack of concrete proof and expertise [19]. According to current research, tyres' special features (flexibility, low weight, etc.) might be utilised in a useful manner if they are reused as a construction material rather than being burned (as fuel for cement kilns) [20]. According to Mishra and Panda [21], the passing ability increased as the rubber aggregate replacement level increased. ...
Article
Full-text available
Due to the exponential growth in global population, the volume of abandoned waste tyres has recently become a serious ecological and environmental hazard. Even though it might take more than 50 years for used tyre rubber to disintegrate, the number of discarded tyres grows every year. This global issue can be mitigated by adding used tyre rubber to self-compacting concrete. By partially substituting the natural fine and coarse aggregate with waste tyre rubber, self-compacting concrete can be made while using less sand and gravel and maintaining the natural components. In this study, M−Sand is partially replaced by Crumb rubber by 10 %, 20 %, 30 %, 40 %, and 50 % for making of paver blocks. Through laboratory testing, this study improves our comprehension of the material properties of self-compacting concrete (SCC), allows us to suggest the right size and amount of crushed rubber to increase the concrete's properties for M30 grade of concrete. The fresh and hardened concrete tests were performed as per IS codal standards. Replacement level of 20 % crumb rubber in concrete mix will improve the compressive strength and split tensile strength by 6.2 % and 9.4 % respectively. The manufacturing cost of paver block is less compared with substitution of crumb rubber waste in place of M−Sand upto 20 %.It is eco-friendly and cost effective in real time construction industry.
... The same is true for Figures 18 and 19, [limit values given by expressions (17 and 18)], which show the change of lateral force with the change in frequency in the time domain of the radial force. Figures 18 and 19 show the changes in lateral force depending on the frequency in the time domain and the radial force domain, for the boundary conditions defined by expressions (17) and (18). By analyzing Figures 18 and 19, and having in mind the adopted hypothesis as well as expressions (17) and (18) Analysis of the data from the mentioned figure shows that the moment changes, and detailed analyzes of all spectra (partially shown in Figure 22) showed that the moment changes over the entire volume of the square, as was the case with the lateral force. ...
Article
Full-text available
Tire models are widely used in research in the field of vehicle dynamics and noise, and especially in the simulation of their movement under the action of forces and moments. In general case, we distinguish theoretical models defined on the basis of tire construction and empirical or semi-empirical models based on experimental tests. In addition, a combination of these two types of models can also produce tire models. In practice, there is a very wide range of mathematical tire models defined using finite element analysis, by approximation of polynomials of different degrees, by approximation of magic formula, etc. In this paper, an attempt is made to calculate non-stationary lateral characteristics of tires on the basis of experimental stationary lateral characteristics, using two-parameter higher level polynomials. This polynomials define the tire lateral characteristics, and take into account their non-uniformity. More specifically, the lateral characteristics are approximated as a function of the dynamic change of the slip angle, radial load due to tire non-uniformity and time.
... The tire: its stiffness, profile height, and tread condition. They mainly affect the tire deflection and its cooperation with the road, and they depend on the pressure force acting on the wheel and its inclination angle [10,11]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The article presents an analysis of the impact of a malfunction resulting from excessive clearance on the rocker arm pin of the front suspension on the vehicle’s steerability. The first part of the article presents an analysis of the influence of the clearance on the rocker arm pin on the geometry of the suspension and steering system. The occurrence of forces acting on the rocker arm pin in various phases of the vehicle motion was analyzed. To assess the vehicle’s steering, the vehicle’s response time to sudden steering wheel movement was used. The vehicle’s response time to sudden movement of the steering wheel was used to assess the vehicle’s steerability. The second part presents the results of bench tests and traction tests of a vehicle equipped with a specially made measuring rocker arm with the possibility of simulating a clearance. The tests were carried out on a class B passenger car in selected road tests. The results of measurements obtained for the roadworthy vehicle and the vehicle with the rocker arm with clearance were compared. The influence of the clearance on the rocker arm pin on the change of vehicle steerability in steady and dynamically changing conditions was analyzed. The test results show the effect of clearance on vehicle steering and on the vehicle steerability. The study tried to determine to what extent the clearance on the rocker arm affects the vehicle’s steerability and thus the safety in road traffic.
... The main advantage of such tests are that they are done under stable conditions and results are repeated which is represented tribologically. An interesting method of investigating safety of a vehicle in curvilinear motion is described by Parczewski and Wnęk (2015), where a physical model scaled 1:5 equipped with all necessary sensors is presented. The advantage of this method, contrary to a full-size vehicle, is that it does not require a lot of space to perform road tests. ...
Article
Full-text available
Tyre-to-road adhesion plays an important role when taking into account transmission of forces between tyres and road surface. It consequently influences vehicle safety. Moreover, it plays a significant role for modelling vehicle motion, which is often applied in the development of automotive active safety systems and in traffic accidents reconstruction. Furthermore, tyre-to-road adhesion properties are dependent on many factors. One of the factors is the type of tyre – summer or winter. This is the reason why it is justified to study the anti-slip properties of summer and winter tyres. This paper shows the method of measuring tyre-to-road adhesion coefficient. It is based on a skid resistance tester SRT-4 that consists of a special dynamometer trailer, towing vehicle and test-measuring equipment. It was designed to be applied in civil/road engineering and further developed. As a result, the SRT-4 system automatically obtains adhesion characteristics, such as the graph of tyre-to-road adhesion coefficient as a function of wheel slip ratio and velocity characteristics of peak adhesion coefficient. Results of the study present the above mentioned characteristics for different types of tyres (summer, winter) in different exploitation conditions. Differences between presented characteristics caused by tyre type and conditions of exploitation are shown. For example, for winter tyres we noticed that the peak value of adhesion coefficient was attained for higher values of slip ratio as compared with summer tyres.
... These parameters mainly affect the tyre deflection and its interaction with the roadway, depending on the force acting on the wheel and its tilt angle. [7][8][9] Suspension -vertical stiffness and characteristics of damping in shock absorbers. Suspension stiffness affects the roll and tilt angles of the vehicle relative to the longitudinal (X) and transverse (Y) axes as well as the forces acting on the axles of the wheels. ...
Article
Full-text available
The article presents the analysis of the impact of reduced damping in the suspension on the change of selected characteristics of vehicle steering. The most important factors influencing the dynamic characteristics of the vehicle steered are described. To this purpose, experimental tests were carried out on a B-class passenger vehicle for selected road tests. These tests were carried out on a vehicle with nominal and reduced damping in the right front wheel suspension. The effect of changing the position of the centre of mass on the behaviour of the vehicle was also taken into account. Comparisons of vehicle test results with standard suspension and with modifications have been carried out. The influence of reduced damping in the suspension on the change of the vehicle steering characteristics in steady and dynamically changing conditions was analysed. In the conducted considerations, the indicators defining the properties of vehicle steerability and stability were used. The determined indicators allowed assessing the impact of the considered changes in the characteristics of the vehicle suspension on its steering and stability of motion.
... The radial stiffness of the tire results from: the tire's construction (including its aspect ratio), the stiffness of its individual layers and the air pressure in the tire. Tire stiffness tests were carried out in the laboratory of the Department of Combustion Engines and Vehicles in University of Bielsko-Biala [7,8]. The radial stiffness of tires with different aspect ratio was compared. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The dimensions of the tires affect the resistance of the vehicle's movement, its traction properties and the ability to reduce the vibrations generated by road unevenness. Modern tires must provide excellent grip on dry and wet surfaces, on a straight and winding road. They should also be characterized by low rolling resistance, aquaplaning resistance, low noise emission and high durability. The general trend in car construction is the use of tires of ever larger diameters and a relatively large width. It is claimed that low aspect ratio tires are characterized by better steering capacity and greater yaw resistance, which is particularly noticeable when cornering. Tires with a higher aspect ratio improve ride comfort, reduce rolling resistance and allow higher obstacles to be overcome. The article presents a comparison of vibrations generated by road unevenness when traversed by a vehicle equipped with tires of different aspect ratio. The tests were divided into two stages: tests of radial stiffness of the tires and road tests on drive through of road unevenness by the B class car equipped with tires of different aspect ratios. A comparison of the spectral density of the power of the vertical acceleration of the car body is provided. The Lomb-Scargle periodogram was used for the analysis.
Article
Full-text available
This paper presents the results of an attempt to transfer resistance to the side overturning of the vehicle to the mobile vehicle in the scale of ~ 1:5 on the real vehicle. Due to the substantial cost of testing and the danger of rollover real vehicle attempt was made to reproduce the behaviour of the vehicle, using the conditions of similarity. The paper presents methods of risk detection and control algorithms in stability systems equipped with a safety feature to prevent rollover. The analysis was based on the tests carried out at research training ground. Shows the results of tests on a real and a mobile smaller scale vehicles, and the values of obtained rollover risk indicators.
Data
Full-text available
The paper presents the problem of reducing the impact of inflation pressure on the tires, and the weight distribution of the vehicle on the road. The results presented in this publication are based on the research bench and passenger vehicle equipped with antilock braking system. Bench testing was conducted stiffness of tires and road tests, performing maneuvers based on ISO standards, braking in the straight patch of road and of the twisting road.
Article
Full-text available
The publication shows the influence of reducing inflation pressure in tyres on tyre characteristics, weight distribution and maintenance of the vehicle on the road. The results presented in this paper are based on both laboratory (bench) and road research of a passenger vehicle equipped with antilock braking system. Bench testing contained tyre stiffness and road tests rely on performing manoeuvres based on ISO standards: braking on the straight fragment and the twisting part of the road.
Article
Full-text available
There are many situations where physical testing of a vehicle or vehicle controller is necessary, yet use of a full-size vehicle is not practical. Some situations include implementation testing of novel actuation strategies, analyzing the behavior of chassis feedback control under system faults, or near-unstable situations such as limit handling under driver-assist feedback control. Historically, many have advocated the use of scale vehicles as surrogates for larger vehicles. This article presents analysis and experimental testing that examines the fidelity of using scaled vehicles for vehicle chassis dynamics and control studies. In support of this effort, this work introduces an experimental system called the Pennsylvania State University Rolling Roadway Simulator (the PURRS). In the PURRS, a custom-built scale-sized vehicle is freely driven on a moving roadway surface. While others have used scale-vehicle rolling roadway simulators in the past, this work is the first to attempt to directly match the planar dynamic performance of the scale-sized vehicle to a specific full-sized vehicle by careful design of the scale vehicle. This article explains details of this effort including vehicle dynamic modeling, detailed measurement of model parameters, conditions for dynamic similitude, validation of the resulting experimental vehicle in the time, frequency, and dimensionless domains. The results of the dynamic comparisons between scale-and full-sized vehicles clearly illustrate operational regimes where agreement is quite good, and other regimes where agreement is quite poor. Both are useful to understand the applicability of scale-vehicle results to full-size vehicle analysis.
Book
Vehicle Dynamics: Theory and Application is written as a textbook for senior undergraduate and first year graduate students in mechanical engineering. It provides both fundamental and advanced topics on handling, ride, components, and behavior of vehicles. This book includes detailed coverage of practical design considerations and a vast number of practical examples and exercises. © 2008 Springer Science+Business Media, LLC. All rights reserved.
Book
This textbook is appropriate for senior undergraduate and first year graduate students in mechanical and automotive engineering. The contents in this book are presented at a theoretical-practical level. It explains vehicle dynamics concepts in detail, concentrating on their practical use. Related theorems and formal proofs are provided, as are real-life applications. Students, researchers and practicing engineers alike will appreciate the user-friendly presentation of a wealth of topics, most notably steering, handling, ride, and related components. This book also: Illustrates all key concepts with examples Includes exercises for each chapter Covers front, rear, and four wheel steering systems, as well as the advantages and disadvantages of different steering schemes Includes an emphasis on design throughout the text, which provides a practical, hands-on approach.
Article
This paper proposes a simple mathematical tyre model that estimates tyre cornering stiffness. The model is derived by considering the tyre to be a combination of two independent systems. The sidewalls are assumed to be negligibly stiff in the lateral direction, and hence their influence on the lateral dynamics of the tyre will be ignored. The belt and tread area of the tyre will be considered to be an homogeneous uniform band, and its stiffness will be estimated with reference to measured tyre data. The resulting model is estimated to yield cornering stiffness values within about 30 per cent of the actual measured values.
Article
This article demonstrates the use of dimensional analysis for scaled vehicle tires. The motivation for this approach is the understanding of realistic nonlinear tire behavior in scaled vehicle control studies. By examining the behavior of vehicle tires within a dimensionless framework, several key tire parameters are developed that allow for an appropriate relationship between full-sized tires and scaled tires. Introducing these scalings into vehicle dynamics studies allows for the development of scaled vehicles that have a high degree of dynamic similitude with full-sized vehicles, but are safer and more economical testbeds on which to develop experimental control strategies. Experimental data are used to compare the nonlinear characteristics for sets of scaled and full-sized tires. Finally, design of a scaled vehicle based on tire characteristics is demonstrated.