Conference Paper

Hydrosystem Optimization with the Use of Evolutionary Algorithms: The Case of Nestos River

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

The optimum management of multi-reservoir systems becomes increasingly complex when conflicting uses of water exist, i.e. water supply, irrigation, hydropower generation, etc. This is especially the case in the Nestos basin, a trans-boundary basin extending between Bulgaria and Greece. The transboundary nature of the catchment makes the management of water resources of Nestos complicated. Between 1971 and 1972, the Hellenic Public Power Corporation (PPC) undertook a feasibility study for the construction of three dams. The original plan was to build three multipurpose reservoirs (serially) the first two of which reversible. However the overall project was not completed due to lack of funds, with only two completed reservoirs to this day (Thysavros and Platanovryssi). This paper presents a methodology that combines both simulation and optimization to develop optimal operational rules for the hydrosystem and assess the impact (and potential benefits) from the construction of the third reservoir (Temenos). The main tools used are WEAP21 which simulates the hydrosystem operation and MATLAB where calibration and optimization is taking place. A bespoke code handling the interaction between the two programs was also developed in Matlab, using the COM-API available in WEAP21. Hydrosystem optimization was undertaken using two criteria: the benefit from hydroenergy production and the hydrosystem reliability in terms of water demand coverage. Four scenarios with variation on the operating rules and with or without the Temenos dam were considered and the results compared. The inputs consisted of long synthetic time series to investigate the reliability and responsiveness of the operating rules under uncertainty. Pareto fronts where produced to explore solutions that can achieve the desired reliability in combination with high hydropower production. Based on the work undertaken, the construction of the Temenos reservoir contributes significantly to the increase of hydroenergy production while ensuring that the system will meet water demands. Significant improvement is shown when seasonal variables are used to distinguish between irrigated and non-irrigated periods in the simulation/optimization. Results and operating rules produced appear to be robust under significant long term hydrologic uncertainty with the hydrosystem performing consistently in high reliability levels.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.

... For the simulation of the hydrosystem (in step 3) a widely used water management model, the Water Evaluation and Planning System (WEAP21 1 ) was used. To enable a twoway communication between the simulation and optimization models (step 5) a coupling was 10 established through the COM-API 2 function of WEAP21 as discussed in Tsoukalas and Makropoulos (2013). ...
... The hydrosystem was modeled ( Figure 6) using WEAP21. The calibration of the hydrosystem was successfully undertaken during a previous study (Tsoukalas and Makropoulos, 2013) yielding a Nash-Sutcliffe coefficient equal to 0.87. WEAP21 doesn't have a built-in module to simulate pump-storage processes; As this is an important functionality for the Nestos hydrosystem, pump storage was simulated using "dummy" demand nodes (D1 and D2) with the appropriate connectivity ( Figure 6, inside the circle). ...
Article
Abstract Developing long term operation rules for multi-reservoir systems is complicated due to the number of decision variables, the non-linearity of system dynamics and the hydrological uncertainty. This uncertainty can be addressed by coupling simulation models with multi-objective optimisation algorithms driven by stochastically generated hydrological timeseries but the computational effort required imposes barriers to the exploration of the solution space. The paper addresses this by (a) employing a parsimonious multi-objective parameterization-simulation-optimization (PSO) framework, which incorporates hydrological uncertainty through stochastic simulation and allows the use of probabilistic objective functions and (b) by investigating the potential of multi-objective surrogate based optimisation (MOSBO) to significantly reduce the resulting computational effort. Three MOSBO algorithms are compared against two multi-objective evolutionary algorithms. Results suggest that MOSBOs are indeed able to provide robust, uncertainty-aware operation rules much faster, without significant loss of neither the generality of evolutionary algorithms nor of the knowledge embedded in domain-specific models.
... Wardlaw et al. used a genetic algorithm for optimal exploitation of the reservoir (Wardlaw, et al., 1999). Tsoukalas et al. dealt with optimizing the operation of the multi-reservoir systems by integrating the WEAP simulation model with heuristic techniques (Tsoukalas, et al., 2013). In Karun river, several studies have been done regarding hydropower energy and some factors affected in power plant generation systems such as sedimentation. ...
Article
Among the major sources of energy supply systems, hydroelectric power plants are more common. Energy supply during peak hours and less environmental issues are some of the most important advantages of hydroelectric power plants. In this study, designing parameters to supply maximum amount of energy was determined by using the simulation-optimization perspective and combination of IWO-WEAP models. Subsequently, the developed model has been applied for designing the Karun II hydroelectric power plant. The sequential streamflow routing method has been developed for obtaining energy in WEAP water resources management software. In addition the optimization algorithm has been applied to optimize the invasive weeds. To verify the performance of this method, obtained results for the firm energy were compared to those of the total energy. Using this method, for 1398 GWY (Giga watt per your) firm energy, the minimum and normal levels of operation were 668 and 672 m.a.s.l (meters above sea level), respectively, and the installation capacity calculated around 498 MW as optimal value.
... Therefore considering these limitations, integrated optimal water resources allocation modelling should consider all the water users and equitably allocate water amongst users, whilst taking into consideration hydro-climatic variability. (Tsoukalas and Makropoulos 1972;Evers, 1992;Arranz and McCartney, 2007;Tilmant et al., 2010;Sharma et al., 2016). A variety of methodologies have been proposed and developed in order to embody in optimal water allocation the uncertainties of various influencing factors and hydro-system characteristics, such as available water flows, water demands, variations in water supplies, corresponding cost and benefit coefficients and policy regulations. ...
Article
Full-text available
The management and allocation of water from multi-reservoir systems is complex and thus requires dynamic modelling systems to achieve optimality. A multi-reservoir system in the Southern Lowveld of Zimbabwe is used for irrigation of sugarcane estates that produce sugar for both local and export consumption. The system is burdened with water allocation problems, made worse by decommissioning of dams. Thus the aim of this research was to develop an operating policy model for the Lowveld multi-reservoir system. The Mann Kendall Trend and Wilcoxon Signed-Rank tests were used to assess the variability of historic monthly rainfall and dam inflows for the period 1899–2015. The WEAP model was set up to evaluate the water allocation system of the catchment and come-up with a reference scenario for the 2015/2016 hydrologic year. Stochastic Dynamic Programming approach was used for optimisation of the multi-reservoirs releases. Results showed no significant trend in the rainfall but a significantly decreasing trend in inflows (p < 0.05). The water allocation model (WEAP) showed significant deficits ( ∼ 40 %) in irrigation water allocation in the reference scenario. The optimal rule curves for all the twelve months for each reservoir were obtained and considered to be a proper guideline for solving multi- reservoir management problems within the catchment. The rule curves are effective tools in guiding decision makers in the release of water without emptying the reservoirs but at the same time satisfying the demands based on the inflow, initial storage and end of month storage.
... Irrigation needs were estimated using the approach of FAO [21]. The model calibration was executed via a WEAP21-Matlab conjunction [19,22] using simulated annealing as optimization algorithm. ...
Article
Full-text available
The Ali Efenti catchment is a rural upstream subcatchment of the Pinios river basin that suffers from seasonal water shortages due to the rapid increase of the total water abstraction in the summer months, which is mainly attributed to local crop irrigation. Catchment modelling is being implemented using two different modelling approaches: a conceptual model based on water balances, the Water Evaluation And Planning system (WEAP), and a physically-based model coupled with routines for irrigation and crop growth, the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT). Both models were set up, calibrated and validated using observed streamflows. The strengths of the two models were combined in order to design effective, efficient and comprehensive demand-side measures for the urban, tourism, industrial and agricultural sectors to achieve sustainable water management in the Ali Efenti catchment. The comparison of the two models and the results of modelling are being discussed.
... Irrigation needs were estimated using the approach of FAO [21]. The model calibration was executed via a WEAP21-Matlab conjunction [19,22] using simulated annealing as optimization algorithm. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The Ali Efenti catchment is a rural upstream subcatchment of the Pinios river basin. It hosts two major urban centres of the region of Thessaly, the cities of Trikala and Karditsa, as well as several industries, mainly from the food sector. The average annual precipitation in this catchment is relatively higher than in the rest parts of river basin, but still seasonal water shortages occur due to the rapid increase of the total water abstraction in the summer months. The water demand rises sharply in the agricultural sector as a result of crop irrigation, while significant increases are also observed in the urban sector. In this study, we examine alternative water efficiency measures for the urban, tourism, industrial and agricultural sectors to address the seasonal peak in water demand. Catchment modelling is being implemented using two different modelling approaches: a conceptual model based on water balances, the Water Evaluation And Planning system (WEAP), and a physically-based model coupled with routines for irrigation and crop growth, the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT). Both models are set up, calibrated and validated using observed streamflows. The strengths of the two models are combined in order to design effective, efficient and comprehensive demand-side measures to achieve sustainable water management in the Ali Efenti catchment. The comparison of the two models and the results of modelling are being discussed.
... In this study a bespoke code handling the interaction between the two programs was developed in MATLAB, using the COM-API 2 available in WEAP21. That interaction makes possible a bi-directional cooperation between WEAP21 and MATLAB, enabling a two-way communication between the simulation and optimization models through the COM-API capabilities of WEAP21 as discussed in Tsoukalas and Makropoulos (2013). ...
Article
Full-text available
Operation of large-scale hydropower reservoirs is a complex problem that involves conflicting objectives, such as hydropower generation and water supply. Deriving optimal operational rules is a challenging task due to the non-linearity of the system dynamics and the uncertainty of future inflows and water demands. A common approach to derive optimal control policies is to couple simulation models with optimization algorithms. This paper in order to investigate the performance of a future reservoir and safely infer about its significance employs stochastic simulation, thus long synthetically generated time-series and a multi-objective version of the Parameterization-Simulation-Optimization (PSO) framework to develop uncertainty-aware operational rules. Furthermore, in order to handle the high computational effort that ensues from that coupling we investigate the potential of a surrogate-based multi-objective optimization algorithm, ParEGO. The PSO framework is deployed with WEAP21 water resources management model as simulation engine and MATLAB for the implementation of optimization algorithms. A comparison between NSGAII and ParEGO optimization algorithms is performed to assess the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm. The aforementioned comparison showed that ParEGO provides efficient approximations of the Pareto front while reducing the computational effort required. Finally, the potential benefit and the significance of the future reservoir is underlined.
... The main tool used in this study for the current and future hydroelectricity power stations was the WEAP21 model [11]. The technical characteristics of the dams were retrieved from the literature , while the inflow discharges to the reservoirs were derived by the hydrologic model outputs. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The design and functioning of water infrastructures have direct impacts on the ecological and social landscape in which they are located and vice versa, as the prevailing social systems and processes form the physical infrastructure used for the management of water. This research work evaluates the way social benefits, in terms of farmers' compensations and environmental sensitivity expressed in terms of rehabilitation costs due to lack of water, affect the economic viability of hydropower projects in the case of two climate change emission scenarios. The results demonstrated that, apart from the evident macro scale decrease of water discharges, the economic sustainability of large scale projects is also connected to the fluctuations of the wholesale prices of electricity.
Article
Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk mengetahui unjuk kerja Turbin Air PLTA Bilibili dengan indikator yaitu Efesiensi dan Capacity Factor (CF). Metode yang digunakan adalah pengambilan data Kuota air atau debit (Q), Head (H) dan Daya keluaran Generator kemudian dilakukan analisa data. Periode pengambilan data dari bulan Juni 2014 sampai dengan Juni 2015. Selama periode pengambilan data, debit tertinggi 45 m3/s dan terendah 6,4 m3/s sedangkan nilai elevasi tertinggi 99,4 mdpl dan terendah 85,8 mdpl. Efesiensi Turbin #1 berada diantara 0,669% sampai dengan 0,881% dan untuk #2 diantara 0,678% sampai dengan 0,916%. Indikator Capacity Factor, #1 berada pada nilai 6,8% sampai dengan 98% dan #2 berada pada nilai 7,7% sampai dengan 100%. Capacity Factor untuk PLTA Bilibili secara kumulatif adalah 53,81%. Sehingga adanya batasan operasional yaitu penentuan kuota pemakaian air untuk PLTA Bilibili, berdampak pada unjuk kerja Turbin khususnya untuk efisiensi Turbin.
Article
Full-text available
The Ali Efenti catchment is a rural upstream subcatchment of the Pinios river basin in central Greece. The average annual precipitation in this subcatchment is relatively higher and groundwater recharge is relatively faster than in the rest of the river basin. Yet, seasonal water shortages occur due to the rapid increase of water abstractions in the summer months, mainly for crop irrigation. Up until 2030 the gap between water supply and demand is expected to deteriorate, considering the impacts of climate and socio-economic change. The adoption of environmental restrictions on water abstraction, which is a measure foreseen in the local river basin management plan, could decrease water stress substantially from 19.2% to 13.9%. However, this would require enormous (−26%) cuts in the current water abstractions during June–September, lowering water demand coverage from 86% to 68%. Optimal combinations of measures, from an economic and environmental perspective, will need to be designed to bridge the gap between water supply and demand and restore water demand coverage to satisfactory levels. Hydrologic and water resources management modelling has been implemented using the Water Evaluation and Planning system (WEAP), which is a conceptual model based on water balances.
Article
Full-text available
The Water Evaluation and Planning Model (WEAP) 2.1 was applied to the Sinú–Caribe river basin in Colombia to create several baseline and adaptation strategy scenarios for water supply, use and demand, and to make projections for the future including the potential impacts of climate change. The analysis of water availability as a limiting factor in the supply–demand balance of the productive sectors and activities in the Sinú–Caribe river basin in Colombia shows that the supply requirement would increase and thus unmet demand would increase more quickly under climate change conditions. The scarcity indexes define the critical points in this balance by the years 2074 under current or baseline conditions and 2066 with climate change. Optimization scenarios for hydropower generation for the critical months of the year were also generated and show how water resources management strategies can mitigate the adverse effects of climate change.
Article
Full-text available
The urban wastewater system is an important part of integrated water management at the catchment level, yet, more often than not, inclusion of the system and its interaction with the surrounding catchment is either oversimplified or totally ignored in catchment modelling. Reasons of complexity and computational burden are mostly at the heart of this modelling gap. This paper proposes to use artificial neural networks (ANN) as a surrogate for the simulation of the urban wastewater system, allowing for a more realistic representation of the urban component to be incorporated into catchment models within a broad scale modelling framework. As a proof of concept, an integrated urban wastewater model is developed and its response in terms of both quantity and quality in combined sewer overflow (CSO) discharges and treatment plant effluent are captured and used to train a feedforward back-propagation ANN. The comparative results of the integrated urban water model and the ANN show good agreement for both water quantity and quality parameters. The resulting trained network is then embedded into a MIKE BASIN catchment model. It is suggested that ANN models greatly improve the level at which broad scale catchment models can accurately take into account urban rural interactions.
Article
Full-text available
Spatial Decision Support Systems (SDSS) represent an attempt to assist in the decision making process by a set of intelligent, knowledge-based techniques and as such have an increasingly important role to play as the data required for spatially sensitive decisions become more available in a wide range of problem areas. The urban environment is a complex, spatially sensitive decision-making environment and as such an ideal case study for the application of these techniques and tools. Building knowledge into a system, particularly through linguistic modelling, is a challenge. This paper briefly discusses the development of such an SDSS based on fuzzy inference and describes techniques enabling the incorporation of both expert judgement and field evidence, where available, in an effort to address one of the main criticisms of linguistic (fuzzy) modelling: that of subjectivity.
Article
Full-text available
Multireservoir operating policies are usually defined by rules that specify either individual reservoir desired (target) storage volumes or desired (target) releases based on the time of year and the existing total storage volume in all reservoirs. This paper focuses on the use of genetic search algorithms to derive these multireservoir operating policies. The genetic algorithms use real-valued vectors containing information needed to define both system release and individual reservoir storage volume targets as functions of total storage in each of multiple within-year periods. Elitism, arithmetic crossover, mutation, and “en bloc” replacement are used in the algorithms to generate successive sets of possible operating policies. Each policy is then evaluated using simulation to compute a performance index for a given flow series. The better performing policies are then used as a basis for generating new sets of possible policies. The process of improved policy generation and evaluation is repeated until no further improvement in performance is obtained. The proposed algorithm is applied to example reservoir systems used for water supply and hydropower.
Article
Full-text available
Evolutionary programming (EP) is an application of the concepts of Darwinian evolution to complex optimisation problems. This is primarily addressed in the literature through the use of genetic algorithms (GAs), but there are problems where a hybrid approach coupling the robustness of GAs with the effectiveness of a heuristic procedure may yield better results. This paper focusses on the development and use of such a hybrid EP algorithm to solve a particular multi-objective spatial object-location problem. The domain knowledge which forms part of the heuristics of the methodology developed is provided by the problem of citing sustainable water management strategies within the urban fabric, taking into account social, economic, technical and cost parameters and constraints.
Article
Full-text available
There is a deep and useful connection between statistical mechanics (the behavior of systems with many degrees of freedom in thermal equilibrium at a finite temperature) and multivariate or combinatorial optimization (finding the minimum of a given function depending on many parameters). A detailed analogy with annealing in solids provides a framework for optimization of the properties of very large and complex systems. This connection to statistical mechanics exposes new information and provides an unfamiliar perspective on traditional optimization problems and methods.
Article
Full-text available
Finding a strategy that allows economically efficient drinking water production at minimal environmental cost is often a complex task. A systematic trade-off among the costs and benefits of possible strategies is required for determining the optimal production configuration. Such a trade-off involves the handling of interdependent and nonlinear relations for drawdown-related objective categories like damage to wetland vegetation, agricultural yield depression, reduction of river base flow rates, and soil subsidence. We developed a method for multiple-objective optimization of drinking water production by combining 's [1961] "minimum cost flow" procedure for optimal use of the transport network with a genetic algorithm (GA) for optimization of other impacts. The performance of the GA was compared with analytically determined solutions of a series of hypothetical case studies. Pareto-optimality and uniqueness of solutions proved to be effective fitness criteria for identifying trade-off curves with the GA.
Article
Full-text available
There is a deep and useful connection between statistical mechanics (the behavior of systems with many degrees of freedom in thermal equilibrium at a finite temperature) and multivariate or combinatorial optimization (finding the minimum of a given function depending on many parameters). A detailed analogy with annealing in solids provides a framework for optimization of the properties of very large and complex systems. This connection to statistical mechanics exposes new information and provides an unfamiliar perspective on traditional optimization problems and methods.
Article
The Water Evaluation and Planning Version 21 (WEAP21) Integrated Water Resource Management (IWRM) model seamlessly integrates water supplies generated through watershed-scale hydrologic processes with a water management model driven by water demands and environmental requirements and is governed by the natural watershed and physical network of reservoirs, canals, and diversions. This version (WEAP21) extends the previous WEAP model by introducing the concept of demand priorities and supply preferences, which are used in a linear programming heuristic to solve the water allocation problem as an alternative to multi-criteria weighting or rule-based logic approaches. WEAP21 introduces a transparent set of model objects and procedures that can be used to analyze a full range of issues faced by water planners through a scenario-based approach. These issues include climate variability and change, watershed condition, anticipated demands, ecosystem needs, the regulatory environment, operational objectives, and available infrastructure.
Article
The objective of the study reported herein is to develop practical procedures for the analysis of a multiple purpose, multiple facility reservoir system to guide real time decisions concerning the optimal operation of the system. Application is made to the California Central Valley Project (CVP). The five purposes (benefits), treated as objectives here in the multiobjective optimization, include (1) hydropower production, (2) fish protection, (3) water quality maintenance, (4) water supply, and (5) recreation. The constraint method is used to develop the trade-offs while a specially modified linear programing and dynamic programing algorithm is used for optimization. Noninferior sets can be obtained with each benefit parameterized singly and in various combinations. Two sets of monthly historical streamflows, one set corresponding to a drought year and the other set to an excess water year, are used to develop the corresponding noninferior sets. These procedures provide guidance for allocating the total benefits derived from a region's water resources and for operating the available system within all statutory, contractual, and other applicable constraints. A very high degree of decomposition of the typically large multiple purpose, multiple facility operation problem is made possible by the above technique, resulting in a rapid delineation of the noninferior policy set. The decision maker participates at various stages of the analysis and can request more or less detail with regard to the noninferior set. In our opinion, information is best presented to him via a series of two dimensional plots representing various cross sections of the noninferior set. Tabular presentations are not conducive to a good appreciation of the consequences of alternative benefit allocation policies.
Article
We present a Monte Carlo algorithm to find approximate solutions of the traveling salesman problem. The algorithm generates randomly the permutations of the stations of the traveling salesman trip, with probability depending on the length of the corresponding route. Reasoning by analogy with statistical thermodynamics, we use the probability given by the Boltzmann-Gibbs distribution. Surprisingly enough, using this simple algorithm, one can get very close to the optimal solution of the problem or even find the true optimum. We demonstrate this on several examples.We conjecture that the analogy with thermodynamics can offer a new insight into optimization problems and can suggest efficient algorithms for solving them.
Article
The principles governing the application of the conceptual model technique to river flow forecasting are discussed. The necessity for a systematic approach to the development and testing of the model is explained and some preliminary ideas suggested.
Castalia: A system for stochastic simulation of hydrologic variables, 6 pages, Department of Water Resources
  • D Koutsoyiannis
Koutsoyiannis D., and Efstratiadis A. (2002), Castalia: A system for stochastic simulation of hydrologic variables, 6 pages, Department of Water Resources, Hydraulic and Maritime Engineering -National Technical University of Athens.
Nestos diversion dam, Macedonia, Greece. Basis of design on the Nestos diversion dam
YDE (1954), Nestos diversion dam, Macedonia, Greece. Basis of design on the Nestos diversion dam. Knappen-Tippetts-Abbett-McCarthy Engineers, New York, Library of Technical Chamber of Greece.
A Dynamic Decision Support System: Linking Water Resource Simulation and Decision Analysis
  • O ' Neil
O'Neil K., and Yates D. (2011) A Dynamic Decision Support System: Linking Water Resource Simulation and Decision Analysis, Project Report, Water Research Foundation.
The hydrodynamics of Greece, notes for lesson Hydroelectric work
  • I Stefanakos
Stefanakos I., The hydrodynamics of Greece, notes for lesson Hydroelectric work, National Technical University of Athens, 2011.
Engineering Hydrology
  • D Koutsoyiannis
  • T Xanthopoulos
Koutsoyiannis, D., and T. Xanthopoulos (1997), Engineering Hydrology, Edition 2, National Technical University of Athens.
A Dynamic Decision Support System: Linking Water Resource Simulation and Decision Analysis
  • K O'neil
  • D Yates
O'Neil K., and Yates D. (2011) A Dynamic Decision Support System: Linking Water Resource Simulation and Decision Analysis, Project Report, Water Research Foundation.
Environmental Impact Assessment for the wider region of the Greek Nestos River Basin
  • Paraskevopoulos -Pangaea
Paraskevopoulos -Pangaea (1994), Environmental Impact Assessment for the wider region of the Greek Nestos River Basin.