ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

Asian elephants Elephas maximus have been captured and trained by Lao mahouts for centuries. While captive elephants are losing their traditional relevance, they still play a significant role in the Lao logging and tourism industries. However, with only an estimated 480 captive elephants remaining nationally and only ?60 cows under 35 yr of age, the future viability of this population is uncertain. We assessed >80% of the captive elephant population and used VORTEX software to create 7 population viability analysis scenarios. Our results demonstrate that without changes to conservation management the current population is likely to be extinct in 112 yr (r = -0.099). Reduced mortality rates, increased reproductive rates and population supplementation will give the population an additional 108 yr of longevity, but will not, of themselves, prevent extinction. Management programs should direct efforts towards in situ breeding programs, a cessation in calf exportation, improved veterinary care and population supplementation. Since captive populations are also small and declining in other range nations, there is also a case for managing all Asian elephants as a single management unit.
Content may be subject to copyright.
ENDANGERED SPECIES RESEARCH
Endang Species Res
Vol. 24: 1–7, 2014
doi: 10.3354/esr00578 Published online April 9
INTRODUCTION
Asian elephant Elephas maximus populations are
in global decline. Total E. maximus numbers have
been reduced by at least 50% in all 13 range nations
in the last 3 generations (Bandara & Tisdell 2004,
Hedges et al. 2005, Choudhury et al. 2008) and the
species is classified as Endangered by the IUCN
(Choudhury et al. 2008). Total population estimates
vary between 30 000 and 50 000, although this is
widely believed to be an outdated overestimate
(Sukumar 2003, Hedges et al. 2005, Dublin et al.
2006, Hedges 2006, Choudhury et al. 2008). What
research has been undertaken has focused mainly on
wild elephants and not the sizeable captive popula-
tion (Lair 1997, Hedges et al. 2005, Hedges 2006,
Sukumar 2006). The captive elephant population
constitutes one-third to one-quarter of all remaining
Asian elephants (Sukumar 2003, Leimgruber et al.
2008). An estimated 14 500 to 16000 elephants live in
captive or semi-wild conditions, typically used for
logging, village, tourism, or temple purposes (Suku-
mar 2003, Dublin et al. 2006). While the captive pop-
ulation is a significant percentage of total elephant
numbers, these numbers are also declining (Khoun-
boline 2011).
The Lao People’s Democratic Republic (PDR) con-
tains Indochina’s largest remaining Asian elephant
population (Ahlering et al. 2011). Even so, only an
estimated 600 to 800 wild and 500 captive elephants
remain throughout Laos, with both wild and captive
populations in decline (Khounboline 2011, Ministry
of Agriculture and Forestry 2009). Major threats to
wild elephant populations include habitat loss and
© Inter-Research 2014 · www.int-res.com*Corresponding author: i.suter@uq.edu.au
Population viability of captive Asian elephants in
the Lao PDR
Ingrid Colette Suter1,*, Gilles Pierre Maurer2, Greg Baxter1
1The University of Queensland, School of Geography, Planning and Environmental Management, St Lucia, Brisbane,
Queensland 4072, Australia
2ElefantAsia, PO Box 3804, Vientiane, Lao People’s Democratic Republic
ABSTRACT: Asian elephants Elephas maximus have been captured and trained by Lao mahouts
for centuries. While captive elephants are losing their traditional relevance, they still play a signif-
icant role in the Lao logging and tourism industries. However, with only an estimated 480 captive
elephants remaining nationally and only ~60 cows under 35 yr of age, the future viability of this
population is uncertain. We assessed >80% of the captive elephant population and used VORTEX
software to create 7 population viability analysis scenarios. Our results demonstrate that without
changes to conservation management the current population is likely to be extinct in 112 yr (r =
−0.099). Reduced mortality rates, increased reproductive rates and population supplementation
will give the population an additional 108 yr of longevity, but will not, of themselves, prevent
extinction. Management programs should direct efforts towards in situ breeding programs, a ces-
sation in calf exportation, improved veterinary care and population supplementation. Since cap-
tive populations are also small and declining in other range nations, there is also a case for man-
aging all Asian elephants as a single management unit.
KEY WORDS: Asian elephants · Captive elephants · Elephas maximus · Lao PDR · Population
viability · VORTEX
Resale or republication not permitted without written consent of the publisher
This authors' personal copy may not be publicly or systematically copied or distributed, or posted on the Open Web,
except with written permission of the copyright holder(s). It may be distributed to interested individuals on request.
Endang Species Res 24: 1–7, 2014
fragmentation, poaching and human− elephant con-
flict (Norachack 2002, Sukumar 2006, Khounboline
2011). A lack of capacity and investment in conserva-
tion are also recognized as major species manage-
ment impediments (Norachack 2002, Ministry of
Agriculture and Forestry 2009).
For centuries captive elephants have shaped Lao
communities, with only minor deviations from tradi-
tional practices occurring. Both elephant acquisition
and usage have changed, bringing about a major
change in mahout lifestyle. Historically a calf would
be captured from the wild as needed by the local
mahout community. The viability of the captive ele-
phant population was never considered until the
Government of Laos introduced a ban on wild ele-
phant capture in 1989 (Sukumar 2003). This ban had
an immediate impact on the captive elephant popu-
lation, with few calves entering the population since
1989 (Fig. 1). As long as elephants were traditionally
captured from wild populations, mahouts never
needed any knowledge of elephant reproduction
(Lair 1997). As a result, the captive population now
confronts a number of demographic challenges such
as an aging population, inadequate replacement
rate, a declining number of females of reproductive
age, a lack of breeding opportunities and, recently,
excessive calf exportation (Lair 1997, Sukumar 2003,
ElefantAsia 2007, Khounboline 2011). Under CITES
rental agreements it is believed that over the past
5 yr the Government of Laos has exported an esti-
mated 10% of the nation’s calves (S. Duffillot, pers.
comm., 12 September 2012). Rentals or outright gifts
are typically granted to countries sympathetic to
Laos’ political agenda, including China, North Korea
and Japan (Suter 2012). The consequence of these
demographic challenges has led to an extremely low
captive breeding rate. In 2011, only 18 captive calves
under the age of 10 yr were documented in Laos
(Xaymountry & Maurer 2011).
Still offering much-needed employment for Lao
mahouts and communities, captive elephant indus-
tries are undergoing significant change. Tradition-
ally utilized for transportation and small-scale vil-
lage use, the majority of captive elephants in Laos
are now employed in the professional logging or
tourism industries (Suter et al. 2013). Similar to
Thailand, in less than 30 yr, elephant-based tourism
has become a principal component of the national
tourism industry (Kontogeorgopoulos 2009). The use
of captive elephants for tourism purposes has been
recognized as holding great significance for the
long-term conservation of both wild and captive
elephant populations (Duffy & Moore 2011). While
still in a nascent state, the Laos tourism industry has
become one of the most important sources of
foreign exchange and employment, and a major
contributor to the national economy (Phakdisoth &
Kim 2007, Harrison & Schipani 2009). Lao mahouts
perceive tourism to be an easier lifestyle, offering
lower pay but greater job security than the dimin-
ishing logging industry (Suter et al. 2013). Certainly
within Laos, mahouts are willing to switch to
tourism once logging in their region be comes unvi-
able (Suter et al. 2013). The Lao elephant-based
tourism industry endeavors to provide mahouts, and
the national economy, with long-term benefits, as
well as being an industry compatible with elephant
reproductive needs.
More demographic data are available for the cap-
tive elephant population in Laos than for the wild
population. Wild population numbers remain esti-
mates, with threatening processes largely uncon-
trolled. Captive elephants have been registered and
monitored by the Department of Livestock and Fish-
eries (DLF) and conservation groups, with sex, age,
location and ownership details of >80% of the entire
captive elephant population recorded (ElefantAsia
2012). This knowledge makes it easier to develop
management programmes for captive elephants than
for their wild counterparts.
Given the significance of the captive elephant
population in Laos, their decline would be detri-
mental to captive elephant populations, mahouts,
businesses and local communities. To understand
the reasons for, and the trajectory of, the declining
captive elephant population we addressed the fol-
lowing questions:
2
Fig. 1. Elephas maximus. Sex and age pyramid of the Lao
captive elephant population (n = 439). The majority of ele-
phants were captured from the wild as calves before the
1989 ban on wild elephant capture
Author copy
Suter et al.: Population viability analysis for captive elephants
(1) What is the long-term viability of Lao captive
elephants under current management regimes?
(2) Can conservation strategies prevent the local-
ized extinction of elephants?
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study area
Our study area encompassed all districts and
provinces in the Lao PDR that had captive elephants
microchipped and registered with the DLF and Ele-
fantAsia between January 2009 and January 2012.
This included the Bokeo, Bolikhamxai, Champassak,
Luang Prabang, Oudomxay, Saravane, Sayaboury
and Vientiane provinces (ElefantAsia 2012). Once
microchipped, unique identification and demo-
graphic data were entered into the Lao national ele-
phant registration database, which we utilized for
this study.
Modelling
To assess the likelihood of Lao captive elephant ex-
tinction we carried out population viability ana lysis
(PVA) using VORTEX Version 9.5. PVA is commonly
used by researchers involved in captive breeding
groups and by conservation managers to gauge mini-
mal population via bility or extinction rates for popula-
tions at risk (Lacy 1993, Beissinger & Westphal 1998).
PVA modeling is typically integrated into conservation
planning, as programs accept assumptive parameters
and environmental variation, and allow for adaptive
species management (Akçakaya & Sjögren-Gulve
2000, Lacy 2000, Myroniuk 2004). VORTEX software
was chosen for our analyses as its simulation program
is suitable for species with low fecundity, long life
spans and uneven sex ratios (Lacy 1993, Miller & Lacy
2005). Asian elephant PVA has been undertaken on
wild populations in Sumatra (Sukumar & Santiapillai
1993), wild populations in Sri Lanka (Sukumar 2003)
and captive populations in Myanmar (Leimgruber et
al. 2008). Perhaps because of the controllable envi-
ronment in which they exist, and the substantial in-
vestments made by zoos, Asian elephant PVA has of-
ten been performed on small, ex situ populations
rather than populations in home ranges. Ex situ Asian
elephant PVA includes populations in Australian zoos
(Myroniuk 2004), North American zoos (Faust et al.
2006) and the viability of Asian elephant cows in Eu-
ropean zoos (Clubb et al. 2009).
Similar to Leimgruber et al. (2008) we ran our
model on a 500 yr timeframe rather than 100 or
1000 yr. A 100 yr timeframe may give declining pop-
ulations false indicators of population perpetuity
(Armbruster et al. 1999). Moderately longer time -
scales are recommended for populations with a neg-
ative growth rate and long generations. Given the
Lao context we considered a 1000 yr timeframe as
having too many unknown variables (political and
environmental) to provide as meaningful an analysis
as a 500 yr time scale. To test our baseline scenario
rigour we ran sensitivity analyses against 2 vital
parameters: percent of females breeding and calf
mortality. Neither increases nor decreases of 20%
affected the model.
Baseline parameters for PVA scenarios
Parameters for the 7 scenarios were determined
from the Lao national elephant registration database
and other published demographic data (Lair 1997,
Leimgruber et al. 2008, ElefantAsia 2012) (Table 1).
From the database we were able to accurately spec-
ify vital parameters, such as elephant age, sex and
initial population size. The population was consid-
ered a single, closed population with no migration,
rather than several small populations. We considered
this to be realistic as mahouts routinely buy, sell,
rent, or move elephants between pro vinces, as eco-
nomic drivers demand. Migration was not included,
as illegally exported calves will typically be un known
to ElefantAsia and not contained in the database. If
the elephant was included in the database, its entry
would be deactivated once exported and not incorpo-
rated in this analysis. Initial population size was 431,
of which 253 were cows and 178 bulls (ElefantAsia
2012). This figure includes only calves and elephants
of reproductive age. Maximum age of reproduction
for cows and bulls was 55 yr (Mar 2002, Leimgruber
et al. 2008). Carrying capacity was 517 —20% above
the current population size.
Following Leimgruber et al. (2008), the age of first
offspring and the mortality rates for bulls and cows
were considered to be alike, since we did not wish to
overstate the rate of extinction. We used infant mor-
tality rates based on Leimgruber et al. (2008) for cap-
tive elephants rather than wild elephant mortality
rates indicated by Armbruster et al. (1999) or wild
elephant mortality rates for Sri Lankan populations
(Sukumar 2003). This was considered appropriate as
captive elephants face fewer environmental threats
and have better veterinary care than wild calves.
3
Author copy
Endang Species Res 24: 1–7, 2014
Similarly, we chose an even sex ratio at birth. While
Lao mahouts believe slightly more males are con-
ceived (authors’ pers. obs.), male calves tend to have
a higher perinatal and juvenile mortality rate (Sara-
gusty et al. 2009). Juvenile bull behaviour and higher
risk-taking typically lead to higher mortality rates in
this sex (Sukumar 2003).
Percentage of breeding females was calculated by
analyzing the past 4 yr of captive elephant births
recorded in the database (ElefantAsia 2012) (Table 2).
This is the most accurate Lao captive elephant data
ever recorded, and it was considered necessary to
use actual representative values rather than breed-
ing estimates from other elephant studies. The aver-
age percentage of breeding females was low (2.3%),
but we considered this an accurate portrayal of the
current Lao context. Percentage of males in the
breeding pool was 80% (Leimgruber et al. 2008), as
social hierarchy dictates that not all bulls have the
opportunity to reproduce. However, as most calves
are sired by wild bulls, the fertility of captive bulls
remains unknown.
We did not include harvesting in any scenario, nor
did we include any wild elephant population demo-
graphics in our scenarios. With wild elephant popula-
tions poorly monitored and managed, we focused
solely on the population with known and controllable
conservation management.
RESULTS
All our simulations indicate that Laos’
captive elephant population is not self-
sustaining. The current captive population
has a negative growth rate (r = −0.099)
(Table 3). Mortality rates are higher than
reproductive rates. Our baseline popula-
tion shows the captive elephant popula-
tion is likely to become extinct in 112 yr. In
no scenario was the carrying capacity
reached. Reducing mortality, increasing
birth rates and population supplementa-
tion reduced the rate at which the popula-
tion reached extinction, but did not stop it.
Scenario 7 provided the Lao captive ele-
phant population with the longest persist-
ence, but even then our model predicted
extinction within 220 yr (Fig. 2).
DISCUSSION
Current management regimes are not
sufficient to support the long-term viability
of the Lao captive elephant population.
Our results are similar to those from
studies of Myanmar captive elephant pop-
ulations (Mar 2002, Leimgruber et al.
2008) and Thai elephants in Australian
zoos (Myroniuk 2004). However, while the
parameters used are largely represen tative
of the Lao elephant population, mortality
rates are estimates and not necessarily
representative of the true mortality rate,
particularly for calves. The 8% mortality
rate for calves taken from Leimgruber et
4
Year No. of No. of cows No. of % of births Reproductive
elephants 15−55 yr births (population) rate
2008 432 229 5 1.16 2.2
2009 434 231 3 0.69 1.3
2010 440 232 7 1.59 3
2011 439 226 6 1.37 2.7
Total 21 1.20 2.3
Table 2. Elephas maximus. Reproductive rate of captive cows in Laos
from 2008 to 2011. New elephants were added to the database as they
were microchipped
Parameter Description
BASELINE
Mating system Polygynous, 80% of males and 2.3%
females in breeding pool
Sexual maturity 15 yr for both sexes, maximum
reproductive age 55 yr
Litter size 1 with a 1:1 sex ratio at birth
Initial population structure Specified aged distribution
Age (yr) Mortality (%)
0−5 8
5−15 2.1
>15 2.9
Initial population size 431
Carrying capacity 512
MODEL ITERATIONS
Scenario 1 Current captive/baseline population
Scenario 2 Scenario 1 + 5% higher fecundity
Scenario 3 Scenario 1 + 10% higher fecundity
Scenario 4 Scenario 2 + 50% lower mortality
Scenario 5 Scenario 3 + 50% lower mortality
Scenario 6 Scenario 5 + 5 calves supplemented
Scenario 7 Scenario 5 + 10 calves supplemented
Table 1. Elephas maximus. Baseline parameters and 7 management
scenarios applied in VORTEX for Lao captive elephant population viabil-
ity analyses. Age applies to both sexes. All model scenarios were repeated
1000 times over 500 yr
Author copy
Suter et al.: Population viability analysis for captive elephants
al. (2008) may be too high, producing an excessive ex-
tinction rate. Understanding the real mortality rates for
this population will provide greater accuracy in fur-
ther population viability analysis. Furthermore, in-
creased funding for additional conservation manage-
ment will permit a greater delivery of services. This
will facilitate improved reproductive and veterinary
efforts. We suggest conservation management aims to
provide better outreach services to mahouts and their
elephants, ensuring a regular birth and death census,
as well as services to lower elephant mortality rates
and increase fecundity rates, and the consideration of
population supplementation.
Reducing mortality rates
Very little information is known about mortality
rates and the official causes of death among cap tive
Lao elephants. Deaths are often under reported by
mahouts; post mortems are rarely performed, and
there is minimal access to laboratories for blood
and tissue analysis (Labatut & Suter 2010). While the
healthcare of captive elephants is improving, a lack of
robust knowledge about disease and in fection rates
combined with a lack of national capacity to contain
potential disease outbreaks should be recognized as
major threats to captive elephants. A reduction in
mortality rates should, therefore, focus on continued
veterinary checks, mahout education, improving lab-
oratory facilities and disease diagnosis, infectious dis-
ease assessments and more frequent post mortem
analysis. Emerging diseases such as elephant en-
dotheliotropic herpesvirus and tuberculosis represent
addition threats to elephants. No studies have been
performed to assess wild elephant disease or infection
rates. Pregnant cows and calves should be identified
and monitored on a quarterly or biannual basis and
the owner should be contacted regularly by telephone
to determine the elephants’ health status.
Increasing fecundity rates
The small number of reproductively vi -
able females inhibits significant popula-
tion growth, although an increase in
fecundity does assist population persist-
ence. The tourism and export industries
are driving demand for calves, with pur-
chase prices reaching >$30 000 US (Suter
et al. 2013). The high price for calves may
now be a very good financial incentive for
mahouts to undertake breeding programs,
5
Scenario Growth Probability of Time until first Years until
rate extinction (%) extinction extinction
1 −0.099 100 41.06 ± 25.86 112
2 −0.081 100 45.42 ± 27.77 136
3 −0.064 100 53.05 ± 32.92 183
4 −0.064 100 58.85 ± 38.52 154
5 −0.047 100 70.74 ± 49.60 219
6 −0.064 100 65.26 ± 41.36 180
7 −0.047 100 74. 36 ± 52.35 220
Table 3. Elephas maximus. Growth rates and extinction risk of 7 popula-
tion viability scenarios for Lao captive elephants. Time until first extinc-
tion is given as mean ±SD; scenarios are described in Table 1
Fig. 2. Elephas maximus. VORTEX population trajectories of the captive Lao population, in a 500 yr simulation time period.
(a) The baseline scenario indicates extinction in 112 yr, whereas (b) the Management Scenario 7 indicates extinction in 220 yr
Author copy
Endang Species Res 24: 1–7, 2014
and more mahouts should be encouraged to partici-
pate. Conservation management should identify and
target the owners of cows 30 yr and under for breed-
ing incentives. There have previously been arrange-
ments between non-governmental organizations and
mahouts to enable their cows to breed, demonstrat-
ing that Lao ma houts are willing to stop work for con-
servation measures if economic losses are not
incurred (Suter 2011). Training in estrus detection is
also an important skill for mahouts to develop. How-
ever, it must be ensured that calves born as a result of
breeding programmes are kept in the country and
not rented or sold to other nations by the Govern-
ment of Laos.
Population supplementation
Our analysis indicates that calf supplementing pro-
vides the population with greater persistence than
increasing female reproduction rates or reducing
mortality. We propose a transparent rental agree-
ment from another range nation of Elephas maximus
indicus as a method to safeguard the Lao elephant
population. Rental agreements regarding Appendix
1 species are permitted under CITES regulations, to
which Laos, Thailand and India are all signatories
(Choudhury et al. 2008). Additions of new elephants
may be expensive, but could prevent extinction of
the Lao captive elephant population. An Interna-
tional Non-Government Organisation could organize
the rental agreements and be responsible for man-
agement of the elephants and a breeding program
while they are in Laos. While supplementation would
be an arduous task, it may be unnecessary if all
calves born into captivity are accounted for and used
for in situ reproductive purposes rather than ex ported
for diplomatic purposes. If exportation continues, a
transparent rental agreement with another range
nation of E. m. indicus may be necessary to avoid
regional extinction.
Management implications
The analyses reported here used the best available
estimates of population parameters for captive ele-
phants in Lao PDR. These findings suggest that,
while still important for industries and communities,
the Lao captive elephant population requires greater
management for population persistence; therefore, it
should not be considered as a separate management
unit. Rather, management of the captive Asian ele-
phant population should be conducted across
national boundaries in order to establish a greater
chance of preventing regional extinction. This man-
agement may take the form of transfers of young to
supplement local populations and prevent the
genetic problems associated with small population
sizes. It may also be feasible to set targets for the
growth of regional populations and to provide incen-
tives or rewards for meeting those targets. While dis-
cussion continues concerning greater cooperation
between range nations, in reality, actions and fund-
ing toward this goal have so far been insignificant
(Lair 2002, Dublin et al. 2006). Funding for Lao cap-
tive elephant management is urgently needed if this
regionally significant population is to persist.
Acknowledgements. The authors appreciate the assistance
given by the Department of Livestock and Fisheries’ director
Dr. Bounkouang and the National Animal Health Center’s
director Dr. B. Douangneun. We also thank the staff at Ele-
fantAsia, specifically S. Duffillot, T. Douangdy and V. Chan-
thavong for database compilation and the intrepid task of
captive elephant microchipping. Veterinarians supervising
the Mobile Veterinary Unit field missions included Dr. B.
Bouchard, Dr. J. Lassausaie and Dr. A. Bret. ElefantAsia
appreciates the financial support received from Critical Eco-
systems Partnership Fund to microchip and to create the Lao
national elephant registration database.
LITERATURE CITED
Ahlering M, Hedges S, Johnson A, Tyson M, Schuttler S,
Eggert L (2011) Genetic diversity, social structure, and
conservation value of the elephants of the Nakai Plateau,
Lao PDR, based on non-invasive sampling. Conserv
Genet 12: 413−422
Akçakaya H, Sjögren-Gulve P (2000) Population viability
analyses in conservation planning; an overview. Ecol
Bull 48: 9−21
Armbruster P, Fernando P, Lande R (1999) Time frames for
population viability analysis of species with long genera-
tions: an example with Asian elephants. Anim Conserv 2:
69−73
Bandara R, Tisdell C (2004) The net benefit of saving the
Asian elephant: a policy and contingent valuation study.
Ecol Econ 48: 93−107
Beissinger M, Westphal MI (1998) On the use of demo-
graphic models of population viability in endangered
species management. J Wildl Manag 62: 821−841
Choudhury A, Lahiri Choudhury DK, Desai A, Duckworth A
and others (2008) Elephas maximus. www. iucn redlist
.org/ apps/redlist/details/7140/0 (accessed 19 April 2011)
Clubb R, Rowcliffe M, Lee P, Mar K, Moss C, Mason G
(2009) Fecundity and population viability in female zoo
elephants: problems and possible solutions. Anim Welf
18: 237−247
Dublin H, Desai AA, Hedges S, Vié JC, Bambaradeniya C,
Lopez A (2006) Asian Elephant Range States Meeting,
24–26 January 2006, Juala Lumpur, Malaysia Report. In:
6
Author copy
Suter et al.: Population viability analysis for captive elephants
IUCN Species Survival Commission (ed) Elephant Range
States Meeting, Kuala Lumpur. www.cites.org
Duffy R, Moore L (2011) Global regulations and local prac-
tices: the politics and governance of animal welfare in
elephant tourism. J Sustainable Tourism 19: 589−604
ElefantAsia (2007) Report: condition of Lao domesticated
elephants 2007. ElefantAsia, Vientiane
ElefantAsia (2012) ElefantAsia (V1-7) database. ElefantAsia,
Vientiane
Faust LJ, Thompson SD, Earnhardt JM (2006) Is reversing
the decline of Asian elephants in North American zoos
possible? An individual-based modeling approach. Zoo
Biol 25: 201−218
Harrison D, Schipani S (2009) Tourism in the Lao People’s
Democratic Republic. In: Hitchcock M, King VT, Parn-
well M (eds) Tourism in Southeast Asia: challenges and
new directions. Nordic Institute of Asian Studies, Copen-
hagen, p 172–180
Hedges S (2006) Conservation. In: Fowler MT, Mikota S
(eds) Biology, medicine, and surgery of elephants. Black-
well Publishing Professional, Ames, IA, p 475488
Hedges S, Tyson M, Sitompul A, Kinnaird M, Gunaryadi D
(2005) Distribution, status, and conservation needs of
Asian elephants (Elephas maximus) in Lampung
Province, Sumatra, Indonesia. Biol Conserv 124: 35−48
Khounboline K (2011) Current status of Asian elephants in
Lao PDR. Gajah 35: 62−66
Kontogeorgopoulos N (2009) Wildlife tourism in semi-
captive settings: a case study of elephant camps in north-
ern Thailand. Curr Issues Tourism 12:429– 449
Labatut F, Suter I (2010) The veterinary care of domesticated
elephants in Laos by a mobile veterinary unit. Gajah 32:
21−26
Lacy R (1993) VORTEX: a computer simulation model for
population viability analysis. Wildl Res 20: 45−65
Lacy RC (2000) Considering threats to the viability of small
populations using individual-based models. Ecol Bull 48:
39−51
Lair R (1997) Gone astray: the care and management of the
Asian elephant in domesticity. Food and Agriculture
Organization of the United Nations, Bangkok
Lair R (2002) A regional overview of the need for registration
of domesticated Asian elephants. In: Baker I, Kashio M
(eds) Giants on our hands: Proc Int Workshop on the
domesticated Asian elephant, 5–10 February 2001,
Bangkok. UN FAO Regional Office for Asia and the
Pacific, Bangkok, p 8–13
Leimgruber P, Senior B, Uga, Aung M and others (2008)
Modeling population viability of captive elephants in
Myanmar (Burma): implications for wild populations.
Anim Conserv 11: 198−205
Mar K (2002) The studbook of timber elephants of Myanmar
with special reference to survivorship analysis. In: Baker
I, Kashio M (eds) Giants on our hands: Proc Int Workshop
on the domesticated Asian elephant, 5–10 February
2001, Bangkok. UN FAO Regional Office for Asia and the
Pacific, Bangkok, p 195–211
Miller P, Lacy R (2005) VORTEX: a stochastic simulation of
the extinction process, Version 9.50’s user’s manual.
Conservation Breeding Specialist Group (SSC/IUCN),
Apple Valley, MN
Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry (2009) National Ele-
phant Management Action Plan: Lao PDR. Vientiane,
Lao PDR
Myroniuk P (2004) Population viability analysis of captive
Asian elephants in Australia: a conservation assessment.
Humane Society International Australia. www. hsi. org. au/
editor/ assets/ legal/ PVA_ Report.pdf (accessed 5 Decem-
ber 2011)
Norachack B (2002) The care and management of domesti-
cated Asian elephants in Lao PDR. In: Baker I, Kashio M
(eds) Giants on our hands: Proc Int Workshop on the
domesticated Asian elephant, 5–10 February 2001,
Bangkok. UN FAO Regional Office for Asia and the
Pacific, Bangkok, p 172–180
Phakdisoth L, Kim D (2007) The determinants of inbound
tourism in Laos. ASEAN Econ Bull 24: 225−237
Saragusty J, Hermes R, Göritz F, Schmitt DL, Hildebrandt
TB (2009) Skewed birth sex ratio and premature mortal-
ity in elephants. Anim Reprod Sci 115: 247−254
Sukumar R (2003) The living elephants: evolutionary ecol-
ogy, behavior, and conservation. Oxford University
Press, New York, NY
Sukumar R (2006) A brief review of the status, distribution
and biology of wild Asian elephants Elephas maximus.
Int Zoo Yearb 40: 1−8
Sukumar R, Santiapillai C (1993) Asian elephant in Suma-
tra population and habitat viability analysis. Gajah 11:
59−63
Suter I (2011) Luxembourg Government assists with Lao
elephant reproduction. Available at: www. elefantasia.
org/ spip. php? article 160 &lang=en (accessed 5 December
2013)
Suter IC (2012) Really Laos, you shouldn’t have: giving ele-
phants to Japan is a bad idea. http: // the conversation.
edu. au/ really-laos-you-shouldnt-have-giving-elephants-
to-japan-is-a-bad-idea-9778 (accessed 13 September
2013)
Suter IC, Hockings M, Baxter G (2013) Changes in elephant
ownership and employment in the Lao PDR: implications
for the elephant-based logging and tourism industries.
Hum Dimens Wildl 18: 279−291
Xaymountry B, Maurer G (2011) Note on domesticated ele-
phant management in Lao PDR. ElefantAsia, Vientiane
7
Editorial responsibility: Nils Bunnefeld,
Stirling, UK
Submitted: September 13, 2013; Accepted: January 7, 2014
Proofs received from author(s): March 7, 2014
Author copy
... Anticipating the future of the increase or reduce the population in various aspects for planning alternatives for further management in the future is an important tool in conservation biology (Radchuk et al. 2016) for management planning to reduce the likelihood of species extinction based on population variables as well as creating hypothetical events in various aspects including defining conditions for variation in population and environment The selection of the VORTEX program is appropriate for low fertility species with long life spans, as well as having unequal sex ratios in the population (Lacy 2019). The VORTEX program was used to analyze the persistence of domesticated elephant populations in Burma (Leimgruber et al. 2008) and Laos (Suter et al. 2014), as well as in wild elephants on Sumatra, Indonesia (Mossbrucker et al. 2016), Sri Lanka (de Silva and Leimgruber 2019), Yunnan Province, China (He et al. 2020). A study by Prado-Oviedo et al. (2016) found that captive Asian elephants kept in zoo conditions in North America cannot survive on their own in the long term, while the results of the study on the ability to sustain the captive elephant population of the European Association of Zoos and Aquaria Ex-situ Program (EEP) found that it can be sustained over the long term. ...
... The results of the existing analysis of the population of captive elephants in Laos with an initial population of 480 captive elephants revealed that the population of the elephants in Laos had a negative growth rate (r= -0.099), having a higher mortality rate than the birth rate. Results of the study show that the captive elephant population in Laos is likely to become extinct within 112 years (Suter et al. 2014). While Leimgruber et al. (2008) reported that although the number of captive elephants in Myanmar is the highest within the Asian elephant range countries, with a population of approximately 6,000 captive elephants, however, the long-term viability analysis shows that the captive elephant population in Myanmar is unable to sustain itself long term. ...
... The study specified a time frame for the 500-year analysis and baseline parameters, as did Leimgruber et al. (2008), Suter et al. (2014), and He et al. (2020), by setting a variable to test the baseline scenario. Only the death variable was tested by assuming the situation on both sides increases and a decrease in population mortality in the current fertility situation of the herd elephant population how it affects the long-term treatment of the population. ...
Article
Full-text available
Pla-ard M, Sukmasuang R, Uthairasmee S. 2022. Some population characteristics and viability of captive Asian elephant (Elephas maximus) in Thailand. Biodiversitas 23: 1072-1081. Sustaining long-term viable populations of captive Asian elephants poses a challenge in managing the existing populations. Therefore, studies of the characterization and long-term persistence of the population are an important aspect of the action. The results of long-term population analysis of captive Asian elephants (Elephas maximus Linnaeus, 1758) using Population Viability Analysis (PVA) from the demography information showed that the birth and reproductive rate of the captive elephants in Thailand are declining significantly while the mortality rate trends are stable. Analysis results of the population's ability to persist in the long term from the initial population of 4,252 elephants, it was found that extinction of the population if the percentage adult female breeding is 80%, which is the best-case scenario, if the mortality rate increases by 6% from the present, the population will start going into extinction. If the percentage adult female breeding is set to 2.3%, which is the lowest breeding condition in captive Asian elephants, the population will become extinct in every scenario. Therefore, the most important method in maintaining the captive Asian elephant population is to increase the birth rate improve the well-being, health, nutrition, environment, and welfare of elephants in captivity are important factors that would reduce deaths and are very important for the long-term survival of the population in Thailand.
... Trophy hunting can be conducted such that those living with wildlife can accrue economic benefits that arise from wildlife management. Elephants are primarily hunted for their ivory, which is used for carvings, ornaments, jewellery, chopsticks, and other crafts (Suter et al., 2014). ...
Article
Full-text available
This study assessed the influence of a 2014 United States of America (USA) imposed ban on the importation of elephant (Loxodonta africana) hunted trophies from Zimbabwe on the hunting patterns (i.e., elephant quota allocation, utilisation and hunter’s or client country of origin dynamics) in Matetsi Hunting Complex. The study was divided into two period, i.e., pre- ban (2008–2013) and post-ban (2014–2017). Study results showed that although the quota allocation did not vary significantly between the pre-ban and post-ban periods, there was however, a significant decline in quota utilisation in post-ban period compared to the pre-ban period. Accordingly, a significant decline in US hunters or clients was recorded post-ban period. It is concluded that trophy hunting and trade bans by some global north countries without an alternative global conservation framework that provides conservation incentives will likely reverse the gains in wildlife conservation and rural development in some global south countries where sustainable utilisation is an integral part of wildlife conservation practice.
... • Taux Les premières modélisations démographiques réalisées sur la population captive au Laos, indique que pour tous les scénarios testés, elle se dirige vers une extinction d'ici un à deux siècles, avec une diminution rapide des effectifs de près de 50 % dans les 20 à 30 prochaines années (Sukumar, 2006 ;Suter et al., 2014). Les dernières études prenant en compte des facteurs politicoéconomiques ainsi que le fort lien avec la population sauvage envisagent plutôt une Je me suis donc demandé si le supposé faible taux de mortalité chez les jeunes ainsi que la très faible importance rapportée de l'EEHV pouvaient être due à une présence peu importance du virus dans la population d'éléphants du Laos. ...
... However, the elephant population in Laos is now highly threatened. A recent study estimates that Laos elephants will be extinct in 112 years (Suter, 2014). ...
Chapter
Full-text available
Do animals work? Is it possible to work with animals without exploiting them? Might animals even be empowered through work? This provocative collection offers original answers to these questions and allows readers to think about human relationships with domestic animals beyond the well-trodden tropes of domination or animal welfare. To study animal work means to look at animals in new ways and to discover in them unsuspected skills and knowledge that open up new ethical and political horizons.
Chapter
Zoos and aquariums are culturally and historically important places where families enjoy their leisure time and scientists study exotic animals. Many contain buildings of great architectural merit. Some people consider zoos little more than animal prisons, while others believe they play an important role in conservation and education. Zoos have been the subject of a vast number of academic studies, whose results are scattered throughout the literature. This interdisciplinary volume brings together research on animal behaviour, visitor studies, zoo history, human-animal relationships, veterinary medicine, welfare, education, enclosure design, reproduction, legislation, and zoo management conducted at around 200 institutions located throughout the world. The book is neither 'pro-' nor 'anti-' zoo and attempts to strike a balance between praising zoos for the good work they have done in the conservation of some species, while recognising that they face many challenges in making themselves relevant in the modern world.
Article
Full-text available
The mahouts and the elephants of Thongmyxay district in Laos form an original hybrid community composed of humans and an animal species represented by both wild and domestic animals (elephants). We investigated in particular the interactions between mahouts' observation of elephants and their own medicinal practices (human and ethnoveterinary), which have been the subject of two previous publications. Based on this material, supplemented by data collected on the status of domestic village elephants and interviews with four local healers, we discuss here with a multispecies approach combining ethnographic data and ethological knowledge, the modalities of construction and possible exchanges of medicinal knowledge between the two species.Elephants have a status characterised by a double hybridity: wild and domestic on the one hand (with ontological circulations from one state to the other), and animal and human on the other. The part of humanity attributed to the elephants is reflected in particular in the self-agency that is recognised in their ability to heal themselves when they are suffering, which leads to the therapeutic use of their dung by Mahouts. The mahouts include in their ethnoveterinary care of the elephants plants that they see the elephants use when they are ill. The medicinal uses they make of some of these plants in their households are more consistent with their observations of these elephant behaviours than it is with the use of the same items by local healers, suggesting a transfer of medicinal knowledge from elephants to mahouts.Since some of the village elephants in Thongmyxay are still periodically released and come into contact with their wild counterparts, the domestication space forms an interface between humans, wild elephants and the forest, and we discuss conversely the possibility of knowledge transfer from mahouts to village elephants through the ethnoveterinary care they receive.This knowledge which is precious for the health and well-being of people and elephants in Laos is threatened by the reduction of the forest cover sheltering the resources used, and by the relocation of village elephants to tourist centres. Thus, emerges the need to think the conservation of the intangible heritage represented by the knowledge of hybrid communities in terms of interspecific heritage, implying that along with the preservation of the ecosystems that host the resources involved in this knowledge, care must be taken to maintain their access to all the populations (human and animal) that use them.
Article
Full-text available
The mahouts and the elephants of Thongmyxay district in Laos form an original hybrid community composed of humans and an animal species represented by both wild and domestic animals (elephants). We investigated in particular the interactions between mahouts' observation of elephants and their own medicinal practices (human and ethnoveterinary), which have been the subject of two previous publications. Based on this material, supplemented by data collected on the status of domestic village elephants and interviews with four local healers, we discuss here with a multispecies approach combining ethnographic data and ethological knowledge, the modalities of construction and possible exchanges of medicinal knowledge between the two species. Elephants have a status characterised by a double hybridity: wild and domestic on the one hand (with ontological circulations from one state to the other), and animal and human on the other. The part of humanity attributed to the elephants is reflected in particular in the self-agency that is recognised in their ability to heal themselves when they are suffering, which leads to the therapeutic use of their dung by Mahouts. The mahouts include in their ethnoveterinary care of the elephants plants that they see the elephants use when they are ill. The medicinal uses they make of some of these plants in their households are more consistent with their observations of these elephant behaviours than it is with the use of the same items by local healers, suggesting a transfer of medicinal knowledge from elephants to mahouts.Since some of the village elephants in Thongmyxay are still periodically released and come into contact with their wild counterparts, the domestication space forms an interface between humans, wild elephants and the forest, and we discuss conversely the possibility of knowledge transfer from mahouts to village elephants through the ethnoveterinary care they receive.This knowledge which is precious for the health and well-being of people and elephants in Laos is threatened by the reduction of the forest cover sheltering the resources used, and by the relocation of village elephants to tourist centres. Thus, emerges the need to think the conservation of the intangible heritage represented by the knowledge of hybrid communities in terms of interspecific heritage, implying that along with the preservation of the ecosystems that host the resources involved in this knowledge, care must be taken to maintain their access to all the populations (human and animal) that use them.
Article
Full-text available
Background Despite a widespread aversion towards faeces and urine, animal excreta are used in traditional medicine in many countries since centuries, but records are scattered and few therapeutic uses have been accurately documented while in the current context of emerging zoonoses such records may be of major interest. Methodology In this study, we investigated the therapeutic uses that mahouts in Xayaboury province, Lao PDR make of elephant urine and faeces as well as of the brood chamber that beetles ( Heliocopris dominus ) fashion from elephant dung. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with mahouts on elephant diet, health problems and responses to disease, andwhether they use elephant products. Data were supplemented by interviews with traditional healers. Results Seven respondents reported the use of elephant urine in ethnoveterinary care for elephants and in human medicine in case of diabetes and otitis. 25 respondents reported therapeutic use of elephant faeces (EF) and elephant dung beetle brood chambers. The major indications are gastrointestinal and skin problems. Macerations or decoctions are drunk or used externally as a lotion. The mahouts attribute the therapeutic effectiveness of EFs to their content which includes the remains of many species from the elephant diet which they consider to be medicinal. Discussion The indications of these uses are consistent with pharmacological and clinical studies highlighting the properties of different animals’ urine and faeces and their curative potential tested in vivo. The acknowledgement by the mahouts of medicinal properties of elephant faecal bolus contrasts with the rare justifications of animal material use recorded in zootherapeutic studies, which falls within the symbolic domain. However, numerous studies highlight the preponderant role of the microbiota in physiological processes, raising the hypothesis of a curative action of EF, by rebalancing the user’s microbiota. Conclusion The therapeutic uses of EF preparations despite their possible curative properties are a potential source of zoonotic transmission from elephants to humans. In the current context of globalisation of trade which favours the emergence of zoonoses and in relation with the issue of One Health, it becomes crucial to further document the zootherapeutic practices to prevent emerging diseases. As elephants and local related ethnoethological knowledge are threatened, documenting them is urgent to contribute to their preservation.
Article
Full-text available
This article focuses on the intersection of indigenous peoples, conservation, and elephant well-being in Cambodia. While social justice advocates emphasize the human cost of conservation in human-animal conflicts, those concerned with animal protection and rights have problematized the treatment of elephants. This critique stems from evidence that the human relationship to elephants, captive and wild, remains largely utilitarian or exploitive. In Cambodia, there is a record of wild Asian elephants co-existing with local communities, but more so long history of elephants used for labor. This article discusses the possible areas of reconciliation between human and Asian elephant interests, in light of the Mondulkiri elephant sanctuary in Cambodia, suggesting potential paths toward win-win scenarios for the local and indigenous people, as well as for the elephants and their habitats.
Article
Ethnopharmacological relevance: To what extent has animal observation contributed to the development of human pharmacopeias? We approach this question here through the study of mahouts' knowledge regarding the responses by elephants to their health problems, and the human medicinal uses of plants and the care of domestic animals that result from their observations. Materials and methods: 32 mahouts were interviewed in Thongmyxay district and 28 at the Elephant Conservation Center in the province of Xayabury. Interviews focused on the elephants' diet, health problems, plant items they consume in particular physiological or pathological contexts and the treatments that mahouts provide them. For each plant mentioned, the part of the plant consumed and mode of preparation and administration if used by mahouts were recorded. Species samples were then collected and later identified by specialists. Results: 114 species were recorded as being consumed by elephants during interviews with mahouts and forest outings with them to collect samples. Twenty species were identified as used by elephants in particular pathological conditions or physiological states. According to interviewed mahouts, the consumption of certain plants improves the health of the elephant. We observed clear convergences between the observations interpreted by the mahouts as self-medication behaviour from elephants and their own medicinal practices (for human and veterinary purposes). Conclusion: Beyond a mere reproduction of elephant self-medication behaviours observed, the human or veterinary medicinal cares derived from these observations are the result of complex arrangements integrating all available medicinal and conceptual resources into elaborate preparations. We recommend that mahouts' knowledge about traditional medicinal care given to elephants be further compiled, as it could have a beneficial impact on veterinary health care provided in elephant resorts and elephants' well-being.
Article
Full-text available
Communities in the Lao People's Democratic Republic (PDR) have been utilizing captive Asian elephants (Elephas maximus) for centuries. The elephant handler (mahout) profession has remained fundamentally unchanged. Captive elephants, however, are no longer necessary in roles where they were once considered vital, particularly the logging industry. To gauge mahout demographics and assess problems associated with elephant industries, we surveyed 133 mahouts in the Lao PDR. We found that mahoutship is an aging industry with a vanishing family association. Contrasts between logging and tourism mahouts were apparent when observing family tradition, finances, and industry-related experiences. Logging mahouts rely on tourism to provide them with future employment; however, tourism cannot currently employ elephants on a scale similar to that of logging operations. The need for the traditional mahout and a large population of captive elephants may have reached its finality in Laos.
Article
Full-text available
Due to improved transportation and communication technology, changing social attitudes towards nature and wildlife, and the physiological benefits of interaction with animals, tourism centred on wildlife in captive and semi-captive settings is becoming increasingly popular. One example of wildlife tourism in a semi-captive setting is the proliferation of ‘elephant camps’ in Thailand, where tourists interact in a variety of ways with domesticated elephants. Though work in elephant camps can be difficult for elephants, tourism provides the only viable legal option for elephant owners and handlers to earn income. This study examines the characteristics, preferences, and values of the visitors of three elephant camps in the vicinity of Chiang Mai in northern Thailand and argues that despite reflecting divergent worldviews on, and practical approaches to, animal rights, each type of camp makes significant contributions to the overall welfare of Thailand's domesticated elephants.
Book
Elephants are possibly the most well-known members of the animal kingdom. The enormous size, unusual anatomy, and longevity of elephants have fascinated humans for millenia. Biology, Medicine, and Surgery of Elephants serves as a comprehensive text on elephant medicine and surgery. Based on the expertise of 36 scientists and clinical veterinarians, this volume covers biology, husbandry, veterinary medicine and surgery of the elephant as known today. Written by the foremost experts in the field. Comprehensively covers both Asian and African elephants. Complete with taxonomy, behavioral, geographical and systemic information. Well-illustrated and organized for easy reference.
Article
We extend an earlier population viability analysis (PVA) of the Asian elephant (Elephas maximus) conducted by Sukumar & Santiapillai (1993) in order to examine how conclusions about viability can depend upon the time frame examined. We find that there is an approximately 200 year lag period before extinction events begin to occur in slowly declining populations of E. maximus. Therefore, examining population persistence over a 100 year time frame seriously underestimates the risk of population extinction over a longer, 1000 year period. These results are supported by the use of both a species-specific model of elephant demography, ELEPHANT, and a generic PVA package, VORTEX. For populations with long generations, a 100 year time period will often not be sufficient to evaluate demographic processes leading to extinction. These results have important implications for how investigators conduct PVAs, and for the listing of endangered species by the World Conservation Union (IUCN).
Article
Population Viability Analysis (PVA) is the estimation of extinction probabilities by analyses that incorporate identifiable threats to population survival into models of the extinction process. Extrinsic forces, such as habitat loss, over-harvesting, and competition or predation by introduced species, often lead to population decline. Although the traditional methods of wildlife ecology can reveal such deterministic trends, random fluctuations that increase as populations become smaller can lead to extinction even of populations that have, on average, positive population growth when below carrying capacity. Computer simulation modelling provides a tool for exploring the viability of populations subjected to many complex, interacting deterministic and random processes. One such simulation model, VORTEX, has been used extensively by the Captive Breeding Specialist Group (Species Survival Commission, IUCN), by wildlife agencies, and by university classes. The algorithms, structure, assumptions and applications of VORTEX are described in this paper. VORTEX models population processes as discrete, sequential events, with probabilistic outcomes. VORTEX simulates birth and death processes and the transmission of genes through the generations by generating random numbers to determine whether each animal lives or dies, to determine the number of progeny produced by each female each year, and to determine which of the two alleles at a genetic locus are transmitted from each parent to each offspring. Fecundity is assumed to be independent of age after an animal reaches reproductive age. Mortality rates are specified for each pre-reproductive age-sex class and for reproductive-age animals. Inbreeding depression is modelled as a decrease in viability in inbred animals. The user has the option of modelling density dependence in reproductive rates. As a simple model of density dependence in survival, a carrying capacity is imposed by a probabilistic truncation of each age class if the population size exceeds the specified carrying capacity. VORTEX can model linear trends in the carrying capacity. VORTEX models environmental variation by sampling birth rates, death rates, and the carrying capacity from binomial or normal distributions. Catastrophes are modelled as sporadic random events that reduce survival and reproduction for one year. VORTEX also allows the user to supplement or harvest the population, and multiple subpopulations can be tracked, with user-specified migration among the units. VORTEX outputs summary statistics on population growth rates, the probability of population extinction, the time to extinction, and the mean size and genetic variation in extant populations. VORTEX necessarily makes many assumptions. The model it incorporates is most applicable to species with low fecundity and long lifespans, such as mammals, birds and reptiles. It integrates the interacting effects of many of the deterministic and stochastic processes that have an impact on the viability of small populations, providing opportunity for more complete analysis than is possible by other techniques. PVA by simulation modelling is an important tool for identifying populations at risk of extinction, determining the urgency of action, and evaluating options for management.
Article
As wildlife populations become smaller, the number of interacting stochastic processes which can destabilize the populations increases: genetic effects (inbreeding and loss of adaptability) and instability of the breeding structure (sex ratio imbalances, unstable age distribution, and disrupted social systems) can decrease population growth and stability. Recent analyses have shown that some populations can be very sensitive to these stochastic processes, at larger population sizes than had been suggested previously, and often in unexpected ways. Interactions among processes can reduce population viability much more so than would be assumed from consideration of isolated factors. For example, in monogamous species, random fluctuations in sex ratio will depress the mean number of breeding pairs in populations with as many as 500 adults. At low population densities, individuals may not be able to find mates, or may not encounter individuals sufficiently unrelated to be accepted as suitable mates. Inbreeding depression of demographic rates can become a significant contributor to population decline in populations with several hundred individuals, even if genetic problems are not the primary threat. Most models of genetic decay in small and fragmented populations assume demographic stability. However, when the increases in demographic fluctuations of small populations are considered, rates of loss of genetic variation and accumulation of inbreeding can be much faster than has been suggested before. These processes can be examined in detailed, individual-based PVA models. Accurate data to parameterize these models, however, are often not available. Thus, we need to interpret cautiously PVA conclusions for populations that are small, highly fragmented, or projected for many generations.
Article
Abstract Captive Asian elephants Elephas maximus, used as work animals, constitute up to 22–30% of remaining Asian elephants. Myanmar has the largest captive population worldwide (∼6000), maintained at this level for over a century. We used published demographic data to assess the viability of this captive population. We tested how this population can be self-sustained, how many elephants must be supplemented from the wild to maintain it, and what consequences live capture may have for Myanmar's wild population. Our results demonstrate that the current captive population is not self-sustaining because mortality is too high and birth rates are too low. Our models also suggest ∼100 elephants year−1 have been captured in the wild to supplement the captive population. Such supplementation cannot be supported by a wild population of fewer than 4000 elephants. Given the most recent expert estimate of ∼2000 wild elephants remaining in Myanmar, a harvest of 100 elephants year−1 could result in extinction of the wild population in 31 years. Continued live capture threatens the survival of wild and captive populations and must stop. In addition, captive breeding should be increased. These measures are essential to slow the decline and extinction of all of Myanmar's elephants.
Article
This paper specifies static and dynamic panel demand models for tourism in Laos and estimates tourism demand equations using tourist inflow data for the period 1995–2004. The models allow us to estimate the short- and long-run effects of tourism determinants. We find that communication and transportation infrastructure, destination risk, bilateral trade, and distance between Laos and countries of origin are, in the long run, among the main determinants of tourism to Laos. In particular, we find that tourism to Laos is income and price inelastic. This suggests that tourism to Laos is not a luxury good. The results of dynamic models indicate that relative price and infrastructure are more important determinants than income in the short-run adjustment of tourist inflow.