Conference PaperPDF Available

Preliminary Evaluation of the Psychometric Properties of the PTSD Checklist for DSM – 5

Authors:

Abstract

Cognitive Behavioral Therapy relies on accurate assessment to provide efficacious treatment. Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) has evolved in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders Fifth Edition (DSM-­5), most notably with the addition of the negative cognitions criterion category. The PTSD Checklist (PCL) is a validated self-­report screen for PTSD that provides both diagnostic and symptom severity assessment. The PCL-­5 is an updated version with new items that correspond to the recent changes. Prior research on the PCL has been limited in its focus to military, clinical, and predominantly male samples, largely ignoring other high risk populations. Public health estimates report significant trauma as high as 50 – 70% in college aged non-­clinical samples, with females at increased risk. Social psychological research posits that women are most likely to be the targets of interpersonal violence and sexual assault. Therefore, we evaluated the PCL-­5 in a largely female sample of undergraduates. To our knowledge, this study is the first to report on the psychometric properties and validity of the PCL-­5. A sample of 1093 participants (437 men, 656 women) enrolled in introductory psychology courses at a large public university in the northeastern United States completed the PCL-­5 in 2014. Using all 20 items of the PCL-­5, a principle component analysis indicated a single factor (Eigen value = 12.2) that accounted for 61% of the variance. Item loadings onto the single component ranged from .40 to .72. Cronbach’s alpha indicated high internal consistency for this scale (α =.97). For each of the criterion subscales, principle component analysis indicated a single factor that accounted for the variance. The variance accounted for in the subscales ranged from 66% to 91%. Cronbach’s alpha indicated high internal consistency for all of the criterion subscales ranging from α = .86 to α = .93. Using the symptom severity scoring method with cut point of 38 put forth by the National Center for PTSD, 8.5% (n = 93) of the sample met criteria for PTSD. Using the diagnostic scoring algorithm proposed by the National Center for PTSD, 10.8% (n = 131) of the sample met DSM 5 diagnostic criteria. The latter method resulted in a higher estimate of the prevalence of PTSD, but the two estimates were not significantly different from one-­another (χ2 = 3.2, p=0.07). We compared these results to a separate sample of 1,439 students (424 men, 1005 women) also drawn from introductory psychology courses at the same university who completed the PCL-­C in 2013. Results for both symptom severity and diagnostic assessment using the PCL-­C were not significantly different from PCL-­5 results. Finally, we found the women in our sample showed an elevation of PTSD symptoms relative to men. This study drew on existing research from other social sciences in order to address the need for the assessment of PTSD in women. Our results provide preliminary evidence for the PCL-­5 as an assessment to measure PTSD utilizing DSM-­5 criteria. Future research should evaluate the PCL-­5 in clinical populations and further test the measure’s psychometric properties. The accurate detection of individuals with PTSD is critical in order to provide the appropriate treatment.
Preliminary Evaluation of the Psychometric Properties
of the PTSD Checklist for DSM – 5
Jeffrey Cohen1, Nitya Kanuri2, Dustin Kieschnick1, Christine Blasey1,2, C. Barr Taylor2, Eric Kuhn3,
Caroline Lavoie1, Danielle M. Ryu1,2, Elise Gibbs1, Josef Ruzek3, & Michelle G. Newman4
PGSP – Stanford University PsyD Consortium1, Stanford University Medical Center2, VA National Center for PTSD2 , & The Pennsylvania State University4
Method'
A sample of 2490 participants (805 men, 1,679 women, 3 transgender ) enrolled in
introductory psychology courses in the northeastern United States completed the PCL-5 in 2014.
Two clinical psychology graduate students independently coded the experiences reported
by participants as traumatic or not according to DSM-5 criteria resulting in n = 248 (176 women,
73 men) of participants exposed to trauma. Agreement between raters was high (kappa = .88).
Using the 10% of participants with trauma exposure (n = 248), principle component analysis
was used to derive factors, loadings of each item onto factors, and internal consistency for the
four PCL-5 criterion subscales. Both symptom severity and the diagnostic classification scoring
were assessed, as well as the association between the two.
Criterion B (Re-experiencing)
A single factor accounted for 71% of the variance (Eigenvalue = 3.5). Item loadings ranged
from .82 to .89. Cronbach's α =.89
Criterion C (Avoidance)
A single factor accounted for 92% of the variance (Eigenvalue = 1.84). Item loadings were
.96 for both items. Cronbach’s α =.91
Criterion D (Negative Alterations in Cognition and Mood)
A single factor accounted for 65% of the variance (Eigenvalue = 4.53). Item loadings ranged
from .67 to .87. α =.91
Criterion E (Hyper-Arousal)
A single factor accounted for 60% of the variance (Eigenvalue = 3.61). Item loadings ranged
from .79 to .82. Cronbach’s α =.87
Results'
Introduc0on'
The definition of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) has
evolved in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders
Fifth Edition (DSM-5). The revised Criterion A delineates what
comprises a traumatic event and removes the previous requirement
of an emotional response of “fear, helplessness, or horror.” The
symptoms of PTSD expanded from the three diagnostic clusters in
the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders Fourth
Edition (DSM-IV-TR) to four behavioral clusters in DSM-5. The newly
added cluster, negative alterations in cognition and mood, joins the
DSM-IV-TR clusters of re-experiencing, avoidance, and arousal.
The PTSD Checklist (PCL) is a self-report screen for PTSD,
which can be scored for both diagnostic assessment and symptom
severity measurement. The PCL-5 is an updated version of the
questionnaire that includes 3 new items which correspond to the
new DSM-5 negative alteration in cognition and mood criterion
category. Additionally, the PCL-5 limits the scope of the assessment
to the “past week,” whereas prior versions of the PCL assessed
symptoms over the past month.
Previous versions of the PCL include the PTSD Checklist-
Military (PCL-M), PTSD Checklist-Civilian (PCL-C), and the PTSD
Checklist-Specific (PCL-S). Similar to the PCL-S, the PCL-5 prompts
participants to identify a specific traumatic event at the start of the
self-report measure.
Research on previous versions of PCL is limited to military,
clinical, and predominantly male samples. While the focus on the
aforementioned population is warranted given their known exposure
to major trauma, other high risk populations, such as female victims
of interpersonal violence, have been largely ignored.
The present study may be the first to estimate basic
psychometric properties of the PCL-5 as an assessment to screen
for PTSD. We evaluated the PCL-5 in a non-clinical, civilian
population comprised of 67% women.
Discussion'
All four criterion scales of the PCL-5 had high internal
consistency.
For this sample of college students, survivors of sexual and
physical assault reported the most severe PTSD
symptomatology.
Both the diagnostic algorithm and the symptom severity cut
point scoring produced comparable results, suggesting
evidence of concurrent validity for both methods.
This is a first step in establishing psychometric and clinical utility
of the PCL-5. Future studies will include testing a four factor
versus five factor model of PTSD (Elhai et al., 2011).
Shown in the figure below:
1.4% (36/2490) of the total sample met DSM-5 diagnostic criteria
for PTSD using the diagnostic algorithm of the PCL-5.
1.3% (32/2490) met criteria for PTSD using the cut-point
suggested by the National Center of PTSD (i.e, >38). For the
cut point of 38, the sensitivity was .78 and specificity was .98.
References
American Psychiatric Association (2013). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual Of Mental Disorders (5th ed.). Arlington, VA:
American Psychiatric Publishing.
Elhai, J. D., & Palmieri, P. A. (2011). The factor structure of posttraumatic stress disorder: A literature update, critique of
methodology, and agenda for future research. Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 25(6), 849-854.
Weathers, F.W., Litz, B.T., Keane, T.M., Palmieri, P.A., Marx, B.P., & Schnurr, P.P. (2013).The PTSD Checklist for DSM-5 (PCL-5)
Results'(con0nued)'
Shown in the table below are the traumas reported by the
participants and the mean PCL- 5 scores. The highest severity of
symptoms was reported by victims of sexual assault.
Denotes new items to PCL-5
1.4% 1.3%
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
Diagnostic Algorithm Symptom Severity
PTSD Prevalence in Sample
PCL-5 Items
20.$Trouble$falling$or$staying$asleep?
9.$Having$strong$negative$beliefs$about$yourself,$other$people,$or$the$world$
(for$example,$having$thoughts$such$as:$I$am$bad,$there$is$something$seriously$
wrong$with$me,$no$one$can$be$trusted,$the$world$is$completely$dangerous)?
10.$Blaming$yourself$or$someone$else$for$the$stressful$experience$or$what$
happened$after$it?
11.$Having$strong$negative$feelings$such$as$fear,$horror,$anger,$guilt,$or$
shame?
12.$Loss$of$interest$in$activities$that$you$used$to$enjoy?
13.$Feeling$distant$or$cut$off$from$other$people?
14.$Having$trouble$experiencing$positive$feelings$(for$example,$being$unable$
to$feel$happinenss$or$having$loving$feelings$for$people$close$to$you)?
15.$Feeling$irritable$or$angry$or$acting$aggressively?
16.$Taking$too$many$risks$or$doing$things$that$could$cause$you$harm?
17.$Being$"superalert"$or$watchful$or$on$guard?
18.$Feeling$jumpy$or$easily$startled?
19.$Having$difficulty$concentrating?
8.$Trouble$remembering$important$parts$of$the$stressful$experience?
In$the$past$week,$how$much$were$you$bothered$by:
1.$Repeated,$disturbing,$and$unwanted$memories$of$the$stressful$
experience?
2.$Repeated,$disturbing$dreams$of$the$stressful$experience?
3.$Suddenly$feeling$or$acting$as$if$the$stressful$experience$were$atually$
happening$again$(as$if$you$were$actuallly$back$there$reliving$it)?
4.$Feeling$very$upset$when$something$reminded$you$of$the$stressful$
experience?
5.$Having$strong$physical$reactions$when$something$reminded$you$of$the$
stressful$experience$(for$example,$heart$pounding,$trouble$breathing,$
sweating)?
6.$Avoiding$memories,$thoughts,$or$feelings$related$to$the$stressful$
experience?
7.$Avoiding$external$reminders$of$the$stressful$experience$(for$example,$
people,$places,$conversations,$activities,$objects,$or$situations)?
... A higher score is associated with a greater level of PTSD symptoms. A cut-off raw score is 38 for a provisional diagnosis of PTSD and this cut-off has high sensitivity (.78) and specificity (.98) (Cohen et al., 2015). In our study, the Ukrainian version was used (Agajev et al., 2016). ...
... The mean PCL-5 score was 39.2 (SD = 14.7, range 5-69). The majority of participants (79%) had PCL-5 scores of 38 or higher, which is the cut-off score for a provisional diagnosis of PTSD (Cohen et al., 2015). ...
... The mean PCL-5 score for the participants was 39.2 (SD = 14.7). Seventy-nine percent of the cohort had a PCL-5 score of 38 or higher (the cut-off raw score is 38 for a provisional diagnosis of PTSD, Cohen et al., 2015). Therefore, it can be inferred that almost four-fifths of the cohort could also have a clinical diagnosis of PTSD. ...
Article
Full-text available
In addition to the loss of life, Russian aggression against Ukraine, which began in February 2022, also brings interpersonal losses resulting from the need to emigrate. Parallel to the fighting men, women bear most of the burden of caring for the family. Using in-depth interviews supplemented by questions about adverse childhood experiences and administration of The Centrality of Events Scale and the PTSD Checklist – PCL-5 with 43 Ukrainian women (18–60 years old), we analyzed adaptation to the situation of emigration and the association of their war and earlier experiences with the level of traumatization. Women were interviewed shortly after emigration to the Czech Republic (3–42 week afterward). High levels of adverse childhood experiences and post-traumatic stress symptoms were found. The war was perceived as a currently negative central event associated with traumatic stress symptoms, and 79% of the sample expressed the opinion that the war had changed them. The results of this study suggest an intertwining of previous life experiences with the current need and ability to adapt.
... This is similar to the results of the original PCL-5 study. 28 In the original PCL-5 study, the eigenvalue of one factor was 12.2, accounting for 61% of the total explanatory value. 28 The AUC calculated to evaluate the sensitivity and specificity of K-PCL-5 was 0.95. ...
... 28 In the original PCL-5 study, the eigenvalue of one factor was 12.2, accounting for 61% of the total explanatory value. 28 The AUC calculated to evaluate the sensitivity and specificity of K-PCL-5 was 0.95. The cutoff value of the K-PCL-5 was 33. ...
Article
Full-text available
Objective: This study presents the reliability and validity of the Korean version of the post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) checklist for the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Mental Disorders-fifth edition (DSM-5) (K-PCL-5) and the short form (K-PCL-5-S). Methods: Seventy-one subjects with PTSD, 74 subjects with mood or anxiety disorders, and 99 healthy controls were enrolled. The Korean version of the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-5-research version was used to confirm the presence of PTSD. The Beck Depression Inventory-II (BDI-II), Beck Anxiety Inventory (BAI), Impact of Event Scale-Revised (IES-R), and Spielberger State Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI) were used to evaluate the concurrent validity of the K-PCL-5 and K-PCL-5-S. Results: It presented good internal consistency (Cronbach's α=0.93) and test-retest reliability (r=0.90). The K-PCL-5 and K-PCL-5-S were highly correlated with the BDI-II, BAI, IES-R, STAI-S, and STAI-T. The suggested cutoff score for PTSD was 33 for the K-PCL-5 with a sensitivity of 88.51 and specificity of 89.09, and 6 for the K-PCL-5-S with a sensitivity of 91.95 and specificity of 89.09. The data were best explained with a one-factor model. Conclusion: These results demonstrated the good reliability and validity of the K-PCL-5 and K-PCL-5-S, and their suitability as simple tools for PTSD assessment.
... Cut-off scores are available for determining overall level of severity of symptoms, from minimal to very severe (including 0-10 for minimal symptoms; 11-23 for mild symptoms; 24-42 for moderate symptoms; 43-59 for severe symptoms; and 60-80 for very severe symptoms). A 2015 study demonstrated "high levels of sensitivity (0.78) and specificity (0.98) using a cutoff of 38 for a provisional diagnosis of PTSD" [17]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Objective: To compare patients with psychogenic non-epileptic seizures (PNES) who requested reinstatement of driving privileges or reported having resumed driving to those who did not. Methods: Diagnosis of PNES was confirmed with video-EEG. Demographic and clinical data and requests for reinstatement of driving privileges (requiring 6 or more months seizure freedom) and reports of decisions to resume driving were noted. Self-report questionnaires of depression, anxiety and PTSD that were administered as part of neuropsychological assessment were analyzed. Results: Of 73 patients with PNES evaluated in 2018-2021, 22 later applied for driving privileges or reported that they resumed driving. When the two groups were compared, the group that applied for driving privileges or decided to resume driving was determined to be significantly less depressed (p = 0.014) when initially assessed than the group that did not. Conclusion: Resumption of driving behavior is an explicit measure of improvement for PNES because patients are advised to discontinue driving until they are seizure-free for a determined time span. Findings revealed that initial lower experienced levels of depression symptoms were associated with subsequent reported seizure-freedom which allowed for the reactivation of driving privileges. This underscores the importance that depression may have on PNES prognosis and supports assessing and treating comorbid mood symptoms in a timely manner.
... It is scored on a five-point Likert scale ranging from 0 (not at all) to 4 (extremely), and participants rate how bothered they were by each of the 20 items during the past month. The PCL-5 is a psychometrically sound measure with high validity and reliability (Blevins et al., 2015;Bovin et al., 2016;Cohen et al., 2014). The questionnaire used was the Arabic version of the PCL-5 validated on the Iraqi population, which has high internal consistency (a = 0 .85) ...
Article
Full-text available
As the Syrian crisis has reached its 10th year, this paper explores posttraumatic growth and the related factors among Syrian refugees in Turkey, with the aim of having a better understanding of the predictors of PTG and the risk factors that may play a role in the inhibition of the growth. In this cross-sectional study, 217 displaced Syrian refugees completed the Post Traumatic Growth Inventory (PTGI), Harvard Trauma Questionnaire (HTQ), Brief COPE, General Self-Efficacy Scale (GSES), PTSD Checklist for DSM-5 (PCL-5), and sociodemographic information form by a self-reported online survey. Risk and protective factors were associated in bivariate analysis with growth p < 0.05 and were retained in multiple regression models to control the confound-ers. Participants' 60.7% were females, and the mean age was 32.6 ± 9.4 years. Growth was found to be highest in the Personal Strengths, New Possibilities and Appreciation of Life, Relating to Others, and Spiritual Change. While the consistency of job education, economic status, education level, number of children, level of self-efficacy, level of Turkish, active coping style, religious coping, and self-distraction (p < 0.05) were protective factors, the number of traumatic events, and the PTSD symptoms and self-blame were risk factors (p < 0.05) in multiple analysis. However, no significant relationship was found for the variables of marital status, taking support, self-distraction, emotional and instrumental support, positive reframing, planning, cultural perception, working type, and age (p > 0.05). In conclusion, the findings have provided valuable insight into the domains of the growth among Syrian refugees and discussed both clinical and research-based future recommendations that could be made to improve the mental health of the refugees based on the obtained results.
... suggesting strong convergent and discriminant validity. Cohen et al. (2014) also found that the PCL-5 total and cluster scores demonstrated high internal reliability (ranging from α = .87 for cluster E to .97 for total score) in a trauma-exposed sample of 2,490 undergraduate students. ...
Thesis
Identifying immigration court respondents with mental illness who are unable to meaningfully participate in their cases is key to preserve their procedural due process rights. Since the enactment of the Matter of M-A-M (2011) standard, immigration judges have increasingly relied on mental health professionals to assess immigrants’ competence to participate and represent themselves in immigration court proceedings. However, to date, there is no standard of practice or specialized assessment instrument to guide the evaluation of competency in immigration court. At present, evaluators are responsible for interpreting the legal standard and developing their evaluation procedures. This study examined the psychometric properties of an adaptation of the Fitness Interview Test-Revised (FIT-R; Roesch et al., 2006) for use in immigration court, the Fitness Interview Test-Immigration Court (FIT-IC), in a sample of 62 Spanish-speaking immigrants. Feedback from seven mental health experts was also obtained to assess the content validity of the FIT-IC. It was hypothesized that the FIT-IC would display good content validity, interrater reliability, and internal consistency. It was also hypothesized that performance on the FIT-IC would be associated with acculturation, symptoms of mental illness (i.e., psychotic, depressive, and posttraumatic symptoms), and intellectual functioning. The study findings showed that the FIT-IC had strong content validity, with mental health experts considering that all FIT-IC items addressed relevant psycholegal abilities for establishing a respondent’s competence. The FIT-IC items and sections also demonstrated moderate to excellent interrater reliability. However, the FIT-IC sections failed to display good internal consistency. Regarding the correlates of performance on the FIT-IC, acculturation to U.S. culture was significantly associated with more factual understanding of immigration court proceedings (Section I), but only after removing questions about understanding the concept of competency from Item 2. Performance on the FIT-IC was not significantly associated with intellectual functioning, psychotic, or depressive symptoms. Contrary to expectations, there was a significant correlation between PTSD symptoms and more understanding of legal rights and possible consequences of the proceedings (Section II). Although more research is needed with a larger sample of immigrants with severe mental illness, the FIT-IC holds promise as a new competency assessment instrument for immigration court.
... The total score ranges from 20 to 80, with higher scores indicating more severe PTSD symptoms. A cut-off score of 38 or higher is often used to indicate a probable diagnosis of PTSD [53]. ...
Article
Mental disorders are conditions that affect a person’s cognitive functions, behavior or thinking, thereby impairing daily functions. The dearth of trained psychologists to the high number of patients living with a mental disorder pose significant challenges in the field of mental health. This study investigates the application of deep learning techniques to speech recognition for the purpose of detecting mental disorders. The main objective of this study is to effectively identify speech patterns associated with various mental disorders and thereafter develop a robust and accurate deep learning model system that can detect risk of a mental disorder in an individual based on their voice. The research methodology involved the collection of a dataset consisting of speech recordings from individuals diagnosed with depression and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). The dataset acquired was carefully curated to include symptom severity levels, and linguistic variations. The results of this study demonstrate the effectiveness of deep learning approaches in speech recognition for mental disorder detection. The trained models achieved 95% and 94% accuracy rates in identifying and differentiating speech patterns associated with depression and PTSD respectively. The findings of this study have significant implications for the field of mental health. The developed deep learning system offers a promising avenue for the early detection and monitoring of mental disorders. Further research is warranted to validate and refine the developed models using larger and more diverse dataset. Additionally, the integration of multimodal data, such as combining speech analysis with psychological or text-based data, could enhance the diagnostic accuracy and reliability of the system. Keywords: Deep Learning, Mental Disorder, Post-traumatic Stress Disorder, Speech Recognition, Depression.
... A cut-off raw score of 38. The cut-off point exhibits a notable level of sensitivity (0.78) and specificity (0.98) [28]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Hand trauma is a common and debilitating condition that can have significant physical, functional, and psychological effects on individuals. This study used a case–control design to investigate the frequency and factors associated with symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in a sample of individuals with complex hand and forearm injuries. Our hypothesis suggests that demographic data, among other factors, influences the intensity of PTSD symptoms measured by the PCL-5 scale three months post-surgery. This study included 166 individuals, 142 males and 24 females, with an average age of 42.14 years (SD = 12.71). Our study found significant associations between symptoms of PTSD and various demographic and clinical factors. PTSD symptoms were observed in females, individuals from specific regions, and certain socio-professional groups. Furthermore, educational attainment and personal background have been identified as significant factors in the development of PTSD. The role of trauma type was crucial, amputees and fractures were more prone to developing PTSD. A strong link was found between increased symptoms of PTSD and negative postoperative outcomes, including amputation of necessity and the need for additional surgery. The absence of family support exacerbates the psychological distress of trauma survivors. The findings highlight the intricate nature of PTSD development and underscore the significance of a comprehensive postoperative treatment strategy encompassing psychological assessment and support.
Article
Background Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a common pathological consequence of a variety of traumatic events. The core symptoms of PTSD, according to the The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-5), include persistent intrusion symptoms, persistent avoidance of stimuli, negative alterations in cognition or mood, and marked changes in arousal and reactivity, all of which are related to the traumatic event experienced. Aim The purpose of this study is to determine the prevalence of PTSD in coronavirus disease 2019 patients 1 month after discharge from the corona isolation unit at a tertiary care hospital. Methodology It was a cross-sectional analytical study. The study population were individuals over 18 years of age who tested positive and had been discharged from the corona isolation ward after recovery. They were interviewed by telephone, 1 month after discharge and enquired about demographic details and the questions from the PCL-5 checklist, after obtaining their consent. Results PTSD prevalence was 43%. A significant association ( P < 0.05) was obtained between PTSD and age (>55), female gender, and number of initial symptoms (≥3). Linear correlation was obtained between length of stay (>14 days) and PCL-5 scores. Diabetes and hypertension had a significant association with PTSD. Conclusion Telemental health programs should be launched to screen for psychological problems, and on positive screening, mental health professionals can help reduce the patient distress level by providing stress coping skills and brief cognitive behavioral therapy. Integrated, holistic care and technology hold hope to address the bidirectional effect of physical and mental illnesses.
Article
We present an update of recent literature (since 2007) exploring the factor structure of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptom measures. Research supporting a four-factor emotional numbing model and a four-factor dysphoria model is presented, with these models fitting better than all other models examined. Variables accounting for factor structure differences are reviewed, including PTSD query instructions, type of PTSD measure, extent of trauma exposure, ethnicity, and timing of administration. Methodological and statistical limitations with recent studies are presented. Finally, a research agenda and recommendations are offered to push this research area forward, including suggestions to validate PTSD’s factors against external measures of psychopathology, test moderators of factor structure, and examine heterogeneity of symptom presentations based on factor structure examination.
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual Of Mental Disorders
American Psychiatric Association (2013). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual Of Mental Disorders (5 th ed.). Arlington, VA: American Psychiatric Publishing.