Article

Rights of Passage: The Ethics of Immigration and Refugee Policy

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

In light of the legal, economic, and political aspects of migration, the authors of this Note on Moral Theology offer a comparative analysis of three rival ethical perspectives that tacitly shape our rhetoric regarding immigration and refugee policy: political liberalism, communitarianism, and Roman Catholic social thought. They conclude with an assessment of the distinctive theological and pastoral implications of migration.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.

... Recent events in Africa -as well as elsewhere -cruelly catch us up on these challenges. Without much ado, it is imperative to emphasise the variety of these problems: discrimination, violation of human rights, vulnerable conditions of women and children, stigma, etc. (O'Neill and Spohn, 1998). These problems accompany the dynamics of identity shifts and create new relational frameworks. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Today human mobility in Africa poses serious challenges to the Catholic Church, whose doors are often those knocked daily by migrants and refugees, seeking material and spiritual answers to their plight. The Church is called to promote a different perspective, where asylum, displacement and migration become a component of dialogue among cultures and societies, and where people on the move are viewed as fellow human beings. Moreover, the Church is expected to question a model of development, which ignores inequalities and disparities that result in displacing people from their home, environment and heritage. Finally, the Church is demanded to build a Christian community capable of appreciating differences while celebrating the unity of the faith.
... 20 Τhe moral demands and practical actions that arise from the enduring biblical imperative is to love the neighbour, and to look after the alien ( Lev. 19:34). 21 The story of uprooted people continues throughout the Hebrew Bible as people of Israel occupy the Promised Land and are eventually sent into Exile and later return. In the time of Babylonian Captivity everyone was on the move and most went into Exile at some time. ...
... He would bring foundational philosophical concerns of a social nature to the notes, among those, human rights; 98 and besides his writings on war, 99 he frequently bridged social ethics and human rights together in addressing the US bishops' pastoral letters, "The Challenge of Peace" and "Economic Justice for All," as well as their "Statement on Capital Punishment." 100 This engagement of Catholic social ethics with human rights gets fortified in subsequent years. 101 Bringing these insights to immigration, Spohn and William O'Neill write first on the topic; 102 Kristin Heyer brings social sin into her lens on immigration and human rights, 103 then looks at displacement using transnational human rights and the scriptural virtue of hospitality, 104 and, finally, in the era of Trump, looks at human rights, structures of social justice and the virtue of civic friendship. 105 In a formidable article that captures how contemporary virtue ethics constantly proposes itself for the social collective, Cathleen Kaveny imaginatively engages both virtue theory and human rights. ...
Article
This article surveys all the contributions in ethics on these pages over the past eighty years and is divided into four historical parts: the first three years; the years from 1943 to 1964; the years Richard McCormick wrote from 1964 to 1984; and the years beyond McCormick. It surveys a period from neo-Scholastic manualism at the eve of World War II to the contemporary era, where methods for attaining moral objectivity are complex. This survey notes shifts in theological method, the movement of the center from the personal to the social, the transition from an exclusively clerical authorship to a much broader array of authors, and a shift in readership from priest confessors to professional theologians.
... Some researchers have delineated the distinction between refugees and immigrants. The difference is that immigrants usually leave their country by will, whereas refugees typically suffer persecution (O'Neil & Spohn, 1998). According to Levine (2001), statistics regarding the exact number of individuals who are illegal, 6 refugee, or asylum seekers are difficult to ascertain. ...
... Resettlement NGOs can observe religious holidays, use religious doctrine and language to guide the mission of their activities, and connect with other religious organizations, specifically houses of worship that may be able to provide material and human resources. In addition, there is a rich tradition of immigrant advocacy in various religious traditions (Christiansen, 1996;Gold, 1997;Kurtz & Fulton, 2002;O'Neill & Spohn, 1998), and faith-based NGOs might collaborate with other religious organizations in their advocacy efforts. Therefore, the place of religion in refugee resettlement goes beyond NGOs with a religious affiliation. ...
Article
Full-text available
This article addresses the role faith-based nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) play in refugee resettlement and how they are both different from and similar to secular resettlement NGOs. The author examines how faith-based and secular NGOs assist in the process of refugee resettlement in the United States. Data indicate that most faith-based resettlement NGOs are similar to secular NGOs in their practice but express their religiosity in their organizational rhetoric and networks. As a practice, religion is frequently tied to culture and, therefore, ethnic organizations engage in religious practice as a way of practicing that ethnicity’s culture.
... Resettlement NGOs can observe religious holidays, use religious doctrine and language to guide the mission of their activities, and connect with other religious organizations, specifically houses of worship that may be able to provide material and human resources. Additionally, there is a rich tradition of immigrant advocacy in various religious traditions (Christiansen 1996;Gold 1997;Kurtz and Fulton 2002;O'Neill and Spohn 1998), and faith-based NGOs might collaborate with other religious organizations in their advocacy efforts. Therefore, the place of religion in refugee resettlement goes beyond NGOs with a religious affiliation. ...
... As Jesus interprets the law from the depth and breadth of his religious tradition-a tradition that he evidently saw as integral to public life and not simply private devotion-'the world with its sure arrangement of insiders and outsiders' is subverted by God's reign. 5 In the domain of God that Jewish and Christian believers are challenged to enact in history by their choices and actions, all are neighbour, all have dignity, all are welcomed as one's own. Now that we have considered aspects of the law, the Samaritan and the neighbour in this parable, we are brought back to the question posed by the scholar of the law, a question restated by one commentator as 'Whom are we Judeans obligated to treat as neighbors and whom not?' 6 However, in view of the law in Leviticus and of his intentions for his disciples, this test question is a non-question to Jesus. ...
Article
In the present climate of debate surrounding United States immigration, both legal and illegal, the call to be neighbour and to exercise hospitality that echoes throughout the biblical tradition provides valid and unequivocal dimensions of a Christian spirituality within the horizon of the immigration discussion. This article traces the development of such a spirituality beginning with the Jewish scriptures, the ministry of Jesus in the gospels and Catholic social teaching. It concludes with a spirituality rooted in the American memory that offers promise and hope and proclaims the best of the American spirit.
... Many of those engaged in the discussion over the impact of immigration on natural environments agree that large populations have a damaging effect on natural systems and for well-documented reasons—generalized increased consumption with all that that entails, [I = PAT] for example (Neumayer, 2006-this issue; Muradian, 2006-this issue; Daly, 2004; Kates, 2004; Chapman, 1999b; O'Neil and Spoon, 1998; Sferios, 1998; Wackernagel and Rees, 1996). Further, there is general agreement that one of the motive forces driving worldwide displacement of people – estimated at over 23 million per year 1 – is globalization; whether in principle or in practice globalization is identified with increased pauperization of natural environments, increased inequality in the distribution of wealth and necessary resources, increased contamination of air, water and soil; overall, it is widely acknowledge that substitution factors and neo-liberal market mechanisms (as presently implemented) cannot overcome ecological limits (Karam, 2005; Kates, 2004; Chapman, 2000; Daly, 2000; Pimentel et al., 1998). ...
Article
Full-text available
The current discussion over the ethical propriety of using environmental degradation arguments to restrict immigration is at an impasse. One group argues from a neo-liberal globalization perspective and rejects such arguments, while the other take a more internationalist approach accepting restrictions. I argue that the neo-liberal position is seriously flawed since it leads to the elimination of 'places'–a morally important category–and that from an internationalist view immigration restriction based on environmental degradation is ethically justifiable.
Article
This paper examines whether—and if so, to what extent—religious scripture and values can promote inclusionary attitudes towards refugees. Sacred texts across faiths call on believers to embrace foreigners, suggesting that religious discourses can be harnessed to promote refugees’ inclusion in host societies. To test this possibility, I implement a survey experiment in which citizens of Lebanon—a religiously diverse country that has received the most Syrian refugees per capita globally—are exposed to various forms of pro-refugee religious messaging. I find that inclusionary religious messaging can shift refugee-related attitudes towards tolerance, particularly for members of sectarian communities with the highest baseline anti-refugee animosity. The study's findings have important implications for understanding religion’s consequences for both the dynamics of refugee integration and intercommunal relations more generally, especially in the Middle East and North Africa and the broader developing world.
Chapter
In this chapter, Yuen offers an in-depth examination of the characteristics of the Catholic human rights theory. In spite of the problems of the rights language, Yuen argues that it is still a useful one for evaluating a society’s social practices in protecting its people, including migrants and other underprivileged, from discrimination and inhuman treatment. She also tries to answer some of the puzzles raised by various scholars. Based on the social encyclicals, Yuen explores thoroughly the distinctive features of the Catholic rights discourse that are different from the Western liberal tradition, such as a social self with a communitarian nature, a correlation of rights and duties, and the emphasis on solidarity and the common good. At the end of the chapter, she assesses the strengths and limitations of the rights language regarding building solidarity with the migrants.
Chapter
Full-text available
Introdução A descoberta da América representou um imenso desafio aos países europeus. Sem entrar no mérito de temas polêmicos ligados à " colonização " , " violência cultural " ou outros que fogem à nossa finalidade, pode-se afirmar que ao mesmo tempo em que Portugal lidava com imensos desafios no Brasil também precisava enfrentar históricos inimigos europeus, enquanto não cessava sua tentativa de marcar presença em territórios da África e da Ásia, bem como de manter atividades comerciais junto a novos mercados. Não se pode esquecer que uma de suas " colônias " , justamente nosso país, em função das guerras napoleônicas, veio a sediar a própria Corte, ou seja, momentaneamente " o Sol gravitou em volta da Terra " , poder-se-ia dizer com uma pobre comparação tirada das ciências físicas. Dessa presença da Corte Portuguesa em nossas terras vieram inúmeros progressos dignos de nota: a criação do Banco do Brasil (ainda anterior ao próprio similar português); o Jardim Botânico; a Biblioteca Nacional, dentre outros. Inclusive, pode-se apontar que amadureceu o sentimento de Independência, não por acaso ocorrido pouco tempo após o retorno da Corte a Portugal. A ocupação de nosso território foi difícil em função da pequena disponibilidade de portugueses. Dessa forma, houve uma grande flexibilidade na aceitação e na miscigenação com o elemento indígena, além do triste fenômeno da escravidão – se não mais presente que em outros países da
Article
Full-text available
When governments create refugee policies they consider several factors (security, economics, ethics, etc.). There are reasons why admitting refugees could have negative consequences (for example, security risks). On the other hand, if the recipient societies have ideals that stress the importance of helping other people, they should act according to their values. The aim of this article is to examine the concept of human dignity and show that European states should admit and help refugees because it is in accordance with their ethical values and the international agreements they have signed. This is important because when European countries hesitate to help refugees, they act not only contrary to their humane tradition, but they can harm them. The western concept of human dignity is one of the main values that stresses that each person is important—that they are equal and free.
Chapter
Contemporary global migration, particularly as seen in the experience of unskilled workers and women, is clearly plagued with serious problems. When one factors in the plight of irregular migrants as well as that of refugees, the picture looks even bleaker. For example, the plight of African migrants trying to cross into Europe without proper documentation is tragic. This is especially true for those coming into Europe via Spain, where Red Cross estimates put the number of deaths between 2,000 and 3,000 every year.1 There are also horrific stories about people trying to escape the recent political turmoil in the Middle East and North Africa. At the height of the conflict in Libya, for example, a ship carrying 600 migrants fleeing the violence sank after the unseaworthy vessel, which smugglers crammed with people way beyond capacity, broke apart.2 The tragedy of it all is that it was discovered that the ship sank when numerous bodies of migrants were seen floating on the sea.
Article
This essay argues that Catholic (magisterial) social teaching's division of ethics into public and private creates a structural lacuna which makes it almost impossible to envision a truly just situation for migrant domestic careworkers (MDCs) within the current horizon of Catholic social thought. Drawing on a variety of sociological studies, I conclude that it is easy for MDCs to "disappear" between two countries, two families, and, finally, two sets of ethical norms. If the magisterium genuinely wishes Catholic ethicists to address the plight of these migrant women, normative Catholic social teaching must pay more attention to household sociological realities and more fully absorb the feminist critique of the sharp line between the public and the private, between care and paid work.
Article
The recently released "On the Corner: Day Labor in the United States," the first systematic, scientific study of the US day-labor sector, exposes the pervasive abuse of day laborers within its borders. In a time when immigration reform debates are frequently clouded by rhetoric of fear and bias, this article aims to shed light on the precarious vulnerability of this understudied group and a Christian moral response to their plight. It offers a normative analysis of the treatment of day laborers in light of Catholic social teachings on human rights, work, and solidarity. It next uses the category of social sin to evaluate broader social forces at play sustaining the day-labor market: economic realities in Mexico and Central America; the US market's reliance on low-wage labor; and the role of fear and racism as immigration legislation incorporates increasingly punitive measures. The essay concludes with a brief constructive proposal concerning worker protections and just immigration reform in light ...
Article
The U.S. and Mexican bishops, in their influential pastoral letter Strangers No Longer, frame immigration ethics through the lens of solidarity with the immigrant. This frame leads them to erroneously interpret the preferential option for the poor and ignore potential harm to poor U.S. citizens caused by recent undocumented immigration from Mexico and other countries. A better framework to immigration ethics is a specified common good approach, which is created in this dissertation. This approach uses the definition of the common good found in Catholic social thought and concretizes it through using a theological anthropology based in Martha Nussbaum's human functioning capabilities approach and through developing a Common Good Index (CGI). This CGI is a set of twelve sociological indicator, which measures the common good through measuring to what extent basic levels of human capabilities are ensured for all people in society. Using the specified common good approach, the ethical focus becomes more balanced and true to original Catholic intent, attending to the needs of poor U.S. citizens as well as poor immigrants. The bishops' policy recommendations are affirmed through the specified common good approach, but additional policies are advocated - ones that aim to promote the capabilities of poor U.S. citizens that are threatened by immigration.
Article
This article analyzes today's global values crisis as a matter of both personal and institutional failure. Social disintegration constitutes humanity's greatest challenge at the turn of the millennium. A viable future requires a new social project which embodies a new ethos —one which includes both traditional and liberal values and which avoids their vices along with the traps of authoritarian socialism. In order to spell out this new social project, the article describes the essential features of the traditional ethos and the liberal ethos: their economies, the understanding of nature, religion, history, politics, and ethics. This article argues that the needed participatory radical ethos incarnates Christian values for our time.