ArticlePDF Available

Community based adaptation to climate change: Strengthening Resilience through Development

Authors:

Abstract

A newly forming approach to adaptation addresses a community's development needs as a way to increase the resilience of poor, vulnerable people to the impacts of climate change. Early examples of such community-based adaptation in Bangladesh highlight the successes and limitations of this approach.
3TRENGTHENING2ESILIENCE
THROUGH$EVELOPMENT
#/--5.)49"!3%$
!$!04!4)/.4/
#,)-!4%#(!.'%
"9*%33)#!!9%23!.$4)-&/2394(
#/524%39*%33)#!!9%23
)ÌiÀ>Ì>ÊivvÀÌÃÊÌÊÀi`ÕViÊ>`ÊÃiµÕiÃÌiÀÊV>ÀLÊ
`Ý`iÊ >`Ê ÌiÀÊ }ÀiiÕÃiÊ }>ÃiÃÊ >ÀiÊ ÌÊ ÞiÌÊ
ÃÜ}Ê ÌiÊ À>ÌiÊ vÊ }L>Ê Ü>À}°Ê `ii`]Ê ÌiÊ
ÕÀÌÊÃÃiÃÃiÌÊ,i«ÀÌÊvÊÌiÊÌiÀ}ÛiÀiÌ>Ê*>iÊ
Ê>ÌiÊ>}iÊ*®Ê>ÌV«>ÌiÃÊÀ>«`ÊV>}iÃÊÊ
V>ÌiÊiÛiÊvÊ}ÀiiÕÃiÊ}>ÃÊiÃÃÃÊ>ÀiÊ Ài`ÕVi`Ê
µÕVÞ]£Ê >`Ê ÀiViÌÊ v`}ÃÊ ÃÕ}}iÃÌÊ Ì>ÌÊ ÌiÃiÊ «À
iVÌÃÊ >ÀiÊ Õ`iÀiÃÌ>Ìi`°ÓÊ /iÊ «>VÌÃÊ vÊ V>ÌiÊ
V>}iÊÜÊLiÊÃiÛiÀi]Ê«>ÀÌVÕ>ÀÞÊvÀÊÌiÊÃÌÊÛÕiÀ
>LiÊ`iÛi«}ÊVÕÌÀiÃÊÌ>ÌÊ >ÛiÊÌiÊi>ÃÌÊ V>«>VÌÞÊ
ÌÊV«i°ÊÃÊ>ÊÀiÃÕÌ]ÊÌiÊii`ÊÌÊÃÕ««ÀÌÊ>`>«Ì>ÌÊÊ
`iÛi«}ÊVÕÌÀiÃÊÃÊ}ÀÜ}ÊÊÕÀ}iVÞ°
 %.6)2/.-%.4 777%.6)2/.-%.4-!'!:).%/2' 6/,5-%.5-"%2
!DAPTATION DESCRIBES ADJUSTMENTS IN
NATURAL OR HUMAN SYSTEMS IN RESPONSE
TO THE IMPACTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE 5NTIL
RECENTLY ADAPTATION WAS A CONTROVERSIAL
TOPIC IN CLIMATE CHANGE POLICY DEBATES
WITH MANY ARGUING THAT TOO MUCH ATTEN
TION TO ADAPTATIONCONSIDERED LOCALLY
FOCUSEDINEXPENSIVEANDBENEFICIALONLY
IN THE SHORT TERMCOULD DETRACT FROM
MOREEXPENSIVEMITIGATIONEFFORTSFORTHE
GLOBAL GOOD )NHIS  BOOK %ARTH IN
THE "ALANCE !L 'ORE SAYS h"ELIEVING
THATWECANADAPTTOJUSTABOUTANYTHINGIS
ULTIMATELYAKINDOF LAZINESSANARROGANT
FAITHINOURABILITYTOREACTINTIMEv
(OWEVER THE TIDE IS TURNING 'IVEN
SLOW PROGRESS ON MITIGATION COUPLED
WITH EVIDENCEOF GREATER AND MORE RAPID
IMPACTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE THAN THOSE
PREVIOUSLYEXPECTEDBYTHE)0##ADAPTA
TION IS FIRMLYON THE INTERNATIONAL POLICY
AGENDAASACRUCIALSUPPLEMENTTOMITIGA
TION 3IGNALING THIS CHANGE 'ORE STATED
INARECENTINTERVIEWWITH4HE%CONOMIST
h) USED TO THINK ADAPTATION SUBTRACTED
FROM OUR EFFORTS ON PREVENTION "UT )VE
CHANGEDMYMIND0OORCOUNTRIESARE
VULNERABLEANDNEEDOURHELPv
/NE GROWING PROPOSAL CALLS FOR A
COMMUNITYBASED APPROACH TO ADAPTATION
#OMMUNITYBASED ADAPTATION OPERATES AT
THELOCALLEVELINCOMMUNITIESTHATAREVUL
NERABLE TO THE IMPACTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
)T IDENTIFIES ASSISTS AND IMPLEMENTS
COMMUNITYBASED DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITIES
THATSTRENGTHENTHECAPACITYOFLOCALPEOPLE
TOADAPTTOLIVINGINARISKIERANDLESSPRE
DICTABLE CLIMATE -OREOVER COMMUNITY
BASED ADAPTATION GENERATES ADAPTATION
STRATEGIES THROUGH PARTICIPATORY PROCESSES
INVOLVING LOCAL STAKEHOLDERS AND DEVELOP
MENTANDDISASTER RISKnREDUCTION PRACTITIO
NERS )T BUILDS ON EXISTING CULTURAL NORMS
ANDADDRESSESLOCALDEVELOPMENTCONCERNS
THATMAKEPEOPLEVULNERABLETOTHEIMPACTS
OFCLIMATE CHANGEINTHEFIRST PLACE4HREE
INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCES ON COMMUNITY
BASED ADAPTATION HAVE BEEN ORGANIZED BY
INTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSANDTHINKTANKS
SINCEWITHPOLICYMAKERSRESEARCHERS
ANDDEVELOPMENT ORGANIZATIONS AMONGTHE
ATTENDEES #OMMUNITYBASED ADAPTATION
PROJECTS ARE NOW IN OPERATION IN VULNER
ABLECOMMUNITIESINDEVELOPINGANDSOME
DEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES
9ETFUNDAMENTALCHALLENGESANDUNCER
TAINTIESREMAINABOUTTHEINTERPRETATIONOF
ADAPTATION POLICY WHICH IN TURN AFFECTS
THE IMPLEMENTATION OF COMMUNITYBASED
ADAPTATION7HATIS ADAPTATIONTO CLIMATE
CHANGE VERSUS MORE GENERAL CLIMATIC
VARIABILITY 7HO OR WHAT ADAPTSAND
HOW(OW DOES COMMUNITYBASEDADAP
TATIONFITWITHLARGERSCALEADAPTATIONPOLI
CIES AND PROGRAMS %ARLY DEBATES ABOUT
COMMUNITYBASEDADAPTATIONANDADAPTA
TION IN GENERALARE GRAPPLING WITH THESE
QUESTIONS)NADDITIONEXAMPLESINVULNER
ABLECOMMUNITIESIN"ANGLADESHHELPILLU
MINATE THE ROLE AND VALUE OFCOMMUNITY
BASED ADAPTATION ITS LIMITATIONS AND ITS
POTENTIALTOHELPINTEGRATECONCERNSABOUT
-ENIN!MTOLAALOWLYINGVILLAGEINTHE-ONGLASUBDISTRICTOFSOUTHERN"ANGLADESHPREPAREFORFLOODSBYRAISINGTHELEVELOFAWALKWAY
THROUGHTHEVILLAGEWITHMUD4HISANDOTHERDEVELOPMENTACTIVITIESCANHELPINCREASEACOMMUNITYSRESILIENCETOCLIMATECHANGE
#/524%394)-&/2394(
*5,9!5'534 777%.6)2/.-%.4-!'!:).%/2' %.6)2/.-%.4 
VULNERABILITYANDDEVELOPMENTINTOWIDER
CLIMATECHANGEPOLICY
!PPROACHESTO!DAPTATION
!DAPTATIONWASNOTAMAJORPARTOFTHE
DEBATE WHEN CLIMATE CHANGE CAME ONTO
THE INTERNATIONAL POLICY AGENDA AT THE
5. 'ENERAL !SSEMBLY IN  )NITIAL
APPROACHES TO MANAGING CLIMATE CHANGE
GENERALLY FOCUSED ON MITIGATION THROUGH
REDUCINGGREENHOUSEGASEMISSIONSATTHE
SOURCEORINCREASINGCARBONSEQUESTRATION
THROUGHREFORESTATION AND BETTER LAND USE
MANAGEMENT4HE5NITED.ATIONS&RAME
WORK #ONVENTION ON #LIMATE #HANGE
5.&###INMENTIONEDADAPTATION
ONLYFIVETIMESNEVERDEFININGIT
3INCE THEN ADAPTATION HAS GAINED
STANDING WITHIN THEINTERNATIONAL CLIMATE
CHANGE ARENA 4HE 4HIRD !SSESSMENT
2EPORTOF THE )0## IN  SHOWEDTHAT
CLIMATE CHANGEIMPACTS ARE ALREADY HAP
PENINGBECAUSEFORTHEFIRSTTIMETHE)0##
USED OBSERVATIONS OVER THE PREVIOUS 
YEARS RATHERTHAN WORKING SOLELY ON PRE
DICTIONS3IXYEARSLATERATTHETH#ON
FERENCE OF THE 0ARTIES OF THE 5.&###
ADAPTATIONFORMEDONEOFFOURSTEPSOFTHE
SOCALLED"ALI2OADMAPWHICHPAVESTHE
WAYFORAPOST+YOTOPOLICYFRAMEWORKTO
INCLUDE ADAPTATION ALONGSIDE MITIGATION
TECHNOLOGYCOOPERATIONANDFINANCE
%MERGINGFROMTHISPOLICYCONTEXTTHE
MOST COMMON APPROACH TO ADAPTATION
CONSIDERSHOWFARPROCESSESOFADAPTATION
CANREDUCE DANGEROUSIMPACTSOF CLIMATE
CHANGE AND THEREFORE DEFINES THE HIGH
EST ACCEPTABLE THRESHOLDS OF GREENHOUSE
GAS CONCENTRATIONS 4HIS APPROACH ALSO
SUPPORTS ADAPTATIONPRACTICES THAT AIM TO
LESSEN THE IMPACTS OF INCREASED ATMOS
PHERICGREENHOUSEGASCONCENTRATIONSFOR
EXAMPLE THROUGH ENGINEERING AND TECH
NOLOGICAL MEASURES INCLUDING NEW SEED
VARIETIES WATER MANAGEMENT AND EARLY
WARNINGSYSTEMS BASEDONPROJECTIONSOF
FUTURE CLIMATECONDITIONS AND AN EXPECT
ED SEVERITY IN EVENTS SUCH AS STORMS
DROUGHTSORTIDALSURGES
!CADEMIC OBSERVERS HAVE DESCRIBED
THISAPPROACHASTHEhPOLLUTIONISTvVIEW
BECAUSE IT FOCUSES ON INFORMING CLIMATE
CHANGEPOLICIESTHATAREDRIVENBYCONTROL
LINGOVERALLLEVELSOFGREENHOUSEGASCON
CENTRATIONSINTHEATMOSPHEREBUTANUM
BEROFCRITICSHAVEQUESTIONEDWHETHERTHIS
APPROACH IS ALWAYS APPROPRIATE &IRST
SOME OBSERVERS HAVE POINTED OUT THAT
FOCUSINGONUNCERTAINCLIMATEIMPACTSHAS
SLOWEDDOWNADAPTATIONPRACTICESBECAUSE
POTENTIAL VICTIMS OF CLIMATE CHANGE AND
AIDDONORSAREOFTENRELUCTANTTO COMMIT
TO ADAPTATION IF THEY DO NOT YET KNOW
EXACTLYWHATTHEYAREADAPTINGTO
3ECOND LARGESCALE ENGINEERING OR
TECHNOLOGICAL INVESTMENTS MAY NOT BE
THE MOST COSTEFFECTIVE WAY TO REDUCE
VULNERABILITYTOCLIMATECHANGE!LONG
STANDING LITERATURE WITHIN DEVELOPMENT
STUDIES HAS ARGUED THAT RISKS POSED BY
DISASTERS AND NATURAL HAZARDS ARE OFTEN
LINKED MORE TO SOCIAL ECONOMIC AND
EVENPOLITICALFACTORSINDIFFERENTCONTEXTS
RATHER THAN SIMPLY THE SIZE OF PHYSICAL
EVENTS SUCH AS STORMS AND FLOODS )N
THISSENSE SOCIAL VULNERABILITYTO CLIMATE
CHANGE IS INSEPARABLEFROM THE DEVELOP
MENT CONTEXT !CCORDINGLY MEASURES
BASEDONTECHNOLOGYCANONLYBEPARTIALLY
EFFECTIVEIFTHEYDONOTALSO ADDRESSNON
CLIMATIC FACTORS THAT ARE THE UNDERLYING
DRIVERSOF VULNERABILITYWHICH MAY VARY
BETWEEN LOCAL CONDITIONS &OR EXAMPLE
THE IMPLEMENTATION AND EFFECTIVENESS OF
NEW DROUGHTRESISTANT CROP VARIETIES IS
LIMITEDBY THEIR ACCEPTANCE IN A COMMU
NITY WHICH IN TURN DEPENDSONCOSTSAND
AVAILABILITY OF THE SEEDS ACCESS TOFERTIL
IZERANDOTHERINPUTSSTORAGECONSTRAINTS
EASE OF PREPARATION AND EVEN CULTURAL
PREFERENCESFORFLAVOR
!S A RESULT OF THESE CONCERNS A NEWLY
FORMING MORE DEVELOPMENTORIENTED PER
SPECTIVE TO ADAPTATION CONSIDERS DEVEL
OPMENT AND ADAPTATION RISKS AS STRONGLY
COMPLEMENTARY 5NDER THIS APPROACH
ADAPTATION IS NOT ONLY FOCUSED ON ANTICI
PATING ENHANCED PHYSICAL RISKS ASSOCIATED
WITHINCREASED GREENHOUSE GAS CONCENTRA
TIONS 2ATHER IT ALSO ADDRESSES DEVELOP
MENTAL NEEDS SUCH AS IMPROVING ACCESS
TO LIVELIHOODS AND PRODUCTIVE ASSETS TO
INCREASE THE ADAPTIVE CAPACITY OF POORER
MORE VULNERABLE PEOPLE 3OME OBSERVERS
HAVESAIDANYADAPTATIONINTERVENTIONCAN
NOTSTANDALONEBUTMUSTGOHANDINHAND
WITH DEVELOPMENT EITHER THROUGH MAIN
STREAMING ADAPTATION INTO DEVELOPMENT
ADAPTATION PLUS DEVELOPMENT OR EVEN
BY BEING SYNONYMOUS WITH DEVELOPMENT
ADAPTATION AS DEVELOPMENT!DAPTATION
ASDEVELOPMENTINEFFECTIMPLIESTHATOVER
ALLDEVELOPMENTISANEFFECTIVECONTRIBUTION
TOWITHSTANDINGFUTURECLIMATECHANGE4HIS
FORM OF DEVELOPMENT WOULD INCLUDE ACTS
SUCHASACHIEVINGTHE-ILLENNIUM$EVELOP
MENT 'OALS OF REDUCING POVERTY ENHANC
INGEDUCATIONANDHEALTHIMPROVINGLIVING
7ATERLOGGINGISONEOFMANYCLIMATECHANGEIMPACTSTHREATENINGLIVELIHOODSIN"ANGLADESH
ANDOTHERVULNERABLECOASTALNATIONS
#/524%39*%33)#!!9%23
 %.6)2/.-%.4 777%.6)2/.-%.4-!'!:).%/2' 6/,5-%.5-"%2
CONDITIONS AND PROVIDINGACCESS TO FINAN
CIAL MARKETS AND TECHNOLOGIES FOR POORER
COUNTRIES COMMUNITIES WITHIN COUNTRIES
ANDEVENINDIVIDUALS
#OMMUNITYBASED ADAPTATION TAKES THE
APPROACH OF ADAPTATION AS DEVELOPMENT
2ESPONDINGTOTHECONCEPTTHATADAPTATION
IS LOCAL AND PLACEBASED IT ADDRESSES THE
LOCALLY AND CONTEXTUALLY SPECIFIED NATURE
OF CLIMATE CHANGE VULNERABILITY BECAUSE
ITTAKESPLACEAT LOCALLEVELS WHEREPEOPLE
ENCOUNTERIMPACTSBUILDADAPTIVECAPACITY
ANDRESPOND!COMMUNITYBASEDAPPROACH
CONSIDERS THAT ADAPTATION STRATEGIES MUST
BE GENERATED THROUGH PARTICIPATORY PRO
CESSES INVOLVING LOCAL STAKEHOLDERS AND
DEVELOPMENT AND DISASTER RISKnREDUCTION
PRACTITIONERS RATHER THAN BEING RESTRICTED
TOIMPACTSBASEDSCIENTIFICINPUTSALONE!S
SUCH EXPERTISE IN VULNERABILITY REDUCTION
MUST COME FROM LOCAL COMMUNITYBASED
CASESTUDIESANDINDIGENOUSKNOWLEDGEOF
LOCALLY APPROPRIATE SOLUTIONS TO CLIMATIC
VARIABILITYANDEXTREMES
#OMMUNITY"ASED
!DAPTATIONIN"ANGLADESH
"ANGLADESHISFREQUENTLYCITEDASONEOF
THE MOST VULNERABLE COUNTRIES TO CLIMATE
CHANGEBECAUSEOFITSFLATANDLOWLYING
TOPOGRAPHY AND LOCATION ON THE COAST AT
THETOPOFTHE"AYOF"ENGALWHICHMAKE
ITVULNERABLETOCYCLONESANDTIDALSURGES
-OREOVER"ANGLADESHALSOSUFFERSFROMA
HISTORY OF IMPOVERISHMENT HIGH POPULA
TION DENSITY WEAK POLITICAL GOVERNANCE
AND A RELIANCE OF MANY LIVELIHOODS ON
CLIMATESENSITIVESECTORSPARTICULARLYAGRI
CULTUREANDFISHERIES-ANYOFTHEANTICI
PATED ADVERSE EFFECTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
SUCHASSEALEVELRISEHIGHERTEMPERATURES
ENHANCED PRECIPITATION FROM MONSOONS
ANDANINCREASEIN CYCLONEINTENSITYWILL
AGGRAVATETHEEXISTINGSTRESSESTHATALREADY
IMPEDEDEVELOPMENTIN"ANGLADESH
4HE INTERNATIONAL COMMUNITY HAS REC
OGNIZED"ANGLADESHASAPARTICULARLYVUL
NERABLE COUNTRY FOR SOME TIME AND THE
COUNTRY HAS RECEIVED DISASTER MANAGE
MENT AND ADAPTATION SUPPORT IN SEVERAL
SECTORS "ANGLADESHHAS DEVELOPED SOME
CAPACITY FOR DEALINGWITH THE IMPACTS OF
CLIMATE CHANGE AT THE NATIONAL LEVEL AND
HAS MOBILIZED POLICY RESPONSE OPTIONS
THAT DEAL WITH VULNERABILITY REDUCTION TO
ENVIRONMENTAL VARIABILITY IN GENERALAND
MORE RECENTLY TO CLIMATE CHANGE IN PAR
TICULAR&OREXAMPLE"ANGLADESHWASONE
OFTHEFIRSTCOUNTRIESTOSUBMITITS.ATIONAL
!DAPTATION0ROGRAMMEOF!CTION.!0!
TO THE 5.&### AND MORE RECENTLY HAS
DEVELOPEDANATIONALCLIMATECHANGESTRAT
EGY TO DEAL WITH MITIGATION AND ADAPTA
TION!TTHESAMETIMECOMMUNITYBASED
ADAPTATION RESPONSES ARE EMERGING BOTH
AUTONOMOUSLY AND SUPPORTED BY .'/S
ANDLOCALPARTNERS
/NE EXAMPLE CAN BE DRAWN FROM THE
'AIBANDHA DISTRICT IN NORTHERN "ANGLA
DESH WHICH IS COVERED BY WATER DURING
THE MONSOON SEASON MAKING IT IMPOS
SIBLETOGROWCROPSUSINGTRADITIONALMETH
ODS4HE)0##&OURTH!SSESSMENT2EPORT
NOTES THAT CLIMATE CHANGE WILL BRING
GREATER PRECIPITATION EXTREMES INCLUDING
MORE INTENSE MONSOONAL RAINFALL WHICH
WILL EXACERBATEFLOODING IN 'AIBANDHA
4HE INTERNATIONAL .'/ 0RACTICAL !CTION
IS WORKING WITH LOCAL COMMUNITIES IN
THISDISTRICT TO DEVELOPWAYSTHATFARMERS
CAN GROW FOOD ON FLOODED LAND USING
A PROCESS OF COMMUNITYLED IDENTIFICA
TIONANDPRIORITIZATIONOF NATURALRESOURCE
MANAGEMENT OPTIONS AND TECHNOLOGIES
$ETAILED CONSULTATION MEETINGS IN ADDI
TION TO ASSESSMENTS OF THE NEEDS SKILLS
ASSETS AND CAPACITIES OF THE COMMUNITY
THROUGH HOUSEHOLD SURVEYS LED TO PAR
TICIPATORY ACTION PLANS OF DEVELOPMENT
WHICHIDENTIFIEDANUMBEROF OPTIONS FOR
TAILORINGEXISTINGANDNEWTECHNOLOGIESTO
MEETTHENEEDSOFTHECOMMUNITY
&OREXAMPLETHEINNOVATIVETECHNOLOGY
OFFLOATINGGARDENSORHYDROPONICSWHICH
VILLAGERS HAVE TAKEN UP IN MANY OTHER
WATERLOGGEDANDFLOODEDAREASOF"ANGLA
DESHHASBEENINTRODUCEDTO'AIBANDHA
! FLOATING GARDEN IS BUILT FROM A RAFT OF
WATER HYACINTH TYPICALLY ABOUT  METERS
LONG AND  METER WIDE 4HE RAFT IS COV
ERED WITH SOIL COMPOST AND MANURE IN
WHICH VEGETABLE SEEDS ARE PLANTED 4HE
RAFTWILLLASTJUSTONEYEARBUTCANBEUSED
AS FERTILIZER DURING THE DRY SEASON 4O
ENSURESUSTAINABILITYOFTHEPROGRAMTRAIN
INGANDINPUT SUPPORTWASTAILOREDTO THE
PARTICULAR PROFILE OFHOUSEHOLD MEMBERS
ANDTECHNOLOGIESWEREACCOMPANIEDBYA
WIDESPREADCLIMATECHANGEAWARENESSPRO
GRAM4HEWORKIN'AIBANDHAWASPARTLY
INSPIREDBY BAD FLOODING IN WHICH
PROMPTEDORGANIZATIONSSUCH AS 0RACTICAL
!CTIONTOLOOKINTOLONGTERMMETHODSOF
REDUCING VULNERABILITY TO INUNDATION AS
WELLSHORTTERMDISASTERRELIEF
6ILLAGERSIN'AIBANDHAUSEFLOATINGGAR
DENS TO GROW VEGETABLES SUCH AS BITTER
GOURDSGREENOKRAANDLEAFYGREENSWHICH
4OPROTECTAGAINSTENCROACHINGSALTWATERVILLAGERSIN!MTOLABUILDHOUSESONRAISEDPLATFORMS
ANDCOLLECTFRESHWATERRESERVOIRSINCLAYPOTSCALLEDMOKTI
#/524%394)-&/2394(
*5,9!5'534 777%.6)2/.-%.4-!'!:).%/2' %.6)2/.-%.4 
PROVIDESUBSISTENCEFORPEOPLEEVENDURING
THE ANNUAL MONGA PERIOD OF FOOD SHORT
AGE)NDEEDINSOMECASESTHESEVEGETA
BLESALSO PROVIDE AN ALTERNATIVESOURCE OF
INCOMEWHENSURPLUSISSOLDINTHEMARKET
"ECAUSETHERAFTSCANBEMOVEDFROMPLACE
TO PLACE THEY ARE ALSO SUITABLE FOR THOSE
WHOHAVETEMPORARILYORPERMANENTLYLOST
THEIRHOMES AND LAND DURING INCREASINGLY
SEVEREFLOODINGCONDITIONS
-EASURING THE SUCCESSOF COMMUNITY
BASED ADAPTATION PROJECTS IS INHERENTLY
PROBLEMATICMAINLY BECAUSE THE IMPACTS
ARE IN THE FORM OF OUTCOMES THAT HAVE
NOTHAPPENEDINTHISCASETHECROPSNOT
LOST DUE TO INUNDATIONAND THE ECONOMIC
IMPACTSTHATDIDNOTRESULT)TISTOOEARLY
TOTELLWHETHERTHEPROJECTHASRESULTEDIN
LONGTERM RESILIENCE BUILDING GIVEN THAT
THEPROJECTISONLYFOURYEARSOLDANDTHE
PROJECTIMPLEMENTERSSUGGESTTHATTHEREAL
TESTFORTHEPROJECTWILLDEPENDONWHETHER
ITCANBESCALEDUP
)NTHECOASTALAREASOFSOUTHERN"ANGLA
DESHONEFURTHERTHREATOFCLIMATECHANGE
IS INCREASING SALINITYTHE ENCROACHMENT
OFSALTWATERONTOANDBENEATHAGRICULTURAL
LAND3ALTWATERMAKESITDIFFICULT TOGROW
CROPSHISTORICALLYIRRIGATEDBYFRESHWATER
AND IT CAN ACCELERATETHE DETERIORATION OF
BUILDINGS )N -ONGLA SUBDISTRICT NEAR
THE MANGROVEFORESTS OF THE 3UNDERBANS
VILLAGERS ARE RESPONDING TO THE THREATS
OF SALINITY BY BUILDING HOUSES ON RAISED
PLATFORMSANDINSTALLINGSEALEDCONTAINERS
OF FRESHWATER 3MALL CONTAINERSCALLED
MOKTIARE OFTEN MADE OF POTTERY AND
PARTLYBURIEDINTOTHECLAYSOILSURROUNDING
HOUSESTOPROVIDERESERVOIRSOFFRESHWATER
FOR EVERY HOUSE ,ARGER WATER TANKS OF
PLASTICOREVENCONCRETEAREALSOINSTALLED
NEAR SCHOOLS OR IN VILLAGER CENTERS TO
PROVIDE A MORE COMMUNAL AND ROBUST
RESERVOIR 4HE FRESHWATER USUALLY COMES
FROMRAIN THATISCHANNELEDOFFROOFSINTO
CONTAINERS 3OME WEALTHIER FARMERS ARE
ALSOCONVERTINGOLDRICEFIELDSTOFISHPONDS
AND USING THESE TO FATTEN CRABS FOR LOCAL
RESTAURANTSORFORCONSUMPTIONIN$HAKA
"ANGLADESHSCAPITALCITY
)NTHECOASTALDISTRICTOF.OAKHALI3OUTH
"ANGLADESH THE )NTERNATIONAL 5NION FOR
#ONSERVATIONOF.ATURE)5#.HASBEEN
IMPLEMENTING THE 0ROMOTION OF !DAP
TATION TO #LIMATE #HANGE AND #LIMATE
6ARIABILITY0ROJECTWHICHAIMSIN PART TO
INCREASEADAPTIVECAPACITYATTHECOMMU
NITYLEVEL/NECOMMUNITYBASEDADAPTA
TION PROJECT UNDER THIS PROGRAM INVOLVES
RAISING AND REINFORCING HOMESTEADS TO
MAKE THEM MORE RESILIENT AGAINST FLOOD
ING AND CYCLONIC ACTIVITY REDUCING THE
NEED FOR PEOPLETO FLEE THEIR HOMES DUR
ING EXTREME WEATHER EVENTS AND REDUC
ING LOSSES4HE PROJECT BRINGS TOGETHER A
DESIGNTEAM OFLOCALINDIVIDUALSENGAGED
ASVILLAGELEVELHOUSEBUILDINGSPECIALISTS
ARCHITECTSPLANNERSANENGINEERA GEOG
RAPHER ARCHITECTURE STUDENTS FROM LOCAL
4HE)NTERNATIONAL5NIONFOR#ONSERVATIONOF.ATUREISWORKINGWITHVILLAGERSINTHE#HAR#LERKUNIONOF3UBARNACHAR5PAZILA.OAKHALITO
RAISEANDREINFORCEHOMESTEADSWHICHFACEINCREASINGTHREATSFROMFLOODINGANDCYCLONES
#/524%39*%33)#!!9%23
 %.6)2/.-%.4 777%.6)2/.-%.4-!'!:).%/2' 6/,5-%.5-"%2
UNIVERSITIESUSERGROUPSAND LOCALBUILD
ERSANDCARPENTERSTODEVELOPPRELIMINARY
DESIGNOPTIONS4HETEAMSELECTS ONEFAM
ILY IN THE COMMUNITYFOR WHOM TO BUILD
THEFIRSTDEMONSTRATIONHOUSE/NCEBUILT
ANEWLOCALDESIGNANDCONSTRUCTIONTEAM
ISFORMEDFROMTHENOWEXPERIENCEDLOCAL
MEMBERSOFTHEFIRSTTEAMWHOMOVETHE
PROJECTFORWARDINTHEIRCOMMUNITYBUILD
INGOTHERHOUSESINTHELOCALITYALONGWITH
THEHOUSEOWNERS
(OUSE DESIGN IS BASED ON TRADITIONAL
CULTURALPREFERENCES BUTINCORPORATEMOD
EST TECHNOLOGICAL INNOVATIONS THAT HELP
STRENGTHEN OR OTHERWISEIMPROVE PARTSOF
THE HOUSE THAT ARE PARTICULARLY WEAK AND
VULNERABLE IN THE LOCAL CLIMATE 4HESE
INCLUDE RAISING FOUNDATIONS REINFORCING
HOUSESTRUCTURESANDCREATINGRAISEDPLAT
FORMSWITHINHOMESWHEREPEOPLECANTAKE
SHELTERDURINGFLOODS0LANTINGEXTENSIVELY
ALONGEDGESOFHOMESTEADSISALOCALWAY
OFREDUCINGWINDIMPACTS
#OMMUNITYBASED ADAPTATION IS NOT
RESTRICTED TODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESSUCHAS
"ANGLADESH BUT CAN ALSO BE USED AMONG
VULNERABLE COMMUNITIES IN MORE DEVEL
OPEDREGIONSSEETHEBOXBELOW
#HALLENGESTO#OMMUNITY
"ASED!DAPTATION
4HE APPROACHES DESCRIBED ABOVE INDI
CATE HOW ADAPTATION TO CLIMATE CHANGE
CAN BE INTEGRATED WITH LOCAL DEVELOP
MENT NEEDS AND ECONOMIC TRENDS RATHER
THAN SIMPLY BEING USED TO SLOW DOWN
PHYSICAL CHANGES SUCH AS RISING SEA LEV
ELS OR INCREASING SALINITY 0ROPONENTS OF
COMMUNITYBASED ADAPTATION SAY IT
HAS MADE EXCELLENT PROGRESS IN ACHIEV
ING PLACEBASED RESILIENCE BUILDING AND
ADDRESSINGLOCALSOCIALVULNERABILITYRATHER
THANASSESSING CLIMATERISKONLYINTERMS
OFPHYSICALEVENTS-OREOVERDONORAGEN
CIESHAVESHOWNANINTERESTININVESTINGIN
COMMUNITYBASED ADAPTATION RECOGNIZ
INGTHATITIS AVALIDAPPROACHTOBUILDING
ADAPTIVE CAPACITY IN VULNERABLE COMMU
NITIES &OR EXAMPLE AT THE 4HIRD )NTER
NATIONAL #OMMUNITY"ASED !DAPTATION
7ORKSHOP IN $HAKA IN &EBRUARY 
THE &OOD AND !GRICULTURAL /RGANIZATION
OFTHE5NITED.ATIONSANNOUNCEDTHEPOS
SIBILITY OF PROVIDING FUNDING FOR SMALL
SCALE COMMUNITYBASED ADAPTATION PROJ
ECTS WHILE OTHER DONORSINCLUDING THE
7ORLD "ANK 5NITED .ATIONS $EVELOP
MENT 0ROGRAMME 5+ $EPARTMENT FOR
)NTERNATIONAL $EVELOPMENT AND 3WEDISH
)NTERNATIONAL $EVELOPMENT #OOPERATION
!GENCYWERE ACTIVELY ENGAGED IN CON
FERENCE DISCUSSIONS ON THE BEST WAY TO
ACHIEVE DONOR SUPPORT FOR COMMUNITY
BASEDADAPTATION
(OWEVER WHILE COMMUNITYBASED
ADAPTATIONISAVITALAPPROACHTO ADDRESS
INGTHE VULNERABILITYOFCOMMUNITIESIT
ALSO PRESENTS MANY CHALLENGES &IRST FOR
SOME ANALYSTS IT IS UNCLEAR HOW MUCH
COMMUNITYBASEDADAPTATIONDIFFERSFROM
COMMUNITYBASEDhDEVELOPMENTvINGEN
ERAL4HISLACKOFDISTINCTIONHASPRESENTED
PROBLEMS FOR PRACTITIONERS AND FUNDING
BODIES WHO REQUIRE FIRMER SIGNPOSTS OF
SUCCESSFUL COMMUNITYBASED ADAPTATION
PROJECTS TO DISTINGUISH GOOD PRACTICE
3ECOND DOES COMMUNITYBASED ADAPTA
TION CONSISTSIMPLY OF LOCAL RESPONSES TO
EXISTINGCLIMATE VARIABILITY RATHER THAN A
PROACTIVE ANTICIPATION OF FUTURE CLIMATE
CHANGE-ANYCOMMUNITYBASEDADAPTA
TIONPROJECTSDONOTCURRENTLYUSEPROJEC
TIONS OF CLIMATE CHANGE FROM RESEARCH
ORGANIZATIONS OR THE )0## !T THE 
WORKSHOP )0## SCIENTISTS IN ATTENDANCE
STRESSED THE IMPORTANCE OF CONSULTING
CLIMATE MODELERS IN COMMUNITYBASED
ADAPTATIONDESIGN9ETHOWUSEFULSUCH
INFORMATIONCANBEATTHECOMMUNITYLEVEL
REMAINSANOPENQUESTION4OOLSAREBEING
DEVELOPED TO IMPROVE THE ACCESSIBILITY
AND RELEVANCE OF DOWNSCALED MODELED
DATA TO COMMUNITYBASED ADAPTATION FOR
EXAMPLE THE WE!$!04 COLLABORATIVE
#/--5.)49"!3%$!$!04!4)/.).4(%!2#4)#
)TISNOTONLYDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESTHATARE
VULNERABLETOCLIMATECHANGE4HESMALL
COMMUNITIESALONGTHE!RCTICCOASTLINES
INCOUNTRIESSUCHAS#ANADA2USSIATHE
5NITED3TATESAND.ORWAYARELOCATEDIN
SUPPOSEDLYDEVELOPEDZONESYETINCLUDE
SOMEOFTHOSECOUNTRIESPOORESTPEOPLE
-OREOVER !RCTIC PEOPLE ARE RELIANT ON
ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES THREATENED BY
CLIMATE CHANGE )NDEED THE!RCTIC RIM
OF.ORTH!MERICAISOFTENREFERREDTOAS
CLIMATECHANGESCANARYINTHECOALMINE
THE FIRST TO EXPERIENCE ITS EFFECTS /NE
MAJOR PROBLEM ASSOCIATED WITH CLIMATE
CHANGEISDECLININGICECOVER4HE )NUIT
POPULATIONS OF THE !RCTIC RELY ON ICE
FOR TRANSPORTATION TO HUNT GATHER FOOD
GENERATE INCOME AND MAINTAIN SOCIAL
CONNECTIONSSOTHECHANGINGBEHAVIOROF
ICEPOSESASIGNIFICANTTHREATTOTHE)NUIT
WAYOFLIFE
!RCTIC COMMUNITIES HAVE ALWAYS
LIVED IN CONDITIONS OF ENVIRONMENTAL
FRAGILITY AND HIGH VARIABILITY AND AS A
RESULTTHEYHAVEAWEALTHOFTRADITIONAL
KNOWLEDGE AND CULTURAL PRACTICES THAT
AREHELPINGTHEMTOCOPEWITHANDADAPT
TO NEW CHALLENGES &OR EXAMPLE THE
)NUITCOMMUNITYOFTHEISLAND OF)GLOO
LIKIN.UNAVUT#ANADAKILOMETERS
NORTH OF THE !RCTIC #IRCLE HAS DEVEL
OPEDMANY BEHAVIORALRESPONSES TOCLI
MATICEXPOSURES)NDIGENOUSKNOWLEDGE
PASSED FROM GENERATION TO GENERATION
ABOUT WHAT TO HUNT WHEN AND WHERE
AND HOW TO TELL WHEN DOG TEAMS INDI
CATE THIN AND UNSAFE ICE IS IN CERTAIN
AREAS HAS RESULTED IN FLEXIBLE HUNTING
ANDHARVESTINGTECHNIQUES0EOPLE HAVE
ALSO DEVELOPED RISKAVERSE PRACTICES
SUCH AS TAKING EXTRA SUPPLIES OF FOOD
ANDGASONEXPEDITIONSANDNEVERTRAV
ELING ALONE OR ON LAND OR WATER WHERE
THEICE SEEMS THIN #RITICALTO ADAPTIVE
CAPACITY ARE SOCIAL NETWORKS SUCH AS
EXTENDED FAMILY UNITS A STRONG SENSE
OFCOLLECTIVECOMMUNITY RESPONSIBILITY
AND MUTUAL AID ALL OF WHICH FACILITATE
THESHARING OF FOOD AND EQUIPMENT AND
ENSURE RAPID RESPONSES TO CRISES !
STUDY ON DEVELOPING APPROPRIATE ADAP
TATIONPOLICYIN.UNAVUTUNDERTAKENIN
RECOMMENDEDTHATINTERVENTIONSTO
REDUCEVULNERABILITYINTHE!RCTICREGION
SHOULDBEDEVELOPEDINPARTNERSHIPWITH
THE LOCAL COMMUNITY AND DRAW ON THIS
IMPORTANT INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE AND
EXISTINGLOCALCOPINGSTRATEGIES
&"ERKESAND $*OLLYh!DAPTINGTO#LIMATE
#HANGE3OCIAL%COLOGICAL2ESILIENCEINA#ANADIAN
7ESTERN!RCTIC#OMMUNITYv#ONSERVATION%COLOGY
NO
*&ORDET ALh2EDUCING6ULNERABILITYTO #LI
MATE#HANGE IN THE !RCTIC4HE #ASE OF .UNAVUT
#ANADAv!RCTICNOn
)BID
*5,9!5'534 777%.6)2/.-%.4-!'!:).%/2' %.6)2/.-%.4 
HASCREATEDTHE#LIMATE#HANGE%XPLORER
TOOLWHICHDISPLAYSOUTPUTFROMMULTIPLE
CLIMATE MODELS DOWNSCALED TO A STATION
LEVELANDALSOGUIDESUSERSTO HELP APPLY
THESE DATA OUTPUTS IN MEANINGFUL WAYS
!N IMPORTANT ELEMENT OF THIS TOOL IS ITS
EMPHASIS ON THE HISTORICAL CONTEXT OF
CHANGES IN CLIMATE TO BETTER UNDERSTAND
FUTURE CHANGES LONGTERM TRENDS OCCUR
RING IN THE PRESENT MAYIN FACT BE MORE
IMPORTANT FOR ADAPTATION IN MANY CASES
THANPROJECTEDCHANGEFOR
4OOLS SUCH AS THE #LIMATE #HANGE
%XPLORERAREINTHEEARLYSTAGESOFDEVEL
OPMENT AND DATA IS NOT YET AVAILABLE
FOR ALL VULNERABLE REGIONS &URTHER AS IS
EMPHASIZED BY THE TOOL ITSELFUSERSMUST
BECAUTIOUSWHENDRAWINGON THEOUTPUTS
OF DOWNSCALED CLIMATE CHANGE MODELS
INDESIGNINGAPPROPRIATECOMMUNITYBASED
ADAPTATION PROJECTS &ROM A COMMUNITY
BASED ADAPTATION STANDPOINT CLIMATIC
CHANGES ARE ACKNOWLEDGED BY TRYING TO
UNDERSTAND LOCALLYOBSERVEDHISTORICPAT
TERNS OF CHANGE IN WAYS THAT ARE MEAN
INGFUL TO LOCAL PEOPLE &OR SOME THIS
REPRESENTS A STRENGTH OF THE APPROACH
WITH PROPONENTS ARGUING THAT A FOCUS ON
THE UNDERLYING hDRIVERSv OF VULNERABILITY
SODEPENDENTONTHEDEVELOPMENTCONTEXT
REPRESENTS A MUCHNEEDED MOVE AWAY
FROMANhIMPACTSBASEDvAPPROACH9ETIF
CLIMATECHANGEPROJECTIONSARENOTBROUGHT
INTOCOMMUNITYBASEDADAPTATIONPROJECTS
THENCANTHEYREALLYBESAIDTOBEADDRESS
INGCLIMATECHANGEANDHENCEBESEENAS
LEGITIMATE APPROACHES TO CLIMATE CHANGE
ADAPTATION!SNOTEDBYONEDONORREPRE
SENTATIVEATTHEWORKSHOPhGOODDEVELOP
MENTISNOTSUFFICIENTFORADAPTATIONv
4HESE QUESTIONS ALSO INFLUENCE HOW
COMMUNITYBASED ADAPTATION SHOULD BE
FUNDED3OME DONORS SUCHASTHE7ORLD
"ANKHAVECALLEDFORAGREATERINVOLVE
MENT OF OFFICIAL SCIENTIFIC ASSESSMENTS OF
CLIMATECHANGEBEFOREUSINGCLIMATECHANGE
FUNDS FOR COMMUNITYBASED ADAPTATION
!NOTHEROPTIONIS TO FUNDITTHROUGHOFFI
CIAL DEVELOPMENT ASSISTANCE 4HIS OPTION
RAISES FURTHER CHALLENGES HOWEVER SINCE
ITMAYTHENBECOMPETINGWITHOTHERLOCAL
DEVELOPMENTPRIORITIES-OREOVERFUNDING
ADAPTATIONTOCLIMATECHANGETHROUGHOFFI
CIAL DEVELOPMENT ASSISTANCE FACES STRONG
CRITICISMS FROM DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
WHOARGUETHATCLIMATECHANGEISANOTHER
STRESSOR ON TOP OF ALBEIT EXACERBATING
UNDERDEVELOPMENT AND IT SHOULD THERE
FOREBETHERESPONSIBILITYOFINDUSTRIALIZED
COUNTRIES WHO HAVE CAUSED THIS PROBLEM
TO BEAR THE BRUNT OF THE ADDITIONAL COSTS
&OR EXAMPLE AT THE *UNE  MEETING
OFTHESUBSIDIARYBODIESTOTHE5.&###
DEVELOPING COUNTRIES CALLED FOR THE MEA
SURABLE REPORTABLE AND VERIFIABLE USE OF
NEW AND ADDITIONAL FUNDING FOR CLIMATE
CHANGEnSPECIFIC ACTIVITIES AS OPPOSED TO
MORE GENERAL RESILIENCE BUILDING 4HIS
PRINCIPLEISRECOGNIZEDBYARTICLEOFTHE
5.&###WHICHSPECIFIESTHATDEVELOPED
COUNTRIESHAVECOMMITTEDTOHELPINGhPAR
TICULARLY VULNERABLEv COUNTRIES MEET THE
COSTSOFADAPTATION
!NOTHER COMMON CONCERN IS HOW TO
MAKE LOCAL LESSONS OF COMMUNITYBASED
ADAPTATIONAPPLYTOWIDERSPATIALSCALESA
CONCEPTOFTENCALLEDhUPSCALINGv.'/S
AND ACADEMICSTUDIES ARE CURRENTLY IDEN
TIFYING SEVERAL EXAMPLES OF SUCCESSFUL
PROJECTS AT THE SCALE OF A HOUSEHOLD A
VILLAGE OR A COLLECTION OF VILLAGES "UT
DO THESE LOCAL COMMUNITYBASED INITIA
TIVES OFFER LESSONS FOR HOW TO ADAPT TO
CLIMATECHANGEATTHENATIONALSCALEORIN
OTHERCOUNTRIES4HECONTEXTUALNATUREOF
COMMUNITYBASED ADAPTATION MAKES
DEVELOPING INDICATORS OR MODELS PROB
LEMATIC RISKING THE PROLIFERATION OF A
PIECEMEALAPPROACHTHATLACKSCLARITYAND
FAILS TO ATTRACTWIDER CLIMATE CHANGE AND
DEVELOPMENTINVESTMENT
!CCORDINGTOSOMEANALYSTSTHEINSTITU
TIONALDESIGNOFCOMMUNITYBASEDADAPTA
TIONLIESINTHELOCALDELIBERATIONSTHATCAN
IDENTIFY DEVELOPMENT NEEDS AND CULTURAL
PREFERENCES RATHER THAN THE APPLICATION
OFTHESAME TECHNOLOGIESORASSUMPTIONS
ABOUT LIVELIHOODS TO DIFFERENT PLACES
)NDEEDONEOPTIONISTO TAKETHEEXISTING
DEVELOPMENTASSISTANCEKNOWNASTHESUS
TAINABLELIVELIHOODSAPPROACHANDSENSITIZE
ITTO FUTURE CLIMATE RISKS! SUSTAINABLE
LIVELIHOODS APPROACH MAKES HOUSEHOLDS
MORERESILIENTTOCLIMATESHOCKSEITHERBY
USING MIGRATION SELECTIVELY OR EMPOWER
ING HOUSEHOLDS TO INTENSIFY AGRICULTURE
OUTPUTSANDDIVERSIFYECONOMICACTIVITIES
&OR EXAMPLE IN -ONGLA SUBDISTRICT OF
SOUTHERN "ANGLADESH SOME HOUSEHOLDS
AREREDUCINGTHEIRVULNERABILITYTOCLIMATE
BYGAININGREMITTANCESFROMFAMILYMEM
BERSWORKINGIN$HAKAANDGROWINGFRESH
WATERCROPSINTHEDRYSEASONANDCRABSIN
SALTWATER IN THE WET SEASON !DDRESSING
CLIMATE RISK SOMETIMES CAN MEAN REDUC
INGTHEDEPENDENCYOFINCOMEFROMAGRI
CULTURALORFISHINGBASEDACTIVITIES
&INALLYPERHAPSTHEULTIMATECRITICISMOF
COMMUNITYBASEDADAPTATIONISTHATITMAY
NOTSUFFICEINPREVENTINGSOMEIMPACTSOF
CLIMATECHANGE)FCURRENTCLIMATECHANGE
POLICIESFAILTOPROLONGATMOSPHERICWARM
ING AT JUST  DEGREES #ELSIUS AND IF
WARMING APPROACHES DEGREES OR MORE
THEN IT IS LIKELY THAT LARGE AREAS OF LAND
WILLINTIMEBEINUNDATEDWITHSEAWATER
2ELOCATION OF VILLAGES WOULD THEREFORE
BE A REALITY #OMMUNITYBASED ADAPTA
TION THAT DOES NOT INCORPORATE DETAILED
CLIMATE CHANGE INFORMATION OR COMMU
NICATE LIKELYSCENARIOS AT THE COMMUNITY
LEVELMAYDISCOURAGETHEKINDOF TECHNO
LOGICAL OR ENGINEERINGBASED APPROACH
ES TO ADAPTATION THAT A COMMUNITY
BASEDAPPROACHSEEKSTOSUPPLEMENT0ER
VERSELY THIS COULD LEAD TO A SITUATION IN
WHICH LARGERSCALE STRATEGIC ADAPTATION
OPTIONSTHATRESPONDDIRECTLYTOFUTURECLI
MATECHANGESCENARIOSAREALIENATEDEVEN
MORE FROM THE COMMUNITIES THEY AFFECT
BECAUSE A LACKOF AWARENESS OF THE NEED
FORSUCHPROGRAMSWILLMAKEPARTICIPATION
WITHLOCALPEOPLEPROBLEMATIC3OMEANA
LYSTS CALL THIS MISMATCH OF EXPECTATIONS
A FORM OF MALADAPTATION )N "ANGLA
DESHSUCHISSUESAREPARTICULARLYPOIGNANT
BECAUSE MANY COMMUNITIES UNDERTAKING
COMMUNITYBASED ADAPTATION ARE LOCATED
INAREASTHREATENEDBYINUNDATIONSEETHE
BOXONPAGE
#ONCLUSIONS
h'OODv ADAPTATION REQUIRES CONSIDER
ATION OF IMMEDIATE AND LONGTERM VUL
NERABILITY IN CLIMATIC AND DEVELOPMENTAL
TERMS 4HERE IS LITTLE POINT IN SEEKING TO
ADAPTTOLIKELYCLIMATERISKSWITHOUTKNOW
INGHOWSOCIALANDECONOMICTRENDSMAKE
PEOPLEVULNERABLEORWHATTHEIRNEEDSARE
9ET DEVELOPMENT OBJECTIVES ALSO NEED TO
 %.6)2/.-%.4 777%.6)2/.-%.4-!'!:).%/2' 6/,5-%.5-"%2
INCORPORATEPROJECTIONSABOUTHOWCLIMATE
WILLCHANGE)N EFFECTTHESEREQUIREMENTS
IMPLYTHATCLIMATECHANGEIMPACTSCANBE
RELEVANT TO COMMUNITYBASED ADAPTATION
ASLONG ASITREMAINSFIRSTANDFOREMOSTA
COMMUNITYDRIVENPROCESS)TISIMPORTANT
THAT INTERVENTIONS ARECONSISTENT WITHCLI
MATE CHANGE IMPLICATIONS AND CAN FORM
PARTOFAWIDERCLIMATECHANGEADAPTATION
STRATEGYINWHICHSPECIFICANDLONGERTERM
CLIMATECHANGEIMPACTSCANBEADDRESSED
ATAVARIETYOFSCALES
!TTHESAMETIMESCIENTIFICASSESSMENTS
OF LIKELY CHANGES IN CLIMATE NEED TO BE
OPENTOCOMMUNITYBASEDADAPTATIONASA
MEANSOFINTEGRATINGCONCERNSABOUTSOCIAL
VULNERABILITYANDDEVELOPMENTWITHCLIMATE
CHANGE POLICY %SPECIALLYASWEAPPROACH
THE  CLIMATE CHANGE NEGOTIATIONS IN
#OPENHAGEN WHERE A POST DEAL ON
MANAGINGCLIMATECHANGEWILLBEREACHED
ITISIMPORTANTTHATOBSERVERSACKNOWLEDGE
THEPOTENTIALOFCOMMUNITYBASEDADAPTA
TION AS A CRITICAL OF REDUCING THE VULNER
ABILITYOFTHEPOORESTCOMMUNITIES0OLICY
DIALOGUEUNDERTHE5.&###NEEDSTO BE
OPENTOANEWRANGEOFEXPERTISEINFORMED
BY INSIGHTS FROM VULNERABLE COMMUNI
TIES GENERATED BY LOCAL STAKEHOLDERS AND
DEVELOPMENT AND DISASTER RISKnREDUCTION
PRACTITIONERS RATHER THAN RESTRICTED TO
IMPACTSBASED SCIENTIFIC INPUTS ARISING
FROMGLOBALORNATIONALMODELSALONE/NE
SIGN OF PROGRESS CAN BE SEEN IN DISCUS
SIONS OVER 5.&###S!DAPTATION &UND
TOSUPPORTADAPTATION INDEVELOPINGCOUN
TRIES THAT ARE 0ARTY TO THE 0ROTOCOL UNDER
THE 5.&### 4HE 2EPORT OF THE &IFTH
!DAPTATION&UND"OARD-EETINGIN-ARCH
 NOTED MEMBERS BROADLYAGREED THAT
SMALLSCALEANDCOMMUNITYBASEDPROJECTS
SHOULD BE INCLUDEDIN FUNDINGCYCLES AND
,)-)434/#/--5.)49"!3%$!$!04!4)/.4(%)-0,)#!4)/.3
/&3%!,%6%,2)3%&/24(%#/!34!,"%,4/&"!.',!$%3(

4HE COASTAL BELT OF "ANGLADESH IS THE
SITEOFMANYCOMMUNITYBASEDADAPTATION
PROGRAMSTHATARERESPONDINGTOPROBLEMS
SUCH AS WATERLOGGING SALINITY INTRUSION
AND INCREASING STORM ANDCYCLONE SEVER
ITY "UT WHAT ARE THE IMPLICATIONS OF
SEALEVEL RISE ON THISREGION FOR THE SUS
TAINABILITY OF THESE PROJECTS IN THE LONG
TERM 3EALEVEL RISE WILL RESULT IN MORE
COASTALFLOODINGUNDERAMBIENTCONDITIONS
AND EVEN MORE SO IN THEEVENT OF STORM
SURGES /NE PROMINENT  STUDY SUG
GESTSTHATAMETERRISEINSEALEVELWOULD
INUNDATEPERCENTOF"ANGLADESHSTOTAL
LAND DIRECTLY THREATENING  PERCENT OF
THE COUNTRYS POPULATION WHILE A 
7ORLD "ANK REPORT SUGGESTS SUCH A RISE
WOULD FLOOD n PERCENT OF THE LAND
MASS AND DISPLACE  MILLION PEOPLE
MAINLYFROM THE SOUTHERNCOASTAL AREAS
4HESEPROJECTIONSAREVERYPOSSIBLEBYTHE
END OF THIS CENTURY WITH RECENT STUDIES
THATFACTORINGLACIALMELTSUGGESTINGRISES
OFTOMETERSBY
)NADDITIONSEALEVELRISEINCONJUNC
TIONWITHINCREASEDFREQUENCYAND INTEN
SITY OF STORMS AND CYCLONES HAS SEVERE
IMPLICATIONS FOR COASTAL INUNDATION IN
THE REGION ! RESEARCHER AT THE "ANGLA
DESH3PACE2ESEARCHAND2EMOTE3ENS
ING/RGANIZATIONCALCULATED THEEFFECTOF
 DEGREES #ELSIUS WARMING ON A REPEAT
OFTHE DEVASTATINGCYCLONEIN "AN
GLADESH WHICH FORCED A METER STORM
SURGE INLAND OVER A WIDE AREA KILL
ING AT LEAST  PEOPLE AND LEAVING
AS MANY AS MILLION HOMELESS 4HE
RESEARCHERFOUNDTHATTHERISEINTEMPERA
TURE WAS ASSOCIATED WITH A  PERCENT
INCREASE IN WIND SPEED AND A  METER
RISE IN SEA LEVEL (E ESTIMATED THAT THIS
SCENARIO WOULD RESULT IN HIGHER STORM
SURGES THAT WOULD INUNDATE  PERCENT
MORELANDTHANTHATOFTHECYCLONE
4HIS PREDICTION IS PARTICULARLY ALARMING
GIVEN THAT CLIMATE SCIENTISTS ARE NOW
QUESTIONINGWHETHERTHEWORLDCANMAKE
THERAPIDREDUCTIONOFEMISSIONSNEEDED
TOHALT WARMING AT DEGREES #ELSIUS IN
THE FACE OF MAJOR ECONOMIC TECHNICAL
AND POLITICAL OBSTACLES 3OME ARE EVEN
SUGGESTINGTHAT WARMINGOFMORETHAN 
DEGREESISMUCHMOREPLAUSIBLE
)N THE FACE OF SUCH DIRE IMPLICATIONS
FOR THE REGION THERE IS A SENSE THAT
COMMUNITYBASED ADAPTATION INITIATIVES
SUCH AS FLOATING GARDENS AND REINFORCED
HOUSING WHILE UNDENIABLY CONTRIBUTING
TO THE SHORTTERM ADAPTIVE CAPACITY OF
A SMALL NUMBER OF PEOPLE TO CURRENT
CLIMATEVARIABILITYCANONLYPROVEAPAL
LIATIVESOLUTIONFOR ASMALLPROPORTION OF
THE THREATENED POPULATION #OMMUNITY
BASEDADAPTATIONINTHEREGIONISHELPING
PEOPLE COPE WITH CURRENT CLIMATIC RISKS
WHICHWILL IN TURN ASSISTIN BUILDING OR
LIMITTHE LOSSOFASSETS ANDENTITLEMENTS
THAT CAN CONTRIBUTE TO ADAPTIVE CAPACITY
OVERALONGERTIMESCALE(OWEVERIFTHEY
ARE NOT INTEGRATED INTO WIDER AND MORE
STRATEGIC POLICYMAKING PROCESSES THAT
ADDRESSTHELONGERTERMANDWIDERSCALE
IMPLICATIONS OF CLIMATE CHANGE SUCH
INTERVENTIONS CAN ONLY BE SHORT TERM
ASSIST A VERY SMALL NUMBER OF PEOPLE
IN RELATION TO THE THREATENED POPULATION
AND MAY RESULT IN ONLY COPINGAGAINST
RISKS THAT PERHAPS SHOULD BE RECOGNIZED
AS UNMANAGEABLE WITHOUT MUCH LARGER
INTERVENTIONS#OPINGWITHADDEDSHOCKS
ANDSTRESSES IMPLIESTHATPEOPLE AREABLE
TO DEAL WITH THESE WHILE MAINTAINING
THEIR ORIGINAL VULNERABLE STATE BUT ARE
NOTABLETOADDRESSTHEMYRIADCHALLENGES
THAT CONSTRAIN LIVES AND LIVELIHOODSAND
MAKEPEOPLEVULNERABLEINTHEFIRSTPLACE
!DAPTATIONON THE OTHER HANDSUGGESTS
APROCESS THAT REDUCES VULNERABILITYAND
BUILDS RESILIENCE TO CLIMATIC STRESSES
FACILITATING MORE GENERAL IMPROVEMENTS
TOTHEQUALITYOFHUMANLIVES
4HE AUTHORS WISH TO ACKNOWLEDGE )AN "URTON FOR
DISCUSSIONSTHATINFORMEDTHISSECTION
 3!GRAWALA 4/TA ! 5!HMED * 3MITH
AND-VAN!ALST$EVELOPMENTAND#LIMATE#HANGE
IN"ANGLADESH &OCUSON #OASTAL &LOODINGAND THE
3UNDARBANS 0ARIS/RGANISATION FOR %CONOMIC #O
OPERATIONAND$EVELOPMENT
7ORLD"ANK"ANGLADESH#LIMATE#HANGEAND
3USTAINABLE $EVELOPMENT 3TUDY 7ASHINGTON $#
7ORLD"ANK
 7 4 0FEFFER * 4 (AERPER AND 3 /.EEL
h+INEMATIC#ONSTRAINTS ON 'LACIER #ONTRIBUTIONSTO
ST#ENTURY3EA,EVEL2ISEv3CIENCENO
3EPTEMBERn
 !!LI h6ULNERABILITY OF "ANGLADESH TO #LI
MATE #HANGE AND 3EA,EVEL 2ISE THROUGH 4ROPICAL
#YCLONESAND3TORM3URGESv7ATER!IR 3OIL0OL
LUTIONNOSnn
)"URTONh"EYOND"ORDERS4HE.EEDFOR3TRA
TEGIC 'LOBAL!DAPTATIONv)NTERNATIONAL )NSTITUTE FOR
%NVIRONMENT AND $EVELOPMENT ))%$ 3USTAINABLE
$EVELOPMENT/PINION0APER ,ONDON))%$
AND- 0ARRY*0ALUTIKOF# (ANSONAND * ,OWE
h#LIMATE 0OLICY 3QUARING 5P TO 2EALITYv .ATURE
2EPORTS #LIMATE #HANGE  NO   n
HTTPWWWNATURECOMCLIMATEFULLCLI
MATEHTMLACCESSED!PRIL
 $ $ODMAN* !YERSAND 3 (UQ h"UILDING
2ESILIENCEv IN 7ORLDWATCH )NSTITUTE 3TATE OF THE
7ORLD  )NTO A 7ARMING 7ORLD 7ASHINGTON
$#7ORLDWATCH)NSTITUTE
*5,9!5'534 777%.6)2/.-%.4-!'!:).%/2' %.6)2/.-%.4 
COMMUNITYBASED PROJECTS COULD ALSO BE
SUBMITTED BY GOVERNMENTS AS PART OF A
MORE STRATEGIC ADAPTATION FUNDING PACK
AGE
!S THE FIELD OF COMMUNITYBASED ADAP
TATION  GROWS IN SIZE AND SIGNIFICANCE IT
IS LIKELY THAT THE LESSONS LEARNEDFROM THE
INCREASING NUMBER OF CASE STUDIES WILL
BEGIN TO PERMEATE THE NEGOTIATIONS AND
HELPCREATEABETTERUNDERSTANDINGOFHOWTO
BUILDTHERESILIENCEOFTHEMOSTVULNERABLE
*ESSICA !YERS IS A 0H$ CANDIDATE AT THE$EVELOPMENT
3TUDIES )NSTITUTE ,ONDON 3CHOOL OF %CONOMICS AND
0OLITICAL3CIENCEANDARESEARCHCONSULTANTFORTHE)NTER
NATIONAL)NSTITUTEFOR%NVIRONMENTAND$EVELOPMENT(ER
WORKFOCUSESTHERELATIONSHIPBETWEENCOMMUNITYBASED
ADAPTATION AND WIDERCLIMATE CHANGE AND DEVELOPMENT
GOVERNANCE STRUCTURES AT THE NATIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL
LEVEL!YERSALSOACTS ASAN INDEPENDENTCONSULTANTFORA
VARIETY OF DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENT ORGANIZATIONS
WORKINGTOIMPROVEPOLICYANDACTIONONCLIMATECHANGE
ADAPTATION 3HE IS CURRENTLY WORKING FOR THE 5NITED
.ATIONS$EVELOPMENT0ROGRAMMEIN.EPALONDESIGNING
THE.ATIONAL!DAPTATION0ROGRAMMEOF!CTION3HEMAY
BECONTACTEDATJMAYERS LSEACUK
4IM&ORSYTHISAFACULTYMEMBERATTHE$EVELOPMENT
3TUDIES)NSTITUTEATTHE,ONDON3CHOOLOF%CONOMICSAND
0OLITICAL3CIENCE(EHASWORKEDFORMORETHANYEARS
ON ENVIRONMENTALPOLICY AND GOVERNANCEESPECIALLY IN
3OUTHAND3OUTHEAST!SIAANDHAS WRITTENESPECIALLYON
COMMUNITYBASEDENVIRONMENTALPRACTICESTHEPROBLEMS
OFIDENTIFYINGENVIRONMENTALRISKANDWAYSOF INTEGRAT
ING DEVELOPMENT OBJECTIVES INTO GLOBAL ENVIRONMENTAL
POLICY (E IS THE AUTHOR OF &OREST 'UARDIANS &OREST
$ESTROYERS 4HE 0OLITICS OF %NVIRONMENTAL +NOWLEDGE
IN .ORTHERN 4HAILAND WRITTEN WITH !NDREW 7ALKER
5NIVERSITY OF7ASHINGTON 0RESS  AND EDITOR OF
%NCYCLOPEDIAOF)NTERNATIONAL$EVELOPMENT2OUTLEDGE
AMONGOTHERPUBLICATIONS(EMAYBECONTACTEDAT
TJFORSYTH LSEACUK
./4%3
 )NTERGOVERNMENTAL 0ANEL ON #LIMATE #HANGE
)0## #LIMATE#HANGE  3YNTHESIS 2EPORT #ON
TRIBUTIONOF7ORKING'ROUPS) )) AND ))) TOTHE &OURTH
!SSESSMENT 2EPORT OF THE )NTERGOVERNMENTAL 0ANEL ON
#LIMATE#HANGE#ORE7RITING4EAM2+0ACHURIAND
!2EISINGEREDS#AMBRIDGE5+ #AMBRIDGE5NIVER
SITY0RESS
 - 0ARRY * 0ALUTIKOF # (ANSON AND *,OWE
h#LIMATE0OLICY3QUARING5PTO2EALITYv.ATURE2EPORTS
#LIMATE #HANGE  NO   n HTTPWWW
NATURECOMCLIMATEFULLCLIMATE
HTMLACCESSED!PRIL
 )0## h3UMMARY FOR 0OLICYMAKERSv IN#LIMATE
#HANGE  )MPACTS !DAPTATION AND 6ULNERABILITY
#ONTRIBUTIONOF7ORKING'ROUP))TO THE&OURTH!SSESS
MENT2EPORTOF THE)NTERGOVERNMENTAL0ANELON#LIMATE
#HANGE-,0ARRY/&#ANZIANI*00ALUTIKOF0*
VANDER,INDENAND#%(ANSONEDS#AMBRIDGE5+
#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESSn
! 'ORE %ARTH IN THE "ALANCE %COLOGYAND THE
(UMAN 3PIRIT "OSTON-! (OUGHTON -IFFLIN 

 h!DAPT OR $IEv 4HE %CONOMIST  3EPTEMBER
 HTTPWWWECONOMISTCOMWORLDINTERNATIONAL
DISPLAYSTORYCFMSTORY?ID ACCESSED  -AY

&OR EXAMPLETHE MEETING WASCOORGANIZED
BYTHE)NTERNATIONAL)NSTITUTEOF%NVIRONMENTAND$EVEL
OPMENT THE "ANGLADESH#ENTRE FOR !DVANCED 3TUDIES
ANDTHE2ING!LLIANCE)TWASCOSPONSOREDBYTHE"RITISH
(IGH#OMMISSIONOF"ANGLADESH%MBASSYOF$ENMARK
"ANGLADESH 7ORLD 7IDE &UND FOR .ATURE &OOD AND
!GRICULTURE/RGANIZATIONOFTHE5NITED.ATIONSAND THE
.'/S#ARE#HRISTIAN!IDAND0RACTICAL!CTION
*!YERSAND3(UQ h4HE6ALUE OF,INKING -ITI
GATION AND!DAPTATION ! #ASE 3TUDY OF "ANGLADESHv
%NVIRONMENTAL -ANAGEMENT  NO   /CTOBER
nAND,3CHIPPERh#ONCEPTUAL(ISTORYOF
!DAPTATIONINTHE5.&###0ROCESSv2%#)%,NO
n
 )0## #LIMATE #HANGE  3YNTHESIS 2EPORT
#ONTRIBUTION OF 7ORKING 'ROUPS ) )) AND ))) TO THE
4HIRD!SSESSMENT2EPORTOFTHE)NTERGOVERNMENTAL0ANEL
ON#LIMATE#HANGE247ATSON ANDTHE #ORE7RITING
4EAM EDS #AMBRIDGE 5+ #AMBRIDGE 5NIVERSITY
0RESS
*!YERSAND$$ODMANh#LIMATE#HANGE!DAPTA
TIONAND $EVELOPMENT4HE3TATEOF THE $EBATEv0ROG
RESSIN$EVELOPMENT3TUDIESACCEPTED
2*4+LEINAND!0ERSSONh&INANCING!DAPTA
TION TO #LIMATE #HANGE )SSUESAND 0RIORITIESv 3TOCK
HOLM %NVIRONMENT)NSTITUTE BRIEFINGNOTE FOR THE %URO
PEAN#LIMATE0LATFORM/CTOBER
 ) "URTON h#LIMATE #HANGE AND THE !DAPTA
TION $EFICITv !DAPTATION AND)MPACTS 2ESEARCH 'ROUP
/CCASIONAL0APER -ETEOROLOGICAL3ERVICE OF#ANADA
%NVIRONMENT#ANADA
*!YERS-!LAMAND 3(UQ h!DAPTATIONINA
0OST 2EGIME $EVELOPING #OUNTRY 0ERSPECTIVESv
IN &"IERMANN 00ATTBERG AND & :ELLIEDS 'LOBAL
#LIMATE 'OVERNANCE 0OST  !RCHITECTURE !GENCY
AND!DAPTATION#AMBRIDGE5+#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY
0RESSFORTHCOMING
 ) "URTON 3 (UQ " ,IM / 0ILIFOSOVA AND
, 3CHIPPERh&ROM )MPACTS !SSESSMENTTO !DAPTATION
0RIORITIES4HE 3HAPING OF !DAPTATION 0OLICYv#LIMATE
0OLICY   n AND 7 . !DGER 3 (UQ
+ "ROWN$ #ONWAY AND- (ULME h!DAPTATIONTO
#LIMATE#HANGE IN THE $EVELOPING7ORLDv0ROGRESSIN
$EVELOPMENT3TUDIESNOn
 3EE FOR EXAMPLE " 7ISNER 0 - "LAKIE
4 #ANNON AND ) $AVIS !T 2ISK .ATURAL (AZARDS
0EOPLES 6ULNERABILITY AND $ISASTERSND ED ,ONDON
AND.EW9ORK2OUTLEDGE  "3MITAND * 7AN
DELh!DAPTATION!DAPTIVE#APACITY AND 6ULNERABILITYv
'LOBAL%NVIRONMENTAL#HANGENOn
AND-!*ANSSEN-,3CHOON7+EAND+"ORNER
h3CHOLARLY .ETWORKS ON 2ESILIENCE 6ULNERABILITY AND
!DAPTATION WITHIN THE (UMAN $IMENSIONS OF 'LOBAL
%NVIRONMENTAL#HANGEv 'LOBAL%NVIRONMENTAL #HANGE
NOn
7ISNER"LAKIE#ANNONAND$AVISIBID
+LEINAND0ERSSONNOTE
!YERSAND$ODMANNOTE
&ORANARGUMENTTHAT CLIMATECHANGEPOLICYMUST
TARGET POOR PEOPLENOT JUST POOR COUNTRIES SEE 2 7
+ATES h#AUTIONARY 4ALES !DAPTATION AND THE 'LOBAL
0OORv#LIMATIC#HANGEn
 !2AHMAN h4HE 3OUTH )S !CTINGv /UR 0LAN
ET  $HAKA "ANGLADESH "ANGLADESH #ENTRE FOR
!DVANCED 3TUDIES  ! !HMED - !LAM AND
!2AHMAN h!DAPTATIONTO#LIMATE #HANGEIN "ANGLA
DESH&UTURE/UTLOOKvIN3(UQ:+ARIM-!SADUZ
ZUMANAND & -AHTABEDS 6ULNERABILITYAND !DAPTA
TIONTO#LIMATE#HANGEFOR"ANGLADESH$ORDRECHT4HE
.ETHERLANDS+LUWER!CADEMIC0UBLISHERS($
6ENEMAAND-#ISSE3EEINGTHE,IGHT!DAPTINGTO#LI
MATE #HANGEWITH $ECENTRALIZED 2ENEWABLE%NERGY IN
$EVELOPING#OUNTRIES7INNIPEG#ANADA)NTERNATIONAL
)NSTITUTEFOR3USTAINABLE$EVELOPMENTAND!YERS
AND(UQNOTE
 3 (UQ AND* !YERSh#LIMATE #HANGE )MPACTS
AND 2ESPONSES IN "ANGLADESHv BRIEFING NOTE PREPARED
FOR THE %UROPEAN 0ARLIAMENT 0OLICY $EPARTMENT %CO
NOMICAND3CIENTIFIC0OLICY$')NTERNAL0OLICIES OFTHE
5NION
)BID
)0##NOTE
+--2AHMAN h2IVER%ROSIONAND &LOODING
IN .ORTHERN "ANGLADESHv IN * %NSOR AND 2 "ERGER
5NDERSTANDING #LIMATE #HANGE !DAPTATION ,ESSONS
FROM#OMMUNITY"ASED!PPROACHES3TERLING6!3TY
LUS0UBLISHINGINPRESS
 4HIS PROGRAM IS ORGANIZED BY THE .'/ 0RAC
TICAL !CTION 3EE HTTPWWWPRACTICALACTIONORG
IDCLIMATECHANGE?FLOATINGGARDENS ACCESSED  -AY

2AHMANNOTE
 $ $ODMAN * !YERS AND 3 (UQ h"UILDING
2ESILIENCEv IN7ORLDWATCH)NSTITUTE3TATE OF THE7ORLD
)NTO A 7ARMING7ORLD 7ASHINGTON $#7ORLD
WATCH)NSTITUTE
2"ERGERAND-!LIh!DAPTATIONIN3OUTH!SIAv
4IEMPOn
 ! ,EOPOLD AND , -EAD h4HIRD )NTERNATIONAL
7ORKSHOP ON #OMMUNITY"ASED !DAPTATION TO #LI
MATE#HANGEv#OMMUNITY"ASED!DAPTATIONTO#LIMATE
#HANGE"ULLETINNO
3(UQAND(2EIDh#OMMUNITY"ASED!DAPTA
TION ! 6ITAL!PPROACH TO THE 4HREAT #LIMATE #HANGE
0OSESTOTHE0OORv)NTERNATIONAL)NSTITUTEOF%NVIRONMENT
AND$EVELOPMENT))%$BRIEFING,ONDON))%$
 2 *ONES AND ! 2AHMAN h#OMMUNITY"ASED
!DAPTATIONv4IEMPOn
,EOPOLDAND-EADNOTE
4HEWE!$!04GROUP ISANINFORMALPARTNERSHIP
AMONG LEADING ORGANIZATIONS WITH EXPERTISE IN VARIOUS
ASPECTSOFCLIMATE ADAPTATION)THAS EVOLVEDASPARTNERS
IN SPECIFIC PROJECTS SEE HTTPWWWWEADAPTORG FOR
THE LIST OF PARTNERS CURRENTLY INVOLVED WE!DAPT HAS
DEVELOPEDAPLATFORMOFTOOLSMETHODSDATASETSEXPERI
ENCEAND GUIDANCETOPROVIDEARESOURCE FORADAPTATION
PRACTITIONERS ANDTHE !DAPTATION %XPLORER IS ONE SUCH
TOOL HOSTED ON THE PLATFORM HTTPWWWWEADAPTORG
ACCESSED-AY
 3EE HTTPWIKIADAPTORGINDEXPHPTITLE4HE
?#LIMATE?#HANGE?%XPLORER?4OOL FOR MORE INFORMATION
ACCESSED-AY
,EOPOLDAND-EADNOTEPAGE
,EOPOLDAND-EADNOTEPAGE
 ,EOPOLD AND -EAD NOTE AND * !YERS AND
3(UQ h#OMMUNITY"ASED!DAPTATION7HATS.EWv
))%$BRIEFING,ONDON))%$INPRESS
2 * 4+LEIN h-AINSTREAMING#LIMATE!DAPTA
TION INTO $EVELOPMENT 0OLICIES AND 0ROGRAMMES !
%UROPEAN0ERSPECTIVEvIN%UROPEAN0ARLIAMENT&INANC
ING #LIMATE #HANGE0OLICIES IN $EVELOPING#OUNTRIES
0% )0!#,)0!#,)-34 "RUSSELS
"ELGIUM%UROPEAN0ARLIAMENT
)BID
 &OR EXAMPLE SEE THE DATABASE OF CASE STUDIES
AT HTTPCOMMUNITYELDISORGCBAX ACCESSED  -AY

*ONES AND 2AHMANNOTE  AND (UQAND 2EID
NOTE
&OREXAMPLESEETHE)NTERNATIONAL&UNDFOR!GRI
CULTURAL$EVELOPMENTHTTPWWWIFADORGSLAACCESSED
-AY
!YERSAND$ODMANNOTE
 4HESE DISCUSSIONS COVERED OPERATIONAL POLICIES
AND GUIDELINES FOR 0ARTIES TO THE 0ROTOCOL TO ACCESS
RESOURCES FROM THE !DAPTATION &UND 3EE !DAPTATION
&UND"OARD 2EPORTON THE!CTIVITIES OFTHE 3ECRETARIAT
!&""  -ARCH  HTTPWWWADAPTATION
FUNDORGIMAGES!&""?2EPORT?ON?THE
?!CTIVITIES?OF?THE?3ECRETARIAT?&INALPDF ACCESSED 
-AY
)"URTON4$ICKINSONAND9(OWARDh5PSCAL
ING!DAPTATION 3TUDIES TO )NFORM 0OLICY AT THE'LOBAL
,EVELv 4HE )NTEGRATED !SSESSMENT *OURNAL  NO 
n
... Community-based adaptation (CBA) emerges as a key strategy in this context (McNamara 2013;McNamara et al. 2020). Characterised by its focus on local-level engagement in climate-vulnerable areas, CBA employs participatory methods with local stakeholders to devise adaptation strategies that integrate cultural norms and local developmental needs to address underlying vulnerabilities (Ayers and Forsyth 2009). This approach emphasises the need for communities to both design and execute their adaptation measures (Dodman and Mitlin 2013;McNamara et al. 2020;Reid 2016). ...
... While foundational work on community-based climate change adaptation in the Pacific has been significant, these initiatives are relatively nascent, leaving the full extent of their community-level impacts yet to be ascertained (McNamara 2013;McNamara et al. 2020). Though these initiatives are designed to strengthen adaptive capacity by aligning with 'local realities in culturally appropriate ways', they face scrutiny for potentially harbouring paternalistic tendencies in their engagement methods (Ayers and Forsyth 2009;McNamara et al. 2020;Westoby et al. 2019). The imposition of Western-centric perspectives in adaptation efforts risks perpetuating top-down methodologies, and technical responses which facilitate predefined outcomes, which may undermine genuine community ownership and the effectiveness of such projects (Ayres and Dodman 2010;McNamara 2013;McNamara et al. 2020). ...
... This study highlights the critical role of focusing facilitation efforts on local social structures and belief systems. However, further research is recommended to avoid paternalistic approaches and maintain sensitivity to the community's cultural dynamics, customs, values, and norms (Ayers and Forsyth 2009;McNamara et al. 2020;Westoby et al. 2019). ...
Article
Full-text available
As global temperatures rise, so does the frequency and intensity of severe weather events and their risks to people and assets. These risks are especially acute for Pacific Islanders in urban informal settlements, given their socio-economic vulnerabilities and limited political influence. There is growing awareness that national adaptation strategies may not fully meet the needs of these vulnerable communities, leading to a focus on community-led adaptation. However, these approaches are in their infancy and have been criticised for fostering paternalistic tendencies, prompting calls for external institutions to facilitate rather than direct community initiatives. This research utilises Photovoice, a method recognised for its cultural relevance and ability to amplify Indigenous and marginalised voices. It involves 42 households in Fiji's Greater Suva Urban Area, using resident-led photography and interviews to explore community-based flood adaptation. Through ethnographic content analysis and inductive coding, the study captures residents’ experiences and strategies, identifying over 31 unique adaptation measures and underscoring the importance of resources, social networks, traditional knowledge, beliefs, and leadership in enhancing adaptive capacity. The findings demonstrate the complexity of factors influencing adaptation, with resource availability and social capital being crucial. The study advocates for adaptive processes that are community driven, calling for a shift in research and funding to support these programmes in a flexible, responsive, and inclusive manner. It also highlights the need to understand community dynamics to prevent paternalistic practices and integrate local insights effectively, ensuring community self-determination in adaptation efforts.
... According to Rahman and Alam (2016), non-formal and informal education channels-such as community workshops and media campaigns-are vital for broadening outreach and deepening public understanding. However, limited resources, linguistic diversity, and varying levels of literacy present significant hurdles (Ayers & Forsyth, 2009). Animation, which transcends linguistic barriers through visuals, stands as a promising medium to bridge these communication gaps. ...
... While the film foregrounds modern technological solutions-renewables and nuclear energy-it is comparatively silent about indigenous or traditional coping mechanisms that have historically helped Bangladeshi communities adapt to environmental challenges (Ayers & Forsyth, 2009). The film could have further enriched its narrative by showcasing local wisdom, such as water management techniques or climate-resilient agricultural practices. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Climate change has become one of the most critical global challenges of the twenty-first century, posing unprecedented risks to both present and future generations. Youth populations around the world are particularly vulnerable to the effects of climate change, yet they are also uniquely positioned to drive societal transformation. This research examines how animation can serve as an effective tool in educating and empowering young people regarding climate change. Focusing on the 2019 Bangladeshi animated short film Tomorrow, directed by Mohammad Shihab Uddin and produced by Kazi Media Limited, the study explores the film's capacity to engage youth audiences, illustrate complex environmental issues, and promote sustainable solutions. Through a qualitative case study approach, the research analyzes thematic elements, visual storytelling techniques, and educational strategies employed by Tomorrow to convey the urgency of the climate crisis and present viable pathways to mitigating it. Additionally, it situates the film within the broader context of Bangladesh's vulnerability to climate change, highlighting the importance of localized narratives in environmental communication. The findings underscore animation's potential to distill complexity, evoke emotional engagement, and shape young viewers' perceptions and behaviors toward climate action. This study concludes that animated media, exemplified by Tomorrow, can effectively raise awareness, foster climate literacy, and inspire collective accountability among youth, ultimately contributing to a more informed and proactive generation ready to address the climate challenge.
... This usually means that the local communities are involved in developing strategies by assessing the local risks and vulnerabilities as they possess the knowledge, networks and experience for the relevant initiatives; to increase resilience and minimise vulnerability to a range of conditions, including climate change (Ayers and Forsyth, 2009;Forsyth, 2013;Furgal and Seguin, 2006;Hadlos et al., 2022;Marshall et al., 2019;Nyangoko et al., 2022;Reid et al., 2009;Qomariah et al., 2021). ...
... Distinct from other community-based approaches, CBA heavily relies on external resources for knowledge, technology and finance (Rashid et al., 2013). It is a collaboration between a communities and their government; sometimes the stakeholdership also sometimes extends to NGO and other private sectors while addressing the complex and urgent issues (Adger et al., 2022;Ayers and Forsyth, 2009;Forsyth, 2013;Reid et al., 2009;Shaw, 2006;Qomariah et al., 2021). Vulnerable communities face limited capacity to invest in climate change adaptation, thus necessitating the need for external knowledge and technology along with their own; the final decision in accepting or rejecting these resources and knowledge should be inherent to the community (Rashid et al., 2013). ...
Thesis
Full-text available
Abstract This study examines the roles of Community-Based Adaptation (CBA) and Ecosystem-Based Adaptation (EbA) in addressing the challenges presented by climate change in coastal ecosystems and communities. Focusing on the specific contexts within Chennai City, the research offers insights into the relevance of varied degrees of adaptation strategies tailored to the vulnerabilities and strengths of different communities. By investigating the convergence and divergence of climate adaptation trends across different parts of the same metropolis, the research adds to the understanding of how adaptation strategies can be context-specific and community-driven. Additionally, the research underscores the significance of preserving cultural values and livelihoods during community rebuilding or post-disaster relocation, emphasising the necessity of holistic approaches that take into account the socio-economic and socio-environmental factors. To do so the study delves into the ecological landscape of the Pallikaranai Marsh and the community landscape of the Srinivasapuram Kuppam. Keywords: Climate Change, Climate Risk, Climate Adaptation, Climate Vulnerability, Resilience Building, Community-Based Adaptation (CBA), Ecosystem-Based Adaptation (EbA), Spatial Resilience, Ecological Memory, Land-Use Management, Land-Use Politics, Relocation, Coastal Commons, Community Resilience, Political Economy, Scalability, Cultural Knowledge Systems, Traditional Knowledge Systems.
... Furthermore, research is exploring the integration of climate goals and SDGs in specific sectors like renewable energy (Lal & Kumar, 2022), disaster risk reduction (UNISDR and UNDP, 2012), and coastal management (Paeniu et al., 2015). There is also growing recognition of the value of community-based approaches, drawing on local knowledge and traditional practices to achieve both climate resilience and sustainable development (Ayers & Forsyth, 2009;Nunn & Kumar, 2024). Regional organisations like the Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat (PIFS) and the Pacific Community (SPC) play a crucial role in supporting these efforts through technical assistance and knowledge sharing. ...
... Despite the Haor region's economic significance, its inhabitants live in poverty compared to those in other regions of Bangladesh. About 28% of Haor people live in poverty (LPL), according to Ayers and Forsyth [7].T1Hors are vital to the local ecology since they are home to a diverse array of flora and fauna, including migratory fish and bird species. They also provide neighbouring towns with essential resources, such as water for agriculture, fishing, and cattle. ...
Article
Full-text available
This review article examines the possibilities and difficulties that the Haor region in northeastern Bangladesh faces in order to look at its needs and problems. The report examines the challenges faced by specific sectors in the Haor regions in addition to outlining the various future development strategies implemented by different governmental and non governmental groups. The Haor areas’ agricultural output is limited by a number of issues, including flash floods, floods, and low winter temperatures. Converting the Haor regions from less productive to more productive land is a difficult task. The socioeconomic and biophysical features of Haors are examined in detail in this study emphasizes both the advantages and disadvantages of agricultural production. It looks on ways to significantly increase fish, cattle, and agricultural productivity in the Haor ecosystem in compliance with government directives. This article provides suggestions for ways to boost crop yields and cropping intensity as well as livestock and fish production in order to improve food security, alleviate poverty, and raise the standard of living for people living in Haor regions. The table included in the report also includes information on the Haor regions’ significance and prospects for growth.
... Community-Based Adaptation (CBA) Theory emphasizes the role of local knowledge, social capital, and agency in developing community-driven adaptation measures. Unlike top-down approaches, CBA advocates for engaging communities directly in planning and decision-making, allowing them to leverage indigenous knowledge for context-specific solutions (Ayers and Forsyth, 2009). This approach has been highly effective in areas with recurrent flooding, where community-driven projects like raised houses and flood barriers have minimized impacts. ...
Article
Full-text available
The Earth's climate is ever-evolving. The detected warming aligns with the anticipated impacts of greenhouse gases released by human activities. Seventy per cent of the global impoverished population resides in rural regions, and rural livelihoods are particularly susceptible to climate change. The effects of climate change on rural populations are detrimental. Nonetheless, certain effects may also be beneficial. This review highlights the strategies rural communities adopt to mitigate and adapt to changing environmental conditions, focusing on agricultural practices, water resource management, livelihood diversification, community resilience, and traditional knowledge. Rural communities rely on these adaptation strategies to cope with increasingly frequent extreme weather events, such as droughts, floods, and unpredictable rainfall patterns, which significantly affect agriculture and food security. The study examines how these adaptation responses are influenced by socioeconomic factors, government policies, and local capacities. Moreover, the study integrates Resilience Theory, CBA Theory, and SES Theory to examine adaptation. These theories emphasise absorbing shocks, leveraging local knowledge, and balancing human-ecological systems for sustainable resilience. By employing a mixed-methods approach, incorporating both qualitative and quantitative data collection, the study draws on case studies from various rural contexts to identify patterns and commonalities in adaptation strategies. Qualitative data from existing studies provide insights into community perceptions, local practices, and traditional knowledge. Meanwhile, quantitative data collected through surveys enable a broader assessment of adaptation practices and the extent of climate impacts. This approach allows for a nuanced understanding of the factors driving adaptive behaviour and the barriers faced by rural communities in achieving sustainable responses. The findings underscore the need for policies that integrate local knowledge and address specific vulnerabilities of rural areas. They also highlight the importance of community-based strategies in enhancing resilience and promoting sustainable development in the face of environmental change.
... CBA approach emerged as a participatory community based approach in reaching the most vulnerable but less rooted on conceptualizing the approach and guiding principles (Kirkby et al., 2017). However, Ayers and Forsyth (2009), have presented characteristics of CBA as: i) grounded in the local communities that are vulnerable to the impacts of climate change; ii) strengthens local people's capacity to adaptation by implementing community-based development activities; iii) participation of local stakeholders while designing adaptation strategies; and iv) builds on existing cultural norms and local capacity to address climate risks and vulnerabilities. Similarly, Dodman and Mitlin (2013), claim that CBA approaches are guided by basic principles such as bottom-up and participatory approach, strengthening local voice in decision making and local solutions to address climate risks and vulnerabilities. ...
... For instance, water user associations in rural India managing irrigation in a way that is both equitable and efficient. Community-based adaptation to climate change involves using strategies that communities develop based on their priorities, needs, knowledge, and capacities [13]. Often these strategies are rooted in traditional knowledge and practices but may be enhanced by external technologies or information. ...
Article
Adaptive strategies for enhancing climate resilience in agricultural extension services in India, amidst escalating climate challenges. It begins by delineating the profound impacts of altered weather patterns, increased frequency of extreme weather events, and shifting pest and disease dynamics on agricultural practices. The paper then delves into the variety of technological innovations, management practices, and policy interventions currently being implemented to bolster climate resilience. Notably, it highlights the adoption of precision agriculture technologies, climate-smart agricultural tools, and the innovative use of ICT in extension services to provide timely, targeted advice to farmers. On the management front, the paper discusses the significant benefits of crop diversification, advanced water management strategies like rainwater harvesting and drip irrigation, and improved soil health practices, which collectively contribute to a sustainable and resilient agricultural system. Policy and institutional adaptations are also examined, emphasizing the crucial role of supportive policy frameworks, community engagement, and multi-stakeholder partnerships in scaling successful adaptations and ensuring their sustainability. Drawing on international case studies-from Vietnam's effective water management techniques to Zambia's success with crop diversification and the technological advancements in North American agriculture-the review identifies key factors contributing to their success, challenges faced, and the potential for transferring these strategies to the Indian context. Each case study provides insights into overcoming barriers to adoption and highlights the importance of integrating local and scientific knowledge to achieve long-term sustainability. Concludes by stressing the need for a multi-faceted, inclusive approach that aligns with local environmental, cultural, and economic contexts to effectively address the unique challenges posed by climate change to Indian agriculture.
Preprint
Full-text available
The study examines the livelihood of the flood affected families in the Haor area of Netrokona district that is commonly recognized for being one of the most significant wetlands in the country. The study's general purpose is to know the livelihood dynamics of flooded families and the rehabilitation system in the Haor area of Bangladesh. This study used both qualitative and quantitative data. About 60 family heads were randomly selected from the two villages. The survey found four types of occupation as their income-generating activities during food and the main occupation was agriculture. The majority of them mentioned inadequate food was the main problem during the flood. Women and children, domestic animals and older people were the main victims of the flood in the Haor. This study found that women’s role during and after the flood are variegated like house care, food processing, agricultural and taking care of livestock etc. Haor people are poor, less educated and vulnerable. With their limited resources, they are trying to survive and contribute to the nation by crops production.
Article
Full-text available
While adaptation has, in the last 3 years, become the most fashionable item on the climate policy agenda, this was not always so. Since the early 1990s, numerous scientists and policy makers have been making the case that adaptation has been the overlooked cousin of greenhouse gas mitigation. As both are seen to be of equal importance, the lack of policy on adaptation is interpreted as a political strategy by developed countries to avoid admitting liability and the financial consequences of this admission. A tension between those in favour of mitigation over adaptation activities has strongly characterized the discourse on climate change policy. However, a closer look at the history of the concept of adaptation as applied in the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) process underscores the original intention that the treaty should focus on reducing the source of climate change, rather than on adapting to the changes. Adaptive capacity was considered to be an indicator of the extent to which societies could tolerate changes in climate, and was not seen as a policy objective. As a result of events that have unrolled since the inception of the UNFCCC, needs and perceptions have shifted. Today, there are strong grounds for having adaptation as a policy goal, but it must be recognized that the UNFCCC, and its Kyoto Protocol in particular, are first and foremost about abating greenhouse gas emissions. Thus, adaptation policy may find a more appropriate home beyond the existing climate change regime.
Article
Full-text available
The world’s climate is changing and will continue to change into the coming century at rates projected to be unprecedented in recent human history. The risks associated with these changes are real but highly uncertain. Societal vulnerability to the risks associated with climate change may exacerbate ongoing social and economic challenges, particularly for those parts of societies dependent on resources that are sensitive to changes in climate. Risks are apparent in agriculture, fisheries and many other components that constitute the livelihood of rural populations in developing countries. In this paper we explore the nature of risk and vulnerability in the context of climate change and review the evidence on present-day adaptation in developing countries and on coordinated international action on future adaptation. We argue that all societies are fundamentally adaptive and there are many situations in the past where societies have adapted to changes in climate and to similar risks. But some sectors are more sensitive and some groups in society more vulnerable to the risks posed by climate change than others. Yet all societies need to enhance their adaptive capacity to face both present and future climate change outside their experienced coping range. The challenges of climate change for development are in the present. Observed climate change, present-day climate variability and future expectations of change are changing the course of development strategies - development agencies and governments are now planning for this adaptation challenge. The primary challenge, therefore, posed at both the scale of local natural resource management and at the scale of international agreements and actions, is to promote adaptive capacity in the context of competing sustainable development objectives.
Article
Under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), adaptation has recently gained importance, yet adaptation is much less developed than mitigation as a policy response. Adaptation research has been used to help answer to related but distinct questions. (1) To what extent can adaptation reduce impacts of climate change? (2) What adaptation policies are needed, and how can they best be developed, applied and funded? For the first question, the emphasis is on the aggregate value of adaptation so that this may be used to estimate net impacts. An important purpose is to compare net impacts with the costs of mitigation. In the second question, the emphasis is on the design and prioritisation of adaptation policies and measures. While both types of research are conducted in a policy context, they differ in their character, application, and purpose. The impacts/mitigation research is orientated towards the physical and biological science of impacts and adaptation, while research on the ways and means of adaptation is focussed on the social and economic determinants of vulnerability in a development context. The main purpose of this paper is to demonstrate how the national adaptation studies carried under the UNFCCC are broadening the paradigm, from the impacts/mitigation to vulnerability/adaptation. For this to occur, new policy research is needed. While the broad new directions of both research and policy can now be discerned, there remain a number of outstanding issues to be considered.
Article
This paper reviews the concept of adaptation of human communities to global changes, especially climate change, in the context of adaptive capacity and vulnerability. It focuses on scholarship that contributes to practical implementation of adaptations at the community scale. In numerous social science fields, adaptations are considered as responses to risks associated with the interaction of environmental hazards and human vulnerability or adaptive capacity. In the climate change field, adaptation analyses have been undertaken for several distinct purposes. Impact assessments assume adaptations to estimate damages to longer term climate scenarios with and without adjustments. Evaluations of specified adaptation options aim to identify preferred measures. Vulnerability indices seek to provide relative vulnerability scores for countries, regions or communities. The main purpose of participatory vulnerability assessments is to identify adaptation strategies that are feasible and practical in communities. The distinctive features of adaptation analyses with this purpose are outlined, and common elements of this approach are described. Practical adaptation initiatives tend to focus on risks that are already problematic, climate is considered together with other environmental and social stresses, and adaptations are mostly integrated or mainstreamed into other resource management, disaster preparedness and sustainable development programs.
Article
Many who study global change, particularly from industrialized countries, are optimistic about the capacity of agriculture to successfully adapt to climate change. This optimism is based on historic trends in yield increases, on the spread of cropping systems far beyond their traditional agroecological boundaries, and the inherent flexibility of systems of international trade. Analysis of the success (or in rare cases, failure) of adaptation is by analogy—either to analogous socioeconomic or technological change or to short term environmental change. Such studies have been limited to industrialized countries. This paper uses five analogs from developing countries to examine potential adaptation to global climate change by poor people. Two are studies of comparative developing country responses to drought, flood, and tropical cyclone and to the Sahelian droughts of the 1970s and 80s that illustrate adaptations to climate and weather events:. Two address food production and rapid population growth in South Asia and Africa. Three types of adaptive social costs are considered: the direct costs of adaptation, the costs of adapting to the adaptations, and the costs of failing to adapt. A final analog reviews 30 village-level studies for the role that these social costs of adaptation play in perpetuating poverty and environmental degradation.