ArticlePDF Available

A Tool to Evaluate Different Renovation Alternatives with Regard to Sustainability

DOI:10.3390/su6074227
Authors:
Kristina Mjörnell at RISE Research Institutes of Sweden
Kristina Mjörnell
Anna Boss
Anna Boss
Anna Boss
  • This person is not on ResearchGate, or hasn't claimed this research yet.
Markus Lindahl at RISE Research Institutes of Sweden
Markus Lindahl
Stefan Molnar at RISE Research Institutes of Sweden & Chalmers University of Technology
Stefan Molnar
  • RISE Research Institutes of Sweden & Chalmers University of Technology
Download full-text PDFDownload full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract and Figures

In Sweden and in other countries, building owners are encouraged to help reduce energy consumption, both in order to contribute to national energy saving goals and, in terms of their own interests, to reduce the costs of heating and operation of the building. However, it is important to pursue the most optimal strategy available so as to achieve cost-effective energy usage while simultaneously maintaining excellent indoor environments, without sacrificing the architectural quality or negatively affecting the environment. Building managers often do not have the time or expertise required to make a proper evaluation of the available options before making a final decision. Renovation measures are often considered in the light of repaying investments in a short time rather than taking into account life cycle costs, despite the fact that a thoughtful, comprehensive renovation is often more cost-effective in the long run. This article presents a systematic approach for evaluating different renovation alternatives based on sustainability criteria. A methodology has been developed to evaluate different renovation alternatives from environmental, economic, and social perspectives. The benefit of using the proposed methodology is that building managers who face a major renovation work are provided with a clear comparison between the different renovation options, viewed from a sustainability perspective, this may facilitate, in the long run, a culture in which renovation measures which involve marginally increased costs, but are seen to lead to significant environmental and social benefits, will be considered and carried out.
Figures - uploaded by Kristina Mjörnell
Author content
All figure content in this area was uploaded by Kristina Mjörnell
Content may be subject to copyright.
577e5bd308aed39f59948b
18.pdf
Content uploaded by Kristina Mjörnell
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Kristina Mjörnell on Jul 07, 2016
Content may be subject to copyright.
A Tool to Evaluate Different Renovation Alternatives with Regard to Sustainabili
ty.pdf
Available via license: CC BY 4.0
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... As thermal renovation of buildings is not a new area of research, several methodologies and tools are available to evaluate the renovation potential of buildings. These tools are usually made for a quick estimation of renovation possibilities based on a few characteristics of the energy demand [6][7][8]. In such tools, the lack of details in the demand evaluation and building thermal characteristics lead to generic solutions. ...
View
... Renovation in the construction industry is considered to be the primary area for achieving the goals set by the EU regarding energy and material resource savings, CO 2 emission reduction, increasing the renewable energy share, and improving social sustainability issues [95][96][97][98][99][100][101]. ...
AHP-Based Model for Energy-Sustainable Renovation of Building Envelopes: A Case Study
Article
Full-text available
  • May 2023
The EU’s low carbon transition relies on the building sector as one of its main pillars, given that around 85% of the 160 million buildings within the EU are thermally inefficient. The energy-sustainable renovation of building envelopes calls for a comprehensive approach from initial design phases to construction, while balancing a series of factors, e.g., function and aesthetics, energy savings and environmental concerns, as well as cost-effectiveness. This article develops a model for the energy-sustainable renovation of building envelopes based on a multi-criteria analysis method—the AHP method. The model facilitates problem solving and development of alternative designs. The AHP method is used for evaluating and narrowing down design variants considering the given building conditions and the adopted set of criteria. The developed model is also applied in a real case study—the envelope energy renovation of a typical residential building built after the 1950s in many suburbs of Belgrade, Serbia. The model developed in the paper may be used by professionals to facilitate and make more efficient the design process of the energy-sustainable renovation of buildings and can inspire further studies on this topic, which has grown in urgency amid the current global energy crisis.
View
... A review of related research reveals that recent studies promote sustainability in the various areas of the built environment: in residential buildings, rural communities [14], schools [15], and other building uses. These studies lead to the readjustment of action strategies based on several alternatives, which are valued and weighted from the sustainability of resources, expenses, and user satisfaction, as stated by Mjörnell et al. [16]. However, it is necessary to carry out research studies that are specifically adapted to the socio-economic circumstances that vulnerable neighbourhoods present in order to be able to employ integrated urban renovation, which is especially needed in developing countries, as argued in the study by Mercader-Moyano et al. [17]. ...
A Study on the Parametric Design Parameters That Influence Environmental Ergonomics and Sustainability
Article
Full-text available
  • Apr 2023
The parametric design applied to the built environment is critical to creating sustainable and resilient spaces. However, this research field involves a vast and complex amount of disconnected information. Therefore, this paper aims to analyse research trends in applying parametric design to optimise sustainability and environmental ergonomics parameters in built environments. The following specific objectives are identified to meet this objective: (i) a quantitative analysis based on a systematic literature review; (ii) a qualitative review based on a performance analysis and scientific mapping; and (iii) a comparative analysis of case studies applying parametric language for the optimisation of sustainability and environmental ergonomics parameters. The 1045 research records covering 1974 to 2021 illustrate a field in development that evolves from early digital advances to climate change adaptations, the circular economy and resilience. It highlights the importance of applying bioclimatic techniques in the built environment, identifying the most optimised measures and encouraging the creation of guidelines to serve as a protocol for future studies, contributing to the existing body of knowledge by highlighting trends, establishing research themes, outlining research networks and suggesting areas for further studies.
View
... A review of related research reveals that recent studies promote sustainability in the various areas of the built environment: in residential buildings, rural communities [14], schools [15], and other building uses. These studies lead to the readjustment of action strategies based on several alternatives, which are valued and weighted from the sustainability of resources, expenses, and user satisfaction, as stated by Mjörnell et al. [16]. However, it is necessary to carry out research studies that are specifically adapted to the socio-economic circumstances that vulnerable neighbourhoods present in order to be able to employ integrated urban renovation, which is especially needed in developing countries, as argued in the study by Mercader-Moyano et al. [17]. ...
Promoting Sustainable and Resilient Constructive Patterns in Vulnerable Communities: Habitat for Humanity’s Sustainable Housing Prototypes in El Salvador
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2022
The global challenges regarding sustainability and the guarantee of minimum habitability requirements have led to the transformation of construction practices, where research has failed to achieve sufficient dissemination and findings. The purpose of this research is to promote sustainable and resilient patterns in construction in vulnerable neighbourhoods in emerging countries by disseminating techniques and mechanisms through in situ transfer workshops and by raising awareness of the environmental importance of construction. Regarding materials and methods, this paper contributes innovative insights by combining training workshops and awareness-raising sessions to promote both environmental education and sustainable and optimised habits in construction. These methods are applied and tested in a real case study in El Salvador. Subsequent to carrying out a multi-disciplinary assessment analysis, the outcomes and results have led to the design of prototypes that have obtained a global EDGE certificate on sustainable construction and efficient use of resources once the users’ testimonies, weaknesses, and strengths have been addressed. The conclusions indicate that families, volunteers, and technical workers need to be trained by promoting environmental awareness in social housing and establishing a plan for dissemination to communicate across universities and public and private institutions in order to replicate guidelines across American dry-corridor countries.
View
... Recent renovation literature displays a diverse picture of interdisciplinary nature for the residential renovation processes. Some studies point to renovation as a decision-making process (Haines et al. 2014;Mjörnell et al. 2014;Abreu et al. 2017;Wilson et al. 2013), others as a socio-technical transition Willand et al. 2019;Killip et al. 2014;Kerr 2018), as cultural expression (Rosenberg 2011;Head et al. 2016) or as social practice embedded in everyday homemaking, to which this chapter contributes (Maller and Horne 2011;Maller et al. 2012;Bartiaux et al. 2014;Gram-Hanssen 2014a, b;Judson and Maller 2014;Abreu et al. 2017;Hulse and Milne 2019). People renovate their homes to respond to complex issues which include emotional, practical, technical and socio-cultural matters (Podkalicka and Milne 2017). ...
Overcoming Abstraction: Affectual States in the Efforts to Decarbonize Energy Among Young Climate Activists in Stavanger, Norway
Chapter
Full-text available
  • Dec 2022
Sørensen engages ethnographically with energy transitions towards a low-carbon future as experienced by young climate activists in Norway’s oil-capital Stavanger. By relating the activists’ sense of climate change as abstract to climate change’s manifestation in digital data models as a phenomenon taking place in no specific location and mainly in the future (Knox. 2021. “Hacking Anthropology”. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 27.S1 (2021): 108–126), the chapter shows that the activists work to overcome abstractions by focusing on the local and contemporary through examples that come from the Global North and provide visceral, embodied effects. The young activists’ concretizing practices, Sørensen argues, result in affective states that render concreteness as something desirable and abstraction as something undesirable to be overcome, but also that in an oil-city, there is a limit to the desirability of concreteness.
View
... Recent renovation literature displays a diverse picture of interdisciplinary nature for the residential renovation processes. Some studies point to renovation as a decision-making process (Haines et al. 2014;Mjörnell et al. 2014;Abreu et al. 2017;Wilson et al. 2013), others as a socio-technical transition Willand et al. 2019;Killip et al. 2014;Kerr 2018), as cultural expression (Rosenberg 2011;Head et al. 2016) or as social practice embedded in everyday homemaking, to which this chapter contributes (Maller and Horne 2011;Maller et al. 2012;Bartiaux et al. 2014;Gram-Hanssen 2014a, b;Judson and Maller 2014;Abreu et al. 2017;Hulse and Milne 2019). People renovate their homes to respond to complex issues which include emotional, practical, technical and socio-cultural matters (Podkalicka and Milne 2017). ...
A New Reflexive Turn: Glitches, Carbon Footprints, and Streaming Videos in Visual Anthropology
Chapter
Full-text available
  • Dec 2022
The global climate crisis demands an ethical account for the environmental costs of anthropology. Anthropologists who trouble the boundaries between art and anthropology often ignore the damage done by their mediums. Digital streaming accounts for one percent of global emissions. The increasing reliance on a nearly invisible media provokes a new reflexive turn. This chapter outlines reflexive media in anthropology and beyond. Following the call for ‘patchwork ethnography’ where ethnographers conduct slow fieldwork, glitchy visual anthropology can also decolonize the energy-consuming, anthropologist filmmaker as hero. There are multiple opportunities for visual anthropologists to conduct ethnographies of a new reflexive media—an anthropology that is not anti-aesthetic. Such a reflexive turn explores eco-conscious streaming as part and parcel of ethnographic art, method, and outcome.
View
Alignment of the life cycle initiative’s “principles for the application of life cycle sustainability assessment” with the LCSA practice: A case study review
Article
Full-text available
Purpose This paper aims at assessing the alignment of eight of the Life Cycle Initiative’s ten principles for life cycle sustainability assessment (LCSA) and the LCSA practice as well as the challenges to reaching the full implementation of the principles as a basis for a harmonized framework. Materials and methods To understand the extent of alignment of existing LCSA studies with the principles, 193 case studies published before the Life Cycle Initiative’s ten principles’ publication were identified. Their levels of alignment were assessed against the criteria designed per principle: full, medium, or no alignment. The principles of “materiality of the system boundaries” and “consistency” could not be assessed as most studies lacked related background information; hence, no objective nor systematic criteria could be designed. Results The alignment of practice with the principles is variable: The vast majority of studies cover the 3 pillars (principle 3 on completeness). Principle 9 (communication of trade-offs) is well addressed in the case studies. Principles 2 (alignment with the phases of ISO 14040: 2006 standard), 4 (taking into account perspectives of key stakeholders), and 8 (transparency) were not properly addressed in a majority of case studies. Principles 1 (understanding the areas of protection and impact pathways), 5 (taking into account product utility beyond functional unit (co-benefits)), and 10 (caution when compensating negative and positive impacts) remain to be implemented as some methodological challenges have to be overcome. Principles 6 and 7 were not assessed. Conclusions LCSA is gaining momentum due to the communication and dissemination of LCSA among practitioners, potential users, and decision-makers in the public and private sectors. However, some key challenges remain for reaching the implementation of the principles: understanding of the inter-relationships between the three dimensions of sustainability to build impact pathways and select relevant impact categories for LCSA, guidance for communicating trade-offs and decision-making based on LCSA, and generalizing the (open) access to publications and related supplementary information.
View
Understanding the mechanisms linking holistic housing renovations to health and well-being of adults in disadvantaged neighbourhoods: A realist review
Article
  • Mar 2023
Holistic housing renovations combine physical housing improvements with social and socioeconomic interventions (e.g. referral to social services, debt counselling, involvement in decision-making, promoting social cohesion). This realist review aimed at understanding underlying mechanisms linking holistic housing renovations to health and well-being of adults in disadvantaged neighbourhoods. Following systematic and iterative searching, and relevance and quality appraisals, 18 scientific articles and reports were analysed. We identified three pathways via which physical housing improvements affect health, four pathways via which social and socioeconomic interventions affect health, and two pathways via which both reinforce each other in their health effects. Our findings are theoretically novel, relevant for those conducting holistic housing renovations, and point towards gaps in the literature.
View
Achieving Efficient Sustainable Retrofitting of Facades in Office Buildings: A Literature Review
Conference Paper
  • Mar 2023
Buildings consume approximately half of energy consumption. About 99% of them are already built as the new construction only adds annually from 1% to 3% to the existing stock. So, retrofitting existing buildings became a necessary shifting focus with different measures from common to deep. This paper aimed at introducing a comprehensive overview of the sustainable retrofitting concept, especially in the facades of office buildings. It offered an introductory review of retrofitting as a concept, its measures, and main challenges such as decision-making process of the optimal solution. Literature discussing developing methodologies seeking perfection in decision-making was reviewed. Also, literature discussing frameworks and office buildings retrofitting was categorized and analysed in tables. 62 research were collected and analysed. The findings of the paper were helping in understanding the potential of existing buildings by developing a proposed framework to be incorporated into an office facade retrofitting plan for achieving efficient sustainability.
View
Ferramenta ACV aplicada em retrofit de edificações: uma revisão sistemática
Conference Paper
  • Nov 2022
O processo de retrofit de edificações pode ser uma opção sustentável para o reaproveitamento de edificações e a mitigação de impactos ambientais. O objetivo do estudo é realizar uma revisão sistemática de literatura sobre o tema de ACV aplicada em retrofit, buscando analisar as contribuições e os métodos considerados. O estudo parte de 27 artigos publicados em periódicos internacionais, estruturados como estudos de caso e revisões sistemáticas. Nota-se que o retrofit de edificações oportuniza o aproveitamento de edificações existentes, a implementação de estratégias sustentáveis e, também, o desenvolvimento de mais estudos no âmbito científico nacional.
View
Guidelines for Social Life Cycle Assessment of Products
Book
Full-text available
  • Jan 2009
Behind the life cycle of a product, from the cradle to the grave, there is a story to tell. Not only about its potential impact on the environment, but as well in terms of social and socio-economic impacts - or potential impacts - of its production and consumption on the workers, the local communities, the consumers, the society and all value chain actors. Today’s value chains are often complex, global and because of it, faceless. Shedding light on the human relationships impacted by the life cycle of goods and services helps to re-establish the connection and identify ways in which social conditions can be improved. Therefore, there is a need for guidelines to complement Environmental Life Cycle Assessment (E-LCA) and Life Cycle Costing (LCC), and by doing so contributing to the full assessment of goods and services within the context of sustainable development. These Guidelines present the Social and socio-economic Life Cycle Assessment (S-LCA), a powerful technique to assess and report about these impacts and benefits of product life cycle from the extraction of the natural resources to the final disposal. It provides an adequate technical framework from which a larger group of stakeholders can engage to move towards social responsibility when assessing the life cycle of goods and services.
View
Unveiling the Process of Sustainable Renovation
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2012
Abstract: Renovation processes are complex and there is a risk of underestimating architectural, cultural, and social values in favor of exterior and interior upgrading, energy efficiency and financing. A synthesized, systematic process is needed for making decisions about renovation measures. The aim of this paper is to survey decision-making procedures aimed for sustainable renovation. We inventory existing tools and methodologies based on (a) a literature review and (b) results from a workshop with participants from the Swedish buildings sector, academia, and other stakeholders. Our results show that there are many tools available but few seem to have reached acceptance in renovation. None of the more established methods and tools addresses a complexity that balances material and immaterial values and they are often too specific. There is a need for simplified tools, especially for evaluating more intangible, experienced values. Instead of one comprehensive tool preferably a methodology for renovation should be developed with references to different tools. In the building sector, renovation should be considered a service-minded process rather than a merely technical one as often is the case in new construction. There is a need to clarify the process and the meaning of the terms, and that need is even more urgent when it comes to the values that are more difficult to define. Keywords: building assessment; tools and methodologies; decision-making support; sustainable renovation
View
Multidimensional Pareto optimization as an approach for site-specific building refurbishment solutions applicable for life cycle sustainability assessment
Article
Full-text available
  • Nov 2013
Purpose This paper addresses the application and potential of LCSA in the built environment with a focus on refurbishments of residential buildings. It specifically addresses the phenomenon of interchange of building technologies efficiencies under different life time assessments from economy, ecology and social fields. An approach of optimization rather than hard target numbers is proposed as win–win–win situations are unlikely. Methods A multidimensional Pareto optimization methodology, using LCC, LCA combined with first stages of a social assessment in a feasibility study but potentially later full SLCA, is proposed, which site-specifically visualizes the interchange between different options in building design or modification, and evaluates optimal overall concepts. LCA and LCC are used to analyze a case study from an EU project named BEEM-UP in which solutions for large-scale uptake of refurbishment strategies are developed. Social frame conditions are taken into account by identifying the driving technologies and feeding the consequences of their implementation for the residents into the tenant involvement part of the project. Results and discussion The calculations prove that the general assumptions leading to the methodology hold true at least for this case study. A clear Pareto-optimal curve is visible when assessing LCC and LCA. The example buildings results show certain systems to be dominating clusters on the figures while others clearly can be identified as not relevant. Several of the driving technologies however fail to be applicable because of social frame conditions, e.g., clear requests by the tenants. Based on the conclusions, the potential for including SLCA as a third dimension in the methodology and possible visualization options are discussed. Conclusions The development in the field of social indicators in the building sector has to be strengthened in order to come up with a holistic picture and respectively with appropriate responses to current challenges. While some solutions identified in the LCC/LCA assessment also have good social characteristics, several others have not and solutions identified as lacking might have social advantages that are currently left out of consideration The upcoming Standards EN 15643-5 and ISO 15686-x are a promising step in this direction as is the work to create a conceptual framework for impact assessment within SLCA by the scientific community.
View
A Framework for Social Life Cycle Impact Assessment (10 pp)
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 2006
Goal, Scope and Background To enhance the use of life cycle assessment (LCA) as a tool in business decision-making, a methodology for Social life cycle impact assessment (LCIA) is being developed. Social LCA aims at facilitating companies to conduct business in a socially responsible manner by providing information about the potential social impacts on people caused by the activities in the life cycle of their product. The development of the methodology has been guided by a business perspective accepting that companies, on the one hand, have responsibility for the people affected by their business activities, but, on the other hand, must also be able to compete and make profit in order to survive in the marketplace. Methods A combined, bottom-up and top-down approach has been taken in the development of the Social LCIA. Universal consensus documents regarding social issues as well as consideration for the specific business context of companies has guided the determination of damage categories, impact categories and category indicators. Results Discussion, and Conclusion. The main results are the following: (1) Impacts on people are naturally related to the conduct of the companies engaged in the life cycle rather than to the individual industrial processes, as is the case in Environmental LCA. Inventory analysis is therefore focused on the conduct of the companies engaged in the life cycle. A consequence of this view is that a key must be determined for relating the social profiles of the companies along the life cycle to the product. This need is not present in Environmental LCA, where we base the connection on the physical link which exists between process and product. (2) Boundaries of the product system are determined with respect to the influence that the product manufacturer exerts over the activities in the product chain. (3) A two-layer Social LCA method with an optional and an obligatory set of impact categories is suggested to ensure both societal and company relevance of the method. The obligatory set of impact categories encompasses the minimum expectations to a company conducting responsible business. (4) A new area of protection, Human dignity and Well-being, is defined and used to guide the modelling of impact chains. (5) The Universal Declaration of Human Rights serves as normative basis for Social LCA, together with local or country norms based on socio-economic development goals of individual countries. The International Labour Organisation's Conventions and Recommendations, and the Tripartite Declaration of Principles concerning Multinational Enterprises and Social Policy, support development of the impact pathway top-down, starting from the normative basis. (6) The obligatory part of Social LCA addresses the main stakeholder groups, employees, local community and society. Recommendations and Outlook Social LCA is still in its infancy and a number of further research tasks within this new area are identified.
View
Categorising Tools for Sustainable Assessment
Article
Full-text available
The aim of this paper is to provide a categorisation of sustainability assessment tools within the broader objective of lifting the understanding of sustainability assessment from the environmental-focused realm to a wider interpretation of sustainability. The suggested framework is based on three main categories: indicators/indices, product-related assessment, and integrated assessment tools. There is furthermore the overarching category of monetary valuation tools that can be used as a part of many of the tools listed in the three categories. The tools are also divided by their spatial focus and the level of nature–society system integration. Discussion focuses on if and how the tools fulfil the objectives from the more current understanding of sustainability assessment.
View
Evaluation of renovation measures for improving the energy performance of external walls in apartment built 1961-75
Conference Paper
  • May 2012
In this work energy improving renovation solutions for exterior walls in a common Swedish multifamily house type from 1961-75 are studied. The solutions have been evaluated in terms of energy savings during a certain time of operation, moisture safety, thermal comfort and life cycle costs. The results show that these renovations can become so costly that they won’t be performed. The question is under what circumstances such measures are feasible to perform. Additional insulation is necessary in order to reach high energy efficiency. The so far gained results indicate that internal insulation is problematic both due to economy and to moisture safety. External insulation is advisable in certain cases but not in others, mainly for economic reasons but also for cultural heritage reasons. Improved air tightness of the building envelope is important for decreasing the heat losses and improving the indoor comfort (less draught). However, the importance depends on the type of ventilation system and ambition for energy and indoor comfort improvements.
View
The social return on investment in the energy efficiency of buildings in Germany
Article
The German government has developed a variety of policy instruments intended to reduce national CO2 emissions. These instruments include a programme administered by KfW bank, which aims at improving the energy efficiency of buildings. It provides attractive credit conditions or subsidies to finance refurbishment measures which improve the energy efficiency of buildings significantly.The refurbishment programme leads to a reduction in energy use, which benefits private investors by reducing their energy bills. In order to estimate whether the programme benefits society as a whole, additional effects must be taken into account, such as the amount of employment generated and the impact on the public budget.The aim of this paper is to evaluate the social benefits of the German CO2 refurbishment programme for the years 2005–2007. An extended input–output model is used to estimate the effect of the refurbishment works on public revenue via taxes and social security contributions. The value of avoided CO2 emissions is approximated using a range of marginal damage estimates from the literature. From these social benefits, the programme cost is deducted. The net social benefit thus computed turns out to be positive. This finding suggests that the refurbishment programme is a reasonable investment of public funds.
View
View
Varför genomförs inte lönsamma energieffektiva investeringar? - En studie av beslutsfaktorerna vid investeringar inom fastighetsbranschen.
Article
Problem: Why are not existing energy efficient techniques utilized? Which aspects influence the decision? Is the decision-making-process in need of a complementary tool for energy efficiency-profitability calculating? Purpose: The primary purpose of this report is to examine the critical elements of the decisions making process concerning energy efficient investments. The secondary purpose of this report is to present a complementary tool for energy efficiency profitability calculating. The tool is to be used as a complementary instrument when evaluating the economical effects of an energy efficient investment. Methods: The method of the report has been to through an abductive approach. Data has been collected through qualitative literature-studies and interviews with people within the ÅF Group, property owners, housing cooperatives and consultants within the industry. Conclusions: The critical elements within the decisions making process for energy efficient investments are: the structure of ownership, split incentives, information asymmetry, lack of economical knowledge and incomplete information from the Energy Declaration of Buildings. A complementary tool, that can be used to motivate energy efficient investments, has been developed. The model takes lifecycle-costs figures, cash flow, and payback-period into consideration, and provides information on how to understand and evaluate financial key data. The tool also prevents information asymmetry between the energy consultant and the customer. The tool further illustrates how the cash flow from profitable investments can be used in order to finance future required investments with an initially negative cash flow. Finally, it helps to create a positive energy attitude towards the user.
View
The Discipline of Cost–Benefit Analysis
Article
  • Feb 2000
Cost-benefit analysis is a general discipline, based on the use of some foundational principles, which are not altogether controversial, but have nevertheless considered plausibility. Divisiveness increases as various additional requirements are imposed. There is a trade-off here between easier usability (through locked-up formulae) and more general acceptability (through allowing parametric variations). The paper examines and scrutinizes the merits and demerits of these additional requirements. The particular variant of cost-benefit approach that is most commonly used now is, in fact, extraordinarily limited, because of its insistence on doing the valuation entirely through an analogy with the market mechanism. This admits only a narrow class of values, and demands that individuals be unconcerned about many substantial variations, ignored in the procedure of market valuation. The use, instead, of a general social choice approach can allow greater freedom of valuation and can also accommodate more informational inputs. Copyright 2000 by the University of Chicago.
View