Conference PaperPDF Available

Virtual Reality and Mobius Floe: Cognitive Distraction as Non-Pharmacological Analgesic for Pain Management

Authors:
  • DeepStream VR

Abstract and Figures

This paper outlines the intentions and current design behind the production of Mobius Floe, an immersive virtual reality game catered to acute and chronic pain patients. Researchers have shown that immersive virtual reality (VR) can serve as a non-pharmacological analgesic by inducing cognitive distraction in acute pain patients [Hoffman 2000]. Mobius Floe experiments with virtual reality as well as auditory immersion, a more experimental approach to cognitive distraction for pain relief; the results will be tested by acute as well as chronic pain patients to determine if chronic sufferers can benefit from similar VR practices as their acute counterparts. Mobius Floe’s game design is informed by contemporary game design theory and cognitive psychology in order to improve its distractive properties.
Content may be subject to copyright.
8
Virtual Reality and Mobius Floe: Cognitive Distraction as
Non-Pharmacological Analgesic for Pain Management
Amber Choo1, Xin Tong1, Diane Gromala1 and Ari Hollander2
1School of Interactive Arts and Technology, Simon Fraser University, Surrey, B.C, Canada
{achoo, tongxint, dgromala}@sfu.ca
2Firsthand Technology Inc., Seattle, W.A, USA
ari@firsthand.com
Abstract. This paper outlines the intentions and current design behind the pro-
duction of Mobius Floe, an immersive virtual reality game catered to acute and
chronic pain patients. Researchers have shown that immersive virtual reality
(VR) can serve as a non-pharmacological analgesic by inducing cognitive dis-
traction in acute pain patients [Hoffman 2000]. Mobius Floe experiments with
virtual reality as well as auditory immersion, a more experimental approach to
cognitive distraction for pain relief; the results will be tested by acute as well as
chronic pain patients to determine if chronic sufferers can benefit from similar
VR practices as their acute counterparts. Mobius Floe’s game design is in-
formed by contemporary game design theory and cognitive psychology in order
to improve its distractive properties.
Keywords. Chronic pain, acute pain, pain management, serious game design,
health games, analgesia, virtual reality, cognitive load
1 Introduction
Virtual reality (VR) applications have yet to become a widely accepted complemen-
tary method to analgesics to reduce the perception of pain despite documented instances
of its success. SnowWorld, a VR game with accompanying head mounted display
(HMD) has demonstrated that VR treatments can work in tandem with pain medications
to further reduce perceived instances of pain in patients with combat-related burn inju-
ries [8]. Virtual reality has also been used to help combat other types of discomfort such
as acute pain from dental procedures [6]. There is already evidence to suggest that
chronic pain patients can benefit from immersive virtual reality applications [10].
Chronic pain patients, although requiring long-term pain reduction strategies, also suf-
fer from shorter-term spikes in pain intensity [1] of which they may also benefit from
non-pharmacological treatment practices suiting acute pain patients. Mobius Floe, the
immersive VR discussed in this paper aims to expand upon non-pharmacological anal-
gesic research for acute and chronic pain patients by improving the quality and varia-
bility of the distractive gameplay of its predecessors while introducing new forms of
gameplay to examine, evaluate and compare to the field. Tasks involving cognitive
B. Schouten et al. (Eds.), Games for Health 2014,
DOI 10.1007/978-3-658-07141-7_2, © Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden 2014
Virtual Reality and Mobius Floe
9
distraction and heightened cognitive load are discussed for usage in Mobius Floe in
order to attract and maintain the attention of pain patients.
2 Related Work
Virtual reality treatments for the reduction of acute pain have seen promising results
in multiple studies. A VR titled SnowWorld, which draws patient’s attention away from
their embodied experience of pain and toward the virtual 3D environment was used to
curb the wound care pain of U.S. soldiers injured with significant burns at the U.S.
Army Institute of Surgical Research (USAISR). SnowWorld featured a snowy land-
scape where the patient could throw snowballs and be hit by snowballs in the virtual
space. This experience combined with analgesic medications served to improve the sol-
dier’s pain experiences in regards to “time spent thinking about pain” and experienced
“pain unpleasantness”, both of which declined significantly with the introduction of
VR to their standard wound care routine [8].
Hoffman et al. reported significantly reduced levels of pain in dental patients under-
going scaling and root planing in those who were immersed in cognitive distraction via
a virtual reality simulation over patients who were asked to watch a movie and those
who had no distraction present during their procedures [6]. Their results imply that
immersive virtual reality applications may serve as an effective non-pharmacologic
analgesic which could to be used in tandem with existing prescribed pain medications
for dental pain; this conclusion by extension may also be applicable to other pain demo-
graphics, especially considering the surrounding literature. For example, in a random-
ized control trial study by Das et al., a virtual reality game was added to the proce-
dural care schedule of children with acute burn injuries. The introduction of VR to
their normally prescribed pharmacological analgesics decreased the average of the
children’s self-reported Faces Scale pain ratings from 4.1 (SD 2.9) to 1.3 (SD 1.8) [3].
The introduction of meaningful game design strategies can improve the gameplay
of Mobius Floe to become more engaging than its previous counterparts, improving
the quality of patient immersion. The examination of the potency of effects such as
Csikszentmihalyi’s ‘flow’ are important to maintaining virtual immersion, for flow
“can be positively associated with degrees of the cognitive phenomenon of immersion
and telepresence” [4]. SnowWorld has some degree of flow and is discussed widely in
virtual reality literature. However, there is no perceivable consequence to inaction in
SnowWorld when clear reactions from the game world in response to the player are
necessary to create a more engaging design [2]. The SnowWorld patients also had
minimal player agency in regards to their potential actions in the space, which is un-
usual considering player agency is an extremely useful tool for user engagement [9].
Mobius Floe aims to learn from and improve upon previous attempts such as Snow-
World by extending the software’s ability to become immersive and cognitively dis-
tract in a more reliable fashion.
Mobius Floe also incorporates techniques from the cognitive sciences by introducing
n-back tasks, attentional switching and dual-task paradigms which work in tandem to
invoke strong immersion, cognitive load, continuous action and heighten arousal
Choo · Tong · Gromala · Hollander
10
[5][11]. Patients are rewarded with ‘health packs’ to increase their player’s health
points (HP) when memorizing short visual patterns within the Mobius Floe space,
recalling them later using a throwing mechanic to interact with the correct sequence
of colors. Attentional switching and dual-task paradigm examples are discussed in the
following section.
3 Virtual Reality Design and Development for Mobius Floe
Mobius Floe is currently being constructed in the Unity game engine and sports vari-
ous distraction-based gameplay strategies in different areas of the virtual space. It can
be played with the Oculus Rift head-mounted display (HMD) or a stereoscopic HMD
provided by Firsthand Technologies, which sits in front of the eyes without touching
the patient; the intent of using this hardware is to provide greater depth of cognitive
immersion.
Mobius Floe appears as a sprawling snowy landscape, and the player is automatically
moved forward through the space. The patient can look around the virtual space using
the Oculus Rift or with a mouse as they are brought to their next destination.
The patient quickly finds themselves under threat from monsters which appear to be
half neuron, half tree (see Fig. 1). These ‘neuron trees’ have menacing expressions and
require sedation to escape from successfully. They chase the player and will damage
their Health Points (HP) on contact. The neuron trees represent the neurological sys-
tems in the human body which are causing the pain experience; patients are able to calm
them down by throwing abstracted particle systems representing analgesics with the
left mouse button. The neuron trees serve as a key mode of cognitive distraction as they
coerce the player into taking defensive actions against them in a strategic and time sen-
sitive manner. Overuse of drugs against the neuron trees results in negative conse-
quences, some of which manifest as detrimental behaviors in the neuron trees, while
others affect the visual rendering of the virtual space in a negative fashion. For example,
Fig. 1. A production still of Mobius Floe which shows an idling neuron tree.
Virtual Reality and Mobius Floe
11
overuse of morphine slows the neuron trees down considerably, but they become
more aggressive once the effect wears off.
Sea otters also wander the virtual space and are able to interact with the patient
(Fig. 2). They are friendly entities always approaching the player on sight, serving as
metaphors for the patient’s friends and family. Sea otters wag their tails and smile up at
the patient when nearby. The patient can toss sea urchins at the otters in the same way
they toss analgesics to the neuron trees. Otters who receive sea urchins will drop health
packs for the player.
Occasionally the n-back tasks discussed in the previous section, sea otters and neu-
ron trees will be in the proximity of the player at the same time, encouraging attentional
switching and dual-task paradigms. The player must switch their attention between the
neuron trees’ location, the n-back task memorization, their health points, and the otters,
fully engaging their cognitive load. For example, the player may find themselves fend-
ing off neuron trees, trying to memorize the n-back task hint and trying to feed the otters
simultaneously.
4 Future Work
The retention of pain experience metaphors and how they translate to new patients
would help distinguish Mobius Floe from ordinary games. For example, do the helpful
sea otters naturally correlate to feelings of comfort, friends or family? How does the
health point mechanic translate to patient’s experiences? Do the depictions of drugs and
how they operate in the virtual space realistically represent pain patient’s affective ex-
periences? We will conduct several case studies with patients from Greater Vancouver
to help evaluate the existing pain experience metaphors as well as the effectiveness of
cognitive distraction and perceived pain reduction within Mobius Floe. To do so will
help situate the position of Mobius Floe within the research field and provide further
context as to where the development of Mobius Floe should gravitate toward.
Fig. 2. Two otters greeting the player. ‘HP’ is visually represented as a red icicle in the top left.
Choo · Tong · Gromala · Hollander
12
5 References
[1] Baliki, Marwan et al. “Chronic Pain and the Emotional Brain: Specific Brain
Activity Associated with Spontaneous Fluctuations of Intensity of Chronic Back
Pain.” The Journal of Neuroscience 26.47 (2006): 12165–12173.
[2] Church, Doug. “Formal Abstract Design Tools.” Game Developer 6.8 (1999):
44.
[3] Das, Debashish et al. “The Efficacy of Playing a Virtual Reality Game in Mod-
ulating Pain for Children with Acute Burn Injuries: A Randomized Controlled
Trial.” BMC Pediatrics 5.1 (2005): n. pag.
[4] Faiola, Anthony et al. “Correlating the Effects of Flow and Telepresence in Vir-
tual Worlds: Enhancing Our Understanding of User Behavior in Game-Based
Learning.” Computers in Human Behavior 29.3 (2003): 1113–1121.
[5] Herff, Christian et al. “Mental Workload during N-Back Task—quantified in
the Prefrontal Cortex Using fNIRS.” Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 7
(2013): 935.
[6] Hoffman, Hunter et al. “The Effectiveness of Virtual Reality for Dental Pain
Control: A Case Study.” Cyberpsychology & Behavior 4.4 (2001): 527–535.
[7] Hoffman, Hunter, David Patterson, and Gretchen Carrougher. “Use of Virtual
Reality for Adjunctive Treatment of Adult Burn Pain During Physical Therapy:
A Controlled Study.” The Clinical Journal of Pain 16.3 (2000): 244–250.
[8] Maani, Christopher et al. “Pain Control During Wound Care for Combat-Re-
lated Burn Injuries Using Custom Articulated Arm Mounted Virtual Reality
Goggles.” Journal of CyberTherapy & Rehabilitation 1.2 (2008): 193–198.
[9] Schubert, Damion. “Narrative and Player Agency.” Game Developer 18.2
(2011): 58.
[10] Shahrbanian, Shahnaz et al. “Scientific Evidence for the Effectiveness of Virtual
Reality for Pain Reduction in Adults with Acute or Chronic Pain.” 7 (2009):
40–43.
[11] Wickens, Christopher. “Multiple Resources and Performance Prediction.” The-
oretical Issues in Ergonomics Science 3.2 (2002): 159–177.
... Nejčastěji se k těmto účelům využívá aplikace SnowWorld z roku 2001 (University of Washington Seattle & U.W. Harborview burn center, n.d.), která je však z dnešního pohledu zastaralá, a proto nenavozuje žádoucí imerzivitu. Proto vznikly také další terapeutické hry, jako například Virtuální gorila (Wolitzky et al., 2005), Továrna na zmrzlinu (Chan et al., 2007) nebo Cool! ještě pod dřívějším názvem Moebius Floe (Choo et al., 2014). ...
Article
Full-text available
Virtual reality is used to treat a variety of mental health problems. However, it is not only another technological stage in the use of games in the therapeutic process, but it also brings with it a number of new psychic phenomena (e.g. presence, including embodiment), which change the nature of the game experience. On the other hand, the degree of experienced presence depends on a certain level of technological level, the current peak of which is the so-called fully immersive virtual reality. One of the ways to use virtual reality in the treatment of mental disorders is through direct or indirect therapeutic games. There are already many therapeutic games also in various degrees of virtual reality towards fully immersive virtual reality. The aim of this article is to present the use and creation of therapeutic games in virtual reality and another aim is to present a model composed of three components – player, game and therapy by Mader et al. (2012) for the creation of therapeutic games in virtual reality on the example of the development of an application for reducing procedural pain in patients with burns on the example of our own application Cold river.
... These modalities have been demonstrated to increase users' sense of presence in virtual spaces, with the impact of multiple combined modalities having a strong gestalt effect on immersion beyond each modality on its own. The present work lays down groundwork for VR simulations intended for relaxation, learning and therapy [10,14,30,7], since Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. Copyrights for components of this work owned by others than the author(s) must be honored. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Wind simulations are typically one-off implementations for specific applications. We introduce WindyWall, a platform for creative design and exploration of wind simulations. WindyWall is a three-panel 90-fan array that encapsulates users with 270? of wind coverage. We describe the design and implementation of the array panels, discussing how the panels can be re-arranged, where various wind simulations can be realized as simple effects. To understand how people perceive "wind" generated from WindyWall, we conducted a pilot study of wind magnitude perception using different wind activation patterns from WindyWall. Our findings suggest that: horizontal wind activations are perceived more readily than vertical ones, and that people's perceptions of wind are highly variable-most individuals will rate airflow differently in subsequent exposures. Based on our findings, we discuss the importance of developing a method for characterizing wind simulations, and provide design directions for others using fan arrays to simulate wind.
... We measured their pain intensity levels thrice repeatedly to understand the effectiveness of Mobile VR compared to the traditional HMD. Oculus Rift has been found effective in Chronic Pain patients in one of our previous studies [2]. To best of our knowledge, the study discussed in this paper is the first research that examines the effectiveness of a Mobile VR device for pain distraction in Chronic Pain patients. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Immersive Virtual Reality (VR) has been shown to work as a non-pharmacological analgesic by enabling cognitive distraction in acute pain patients, including burn patients, dental patients and chemotherapy patients. However, little research literature exists on the effectiveness of VR for chronic pain patients who suffer from longer-term pain. This paper aims at contributing to this research gap regarding VR and chronic pain by examining the viability of Cardboard VR– a Mobile VR device. We conducted a randomized crossover study in a clinical setting with thirty chronic pain patients to understand Cardboard’s effectiveness in pain distraction. We asked the patients to play a VR game on both Cardboard and Oculus Rift. The study results showed that Cardboard VR, coupled with a smartphone, is capable of reducing the patients’ perceived pain intensity significantly compared the control (pre-VR) condition. However, Oculus Rift was found to be significantly more effective in pain patients than both the Cardboard and the control condition. The results of this study encourage future research inquiries of Mobile VR in management of chronic pain. Mobile VR, because of its affordability and ease of use, shows the potential to become an effective tool for pain management for the patients. Details about the results can be found at: http://ashfaqamin.com/research-study-2_alt.php
... Carlin et al. [4] also found that immersive VR distraction using SpiderWorld resulted in lower subjective pain ratings in two adolescents undergoing wound care for severe burns, compared to trials in which they played Mario Kart or Wave Race on a Nintendo without VR. More recently, VR combined with biofeedback and mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR), proved effective in reducing pain over short periods [6]. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
This paper describes a study that aims at finding the difference in levels of immersion between a Cardboard VR and a traditional Head-mounted Display (HMD)—the Oculus Rift DK2. Three groups of participants—the experimental group for Cardboard VR, and two control groups for Oculus Rift and a Desktop display—played Cryoblast in the same experimental setups for this study. Jennett et al.’s Immersive Experience Questionnaire was used to measure immersion for all the groups. The results indicate that the Cardboard VR, despite its simplicity and small screen size, is capable of providing an acceptable level of immersion compared to Oculus Rift’s larger screen size. Since ‘immersion’ plays an important role in VR pain distraction, knowing the level of immersion for Cardboard VR may help determine its potential as an accessible VR device for chronic pain self-management.
... Carlin et al. [4] also found that immersive VR distraction using SpiderWorld resulted in lower subjective pain ratings in two adolescents undergoing wound care for severe burns, compared to trials in which they played Mario Kart or Wave Race on a Nintendo without VR. More recently, VR combined with biofeedback and mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR), proved effective in reducing pain over short periods [6]. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
This paper describes a study that aims at finding the difference in levels of immersion between a Cardboard VR and a traditional Head-mounted Display (HMD)––the Oculus Rift DK2.
... Such games strive to provide a fun way to facilitate patient self-efficacy and to allow people to take control of their own well-being. 3 As we know from the serious game literature at large, games must captivate and engage players in order to achieve the development of new knowledge and skills or to facilitate uptake. 4 Thus, with the increased role of games in the healthcare domain, it is imperative to understand how to create engaging games for patients. ...
Article
Full-text available
Objective: Serious games for health care are on the rise. These games are thought to be effective because they can provide information in a context that is engaging. However, it is likely that game-based health training is most effective for a subset of people with specific skills, traits, and experiences. Understanding the factors associated with optimum game outcomes will help us better describe the learners for whom they are appropriate. Toward this end, the present study examined specific cognitive skills related to the achievement of flow state while playing a game for health. Materials and methods: In total, 59 college students were recruited from undergraduate classes to play a game for health and were assessed on levels of mindfulness, cognitive flexibility, and flow state. Results: The results suggest that the effect of cognitive flexibility on flow changes as a function of mindfulness. More specifically, the results suggest that there is a negative relationship between cognitive flexibility and flow in individuals low on mindfulness and a positive relationship between cognitive flexibility and flow in individuals high on mindfulness. Conclusions: Game designers wishing to create effective game-based treatment supplements may wish to implement cognitive flexibility and mindfulness training.
Chapter
This chapter aims to provide the reader with basic knowledge about the experiment as a general method that can be applied towards serious games research and evaluation. It explains the main terms and rules of the experimental design, as well as points out the main risks and difficulties to avoid. The chapter also explains the differences in possible conclusions between true experiments, quasi-experiments, and correlational studies.
Article
Full-text available
When interacting with technical systems, users experience mental workload. Particularly in multitasking scenarios (e.g., interacting with the car navigation system while driving) it is desired to not distract the users from their primary task. For such purposes, human-machine interfaces (HCIs) are desirable which continuously monitor the users' workload and dynamically adapt the behavior of the interface to the measured workload. While memory tasks have been shown to elicit hemodynamic responses in the brain when averaging over multiple trials, a robust single trial classification is a crucial prerequisite for the purpose of dynamically adapting HCIs to the workload of its user. The prefrontal cortex (PFC) plays an important role in the processing of memory and the associated workload. In this study of 10 subjects, we used functional Near-Infrared Spectroscopy (fNIRS), a non-invasive imaging modality, to sample workload activity in the PFC. The results show up to 78% accuracy for single-trial discrimination of three levels of workload from each other. We use an n-back task (n ∈ {1, 2, 3}) to induce different levels of workload, forcing subjects to continuously remember the last one, two, or three of rapidly changing items. Our experimental results show that measuring hemodynamic responses in the PFC with fNIRS, can be used to robustly quantify and classify mental workload. Single trial analysis is still a young field that suffers from a general lack of standards. To increase comparability of fNIRS methods and results, the data corpus for this study is made available online.
Article
Full-text available
We describe the first two cases where virtual reality was added to usual pain medications to reduce excessive pain during wound care of combat-related burn injuries. Patient 1 was a 22 year old male who suffered 3rd degree burns on 32% of his body, including his right hand, during a roadside bomb terrorist attack in Iraq. The nurse administered wound care to half of the right hand during VR and the other half of the same hand during no VR (treatment order randomized). This patient was the first to use a unique custom articulated robotic-like arm mounted VR goggle system. Three 0-10 graphic rating scale pain scores for each of the two treatment conditions served as the primary dependent variables. The patient reported less pain when distract- ed with VR. "Time spent thinking about pain" dropped from 100% during no VR to 15% during VR, "pain unpleasantness" ratings dropped from "moderate" (6/10) to "mild" (4/10). Wound care was "no fun at all" (0/10) during no VR but was "pretty fun" (8/10) during VR. However, Patient 1 reported no reduction in worst pain during VR. Patient 2 suffered 2nd and 3rd degree burns when his humvee was hit by a terrorist's rocket propelled grenade in Iraq. During his wound care debridement, "time spent thinking about pain" was 100% (all of the time) with no VR and 0 (none of the time) during VR, "pain unpleasantness" ratings dropped from "severe" (7/10) to "none". Worst pain dropped from "severe" (8/10) to mild pain (2/10). And fun increased from zero with no VR to 10 (extremely fun) during VR. Although preliminary, using a within-sub- jects experimental design, the present study provided evidence that immersive VR can be an effective adjunc- tive nonpharmacologic analgesic for reducing cognitive pain, emotional pain and the sensory component of pain of soldiers experiencing severe procedural pain during wound care of a combat-related burn injury.
Article
Full-text available
This paper describes the origins and hisotry of multiple resource theory in accounting for difference in dual task interference. One particular application of the theory, the 4-dimensional multiple resources model, is described in detail, positing that there will be greater interference between two tasks to the extent that they share stages (perceptua/cognitive vs response) sensory modalities (auditory vs visual), codes (visual vs spatial) and channels of visual information (focal vs ambient). A computational rendering of this model is then presented. Examples are given of how the model predicts interference differences in operational environments. Finally, three challenges to the model are outlined regarding task demand coding, task allocation and visual resource competition.
Article
Full-text available
The objective of this systematic review was to determine the level of scientific evidence for the effectiveness of VR for pain management in adults with pain. A comprehensive systematic search involving major health care databases was undertaken to identify randomized clinical trials (RCTs) and descriptive studies. Twenty-seven studies were identified that fulfilled the inclusion criteria. There was strong (Level 1a) evidence of a greater benefit from immersive VR and limited evidence (Level 2a) for the effectiveness of non-immersive VR in reducing acute pain. Moreover, there is limited evidence (Level 2a) of effectiveness of immersive VR compared to no VR for reducing chronic pain. There is currently no published study that has explored the effectiveness of non-immersive VR for chronic pain (level 5). It is concluded that VR can be recommended as a standard or adjunct clinical intervention for pain management at least in the management of acute pain.
Article
Full-text available
The management of burn injuries is reported as painful, distressing and a cause of anxiety in children and their parents. Child's and parents' pain and anxiety, often contributes to extended time required for burns management procedures, in particular the process of changing dressings. The traditional method of pharmacologic analgesia is often insufficient to cover the burnt child's pain, and it can have deleterious side effects 12. Intervention with Virtual Reality (VR) games is based on distraction or interruption in the way current thoughts, including pain, are processed by the brain. Research on adults supports the hypothesis that virtual reality has a positive influence on burns pain modulation. This study investigates whether playing a virtual reality game, decreases procedural pain in children aged 5-18 years with acute burn injuries. The paper reports on the findings of a pilot study, a randomised trial, in which seven children acted as their own controls though a series of 11 trials. Outcomes were pain measured using the self-report Faces Scale and findings of interviews with parent/carer and nurses. The average pain scores (from the Faces Scale) for pharmacological analgesia only was, 4.1 (SD 2.9), while VR coupled with pharmacological analgesia, the average pain score was 1.3 (SD 1.8) The study provides strong evidence supporting VR based games in providing analgesia with minimal side effects and little impact on the physical hospital environment, as well as its reusability and versatility, suggesting another option in the management of children's acute pain.
Article
Full-text available
Living with unrelenting pain (chronic pain) is maladaptive and is thought to be associated with physiological and psychological modifications, yet there is a lack of knowledge regarding brain elements involved in such conditions. Here, we identify brain regions involved in spontaneous pain of chronic back pain (CBP) in two separate groups of patients (n = 13 and n = 11), and contrast brain activity between spontaneous pain and thermal pain (CBP and healthy subjects, n = 11 each). Continuous ratings of fluctuations of spontaneous pain during functional magnetic resonance imaging were separated into two components: high sustained pain and increasing pain. Sustained high pain of CBP resulted in increased activity in the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC; including rostral anterior cingulate). This mPFC activity was strongly related to intensity of CBP, and the region is known to be involved in negative emotions, response conflict, and detection of unfavorable outcomes, especially in relation to the self. In contrast, the increasing phase of CBP transiently activated brain regions commonly observed for acute pain, best exemplified by the insula, which tightly reflected duration of CBP. When spontaneous pain of CBP was contrasted to thermal stimulation, we observe a double-dissociation between mPFC and insula with the former correlating only to intensity of spontaneous pain and the latter correlating only to pain intensity for thermal stimulation. These findings suggest that subjective spontaneous pain of CBP involves specific spatiotemporal neuronal mechanisms, distinct from those observed for acute experimental pain, implicating a salient role for emotional brain concerning the self.
Article
Recent research on online learning suggests that virtual worlds are becoming an important environment to observe the experience of flow. From these simulated spaces, researchers may gather a deeper understanding of cognition in the context of game-based learning. Csikszentmihalyi (1997) describes flow as a feeling of increased psychological immersion and energized focus, with outcomes that evoke disregard for external pressures and the loss of time consciousness, issuing in a sense of pleasure. Past studies suggest that flow is encountered in an array of activities and places, including those in virtual worlds. The authors' posit that flow in virtual worlds, such as Second Life (SL), can be positively associated with degrees of the cognitive phenomenon of immersion and telepresence. Flow may also contribute to a better attitude and behavior during virtual game-based learning. This study tested three hypotheses related to flow and telepresence, using SL. Findings suggest that both flow and telepresence are experienced in SL and that there is a significant correlation between them. These findings shed light on the complex interrelationships and interactions that lead to flow experience in virtual gameplay and learning, while engendering hope that learners, who experience flow, may acquire an improved attitude of learning online.
Article
The pain experienced by burn patients during physical therapy range of motion exercises can be extreme and can discourage patients from complying with their physical therapy. We explored the novel use of immersive virtual reality (VR) to distract patients from pain during physical therapy. This study was conducted at the burn care unit of a regional trauma center. Twelve patients aged 19 to 47 years (average of 21% total body surface area burned) performed range of motion exercises of their injured extremity under an occupational therapist's direction. Each patient spent 3 minutes of physical therapy with no distraction and 3 minutes of physical therapy in VR (condition order randomized and counter-balanced). Five visual analogue scale pain scores for each treatment condition served as the dependent variables. All patients reported less pain when distracted with VR, and the magnitude of pain reduction by VR was statistically significant (e.g., time spent thinking about pain during physical therapy dropped from 60 to 14 mm on a 100-mm scale). The results of this study may be examined in more detail at www.hitL.washington.edu/projects/burn/. Results provided preliminary evidence that VR can function as a strong nonpharmacologic pain reduction technique for adult burn patients during physical therapy and potentially for other painful procedures or pain populations.
Article
The present study explored whether immersive virtual reality can serve as an effective non-pharmacologic analgesic for dental pain. Two patients (aged 51 and 56 years old) with adult periodontitis, a chronic, progressive inflammatory disease that affects gums, ligaments, and bones around the teeth, were studied in the treatment room of a periodontist. Each patient received periodontal scaling and root planing (scraping off/removing plaque deposits below the gum line, hereafter referred to as scaling) under three treatment conditions: (1) virtual reality distraction, (2) movie distraction, and (3) a no-distraction control condition. Condition order was randomized and counterbalanced. For each of the three treatment conditions, five visual analog pain scores for each treatment condition served as the dependent variables. On 0-10 labeled scales, both patients provided sensory and affective pain ratings, and subjective estimates of time spent thinking about his pain during the procedure. For patient 1, mean pain ratings were in the severe range while watching a movie (7.2), or no distraction (7.2) but in the mild pain range (1.2) during the VR condition. Patient 2 reported mild to moderate pain with no distraction (mean = 4.4), mild pain while watching the movie (3.3), and essentially no pain while in VR (0.6) during his periodontal scaling. Although the small sample size limits generalizability, we contend that virtual reality is a uniquely attention-grabbing medium capable of maximizing the amount of attention drawn away from the "real world," allowing patients to tolerate painful dental procedures. These preliminary results suggest that immersive VR merits more attention as a potentially viable adjunctive nonpharmacologic analgesia for procedural dental/periodontal pain. Virtual reality may also have analgesic potential for other painful procedures or pain populations. Practical implications are discussed.