Over the past decades, biomarkers (e.g. lignin, lipids) and stable isotopes (e.g. 2H and 18O) were increasingly used to reconstruct vegetation and climate changes. Hitherto, factors affecting the abundance and distribution of biomarkers and their stable isotope composition are not similar worldwide and regional calibration studies are, therefore, highly recommended. The main aim of this Ph.D. dissertation is to evaluate the potential and limitations of biomarkers and their stable isotope composition for chemotaxonomic characterization of the keystone plant species in the Bale Mountains, Ethiopia, and its implication for paleovegetation and paleoclimate reconstruction. More specifically, I focused on lignin-derived phenols, leaf wax-derived n- alkanes, stable isotopes in precipitation (δ2Hprec and δ18Oprec), and compound-specific stable isotopes (δ2Hn-alkane and δ18Osugar). Mild alkaline cupric oxide (CuO) oxidation method was used to extract phenolic compounds. Leaf wax-derived n-alkanes have been Soxhlet-extracted and purified using aminopropyl columns from leaves and topsoils (O-layers as well as Ah-horizons). Individual phenols and n-alkanes were separated by gas chromatography (GC) and detected by mass spectrometry (MS) and flame ionization detector (FID), respectively. The δ2Hprec and δ18Oprec values were measured using a Thermo Conversion Unit coupled with a ConFlo IV interface to an isotope ratio mass spectrometry (IRMS). Compound-specific δ2Hn-alkane and δ18Osugar values were measured using gas chromatography - thermal conversion - isotope ratio mass spectrometry (GC-TC-IRMS).
While conventional phenol ratios such as syringyl vs. vanillyl (S/V) and cinnamyl vs. vanillyl (C/V) phenols failed for unambiguous Erica identification, using machine-learning approaches, we found that the relative abundance of coumaryl phenols (> 0.2) and benzoic acids (0.05–0.12) can be used as a proxy to distinguish Erica from other keystone plant species. Erica in particular is characterized by relatively high cinnamyl contributions of > 40%. However, litter degradation strongly decreases the lignin phenol content and changes the lignin phenol pattern. The relative cinnamyl contribution in the soils under Erica were < 40%, while soils that developed under Festuca abyssinica exhibited relative cinnamyl contributions of > 40%.
Similarly, long-chain n-alkanes extracted from the leaf waxes allowed a differentiation between Erica versus Festuca abyssinica and Alchemilla haumannii, based on a lower C31/C29 ratio (x͂ = 1.7) in Erica. Nevertheless, this characteristic plant pattern was also lost due to degradation in the respective O-layers and Ah-horizons.
At the first hand, the isotope composition of precipitation in the Bale Mountains shows values for δ2Hprec and δ18Oprec in the range of −38 to +29‰ and −8.7 to +3.7‰, respectively. The local meteoric water line (LMWL, δ2H = 5.3 ∗ δ18O + 14.9) is characterized by a lower slope and higher intercept compared to the global meteoric water line (GMWL, δ2H = 8 ∗ δ18O + 10). Furthermore, our isotope data correlate significantly with altitude and amount of precipitation. At the same time, δ18Oprec and δ2Hprec values exhibited seasonal pattern reflecting rainy versus dry season. Thus, shortly after the end of the dry season, isotope values were enriched, while more depleted isotope values coincided with high precipitation amounts recorded in May, August, and September. The Hybrid Single Particle Lagrangian Integrated Trajectory (HYSPLIT) model revealed that during the dry season water vapour originates primarily from the Arabian Sea, whereas during the wet season it originates primarily from the Southern Indian Ocean.
On the other hand, the weighted mean δ2Hn-alkane and δ18Osugar values ranged from −186 to −89‰ and from +27 to +46‰, respectively and exhibited a much wider range than δ18Oprec and δ2Hprec. The δ2Hn-alkane and δ18Osugar values of leaves, O-layers, and Ah-horizons are statistically not significantly different from each other. Hence, in contrast to the biomarker contents and patterns, our dataset provides no evidence for degradation and/or root input affecting the isotope composition of the biomarkers of topsoils. The keystone plant species in the Bale Mountains are characterized by variable values of δ2Hn-alkane as well as apparent isotope fractionation (ɛapp); δ18Osugar yielded the same species-dependent trends. When considering a systematic biosynthetic fractionation offset of −160‰ and +27‰ for δ2Hn-alkane and δ18Osugar, respectively, leaf water of Erica arborea and Erica trimera is 2H- and 18O-enriched by +55 ± 5 and +9 ± 1‰, respectively, compared to precipitation. By contrast, Festuca abyssinica reveals the most depleted δ2Hn-alkane and δ18Osugar values. This can be attributed to “signal-dampening” caused by basal grass leaf growth. The intermediate values for Alchemilla haumannii and Helichrysum splendidum can be explained by plant physiological or microclimatic conditions affecting relative humidity (RH) and thus leaf water enrichment. Once the isotope composition of leaf water calculated, it is possible to reconstruct the isotope composition of source water, deuterium excess and RH using coupled δ2Hn-alkane-δ18Osugar approach. While the actual RH values range from 69 to 82% (x̄ = 80 ± 3.4%), the reconstructed relative humidity, based on a recently suggested coupled δ2Hn-alkane-δ18Osugar (paleo-) hygrometer approach yielded a mean of 78±21%.
In conclusion, chemotaxonomic differentiation of modern-day plants (leaves) is possible using phenols and n-alkanes but soil degradation processes and root input seem to render the proxies unusable for the reconstruction of the past extent of Erica in the Bale Mountains. Similarly, vegetation changes, particularly in terms of grass versus non-grassy vegetation, need to be considered in paleoclimate studies based on δ2Hn-alkane and δ18Osugar records. Furthermore, our δ2Hprec and δ18Oprec results challenge the traditional amount effect interpretation of paleoclimate isotope records from Eastern Africa and rather pinpointed to a previously underestimated source effect. And, the coupled δ2Hn-alkane-δ18Osugar (paleo-) hygrometer approach holds great potential for deriving additional paleoclimatic information compared to single isotope approaches.