ArticlePDF Available

Abstract

Contemporary demographics reveal that the Asian Population is the fastest growing minority in the U.S. Thus, vocational rehabilitation counselors must be prepared to face cultural dynamics that can influence outcomes in the treatment process. While many people may view Asians as a homogenous population, people who are of Asian descent come from many places including, but not limited to Cambodia, China, India, Japan, Korea, Malaysia, Pakistan, the Philippine Islands, Thailand, Vietnam and Asian/Pacific Islander population. The present study provides information about the Asian culture relative to people with disabilities and seeks to give clinicians more tools to apply when working with people who are of Asian descent. Asians represent 4.8% of the civilian non-institutionalized population. Since the Asian/Pacific Islander population is a large racial ethnic group in the U.S., it is important to understand how vocational rehabilitation counselors educate them to live in their new land.
Journal
of
Applied Rehabilitation Counseling
Disability and the Asian Culture
KennyK. Van
Michael
P.
Accordino
Daniel
L.
Boutin
Keith
B.
Wilson
Abstract -- Contemporary demographics reveal that the Asian Population is the fastest grow-
ing minority
in
the
u.s.
Thus, vocational rehabilitation counselors must be prepared to face
cultural dynamics that can influence outcomes
in
the treatment process. While many people
may view Asians as a homogenous population, people who are
of
Asian descent come from
many places including, but not limited
to
Cambodia, China, India, Japan, Korea, Malaysia,
Pakistan, the Philippine Islands, Thailand, Vietnam and Asian/Pacific Islander population.
The present study provides information about the Asian culture relative
to
people with dis-
abilities and seeks to give clinicians more tools
to
apply when working with people who are
of
Asian descent. Asians represent 4.8%
of
the civilian non-institutionalized population. Since
the Asian/Pacific Islander population
is
a large racial ethnic group
in
the
u.s.,
it is important
to
understand how vocational rehabilitation counselors educate them
to
live
in
their new
land.
T
he
Asian population is one
of
the fastest-growing racial
groups in the U.S. with the growth rate
of
Asians with
disabilities steadily increasing.
In
the context
of
cultural differences, Asians with disabilities may avoid
or
refuse some services from rehabilitation agencies because
negative family issues may not be shared beyond family
members in a traditional aspect
of
Asians. Tradiliullal
Asian parents were educated that family is the central and
primary unit and emphasize loyalty within the family
(Committee
of
100, 2001). Therefore, Asians consider a
family member with a disability as a family problem.
Because Asians believe that disability is shameful and
represents family failure, such issues are hidden from the
public and only handled within the families.
Asians are defined as people who are originally
from the Eastern Asia, Western Asia, Southeast Asia,
or
the
Indian subcontinent. The most common countries repre-
sented are Cambodia, China, India, Japan, Korea, Malaysia,
Pakistan, the Philippine Islands, Thailand, and Vietnam
(U.S. Census Bureau, 2003).
In
this review, two groups
of
Asians are selected: Chinese (including people from main-
land China, Taiwan, and Hong Kong) and South Korean.
History of Asian Immigration in the United States
During the 1800s, most
of
the Chinese living in the
U.S. worked as merchants, domestics, farmers, and grocers
4
in mainland China. The Chinese believed that the Gold
Rush could bring them fortune; therefore, they came to the
U.S., hoping to return home with wealth. Beginning in
1865, the businessman
of
Transcontinental Railroad project
used the Gold Rush as an attraction to entice many Chinese
to work in the railroad industry. The Chinese Exclusion Act
or
1882 sigllcu by Plcsident Chester
A.
Althur prohibited
all immigration
of
Chinese laborers; therefore, Chinese
workers became part
of
an isolated community. As a result,
the first generation Chinese immigrants built their own
community
by
promoting small business ownerships in vo-
cational sectors including restaurants, laundry, and
merchandise retail (Le, 2009).
In
1965, the Immigration and Nationality Act
opened the door for millions
of
Asians to immigrate (Le,
2009). Thus, Asians tended to reside in metropolitan areas
in the U.S. Due to labor market discrimination, Asian
Americans chose to
be
self-employed and often earned a
higher salary than other ethnic groups. In terms
of
profit-
ability, most Asian Americans hired their relatives as a
cheap labor source and many
of
these relatives had to work
very long hours. Because
of
the language barrier, the Asian
family member often did not understand American laws and
business regulations and were hired as cheap labor, usually
working without benefits, insurance
or
knowledge
of
job
safety (Le). This review
of
literature has been divided into
the following five sections: (a) Asian demography and re-
Volume 45, Number
2,
Summer 2014
habilitation, (b) Traditional Chinese views
of
disabilities,
(c) attitudes toward people with disabilities, (d) a South Ko-
rean view
of
disabilities, and (
e)
changing views
of
Asians
toward individuals with disabilities.
Asian Demography and Rehabilitation
According to the Asian and Pacific Islander Ameri-
can Health Forum (2008), more than 63%
of
Chinese Amer-
icans are foreign-born, 23% do not speak English fluently,
and 72.5% speak a language other than English at home.
Since the early 1980s, approximately 850,000 people have
annually come to the U.S. from other countries. The esti-
mated foreign-born population
of
the U.S. in 2009 was 37.3
million (9.9 million were Asian, 2.4 million are Chinese, 1
million are Korean). According
to
the U.S. Census (2010),
14.7 million Asians were living in the U.S., with 45.5% lo-
cated in the West, 21.9% in the South, 11.8% in the Mid-
west, and 20.9% in the Northeast. Asians represent 4.2%
of
the civilian non-institutionalized population. The Asian
population is one
of
the fastest growing racial groups
in
the
U.S. from 2000 to 2010; furthermore, the rate
of
the popula-
tion continues to increase. Moreover, Asians with disabili-
ties may refuse any kind
of
services from rehabilitation
agencies because
of
cultural differences from other races.
Rehabilitation services include physical, occupa-
tional and speech language therapists, vocational rehabilita-
tion personnel, rehabilitation technology specialists,
rehabilitation physicians and nurses, special educators,
staff
of
centers for independent living and community ser-
vice providers (Johnstone, 2001). A disability can be a
challenge regardless
of
race and ethnicity. Since most
Asian countries such
as
China and Korea have over thou-
sand years
of
history, they have a strong negative founda-
tion to judge disabilities. For a new Asian immigrant the
challenge is often magnified because the Asian culture dif-
fers greatly from western culture. In addition to difficulties
with languages, housing, and employment, new immigrants
tend to experience a language barrier. Consequently, they
may have difficulty understanding and accessing
rehabilitation services.
Traditional Chinese Views
The most influential philosophical and religious
beliefs affecting the Chinese are Confucianism and Taoism.
The focus
of
Confucian society is on keeping relationships
stable, which affects social harmony and order. Social har-
mony
is
important for the expression
of
ones' opinions and
values. When people
of
Chinese descent begin their fami-
lies, they base its foundation on the five cardinal relations in
harmonious interdependence, which include aspects of: (a)
sovereignty and subject, (b) father and son, (c) elder and
younger brother, (d) husband and wife, and, (e) friend and
friend (lenni, 1999). Thus, Chinese have a strong family
structure in which elderly males hold the family authority.
Senior family members are superior to junior generations
and newly married couples are expected to live with the
family
of
the groom. Elderly family members want the
5
family to stay together in order to maintain future existence
(Lau, 1996).
Taoism is based on the two principles
of
following
natural laws and the Way (or Tao)
as
well
as
being humanis-
tic (i.e. kind, polite, considerate) by following human laws.
The belief
of
Taoism
is
duality
of
all things
in
the universe
(i.e. Yin and Yang), the dialectic
of
change and the impor-
tance
of
balance. Harmonious interactions exist between
Confucianism and Taoism,
as
both are part
of
ancient and
contemporary China. The philosophies provide the plank
for social order and responsibility. The idea
of
disability is
seen to be disharmony, therefore, hardly tolerable among
the Chinese (lenni, 1999).
The Effects
of
Stereotypes and Superstitions
Because
of
this strong need
to
maintain the family
structure, people with disabilities often face particular chal-
lenges (Lau & Kwok, 2000). In the Chinese culture, most
people with disabilities experience discrimination and are
treated with prejudice. People with a disahility have been
judged based solely on the outside appearance and attitudi-
nal stereotypes are passed on from generation
to
generation.
People with disabilities are often seen
as
outcasts
of
society
and having little worth
as
citizens in the Chinese culture. In
many Asian countries, people with disabilities are still re-
garded
as
incapable to be educated and functioning mem-
bers
of
society. Therefore, people with disabilities are often
forgotten and fall through the cracks (lenni, 1999). Even in
the U.S., people with disabilities in the Chincsc culture arc
discriminated against and treated
as
second-class citizens.
Traditional views often rely on superstitions that
disability is a form
of
punishment, promoting the idea that
having a disability may be considered a tragic experience.
Therefore, parents may hide a child with a physical disabil-
ity because the traditional Chinese may be judgmental
to
physical disabilities. Traditional Chinese who have strong
religious beliefs might also generalize negative judgments
to
the whole family because they believe that the disability
was caused by family members who have committed bad
deeds in the past or present (Mente, 2000). Therefore,
as
a
result
of
this rationale, the family
is
deemed
to
have a nega-
tive fate as well
as
shame (Choi & Choi, 2002). The percep-
tions that traditional Chinese hold about disabilities come
from superstitions within the culture (Hur & Hur, 1999).
Furthermore, traditional Chinese culture dictates that
fe-
males are assumed to be less intelligent than males. Chi-
nese American females with a disability are often unsure
of
how they will be treated by the American culture since their
own culture has often demeaned them (Choi & Choi).
Parental Expectations
Chinese parents who have children with visible dis-
abilities tend to want their children
to
be the best even
though they may struggle to compete. Sometimes, children
with disabilities may be sheltered by their parents. For in-
stance, at certain functions where many first generation
Chinese Americans get together, parents would try
to
hide
Journal
of
Applied Rehabilitation Counseling
in order to "protect" their children, because parents
of
chil-
dren with disabilities fear that the elders would not under-
stand
or
accept someone who has disability.
High expectations are often placed on Asian chil-
dren who are able-bodied. Young adults feel constant pres-
sure from their Chinese families to be more successful than
their peers academically. In contrast, American parents
may give more freedom to their children to choose in order
to develop the child's potential in different areas. Chinese
parents rarely consider that it can be damaging to their child
when they send messages that failure is not an option (Lau,
1996). Chinese children may feel pressure to consistently
"be
the best" in order to prevent disappointing their parents.
Children have gone as far as making important life deci-
sions, such as their work and life plans in order to satisfy
their parents. Asian children also may pursue the dreams
of
parents, and not their own. Consequently, the constant ten-
sions and the pursuit
of
goals that are not their own may
lead to burnout and eventually academic
or
vocational
failure in children (Lau, 1996).
Attitudes Toward People with Disabilities in the
Chinese Culture
Cultural differences between Chinese and Ameri-
cans affect
how
each forms attitudes toward people with
disabilities (Chan, Lam, Wong, Leung, & Fang, 1988;
Chan, Lee, Yuen, & Chan, 2002; Tsang, Chan, & Chan,
2004; Wang, Chan, Thomas, Larson, & Lin, 1997; Wang,
Thomas, Chan, & Cheing, 2003). Chan et aI., (2002) exam-
ined Chinese high school and college students and found
that they have less positive attitudes toward either mental
or
physical disabilities than American students. Students in
Hong Kong and Taiwan reported more negative attitudes
toward people with physical disabilities than toward people
with developmental disabilities.
On
the other hand, the
U.S. government enforces the Americans with Disability
Act, which offers support to and prevents discrimination
against students with disabilities (Blackseth, 2011), thus
U.S. students tend to be more positive toward individuals
with special needs in comparison to Chinese students.
Chan et ai. (2002), using the Attitudes Toward Dis-
abled Person Scale (ATDP, 2002), surveyed first year col-
lege students in Chinese and American universities; the
results showed that, on average, American students scored
10
points (0.5 standard deviation) more positive than Chi-
nese students. Wang et ai. (2003) analyzed the attitudes
of
American and Taiwanese college students toward people
with disabilities. Wang et ai. found that both groups most
often preferred females with milder disabilities at a younger
age and with higher education. Furthermore, most Ameri-
can students tended to be more accepting
of
people with de-
velopmental disabilities, and Taiwanese students tended to
be more accepting
of
people with physical disabilities.
Chinese attitudes toward people with disabilities
have been changing because
of
education offered in acade-
mia. However, not all college majors have a positive effect
on attitudes toward disability. Chan et ai. (2002) compared
undergraduate occupational therapy and business students
in Hong Kong, and found that first year students in both ma-
jors had similar attitudes toward disabilities.
By
the end
of
the first year, occupational therapy students showed more
positive attitudes than business students toward individuals
with disabilities.
A South Korean View
of
Disabilities
Traditional South Korean culture values harmony
with order, contrasting with American mainstream culture
that stresses individualism (Hur & Hur, 1999). South Kore-
ansvalue
harmony within family, community, and society.
They are influenced
by
Confucianism and strong ties to
family. In addition, South Koreans value education, hard
work, and possess high ambition to excel. Traditional
South Korean values include filial piety, respect for elders,
benevolence, loyalty, trust cooperation, reciprocity, and hu-
mility. While there may be some similarities between the
American and South Korean cultures, it is clear that South
Koreans may value community and harmony within the
family more than a non-Asian family in the U.S.
6
Demographically, South Korean Americans repre-
sent
1.1
million
of
the U.S. population (U.S. Census Bu-
reau, 2003). South Korean Americans adaptive to
American mainstream culture (Kim-Rupnow, 2001). One
of
these differences is the American emphasis on individu-
alism. Since South Koreans emphasize harmony with or-
der, they tend to
be
influenced
by
the opinions
of
family
members
or
others within the community when making de-
cisions.
If
South Korean Americans make decisions based
on their own preferences without considering others, South
Korean Americans could
be
labeled "selfish." Many South
Koreans consider themselves as extensions
of
their families
and often regard the welfare
of
family members based on
gender and age. Exchanging roles and sharing power are
not encouraged because
of
strong beliefs that order and har-
mony exist when South Koreans have clear distinctions be-
tween the roles and duties
of
men and women. This
traditional legacy often results in the husband leading and
the wife following. Children are ranked
by
age with
younger children required to respect their older siblings
(Breen, 2004).
South Koreans believe supernatural influences
cause disabilities (Hur & Hur, 1999) and tend to feel help-
less, depressed,
or
blame themselves or their ancestors
when they discover a disability in themselves
or
their fam-
ily. South Koreans tend to seek little help and leave every-
thing to fate. The person with a disability is often cared for
by parents, who usually expect their child to "outgrow"
such conditions. People who have had a scientific educa-
tion believe that disabling conditions may be overcome
with appropriate medical intervention and actively search
for medicine, therapy,
or
surgery from health professionals
(Kim-Rupnow, 2001). The
modem
views
of
South Kore-
ans are that lifelong disability is a revenge for a past wrong
doing
of
the person with the disability
or
the
of
the family.
Many South Koreans with disabilities and their families
suffer from shame, helplessness, denial, withdrawal, and
Volume
45,
Number
2,
Summer 2014
depression. Some people view acquired disability as the re-
sult
of
bad
luck
or
misfortune (National Center for the
Dissemination
of
Disability Research, 1999).
Changing Views
of
Asians Toward Individuals
with Disabilities
Western countries have influenced Asians in areas
such as housing
and
clothing. The family structure is be-
coming modernized and most young people move out after
they get married and live in small family units with only
three to four family members (Nagayama Hall & Okazaki,
2002). In the
modem
Asian families, males and females
both work and pursue careers. Females
and
males tend to
receive more equal respect than in the traditional Asian
community.
As
Asian countries are developing, people
have greater opportunities to get a higher education.
The views
of
disability are also changing.
For
ex-
ample, older generation mothers tended to lack knowledge
about physical examinations; most
of
them went without,
even during pregnancy. However, young mothers are will-
ing
to have a physical examination before and during preg-
nancy. The physical check-up is a good
way
to decrease the
chance
of
having a child with a disability (Hong Kong Gov-
ernment, 2006).
In
Hong Kong, the government delivers
more
supportive services. For example, more Hong Kong
special education schools have opened
and
teachers are
trained to teach children with disabilities. The Hong Kong
government offers financial support
by
providing a stable
place for people with disabilities to work (Hong
Kong
Paralympic Committee, 2006). These services provide
job-related training
and
counseling and at least 6 months
of
post-placement service to help the individual with disability
to settle in employment. The Department
of
Health
in
Hong
Kong
also provides antenatal service to pregnant women.
Through the antenatal shared-care program to monitor the
whole pregnancy
and
delivery process, the parents are noti-
fied
of
any defects
of
the embryo such as
Down
Syndrome;
therefore, parents have chance to "prevent" having a child
with disability (Hong Kong Department
of
Health, 2013).
Lastly,
modem
society no longer seems to view that disabil-
ity is physical
and
mental "punishment" for past
wrong
doing; however, there are remnants
of
this belief, especially
from those
in
older
generations.
Summary
Similar to all racial groups, there is variation within
and
between
Asian
cultures.
For
the purposes
of
this study,
the researchers
have
explored the perspectives
of
disability
and
human development for two specific ethnic groups
within the
"Asian"
community: Chinese
and
South Korean.
South Koreans seem to have a stronger sense
of
self-esteem
than the Chinese
(Lau
& K wok, 1997). Disability issues
still need to
be
addressed because people with disabilities
from culturally diverse backgrounds experience twice the
amount
of
discrimination than experienced
by
individuals
who
are able bodied (Tan et aI., 1999).
As
people from
across the globe become educated about disability and dis-
ability-related issues, traditional ideas should be gradually
replaced
by
more respectful and supportive perceptions.
The major issue blocking Asian access to rehabili-
tation service stems from the traditional
view
of
disabilities.
Most Asians are living in developing counties where eco-
nomic problems have blocked people from getting higher
education. As a result, the environment does not encourage
or
often permit people to gain
new
infonnation. Therefore,
the knowledge
of
the people is passed mouth-to-mouth to
the next generation. In addition, the structure
of
family
shifts power to the elderly. Family members tend to place
the greatest trust in what has
been
passed
on
to them from
their elders, who
may
have not had educational opportuni-
ties. Still, people from older generations
may
believe that
negative views
of
disability, which were passed down
through generations, continue to be valid.
Education is a crucial tool
to
change views
of
Asians especially concerning people with disabilities. Ac-
cording to a survey from a Hong Kong researcher (Chan et
al., 2002), college majors, as well as courses that view dis-
ability more favorably could affect attitudes ofundergradu-
ate students. Furthermore, the college environment has
been
more conducive to positive treatment
of
disability.
Overall, higher education can help change the traditional
views
of
students (Chan
et
aI., 2002).
Education is also one
of
the
best
interventions for
changing traditional discriminatory views and superstitions
toward disability (Schauer, 2003). The planning committee
for 2008 Paralympic games successfully scheduled events
that were held in China after the Olympic Games (Hong
Kong Paralympic Committee 2006)
and
were a good world-
wide example
of
the opportunity to change educational sys-
tems. Such an occurrence would
not
have
been
likely in a
previous generation. Knowledge dissemination will con-
tinually
be
needed to change traditional views toward
Asians with disabilities
in
the next generation.
7
Unfortunately, cultural distrust
of
the dominant
culture
may
block
Asian access to rehabilitation
in
the U.S.
This trend is especially true for
new
Asian immigrants since
most
of
them
may
have the traditional beliefs toward people
with disabilities. Interpersonally, Asians
may
tend to avoid
sharing problems considered abnormal
to
others.
They
may
also
try
to hide mental
or
physical disabilities
and
avoid
seeking help from professionals. Therefore, such problems
may
become increasingly worse
due
to denial and
camouflage.
Rehabilitation Counseling Application
When
a rehabilitation counselor is working with
clients from an Asian communities, he/she needs to incor-
porate culture and the clients' world
view
into rehabilitation
planning. Since most
of
Asian clients expect solutions from
their counselors, during the counseling process, the coun-
selor should educate Asian clients
and
explore the best way
to deal with the issues together. The counselor should also
encourage family involvement throughout the counseling
process because
of
the traditional Asian family structure.
Journal
of
Applied Rehabilitation Counseling
The key to success when working with Asian clients is to
understand Asians' belief system
as
well
as
their cultural
background. As a result, some degree
of
preparation
is
re-
quired before the initial intake. With preparation and
an
open mind, rehabilitation counselors will be able to work
more effectively with Asian clients with disabilities and
promote more favorable outcomes.
References
Asian & Pacific Islander American Health Forum. (2008). Asian and Pa-
cific Islander American population statistics. San Francisco,
CA: Author. Retrieved from http://www.apiahf.org.
Blackseth, K. (2011). How the new ADA affects all
of
us.
Oakland, CA.
Interest, Inc.
Breen, M. (2004). The Koreans:
Who
they are, what they want, where
their future lies. New York, NY: St. Martin's Press.
Chan,
C. C.
H., Lee, M. C., Yuen, H. K., & Chan,
F.
(2002). Attitudes to-
ward people with disabilities between Chinese rehabilitation
and business students -An implication for practice. Rehabili-
tation Psychology,
47,
324-338.
Chan, F., Lam, C. S., Wong, D., Leung, P., & Fang, X.
S.
(1988). Coun-
seling Chinese Americans with disabilities. Journal
of
Applied
~
Rehabilitation Counseling, 19(4), 21-25.
Choi, 1., & Choi, Y. (2002). Culture and self-concept flexibility. Person-
ality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 28, 1508-1517.
Committee
of
100.
(200\).
Committee
of
100 Announces Results
of
Landmark National Survey on American Attitudes towards
Chinese Americans and Asian Americans. Retrieved March
11,2014.
Hong Kong Department
of
Health. (2013). Family Health Service. Re-
trieved from http://www.ths.gov.hk/english.
Hong Kong Government. (2006). Hong Kong Government. Retrieved
from http://www.gov.hk.
Hong Kong Paralympic Committee. (2006). Hong Kong Special Olym-
pics. Retrieved from http://www.hkparalympic.org/
hkparalymic/chlinex
03
01.asp.
Hur,
S.
V., & Hur, B. S. (1999). Culture shock! Korea. Portland, OR:
Graphic Arts Center Publishing.
Humes, K., Jones, N., & Ramirez,
R.
(2011). Overview
of
Race and His-
panic Origin: 2010. United States Census Bureau.
U.S.
De-
partment
of
Commerce. Retrieved March 11, 2014.
Jenni,
C.
B. (1999). Psychologists in China: National transformation and
humanistic psychology. Journal
of
Humanistic Psychology,
39(2) 26-47.
Johnstone, D. (2001). An introduction to disability studies (2nd
ed.).London, England: David Fulton Publishers.
Jones, N. (2010). The Asian population in the United States: Results from
the 2010 census. Washington, DC. U.S. Census Bureau. Re-
trieved March 11,2014.
Kim-Rupnow, W.
S.
(2001).
An
introduction
to
Korean culture
for
reha-
bilitation service providers. A monograph written as part
of
an
eleven-volume monograph series, The rehabilitation pro-
vider's guide to cultures
of
the foreign-born. Retrieved from
http://www . cirrie. buffalo.edulmonographs/kprea. pdf.
Lau,
S.
(1996). Parents-child relationship: A comparison
of
three cities -
Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou. Hong Kong, China: Chiu
Wah Press.
Lau, S., & Kwok, H. K. (2000). A comparative study
ofthe
relationships
between two generations in three Chinese cities: Beijing,
Shanhai & Guangzhou. Youth in the great transitional period,
(in
Chinese) (pp. 347-392). Nanjing, China: Nanjing Univer-
sity Press.
Le,
C.
N. (2009). Employment & occupational patterns. Retrieved from
http://www.asian-nation.orglemployment.shtml.
Mente, B. (2000). The Chinese Have a Wordfor
it:
The Complete Guide
to
Chinese thought and Culture. New York, NY. McGraw-Hill .
Professional.
Nagayama Hall,
G.
c.,
& Okazaki,
S.
(Eds.). (2002). Asian American
Psychology:
The
science
of
lives
in
context. Washington DC:
American Psychological Association.
National Center for the Dissemination
of
Disability Research Southwest
Educational Development Laboratory. (1999). Disability, di-
versity, and dissemination: A review
of
the literature
on
topics
related
to
increasing the utilization
of
rehabilitation research
outcomes among diverse consumer groups. Retrieved from
http://www .mcddr/orgidulproducts/dddreview /index.html.
8
Schauer,
F.
(2003). Profiles, probabilities and stereotypes. Boston, MA:
Belknap Press
of
Havard University Press.
Tan, T. S., Solomon,
L.
J., & Worden,
J.
K. (1999). The role
of
cultural
variables in breast self-examination and cervical cancer
screening behavior in young Asian women living in the United
States. Journal
of
Behavioral Medicine, 22, 419-426.
Tsang, H., Chan, F., & Chan
C.
C.
H. (2004). Attitudes
of
occupational
therapy students toward placement
of
treatment facilities in the
community: A conjoint analysis. American Journal
of
Occu-
pational Therapy,
58,
426-434.
U.S. Census Bureau. (2003). The Asian and Pacific Islander Population
in
the United States: March 2002. Retrieved from http://
www.cenus.gov/populaionlwww/spcdemo/race/api.html.
Wang, M. H., Chan. F., Thomas, K. R., Larson, P., & Lin,
S.
H.
(1997).
Coping style and personal responsibility as factors in the per-
ception
of
people with disabilities
by
Chinese international
students. Rehabilitation Psychology, 42, 303-316.
Wang, M, H., Thomas, K., Chan, F., & Cheing,
G.
(2003). A conjoint
analysis
of
factors influencing American and Taiwanese col-
lege students' preferences for people with disabilities. Reha-
bilitation Psychology,
48,
195-201.
The authors would like to acknowledge Dr. Anita N. Lee from the De-
partment
of
Health and Physical Education, Eastern Connecticut State
University for proofreading this manuscript; research advisor, Dr. Ber-
nard
J.
Graney, from the Department
of
Rehabilitation and Disability
Studies, Springfield College; and Miss Kayla Y Lin, from Wheelock
College for information collection.
Kenny
K.
Yan, MS, Vocational Serivces Specialists, Boston
Higashi School
in
Randolph, MA.
email: kyan@bostonhigashi.org
Michael
P.
Accordino, D.Ed, CRC,
LMHC,
Professor
of
Rehabilitation and Disability Studies, Springfield College
in Springfield, MA.
email: maccordi@springfieldcollege.edu
Daniel L. Boutin, PhD, CRC, CDMS, NCC, Associate
Professor, School
of
Allied Health and Communicative Dis-
orders, Northern Illinois University in DeKalb,
IL.
email: dboutin@niu.edu
Keith B. Wilson, PhD, CRC, LPC, NCC,
ABDA,
Dean,
College
of
Education and Human Services, Southern Illi-
nois University
in
Carbondale,
IL.
Correspondence should be addressed
to
Kenny
K.
Yan,
Boston Higashi School, 800 North Main Street, Randolph,
MA 02368. email: kyan@bostonhigashi.org
... The Chinese culture is influenced by Confucianism, where mothers are expected to bring up successful children that can contribute to society (Ng et al., 2021). Chinese societies are also collectivist, which means prioritising commonality for the well-being of the group (Yan et al., 2014). Buddhism and Taoism are major religions in the Chinese culture, sharing the belief that past lives have an influence on current life (Yan et al., 2014). ...
... Chinese societies are also collectivist, which means prioritising commonality for the well-being of the group (Yan et al., 2014). Buddhism and Taoism are major religions in the Chinese culture, sharing the belief that past lives have an influence on current life (Yan et al., 2014). Research has suggested that these cultural beliefs could lead to Chinese mothers who have children with disabilities being blamed for producing 'bad seeds' resulting from their deeds in previous lives (Yan et al., 2014). ...
... Buddhism and Taoism are major religions in the Chinese culture, sharing the belief that past lives have an influence on current life (Yan et al., 2014). Research has suggested that these cultural beliefs could lead to Chinese mothers who have children with disabilities being blamed for producing 'bad seeds' resulting from their deeds in previous lives (Yan et al., 2014). Hence, the culture may have perpetuated negative attitudes towards disabilities, leaving mothers feeling ostracised and unsupported (Sim et al., 2021b;Yang, 2015). ...
Article
Introduction Mothers of children with disabilities report increased maternal stress, compromised mental health and reduced leisure and social participation compared with other mothers. The aim of the study was to explore the similarities and differences between three groups of Chinese mothers of children with disabilities in their caregiving occupations and selected maternal variables. Methods An online survey collected mothers’ demography, caregiving occupations and six maternal measures: frequency in participation in health promoting activities, mental well-being, personal well-being, psychological distress, perceived support and perceived stigma. Descriptive and inferential statistics were used to investigate group similarities and differences, and detect associations between variables. Results The survey responses of Chinese mothers ( N = 261) from Australia ( n = 80), Singapore ( n = 95) and Taiwan ( n = 86) were analysed. Similarities and differences in caregiving occupations were found between groups. The Kruskal–Wallis test showed no differences in maternal variables between groups. There were associations found between some caregiving occupations and maternal variables when mothers were analysed as a single group. Conclusion The health and well-being of mothers of children with disabilities may be influenced more by their cultural similarities than differences in their socio-political environments. Recognising cultural influences on caregiving occupations is crucial in the delivery of culturally competent and culturally intelligent practice.
... The influence of culture on the utilization of rehabilitation services and outcomes is profound. Culture shapes perceptions of disability, beliefs surrounding the causes of disabilities and rehabilitation services, and several aspects of help-seeking behavior (Yan et al. 2014). The intersection of disability and Asian culture can pose unique challenges, as disabilities have historically carried a sense of shame and familial failure within Asian cultures. ...
... The intersection of disability and Asian culture can pose unique challenges, as disabilities have historically carried a sense of shame and familial failure within Asian cultures. This perception often leads to avoidance or refusal of rehabilitation services outside the family sphere, contributing to comparatively lower rates of Asian Americans applying for VR services (Yan et al. 2014;Yin et al. 2021). In mental health literature, Asian Americans are often characterized as challenging to reach within social support systems (U.S. ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose The current study investigated the relationships between demographic variables, cash benefits, vocational rehabilitation (VR) services, and employment outcomes of Asian Americans VR clients. Methods The data were extracted from the most recent Rehabilitation Service Administration database (RSA‐911). Among 17,278 case services records, 5784 clients met the inclusion criteria. Chi‐square automatic interaction detector and logistic regression analyses were employed to investigate the employment outcomes. Results The results indicated that Asian American clients who have completed a bachelor's degree or more do not receive disability‐related benefits, and those who received more VR services were more likely to achieve competitive integrated employment (CIE). In addition, VR counseling and job placement services were significant predictors of employment outcomes. Conclusions These findings provide valuable insights into the factors influencing CIE among Asian American VR clients with disabilities. The results further underscore the importance of VR professionals possessing cultural competence to effectively serve a diverse clientele.
... Focusing on Asian children and youth with disabilities (i.e., living in Asian countries and Asians living in western countries) is important because they are often under-diagnosed, and often receive fewer supports from professional services, and experience stigma and discrimination in various settings [31][32][33][34][35][36]. For instance, Asian youth with disabilities are under-represented among those accessing disability-support services in the United States [31]. ...
... For instance, Asian youth with disabilities are under-represented among those accessing disability-support services in the United States [31]. Previous studies highlighted that Asian youth with disabilities are less likely to be diagnosed and use health services, largely due to stigma and discrimination from service providers [32][33][34][35]. ...
Article
Purpose: Asian children and youth with disabilities often experience multiple barriers, stigmas and discrimination within and outside their families; yet less is understood about their lived experiences. this systematic review explored the experiences of ableism among Asian children and youth with disabilities and their families. Methods: we conducted a systematic review of qualitative studies and a qualitative meta-synthesis. we searched six databases including Ovid Medline, embase, Psychinfo, Healthstar, web of Science, and Scopus. Results: Forty-two articles met our inclusion criteria involving 17 countries and regions over a 22-year period. the findings were synthesized into four themes: (1) individual- and family-level ableism (i.e., stigma, fears, concerns, stress and anxieties, physical abuse, bullying, reduced engagement in community activities); (2) institutional-level ableism (i.e., barriers to accessing and navigating supports, ableist attitudes among service providers, unavailable services); (3) societal-level ableism (i.e., cultural and religious stigma, social rejection, discrimination, environmental and policy barriers); and (4) coping strategies (i.e., self-care activities, supports from family, friends and people with similar conditions, religious beliefs). Conclusions: Our results highlight the ableist experiences that Asian children and youth with disabilities and their caregivers often encounter and the strong need for further supports to address ableism using culturally responsive strategies.
... Individuals from traditional Asian cultural backgrounds may view having children with disabilities as punishment for an ancestor from a past life (Tsai et al., 2017). Within this context, families may feel the need to hide their punishment by isolating their children from society (Yan et al., 2014). Similarly, some Korean parents believe their children with a disability equates to a 'loss of face'-a concept associated with less prestige (Wang, 2009) and lower social status. ...
Article
This study seeks to (a) examine the relationship among demographic variables of Korean immigrant parents of children with developmental disabilities (DDs), (b) predict which demographic characteristics impact acculturative stress, and (c) investigate the effect of coping strategies while controlling for those demographics. Korean immigrant parents of children with DDs who reside in the United States (n = 64) completed modified versions of the acculturative stress scale from the National Latino Asian American Study (NLAAS), and coping pattern scale from the Coping Health Inventory for Parents (CHIP). Measures were translated into Korean. The hierarchical multiple regression found that the country where the participants attained their highest level of education, coping patterns for maintaining social support, and psychological well-being on positive self-esteem were significant variables at predicting the level of acculturative stress. The recognition of cultural characteristics and cultural sensitivity to support Korean immigrant parents were identified as implications for research and practices. Further discussion of the findings and limitations are provided.
... This perception may not only affect their image as wise elders and leaders in the family and society but also increase the burden of care for family members. Consequently, these long-term negative psychological implications may adversely impact their sleep (38,39). Our findings align with the stress process theory that the decline of IADL function as a stressor may be associated with the depletion of self-resources, such as sleep disorders, resulting in negative emotions such as depressive symptoms (11). ...
Article
Full-text available
Objective This study aimed to develop and validate a serial multiple mediation model to investigate the association between instrumental activities of daily living (IADL) function and cognitive status among older adults while exploring the underlying mechanisms. Methods This cross-sectional study involved 3,665 individuals aged 60 years and older who participated in the China Health and Retirement Longitudinal Survey (CHARLS). A serial multiple mediation model was utilized to explore the direct and indirect relationship between IADL function and cognitive status and whether sleep duration, social engagement, and depressive symptoms mediated this relationship. Results Decreased IADL function was associated with worse cognitive status [effect = −0.620, 95% CI: (−0.692, −0.540)]. Sleep duration, social participation (SP), and depressive symptoms all acted as mediators in the relationship between IADL function and cognitive status. Conclusion This study found both direct and indirect associations between IADL function and cognitive status, providing new insights into the effective prevention and intervention of cognitive decline among older adults.
Article
Introduction In Asia, many caregivers are culturally obliged to assume the role of taking care of individuals experiencing chronic schizophrenia, even as they grapple with stigma and compassion fatigue. Despite the significance of this phenomenon, the collective experiences of Asian caregivers remain poorly understood. Aim To synthesise qualitative evidence on the experiences of informal caregivers when caring for individuals with chronic schizophrenia in Asia. Methods A search was conducted on seven databases for studies published between 2013 and 2023. The included studies were appraised using the Critical Appraisal Skills Program tool. Data extraction was based on the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) Qualitative Extraction Form. The data synthesis was based on the framework by Sandelowski and Barroso. Results Our review included the experiences of 1345 informal caregivers from 57 included studies. The analysis yielded the overarching theme of ‘Navigating Challenges, Forging Resilience’. Three themes were identified: (i) challenges in caregiving, (ii) lack of support and (iii) coping and resilience. Discussion Our findings highlighted the Asian caregivers' stressors, particularly cultural and traditional factors, a facet often overlooked in the literature. Implications for Practice Mental healthcare practitioners must provide caregivers with comprehensive information. Anticipatory guidance is essential during the initial stages of the diagnosis. To negate geographical limitations, caregiver‐training sessions can be pre‐recorded and posted to online platforms. Finally, cultural and spiritual beliefs can be integrated into the treatment plans for individuals with schizophrenia in the community. Relevance Statement Within the institutional setting, mental healthcare practitioners are encouraged to provide caregivers with comprehensible information or training in person and through written or online platforms, which can transcend geographical limitations. Anticipatory guidance is essential, especially during the initial stages of the diagnosis, when confusion and uncertainties are prevalent. Periodic home visits by mental healthcare practitioners can help ease caregivers' concerns and enhance their caregiving confidence. Finally, cultural and spiritual beliefs should be integrated into the treatment plans for individuals with schizophrenia in the community as it promotes cultural acceptability, encourages referrals to appropriate institutions and reduces the stigma of mental healthcare.
Chapter
This chapter defines concepts related to diversity and summarizes a foundational framework in the field of rehabilitation counseling that conceptualizes disparities in the disability community. It provides an extensive overview of different cultural perspectives of disability for each of the main racial and ethnic groups represented in the United States. This is followed by documented disparities found in research literature for each racial and ethnic groups in intellectual, psychiatric, cognitive, and/or physical disabilities. The cultural aspects of culturally diverse racial and ethnic people with disabilities are summarized. Brief suggestions are provided to deliver culturally responsive services. The future research directions section suggests that since cultural competence is evolving, it is important to acknowledge the expansion of the definition of culture and provide more rigorous research to address the intersectionality of cultural concepts, as well as mixed methodology and qualitative research to provide a rich description of the multicultural and disability experience.
Article
Full-text available
This study examined coping style and personal responsibility as factors influencing the perceptions of Chinese international students regarding people with physical disabilities. Sixty Chinese international students were randomly assigned to four experimental conditions (optimistic-not responsible, optimistic-responsible, pessimistic-not responsible, and pessimistic-responsible), and then asked to view a videotape of an interview with a Chinese international student in a wheelchair who assumed one of the four roles listed above. After viewing the tape, the students were asked to complete the Semantic Differential Scale and the Subject Rating Scale. The ANCOVA results indicated that the optimistic-not responsible condition resulted in the most positive evaluations, with the optimistic-pessimistic variable being more potent than the responsible-not responsible variable. Implications for clinical practice and rehabilitation program development in Chinese communities are discussed.
Article
Full-text available
Objective: To study the effects of curriculum on changing the attitudes of students toward people with disabilities. Participants: Seventy-three rehabilitation students and 107 business students in either their 1st or 3rd year at a Chinese university. Main Outcome Measures: The Attitude Towards Disabled Persons (ATDP) Scale and a questionnaire on course work and personal experience. Results: At the end of the 1st year, rehabilitation students had significantly more positive attitudes, whereas the business students were more negative. In the 3rd year, these attitudes were also found among both groups of students. Conclusion: Rehabilitation psychologists should expand their practice to foster positive attitudinal changes in students in nonrehabilitation programs, which helps create a positive environment for people with disabilities. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
Full-text available
Objective: To determine the effect of demographic variables on attitudes toward disability. Participants: Eighty-three female American and 89 female Taiwanese college students. Outcome Measure: A conjoint measurement of 16 stimulus cards (representing people with varying disability labels, severity of disability, age, gender, and education). Procedures: The participants were asked to sort the stimulus cards according to their personal preferences for working with people with disabilities. Results: Younger and higher educated women with milder disabilities were preferred by both Taiwanese and American students. Preference formation is affected by both disability-related variables and other demographic variables (e.g., educational levels). Conclusion: The use of conjoint analysis to examine multiple attributes of persons with disabilities may have higher external validity than single-attribute-design studies.
Article
Full-text available
This study examined coping style and personal responsibility as factors influencing the perceptions of Chinese international students regarding people with physical disabilities. Sixty Chinese international students were randomly assigned to four experimental conditions (optimistic-not responsible, optimistic-responsible, pessimistic-not responsible, and pessimistic-responsible), and then asked to view a videotape of an interview with a Chinese international student in a wheelchair who assumed one of the four roles listed above. After viewing the tape, the students were asked to complete the Semantic Differential Scale and the Subject Rating Scale. The ANCOVA results indicated that the optimistic-not responsible condition resulted in the most positive evaluations, with the optimistic-pessimistic variable being more potent than the responsible-not responsible variable. Implications for clinical practice and rehabilitation program development in Chinese communities are discussed. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
Psychology in the People’s Republic of China is experiencing rapid growth and redefinition in response to dramatic changes in economic, cultural, and political conditions. This article discusses the common points of agreement and opportunities for dialogue and collaboration between western humanistic psychology, Chinese psychology and the philosophical and religious traditions of Daoism and Mencian humanistic Confucianism. This article provides an historical and contemporary context for Chinese psychology. It discusses aspects of Chinese culture that interact with the development of a uniquely Chinese psychology. The emergent discipline of psychology in China and humanistic psychological approaches have much to offer each other in the understanding and solution of human and global dilemmas.
Article
For rehabilitation counselors to be effective in counseling Americans of Chinese descent with disability, counselors must have some understanding of cultural variables that have impact on Chinese Americans. Rehabilitation counselors need to be sensitive to the differential counseling needs and expectations of Chinese Americans. A brief overview of the cultural variables affecting Chinese Americans is discussed in relationship to counseling issues that may affect rehabilitation counseling outcome.
Article
This study examined cultural factors as predictors of breast self-examination (BSE) and participation in cervical cancer screening in young Asian and Caucasian women in the United States. Comparisons between Asian and Caucasian samples revealed significant differences in ever performing BSE and obtaining a pap test; the Caucasian women reported higher participation in both behaviors. Factor analysis of cultural barriers to screening revealed four factors: communication with mother, openness around sexuality, prevention orientation, and utilization of Western medicine. Logistic regression predicting BSE performance from demographics, acculturation, and cultural barriers revealed openness around sexuality to be a significant predictor. Pap test participation was predicted by year in college, ever having engaged in sexual intercourse, prevention orientation, and global acculturation. Cultural factors should be considered in programs to enhance participation in cancer screening.
Asian and Pacific Islander American population statistics
Asian & Pacific Islander American Health Forum. (2008). Asian and Pacific Islander American population statistics. San Francisco, CA: Author. Retrieved from http://www.apiahf.org.