ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

In felids, mortality caused by dominant males can affect life history characteristics, demography and reproductive success. When a dominant male is removed, an incoming male may kill offspring sired by the previous male to induce the resident female into oestrus. We had the opportunity to observe the infanticide avoidance responses of female tigers (Panthera tigris) to incoming males in the core area of Ranthambhore Tiger Reserve (RTR), Rajasthan, during 2008–2010. In one case, following the disappearance of a dominant male tiger (TM-12) from the established territory of a female tiger (TF-13), the female tiger, accompanied by two cubs, immediately moved approximately 20 km away into riverine areas outside the protected area of RTR. In another case, a female (TF-04) died from a battle with a male while defending her cubs. These observations reveal the attempts of female tigers to avoid infanticide. Observations and results from behavioural decisions made by tigers are important to understand the species and the factors that facilitate their conservation.
Content may be subject to copyright.
RESEARCH COMMUNICATIONS
CURRENT SCIEN CE, VOL. 107, NO. 9 , 10 NOVEMBER 2 014 1595
*For correspondence. (e-mail: randeep04 @redi ffmail.com)
Strategy of female tigers to avoid
infanticide
Randeep Singh1 ,*, Parag Nigam1,
Qamar Qureshi1, Kalyanasundaram Sankar1,
Paul R. Krausman2 and
Surendra Prakash Goyal1
1Wildl ife Institu te of India, Post Box # 18 , D ehradun 24 8 001 , India
2Boone and C rockett Program in W ildli fe Con servation,
University of Mo ntana, Missoula, Montana 598 12, USA
In felids, mortality caused by dominant males can affect
life history characteristics, demography and repro-
ductive success. When a dominant male is removed,
an incoming male may kill offspring sired by the pre-
vious male to induce the resident female into oestrus.
We had the opportunity to observe the infanticide
avoidance responses of female tigers (Panthera tigris)
to incoming males in the core area of Ranthambhore
Tiger Reserve (RTR), Rajasthan, during 2008–2010.
In one case, following the disappearance of a domi-
nant male tiger (TM-12) from the established territory
of a female tiger (TF-13), the female tiger, accompa-
nied by two cubs, immediately moved approximately
20 km away into riverine areas outside the protected
area of RTR. In another case, a female (TF-04) died
from a battle with a male while defending her cubs.
These observations reveal the attempts of female
tigers to avoid infanticide. Observations and results
from behavioural decisions made by tigers are impor-
tant to understand the species and the factors that
facilitate their conservation.
Keywords: Camera trap, female tigers, infanticide avoid-
ance, Ranthambore Tiger Reserve.
IN carnivores, adult males play an important role in popu-
lation dynamics, reproduction and breeding success1 ,2.
Removal of adult territorial males can led to increased
immigration of new males, reduced survival of cubs and
reduced population growth3–7. In fanticide by imm igrating
males is a male reproductive strategy whereby new males
may kill the offspring sired by the dominant male to en-
able the mother to come into oestrus earlier (i.e. killing
for accelerated oestr ous cycle)8, 9. When females are faced
with these events they have behavioural options or counter
strategies to avoid infanticide, such as moving to an al-
ternative location outside th e new male’s territory or
staying to defend their cubs from attacks1 0–12. Moving to
an alternative location and avoiding the male could likely
lead to resettling in inferior habitat3, or enhance the
chances for injury and death if they have to repeatedly
defend their cubs from the males. These consequences on
the impacts of population dynamics have been rarely con-
sidered by biologists, partly due to the rare opportunities
to document this behaviour in the wild4,10.
Some records of females trying to avoid sexually
selected infanticide (i.e. when an immigrating male,
which is not the father of dependent cubs, may gain
increased mating success by killing the cubs) have been
documented for lions4 (Panthera leo), brown bears10
(Ursus arctos) and jaguars13 (Panthera onca), but similar
data for tigers (Panthera tigris) are limited to anacedontal
observations14 ,15. We report here the responses of two
female tigers to incoming immigrant males in order to
avoid infanticide.
The Ranthambhore Tiger Reserve (RTR; 2554N–
2612N and 7622E to 7639E) is situated in the semi-
arid part of western Rajasthan and is characterized by a
subtropical dr y climate with four distinct seasons: summer
(March–June), monsoon (July–August), post-monsoon
(September–October) and winter (November–February).
The study area has been described in detail by Singh
et al.16 .
The tiger population in RTR is composed of <30 ind i-
viduals in the past five years17,18. We monitored the tiger
population through camera traps (1 camera trap/km2) and
direct observations in 233 km2 of the core area in RTR
from April 2005 to June 2011 (refs 16, 19–22). We iden-
tified the distribution and home ranges of individual male
and female tigers and recorded population and reproduc-
tive parameters (i.e. inter-birth interval, dispersal, litter
size, age of first reproduction)16,1 9–22. Besides monitoring
individual tigers by camera trapping, we also used infor-
mation on tiger movements by intensive searching with
the Forest Department and direct sighting. If we found
tigers (inside or outside RTR) involved in conflicts with
humans, including killing livestock near human habita-
tions and attacking people, we photographed them
directly or with camera traps. We identified each tiger by
matching its stripe patterns with the tiger photo database
of RTR at the Wildlife Institute of India (WII),
Dehradun16. We marked the locations of tigers using a
handheld GPS device and plotted their locations in the
GIS domain using the ArcView 3.3 software package
(ESRI, Redlands, California, USA). We calculated the ae-
rial distance between the plotted locations. We observed
the behaviour of three tigers (one dominant male (TM-
12); one resident female (TF-13) and one incoming male
(TM-24)) during our study period. The home range of all
three tigers was calculated using the Home Range Exten-
sion in ArcView 3.3 to generate minimum convex pol y-
gons (MCPs)23 utilizing 100% of locations. We estimated
the home range of individuals that were encountered at
least three times at different locations during the study
period using the MCP method, because a minimum of
three points are needed to make a polygon. Additionally
the open, thorny, deciduous forest with scanty vegetation
and a good road network in RTR provide ideal
conditions for tiger sightings. We recorded additional
RESEARCH COMMUNICATIONS
CURRENT SCIEN CE, VOL. 107, NO. 9 , 10 NOVEMBER 2 014 1596
Figure 1. Distribution of thr ee tigers in Ra nthambhore Tiger Reserve, western I ndia, 200 8 to 2010 .
information about the behaviour (i.e. mating, scent spray-
ing, territorial marking, fight, prey hunting, rearing of
cubs) of male and female tigers.
In one case we observed that the female (TF-13) with
two cubs moved to a new area after the disappearance of
the dominant male tiger (TM-12). Before its disappear-
ance the male’s range covered the home range of the
female (Figure 1). In August 2008, female (TF-13) deli-
vered two cubs (M, F) and reared them until they dis-
persed. Subsequently, after 2 years, in August 2010, TF-
13 was photo-captured with two cubs (unknown sex). Be-
cause the male and female shared the same home range,
both litters were likely the progeny of the male TM-12.
After the emigration of male TM-12, the vacant home
range was acquired by another immigrant male (TM-24).
Evidence of this was confirmed by our regular monitor-
ing of tigers using camera traps (October 2010, adult
male TM-24 (> 3 years) was photo-trapped within the ter-
ritory of TF-13). This male tiger had been previously
physically captured approximately 4 km away in a subop-
timal habitat24. To possibly avoid infanticide, th e female
moved h er cubs to a new area approximately 20 km away
in riverine areas (Figure 1). Th e female (TF-13) and cubs
were confirmed by photographic evidence through cam-
era traps (December 2010) in the riverine area. Both the
female and the cubs were monitored continuously using
camera traps until the following monsoon (August 2011).
Our results highlight the response of a female tiger
with cubs (<6 month) to an immigrating male, including
avoidance of the new male. After the arrival of the new
male, the female left her established territory in which
she had successfully reared previous cubs. Similar female
strategies to avoid infanticide have been observed in sev-
eral species (felids, primates and captive rodents), thus
providing a mechanism whereby females may reduce
their losses to infanticide10. A few records of infanticide
have also been reported in tigers at the Kanha Tiger
Reserve, India (M. S. Panwar, unpublished) and Chitwan
National Park, Nepal1 4,15,25 . Sunquist26 also observed im-
migration of males after the death of a dominant male
tiger, which lead to fighting among them, and there was
no breeding for two years.
In another case we observed a female (TF-04) with
cubs vigorously attacking (2 April 2009) an intruding
male and successfully defending her cubs. The day after
the fight the female succumbed to injuries. The postmortem
report confirmed that the animal died due to deep canine
injuries in her skull and neck. This could be the immedi-
ate response of mothers against intruding males to pr e-
vent conspecifics from killing their offspring10,11 .
This study has recorded the response of a female tiger
to an immigrating male to likely avoid infanticide in a
semi-arid region in western India. This information
is important to better understand the behaviour of an
RESEARCH COMMUNICATIONS
CURRENT SCIEN CE, VOL. 107, NO. 9 , 10 NOVEMBER 2 014 1597
*For correspondence. (e-mail: dolenec@zg.biol.pmf. hr)
endangered species towards pr obable infanticide and
factors that can govern their conservation implications.
1. LeGalliard, J. F., Fitze, P. S., Ferriére, R. and Clobert, J., Sex r atio
bias, male aggressio n, and popula tion collapse in lizards. Proc.
Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 2005, 1 02(18 ), 231–236.
2. Parker, H., R osell, F. a nd Mysterud, A., Harvesting o f males
delays female breeding in a socially monogam ous mam mal; the
beaver . Biol. Lett., 2007, 3, 10 6–108.
3. Wielgus, R. B. and Bunnell, F. L., Tests of hypotheses of sexual seg-
regation in grizzly bears. J. Wildl. Manage., 1995, 58, 552–560.
4. Swenson, J. E., Sandegren, F., Söderberg, A., Bjä rval l, A., Fra n-
zén, R. a nd Wabakken, P., Infanticide caused by hu nting of male
bears. Nature, 1997 , 386, 450 –451.
5. Wielgus, R. B ., Sarrazin, S., Ferriere, R. a nd Clobert, J., E stimat-
ing effect s of adult male morta lity on grizzly bear population
growth and per siste nce using matrix model s. Biol. Conserv., 2001,
98, 293–303.
6. Andreasse n, H. P. and Gundersen, G., Male tur nover re duces
popul ation growth: an enclosu re experiment on voles. Eco logy ,
2006 , 87 , 88–94.
7. López, G., L ópez -Parra, M., Ferná ndez, L., Ruiz, G ., Gil-Sá nchez,
J. M. and Simón, M. A., First evidence of non-parental male in-
fanticide in the endangered Iberian Lynx (Lynx pardinus) Wildl .
Biol. Pract., 2010, 6(3), 67–74.
8. Hrdy, S. B., Male–male competition and infanticid e amon g the
langurs (Presbytis entellus) of Abu, Ra jasthan. Folia Primatol.,
1974 , 22 , 19–58.
9. Hrdy, S. B., Infanticide among anima ls: a review, clas sification
and examination of the impl ications for the reproductive strategies
of females. Eth ol. S ociobiol., 1979 , 1, 13 –40.
10. Packer, C. and Pu sey, A. E., Adaptations of female lions to in fan-
ticide by incomi ng males. Am. Nat., 1983, 121(5 ), 716–728.
11. Packer, C. and Pusey, A. E., Infanticide in carnivores. In Infanti-
cide : Comparative and Evolu tionary Perspectives (eds Hausfater,
G. a nd Blaffer, I.), Aldine, New York, 1994, pp. 31–42.
12. Packer, C., Pu sey, A. E. and E berly, L. E., E galitaria nism in
femal e African lions. Sci ence , 200 1, 1293, 690–69 3.
13. Soares, T. N. et al., Paternity testi ng and behavioral ecology: a
case study of jaguars (Pan thera onca ) in Emas National Park,
Central Brazil. Gen . Mol. Biol., 2006, 29(4), 735 –740.
14. Smith, J. L. D. and McDou gal, C. W., The contribu tion of vari-
ance in lifetime reproducti on t o e ffective popu lation size in tigers.
Conserv. Biol. , 1991 , 5, 484–49 0.
15. Barlow, A. C. D. e t al. , Temporal va ria tion in tiger (Panthera
tigris) populations and its i mplication s to monitoring. J . Ma mma l.,
2009 , 90 , 472–478.
16. Singh, R., Mazumda r, A., Sankar, K., Qur eshi, Q., Goyal, S. P.,
and Nigam, P., Interbirth interval and litter size of free-r anging
Bengal tiger (Panther a tigris tigris) in dry tropical deciduous
forest s of India. Eur. J. Wildl. Res., 2013; doi: 10.1007/s10344-
013-0713 -z.
17. Chauha n, D. S., Hariha r, A., Goyal , S. P. , Qu reshi, Q., Lal, P. and
Mathur, V. B., Estimating tiger population using camera traps in
Ranthambhore National Pa rk. Wildlife Institute of India,
Dehra dun, 2005, p. 151.
18. Jhala, Y. V., Qureshi, Q., Gopal, R. and Sinha, P. R., Status of
tigers, co-preda tors and prey in India. National Tiger Conservation
Authority, Governme nt of India, and Wildli fe Institute of India,
Dehra dun, TR 0 8/001 , 201 1.
19. Singh, R., Nigam, P., Goyal, S. P., Joshi, B. D., Shar ma, S. and
Shekhawat, R. S., Su rvival of dispersed or phaned ti ger cubs (Pan-
thera tigris tigris) in fragmented habitat of Ranthambhore Tiger
Reserv e In India . Indian For., 201 1, 13 7(10 ), 117 1–1176.
20. Singh, R., Qureshi, Q., Sankar, K., Krausman, P. R. and Goyal, S. P.,
Use of camera traps to determine dispersal of tigers in semi-arid land-
scape, western India. J. Arid. Environ., 2013, 98, 105108.
21. Singh, R., Krausman, P. R., Pandey, P., Qureshi, Q., Sanka r, K.,
Goyal, S. P. and T ripat hi, A., First parturit ion of tiger s in a semi -
arid habitat, western India. Euro. J. Wildl . Res., 2014 , 60, 383–
386.
22. Singh, R., Qureshi, Q., Sankar, K., Krausman, P. R. and Goyal,
S. P., Female reproductive characterist ics of Bengal tigers, Ran-
thambhore Tiger Reserve, India. Eur. J. Wild l. Res., 2014; doi:
10.1007/ s10344-014-0822 -3.
23. Mohr, C. O., Table of equivalent populations of North America n
small mamma ls. A m. Midl. Nat., 1947, 37, 223 –249 .
24. Singh, R., Garg, R., Shekhawa t, R. S., Back to wild – a tiger. In
India n Wildli fe Year Boo k (ed. Arora , B. M.), Association of
India n Zoo and Wildlife Veterinarian, India, 2008 , pp. 85–8 6.
25. McDouga l, C., The Face of the Tiger, Rivington Books, London,
1977 .
26. Sunquist, M. E. , Social orga nization of tigers (Panthe ra tigris) in
Chitwan Na tiona l Park , Nepal. Smi thson ian Contrib. Zool., 1981,
336, 1–98 .
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS. We thank the D irector and Dea n, WII,
Dehra dun for thei r continuou s support. We also thank the Rajastha n
Forest Department and the pa rk offi cials and field staff at RTR for
permis sions and f or facilitating fi eld work. T his study was ma de possi -
ble by fina ncial and logi stic support from WII (Ministry of the Envi-
ronment and Forests, Government of India ).
Receiv ed 26 Ma y 201 4; revised a ccepted 2 4 Au gust 2014
Resource allocation within the
replacement clutch: do female
European starling (Sturnus vulgaris
Linneus) adjust their reproductive
strategy after a full clutch loss?
Ivna Kocijan1, Petra Dolenec2,
Zdravko Dolenec3,* and Andreja Radović4
1University o f Applied Health Studies, Mlinarska St. 38,
HR-10000 Zagreb, Cr oatia
2Department o f Pha rmacology, School of Medi cine,
University of Rijeka , Br a ć e Branchetta 20, HR-51000 , Rijeka, Croatia
3Department o f Zoology, Facu lty of Science, University of Zagr eb,
Rooseveltov trg 6, HR-10 000 Zagreb, Cr oatia
4Group for T errestria l Biodiversity, Divisio n of Biology,
Facu lty of Scien ce, Univer sity of Za greb, Maru lićev trg 20/II,
HR-10000 Zagreb, Croatia
An important factor in the evolution of reproductive
strategies in birds is the loss of a clutch or a brood.
Many avian species produce a replacement clutch fol-
lowing the loss of the first clutch, but additional
breeding effort carries physiological costs and can
also reduce female fitness. Thus, egg production in
replacement clutches is usually reduced. In contrast,
European starling mothers seem to invest equally in
their first and replacement clutches. This study inves-
tigated whether female starlings use differential allo-
cation of resources to offspring, rather than egg
production, to strategically balance investment and
... It is especially important to assess the compatibility of males, who might otherwise pose a threat to the safety of their progeny. In the wild, male felids often present a threat to infants [20][21][22][23]. Overall, this study identified no substan- Sumatran tiger cubs. ...
... Furthermore, there is limited evidence to suggest that wild Panthera males engage in care of their offspring [8]. Indeed, some species regularly practice infanticide in the wild (usually from unrelated males), in order to reduce the amount of time before females become receptive [21,23]. The defence of cubs by the female may therefore be a biologically driven strategy [8]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Felids are commonly housed in zoological collections worldwide. While aspects of their behaviour are well studied, there remain questions on best practice husbandry including during reproduction and breeding scenarios. In 2016, the Zoological Society of London’s (ZSL) London Zoo held a pair of Sumatran tigers (Panthera tigris sumatrae) for the purpose of breeding. While they are believed to be solitary in the wild, many collections maintain their tigers in pairs, with some keeping pairs together during parturition and rearing periods. The aim of this study was to investigate the social interactions between a male Sumatran tiger and cubs when housed in a shared enclosure. The data were collected using CCTV footage in the indoor enclosure for the tigers. The CCTV footage ran continuously throughout the day and night, allowing a more holistic overview of behaviour. These 24-hour recordings were split into 6 equal hour ranges to calculate behaviour activity budgets and proximity of the male from the cubs. Data were analysed using a Chi-squared test for association to determine differences between individual behaviour. Overall, the male spent longer than expected engaging in guarding behaviour of the cubs. The male also regularly engaged in affiliative behaviours directed towards the cubs. No cub-directed aggression was observed from the male toward the cubs. Overall, this suggests that maintaining a male tiger with its progeny may be feasible as a management approach in some zoological collections, provided the male’s personality is compatible, and alternative accommodation is available. Keywords: Felidae; Affiliative Behaviour; Guarding; Nocturnal Behaviour; Zoo; Panthera Tigris Sumatrae
... The adult male TM-12 (≥6 years; TM is tiger male) was translocated to STR and his vacated home range was filled by a neighbouring adult male TM-24 (≥4 years) living in the proximate habitat. This male tiger had been previously physically captured approximately 4 km away in a suboptimal habitat 36 . The home range area occupied by TM-02 during 2005 to 2010 was approximately 73 sq. ...
... Female TF-13 took over the entire natal home range following the disappearance of her mother TF-14 (Figure 2). The female TF-13 left her natal home range in December 2010 to avoid infanticide36 and the home range was acquired by her daughter (TF-39). Similarly in another case after the death of the resident adult female (TF-15) in September 2008 (ref. ...
Article
Full-text available
Understanding the social organization and acquisition of potential home ranges in solitary polygamous mammals is important for their management and conservation. However, such information requires a continuous long-term study. Therefore, limited information is available for mammals from South Asia. We studied the western most distributed Bengal tiger (Panthera tigris) population of Ranthambhore Tiger Reserve (RTR), Rajasthan, India, intensively during 2005-2011 using direct observation and intensive camera trapping-based methods. We examined how the home ranges of deceased tigers would be filled. Nine home ranges of tigers were vacated (two males and seven females) because of death, translocation, emigration and dispersal. Vacated female home ranges were filled by neighbouring tigers; 57% of neighbouring females were related to each other and after females vacated their ranges, their daughters acquired these home ranges. Mother tigers shared their home ranges with their daughters to increase the reproductive success of the latter. The home range of adult male tiger (TM-02) was estimated to be 73 sq. km using camera traps. Vacated male home ranges were filled by four transient individuals that were not related to each other. These data help understand the social organization and land tenure system of tigers in semi-arid habitats of India.
... leo, Grinnell and McComb 1996), and the Bengal tiger (P. tigris, Singh et al. 2014). Male leopards are observed to leave their natal home ranges, whereas females are philopatric, establishing territories near their mothers or other individuals with familial ties (Bailey 1993;Kumbhojkar et al. 2020). ...
Article
We documented alloparenting and social group behavior within a leopard (Panthera pardus fusca) population in the Jhalana Reserve Forest (JRF), northwest India. Our observations revealed subadult offspring assisting their mothers in raising their newborn litters, exhibiting previously undocumented alloparenting behaviors. We propose that the familial intra-specific interactions and inter-specific competition collectively influence the social structure of the leopard population. Specifically, we suggest that the inter-specific competition and predation, particularly with striped hyenas (Hyaena hyaena), may encourage alloparenting in leopards. Additionally, we hypothesize that alloparenting, combined with natal philopatry, serves as an alternative strategy for leopards to enhance the survival chances of their progeny. *Full-text access for view-only version courtesy Springer Nature: https://rdcu.be/dQwzF
... Various age and sex classes of tiger used different temporal activity peak in the present study, potentially to enhance their reproductive success and survival strategy. According to Singh et al., (2014), "Observations and results from behavioral decisions made by tigers are important to understand the species and the factors that facilitate their conservation". Breeding tigress might adopt a strategy to protect her cubs from infanticide, utilizing different temporal activity periods compared to female without cubs and transient male tigers. ...
Article
Full-text available
Citation: Majumder, A. (2023). Survival strategy-Temporal segregation of different age and sex classes of a Bengal tiger (Panthera tigris tigris Linnaeus) population in Pench Tiger Reserve, Madhya Pradesh India. Journal of Animal Diversity, 5 (3): 43-54. http://dx. Abstract Temporal activity patterns of different age and sex classes of a Bengal tiger population were studied at Pench Tiger Reserve, Madhya Pradesh between May 2006 and July 2009 using systematic camera traps. Based on the exact time of photo-capture tigers, information on temporal activity patterns of following age and sex categories of individual tigers (resident male (n= 55 photographs), female with cubs or breeding female (n= 70 photographs), female without cubs or non-breeding female (n= 72 photographs) and transient male (n= 42 photographs)) were recorded. Breeding females utilized significantly different activity period compared to transient males (P< 0.001) and females without cubs (P<0.001). Overall activity period between breeding female and resident male did not differ significantly (P >0.6) during the study period. The observed temporal segregation may provide valuable information on cub survival strategies adopted by breeding tigresses, potentially enhancing their reproductive success in a tropical deciduous forest. The adoption of camera trap-based population monitoring studies is advocated for the reproductive behavior of elusive large carnivores such as tigers in the wild on a long-term basis.
... No instances of physical aggression directed from the male to either of his cubs were observed and only one occurrence of vocal aggression. In the wild, some male felids (mainly unrelated) regularly practice infanticide in order to both reduce competition and the amount of time before the female becomes receptive again [49]. Yet, the lack of agonistic or avoidance behaviors suggests the male was tolerant of the cubs' presence, further signifying the social flexibility that has been previously underestimated in solitary male felids. ...
Article
Full-text available
The survival of endangered felids is becoming increasingly dependent on the successful management and breeding of reserve populations in captivity. While most felid species are reported to be solitary in the wild, increasing evidence suggests that some big cats have greater social plasticity than is currently acknowledged. This social plasticity allows felids to be sometimes socially housed in environments such as zoos and rescue centers. While the effects of such shared enclosures remain in question, many reports provide evidence of several welfare benefits of maintaining these large carnivores in pairs or even groups. Since 2019, Le Parc des Félins has housed a breeding pair of Malaysian tigers (Panthera tigris jacksoni) alongside their offspring. The purpose of this study was to quantify the social affiliation between the male tiger and his cubs and to investigate the female’s tolerance toward him. The data were collected using video recordings in the outdoor enclosure when social interactions were observed. The data were coded and categorized in the open-source software BORIS, from which behavioral activity budgets were calculated. Data were analyzed using the chi-squared test for association to determine differences in affiliative frequency, with directed and undirected sociograms created to visualize individual relationships. Overall, the male regularly engaged in affiliative behaviors with the cubs, with no significant difference found in the frequency of interactions with them compared to the female. No physical aggression was directed by the male toward the cubs. Although the female maintained a stronger bond with the cubs compared to the male, he displayed a greater range of affiliative behaviors toward them than male tigers are thought to exhibit. Both adults showed a high degree of tolerance toward their conspecifics, suggesting that maintaining breeding pairs with their offspring is a viable management strategy in zoological collections. This study could therefore improve husbandry and conservation practices by developing our understanding of felid sociality and the potential welfare benefits of social housing, allowing for evidence-based captive management decisions.
... The short life span (~15 yrs) of tigers in the wild leads to a high turnover rate and human-induced factors (e.g., poaching) accelerate the changes in demography (Bisht et al., 2019;Duangchantrasiri et al., 2016;Karanth et al., 2006;Majumder et al., 2017). During the process of the acquisition of new territories by adult male tigers, the non-breeding (juveniles and sub-adults) male tigers in the demographic group are more vulnerable to infanticide, emigration or dispersal, and territorial fights, whereas non-breeding females remain nearer to natal areas (Barlow et al., 2009;Singh et al., 2014a;Smith, 1993;Sunquist, 1981). Hence, it is important to understand the demographic stage that is vulnerable and causes fluctuations in populations, which can help biologists develop strategies and monitoring protocols for the long-term viability of populations. ...
Article
Full-text available
Understanding temporal variations in wildlife populations is a prerequisite for conservation planning of wide-ranging species such as tigers (Panthera tigris). We determined the temporal variation in abundance, population growth, and sex ratios at different age and sex stages for a tiger population in Ranthambhore Tiger Reserve, India from November 2007 to February 2011 using motion-sensing cameras. We identified 19 male and 21 female tigers from stripe patterns during 16,110 trap nights within an area covering 233 km 2. The annual abundance of the population varied from 34.9 (mean)±3.8 (SE) to 23.9±1.5, with a declining trend in the mean annual change of abundance (−12%). The density of adult females remained stable across the study duration, but the densities of adult males and non-breeding tigers fluctuated. The sex ratio was female-biased (0.58 males/female) for breeding tigers and male-biased (1.74 males/female) for non-breeding tigers. Our results reinforce the importance of long-term studies for monitoring the naturally occurring processes in populations to develop population indicators and identify reliable baseline information for conservation and management planning of populations. ABSTRACT Original Article PNIE 2022;3(3):154-164
... Thus, sympatric carnivore species may be frequenting areas near fields at this time, leading to additional risk for female bobcats with kittens. Kitten survival is a crucial component of lifetime reproductive success, and female felids will adjust behavior preemptively to ensure survival of young [67,[76][77][78]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Across taxa, sex-specific demands vary temporally in accordance with reproductive investments. In solitary carnivores, females must provision and protect young independently while meeting increased energetic demands. Males seek to monopolize access to females by maintaining large territories and defending them from other males. For many species, it is poorly understood how these demands relate to broad-scale animal movements. To investigate predictions surrounding the reproductive strategies of solitary carnivores and effects of local conditions on bobcat (Lynx rufus) spatial ecology, we examined the effects of sex and reproductive season on home range size, movement rate, and resource selection of bobcats in the central Appalachian Mountains. Male seasonal home ranges were approximately 3 times larger than those of females (33.9 ± 2.6 vs. 12.1 ± 2.4 km², x±SE), and male movement rates were 1.4 times greater than females (212.6 ± 3.6 vs. 155 ± 8.2 m/hr), likely reflecting male efforts to maximize access to females. Both sexes appear to maintain relatively stable seasonal home ranges despite temporally varying reproductive investments, instead adjusting movements within home ranges. Males increased movements during the dispersal period, potentially reflecting increased territoriality prior to breeding. Females increased movements during the kitten-rearing period, when foraging more intensively, and frequently returning to den sites. Both sexes selected home ranges at higher elevations. However, females selected deciduous forest and avoided fields, whereas males selected fields and avoided deciduous forest, perhaps explained by male pressure to access multiple females across several mountain ridges and higher risk tolerance. Seasonal changes in home range selection likely reflect changes in home range shape. Increased female avoidance of fields during kitten rearing may indicate female avoidance of presumably resource rich, yet risky, fields at the time when kittens are most vulnerable. Our results indicate that while reproductive chronology influences the spatial ecology of solitary carnivores, effects may be constrained by territoriality.
... None or very little of this information notes the age of the females, temporal changes in characteristics of the litters, or kitten mortality. For example, although infanticide is considered an adaptive and widespread strategy in felids, it has been studied mainly in big cats such as lion (Panthera leo), tiger (Panthera tigris) (Singh et al., 2014), leopard (Panthera pardus) (Balme and Hunter, 2013), puma (Puma concolor) and jaguar (Panthera onca). It has also been detected in Iberian lynx (Lynx pardinus) (López et al., 2010) and domestic cats (Felis catus) (Pontier and Natoli, 1999). ...
Article
Full-text available
We studied the effect of several environmental and reproductive variables on the reproductive performance of captive European wildcat (Felis silvestris silvestris, Schreber 1777) females in Spain. We collected reproductive data from 34 females that produced 77 litters and 295 kittens. The youngest females that gave birth were 12 months old, whereas the oldest was11+ years old. On average, females giving birth were 3.8 years old (n=62), with a mode of one+ years old. Mean litter size was 3.7 kittens±1.0 (range: one to six; n=77 litters), with three or four kittens comprising 67.
... For example, we have documented multiple females that have raised litters in farmlands away from their primary habitats. Such strategies may be a response to the risk of infanticide from displacement of a dominant male (Ebensperger, 1998;Singh et al., 2014;Swenson, 2003). Our results also highlight that variation in ASR is temporally dynamic, and that skewed ASR may be reversed by sex-biased mortality or immigration/emigration of a few individuals from or into small populations (Robinson et al., 2008;Sweanor et al., 2000). ...
Article
The distribution of mammals is determined by a suite of endogenous and exogenous factors. In territorial, polygynous species like tigers (Panthera tigris), males often center their space-use around female territories, repelling competitors from these areas. Competition among males for females leads to increased mortality of both sexes and infanticide of unrelated cubs, which can lead to population declines. We hypothesized that increased territorial overlap among adult male tigers and elevated levels of inter and intra-sex competition would be manifest in populations with male-biased adult sex ratios (ASR). We also assessed whether inter-sex variation in adult survival or degree of habitat connectivity resulted in skewed ASR. We evaluated these hypotheses using camera trap data from three tiger populations occupying habitat patches with varying levels of connectivity and ASRs. Data were analyzed using multi-state occupancy models, where states were defined as habitat use by one or more male tigers in sites with and without female use. As predicted, in populations with male-biased or even ASR we found evidence for increased spatial overlap between male tigers, particularly pronounced in areas adjacent to female territories. Given parity in adult survival, habitat fragmentation likely caused male-biased ASR. Our results suggest that the persistence of small tiger populations in habitat patches with male-biased ASR may be significantly compromised by behavior-mediated endogenous demographic processes that are often overlooked. In habitat fragments with pronounced male biased ASR, population recovery of territorial carnivores may require timely supplementation of individuals to compensate for population losses from intraspecific competition.
... Jaguar infanticide was noted in the Brazilian Cerrado, but in an area where the population density was low (Soares et al., 2006). In tigers, infanticide avoidance by a female and the death of a female while defending her cubs from a male has been recorded (Singh et al., 2014). Female lions (Panthera leo) also defend their cubs and avoid infanticide by immigrating male (Packer and Pusey, 1983). ...
Article
Female jaguars have lower capture rates because they move less, have smaller territories and use habitat differently than males. Also, I found evidence that suggests that females may avoid camera traps and thus cause a sex bias in camera trap records. Most records of females (83%) were from the first year of a 54 month study (2005–2013), and 79% of those were during the first six months of camera trapping. Males were also captured at a greater rate during the first six months of sampling (39% of all records), and they were recorded continuously when camera traps were installed on roads (in contrast to females). A previous study found individual heterogeneity in capture probability and estimated 78% annual survival probability for the local population over five sampling periods. If population size was declining, a bias towards a greater rate of decline in females (or the disappearance of only females) is unlikely (males continued to be captured), and does not explain the fourfold reduction in the capture success of females after the first six months of sampling (four females were present throughout the entire first period). The deliberate tendency of females to avoid camera traps, more than males, as I suggest here, may cause a bias in determining both population size and sex ratios in jaguars, as well as an important underestimation of reproduction, thereby biasing estimates of population structure. This issue is important when using camera-traps to examine feline population biology and requires further evaluation.
Article
Full-text available
We studied 2 grizzly bear (Ursus arctos) populations to test 3 hypotheses of sexual segregation. The "no avoidance" hypothesis predicts that females do not avoid males and male-occupied habitats but simply have different habitats available to them within their home ranges. The "food" hypothesis predicts that subadult and adult females avoid males because of competition or cannibalism by males for food. The "sex" hypothesis predicts that only sexually mature adult females avoid males because of sexually motivated infanticide by nonsire males. Sexually mature females avoided (P < 0.05) food-rich, male-occupied habitats in Kananaskis, Alberta, but selected (P < 0.05) such habitats in the Selkirk Mountains of Idaho. Sexually immature females selected (P < 0.05) food-rich, male-occupied habitats in both areas. Unequal availability of habitat did not explain the pattern of segregation because food-rich habitats were available to all age-sex classes. Competition or cannibalism by males did not explain segregation because only sexually mature females avoided male-occupied habitats in Kananaskis and no females avoided males in the Selkirks. Adult female avoidance of potentially infanticidal, nonsire, immigrant males in Kananaskis appeared to explain the pattern of segregation. High mortality of older males in Kananaskis coincided with an influx of younger, potentially infanticidal, immigrant males, and adult females avoided those males and their favored habitats. No such segregation was observed in the Selkirks where mortality of older males was low and where there were few or no immigrant males. Results are inconsistent with the no avoidance and food hypotheses but consistent with the sex hypothesis of sexual segregation.
Article
Full-text available
Two orphaned tigers cubs aged 8-10 months of either sex were monitored over a period of one and half years between October2008–March 2010 in the fragmented landscape of Ranthambhore Tiger Reserve (RTR), India. Both animals dispersed out into fragmented landscapes, however the male cub accidently ventured into human habitation and resulted in conflict. The cub was rescued and rehabilitated in an adjoining forest. The female cub dispersed naturally outside the national park area into Chambal ravines. Both the animals were monitored using camera trap and pugmark based tracking method during the study period. Both tiger cubs adapted well in the human dominated (fragmented) landscape, caused minimal conflict, and survived their first winter and summer till they attained the age of > 24 months. This paper presents the survival of orphaned cubs in fragmented landscape and highlights the importance of translocation as a tool for alleviating conflict.
Article
Full-text available
Reproductive characteristics of tigers (Panthera tigris) are important to understand population viability. We studied the reproductive parameters of female Bengal tigers (P. t. tigris) in a dry, tropical, deciduous habitat in Ranthambhore Tiger Reserve (RTR), western India, from April 2005 to March 2010. We monitored tigers by direct observation and with cameras placed throughout their habitat. The potential breeding population included 13 adult females. The average age at first reproduction was 3.3 years; 34 cubs were born during the study period (6.2±0.82 per year). Sixtysix percent of the births occurred between October and December. Mean litter size was 2.26±0.52 (n=13, range=1–3). The sex ratio of 32 cubs was 1.29 M:1.00 F. The survival rate of cubs (<12 months) was 85 % (95 % CI=0.68–0.94), whereas that of juveniles (12–24 months), and subadults (24–36 months) was 79%(95%CI=0.61–0.91). All breeding females were >3 years old. Only 2 of the 13 females reproduced twice during the 5 years of the study. The birth interval was 33.4±3.7 months (range 24–65 months). The mean reproductive rate was 0.59±0.23 cubs/female/year. Our study indicates that tiger populations can grow rapidly if the habitat provides adequate protection, an adequate population of prey, and minimal to no poaching.
Article
Full-text available
Long-term data of large felids is important to understand their reproductive biology and behavior for effective conservation planning. We used camera trap data and direct sightings from 2005 to 2013 to estimate the age of the first parturition of Bengal tigers (Panthera tigris) in a semi-arid habitat in India. We monitored 11 females in the Ranthambhore Tiger Reserve (RTR) from when they were 2–6 months old. The mean age at first reproduction (impregnation leading to cubs) was 51.3 ± (SE) 4.5 months. The tiger population in RTR is an important source population and genetic pool in the western most distribution of tiger. Thus, continuous monitoring of tiger populations is important to develop an understanding of reproductive biology.
Article
Full-text available
We studied the interbirth interval (IBI) and litter size of the population of free-ranging Bengal tigers (Panthera tigris tigris) in dry tropical deciduous forests in Ranthambhore Tiger Reserve (RTR), Rajasthan, and Pench Tiger Reserve (PTR), Madhya Pradesh, between April 2005 and June 2011. Data on 15 breeding females in RTR and nine breeding females in PTR were collected using camera trapping, direct observation and radio-telemetry. The mean ± standard error of IBI (months) in RTR was 33.4 ± 3.7 and in PTR was 25.2 ± 1.8. A significant difference was observed between the mean IBI of tigresses in RTR and those in PTR (df = 9, P = 0.04). The estimated mean litter size in RTR was 2.3 ± 0.1 and that in PTR was 2.9 ± 0.2. There was a significant difference between the litter size in RTR and that in PTR (χ 2 = 12.04, P = 0.017, df = 4). Since RTR and PTR are the important source populations of tigers in the Western and Central Indian landscapes, we propose that the tigers in these reserves be monitored, particularly for reproductive traits that are essential for understanding aspects of their population ecology.
Article
Full-text available
Tigers (Panthera tigris) are endangered wild felids whose elusive nature and naturally low densities make them notoriously difficult to count. We present 7 years of camera trapping, tracking, and observational data on a local tiger population in Chitwan National Park, Nepal, to quantify changes in abundance of demographic groups and to identify underlying causes. Mean abundance in the 100-km2 study area was 18 tigers, but there was high variance among years. Transients were generally recorded at low levels, but there were large oscillations in numbers of tiger offspring, driven by infanticide perpetrated by male tigers taking over territories. The number of breeding animals in the study area remained relatively stable, with about 6 breeding females and 1 or 2 breeding males. The high density of breeding adults in Chitwan National Park highlights the region as a potential stronghold for tigers. Concentrating on counting breeding animals increases the power of monitoring programs to detect change over time. An alternative approach is to carry out surveys on a scale large enough to encompass sufficient territories to compensate for the local impacts of periodic turnover of adult males on total abundance.
Article
Dispersal is a life history trait that plays a key role in population dynamics. We used camera traps to estimate the distance male and female tigers (Panthera tigris) dispersed from Ranthambhore Tiger Reserve (RTR) in semi-arid habitats of western India from 2003 to 2010. We deployed camera traps whenever tiger tracks were found in places adjacent to protected areas where tigers had not been recently reported. We identified tigers by matching strip patterns by using their photographs with the database of camera-trapped tigers of RTR at the Wildlife Institute of India, Dehradun. We determined the aerial distance (straight line) between the last location of photo-capture in the natal area (in RTR) and the location of the most recent photo-capture. One female and three male tigers that dispersed from RTR were identified from photographs. The longest distance dispersed by a tiger was 148.4 km, and the average dispersed distance was 124.2 ± 23.7 km (n = 3) for male tigers and 78.4 km for the female tiger. The minimum age of the male tigers when they dispersed was 24 months. These data are important for making conservation and management decisions for restoration of potential connectivity between landscapes.
Article
Female Panthera leo with cubs show various direct responses to immigrating males, including defense of their cubs or avoidance of the new males. Despite these responses, male replacement in the females' pride results in considerable cub mortality. Those females that remain in the pride and mate with the new males show low fertility in the first few months after a takeover of their pride. At the same time, however, females show heightened sexual activity, being more active in initiating copulations and seeking a greater number of mating partners. These 2 factors appear to elicit competition between male coalitions for control of the pride, with the result that larger coalitions eventually become resident. This is adaptive because a female needs protection from male harassment of her cubs for >2 yr in order to rear her cubs successfully, and only large male coalitions are likely to remain in a pride for >2 yr. A simple model specifies one set of conditions under which a female will improve her lifetime reproductive success by showing temporary periods of infertility, but attracting a larger coalition. -Authors