ArticlePDF Available

The Studies on Hydrophilic-Lipophilic Balance (HLB): Sixty Years after William C. Griffin's Pioneer Work (1949-2009)

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

6° piso (1113) Buenos Aires, Argentina. SUMMARY. The Hydrophilic-Lipophilic Balance (HLB)was formally presented by William C. Griffin sixty years ago at a meeting in Chicago for the first time and later on in an article published in the first volume of the Journal of the Society of Cosmetic Chemists. In later publications, Griffin proposed formu-las for the HLB value calculation that are satisfactory for non-ionic surfactants of various types. Several experimental methods developed then in order to obtain the HLB values of surfactants and required HLB of oils in a way simpler than with Griffin's original experimental method. Also there were proposed math-ematical equations that HLB values of surfactants allows to calculate from its chemical formulae and also from quality control data of surfactants and its components.
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... One of the most important parameters of the emulsifier is the Hydrophilic-Lipophilic Balance (HLB). The concept of using HLB for the classification and selection of non-ionic emulsifiers for the first time was proposed in 1948 [61]. In 1954, Griffin numerically defined HLB as [62]: One of the most important parameters of the emulsifier is the Hydrophilic-Lipophilic Balance (HLB). ...
... In 1954, Griffin numerically defined HLB as [62]: One of the most important parameters of the emulsifier is the Hydrophilic-Lipophilic Balance (HLB). The concept of using HLB for the classification and selection of non-ionic emulsifiers for the first time was proposed in 1948 [61]. In 1954, Griffin numerically defined HLB as [62]: ...
Article
Full-text available
Fuel with the addition of water, forming fuel-water emulsions, is a potential way to reduce the emission of pollutants from gas turbines powered by any liquid fuel. This article analyzes the available work on the combustion of fuel-water emulsions in gas turbines. The literature analysis was preceded by a theoretical introduction on fuel-water emulsion, taking into account the factors influencing its micro- and macroscopic properties. The basic features of the agents used to stabilize the emulsion were also discussed and the process of its combustion was described. The analyzed research differed in terms of the test stands on which the experiments were conducted, the fuel constituting the continuous phase of the emulsion, the amount of water contained in the mixture and the method of producing the emulsion. On the basis of the conducted analysis, conclusions were drawn concerning the influence of feeding a gas turbine with a fuel-water emulsion on the emission of nitrogen oxides, carbon monoxide and exhaust smoke. Conclusions were formulated regarding the influence of the water additive to fuel-on-fuel consumption. In addition, the impact of the presence of water on the conversion of nitrogen contained in the fuel to nitrogen oxides was indicated, and areas requiring further research were presented.
... The oldest yet still most popular concept is the HLB (hydrophilic lipophilic balance) approach. [138][139][140][141][142] The HLB value of a surfactant is governed by the size of the polar moiety. It was initially simply calculated as one fifth of the molecular weight percentage of the hydrophilic portion, leading to an empirical scale ranging from 0 to 20. ...
... Numerous other researchers attempted to relate the HLB to diverse molecular properties, such as cloud point or critical micelle concentration, with limited success though. 126,139 Even though the HLB concept is widely used, it has serious limitations. What the method can do is, is indicating which type of emulsion can be expected from a surfactant with certain HLB value. ...
Thesis
Full-text available
This work explores the preparation of porous poly(epoxide) foams using the method of emulsion templating and describes the thorough characterisation thereof. Furthermore, special focus was placed on the development of a custom-designed apparatus for gas permeability testing.
... Surfactant selection was based on the HLB system. Hydrophilic -Lipophilic Balance (HLB) is the ratio of oil and water-soluble constituents of a non ionic surfactant , all surfactants have a hydrophilic head (water loving) that is composed of a water soluble group and a lipophilic tail (oil loving) which composed of a fatty acid or fatty alcohol (16). In the HLB System, any surfactant has an HLB value, and Each oil or wax intended to be used in emulsion formulation has a required HLB number, by using surfactants with HLB value that is required by the oil, trial and error effort will be reduced and optimum formula will be obtained . ...
Article
Full-text available
Ticagrelor is a new drug use to inhibit platelet aggregation induced by adenosine di phosphate (ADP) that's used to reduce atherothrombotic occurring in adults with acute coronary syndrome. Ticagrelor is class IV drug according to BCS drug classification, which is practically insoluble in water 10 µg/ml, with an absolute bioavailability of about 36 %, so this study intended to improve its water solubility and bioavailability. Method: maximum solubility of drug in different oil and co surfactant was determined and a suitable surfactant was used according to HLB system, after that a 20 formula of Ticagelor self-nano emulsion was prepared, and best formula was chosen according to different tests and subjected to an in-vivo evaluation. Results: the obtained results showed that Oleic acid, Tween 20, and Propylene glycol combination are the best constituent to prepare Ticagrelor as self-nano emulsion formula, this combination gave a large nano region upon titration with water. The best formula F5 was 10% oil and 90% surfactant-co surfactant mixture (S mix) in ratio 4:1 (tween/ Propylene glycol), showed 25 nm particle size, 0.098 polydispersity index, 10 times improvement in drug release rate than pure drug powder, and about 10 time prolongation of drug clotting time in the in-vivo study. Conclusion: the preparation of Ticagrelor as self-nano emulsion improve both the aqueous solubility of drug and the bioavailability.
... The principal researcher behind their development was Gerard P. Canevari (1924Canevari ( -2012 (Fig. 2). His key 1974 patent (Canevari, 1974) taught that the hydrophilic-lipophilic balance (Pasquali et al., 2009) was key to effective dispersion of oil in water, and that a blend of the SPANs and TWEENssubstituted sorbitanswith dialkysulfosuccinate dissolved in isoparaffins yielded a particularly effective dispersant (Figs. 3 and 4). These were used in a series of Corexits (Table 2), and remain the basis of current commercial formulations, with the ratio adjusted for particular applications. ...
Article
Massive oil spills leading to ‘Black Tides’ have been sad features of the last half century, although fortunately of generally decreasing frequency. Such spills often led to massive bird mortality and enormous public pressure for mitigation. One unfortunately misunderstood response has been the development of chemical dispersants designed to move floating slicks into the water column as tiny droplets. These droplets become entrained in the water and dilute to levels below those of acute toxic concern within hours; equally importantly, they naturally biodegrade within weeks, and do not impact shorelines. Initial dispersants were not especially effective, but a deeper understanding of what controls the lowering of interfacial tension between oil and water has led to very effective modern products, exemplified by Corexit 9500 used in the Deepwater Horizon response. By getting oil off the sea surface, dispersants protect birds and animals from potentially lethal oiling and the likely fouling of shorelines with its attendant problems of human exposure to oil residues as shorelines are physically cleaned. And by increasing the surface area of the spilled oil they promote indigenous microbial biodegradation, which can consume oil droplets with a half-life of 1–3 weeks without the need for any additional intervention. Dispersants thus provide the most environmentally-beneficial bioremediation option for ameliorating potentially environmentally devastating oil spills (when they work), and it is disappointing that they are not always tried on a significant (not test) scale.
... The EACN of an oil quantitatively expresses its hydrophobicity and corresponds to the related but obsolete concept of "required HLB" of oils introduced by Griffin in 1949. 2,46 The more hydrophobic the oil, the higher its EACN. In particular, for the n-alkane series, the EACN is, by definition, equal to the carbon number of the alkane and is denoted ACN. ...
Article
Full-text available
The hydrophobicity of oils is a key parameter to design surfactant/oil/water (SOW) macro-, micro-, or nano-dispersed systems with the desired features. This essential physicochemical characteristic is quantitatively expressed by the equivalent alkane carbon number (EACN) whose experimental determination is tedious since it requires knowledge of the phase behavior of the SOW systems at different temperatures and for different surfactant concentrations. In this work, two mathematical models are proposed for the rapid prediction of the EACN of oils. They have been designed using artificial intelligence (machine-learning) methods, namely, neural networks (NN) and graph machines (GM). While the GM model is implemented from the SMILES codes of a 111-molecule training set of known EACN values, the NN model is fed with some σ-moment descriptors computed with the COSMOtherm software for the 111-molecule set. In a preliminary step, the leave-one-out algorithm is used to select, given the available data, the appropriate complexity of the two models. A comparison of the EACNs of liquids of a fresh set of 10 complex cosmetic and perfumery molecules shows that the two approaches provide comparable results in terms of accuracy and reliability. Finally, the NN and GM models are applied to nine series of homologous compounds, for which the GM model results are in better agreement with the experimental EACN trends than the NN model predictions. The results obtained by the GMs and by the NN based on σ-moments can be duplicated with the demonstration tool available for download as detailed in the Supporting Information.
... Griffin's HLB number [140] is a semi-empirical scale for choosing surfactants. Since then, numerous researchers have sought to establish a quick and reliable procedure for determining the HLB of every new surfactant as a measure of surfactant polarity [141]. The HLB criteria assess whether a surfactant is lipophilic or hydrophilic [142][143][144][145]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The global increase of road infrastructure and its impact on the environment requires serious attention to develop sustainable and environmentally friendly road materials. One group of those materials is produced by using bitumen emulsion. However, there are still scientific and technical obstacles standing against its regular application. The bitumen emulsion formulation process and compositional optimization are subjected to a high number of degrees of freedom. Consequently, obtaining the desired product is mostly based on a series of random and tedious trials because of the enormous number of tests that are carried out to meet the required properties, such as emulsion stability, viscosity, droplet size (and distribution), and bitumen emulsion chemistry. Several pre-established formulation procedures have been presented in the literature. Some of them have technical limitations to be utilized for practical industrial application, whereas others are still not understood enough to be applied in bitumen emulsion formulation. Therefore, discussing some important issues in this field could be useful to offer a practical guide for bitumen emulsion manufacturers when trying to formulate a well-defined bitumen emulsion to best fit its use in pavement infrastructure rather than to simply to meet standard specifications. This review paper aims to enable the ultimate potential of bitumen emulsion by further reviewing the research progress of bitumen emulsion manufacturing and discussing the literature available up to now on this topic, in the realm of bitumen emulsion manufacturing and emulsion chemistry.
Thesis
Les émulsions de bitume sont des émulsions directes principalement composées de bitume et d’une phase aqueuse contenant un tensioactif cationique permettant de stabiliser les gouttelettes d’huile dans l’eau. Les tensioactifs utilisés actuellement sont bien souvent des composés aminés, issus de ressources fossiles, généralement toxiques et/ou écotoxiques. Ces travaux ont donc pour objectif de remplacer ces composés par une gamme de produits moins dangereux et en meilleur accord avec l’environnement.Dans cette optique, une méthode contrôlée et reproductible de dépolymérisation du chitosane a été mise en place. Ainsi, la désamination nitreuse a été choisie dans le but d’obtenir une tête hydrophile constituée de 5 à 20 unités. Par la suite, des oligomères amphiphiles de chitosane ont été obtenues par couplage époxy-amine et amidification. Les caractéristiques physicochimiques de ces tensioactifs ont été évaluées ainsi que leur capacité à stabiliser une émulsion huile dans eau. Finalement, des tensioactifs à base de chitosane, pour certains potentiellement 100% biosourcés, non toxiques et permettant l’obtention d’émulsions directes ont bien été synthétisés pour répondre au cahier des charges imposé par cette étude.Les émulsions de bitume sont des émulsions directes principalement composées de bitume et d’une phase aqueuse contenant un tensioactif cationique permettant de stabiliser les gouttelettes d’huile dans l’eau. Les tensioactifs utilisés actuellement sont bien souvent des composés aminés, issus de ressources fossiles, généralement toxiques et/ou écotoxiques. Ces travaux ont donc pour objectif de remplacer ces composés par une gamme de produits moins dangereux et en meilleur accord avec l’environnement.Dans cette optique, une méthode contrôlée et reproductible de dépolymérisation du chitosane a été mise en place. Ainsi, la désamination nitreuse a été choisie dans le but d’obtenir une tête hydrophile constituée de 5 à 20 unités. Par la suite, des oligomères amphiphiles de chitosane ont été obtenues par couplage époxy-amine et amidification. Les caractéristiques physicochimiques de ces tensioactifs ont été évaluées ainsi que leur capacité à stabiliser une émulsion huile dans eau. Finalement, des tensioactifs à base de chitosane, pour certains potentiellement 100% biosourcés, non toxiques et permettant l’obtention d’émulsions directes ont bien été synthétisés pour répondre au cahier des charges imposé par cette étude.
Article
Due to strengthened emission regulations, it is difficult to continuously use fuels for internal combustion engines such as gasoline and diesel. Emulsion fuel is a technology that can simultaneously reduce NOx and PM, the biggest problems of existing compression ignition engines. Since conventional emulsification technology involve various limitations. An emulsion fuel was prepared using a porous membrane emulsification method that maximizes stability and production efficiency. The kinematic viscosity of the emulsion fuel according to the water content and temperature was evaluated. And various basic properties (sulfur content, flash point, kinematic viscosity, density, ultimate analysis, net calorific value, and gross calorific value) of the prepared fuel was requested from an external institute for validation. The density and kinematic viscosity increased as the water content used in the manufacture of emulsion fuel increased, and the density and kinematic viscosity decreased as the temperature of the fuel increased. Based on the measurement results, an empirical equation according to temperature and water content was proposed. The error rate of the derived empirical equation is mostly less than 5%. And in most cases, the adjusted R-square value exceeded 0.95, so the proposed empirical equation was considered reliable. The proposed empirical equation can be utilized for obtaining the basic data for the emulsion fuel or water blended fuel.
Chapter
Emulsions are thermodynamically unstable systems, since they will separate to reduce the interfacial area between the oil phase and the water phase, as a function of time. As a metastable system, surfactant molecules, amphiphilic polymers or solid particles must be present before a stable emulsion system is formed. These components of an emulsion system are called emulsifiers. The relative balance of the hydrophilic and lipophilic properties of these emulsifiers is known to be the most important parameter dictating the emulsion type, whether an oil-in-water (o/w) or water-in-oil (w/o) emulsion. Irrespective of the emulsion type formed, demulsification is a costly exercise in the oil and gas industry. This chapter describes the fundamental role played by surface active agents (surfactants) as integral components of a chemical demulsifier.
Article
RÉSUMÉ Un système basé sur la température d'inversion des phases (TIP) pour la sélection des agents émulsionnants a été développé et comparé au systéme de la valeur HLB. Le rapport hydro-lipophile (HLB) d'un agent de surface non-ionique change avec la température et provoque l'inversion des phases d'une émulsion, quand les deux propriétés sont égales. La TIP varie avec les conditions d'essais el fournit des informations concernant les types d'huiles, le volume des phases, la concentration des agents émulsionnants, l'effet de la température etc. La valeur HLB ne fournit pas d'informations pareilles. La TIP est également en relation étroite avec d'autres propriétés. ZUSAMMENFASSUNG Ein Phasen-Inversions-Temperatur (PIT)-System wurde zur Auswahl eines Emulgators entwickelt und verglichen mit dent HLB-Wert System. Das hydro-lipophile Verhältnis (HLB) eines nicht ionischen Tensids verändert sich mit der Temperatur and bewirkt die Phasenumkehr einer Emulsion, wenn beide Eigcnschaften gleich sind. Die PIT variiert mit den experimentellen Bedingungen und ermöglicht Informationen über Öltypen, Phasenvolumen, Konzentration der Emulgatoren, Temperatureffekt etc. Der HLB-Wert liefert keine solchen Informationen. Die PIT steht auch in enger Beziehung zu andern Eigenschaften.
Article
Hydrophilic lipophilic balance (HLB) values for various commercial nonionic surfactants have been determined by means of high resolution NMR. The results are in good agreement with given HLB values. The method is rapid, nondestructive and requires only small samples.
Article
To study the additivity of the HLB values of an oil mixture from its component and the characteristics of the oil mixture forming a component of the emulsion, the required HLB values of several oil mixtures were determined by means of the emulsification tests proposed by Griffin.The oil mixtures examined in this series of experiments consist of two oils, one being a mineral oil of fixed components and the other an oil to be studied as the additive, which is added in varying ratios to the fixed-component mineral oil.The additivity of the required HLB values in oil mixtures was shown to hold to some extent for the case of saturated fatty acids, n-fatty alcohols, and some acetylated esters. For the rest of the additives, the additivity is not valid.The required HLB values of these additive oils were remarkably large in the case of fatty acids, alcohols and some acetylated esters, excepting the anomalous value for oleic acid.The structural effects on the increase of required HLB values seem to be in the following order:COOH>OH>COOR
Article
The goals of this articles are to find a correlation between the required HLB values and the solubility parameters of oils; find a more precise correlation between the required HLB values and the dielectric constant, than the one obtained by other authors; and to determine the required HLB values for o/w emulsions of solid fatty acids and alcohols from the values of the solubility parameters and dielectric constants, that could be more trustful than the ones obtained by the methodology proposed by Griffin. It was obtained lineal relation between required HLB and solubility parameter (r = 0.995). Also it was observed lineal relations between required HLB and dielectric constants or logarithm of the dielectric constant more precise than the one obtained by other authors.
Article
Many of the criticisms of the HLB concept are based on the failure of different mixtures of emulsifier all having the same HLB number to exhibit the same emulsion stability. This failure is attributed here to the partitioning of emulsifiers into the aqueous and oleic phases and the resultant variation of the interfacial HLB number. A new set of mixing rules for nonionic emulsifiers which maintain a fixed interfacial HLB number is shown to be in accord with experiment.
Article
The titration by water of a dioxane-benzene solution of an oil or a surface active agent to a cloud end point can be used to determine a value related to the hydrophile-lipophile balance character of the oil or surface active agent. Details of such a titration are given and the method is compared with other rating procedures.
Article
Measurement of the relative retention time of a pair of liquids, one polar and one nonpolar, permits determination of the polarity of the liquid Chromatographic substrate. It is shown that this polarity is a measure of the hydrophile-lipophile balance (HLB) when the substrate is a surface-active agent. The effects of structure, additivity in mixtures, and free polyol are discussed. A GLC apparatus, designed, to permit the rapid determination of HLB by this technique, is described.